Comparative study between transcriptionally- and translationally-acting adenine riboswitches reveals key differences in riboswitch regulatory mechanisms

Decoding the effect of temperatures on conformational stability and order of ligand unbound thermosensing adenine riboswitch using molecular dynamics simulation

The structure-function relationship of the riboswitch is governed mainly by two factors, ligand binding and temperature. Most of the experimental studies shed light on structural dynamics and gene regulation function of Adenine riboswitch from the aspect of ligand instead of temperature. Two unliganded Adenine riboswitch conformations (apoA and apoB) from the thermophile Vibrio vulnificus draw particular attention due to their diverse and polymorphic structures. Ligand-free apoB Adenine riboswitch conformation is not able to interact with the ligand whereas ligand-free apoA Adenine riboswitch conformation adopts ligand-receptive form. The interconversion between apoA and apoB conformation is temperature-dependent and thermodynamically controlled. Therefore Adenine riboswitch is called temperature sensing RNA. The molecular mechanism underlying the thermosensitivity of ligand free Adenine riboswitch is not well known. Hence an attempt is made to examine conformational stability and order of apoA with respect to apoB Adenine riboswitch aptamer computing RMSD, RMSF, RG, principal component analysis, hydrogen bonding interaction and conformational thermodynamics derived from all-atom molecular dynamics trajectories in the temperature range 283K-400K. The temperatures corresponding to the conformational stability and order of apoA adenine riboswitch with respect to apoB adenine riboswitch whole aptamer are shown in descending order 293K∼303K> 313K∼283K>373K>323K. Residue wise and domain wise changes in conformational free energy and entropy of conformational degrees of freedom like pseudo-torsion angle ƞ and θ reflect apoA exhibits pronounced conformational stability compared to apoB at temperatures 293K and 303K, whereas both forms reveal decreased stability at 323K and 400K and may be inactivated, highlighting their role as temperature sensors.

Gene Regulation by a Kinetic Riboswitch with Negative Feedback Loop

Understanding the folding behaviors and cellular roles is important to fully illuminate functions of riboswitches in vivo. Since riboswitches act without the need for protein factors, RNA structure prediction methods are ideally suited for computationally analyzing their cellular activities. Here, a helix-based RNA folding theory is used to predict the cotranscriptional folding pathways of the flavin mononucleotide (FMN)-binding riboswitch from Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis) under different conditions. The results show that the efficient function is determined by a balance between the transcription speed, pausing, and the binding rates of the metabolite. According to the predicted behaviors, a general kinetic model is established to investigate how the riboswitch couples sensing and regulatory functions to help bacteria respond to environmental changes at the system levels.

RNA folding kinetics control riboswitch sensitivity in vivo

Riboswitches are ligand-responsive gene-regulatory RNA elements that perform key roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. Understanding how riboswitch sensitivity to ligand (EC50) is controlled is critical to explain how highly conserved aptamer domains are deployed in a variety of contexts with different sensitivity demands. Here we uncover roles by which RNA folding dynamics control riboswitch sensitivity in cells. By investigating the Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, we identify multiple mechanistic routes of altering expression platform sequence and structure to slow RNA folding, all of which enhance riboswitch sensitivity. Applying these methods to riboswitches with diverse aptamer architectures and regulatory mechanisms demonstrates the generality of our findings, indicating that any riboswitch that operates in a kinetic regime can be sensitized by slowing expression platform folding. Our results add to the growing suite of knowledge and approaches that can be used to rationally program cotranscriptional RNA folding for biotechnology applications, and suggest general RNA folding principles for understanding dynamic RNA systems in other areas of biology.

NusG-dependent RNA polymerase pausing is a common feature of riboswitch regulatory mechanisms

Transcription by RNA polymerase is punctuated by transient pausing events. Pausing provides time for RNA folding and binding of regulatory factors to the paused elongation complex. We previously identified 1600 NusG-dependent pauses throughout the Bacillus subtilis genome, with ∼20% localized to 5' leader regions, suggesting a regulatory role for these pauses. We examined pauses associated with known riboswitches to determine whether pausing is a common feature of these mechanisms. NusG-dependent pauses in the fmnP, tenA, mgtE, lysP and mtnK riboswitches were in strategic positions preceding the critical decision between the formation of alternative antiterminator or terminator structures, which is a critical feature of transcription attenuation mechanisms. In vitro transcription assays demonstrated that pausing increased the frequency of termination in the presence of the cognate ligand. NusG-dependent pausing also reduced the ligand concentration required for efficient termination. In vivo expression studies with transcriptional fusions confirmed that NusG-dependent pausing is a critical component of each riboswitch mechanism. Our results indicate that pausing enables cells to sense a broader range of ligand concentrations for fine-tuning riboswitch attenuation mechanisms.

The Escherichia coli ribB riboswitch senses flavin mononucleotide within a defined transcriptional window

Riboswitches are metabolite-binding RNA regulators that modulate gene expression at the levels of transcription and translation. One of the hallmarks of riboswitch regulation is that they undergo structural changes upon metabolite binding. While a lot of effort has been put to characterize how the metabolite is recognized by the riboswitch, there is still relatively little information regarding how ligand sensing is performed within a transcriptional context. Here, we study the ligand-dependent cotranscriptional folding of the FMN-sensing ribB riboswitch of Escherichia coli Using RNase H assays to study nascent ribB riboswitch transcripts, DNA probes targeting the P1 and sequestering stems indicate that FMN binding leads to the protection of these regions from RNase H cleavage, consistent with the riboswitch inhibiting translation initiation when bound to FMN. Our results show that ligand sensing is strongly affected by the position of elongating RNA polymerase, which is defining an FMN-binding transcriptional window that is bordered in its 3' extremity by a transcriptional pause site. Also, using successively overlapping DNA probes targeting a subdomain of the riboswitch, our data suggest the presence of a previously unsuspected helical region involving the 3' strand of the P1 stem. Our results show that this helical region is conserved across bacterial species, thus suggesting that this predicted structure, the anti*-P1 stem, is involved in the FMN-free conformation of the ribB riboswitch. Overall, our study further demonstrates that intricate folding strategies may be used by riboswitches to perform metabolite sensing during the transcriptional process.

Insights into the cotranscriptional and translational control mechanisms of the Escherichia coli tbpA thiamin pyrophosphate riboswitch

Riboswitches regulate gene expression by modulating their structure upon metabolite binding. These RNA orchestrate several layers of regulation to achieve genetic control. Although Escherichia coli riboswitches modulate translation initiation, several cases have been reported where riboswitches also modulate mRNA levels. Here, we characterize the regulation mechanisms of the thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP) tbpA riboswitch in E. coli. Our results indicate that the tbpA riboswitch modulates both levels of translation and transcription and that TPP sensing is achieved more efficiently cotranscriptionally than post-transcriptionally. The preference for cotranscriptional binding is also observed when monitoring the TPP-dependent inhibition of translation initiation. Using single-molecule approaches, we observe that the aptamer domain freely fluctuates between two main structures involved in TPP recognition. Our results suggest that translation initiation is controlled through the ligand-dependent stabilization of the riboswitch structure. This study demonstrates that riboswitch cotranscriptional sensing is the primary determinant in controlling translation and mRNA levels.

Thermodynamic compensation to temperature extremes in B. subtilis vs T. maritima lysine riboswitches

T. maritima and B. subtilis are bacteria that inhabit significantly different thermal environments, ∼80 vs. ∼40°C, yet employ similar lysine riboswitches to aid in the transcriptional regulation of the genes involved in the synthesis and transport of amino acids. Despite notable differences in G-C basepair frequency and primary sequence, the aptamer moieties of each riboswitch have striking similarities in tertiary structure, with several conserved motifs and long-range interactions. To explore genetic adaptation in extreme thermal environments, we compare the kinetic and thermodynamic behaviors in T. maritima and B. subtilis lysine riboswitches via single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer analysis. Kinetic studies reveal that riboswitch folding rates increase with lysine concentration while the unfolding rates are independent of lysine. This indicates that both riboswitches bind lysine through an induced-fit ("bind-then-fold") mechanism, with lysine binding necessarily preceding conformational changes. Temperature-dependent van't Hoff studies reveal qualitative similarities in the thermodynamic landscapes for both riboswitches in which progression from the open, lysine-unbound state to both transition states (‡) and closed, lysine-bound conformations is enthalpically favored yet entropically penalized, with comparisons of enthalpic and entropic contributions extrapolated to a common [K+] = 100 mM in quantitative agreement. Finally, temperature-dependent Eyring analysis reveals the TMA and BSU riboswitches to have remarkably similar folding/unfolding rate constants when extrapolated to their respective (40 and 80°C) environmental temperatures. Such behavior suggests a shared strategy for ligand binding and aptamer conformational change in the two riboswitches, based on thermodynamic adaptations in number of G-C basepairs and/or modifications in tertiary structure that stabilize the ligand-unbound conformation to achieve biocompetence under both hyperthermophilic and mesothermophilic conditions.

Structural Characterization of the Cotranscriptional Folding of the Thiamin Pyrophosphate Sensing thiC Riboswitch in Escherichia coli

Riboswitches are RNA-regulating elements that mostly rely on structural changes to modulate gene expression at various levels. Recent studies have revealed that riboswitches may control several regulatory mechanisms cotranscriptionally, i.e., during the transcription elongation of the riboswitch or early in the coding region of the regulated gene. Here, we study the structure of the nascent thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP)-sensing thiC riboswitch in Escherichia coli by using biochemical and enzymatic conventional probing approaches. Our chemical (in-line and lead probing) and enzymatic (nucleases S1, A, T1, and RNase H) probing data provide a comprehensive model of how TPP binding modulates the structure of the thiC riboswitch. Furthermore, by using transcriptional roadblocks along the riboswitch sequence, we find that a certain portion of nascent RNA is needed to sense TPP that coincides with the formation of the P5 stem loop. Together, our data suggest that conventional techniques may readily be used to study cotranscriptional folding of nascent RNAs.

Riboswitch and small RNAs modulate btuB translation initiation in Escherichia coli and trigger distinct mRNA regulatory mechanisms

Small RNAs (sRNAs) and riboswitches represent distinct classes of RNA regulators that control gene expression upon sensing metabolic or environmental variations. While sRNAs and riboswitches regulate gene expression by affecting mRNA and protein levels, existing studies have been limited to the characterization of each regulatory system in isolation, suggesting that sRNAs and riboswitches target distinct mRNA populations. We report that the expression of btuB in Escherichia coli, which is regulated by an adenosylcobalamin (AdoCbl) riboswitch, is also controlled by the small RNAs OmrA and, to a lesser extent, OmrB. Strikingly, we find that the riboswitch and sRNAs reduce mRNA levels through distinct pathways. Our data show that while the riboswitch triggers Rho-dependent transcription termination, sRNAs rely on the degradosome to modulate mRNA levels. Importantly, OmrA pairs with the btuB mRNA through its central region, which is not conserved in OmrB, indicating that these two sRNAs may have specific targets in addition to their common regulon. In contrast to canonical sRNA regulation, we find that OmrA repression of btuB is lost using an mRNA binding-deficient Hfq variant. Together, our study demonstrates that riboswitch and sRNAs modulate btuB expression, providing an example of cis- and trans-acting RNA-based regulatory systems maintaining cellular homeostasis.

Fluorescent riboswitch-controlled biosensors for the genome scale analysis of metabolic pathways

Fluorescent detection in cells has been tremendously developed over the years and now benefits from a large array of reporters that can provide sensitive and specific detection in real time. However, the intracellular monitoring of metabolite levels still poses great challenges due to the often complex nature of detected metabolites. Here, we provide a systematic analysis of thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP) metabolism in Escherichia coli by using a TPP-sensing riboswitch that controls the expression of the fluorescent gfp reporter. By comparing different combinations of reporter fusions and TPP-sensing riboswitches, we determine key elements that are associated with strong TPP-dependent sensing. Furthermore, by using the Keio collection as a proxy for growth conditions differing in TPP levels, we perform a high-throughput screen analysis using high-density solid agar plates. Our study reveals several genes whose deletion leads to increased or decreased TPP levels. The approach developed here could be applicable to other riboswitches and reporter genes, thus representing a framework onto which further development could lead to highly sophisticated detection platforms allowing metabolic screens and identification of orphan riboswitches.

A nascent riboswitch helix orchestrates robust transcriptional regulation through signal integration

Widespread manganese-sensing transcriptional riboswitches effect the dependable gene regulation needed for bacterial manganese homeostasis in changing environments. Riboswitches - like most structured RNAs - are believed to fold co-transcriptionally, subject to both ligand binding and transcription events; yet how these processes are orchestrated for robust regulation is poorly understood. Through a combination of single-molecule and bulk approaches, we discover how a single Mn2+ ion and the transcribing RNA polymerase (RNAP), paused immediately downstream by a DNA template sequence, are coordinated by the bridging switch helix P1.1 in the representative Lactococcus lactis riboswitch. This coordination achieves a heretofore-overlooked semi-docked global conformation of the nascent RNA, P1.1 base pair stabilization, transcription factor NusA ejection, and RNAP pause extension, thereby enforcing transcription readthrough. Our work demonstrates how a central, adaptable RNA helix functions analogous to a molecular fulcrum of a first-class lever system to integrate disparate signals for finely balanced gene expression control.

RNA folding kinetics control riboswitch sensitivity in vivo

Riboswitches are ligand-responsive gene-regulatory RNA elements that perform key roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. Understanding how riboswitch sensitivity is controlled is critical to understanding how highly conserved aptamer domains are deployed in a variety of contexts with different sensitivity demands. Here we uncover new roles by which RNA folding dynamics control riboswitch sensitivity in cells. By investigating the Clostridium beijerinckii pfl ZTP riboswitch, we identify multiple mechanistic routes of altering expression platform sequence and structure to slow RNA folding, all of which enhance riboswitch sensitivity. Applying these methods to riboswitches with diverse aptamer architectures that regulate transcription and translation with ON and OFF logic demonstrates the generality of our findings, indicating that any riboswitch that operates in a kinetic regime can be sensitized by slowing expression platform folding. Comparison of the most sensitized versions of these switches to equilibrium aptamer:ligand dissociation constants suggests a limit to the sensitivities achievable by kinetic RNA switches. Our results add to the growing suite of knowledge and approaches that can be used to rationally program cotranscriptional RNA folding for biotechnology applications, and suggest general RNA folding principles for understanding dynamic RNA systems in other areas of biology.

Direct and indirect control of Rho-dependent transcription termination by the Escherichia coli lysC riboswitch

Bacterial riboswitches are molecular structures that play a crucial role in controlling gene expression to maintain cellular balance. The Escherichia coli lysC riboswitch has been previously shown to regulate gene expression through translation initiation and mRNA decay. Recent research suggests that lysC gene expression is also influenced by Rho-dependent transcription termination. Through a series of in silico, in vitro, and in vivo experiments, we provide experimental evidence that the lysC riboswitch directly and indirectly modulates Rho transcription termination. Our study demonstrates that Rho-dependent transcription termination plays a significant role in the cotranscriptional regulation of lysC expression. Together with previous studies, our work suggests that lysC expression is governed by a lysine-sensing riboswitch that regulates translation initiation, transcription termination, and mRNA degradation. Notably, both Rho and RNase E target the same region of the RNA molecule, implying that RNase E may degrade Rho-terminated transcripts, providing a means to selectively eliminate these incomplete messenger RNAs. Overall, this study sheds light on the complex regulatory mechanisms used by bacterial riboswitches, emphasizing the role of transcription termination in the control of gene expression and mRNA stability.

Shine-Dalgarno Accessibility Governs Ribosome Binding to the Adenine Riboswitch

Translational riboswitches located in the 5' UTR of the messenger RNA (mRNA) regulate translation through variation of the accessibility of the ribosome binding site (RBS). These are the result of conformational changes in the riboswitch RNA governed by ligand binding. Here, we use a combination of single-molecule colocalization techniques (Single-Molecule Kinetic Analysis of RNA Transient Structure (SiM-KARTS) and Single-Molecule Kinetic Analysis of Ribosome Binding (SiM-KARB)) and microscale thermophoresis (MST) to investigate the adenine-sensing riboswitch in Vibrio vulnificus, focusing on the changes of accessibility between the ligand-free and ligand-bound states. We show that both methods faithfully report on the accessibility of the RBS within the riboswitch and that both methods identify an increase in accessibility upon adenine binding. Expanding on the regulatory context, we show the impact of the ribosomal protein S1 on the unwinding of the RNA secondary structure, thereby favoring ribosome binding even for the apo state. The determined rate constants suggest that binding of the ribosome is faster than the time required to change from the ON state to the OFF state, a prerequisite for efficient regulation decision.

Flipping the script: Understanding riboswitches from an alternative perspective

Riboswitches are broadly distributed regulatory elements most frequently found in the 5'-leader sequence of bacterial mRNAs that regulate gene expression in response to the binding of a small molecule effector. The occupancy status of the ligand-binding aptamer domain manipulates downstream information in the message that instructs the expression machinery. Currently, there are over 55 validated riboswitch classes, where each class is defined based on the identity of the ligand it binds and/or sequence and structure conservation patterns within the aptamer domain. This classification reflects an "aptamer-centric" perspective that dominates our understanding of riboswitches. In this review, we propose a conceptual framework that groups riboswitches based on the mechanism by which RNA manipulates information directly instructing the expression machinery. This scheme does not replace the established aptamer domain-based classification of riboswitches but rather serves to facilitate hypothesis-driven investigation of riboswitch regulatory mechanisms. Based on current bioinformatic, structural, and biochemical studies of a broad spectrum of riboswitches, we propose three major mechanistic groups: (1) "direct occlusion", (2) "interdomain docking", and (3) "strand exchange". We discuss the defining features of each group, present representative examples of riboswitches from each group, and illustrate how these RNAs couple small molecule binding to gene regulation. While mechanistic studies of the occlusion and docking groups have yielded compelling models for how these riboswitches function, much less is known about strand exchange processes. To conclude, we outline the limitations of our mechanism-based conceptual framework and discuss how critical information within riboswitch expression platforms can inform gene regulation.

A nascent riboswitch helix orchestrates robust transcriptional regulation through signal integration

Widespread manganese-sensing transcriptional riboswitches effect the dependable gene regulation needed for bacterial manganese homeostasis in changing environments. Riboswitches - like most structured RNAs - are believed to fold co-transcriptionally, subject to both ligand binding and transcription events; yet how these processes are orchestrated for robust regulation is poorly understood. Through a combination of single molecule and bulk approaches, we discovered how a single Mn 2+ ion and the transcribing RNA polymerase (RNAP), paused immediately downstream by a DNA template sequence, are coordinated by the bridging switch helix P1.1 in the paradigmatic Lactococcus lactis riboswitch. This coordination achieves a heretofore-overlooked semi-docked global conformation of the nascent RNA, P1.1 base pair stabilization, transcription factor NusA ejection, and RNAP pause extension, thereby enforcing transcription readthrough. Our work demonstrates how a central, adaptable RNA helix functions analogous to a molecular fulcrum of a first-class lever system to integrate disparate signals for finely balanced gene expression control.

Co-transcriptional folding of the glmS ribozyme enables a rapid response to metabolite

The glmS ribozyme riboswitch, located in the 5' untranslated region of the Bacillus subtilis glmS messenger RNA (mRNA), regulates cell wall biosynthesis through ligand-induced self-cleavage and decay of the glmS mRNA. Although self-cleavage of the refolded glmS ribozyme has been studied extensively, it is not known how early the ribozyme folds and self-cleaves during transcription. Here, we combine single-molecule fluorescence with kinetic modeling to show that self-cleavage can occur during transcription before the ribozyme is fully synthesized. Moreover, co-transcriptional folding of the RNA at a physiological elongation rate allows the ribozyme catalytic core to react without the downstream peripheral stability domain. Dimethyl sulfate footprinting further revealed how slow sequential folding favors formation of the native core structure through fraying of misfolded helices and nucleation of a native pseudoknot. Ribozyme self-cleavage at an early stage of transcription may benefit glmS regulation in B. subtilis, as it exposes the mRNA to exoribonuclease before translation of the open reading frame can begin. Our results emphasize the importance of co-transcriptional folding of RNA tertiary structure for cis-regulation of mRNA stability.

Regulation of magnesium ion transport in Escherichia coli: insights into the role of the 5' upstream region in corA expression

In Escherichia coli, transport of magnesium ions across the cellular membrane relies on MgtA and CorA transporters. While the expression of mgtA is controlled by the two-component system PhoQ/PhoP and 5' upstream region elements, corA expression is considered to be constitutive and not to depend on cellular factors. Importantly, the 5' upstream region of corA is predicted to fold into structures highly similar to the magnesium-sensing mgtA 5' upstream region. Here using biochemical and genetic assays, we show that the intracellular concentration of magnesium ions affects corA expression. Similarly to mgtA, we find that the effect of magnesium ions on corA expression is mediated by the 5' upstream region. We demonstrate that the RNA structure is important for regulation and that the Rho transcription factor is involved in the modulation of transcription termination. Consistent with previous studies, we find that translation of corL, a short ORF located within the 5' upstream region, is important for corA regulation. Our data indicate that the efficiency of corL translation is inversely proportional to corA expression, similar to what has been described for mgtA and corA in Salmonella enterica. Using a novel assay to control the import of magnesium ions, we show that while the expression of mgtA is regulated by both extra- and intracellular magnesium ions, corA is regulated by variations in intracellular magnesium ions. Our results support a model in which the expression of corA is regulated by the 5' upstream region that senses variations of intracellular magnesium ions.

Targeting FMN, TPP, SAM-I, and glmS Riboswitches with Chimeric Antisense Oligonucleotides for Completely Rational Antibacterial Drug Development

Antimicrobial drug resistance has emerged as a significant challenge in contemporary medicine due to the proliferation of numerous bacterial strains resistant to all existing antibiotics. Meanwhile, riboswitches have emerged as promising targets for discovering antibacterial drugs. Riboswitches are regulatory elements in certain bacterial mRNAs that can bind to specific molecules and control gene expression via transcriptional termination, prevention of translation, or mRNA destabilization. By targeting riboswitches, we aim to develop innovative strategies to combat antibiotic-resistant bacteria and enhance the efficacy of antibacterial treatments. This convergence of challenges and opportunities underscores the ongoing quest to revolutionize medical approaches against evolving bacterial threats. For the first time, this innovative review describes the rational design and applications of chimeric antisense oligonucleotides as antibacterial agents targeting four riboswitches selected based on genome-wide bioinformatic analyses. The antisense oligonucleotides are coupled with the cell-penetrating oligopeptide pVEC, which penetrates Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria and specifically targets glmS, FMN, TPP, and SAM-I riboswitches in Staphylococcus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes, and Escherichia coli. The average antibiotic dosage of antisense oligonucleotides that inhibits 80% of bacterial growth is around 700 nM (4.5 μg/mL). Antisense oligonucleotides do not exhibit toxicity in human cell lines at this concentration. The results demonstrate that these riboswitches are suitable targets for antibacterial drug development using antisense oligonucleotide technology. The approach is fully rational because selecting suitable riboswitch targets and designing ASOs that target them are based on predefined criteria. The approach can be used to develop narrow or broad-spectrum antibiotics against multidrug-resistant bacterial strains for a short time. The approach is easily adaptive to new resistance using targeting NGS technology.

A transient intermediate RNA structure underlies the regulatory function of the E. coli thiB TPP translational riboswitch

Riboswitches are cis-regulatory RNA elements that regulate gene expression in response to ligand binding through the coordinated action of a ligand-binding aptamer domain (AD) and a downstream expression platform (EP). Previous studies of transcriptional riboswitches have uncovered diverse examples that utilize structural intermediates that compete with the AD and EP folds to mediate the switching mechanism on the timescale of transcription. Here we investigate whether similar intermediates are important for riboswitches that control translation by studying the Escherichia coli thiB thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP) riboswitch. Using cellular gene expression assays, we first confirmed that the riboswitch acts at the level of translational regulation. Deletion mutagenesis showed the importance of the AD-EP linker sequence for riboswitch function. Sequence complementarity between the linker region and the AD P1 stem suggested the possibility of an intermediate nascent RNA structure called the antisequestering stem that could mediate the thiB switching mechanism. Experimentally informed secondary structure models of the thiB folding pathway generated from chemical probing of nascent thiB structures in stalled transcription elongation complexes confirmed the presence of the antisequestering stem, and showed it may form cotranscriptionally. Additional mutational analysis showed that mutations to the antisequestering stem break or bias thiB function according to whether the antisequestering stem or P1 is favored. This work provides an important example of intermediate structures that compete with AD and EP folds to implement riboswitch mechanisms.

Cell-free transcription-translation system: a dual read-out assay to characterize riboswitch function

Cell-free protein synthesis assays have become a valuable tool to understand transcriptional and translational processes. Here, we established a fluorescence-based coupled in vitro transcription-translation assay as a read-out system to simultaneously quantify mRNA and protein levels. We utilized the well-established quantification of the expression of shifted green fluorescent protein (sGFP) as a read-out of protein levels. In addition, we determined mRNA quantities using a fluorogenic Mango-(IV) RNA aptamer that becomes fluorescent upon binding to the fluorophore thiazole orange (TO). We utilized a Mango-(IV) RNA aptamer system comprising four subsequent Mango-(IV) RNA aptamer elements with improved sensitivity by building Mango arrays. The design of this reporter assay resulted in a sensitive read-out with a high signal-to-noise ratio, allowing us to monitor transcription and translation time courses in cell-free assays with continuous monitoring of fluorescence changes as well as snapshots of the reaction. Furthermore, we applied this dual read-out assay to investigate the function of thiamine-sensing riboswitches thiM and thiC from Escherichia coli and the adenine-sensing riboswitch ASW from Vibrio vulnificus and pbuE from Bacillus subtilis, which represent transcriptional and translational on- and off-riboswitches, respectively. This approach enabled a microplate-based application, a valuable addition to the toolbox for high-throughput screening of riboswitch function.

Translation regulation by a guanidine-II riboswitch is highly tunable in sensitivity, dynamic range, and apparent cooperativity

Riboswitches function as important translational regulators in bacteria. Comprehensive mutational analysis of transcriptional riboswitches has been used to probe the energetic intricacies of interplay between the aptamer and expression platform, but translational riboswitches have been inaccessible to massively parallel techniques. The guanidine-II (gdm-II) riboswitch is an exclusively translational class. We have integrated RelE cleavage with next-generation sequencing to quantify ligand-dependent changes in translation initiation for all single and double mutations of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa gdm-II riboswitch, a total of more than 23,000 variants. This extensive mutational analysis is consistent with the prominent features of the bioinformatic consensus. These data indicate, unexpectedly, that direct sequestration of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence is dispensable for riboswitch function. Additionally, this comprehensive data set reveals important positions not identified in previous computational and crystallographic studies. Mutations in the variable linker region stabilize alternate conformations. The double mutant data reveal the functional importance of the previously modeled P0b helix formed by the 5' and 3' tails that serves as the basis for translational control. Additional mutations to GU wobble base pairs in both P1 and P2 reveal how the apparent cooperativity of the system involves an intricate network of communication between the two binding sites. This comprehensive examination of a translational riboswitch's expression platform illuminates how the riboswitch is precisely tuned and tunable with regard to ligand sensitivity, the amplitude of expression between ON and OFF states, and the cooperativity of ligand binding.

Ionic Cooperativity between Lysine and Potassium in the Lysine Riboswitch: Single-Molecule Kinetic and Thermodynamic Studies

Functionality in many biological systems, including proteins and nucleic acid structures, including protein and nucleic acid riboswitch structures, can depend on cooperative kinetic behavior between multiple small molecule ligands. In this work, single-molecule FRET data on the Bacillus subtilis lysine riboswitch reveals that affinity for the cognate lysine ligand increases significantly with K⁺, providing evidence for synergism between lysine/K⁺ binding to the aptamer and successful folding of the riboswitch. To describe/interpret this more complex kinetic scenario, we explore the conventional 4-state ("square") model for aptamer binding as a function of K⁺. Extension into this additional dimension generates a novel "cube" model for riboswitch folding dynamics with respect to lysine/K⁺ binding, revealing that riboswitch folding (k_fold) and unfolding (k_unfold) rate constants increase and decrease dramatically with K⁺, respectively. Furthermore, temperature-dependent single-molecule kinetic studies indicate that the presence of K⁺ entropically enhances the transition state barrier to folding but partially compensates for this by increasing the overall exothermicity for lysine binding. We rationalize this behavior as evidence that K⁺ facilitates hydrogen bonding between the negatively charged carboxyl group of lysine and the RNA, increasing structural rigidity and lowering entropy in the binding pocket. Finally, we explore the effects of cation size with Na⁺ and Cs⁺ studies to demonstrate that K⁺ is optimally suited for bridging interactions between lysine and the riboswitch aptamer domain. Regulation of lysine production and transport, dictated by the riboswitch's ability to recognize and bind lysine, is therefore intimately tied to the presence of K⁺ in the binding pocket and is strongly modulated by local cation conditions. The results suggest an increase in lysine riboswitch functionality by sensitivity to additional species in the cellular riboswitch environment.

Discovering riboswitches: the past and the future

Riboswitches are structured noncoding RNA domains used by many bacteria to monitor the concentrations of target ligands and regulate gene expression accordingly. In the past 20 years over 55 distinct classes of natural riboswitches have been discovered that selectively sense small molecules or elemental ions, and thousands more are predicted to exist. Evidence suggests that some riboswitches might be direct descendants of the RNA-based sensors and switches that were likely present in ancient organisms before the evolutionary emergence of proteins. We provide an overview of the current state of riboswitch research, focusing primarily on the discovery of riboswitches, and speculate on the major challenges facing researchers in the field.

Efficient quantitative monitoring of translational initiation by RelE cleavage

The sequences of the 5′ untranslated regions (5′-UTRs) of mRNA alter gene expression across domains of life. Transcriptional modulators can be easily assayed through transcription termination, but translational regulators often require indirect, laborious methods. We have leveraged RelE’s ribosome-dependent endonuclease activity to develop a quantitative assay to monitor translation initiation of cis-regulatory mRNAs. RelE cleavage accurately reports ligand-dependent changes in ribosome association for two translational riboswitches and provides quantitative information about each switch's sensitivity and range of response. RelE accurately reads out sequence-driven changes in riboswitch specificity and function and is quantitatively dependent upon ligand concentration. RelE cleavage similarly captures differences in translation initiation between yeast 5′-UTR isoforms. RelE cleavage can thus reveal a plethora of information about translation initiation in different domains of life.

Key players in regulatory RNA realm of bacteria

Precise regulation of gene expression is crucial for living cells to adapt for survival in diverse environmental conditions. Among the common cellular regulatory mechanisms, RNA-based regulators play a key role in all domains of life. Discovery of regulatory RNAs have made a paradigm shift in molecular biology as many regulatory functions of RNA have been identified beyond its canonical roles as messenger, ribosomal and transfer RNA. In the complex regulatory RNA network, riboswitches, small RNAs, and RNA thermometers can be identified as some of the key players. Herein, we review the discovery, mechanism, and potential therapeutic use of these classes of regulatory RNAs mainly found in bacteria. Being highly adaptive organisms that inhabit a broad range of ecological niches, bacteria have adopted tight and rapid-responding gene regulation mechanisms. This review aims to highlight how bacteria utilize versatile RNA structures and sequences to build a sophisticated gene regulation network.

•

The three major classes of prokaryotic ncRNAs and their characterized mechanisms of operation in gene regulation.

•

sRNAs emerging as major players in global gene regulatory networks.

•

Riboswitch mediated gene control mechanisms through on/off switches in response to ligand binding.

•

RNA thermo sensors for temperature-dependent gene expression.

•

Therapeutic importance of ncRNAs and computational approaches involved in the discovery of ncRNAs.

Characterization of Five Purine Riboswitches in Cellular and Cell-Free Expression Systems

Bacillus subtilis employs five purine riboswitches for the control of purine de novo synthesis and transport at the transcription level. All of them are formed by a structurally conserved aptamer, and a variable expression platform harboring a rho-independent transcription terminator. In this study, we characterized all five purine riboswitches under the context of active gene expression processes both in vitro and in vivo. We identified transcription pause sites located in the expression platform upstream of the terminator of each riboswitch. Moreover, we defined a correlation between in vitro transcription readthrough and in vivo gene expression. Our in vitro assay demonstrated that the riboswitches operate in the micromolar range of concentration for the cognate metabolite. Our in vivo assay showed the dynamics of the control of gene expression by each riboswitch. This study deepens the knowledge of the regulatory mechanism of purine riboswitches.

High-throughput screening of cell-free riboswitches by fluorescence-activated droplet sorting

Cell-free systems that display complex functions without using living cells are emerging as new platforms to test our understanding of biological systems as well as for practical applications such as biosensors and biomanufacturing. Those that use cell-free protein synthesis (CFPS) systems to enable genetically programmed protein synthesis have relied on genetic regulatory components found or engineered in living cells. However, biological constraints such as cell permeability, metabolic stability, and toxicity of signaling molecules prevent development of cell-free devices using living cells even if cell-free systems are not subject to such constraints. Efforts to engineer regulatory components directly in CFPS systems thus far have been based on low-throughput experimental approaches, limiting the availability of basic components to build cell-free systems with diverse functions. Here, we report a high-throughput screening method to engineer cell-free riboswitches that respond to small molecules. Droplet-sorting of riboswitch variants in a CFPS system rapidly identified cell-free riboswitches that respond to compounds that are not amenable to bacterial screening methods. Finally, we used a histamine riboswitch to demonstrate chemical communication between cell-sized droplets.

Repurposing an adenine riboswitch into a fluorogenic imaging and sensing tag

Fluorogenic RNA aptamers are used to genetically encode fluorescent RNA and to construct RNA-based metabolite sensors. Unlike naturally occurring aptamers that efficiently fold and undergo metabolite-induced conformational changes, fluorogenic aptamers can exhibit poor folding, which limits their cellular fluorescence. To overcome this, we evolved a naturally occurring well-folded adenine riboswitch into a fluorogenic aptamer. We generated a library of roughly 1015 adenine aptamer-like RNAs in which the adenine-binding pocket was randomized for both size and sequence, and selected Squash, which binds and activates the fluorescence of green fluorescent protein-like fluorophores. Squash exhibits markedly improved in-cell folding and highly efficient metabolite-dependent folding when fused to a S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-binding aptamer. A Squash-based ratiometric sensor achieved quantitative SAM measurements, revealed cell-to-cell heterogeneity in SAM levels and revealed metabolic origins of SAM. These studies show that the efficient folding of naturally occurring aptamers can be exploited to engineer well-folded cell-compatible fluorogenic aptamers and devices.

Lysine-Dependent Entropy Effects in the B. subtilis Lysine Riboswitch: Insights from Single-Molecule Thermodynamic Studies

Riboswitches play an important role in RNA-based sensing/gene regulation control for many bacteria. In particular, the accessibility of multiple conformational states at physiological temperatures allows riboswitches to selectively bind a cognate ligand in the aptamer domain, which triggers secondary structural changes in the expression platform, and thereby "switching" between on or off transcriptional or translational states for the downstream RNA. The present work exploits temperature-controlled, single-molecule total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) microscopy to study the thermodynamic landscape of such ligand binding/folding processes, specifically for the Bacillus subtilis lysine riboswitch. The results confirm that the riboswitch folds via an induced-fit (IF) mechanism, in which cognate lysine ligand first binds to the riboswitch before structural rearrangement takes place. The transition state to folding is found to be enthalpically favored (ΔH_fold^‡ < 0), yet with a free-energy barrier that is predominantly entropic (-TΔS_fold^‡ > 0), which results in folding (unfolding) rate constants strongly dependent (independent) of lysine concentration. Analysis of the single-molecule kinetic "trajectories" reveals this rate constant dependence of k_fold on lysine to be predominantly entropic in nature, with the additional lysine conferring preferential advantage to the folding process by the presence of ligands correctly oriented with respect to the riboswitch platform. By way of contrast, van't Hoff analysis reveals enthalpic contributions to the overall folding thermodynamics (ΔH⁰) to be surprisingly constant and robustly independent of lysine concentration. The results demonstrate the crucial role of hydrogen bonding between the ligand and riboswitch platform but with only a relatively modest fraction (45%) of the overall enthalpy change needed to access the transition state and initiate transcriptional switching.

A transient conformation facilitates ligand binding to the adenine riboswitch

RNAs adopt various conformations to perform different functions in cells. Incapable of acquiring intermediates, the key initiations of ligand recognition in the adenine riboswitch have not been characterized. In this work, stopped-flow fluorescence was used to track structural switches in the full-length adenine riboswitch in real time. We used PLOR (position-selective labeling of RNA) to incorporate fluorophores into desired positions in the RNA. The switching sequence P1 responded to adenine more rapidly than helix P4 and the binding pocket, followed by stabilization of the binding pocket, P4, and annealing of P1. Moreover, a transient intermediate consisting of an unwound P1 was detected during adenine binding. These events were observed in both the WT riboswitch and a functional mutant. The findings provide insight into the conformational changes of the riboswitch RNA triggered by a ligand.

•

Real-time tracking of the adenine riboswitch at nucleotide resolution

•

A transient conformation with unwound P1 is identified in the adenine riboswitch

•

Helix P1 responds to ligand quicker than the binding pocket or expression platform

Dynamic competition between a ligand and transcription factor NusA governs riboswitch-mediated transcription regulation

Cotranscriptional RNA folding is widely assumed to influence the timely control of gene expression, but our understanding remains limited. In bacteria, the fluoride (F^-)-sensing riboswitch is a transcriptional control element essential to defend against toxic F^- levels. Using this model riboswitch, we find that its ligand F^- and essential bacterial transcription factor NusA compete to bind the cotranscriptionally folding RNA, opposing each other's modulation of downstream pausing and termination by RNA polymerase. Single-molecule fluorescence assays probing active transcription elongation complexes discover that NusA unexpectedly binds highly reversibly, frequently interrogating the complex for emerging, cotranscriptionally folding RNA duplexes. NusA thus fine-tunes the transcription rate in dependence of the ligand-responsive higher-order structure of the riboswitch. At the high NusA concentrations found intracellularly, this dynamic modulation is expected to lead to adaptive bacterial transcription regulation with fast response times.

Siblings or doppelgängers? Deciphering the evolution of structured cis-regulatory RNAs beyond homology

Structured cis-regulatory RNAs have evolved across all domains of life, highlighting the utility and plasticity of RNA as a regulatory molecule. Homologous RNA sequences and structures often have similar functions, but homology may also be deceiving. The challenges that derive from trying to assign function to structure and vice versa are not trivial. Bacterial riboswitches, viral and eukaryotic IRESes, CITEs, and 3′ UTR elements employ an array of mechanisms to exert their effects. Bioinformatic searches coupled with biochemical and functional validation have elucidated some shared and many unique ways cis-regulators are employed in mRNA transcripts. As cis-regulatory RNAs are resolved in greater detail, it is increasingly apparent that shared homology can mask the full spectrum of mRNA cis-regulator functional diversity. Furthermore, similar functions may be obscured by lack of obvious sequence similarity. Thus looking beyond homology is crucial for furthering our understanding of RNA-based regulation.

Switching at the ribosome: riboswitches need rProteins as modulators to regulate translation

Translational riboswitches are cis-acting RNA regulators that modulate the expression of genes during translation initiation. Their mechanism is considered as an RNA-only gene-regulatory system inducing a ligand-dependent shift of the population of functional ON- and OFF-states. The interaction of riboswitches with the translation machinery remained unexplored. For the adenine-sensing riboswitch from Vibrio vulnificus we show that ligand binding alone is not sufficient for switching to a translational ON-state but the interaction of the riboswitch with the 30S ribosome is indispensable. Only the synergy of binding of adenine and of 30S ribosome, in particular protein rS1, induces complete opening of the translation initiation region. Our investigation thus unravels the intricate dynamic network involving RNA regulator, ligand inducer and ribosome protein modulator during translation initiation.

Translational regulation by riboswitches is an important mechanism for the modulation of gene expression in bacteria. Here the authors show that the ligand-induced allosteric switch in the adenine-sensing riboswitch from V. vulnificus is insufficient and leads only to a partial opening of the ribosome binding site and requires interaction with 30S-bound ribosomal protein S1, which acts as an RNA chaperone.

A structural intermediate pre-organizes the add adenine riboswitch for ligand recognition

Riboswitches are RNA sequences that regulate gene expression by undergoing structural changes upon the specific binding of cellular metabolites. Crystal structures of purine-sensing riboswitches have revealed an intricate network of interactions surrounding the ligand in the bound complex. The mechanistic details about how the aptamer folding pathway is involved in the formation of the metabolite binding site have been previously shown to be highly important for the riboswitch regulatory activity. Here, a combination of single-molecule FRET and SHAPE assays have been used to characterize the folding pathway of the adenine riboswitch from Vibrio vulnificus. Experimental evidences suggest a folding process characterized by the presence of a structural intermediate involved in ligand recognition. This intermediate state acts as an open conformation to ensure ligand accessibility to the aptamer and folds into a structure nearly identical to the ligand-bound complex through a series of structural changes. This study demonstrates that the add riboswitch relies on the folding of a structural intermediate that pre-organizes the aptamer global structure and the ligand binding site to allow efficient metabolite sensing and riboswitch genetic regulation.

Thermal adaptation of structural dynamics and regulatory function of adenine riboswitch

Ligand binding and temperature play important roles in riboswitch RNAs' structures and functions. However, most studies focused on studying structural dynamics or gene-regulation function of riboswitches from the aspect of ligand, instead of temperature. Here we combined NMR, ITC, stopped-flow and in vivo assays to investigate the ligand-triggered switch of adenine riboswitch from 10 to 45°C. Our results demonstrated that at single-nucleotide resolution, structural regions sensed ligand and temperature diversely. Temperature had opposite effects on ligand-binding and gene-regulation of adenine riboswitch. Compared with higher temperature, the RNA bound with its cognate ligand obviously stronger, while its regulatory capacity was weakened at lower temperature. In addition, application of specific-labelled RNAs to the stopped-flow experiments identified the real-time folding of the specific positions upon ligand addition at different temperatures. The kissing loop and internal loop at the riboswitch responded to ligand and temperature differently. The distinct thermo-dynamics of adenine riboswitch exposed here may contribute to the fields of RNA sensors and drug design.

A second riboswitch class for the enzyme cofactor NAD. RNA (NEW YORK, N.Y.) 2021;27:99-105. [PMID: 33087526 PMCID: PMC7749635 DOI: 10.1261/rna.077891.120]

A bacterial noncoding RNA motif almost exclusively associated with pnuC genes was uncovered using comparative sequence analysis. Some PnuC proteins are known to transport nicotinamide riboside (NR), which is a component of the ubiquitous and abundant enzyme cofactor nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD⁺). Thus, we speculated that the newly found "pnuC motif" RNAs might function as aptamers for a novel class of NAD⁺-sensing riboswitches. RNA constructs that encompass the conserved nucleotides and secondary structure features that define the motif indeed selectively bind NAD⁺, nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN), and NR. Mutations that disrupt strictly conserved nucleotides of the aptamer also disrupt ligand binding. These bioinformatic and biochemical findings indicate that pnuC motif RNAs are likely members of a second riboswitch class that regulates gene expression in response to NAD⁺ binding.

Requirements for efficient ligand-gated co-transcriptional switching in designed variants of the B. subtilis pbuE adenine-responsive riboswitch in E. coli

Riboswitches, generally located in the 5'-leader of bacterial mRNAs, direct expression via a small molecule-dependent structural switch that informs the transcriptional or translational machinery. While the structure and function of riboswitch effector-binding (aptamer) domains have been intensely studied, only recently have the requirements for efficient linkage between small molecule binding and the structural switch in the cellular and co-transcriptional context begun to be actively explored. To address this aspect of riboswitch function, we have performed a structure-guided mutagenic analysis of the B. subtilis pbuE adenine-responsive riboswitch, one of the simplest riboswitches that employs a strand displacement switching mechanism to regulate transcription. Using a cell-based fluorescent protein reporter assay to assess ligand-dependent regulatory activity in E. coli, these studies revealed previously unrecognized features of the riboswitch. Within the aptamer domain, local and long-range conformational dynamics influenced by sequences within helices have a significant effect upon efficient regulatory switching. Sequence features of the expression platform including the pre-aptamer leader sequence, a toehold helix and an RNA polymerase pause site all serve to promote strong ligand-dependent regulation. By optimizing these features, we were able to improve the performance of the B. subtilis pbuE riboswitch in E. coli from 5.6-fold induction of reporter gene expression by the wild type riboswitch to over 120-fold in the top performing designed variant. Together, these data point to sequence and structural features distributed throughout the riboswitch required to strike a balance between rates of ligand binding, transcription and secondary structural switching via a strand exchange mechanism and yield new insights into the design of artificial riboswitches.

Real-time monitoring of single ZTP riboswitches reveals a complex and kinetically controlled decision landscape

RNAs begin to fold and function during transcription. Riboswitches undergo cotranscriptional switching in the context of transcription elongation, RNA folding, and ligand binding. To investigate how these processes jointly modulate the function of the folate stress-sensing Fusobacterium ulcerans ZTP riboswitch, we apply a single-molecule vectorial folding (VF) assay in which an engineered superhelicase Rep-X sequentially releases fluorescently labeled riboswitch RNA from a heteroduplex in a 5′-to-3′ direction, at ~60 nt s⁻¹ [comparable to the speed of bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP)]. We demonstrate that the ZTP riboswitch is kinetically controlled and that its activation is favored by slower unwinding, strategic pausing between but not before key folding elements, or a weakened transcription terminator. Real-time single-molecule monitoring captures folding riboswitches in multiple states, including an intermediate responsible for delayed terminator formation. These results show how individual nascent RNAs occupy distinct channels within the folding landscape that controls the fate of the riboswitch.

Many RNAs become functional before their synthesis completes. Here the authors employ a single-molecule vectorial folding assay mimicking RNA transcription and show that the ZTP riboswitch is kinetically controlled and activated by slower unwinding and strategic pausing.

Analysis of a preQ1-I riboswitch in effector-free and bound states reveals a metabolite-programmed nucleobase-stacking spine that controls gene regulation

Riboswitches are structured RNA motifs that recognize metabolites to alter the conformations of downstream sequences, leading to gene regulation. To investigate this molecular framework, we determined crystal structures of a preQ1-I riboswitch in effector-free and bound states at 2.00 Å and 2.65 Å-resolution. Both pseudoknots exhibited the elusive L2 loop, which displayed distinct conformations. Conversely, the Shine-Dalgarno sequence (SDS) in the S2 helix of each structure remained unbroken. The expectation that the effector-free state should expose the SDS prompted us to conduct solution experiments to delineate environmental changes to specific nucleobases in response to preQ1. We then used nudged elastic band computational methods to derive conformational-change pathways linking the crystallographically-determined effector-free and bound-state structures. Pathways featured: (i) unstacking and unpairing of L2 and S2 nucleobases without preQ1-exposing the SDS for translation and (ii) stacking and pairing L2 and S2 nucleobases with preQ1-sequestering the SDS. Our results reveal how preQ1 binding reorganizes L2 into a nucleobase-stacking spine that sequesters the SDS, linking effector recognition to biological function. The generality of stacking spines as conduits for effector-dependent, interdomain communication is discussed in light of their existence in adenine riboswitches, as well as the turnip yellow mosaic virus ribosome sensor.

Transcriptional and translational S-box riboswitches differ in ligand-binding properties

There are a number of riboswitches that utilize the same ligand-binding domain to regulate transcription or translation. S-box (SAM-I) riboswitches, including the riboswitch present in the Bacillus subtilis metI gene, which encodes cystathionine γ-synthase, regulate the expression of genes involved in methionine metabolism in response to SAM, primarily at the level of transcriptional attenuation. A rarer class of S-box riboswitches is predicted to regulate translation initiation. Here we identified and characterized a translational S-box riboswitch in the metI gene from Desulfurispirillum indicum The regulatory mechanisms of riboswitches are influenced by the kinetics of ligand interaction. The half-life of the translational D. indicum metI RNA-SAM complex is significantly shorter than that of the transcriptional B. subtilis metI RNA. This finding suggests that, unlike the transcriptional RNA, the translational metI riboswitch can make multiple reversible regulatory decisions. Comparison of both RNAs revealed that the second internal loop of helix P3 in the transcriptional RNA usually contains an A residue, whereas the translational RNA contains a C residue that is conserved in other S-box RNAs that are predicted to regulate translation. Mutational analysis indicated that the presence of an A or C residue correlates with RNA-SAM complex stability. Biochemical analyses indicate that the internal loop sequence critically determines the stability of the RNA-SAM complex by influencing the flexibility of residues involved in SAM binding and thereby affects the molecular mechanism of riboswitch function.

Determination of RNA structural diversity and its role in HIV-1 RNA splicing

Human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) is a retrovirus with a 10-kb single-stranded RNA genome. HIV-1 must express all of its gene products from the same primary transcript, which undergoes alternative splicing to produce diverse protein products, including structural proteins and regulatory factors^1,2. Despite the critical role of alternative splicing, the mechanisms driving splice-site choice are poorly understood. Synonymous RNA mutations that lead to severe defects in splicing and viral replication indicate the presence of unknown cis-regulatory elements³. We use DMS-MaPseq to probe the structure of HIV-1 RNA in cells and develop an algorithm called Detection of RNA folding Ensembles using Expectation-Maximization (DREEM), which reveals alternative conformations assumed by the same RNA sequence. Contrary to previous models, which analyzed population averages⁴, our results reveal the widespread heterogeneous nature of HIV-1 RNA structure. In addition to confirming that in vitro characterized alternative structures for the HIV-1 Rev Responsive Element (RRE) exist in cells, we discover alternative conformations at critical splice sites that influence the ratio of transcript isoforms. Our simultaneous measurement of splicing and intracellular RNA structure provides evidence for the long-standing hypothesis^5–7 that RNA conformation heterogeneity regulates splice site usage and viral gene expression.

Refolding through a Linear Transition State Enables Fast Temperature Adaptation of a Translational Riboswitch

The adenine-sensing riboswitch from the Gram-negative bacterium Vibrio vulnificus is an RNA-based gene regulatory element that acts in response to both its cognate low-molecular weight ligand and temperature. The combined sensitivity to environmental temperature and ligand concentration is maintained by an equilibrium of three distinct conformations involving two ligand-free states and one ligand-bound state. The key structural element that undergoes refolding in the ligand-free states comprises a 35-nucleotide temperature response module. Here, we present the structural characterization of this temperature response module. We employ high-resolution NMR spectroscopy and photocaged RNAs as molecular probes to decipher the kinetic and thermodynamic framework of the secondary structure transition in the apo state of the riboswitch. We propose a model for the transition state adopted during the thermal refolding of the temperature response module that connects two mutually exclusive long-lived and stable conformational states. This transition state is characterized by a comparatively low free activation enthalpy. A pseudoknot conformation in the transition state, as commonly seen in RNA refolding, is therefore unlikely. More likely, the transition state of the adenine-sensing riboswitch temperature response module features a linear conformation.

High-affinity recognition of specific tRNAs by an mRNA anticodon-binding groove

T-box riboswitches are modular bacterial noncoding RNAs that sense and regulate amino acid availability through direct interactions with tRNAs. Between the 5' anticodon-binding stem I domain and the 3' amino acid sensing domains of most T-boxes lies the stem II domain of unknown structure and function. Here, we report a 2.8-Å cocrystal structure of the Nocardia farcinica ileS T-box in complex with its cognate tRNA^Ile. The structure reveals a perpendicularly arranged ultrashort stem I containing a K-turn and an elongated stem II bearing an S-turn. Both stems rest against a compact pseudoknot, dock via an extended ribose zipper and jointly create a binding groove specific to the anticodon of its cognate tRNA. Contrary to proposed distal contacts to the tRNA elbow region, stem II locally reinforces the codon-anticodon interactions between stem I and tRNA, achieving low-nanomolar affinity. This study illustrates how mRNA junctions can create specific binding sites for interacting RNAs of prescribed sequence and structure.

Evidence that the nadA motif is a bacterial riboswitch for the ubiquitous enzyme cofactor NAD. RNA (NEW YORK, N.Y.) 2019;25:1616-1627. [PMID: 31467147 PMCID: PMC6859854 DOI: 10.1261/rna.072538.119]

The nadA motif is a riboswitch candidate present in various Acidobacteria species that was previously identified by bioinformatic analysis of bacterial DNA data sets. More than 100 unique representatives have been identified exclusively upstream of nadA genes, which code for an enzyme in the biosynthetic pathway of the ubiquitous coenzyme NAD⁺ The architecture of nadA motif RNAs suggests they use structurally similar tandem ligand-binding aptamer domains to control translation initiation. Biochemical analyses reveal that the first domain selectively binds ligands carrying an adenosine 5'-diphosphate (5' ADP) moiety, including NAD⁺ and its reduced form, NADH. Genetic analyses indicate that a tandem nadA motif RNA suppresses gene expression when NAD⁺ is abundant, and that both aptamer domains are required for maximal gene regulation. However, we have not observed selective binding of the nicotinamide moiety of NAD⁺ or binding by the second putative aptamer in vitro, despite sequence and structural similarities between the tandem domains.

On the role of mRNA secondary structure in bacterial translation

Messenger RNA (mRNA) is no longer considered as a mere informational molecule whose sole function is to convey the genetic information specified by DNA to the ribosome. Beyond this primary function, mRNA also contains additional instructions that influence the way and the extent to which this message is translated by the ribosome into protein(s). Indeed, owing to its intrinsic propensity to quickly and dynamically fold and form higher order structures, mRNA exhibits a second layer of structural information specified by the sequence itself. Besides influencing transcription and mRNA stability, this additional information also affects translation, and more precisely the frequency of translation initiation, the choice of open reading frame by recoding, the elongation speed, and the folding of the nascent protein. Many studies in bacteria have shown that mRNA secondary structure participates to the rapid adaptation of these versatile organisms to changing environmental conditions by efficiently tuning translation in response to diverse signals, such as the presence of ligands, regulatory proteins, or small RNAs. This article is categorized under: Regulatory RNAs/RNAi/Riboswitches > Regulatory RNAs RNA Structure and Dynamics > Influence of RNA Structure in Biological Systems Translation > Translation Regulation.

Regulation of the thiamine pyrophosphate (TPP)-sensing riboswitch in NMT1 mRNA from Neurospora crassa

The expression of Neurospora crassa NMT1 involved in thiamine pyrophosphate (TPP) metabolism is regulated at the level of mRNA splicing by a TPP-sensing riboswitch within the precursor NMT1 mRNA. Here, using the systematic helix-based computational method, we investigated the regulation of this riboswitch. We find that the function of the riboswitch does not depend on the transcription process. Whether TPP is present or not, the riboswitch predominately folds into the ON state, while the OFF state aptamer structure does not appear during transcription. Since the transition from the ON state to the aptamer structure is extremely slow, TPP may interact with the RNA before full formation of the aptamer structure, promoting the switch flipping. The potential to fully form helix P0 of the ON state is necessary to restore ligand-dependent gene control by the riboswitch.

Riboswitches: choosing the best platform

Riboswitch discovery and characterisation have come a long way since the term was first coined almost two decades ago. Riboswitches themselves are likely derived from ancient ligand-binding transcripts, which have evolved into sophisticated genetic control elements that are widespread in prokaryotes. Riboswitches are associated with a multitude of cellular processes including biosynthetic pathways, transport mechanisms and stress responses leading to an ever-increasing appreciation for an in-depth understanding of their triggers and functions in order to address physiological and regulatory questions. The majority of riboswitches exert their control via transcriptional or translational expression platforms depending on their genetic context. It remains, however, to be determined precisely why one platform is favoured over another. Is this a question of the layout of the gene expression machinery, ligand availability, the degree of control required, serendipity or various combinations of these? With this review, rather than providing answers, I am hoping to plant a seed for further scientific discussions about this puzzle.