CD40-ligand in primate cardiac allograft and viral immunity

Nonhuman primate models of transplant tolerance: closer to the holy grail

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Transplantation tolerance, successful acceptance of an organ without the perils of immunosuppression, has been a central goal of transplant research. Many strategies to achieve this tolerance have been examined over the past three decades, culminating in several human trials of transplant tolerance. This progression from the 'benchtop to the clinic' has depended on the successful implementation of these tolerance strategies in nonhuman primates. This review will examine the described methods of transplant tolerance induction in nonhuman primates.

RECENT FINDINGS

Although costimulatory blockade and mixed chimerism have an established record of achieving transplant tolerance in nonhuman primates, some of the most innovative recent techniques of tolerance induction have relied on cellular transfer. This review will fully examine the role of regulatory T-cell transfer and the use of mesenchymal stem/stromal cells to promote tolerance of organ allografts in nonhuman primates.

SUMMARY

Use of translational nonhuman primate transplant models is a vital intermediate step to advance new approaches of transplant tolerance induction from the lab to the clinic. This review will explore numerous techniques of tolerance induction that have been piloted in primates, including depletional techniques, induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism, costimulation blockade, and adoptive transfer of tolerogenic cell populations.

Update on CD40 and CD154 blockade in transplant models

Generation of an effective immune response against foreign antigens requires two distinct molecular signals: a primary signal provided by the binding of antigen-specific T-cell receptor to peptide-MHC on antigen-presenting cells and a secondary signal delivered via the engagement of costimulatory molecules. Among various costimulatory signaling pathways, the interactions between CD40 and its ligand CD154 have been extensively investigated given their essential roles in the modulation of adaptive immunity. Here, we review current understanding of the role CD40/CD154 costimulation pathway has in alloimmunity, and summarize recent mechanistic and preclinical advances in the evaluation of candidate therapeutic approaches to target this receptor-ligand pair in transplantation.

Primate models in organ transplantation

Large animal models have long served as the proving grounds for advances in transplantation, bridging the gap between inbred mouse experimentation and human clinical trials. Although a variety of species have been and continue to be used, the emergence of highly targeted biologic- and antibody-based therapies has required models to have a high degree of homology with humans. Thus, the nonhuman primate has become the model of choice in many settings. This article will provide an overview of nonhuman primate models of transplantation. Issues of primate genetics and care will be introduced, and a brief overview of technical aspects for various transplant models will be discussed. Finally, several prominent immunosuppressive and tolerance strategies used in primates will be reviewed.

Mixed chimerism to induce tolerance: lessons learned from nonhuman primates

The mixed chimerism approach has been demonstrated to be an effective means of inducing allograft tolerance. Based on our rodent studies on mixed chimerism, we previously developed a clinically relevant nonmyeloablative preparative regimen that permits the induction of mixed chimerism and renal allograft tolerance following donor bone marrow transplantation in major histocompatibility complex fully mismatched cynomolgus monkeys. This approach has been successfully extended to HLA matched or mismatched kidney transplant recipients. In the manuscript, we summarize some of the important conclusions made in our laboratories regarding induction of mixed chimerism and allograft tolerance in a nonhuman primate model.

Central role of ILT3 in the T suppressor cell cascade

CD8+ T suppressor cells differentiate both in vivo and in vitro upon chronic exposure of responding T cells to allogeneic APC. These Ts are allospecific and exhibit their function interacting directly with priming APC which they render tolerogenic. Tolerogenicity of professional and non-professional human APC, such as dendritic cells and endothelial cells, respectively is due to the upregulation of the inhibitory receptors ILT3 and ILT4. ILT3 signals both intracellularly, inhibiting NF-kappaB activation, and transcription of costimulatory molecules, and extracellularly, inducing anergy and regulatory function in T cells with cognate specificity. Both membrane and soluble ILT3 are proteins with potent immunosuppressive activity which are of importance for treatment of rejection, autoimmunity and cancer.

CCR5 Blockade Modulates Inflammation and Alloimmunity in Primates

Pharmacologic antagonism of CCR5, a chemokine receptor expressed on macrophages and activated T cells, is an effective antiviral therapy in patients with macrophage-tropic HIV infection, but its efficacy in modulating inflammation and immunity is only just beginning to be investigated. In this regard, the recruitment of CCR5-bearing cells into clinical allografts is a hallmark of acute rejection and may anticipate chronic rejection, whereas conventionally immunosuppressed renal transplant patients homozygous for a nonfunctional Delta32 CCR5 receptor rarely exhibit late graft loss. Therefore, we explored the effects of a potent, highly selective CCR5 antagonist, Merck's compound 167 (CMPD 167), in an established cynomolgus monkey cardiac allograft model. Although perioperative stress responses (fever, diminished activity) and the recruitment of CCR5-bearing leukocytes into the graft were markedly attenuated, anti-CCR5 monotherapy only marginally prolonged allograft survival. In contrast, relative to cyclosporine A monotherapy, CMPD 167 with cyclosporine A delayed alloantibody production, suppressed cardiac allograft vasculopathy, and tended to further prolong graft survival. CCR5 therefore represents an attractive therapeutic target for attenuating postsurgical stress responses and favorably modulating pathogenic alloimmunity in primates, including man.

Tolerance in Heart Transplantation: The Holy Grail, or an Attainable Goal?

The father of cardiac transplantation, Norman Shumway, famously predicted that tolerance was the future of the field, and always would be. Although his prediction remains true to date, significant progress has been made toward this goal, the "Holy Grail" for transplant clinicians. Current efforts are fueled by disappointing long-term outcomes associated with chronic immunosuppression, and the promise that partial or complete tolerance will impact long-term results favorably. This article provides a clinical definition of tolerance primarily based on lessons learned from animal heart allograft models. It reviews several promising strategies for inducing tolerance and detecting its presence through the use of biomarkers in peripheral blood or the graft, and outlines a possible path toward making this vision a clinical reality.

Lung Transplantation: Current Status and Challenges

The lung is an anatomically complex vital organ whose normal physiology depends on actively regulated ventilation and perfusion, and maintenance of a delicate blood-air barrier over a huge surface area in direct contact with a potentially hostile environment. Despite significant progress over the past 25 years, both short- and long-term outcomes remain significantly inferior for lung recipients relative to other "solid" organs. This review summarizes the current status of lung transplantation so as to frame the principle challenges currently facing end-stage lung-failure patients and the practitioners who care for them.

Transplant tolerance in non-human primates: progress, current challenges and unmet needs

Given the significant morbidity associated with current post-transplant immunosuppressive regimens, induction of immune tolerance continues to be an important goal of clinical organ transplantation. While many strategies for inducing tolerance have been successfully applied in murine models, significant barriers are faced when translating these approaches to the clinic. This has necessitated pre-clinical studies in the more closely related model system, the non-human primates (NHP). In this review, we will discuss the four most prominent strategies for inducing transplantation tolerance and highlight their relative success and shortcomings in NHP. These strategies are: (1) T-cell costimulation blockade (2) mixed chimerism induction (3) T-cell depletion and (4) tolerance induction through regulatory T-cells. After discussing the progress that has been made with each of these strategies, we will identify this field's most pressing unmet needs and discuss how we may best overcome the resulting barriers to tolerance induction.

Recombinant Ig-like transcript 3-Fc modulates T cell responses via induction of Th anergy and differentiation of CD8+ T suppressor cells

The Ig-like transcript (ILT)3 is crucial to the tolerogenic activity acquired by dendritic cells exposed to allospecific T suppressor (Ts) cells. We have explored the immunomodulatory property of the extracellular region of ILT3 using a cytoplasmic deletion mutant of ILT3 (ILT3delta), expressed as membrane-bound ILT3 on KG1 cells, and a rILT3-Fc fusion protein. We found that both membrane-bound and soluble ILT3 inhibited T cell proliferation in primary and secondary MLC inducing anergy in CD4+ Th cells and suppressing the differentiation of IFN-gamma-producing CD8+ CTL. Furthermore, membrane-bound and soluble ILT3 induced the differentiation of CD8+ FOXP3+ Ts cells in primary 7-day MLC. The suppressive activity of these CD8+ Ts cells is alloantigen specific and mediated by their capacity to induce the up-regulation of ILT3 and down-regulation of costimulatory molecules such as CD86 in APC from the stimulator used for priming, but not on control HLA-mismatched APC. Our finding that ILT3-Fc has potent immunosuppressive activity in vitro and that it acts on T cells only upon activation suggests the possibility that this agent may be of use for specific suppression of the immune response in autoimmunity or transplantation.

Alloimmunity in primate heart recipients with CD154 blockade: evidence for alternative costimulation mechanisms

BACKGROUND

CD154 mediates key facets of humoral and cellular immunity to alloantigens, and is tolerogenic to influenza antigens in primates. Barriers to CD154-based tolerance induction for primate cardiac allografts have not previously been defined.

METHODS

Heterotopic cardiac allograft outcomes in cynomolgus monkeys treated with a CD154 inhibitor, IDEC-131 (n=27), were compared to no treatment (n=4) or cyclosporine A (n=6).

RESULTS

CD154 blockade significantly prolonged median allograft survival, from 6.2 (range 6, 7, n=4) days in untreated controls, to 39 (8,112, n=16) days with intensive monotherapy and 93 (>25, 386; n=3) days with added antithymocyte globulin (ATG), but did not yield tolerance. Alloantibody production was delayed but not prevented by IDEC-131 alone or with ATG, and was exacerbated by infusion of donor bone marrow (n=8). Expression of ICOS was prominent in graft infiltrating lymphocytes, and preceded elaboration of antidonor antibody and vasculopathy.

CONCLUSION

CD154 monotherapy modulates primate cardiac alloimmunity, but does not readily induce tolerance. Targeting alternative costimulation pathways, including ICOS, may facilitate tolerance induction based on CD154 blockade.

Induction of transplantation tolerance in non-human primate preclinical models

Short-term outcomes following organ transplantation have improved considerably since the availability of cyclosporine ushered in the modern era of immunosuppression. In spite of this, many of the current limitations to progress in the field are directly related to the existing practice of relatively non-specific immunosuppression. These include increased risks of opportunistic infection and cancer, and toxicity associated with long-term immunosuppressive drug exposure. In addition, long-term graft loss continues to result in part from a failure to adequately control the anti-donor immune response. The development of a safe and reliable means of inducing tolerance would ameliorate these issues and improve the lives of transplant recipients, yet given the improving clinical standard of care, the translation of new therapies has become appropriately more cautious and dependent on increasingly predictive preclinical models. While convenient and easy to use, rodent tolerance models have not to date been reliably capable of predicting a therapy's potential efficacy in humans. Non-human primates possess an immune system that more closely approximates that found in humans, and have served as a more rigorous preclinical testing ground for novel therapies. Prior to clinical adaptation therefore, tolerance regimens should be vetted in non-human primates to ensure that there is sufficient potential for efficacy to justify the risk of its application.

Challenges in therapeutic strategies for transplantation: Where now from here?

The current standard of care in transplantation reliably achieves acceptable graft and patient survival but still depends on life long immunosuppression in most patients. Current strategies employ medications that, in general, inhibit distal events mediating rejection, namely T cell activation and cytotoxicity. They do not typically interfere with initial allorecognition or the factors that influence the direction of an immune response (towards cytotoxicity as opposed to anergy or regulation). Given the exponential amplification of immune responses, these proximal targets may be more efficient in preventing rejection. Recent laboratory investigations have identified several approaches, e.g., costimulation blockade, depletion, and hematopoietic chimerism, that influence the initial stages of the alloimmune response, or establish self-perpetuating means of eliminating rejection without chronic immunosuppression. This manuscript reviews methods of immune manipulation that the authors view as promising for future exploitation and transfer to the clinic. These therapies are similar in that they are viewed as attempts to influence the ability of the body to mount an immune response and its subsequent direction, as opposed to supplying late effector phase inhibition. While it is recognized as unlikely that any one therapy will universally lead to tolerance, the authors propose that these concepts will make immunosuppressive drug minimization more readily successful.

Humoral immunity to vimentin is associated with cardiac allograft injury in nonhuman primates

Immunity to autologous protein has not previously been described following nonhuman primate cardiac transplant. Native hearts and cardiac allografts from cynomolgus monkeys were assessed by immunohistology for vimentin, a highly conserved intermediate filament protein. IgM and IgG to vimentin were measured in serial sera from untreated (n = 4) or cyclosporine (CsA)-treated (n = 8, 2 with ATG) cardiac allograft recipients, and in groups treated with anti-CD154 antibody with (n = 6) or without ATG (n = 28). IgM or IgG reactive with vimentin was elaborated within 30 days with unmodified acute rejection (3/4) or in CsA-treated animals (5/6). CD154 blockade did not prevent anti-vimentin IgM (14/28) but tended to delay the IgG response during therapy (anti-CD154: 8/28, p = 0.10 vs. CsA; anti-CD154+ATG: 2/6). CAV and alloantibody were seen in 25 of 26 animals with grafts surviving over 30 days, including seven animals without increasing anti-vimentin antibody. Anti-vimentin antibodies and vascular complement deposition were found in rejected hearts. Acute and chronic alloimmunity disrupt modulation of autoreactivity to vimentin through pathways, which are resistant to CsA, but may be partially regulated by CD154.

Effect of Mediators of Innate Immunity and Inflammation on CD8+ Veto Cells

BACKGROUND

Methods of allotolerance induction that are successful in mice often fail in primates. Activators of innate immunity derived from microbial pathogens, which are present in primate populations but not in pathogen-free mouse colonies, have been shown to overcome tolerance induction by co-stimulatory blockade or regulatory T cells. Unlike other strategies, veto cells promote long-term allograft survival in primates. Accordingly, the authors hypothesized that veto cells are resistant to the effects of innate immune activation.

METHODS

Using mixed lymphocyte reactions as a model of alloimmunization, the authors assessed the effect of inflammatory mediators on veto cell activity. RESULTS.: The authors demonstrate that the activity of veto cells is unaltered by lipopolysaccharide, double-stranded RNA, or interferon-gamma. Tumor necrosis factor-alpha modestly inhibited the veto effect, but only when veto cells were limiting.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings may help to explain why veto cell-based therapies are more effective than other approaches in primate populations.

Crossing the bridge: large animal models in translational transplantation research

Many methods for reducing the immunosuppressive requirements of allotransplantation have been proposed based on a growing understanding of physiological and allospecific immunity. As these regimens are developed for clinical application, they require validation in models that are reasonably predictive of their performance in humans. This article provides an overview of the large animal models commonly used to test immunomodulatory organ transplant protocols. The rationale for the use of large animals and the effects of common immunosuppressants in the dog, pig, and non-human primate are reviewed. Promising methods for the induction of allospecific tolerance are surveyed with references to early human trials where appropriate.

Efficacy and safety of ABI793, a novel human anti-human CD154 monoclonal antibody, in cynomolgus monkey renal allotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Anti-CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) cause long-term graft survival in preclinical allotransplantation experiments. This is the first report on the efficacy and safety of ABI793, a novel human anti-human CD154 mAb, in Cynomolgus renal transplant recipients.

METHODS

ABI793 (human immunoglobulin-G1:kappa) was derived from a hybridoma generated after immunization of human immunoglobulin transgenic mice (HuMAb-Mouse, Medarex Inc., Annandale, NJ). Cynomolgus monkey recipients of major histocompatibility complex-mismatched, life-supporting renal allografts were treated repeatedly with intravenous ABI793 for a 3-month period posttransplantation. Graft function was monitored by serum creatinine, and rejection was confirmed histologically.

RESULTS

ABI793 binds to human, Cynomolgus and Rhesus monkey CD154; it inhibits dose dependently in vitro CD154:CD40 binding and human mixed lymphocyte reaction. ABI793 is comparable to the mouse anti-human CD154 mAbs 5c8 and 24-31 with respect to affinity, inhibitory capacity, and species specificity; however, ABI793 binds to a different CD154 epitope. With 20 mg/kg of ABI793, five of nine recipients showed substantially prolonged graft survival after cessation of treatment, whereas four of nine recipients were killed because of high serum creatinine while still receiving treatment. ABI793 treatment was associated with episodes of severe acute tubular necrosis (which was unrelated to rejection and responded to fluid and diuretic treatment) and a decrease in platelet numbers. Chronic and acute thromboembolic vascular lesions with hemorrhages were observed in the lung and brain of two allograft recipients. None of these side effects were observed in animals that underwent autotransplantation, thus excluding direct toxicity of ABI793.

CONCLUSIONS

ABI793 treatment effectively prevents graft rejection in Cynomolgus monkeys. Evidence for rare thromboembolic events, as also previously observed with different anti-human CD154 mAbs, suggests that thromboembolic complications may be a class effect of anti-CD154 mAbs, unrelated to their epitope specificity.

Anti-CD20 treatment depletes B-cells in blood and lymphatic tissue of cynomolgus monkeys

INTRODUCTION

Macaque species offer a valuable model for translational allo-transplantation and tolerance studies. Cardiac allograft vasculopathy in Macaca fascicularis is associated with elaboration of anti-donor antibodies. Since T-independent pathways of B cell activation have been described, and anti-B cell strategies have proven to be a fruitful tolerogenic adjunct in rodent and xenogenic models, here we investigate whether an anti-CD20 antibody (rituximab) would be useful to deplete B-cells in a pre-clinical allo-transplantation setting in macaques.

METHODS

Three cynomolgus macaques which had previously rejected a cardiac allograft and one with concurrent subacute vascular rejection were treated weekly with rituximab 20 mg/kg i.v. for 4 and 2 weeks, respectively. B-cell levels (CD19+ cells) were measured by flow cytometry in peripheral blood, spleen, lymph node and bone marrow cells at various intervals after initiation of treatment. B-cells and plasma cells were also analyzed by immunohistochemistry at necropsy in spleen, lymph node, tonsil and thymus tissue sections. Anti-donor antibody titers were measured by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

B-cells expressing CD19 were not detectable in the peripheral blood in any animal within 24 h after initial treatment, or over the ensuing month. At necropsy, the germinal centers in spleen and lymph node were completely depleted of CD20+ B-cells in 2 animals, leaving a hypocellular trabecular pattern around preserved plasma cell follicles. Substantial but incomplete depletion of B-cells was demonstrated in the other 2 animals, in each instance immunohistochemical findings in spleen and lymph node exhibiting higher sensitivity for residual B-cells compared to FACS. Anti-donor antibody titers exhibited kinetics similar to untreated animals over this short follow-up.

COMMENT

Treatment with anti-CD20 very efficiently depletes peripheral and tissue B-cells but not plasma cells in this macaque species. Biopsy of lymph node is necessary and may be sufficient to assess B-cell clearance in secondary lymphoid organs in this model.

Feline immunodeficiency virus-mediated viral interleukin-10 gene transfer prolongs non-vascularized cardiac allograft survival

Previous experiments demonstrated plasmid-, retroviral-, or adenoviral-mediated vIL-10 gene transfer could prolong allograft survival, but transgene expression was rapidly extinguished. Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) can integrate into genomic DNA of nondividing cells, resulting in indefinite transgene expression. We hypothesized FIV-mediated gene transfer could provide long-term gene expression, and improved allograft survival. FIV-vIL-10 and FIV-beta-gal were produced using the FELIX vector system. With vector transfer to syngeneic cardiac grafts, beta-galactosidase reporter gene expression was noted as early as day 5, was strongly expressed at days 10 and 20, and persisted for 50 days after transplantation. For allografts, FIV-vIL-10 gene transfer more than doubled mean survival from 10 +/- 1.6 to 22.3 +/- 3 days. When combined with other immunosuppressants, such as anti-CD40L mAb, FTY720, or anti-CD3 mAb, the mean survival times were prolonged to 27 +/- 4.6 days, 27.8 +/- 4.6 days, and 45.5 +/- 4.9 days, respectively. Multiple chemokine and chemokine receptor genes were induced by ischemia-reperfusion injury in syngeneic grafts, and in allogeneic grafts more genes were induced and to a greater degree. In allogeneic grafts transduced with FIV-IL-10, a number of the chemokine genes were suppressed. Therefore, FIV virus-mediated vIL-10 gene transfer prolongs allograft survival and, in combination with other agents, produces an additive effect.

Combined effects of calcineurin inhibitors or sirolimus with anti-CD40L mAb on alloengraftment under nonmyeloablative conditions

The immunosuppressive drugs, cyclosporine A (CsA), tacrolimus, or sirolimus, were analyzed as single agents and in combination with anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) for their effects on alloengraftment in mice conditioned with minimal total body irradiation (TBI). Whereas anti-CD40L mAb facilitated chimerism, neither sirolimus nor CsA resulted in substantial alloengraftment. However, sirolimus was synergistic with anti-CD40L mAb for inducing donor chimerism. Contrary to expectations, CsA, a T-cell receptor (TCR) signaling inhibitor, did not abrogate anti-CD40L mAb-facilitated engraftment but rather increased engraftment in anti-CD40L mAb-treated mice. Although tacrolimus alone or with anti-CD40L mAb resulted in similar levels of donor chimerism, donor T-cell reconstitution was very low in tacrolimus-treated mice. At 1 week after transplantation, CsA decreased thymic numbers more profoundly than sirolimus or tacrolimus in anti-CD40L mAb-treated recipients. In contrast, only sirolimus resulted in a decrease in host splenic T-cell numbers in anti-CD40L mAb-treated recipients. Importantly, sirolimus and anti-CD40L mAb induced profound donor tolerance with 100% acceptance of donor skin grafts placed early after bone marrow transplantation (BMT). In contrast, anti-CD40L mAb alone or in combination with CsA resulted in 12% or less donor skin graft acceptance early (1 month) and 60% or less later (3 months) after BMT. These data have clinical relevance and indicate that immunosuppressive pharmacologic agents enhance anti-CD40L mAb-facilitated alloengraftment and tolerance induction under nonmyeloablative conditioning.