Level of B cell antigen receptor surface expression influences both positive and negative selection of B cells during primary development

Site-specific labeling uncovers differences in levels and distribution of B-cell receptors of different isotypes on primary B cells

Expression of the BCR is essential for survival, development, and effector functions of B cells. Naive B cells express surface IgM and IgD, while surface IgG1 is expressed by class-switched (memory) B cells. Despite similar overall structures, the different BCR isotypes show differences in distribution and expression levels. The dynamics of BCR behavior have been difficult to explore owing to a lack of appropriate tools that can track the BCR without causing concomitant activation. Using CRISPR-Cas9, we inserted a sortase recognition motif (LPETG [LeuProGluThrGly]) at the C-terminus of the OB1 transnuclear ovalbumin-specific Cκ chain (Igκ-LPETG mice). The surface BCR from Igκ-LPETG mice is fully functional and can be labeled site-specifically with biotin or fluorophores. Igκ-LPETG mice show near-normal B-cell development, with an increase in Igλ-producing cells, presumably due to massive contraction of the κ locus V-region cluster upon V-J recombination to generate the OB1 light chain. Using the Igκ-LPETG mice, we compared organization and density of BCRs on the surface of IgM/IgD+ B cells bearing a wild-type (WT) heavy chain locus and IgG1 B cells in the OB1 model. The density of IgG1 BCRs is much reduced compared to IgM/IgD BCRs on primary B cells. Upon activation, IgM/IgD BCRs are found in detergent-insoluble domains, whereas IgG1 BCRs are not. The isotype of the Ig heavy chain thus contributes to surface expression and nanoscale organization of the BCR.

FCRL1 Regulates B Cell Receptor-Induced ERK Activation through GRB2

Regulation of BCR signaling has important consequences for generating effective Ab responses to pathogens and preventing production of autoreactive B cells during development. Currently defined functions of Fc receptor-like (FCRL) 1 include positive regulation of BCR-induced calcium flux, proliferation, and Ab production; however, the mechanistic basis of FCRL1 signaling and its contributions to B cell development remain undefined. Molecular characterization of FCRL1 signaling shows phosphotyrosine-dependent associations with GRB2, GRAP, SHIP-1, and SOS1, all of which can profoundly influence MAPK signaling. In contrast with previous characterizations of FCRL1 as a strictly activating receptor, we discover a role for FCRL1 in suppressing ERK activation under homeostatic and BCR-stimulated conditions in a GRB2-dependent manner. Our analysis of B cells in Fcrl1 -/- mice shows that ERK suppression by FCRL1 is associated with a restriction in the number of cells surviving splenic maturation in vivo. The capacity of FCRL1 to modulate ERK activation presents a potential for FCRL1 to be a regulator of peripheral B cell tolerance, homeostasis, and activation.

Transcriptional Control of Mature B Cell Fates

The mature naïve B cell repertoire consists of three well-defined populations: B1, B2 (follicular B, FOB), and marginal zone B (MZB) cells. FOB cells are the dominant mature B cell population in the secondary lymphoid organs and blood of both humans and mice. The driving forces behind mature B lineage selection have been linked to B cell receptor (BCR) signaling strength and environmental cues, but how these fate-determination factors are transcriptionally regulated remains poorly understood. We summarize emerging data on the role of transcription factors (TFs) - particularly the ETS and IRF families - in regulating MZB and FOB lineage selection. Indeed, genomic analyses have identified four major groups of target genes that are crucial for FOB differentiation, revealing previously unrecognized pathways that ultimately determine biological responses specific to this lineage.

Epigenetic Enhancer Marks and Transcription Factor Binding Influence Vκ Gene Rearrangement in Pre-B Cells and Pro-B Cells

To date there has not been a study directly comparing relative Igκ rearrangement frequencies obtained from genomic DNA (gDNA) and cDNA and since each approach has potential biases, this is an important issue to clarify. Here we used deep sequencing to compare the unbiased gDNA and RNA Igκ repertoire from the same pre-B cell pool. We find that ~20% of Vκ genes have rearrangement frequencies ≥2-fold up or down in RNA vs. DNA libraries, including many members of the Vκ3, Vκ4, and Vκ6 families. Regression analysis indicates Ikaros and E2A binding are associated with strong promoters. Within the pre-B cell repertoire, we observed that individual Vκ genes rearranged at very different frequencies, and also displayed very different Jκ usage. Regression analysis revealed that the greatly unequal Vκ gene rearrangement frequencies are best predicted by epigenetic marks of enhancers. In particular, the levels of newly arising H3K4me1 peaks associated with many Vκ genes in pre-B cells are most predictive of rearrangement levels. Since H3K4me1 is associated with long range chromatin interactions which are created during locus contraction, our data provides mechanistic insight into unequal rearrangement levels. Comparison of Igκ rearrangements occurring in pro-B cells and pre-B cells from the same mice reveal a pro-B cell bias toward usage of Jκ-distal Vκ genes, particularly Vκ10-96 and Vκ1-135. Regression analysis indicates that PU.1 binding is the highest predictor of Vκ gene rearrangement frequency in pro-B cells. Lastly, the repertoires of iEκ^−/− pre-B cells reveal that iEκ actively influences Vκ gene usage, particularly Vκ3 family genes, overlapping with a zone of iEκ-regulated germline transcription. These represent new roles for iEκ in addition to its critical function in promoting overall Igκ rearrangement. Together, this study provides insight into many aspects of Igκ repertoire formation.

Contribution of secondary Igkappa rearrangement to primary immunoglobulin repertoire diversification

Abs reactive to DNA and DNA/histone complexes are a distinguished characteristic of primary immunoglobulin repertoires in autoimmune B6.MRL-Fas^lpr and MRL/MpJ-Fas^lpr mice. These mice are defective in Fas receptor, which is critical for the apoptosis of autoreactive B cells by an extrinsic pathway. In the present study, we explored the possibility that bone marrow small pre-B and immature B cells from adult B6.MRL-Fas^lpr mice and MRL/MpJ-Fas^lpr mice respectively, which contain autoreactive B-cell antigen receptors (BCR) and manifest autoimmune syndromes, exhibit enhanced receptor editing patterns. Indeed, FAS^lpr pre B and immature B cells were shown to possess more ongoing replacements of non-productive (nP) than productive (P) primary VκJκ rearrangements. Significantly, the P vs nP ratios of these replaced primary rearrangements were 1:2, thus indicating that κ light-chain production appears not to inhibit secondary rearrangements. In addition, we identified multiple atypical rearrangements, such as Vκ cRS (cryptic recombination signals) cleavages. These results suggest that the onset of light chain secondary rearrangements persists similarly as a non-selected mode and independent of BCR autoreactivity during certain developmental windows of bone marrow B cells in lupus-prone mice and control, and leads us to propose the function of secondary, de novo Igκ rearrangements to increase BCR diversity.

Antibody-reactive class I epitopes defined by pairs of mismatched eplets and self-eplets

The identification of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies in the sera of candidates awaiting organ transplantation has evolved over time. This has been possible because of the introduction of more sensitive techniques and to the increasing focus on the structural aspects of the HLA epitopes. The use of the HLAMatchmaker algorithm in the analysis of positive sera and the verification of HLA ABC epitopes in the HLA Epitope Registry website provide new stimuli on the interpretation of antibody reactivity. The epitopes defined by eplet pairs often involve a nonself-eplet and a self-eplet (nonself-self paradigm), suggesting that the antibody response to an HLA mismatch must have an auto-reactive component. Here, we report an application of the nonself-self paradigm that provides a basis for better knowledge and interpretation of HLA-antibody reactivity in Luminex assays with single alleles.

Multiple factors influence the contribution of individual immunoglobulin light chain genes to the naïve antibody repertoire

Background

The naïve antibody repertoire is initially dependent upon the number of germline V(D)J genes and the ability of recombined heavy and light chains to pair. Individual VH and VL genes are not equally represented in naïve mature B cells, suggesting that positive and negative selection also shape the antibody repertoire. Among the three member murine Vκ10 L chain family, the Vκ10C gene is under-represented in the antibody repertoire. Although it is structurally functional and accessible to both transcriptional and recombination machinery, the Vκ10C promoter is inefficient in pre-B cell lines and productive Vκ10C rearrangements are lost as development progresses from pre-B cells through mature B cells. This study examined VH/Vκ10 pairing, promoter mutations, Vκ10 transcript levels and receptor editing as possible factors that are responsible for loss of productive Vκ10C rearrangements in developing B cells.

Results

We demonstrate that the loss of Vκ10C expression is not due to an inability to pair with H chains, but is likely due to a combination of other factors. Levels of mRNA are low in sorted pre-B cells and undetectable in B cells. Mutation of a single base in the three prime region of the Vκ10C promoter increases Vκ10C promoter function in pre-B cell lines. Pre-B and B cells harbor disproportionate levels of receptor-edited productive Vκ10C rearrangements.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that the weak Vκ10C promoter initially limits the amount of available Vκ10C L chain for pairing with H chains, resulting in sub-threshold levels of cell surface B cell receptors, insufficient tonic signaling and subsequent receptor editing to limit the numbers of Vκ10C-expressing B cells emigrating from the bone marrow to the periphery.

Activation of Ras overcomes B-cell tolerance to promote differentiation of autoreactive B cells and production of autoantibodies

Newly generated immature B cells are selected to enter the peripheral mature B-cell pool only if they do not bind (or bind limited amount of) self-antigen. We previously suggested that this selection relies on basal extracellular signal-regulated kinase (Erk) activation mediated by tonic B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) signaling and that this signal can be replaced by an active rat sarcoma (Ras), which are small GTPase proteins. In this study we compared the activity of Ras and Erk in nonautoreactive and autoreactive immature B cells and investigated whether activation of Ras can break tolerance. Our results demonstrate lower levels of active Erk and Ras in autoreactive immature B cells, although this is evident only when these cells display medium/high avidity for self-antigen. Basal activation of Erk in immature B cells is proportional to surface IgM and dependent on sarcoma family kinases, whereas it is independent of B-cell activating factor, IFN, and Toll-like receptor signaling. Ectopic expression of the constitutively active mutant Ras form N-RasD12 in autoreactive cells raises active Erk, halts receptor editing via PI3 kinase, and promotes differentiation via Erk, breaking central tolerance. Moreover, when B cells coexpress autoreactive and nonautoreactive BCRs, N-RasD12 leads also to a break in peripheral tolerance with the production of autoantibodies. Our findings indicate that in immature B cells, basal activation of Ras and Erk are controlled by tonic BCR signaling, and that positive changes in Ras activity can lead to a break in both central and peripheral B-cell tolerance.

Role of the Igh intronic enhancer Eμ in clonal selection at the pre-B to immature B cell transition

We previously described a checkpoint for allelic exclusion that occurs at the pre-B cell to immature B cell transition and is dependent upon the IgH intronic enhancer, Eμ. We now provide evidence that the breach in allelic exclusion associated with Eμ deletion results from decreased Igμ levels that make it difficult for emerging BCRs to reach the signaling threshold required for positive selection into the immature B cell compartment. We show that this compartment is smaller in mice carrying an Eμ-deficient, but functional, IgH allele (VHΔ(a)). Pre-B cells in such mice produce ≈ 50% wild-type levels of Igμ (mRNA and protein), and this is associated with diminished signals, as measured by phosphorylation of pre-BCR/BCR downstream signaling proteins. Providing Eμ-deficient mice with a preassembled VL gene led not only to a larger immature B cell compartment but also to a decrease in "double-producers," suggesting that H chain/L chain combinations with superior signaling properties can overcome the signaling defect associated with low Igμ-chain and can eliminate the selective advantage of "double-producers" that achieve higher Igμ-chain levels through expression of a second IgH allele. Finally, we found that "double-producers" in Eμ-deficient mice include a subpopulation with autoreactive BCRs. We infer that BCRs with IgH chain from the Eμ-deficient allele are ignored during negative selection owing to their comparatively low density. In summary, these studies show that Eμ's effect on IgH levels at the pre-B cell to immature B cell transition strongly influences allelic exclusion, the breadth of the mature BCR repertoire, and the emergence of autoimmune B cells.

The endocytic adaptor Eps15 controls marginal zone B cell numbers

Eps15 is an endocytic adaptor protein involved in clathrin and non-clathrin mediated endocytosis. In Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster lack of Eps15 leads to defects in synaptic vesicle recycling and synapse formation. We generated Eps15-KO mice to investigate its function in mammals. Eps15-KO mice are born at the expected Mendelian ratio and are fertile. Using a large-scale phenotype screen covering more than 300 parameters correlated to human disease, we found that Eps15-KO mice did not show any sign of disease or neural deficits. Instead, altered blood parameters pointed to an immunological defect. By competitive bone marrow transplantation we demonstrated that Eps15-KO hematopoietic precursor cells were more efficient than the WT counterparts in repopulating B220⁺ bone marrow cells, CD19⁻ thymocytes and splenic marginal zone (MZ) B cells. Eps15-KO mice showed a 2-fold increase in MZ B cell numbers when compared with controls. Using reverse bone marrow transplantation, we found that Eps15 regulates MZ B cell numbers in a cell autonomous manner. FACS analysis showed that although MZ B cells were increased in Eps15-KO mice, transitional and pre-MZ B cell numbers were unaffected. The increase in MZ B cell numbers in Eps15 KO mice was not dependent on altered BCR signaling or Notch activity. In conclusion, in mammals, the endocytic adaptor protein Eps15 is a regulator of B-cell lymphopoiesis.

Central B-cell tolerance: where selection begins

The development of an adaptive immune system based on the random generation of antigen receptors requires a stringent selection process that sifts through receptor specificities to remove those reacting with self-antigens. In the B-cell lineage, this selection process is first applied to IgM(+) immature B cells. By using increasingly sophisticated mouse models, investigators have identified the central tolerance mechanisms that negatively select autoreactive immature B cells and prevent inclusion of their antigen receptors into the peripheral B-cell pool. Additional studies have uncovered mechanisms that promote the differentiation of nonautoreactive immature B cells and their positive selection into the peripheral B-cell population. These mechanisms of central selection are fundamental to the generation of a naïve B-cell repertoire that is largely devoid of self-reactivity while capable of reacting with any foreign insult.

Structural aspects of human leukocyte antigen class I epitopes detected by human monoclonal antibodies

This study addresses the concept that human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I-specific alloantibodies are specific for epitopes that correspond to HLAMatchmaker-defined eplets. Eplets are essential parts of so-called structural epitopes that make contact with the 6 complementarity determining regions of an antibody. From published molecular models of crystallized protein antigen-antibody complexes, we have calculated that contact residues on structural HLA epitopes should reside within a 15-Å radius of a mismatched eplet. This study addresses the structural basis of high-frequency HLA class I epitopes reacting with human monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) derived from women sensitized during pregnancy. All mAbs were tested in Luminex assays with single HLA allele panels. The HLAMatchmaker algorithm was used to determine their specificity in context with eplet sharing between the immunizing allele and antibody-reactive alleles. To assess the autoreactive B cell origin of these antibodies, we have applied the recently developed nonself-self paradigm of epitope immunogenicity to analyze residue differences between the immunizer and the alleles of the antibody producer. A total of 9 mAbs were specific for epitopes associated with the 41T, 80NRG, 163LW, 69AA, or 80ERILR eplets. In each case, the immunizing allele had within 15 Å of the mismatched eplet, no residue differences with 1 of the alleles of the antibody producer. This observation is consistent with the concept that these mAbs originated from B cells with self HLA immunoglobulin receptors. Eplet-carrying alleles exhibited different levels of reactivity, which, when compared with the immunizing allele, ranged from high to intermediate to very low. In many cases, lower reactivities were associated with differences from self to nonself residues in surface locations within 15 Å of the specific eplet. Apparently, such locations may serve as critical contact sites for the antibody. In other cases, other residue differences did not appear to affect binding with the antibody, suggesting that these locations do not play a major role in antibody binding. For these mAbs we did not obtain convincing evidence that residue differences in hidden positions below the molecular surface had significant effects on antibody binding. These findings have increased our understanding of the structural basis of the immunogenicity and antigenicity of HLA class I epitopes and provide a basis for interpreting HLA antibody reactivity patterns in Luminex assays with single alleles.

The antibody response to an HLA mismatch: a model for nonself-self discrimination in relation to HLA epitope immunogenicity

Antibodies to HLA mismatches are specific for epitopes rather than antigens. HLAMatchmaker considers each HLA antigen as a string of eplets that represent key elements of epitopes. Certain antibodies are specific for single eplets, but recent studies have demonstrated that epitopes defined by eplet pairs always involve one nonself-eplet and a self-eplet shared between the immunizing antigen and the antibody producer. This suggests an autoreactive component of the alloantibody response to an HLA mismatch and this report expands this concept. During B-cell development, V(H) and V(L) gene rearrangements produce a diversity of Ig receptors that can recognize epitopes on autologous proteins. It is hypothesized that B cells carry low-affinity receptors for self-HLA antigens. Their interactions with self-HLA proteins will not lead to B-cell activation or antibody production. In contrast, exposure to HLA mismatches induces often strong alloantibody responses. The activation of self-HLA-specific B cell by a nonself-eplet may require that the remainder of the structural epitope of the immunizing antigen has considerable structural similarity with one of the antibody producer's alleles. This hypothesis has been tested in molecular modelling studies with six epitopes defined by human monoclonal antibodies. In each case, one allele of the antibody producer had no or few differences with the immunizing allele in antibody-accessible positions defined by a 15 Ångstrom radius of the mismatched eplet. The other alleles of the antibody producer showed significantly greater numbers of residue differences with the immunizer (5.8 ± 2.0 versus 1.0 ± 0.6, P < 0.0001). These data support the concept that HLA antibodies originate from B cells with self-HLA immunoglobulin receptors that recognize mismatched eplets as nonself entities on immunizing antigens. The nonself-self paradigm provides a new insight of HLA epitope immunogenicity and may explain why sensitized patients have antibodies to a restricted number of mismatched epitopes.

New insights into the enigma of immunoglobulin D

Immunoglobulin D (IgD) has remained a mysterious antibody class for almost half a century. IgD was initially thought to be a recently evolved Ig isotype expressed only by some mammalian species, but recent discoveries in fishes and amphibians demonstrate that IgD was present in the ancestor of all jawed vertebrates and has important immunological functions. The structure of IgD has been very dynamic throughout evolution. Mammals can express IgD through alternative splicing and class switch recombination. Active cell-dependent and T-cell-independent IgM-to-IgD class switching takes place in a unique subset of human B cells from the upper aerodigestive mucosa, which provides a layer of mucosal protection by interacting with many pathogens and their virulence factors. Circulating IgD can bind to myeloid cells such as basophils and induce antimicrobial, inflammatory, and B-cell-stimulating factors upon cross-linking, which contributes to not only immune surveillance but also inflammation and tissue damage when this pathway is overactivated under pathological conditions. Recent research shows that IgD is an important immunomodulator that orchestrates an ancestral surveillance system at the interface between immunity and inflammation.

IFN regulatory factor 8 restricts the size of the marginal zone and follicular B cell pools

Transcriptional control of marginal zone (MZ) and follicular (FO) B cell development remains incompletely understood. The transcription factor, IFN regulatory factor (IRF)8, is known to play important roles in the differentiation of early B cells. In this article, we demonstrate that IRF8 is also required for normal development of MZ and FO B cells. Mice with a conventional knockout of Irf8 (IRF8(-/-)) or a point mutation in the IRF association domain of IRF8 had increased numbers of MZ B cells. To determine the B cell-intrinsic effects of IRF8 deficiency, we generated mice with a conditional allele of Irf8 crossed with CD19-Cre mice (designated IRF8-conditional knockout [CKO]). These mice had enlarged MZ and increased numbers of MZ and FO B cells compared with controls. The FO B cells of CKO mice exhibited reduced expression of CD23 and moderately increased expression of CD21. Gene-expression profiling showed that increased B cell production in IRF8-CKO mice was associated with changes in expression of genes involved in regulation of transcription, signaling, and inflammation. Functional studies showed that IRF8-CKO mice generated normal Ab responses to T-independent and T-dependent Ags. Thus, IRF8 controls the expansion and maturation of MZ and FO B cells but has little effect on B cell function.

Augmented B lymphocyte response to antigen in the absence of antigen-induced B lymphocyte signaling in an IgG-transgenic mouse line

IgG-containing B cell antigen receptor (IgG-BCR), the BCR mostly expressed on memory B cells, contains a distinct signaling function from IgM-BCR or IgD-BCR expressed on naïve B cells. Because naïve B cells transgenic for IgG exhibit augmented response to antigens similar to memory B cells, the distinct signaling function of IgG-BCR appears to play a role in augmented antibody responses of memory B cells. However, how IgG-BCR signaling augments B cell responses is not yet well understood. Here we demonstrate that B cells from IgG-transgenic mice are anergic with defect in generation of BCR signaling upon BCR ligation. However, these IgG-transgenic B cells generate markedly augmented antibody response to a T cell-dependent antigen, probably due to hyper-responsiveness to a T cell-derived signal through CD40. Both BCR signaling defect and augmented response to CD40 ligation are partially restored in xid IgG-transgenic mice in which BCR signaling is down-modulated due to a loss-of-function mutation in the tyrosine kinase Btk crucial for BCR signaling. Thus, IgG-BCR induces augmented B cell responses in the absence of antigen-induced BCR signaling probably through high ligand-independent BCR signaling that may “idle” B cells to make them ready to respond to T cell help. This finding strongly suggests a crucial role of ligand-independent signaling in receptor function.

Long-term maternal imprinting of the specific B cell repertoire by maternal antibodies

Maternal antibodies protect newborns whilst they are immunologically immature. This study shows that maternal antibodies can also shape the B cell repertoire of the offspring long after the maternal antibodies themselves become undetectable. V(H)DJ(H) gene-targeted (VI10) mice expressing a heavy chain specific for vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) produce a 20-fold increased spontaneous titer of VSV-neutralizing antibodies. When transferred from mother to offspring, these antibodies prevented accumulation of Ag-specific transitional type 2 and marginal zone B cells with an activated phenotype and favored selection to the B cell follicles. This effect was B cell-intrinsic and lasted up to adulthood. The pups nursed by mothers producing specific antibodies developed higher endogenous antibody titers of this specificity which perpetuated the effects of specific B cell selection into the mature follicular compartment, presumably by blocking auto-Ag-dependent development of transitional type 2 B cells in the spleen. This repertoire change was functional, as following infection of adult mice with VSV, those pups that had received specific maternal antibodies as neonates had increased pre-immune titers and mounted strong early IgG neutralizing antibodies.

Autoantigen-B cell antigen receptor interactions that regulate expression of B cell antigen receptor Loci

Levels of AgR (BCR) expression are regulated during B cell development, activation, and induction of tolerance. The mechanisms responsible for and consequences of this regulation are poorly understood. We have described a class of DNA-based autoantigen-reactive B cell that down-regulates BCR expression during development to mature follicular phenotype. In this study, we show that at immature stages of primary differentiation, individual B cells of this type can dynamically modulate levels of expression of BCR in inverse proportion to degree of autoantigen engagement and induced BCR signaling. These adjustments in BCR expression are not associated with cell death, BCR revision, or altered development, and do not require TLR 9. Strikingly, modulation of BCR subunit gene RNA levels and transcription parallels these changes in BCR expression, indicating a direct link between autoantigen-BCR interactions of this type and regulation of transcription of BCR-encoding loci. We propose that this adaptive process allows this class of autoreactive B cell to avoid conventional tolerance pathways and promotes development to mature phenotype.

Quantitatively Reduced Participation of Anti-Nuclear Antigen B Cells That Down-Regulate B Cell Receptor during Primary Development in the Germinal Center/Memory B Cell Response to Foreign Antigen

The peripheral B cell compartment contains high levels of "polyreactivity" including autospecificities. We have described a pathway that certain autoreactive B cells may take in gaining stable access to the foreign Ag-responsive peripheral compartment. This pathway was revealed in mice expressing a targeted Ig H chain transgene encoding BCRs with "multireactivity" for the hapten arsonate and DNA-based autoantigens. B cells expressing such BCRs develop to mature follicular phenotype and locale, and are not short-lived. These B cells express very low levels of BCR, indicating that they are not "ignorant" of self Ag, but do not display features of anergy in in vitro assays. Nonetheless, a variety of states of lymphocyte anergy has been described, and some may only be manifested in vivo. As such, we analyzed the ability of these B cells to participate in a T cell-dependent immune response to arsonate in vivo. These B cells mount an early primary response similar to control B cells, including homing to follicles, migration to the T-B interface, and induction of costimulatory molecules, proliferation, differentiation to AFCs, class switching, and entry into GCs and somatic hypermutation. Nonetheless, these B cells display reduced participation in the latter stages of the GC response and in the anamnestic AFC response. In total, these data suggest that while the autoreactivity of this type of B cell does not result in anergy, the ability of such B cells to participate in a cross-reactive immune response to foreign Ag is compromised.

The riddle of the dual expression of IgM and IgD

Signalling through the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) is required for peripheral B lymphocyte maturation, maintenance, activation and silencing. In mature B cells, the antigen receptor normally consists of two isotypes, membrane IgM and IgD (mIgM, mIgD). Although the signals initiated from both isotypes differ in kinetics and intensity, in vivo, the BCR of either isotype seems to be able to compensate for the loss of the other, reflected by the mild phenotypes of mice deficient for mIgM or mIgD. Thus, it is still unclear why mature B cells need expression of mIgD in addition to mIgM. In the current review we suggest that the view that IgD has a simply definable function centred around the basic signalling function should be replaced by the assumption that IgD fine tunes humoral responses, modulates B cell selection and homeostasis and thus shapes the B cell repertoire, defining IgD to be a key modulator of the humoral immune response.

Signals from a self-antigen induce positive selection in early B cell ontogeny but are tolerogenic in adults

Positive and negative signals from self-Ags shape the B cell repertoire and the development of distinct B cell subsets, but little is known about what distinguishes these signals. To address this question, we have studied the development of anti-hen egg lysozyme MD4 Ig transgene B cells while systematically varying the level, distribution, and timing of exposure to different forms of hen egg lysozyme as a self-Ag. This process has allowed us to explore the effects of Ag independent of BCR specificity. Our findings show how the selection of autoreactive B cells is a competitive process involving immunogenic and tolerogenic forms of self-Ags. Due to a developmental switch during B cell ontogeny, autoreactive anti-hen egg lysozyme MD4 Ig transgene B cells are negatively selected by self-Ags in adult bone marrow but susceptible to positive selection by some of the same self-Ags in fetal and neonatal life. However, the persistence of B1 cells and IgM autoantibodies from early ontogeny enables autoreactive B cells from the adult bone marrow to escape negative selection. Our data suggest that this rescue may be due to the clearance or masking of self-Ag by IgM autoantibody. We discuss the implications of these findings in terms of B cell selection and the maintenance of self-tolerance during early and adult life.

Evidence of marginal-zone B cell-positive selection in spleen

Antigen receptor-mediated signaling is critical for the development and survival of B cells. However, it has not been established whether B cell development requires a signal from self-ligand engagement at the immature stage, a process known as "positive selection." Here, using a monoclonal B cell receptor (BCR) mouse line, specific for the self-Thy-1/CD90 glycoprotein, we demonstrate that BCR crosslinking by low-dose self-antigen promotes survival of immature B cells in culture. In spleen, an increase in BCR signaling strength, induced by low-dose self-antigen, directed naive immature B cells to mature, not into the default follicular B cell fate, but instead into the marginal-zone B cell subset. These data indicate that positive selection can occur in developing B cells and that BCR signal strength is a key factor in deciding between two functionally distinct mature B cell compartments in the microenvironment of the spleen.

Analysis of marginal zone B cell development in the mouse with limited B cell diversity: role of the antigen receptor signals in the recruitment of B cells to the marginal zone

The quasimonoclonal (QM) mouse provides an intelligible model to analyze the B cell selection as the competition between two major 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl-specific B cell populations whose BCR are comprised of the knockin V(H)17.2.25 (V(H)T)-encoded H chain and the lambda1 or lambda2 L chain. In this study, we show the QM system is useful to examine how BCR signals guide a subset of B cells to the marginal zone (MZ). Compared with the control C57BL/6 mice, the QM mice had approximately 2.7-fold increased number of B cells exhibiting the MZ B cell phenotype and a larger MZ area in the spleen. Interestingly, V(H)T/lambda2 B cells significantly predominated over V(H)T/lambda1 B cells in MZ-(V(H)T/lambda1:V(H)T/lambda2 approximately 3:7) and transitional 2-B cell subsets, while these two populations were comparable in immature, transitional 1, and mature counterparts. Thus, the biased use of lambda2 in the MZ B cells may be the result of selection in the periphery. The enlargement of MZ B cell compartment and the preferred recruitment of the V(H)T/lambda2 B cells were further augmented by doubling the V(H)T gene, but dampened by the dysfunction of Bruton's tyrosine kinase, suggesting a positive role of BCR signaling in this selection. Comparison of Ag specificity between V(H)T/lambda1 and V(H)T/lambda2 IgM mAbs revealed a polyreactive nature of the V(H)T/lambda2 BCR, including the reactivity with ssDNA. Taken together, it is suggested that polyreactivity (including self-reactivity) of BCR is crucial in driving B cells to differentiate into the MZ phenotype.

B-lymphocytes, innate immunity, and autoimmunity

Having evolved to generate a huge Ag-specific repertoire and to mount T cell-dependent responses and long-term memory, the B lymphocyte is a central player in the adaptive branch of immune defense. However, accumulating evidence indicates that B-1 cells of the peritoneal cavity and marginal zone (MZ) B cells of the spleen also can play innate-like immune functions. Their anatomical locations allow frequent Ag encounter. Secreting essentially germline-encoded, polyreactive Abs, and responding rapidly and vigorously to stimulation, these two B cell subsets have evolved to impart potentially protective responses. With their additional capacities to secrete factors that can directly mediate microbial destruction and to express Toll-like receptors (TLR), B cells provide an important link between the innate and adaptive branches of the immune system. Currently, the relevance of these innate-like B cells to the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease is the focus of investigation. In experimental models of autoimmunity, the sequestration of autoreactive B cells in the MZ has been proposed to be essential for the maintenance of self-tolerance. The low activation threshold of MZ B cells makes them particularly reactive to high loads and/or altered self-Ags, potentially exacerbating autoimmune disease. Their expansion in autoimmune models and their association with autoantibody secretion indicate that they may participate in tissue damage. The demonstration that B cell depletion therapies may represent a highly beneficial therapeutic goal in autoimmune disorders suggests that specific elimination of B-1 and MZ B cells may represent a more efficient immunointervention strategy in systemic autoimmunity.

B Cell Selection and Susceptibility to Autoimmunity

Autoreactive B cells arise routinely as part of the naive B cell repertoire. The immune system employs several mechanisms in an attempt to silence these autoreactive cells before they achieve immunocompetence. The BCR plays a central role in B cell development, activation, survival, and apoptosis, and thus is a critical component of the regulation of both protective and autoreactive B cells. The strength of signal mediated by the BCR is determined by numerous factors, both B cell intrinsic and B cell extrinsic. Perturbations in the molecules that regulate the BCR signal strength or that activate pathways that engage in cross talk with the BCR-mediated signaling pathways can lead to the aberrant survival and activation of autoreactive B cells. In this review, we will discuss the some newly identified genetic loci and factors that modulate the BCR signal transduction pathway and, therefore, the regulation of autoreactive B cells. We will also provide evidence for a model of autoreactivity in which a reduction in the strength of the BCR signal allows the survival and the modulation of a naive B cell repertoire replete with autoreactivity.

Positive selection of the peripheral B cell repertoire in gut-associated lymphoid tissues

Gut-associated lymphoid tissues (GALTs) interact with intestinal microflora to drive GALT development and diversify the primary antibody repertoire; however, the molecular mechanisms that link these events remain elusive. Alicia rabbits provide an excellent model to investigate the relationship between GALT, intestinal microflora, and modulation of the antibody repertoire. Most B cells in neonatal Alicia rabbits express V_Hn allotype immunoglobulin (Ig)M. Within weeks, the number of V_Hn B cells decreases, whereas V_Ha allotype B cells increase in number and become predominant. We hypothesized that the repertoire shift from V_Hn to V_Ha B cells results from interactions between GALT and intestinal microflora. To test this hypothesis, we surgically removed organized GALT from newborn Alicia pups and ligated the appendix to sequester it from intestinal microflora. Flow cytometry and nucleotide sequence analyses revealed that the V_Hn to V_Ha repertoire shift did not occur, demonstrating the requirement for interactions between GALT and intestinal microflora in the selective expansion of V_Ha B cells. By comparing amino acid sequences of V_Hn and V_Ha Ig, we identified a putative V_H ligand binding site for a bacterial or endogenous B cell superantigen. We propose that interaction of such a superantigen with V_Ha B cells results in their selective expansion.

Germline transcription and switch recombination of a transgene containing the entire H chain constant region locus: effect of a mutation in a STAT6 binding site in the gamma 1 promoter

The switch (S) in H chain class is preceded by germline transcription and then mediated by a DNA recombination event. One of the impediments toward understanding the mechanism is the lack of a system in which a recombinant DNA molecule undergoes cytokine-regulated class S recombination. To study class S recombination, we used transgenic mice with a 230-kb bacterial artificial chromosome that included a rearranged VDJ gene and the entire murine H chain constant region locus. We found that both germline transcription and S recombination to the transgenic gamma1 H chain gene were regulated by IL-4 like that of the endogenous genes. In mice with two or more copies of the H chain locus transgene, both germline transcripts and S recombination took place at levels comparable to those from the endogenous loci. We also prepared a version of the transgene with a 4-bp mutation in a STAT6 binding site in the gamma1 promoter region. On the average, this mutation reduced germline transcription by 80%, but did not change the amount of S recombination in vitro. Among both the wild-type and mutant transgenes, we found no significant correlation between the amount of germline transcripts and the amount of S recombination. We infer that the physiologic level of germline transcription of the gamma1 gene is in excess over the amount required for efficient S recombination.

Regulation of B-cell development by antibody specificity

Although autoantigen-induced negative selection plays an important role in shaping the mature B-cell repertoire, studies in recent years have suggested that differentiation into any of the three mature B-cell subsets (marginal zone B cells, follicular B cells and B-1 B cells) is not a passive product of autoreactive B-cell elimination. Instead, evidence suggests that entry into a mature subset involves active B-cell receptor signaling and self-antigen-mediated positive selection.

Positive selection of B cells expressing low densities of self-reactive BCRs

B cell tolerance or autoimmunity is determined by selective events. Negative selection of self-reactive B cells is well documented and proven. In contrast, positive selection of conventional B cells is yet to be firmly established. Here, we demonstrate that developing self-reactive B cells are not always highly sensitive to the deletion mechanisms imposed by membrane-bound self-antigens. At low amounts, membrane-bound antigens allow survival of B cells bearing a single high affinity self-reactive B cell receptor (BCR). More importantly, we show that forced allelic inclusion modifies B cell fate; low quantities of self-antigen induce the selection and accumulation of increased numbers of self-reactive B cells with decreased expression of antigen-specific BCRs. By directly measuring antigen binding by intact B cells, we show that the low amounts of self-antigen select self-reactive B cells with a lower association constant. A fraction of these B cells is activated and secretes autoantibodies that form circulating immune complexes with self-antigen. These findings demonstrate that conventional B cells can undergo positive selection and that the fate of a self-reactive B cell depends on the quantity of self-antigen, the number of BCRs engaged, and on its overall antigen-binding avidity, rather than on the affinity of individual BCRs.

Polyreactive antigen-binding B (PAB-) cells are widely distributed and the PAB population consists of both B-1+ and B-1- phenotypes

B cells that make polyreactive antibodies (PAB+ cells) express polyreactive Ig receptors on their surface and can bind a variety of different antigens. The present study shows that PAB+ cells are widely distributed, are present in varying numbers in different lymphoid organs and that their phenotype varies depending on the organs from which they are isolated. Up to 10 times more cells in PAB+ enriched populations bind antigens as compared to PAB- populations. Comparison of PAB+ with B-1+ cells showed that a high percentage of PAB+ cells are B-1+, but that many PAB+ cells do not express B-1 cell surface markers and, in fact, are B-1-. It is concluded that the B cell population consists of PAB+/B-1+, PAB+/B-1-, PAB-/B-1+, and PAB-/B-1- cells. The presence of PAB+ cells in the thymus points to the possibility that PAB+ cells may carry endogenous host antigens from peripheral tissues to the thymus where they may contribute to immunological tolerance.

On Immunity Against Infections and Vaccines: Credo 2004

Resistance of vertebrate hosts against infections comprises important natural or innate resistance combined with adaptive immune responses of T and B cells. Viruses, bacteria or classical parasites all probe the limit of immune responses and of immunity. They, therefore, offer an excellent opportunity to assess the biology, physiology and molecular aspects of immune responses and help in characterizing the three basic parameters of immunology-- specificity, tolerance and memory. Various experiments are summarized that indicate that the rules of antiviral, antitumour, antiorgan graft and of autoimmune responses are basically the same. The practical specificity repertoire of T and B cells is probably in the order of 10(4)-10(5) specificities expressed by T cells or by neutralizing antibodies. Tolerance is best defined by rules of reactivity to eliminate infections while avoiding destruction of normal cells by complete elimination of T cells that are specific for antigens persisting within the blood and lymphatic (lymphohaemopoietic) system. Induction of a T-cell response is the result of antigens newly entering lymph nodes or spleen, initially in a local fashion and exhibiting an optimal distribution kinetics within the lymphohaemopoietic system. Antigen staying outside lymphatic tissues are immunologically ignored (e.g. are non-events). Thus immune reactivity is regulated by antigen dose, time and relative distribution kinetics. Memory is the fact that a host is resistant against disease caused by reinfection with the same agent. Memory correlates best with antigen-dependent maintenance of elevated antibody titres in serum and mucosal secretions, or with an antigen-driven activation of T cells, such that they are protective immediately against peripheral reinfections in solid tissues. While antibodies transferred from mother to offspring are a prerequisite for the survival of otherwise unprotected immuno-incompetent offsprings, activated memory T cells cannot be transmitted. Thus, attenuation of infections in newborns and babies by maternal antibodies is the physiological correlate of man-made vaccines. T cells not only play an essential role in maintaining T-help-dependent memory antibody titres, but also in controlling the many infections that persist in a host at rather low levels (such as tuberculosis, measles and HIV).

B-cell homeostasis, competition, resources, and positive selection by self-antigens

In adult mice, the number of B lymphocytes remains constant under homeostatic control, in spite of the fact that B cells are produced continuously in numbers that largely exceed the number required to replenish the peripheral pools. It follows that each newly formed lymphocyte can only persist if another lymphocyte dies. In an immune system where the total number of cells is limited, cell survival is no longer a passive phenomenon but rather a continuous active process where each lymphocyte must compete with other lymphocytes to survive. Consequently, the number and the life expectancy of a B-cell clone vary according to the presence or absence of competitor populations. This process of lymphocyte competition is likely controlled by a common need for resources that are in limited supply. The number of peripheral B-cells varies according to the availability of B-cell receptor (BCR) ligands. Indeed, it is possible to modify steady-state B-cell numbers by antigen manipulation. Moreover, conventional self-reactive B cells can undergo positive selection. We showed that the fate of a self-reactive B cell is determined by the quantity of self-antigens, the number of antigen-specific receptors engaged, and its overall antigen-binding avidity rather than the affinity of individual BCRs.

Selection of B lymphocytes in the periphery is determined by the functional capacity of the B cell antigen receptor

Within the B cell antigen receptor (BCR), the cytoplasmic tails of both Igalpha and Igbeta are required for normal B cell development and maturation. To dissect the mechanisms by which each tail contributes to development in vivo, Igbeta(-/-) mice were reconstituted with retroviruses encoding either wild-type Igbeta, an Igbeta molecule lacking a cytoplasmic tail (Igbeta(deltaC)) or one in which the cytoplasmic tail was derived from Igalpha (Igbeta(Calpha)). All constructs rescued B cell development and generated immature B cell populations in the bone marrow with similar expression levels of both Igbeta and membrane-bound IgM. In the periphery, receptor-surface density was inversely proportional to the number of Igalpha tails in the BCR. Although peripheral-surface-receptor levels differed, splenic B cells expressing either Igbeta or Igbeta(Calpha) responded similarly to stimulation through the BCR. Analysis of membrane-bound IgM and Igbeta expression revealed that peripheral-receptor expression was primarily determined by positive selection between the bone marrow and peripheral immature B cell populations. These data indicate that B cells are selected into the periphery on the basis of a common level of antigen responsiveness.

Progressive Surface B Cell Antigen Receptor Down-Regulation Accompanies Efficient Development of Antinuclear Antigen B Cells to Mature, Follicular Phenotype

Previous studies have suggested that B cell Ag receptor (BCR) down-regulation by potentially pathological autoreactive B cells is associated with pathways leading to developmental arrest and receptor editing, or anergy. In this study we compare the primary development of B cells in two strains of mice expressing transgenic BCRs that differ by a single amino acid substitution that substantially increases reactivity for nuclear autoantigens such as DNA. Surprisingly, we find that both BCRs promote efficient development to mature follicular phenotype, but the strongly autoreactive BCR fails to promote marginal zone B cell development. The follicular B cells expressing the strongly autoreactive BCR do not appear to be anergic, as they robustly respond to polyclonal stimuli in vitro, are not short-lived, and can participate in germinal center reactions. Strikingly however, substantial and progressive down-modulation of surface IgM and IgD takes place throughout their primary development in the BM and periphery. We propose that BCR-autoantigen interactions regulate this pathway, resulting in reduced cellular avidity for autoantigens. This process of "learned ignorance" could allow autoreactive B cells access to the foreign Ag-driven memory B cell response, during which their self-reactivity would be attenuated by somatic hypermutation and selection in the germinal center.

Dominant, hierarchical induction of peripheral tolerance during foreign antigen-driven B cell development

We created mice expressing transgene-encoded BCRs with "dual reactivity" for the hapten Ars and nuclear autoantigens. Expression of transgene-encoded BCRs was not evident in the memory compartment despite observation of transgene-expressing B cells in germinal centers following Ars immunization. In contrast, dual reactive mAbs were readily obtained from mice with enforced expression of Bcl-2 following secondary Ars immunization. However, while these mAbs were hypermutated and displayed increased affinity for Ars, all had reduced avidity for DNA and intracellular autoantigens. Thus, Bcl-2 alters dominant-negative selection of dual reactive B cells during the Ars response, but this is restricted to those with lowered autoreactivity, demonstrating a hierarchy of peripheral tolerance during memory B cell development.