Quantitative studies on T cell diversity. IV. Mathematical analysis of multiple limiting populations of effector and suppressor T cells

Limiting Dilution Analysis of Interleukin-2 Producing Helper T-cell Frequencies as a Tool in Allogeneic Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation

BACKGROUND

A reliable in vitro test that estimates the level of ongoing alloreactivity would be valuable in allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) as a help to guide clinical interventions such as donor lymphocyte infusions and changes in the immunosuppression. In the present study, the use of limiting dilution analysis of interleukin-2 (IL-2) producing helper T lymphocyte frequencies (HTL assay) as a way to quantify alloreactivity following HCT was investigated.

METHODS

Serial HTL assays were performed following allogeneic HCT with myeloablative or nonmyeloablative conditioning in 26 patients with hematologic malignancies.

RESULTS

Deviations from single-hit kinetics were frequently observed in the HTL assays and a nonlinear model was therefore used for analysis. The results of this analysis suggested the presence of an inhibitory cell population. Inhibition was observed in the majority of patients and was not restricted to a specific transplant regimen. Inhibition occurred more often with high frequencies of IL-2 producing cells, indicating a physiological role of the putative inhibitory cell population in the regulation of an immune response. Higher frequencies of IL-2 producing cells were observed in patients with acute graft-versus-host disease grades II-IV than in patients with grades 0-I (P = 0.046), indicating that the degree of ongoing alloreactivity is indeed quantified by the HTL assay.

CONCLUSIONS

We find that the HTL assay may yield interesting insight into regulation of immune responses following allogeneic HCT, but because of the complexity of the results obtained, its use as a routine procedure to guide immunosuppression cannot be recommended.

Quantitating Effector and Regulatory T Lymphocytes in Immune Responses by Limiting Dilution Analysis Modeling

Although there is currently no doubt that regulatory lymphocytes represent a master player in the immune system, a major unresolved problem is the accurate quantitation of these cells among unfractionated cell populations. This difficulty mainly arises because there are no specific immunophenotypic markers that can reliably discriminate between effector and regulatory lymphocytes. To face this problem, we have developed computational models of limiting dilution analyses addressing the question of the accurate estimation of the frequencies of effector and regulatory cells functionally engaged in an immune response. A set of generic equations were provided to form a framework for modeling limiting dilution data, enabling discrimination between qualitatively different models of suppression. These models include either one or two subpopulations of regulatory cells, featured by either low or potent regulatory activity. The potential of this modeling approach was illustrated by the accurate determination of the frequencies of effector and regulatory T lymphocytes in one real limiting dilution experiment of CD4+ CD25+ T lymphocytes performed in the context of an allogeneic response in the human system. The crucial advantage of the limiting dilution method over the "static, phenotype-based" method is the dynamic evaluation of effector and regulatory T cell biology through their actual functional activity.

Regulation by CD25+ lymphocytes of autoantigen-specific T-cell responses in Goodpasture's (anti-GBM) disease

BACKGROUND

Goodpasture's, or anti-glomerular basement membrane (GBM), disease is unusual among autoimmune diseases in that it rarely follows a relapsing-remitting course. Moreover, untreated, autoantibodies disappear spontaneously after 1 to 3 years and, following treatment, autoreactive T cells diminish in frequency. This suggests that operational tolerance toward the autoantigen is reestablished. However, the mechanisms underlying this have remained unclear. Recent data have suggested that a population of regulatory T lymphocytes can suppress both autoimmune and alloimmune responses in animal models and are present in normal individuals. However, to date, they have not been demonstrated to play a role in human renal autoimmune disease.

METHODS

We studied the role of regulatory CD25+ cells in suppressing T-cell responses to the Goodpasture autoantigen in nine patients with Goodpasture's disease.

RESULTS

At the time of acute presentation, there was no evidence of a regulatory cell population. However, from 3 months onward a population emerged, capable of suppressing the response to the Goodpasture autoantigen. Following depletion of CD25+ cells, the frequencies of autoreactive-, GBM-, or collagen alpha 3(IV)NC1-specific T cells were significantly increased (P = 0.031 by paired t test), with five of seven (71%) convalescent patients and no acute patients demonstrating regulation.

CONCLUSION

These data demonstrate that, in Goodpasture's disease, regulatory CD25+ T cells play a role in inhibiting the autoimmune response. Their emergence and persistence may underlie the "single hit" nature of this condition. Understanding the conditions required for the development and propagation of these cells would allow development of novel therapeutic strategies for inducing hyporesponsiveness in autoimmune disease.

Detection of suppressor T lymphocytes and estimation of their frequency in limiting dilution assays by generalized linear regression modeling

The estimate of the frequency of suppressor T lymphocytes in unfractionated cell populations remains challenging, mainly because these regulatory cells do not display specific immunophenotypic markers. In this paper, we describe a novel theoretical approach for quantifying the frequency of suppressor cells. This method is based on limiting dilution data modeling, and allows the simultaneous estimation of the frequencies of both proliferating and suppressor cells. We used previously published biological data, characterizing the inhibiting activity of suppressor T cell clones. Starting from these data, we propose a mathematical model describing the interaction between suppressor and proliferating T cells, and applied to a Poisson process. Limiting dilution data corresponding to this non-single-hit, suppressor two-target Poisson model were artificially generated, then modeled according to a generalized linear regression procedure. Deviation from the single-hit Poisson model was revealed by a statistical slope test, and a stepwise analysis of the regression appeared to be an efficient method that strongly argued in favor of the presence of suppressor cells. By using the frequency of proliferating T cells calculated in the first step of the regression, we demonstrated the possibility to provide a reasonable estimate of the frequency of suppressor T cells. Based on these findings, a practical decision-making procedure is given to perform standard analyses of limiting dilution data.

Renal transplant patients show variations in their self-reactive repertoires: a serial study

We addressed the question of whether allo-transplantation (Tx) induces breakdown of tolerance to self-antigens or alteration of the autoreactive T cell repertoire in humans. The serial variation of T cell autoreactivity was studied in the peripheral blood of 12 renal transplant patients, by autologous limiting dilution assay and autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction. Ten of 12 patients presented a positive response in autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells in the post-Tx period, in contrast to four of 12 patients before Tx (P = 0.038). Multi-hit kinetics was found in 57% of the assays analyzed, indicating frequent regulatory control of the autologous response. Quantitative analysis performed in eight patients showed an increase in precursor frequency at >1 year post-Tx in five patients. These data indicate that autoreactivity increases or develops following Tx, in humans. Post-Tx events such as alloreactivity, infections or immunosuppression could interfere with the balance of autoreactive and regulatory cells, leading to changes in the T cell repertoires to self-antigens and eventually breakdown of self-tolerance. Further investigation is needed to elucidate whether post-Tx autoreactivity contributes to rejection, plays a regulatory role over alloreactivity or both, at separate times.

Identification and precursor frequency analysis of a common T cell epitope motif in mitochondrial autoantigens in primary biliary cirrhosis

The immunodominant antimitochondrial antibody response in patients with primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is directed against the E2 component of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDC-E2). Based on our earlier observations regarding peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) T cell epitopes, we reasoned that a comparative analysis of the precursor frequencies of PDC-E2 163-176-specific T cells isolated from PBMC, regional hepatic lymph nodes, and from the liver of PBC patients would provide insight regarding the role of T cells in PBC. Results showed a disease-specific 100-150-fold increase in the precursor frequency of PDC-E2 163-176-specific T cells in the hilar lymph nodes and liver when compared with PBMC from PBC patients. Interestingly, autoreactive T cells and autoantibodies from PBC patients both recognize the same dominant epitope. In addition, we demonstrated cross-reactivity of PDC-E2 peptide 163-176-specific T cell clones with PDC-E2 peptide 36-49 and OGDC-E2 peptide 100-113 thereby identifying a common T cell epitope "motif" ExETDK. The peptide 163-176-specific T cell clones also reacted with purified native PDC-E2, suggesting that this epitope is not a cryptic determinant. These data provide evidence for a major role for PDC-E2 peptide 163-176 and/or peptides bearing a similar motif in the pathogenesis of PBC.

Indirect allorecognition of major histocompatibility complex allopeptides in human renal transplant recipients with chronic graft dysfunction

BACKGROUND

It has been suggested that T cells primed by processed donor major histocompatibility complex antigen (the "indirect" pathway of allorecognition) may be responsible for mediating chronic allograft rejection. The purpose of this study was to develop a clinically useful assay to study the occurrence of indirect allorecognition during chronic rejection in humans.

METHODS

A panel of 20 mer peptides corresponding to the hypervariable regions of HLA-DRB1*0101, DRB1*1501, and DRB1*0301 were synthesized. Lymphocytes obtained from renal allograft recipients were cocultured with these peptides. Proliferation was assayed by DNA incorporation of [3H]thymidine, and positive proliferation was defined by a statistically significant increase in counts per minute over background with a minimum stimulation index of 2. The precursor frequency of allopeptide reactive T cells was determined by limiting dilution analysis.

RESULTS

Lymphocytes from 82% of patients who were mismatched for at least one of the three DR molecules and had chronic allograft dysfunction specifically proliferated to the mismatched allopeptides (n=11). Proliferation was seen in only 6% of control subjects (2/33, P<0.0001). The proliferative response was low grade and was best detected on day 7-8 of culture in vitro. The precursor frequency of peptide-specific T cells was more than 10-fold higher compared with controls (P<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate for the first time that T cells of patients with chronic graft dysfunction are primed to recognize and respond to specific donor-derived major histocompatibility complex allopeptides. Our results support the hypothesis that T cells primed via the indirect pathway of allorecognition may be important mediators of chronic rejection and provide the rationale to develop specific therapeutic strategies to prevent or interrupt this process.

Fitting limiting dilution experiments with generalized linear models results in a test of the single-hit Poisson assumption

Limiting dilution analysis is a common technique that is used in immunology to estimate accurately the frequency of cells possessing a wide variety of functional activities such as growth, cytotoxicity and production of lymphokines. The reliability of the estimated frequency is usually checked by a standard chi-square (x2) test validating the goodness-of-fit to the single-hit Poisson model (SHPM). We present evidence that modelling limiting dilution data according to a generalized linear model offers an alternative to the standard x2 test for detecting departures from the SHPM, with a considerable increase in power compared to the x2 test.

Analysis of cellular interactions in limiting dilution cultures

Limiting dilution (LD) cultures are often used to study cellular heterogeneity in responses of murine splenocytes to specific or polyclonal activation. LD titration curves often reveal a nonlinear dependence of response on input cell dose. Although 'zigzag' shaped curves of this kind are often interpreted and analyzed as resulting from interactions among three distinct cell types, we observe that a more parsimonious two cell model, including a cell type that can generate both positive and negative effects, provides better fit to a wide range of experimental data. We have developed mathematical models for the accurate estimation of the frequencies of both interacting cell types and of the parameters for their multi-hit interaction. We show examples of LD cultures in which specific experimental manipulations alter the frequency of only one of the two cell types, or alter the interaction parameters without a change in responder frequency. We also provide a simplified method for approximation of the model parameters using graphical approaches and simple algebra. Lastly, we present an improved method for calculation of the effect generated per responder cell in microclonal cultures.

Regulatory cellular interactions in the primary mixed lymphocyte reaction

Limiting dilution analysis (LDA) of allogeneic and syngeneic murine mixed lymphocyte reactions was used to study the heterogeneity both of the responding spleen cells and of the stimulating antigen-presenting dendritic cells (DC). In contrast with traditional LDA of single-hit processes, a non-linear dependence of the proportion of negative microcultures on responding spleen cell concentration was obtained. The non-linearity of this LDA plot was interpreted as being the result of a competitive interaction between two types of limiting precursor cells. The regulatory and stimulatory functions of DC were investigated in the same LDA systems by testing various levels of DC from spleen or thymus as limiting cells in the presence of a constant quantity of syngeneic splenic responder T cells. This revealed a functional heterogeneity amongst DC, which were found to suppress proliferation of responder cells at low DC levels but to stimulate proliferation at higher levels. At levels where splenic DC became stimulatory, thymic DC remained suppressive.

Increased frequency of interleukin 2-responsive T cells specific for myelin basic protein and proteolipid protein in peripheral blood and cerebrospinal fluid of patients with multiple sclerosis

Equal numbers of CD4+ T cells recognizing myelin basic protein (MBP) and proteolipid protein (PLP) are found in the circulation of normal individuals and multiple sclerosis (MS) patients. We hypothesized that if myelin-reactive T cells are critical for the pathogenesis of MS, they would exist in a different state of activation as compared with myelin-reactive T cells cloned from the blood of normal individuals. This was investigated in a total of 62 subjects with definitive MS. While there were no differences in the frequencies of MBP- and PLP-reactive T cells after primary antigen stimulation, the frequency of MBP or PLP but not tetanus toxoid-reactive T cells generated after primary recombinant interleukin (rIL-2) stimulation was significantly higher in MS patients as compared with control individuals. Primary rIL-2-stimulated MBP-reactive T cell lines were CD4+ and recognized MBP epitopes 84-102 and 143-168 similar to MBP-reactive T cell lines generated with primary MBP stimulation. In the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of MS patients, MBP-reactive T cells generated with primary rIL-2 stimulation accounted for 7% of the IL-2-responsive cells, greater than 10-fold higher than paired blood samples, and these T cells also selectively recognized MBP peptides 84-102 and 143-168. In striking contrast, MBP-reactive T cells were not detected in CSF obtained from patients with other neurologic diseases. These results provide definitive in vitro evidence of an absolute difference in the activation state of myelin-reactive T cells in the central nervous system of patients with MS and provide evidence of a pathogenic role of autoreactive T cells in the disease.

The standard chi 2 test used in limiting dilution assays is insufficient for estimating the goodness-of-fit to the single-hit Poisson model

Limiting dilution analysis is a common technique that is used in immunology to estimate accurately the frequency of cells possessing a wide variety of functional activities, such as growth, cytotoxicity and production of lymphokines. In the literature, most experiments are fit well by the single-hit Poisson model (SHPM), which assumes that only one cell of one defined cell subset is necessary for a positive response. This is somewhat surprising since other models such as multi-hit or multi-target models that involve the interaction of one or more cells from one or more cell subpopulations for generating or inhibiting a positive response are conceivable. Since the validity of the SHPM is usually investigated by performing a standard chi 2 test, based on the number of observed and expected positive and negative responses, we questioned here the efficiency of this test in comparison with other validity tests for the SHPM, the log likelihood test derived by Cox, and the modified Weibull plot tests, the principles of which are entirely different from that of the standard chi 2 test. We used the following theoretical approach. First, we generated artificial data corresponding to multi-hit and multi-target models. Second, considering that these data were derived from real experiments, we calculated the frequency of the desired cell subset according to the SHPM using the maximum likelihood method. Then, the goodness-of-fit of these data with the SHPM was evaluated. The log likelihood test and the modified Weibull plot tests rejected the SHPM hypothesis, while the standard chi 2 test did not. Thus, the standard chi 2 test is unable to discriminate sensitively between the SHPM and more complicated (non-single-hit) Poisson models. We concluded that the results of limiting dilution studies published thus far must be evaluated with caution. The statistical tests presented here should be routinely applied for each limiting dilution experiment.

Shifts in the epitopes of myelin basic protein recognized by Lewis rat T cells before, during, and after the induction of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

An epitope present in the 71-90 sequence of basic protein (BP) has been identified as the dominant epitope recognized by most Lewis rat encephalitogenic T cells isolated during experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). In the present study, we investigated the BP epitopes recognized by Lewis rat T cells in naive rats, in rats suffering from acute EAE, and in recovered rats. T cells isolated from the spinal cord lesions and from the lymph nodes were studied using T cell lines and bulk cultures. Virulence of the T cells was assayed by adoptive transfer. We now report that naive and recovered Lewis rats are populated with T cells reactive to a variety of BP epitopes and only a minority are specific for the 71-90 epitope. In contrast, the induction of EAE was associated with a predominance of T cells reactive to the 71-90 epitope. T cells recovered from naive, diseased, or recovered rats were found to be virulent upon passive transfer. Some of these virulent T cells were specific to BP epitopes other than the 71-90 epitope. There was no major difference in the BP specificities of T cells isolated from the lesions and from the lymph nodes. Thus, natural T cell reactivity to BP is heterogeneous and pathogenicity is not confined to one particular epitope, active disease is characterized by a dominant response to the 71-90 epitope, and recovery is marked by a return to heterogeneity.

T cells in the lesion of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. Enrichment for reactivities to myelin basic protein and to heat shock proteins

To characterize the cellular immune response in an autoimmune lesion, we investigated the accumulation of specific T cells in the central nervous system in actively induced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in Lewis rats, using a limiting dilution analysis (LDA) assay for T cells that proliferate in response to antigens. Lymphocytes isolated from the spinal cord infiltrate were compared with cells from the popliteal lymph nodes with respect to frequency of cells responding to basic protein (BP), mycobacterium tuberculosis (MT), the 65-kD heat shock protein (hsp65), allogeneic brown norway spleen cells, and concanavalin A. Additionally, we compared the BP frequency in acute EAE of cells from the spinal cord, peripheral blood, spleen and lymph nodes, and the spinal cord and lymph node after recovery from EAE. We found that acute EAE was associated with marked enrichment of BP-reactive T cells in the spinal cord relative to their frequency in the lymphoid organs and peripheral blood. The infiltrate was also enriched for T cells responding to hsp65; alloreactive T cells, in contrast, were not enriched. The frequency of BP reactive T cells in the spinal cord was highest at the peak of paralysis; however, BP-reactive T cells could still be detected at moderate frequencies after clinical recovery. We established BP- and Mycobacteria-reactive T cell lines from the spinal infiltrates that were CD4+ and TcR alpha beta +. Most of the BP lines were found to react to the major encephalitogenic epitope of guinea pig BP for rats (amino acids 71-90); these lines were found to mediate EAE in naive recipients. T cell lines recognizing other epitopes of BP were not encephalitogenic. All of the lines responsive to Mycobacteria recognized hsp65 or hsp70. These results indicating that the immune infiltrate in active EAE is enriched with cells responding to the autoantigen and to hsp65 were confirmed in EAE adoptively transferred by anti-BP T cell clone.

Immunologic tolerance in lymphatic filariasis. Diminished parasite-specific T and B lymphocyte precursor frequency in the microfilaremic state

To explore the mechanisms of antigen-specific immune unresponsiveness seen in microfilaremic patients with bancroftian filariasis, T and B cell precursor frequency analysis was performed using PBMC from individuals with either asymptomatic microfilaremia (MF, n = 7) or chronic lymphatic obstruction (CP, n = 20). Highly purified CD3+ cells were partially reconstituted with adherent cells and their proliferative response to parasite antigens determined in cultures of T cells by limiting dilution analysis. A filter immunoplaque assay also assessed the frequency of both total and parasite-specific Ig-producing B cells. While the lymphocyte proliferation to mitogens and to a nonparasite antigen (Streptolysin-O, [SLO]) were similar in all groups of patients, the frequency of parasite-specific CD3+ T cells was significantly lower (geometric mean [GM], 1/3,757) in MF patients when compared to that in CP patients (GM 1/1,513; P less than 0.001). Similarly, the proportion of lymphocytes producing parasite-specific IgE or IgG was significantly lower in MF patients (IgE mean, 0.2%; IgG mean, 0.33%) compared with CP patients (IgE mean, 3.2%; IgG mean, 1.76%; P less than 0.05 for both comparisons). These observations imply that low numbers of parasite-specific T and B lymphocytes may be partially responsible for the severely diminished capacity of lymphocytes from patients with MF to produce parasite-specific antibody and to proliferate to parasite antigen in vitro. Such differences in parasite-specific lymphocyte responses suggest that tolerance by clonal anergy may be a critical mechanism for maintaining the microfilaremic state.

Macrophage regulation of immune responses of spleen cells from mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi

Mice infected with the protozoan parasite, Trypanosoma cruzi, are known to be immunosuppressed in responsiveness to heterologous antigens and parasite-specific antigens. This suppression is mediated by suppressor macrophages and is exemplified by deficient T cell activity and abnormal cytokine production. Neither the mechanism by which suppressor macrophages effect suppression nor the characteristics of these suppressor macrophages is known. In the present study, we analyzed the regulatory cell populations in splenocytes of infected mice (SCinf) and their interactions by limiting dilution-partition analysis, an approach which allows the functional separation of multiple regulatory cell subpopulations within cell mixtures. Our results demonstrate the presence of a complex immunoregulatory circuit in SCinf affecting the generation of anti-sheep erythrocyte antibody responses in vitro. Titration of SCinf (but not peritoneal exudate or lymph node cells) into Mishell-Dutton microcultures of normal spleen cells generated complex dose-response curves with two zones of suppressed responses following the addition of either low or high doses of SCinf to the cultures. Addition of intermediate doses of SCinf to the microcultures restored responsiveness. Both the low- and high-dose zones of suppression were shown to be mediated by macrophages, whereas T cells were responsible for the restored responsiveness at intermediate doses of SCinf. Examination of the development of this complex regulatory pattern during the course of the acute phase of infection indicated the sequential development of one suppressor macrophage population, followed by the development of the beneficial T cell population, and finally the expression of the second suppressive macrophage population.

HgCl2-induced perturbation of the T cell network in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. I. In vitro characterization of T cells involved

Mercuric chloride (HgCl2) induces in Lewis (LEW) rats a non-antigen-specific immunosuppression and is able to down-modulate experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in about 70% of the rats. The aim of the present study was to determine the frequencies of lymph node cells involved in the proliferative response to myelin basic protein in rats injected with HgCl2 and immunized with myelin by using limiting dilution analysis (LDA). Highly frequent CD8+ T suppressor cells and at least 10-fold less frequent protein basic-specific T helper cells were detected in these rats. A third cell type allowing the proliferative response of Th cells in spite of Ts cells was also demonstrated. These cells, which could act as contrasuppressor cells, were CD4+ and adhered to Vicia villosa lectin; their frequency was in the same range as that of T helper cells. These data illustrate the potential role of different levels of T cell immunoregulatory activity in autoimmunity and the major interest of LDA in their analysis.

A novel autoregulatory cytokine is required for the regulation of autoaggressive responses

Limiting dilution studies indicate that cells with the potential to lyse autologous target cells exist in the peripheral blood of all normal individuals. In contrast to allocytotoxic cells, autocytolytic cells are down-regulated by a second less frequent cell population. When recombinant interleukin 2 is substituted for crude lymphocyte conditioned medium in these limiting dilution experiments, autocytotoxicity develops normally. Under these conditions, however, the autocytotoxic response is not down-regulated. Mixing crude lymphocyte-conditioned medium together with recombinant interleukin 2 restores the regulation of autocytotoxicity normally seen at high responder cell dose. These findings indicate that a second soluble factor present in the conditioned medium is necessary either for the activation, growth, or differentiation of the regulatory cell population or alternatively, to render the cytotoxic population responsive to the activity of regulatory cells. Gel filtration studies indicate that the molecular weight of this factor is between 60 and 80 kd. This factor appears to be distinct from known immunologically active cytokines. It is conceivable that deficiencies of this cytokine may be relevant to the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases or graft-versus-host reactions.

Monoclonal antibodies against leucoagglutinin-reactive human T-lymphocyte surface components. II. Studies on the mechanism of K46M-induced activation and determination of the frequency of responding cells

A monoclonal antibody, K46M (IgM kappa), obtained after immunization with leucoagglutinin (La)-reactive T-cell surface components, stimulated human lymphocytes to proliferate. It induced maximal proliferation at greater than 20 micrograms IgM/ml after 3-4 days of culture. Cells stimulated by K46M produced interleukin 2 (IL-2) and gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) and expressed receptors for IL-2 and transferrin. The majority of the activated cells were phenotypically T cells as defined by monoclonal antibodies against CD3 and CD2, and an increase in the K46M-positive cells was also observed during the activation period. K46M-activated cells display major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-unrestricted cytotoxicity against several cultured target cells. The frequencies of the cytotoxic and of the proliferative precursor cells were determined using a limiting dilution assay. K46M seems to activate a larger fraction of cytotoxic precursor cells against Molt 4 than against K562, but the statistical significance of these observations requires further exploration. Both K46M or La activated 40% of PBL to proliferate, whereas 70% of PBL were induced by OKT3. However, the frequency of K46M-activated cells was 40% only when the lymphocytes were plated at low cell densities, i.e. less than 0.5 cells per well. At higher densities an inhibition of proliferation was seen that resulted in a biphasic response curve, indicating that the activation of PBL by K46M was not a single hit event. This was not found with either La or OKT3. Whether K46M, in contrast to OKT3 and La, activates a subpopulation with suppressor activity remains to be established.

Autoreactive T cells in mercury-induced autoimmunity. Demonstration by limiting dilution analysis

Mercuric chloride is responsible in Brown-Norway rats for an autoimmune disease that is autoregulated. Previous studies have shown that this agent induces T cell-dependent polyclonal B cell activation in these rats. Evidence has also been obtained for the existence of autoreactive T cells which play a role in the evolution of this process. In the present study, limiting dilution analysis was used to demonstrate that (a) frequent autoreactive T helper cells which proliferate in the presence of T cells from HgCl2-injected rats are present from day 4; (b) frequent auto-anti-Ia T helper cells which recognize normal B cells as well as B cells from HgCl2-injected rats appear from day 6; and (c) less frequent T suppressor cells which could play a role in autoregulation emerge from day 14.

Suppression of the number of clonally expanding T cells by CD8+ cells as demonstrated by murine T-cell colony formation

Clonally developing murine T cells in the form of T-cell colonies (TCC) in methylcellulose were used to investigate the interaction between polyclonally activated T cells. Only CD8+ T cells proliferate in the methylcellulose and form TCC after stimulation with PHA and IL-2. When the number of developing TCC was counted as a measure of developing clones, it was found that increased cell numbers in the cultures led to decreased percentages of TCC (Number of TCC per 100 seeded cells). This was found already at very low cell concentrations: 40 cells per ml culture, and was maintained at least up to 10,000 cells per culture. Cell sorting (FACS) of cells showed that the suppression of developing clones was mediated via a non-adherent, Thy-1+, CD8+ cell, present in lymph nodes, spleen and the thymic medulla. Such seemingly non-specific suppressor cells may be considered in the network regulation of the functionally mature T-cell population.

Limiting dilution analysis of the frequencies of helper and suppressor T cells in untreated and TNP-treated BALB/c mice: response as a consequence of perturbation of a stable steady state

B-cell response and suppression of response were analysed with respect to changes in frequency or composition of regulatory elements in comparison to untreated BALB/c mice. As antigenic stimulus the hapten TNP was used. Suppression was induced by intravenous (i.v.) injection of TNP-haptenized syngeneic lymphocytes; for inducing response, mice received TNP-horse red blood cells (HRBC). As the read-out system, plaque-forming cells (PFC) were determined after either the addition of naive B cells only [determination of the frequency of helper T-cells (TH)], or the addition of naive B cells plus saturating doses of TNP-specific TH [determination of the frequency of suppressor T-cells (Ts)]. The data indicate that, in untreated animals, a network of help and suppression is pre-existing, wherein TH are more frequent (1/1471) than TS (1/4413), but TS are dominant, i.e. when the fraction of non-responding cultures (F0) (determination of help) was plotted, an inversion of the curve was seen at high numbers of cells per well; however, the fractions of responding cultures (F+) (determination of suppression) could be plotted on a straight line. Application of antigen in suppressogenic or immunogenic form resulted in a two- to four-fold increase in the corresponding regulatory population but, concomitantly, a minor increase in the frequency of the mutual counteracting population was observed. Irrespective of any immunization schedule, TH were more frequent than TS. The overall shape of the 'helper' and 'suppressor' curves with spleen cells (SC) from suppressed mice resembled--besides changes in the frequencies--those obtained with SC of untreated animals. This corresponds to the maintenance of a state of unresponsiveness as in untreated animals. However, when SC from primed or suppressed plus primed mice were analysed, a different type of curve was obtained. Suppressor curves no longer followed a ratio dominance model; instead, at high numbers of cells per well, the frequency of wells with suppressive activity decreased. Correspondingly, in helper curves, a second slope of increasing numbers of wells with helper activity was seen at a high input of cells. Hence, response cannot be explained solely by expansion/activation of TH, but obviously a third regulatory population is involved which could not be detected in untreated animals. This third regulatory population could either be non-suppressible TH or--more likely, as will be discussed--contrasuppressor cells.

Cluster formation in a symmetrical network: a dynamical system for the description of the suppression among non-immune T lymphocytes and its application to the effects of immunization

A mathematical model has been developed for the description of the suppressive regulation between polyclonally activated normal and immune T cells. The model assumes reversible cell-cell interactions to interpret results from limiting dilution experiments performed to determine the frequencies of precursor cells for antigen-specific T effector lymphocytes and to analyse mechanisms regulating the maturation of precursor into effector T cells. In particular, the model deals with the changes induced in the T lymphocytes population following immunization with antigens. In these limiting dilution experiments, T cells are placed in cultures at varying cell numbers with all other essential culture constituents kept in excess. After polyclonal activation of the T cells in culture they are supplied with growth and maturation factors so that they form daughter clones of functionally active T effector cells. The typical result observed was that effector T cells develop in cultures at low cell input but that this development is totally suppressed at high cell numbers. This result suggested that, at high cell numbers, the effector T cells are exposed to a sufficient number of other T cells of appropriate specificity to permit suppressive interactions. Whereas this is the case for non-immune T cells, T cells after immunization develop into effector cells both at high as well as at low cell concentrations, though with efficiencies less than proportional to their number of precursors. Our mathematical model is made up of a set of first order autonomous ordinary differential equations in many variables permitting the calculations of numbers of free cells and of cells engaged in cellular clusters of varying sizes. Free cells can develop into effector cells whereas cells engaged in clusters cannot. We calculate the consequences of several reasonable hypotheses concerning the effects of immunization. We consider the possibility that immunization modifies the growth behavior of the antigen-specific cells to permit an increased or accelerated clonal expansion in culture. Alternatively, we consider the possibility that immunization changes the interaction strength between cells specific for the immunizing antigen and other cells. Thirdly, we have connected both behaviors by calculating the case of an inverse relationship between growth rates and intensities of interaction between cells. Our model has been inspired by the symmetrical network model and can be interpreted in this framework. It proposes that immune regulation is a consequence of idiotype-anti-idiotype interactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

High frequency of precursors of anomalous killer cells in human peripheral blood: evidence for T-cell regulation

The frequency of precursors (P) of the anomalous killer (AK) cells able to kill a melanoma target cell line without prior sensitization was determined by limiting dilution analysis. The frequencies obtained from the peripheral blood mononuclear cells of six healthy individuals ranged from 1/250 to 1/750, which was considerably higher than those of alloreactive cytolytic T-lymphocyte (CTL) precursors induced in the same cultures (range 1/900 to 1/7500). The presence of phytohemagglutinin (PHA) inhibited the appearance of both CTL and AK in bulk cocultures, and in limiting dilution analysis the presence of the lectin resulted in multiphasic cell dose-response curves rather than linear single hit responses for both types of precursor cells. The results suggest that AK-P are under the same type of regulation as are CTL-P.

Hypothesis: the MHC-restricted T-cell receptor as a structure with two multistate allosteric combining sites

This paper presents a dual-recognition model of the T-cell receptor that has been constructed to account for the phenomenon of MHC restriction as well as the paradoxical ability of T-cells to be both multispecific and precisely specific at the same time. In our model the combining sites for antigen and MHC are not independent as in classical dual-recognition models, but interact with each other by an allosteric mechanism. We envision a flexible receptor with combining sites for antigen and MHC that are capable of existing in a multitude of distinct complementarity states. MHC and antigen molecules act as allosteric effectors such that one ligand perturbs the conformation and therefore the specificity of the site for the other ligand. An essential feature of the model is that different MHC determinants induce different conformations at the anti-antigen site. In this way the receptor acquires multiple specificities. Within a particular complementarity state, precise recognition results from the requirement that antigen and MHC exhibit positive cooperativity in their binding to the T-cell receptor. Positive cooperativity is also the basis for MHC restriction. Reaction mechanisms are presented which describe the requirement that antigen and MHC both induce conformational changes in order to generate high-affinity binding to either ligand. As a precedent for the multistate allosteric receptor model, we discuss the properties of allosteric enzymes, especially ribonucleotide reductase, whose properties are analogous to those we have postulated for the T-cell receptor. Also discussed is the possibility that molecules such as Ly2, L3T4 and the Mls antigen, which have been found to play a role in antigen recognition, function as affinity-enhancing allosteric effectors that interact with the constant portion of the T-cell receptor.

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes of the rat are predominantly restricted by RT1.A and not RT1.C-determined major histocompatibility class I antigens

Two types of biochemically defined class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens are found in the rat, RT1.A antigens that are ubiquitously expressed and RT1.C antigens which so far are detectable only on certain cell types, notably B and T lymphocytes. It is shown that the cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to minor H antigens of the LEW strain, including the H-Y antigen, and to TNP-modified syngeneic lymphoid cells is restricted by RT1.A but not RT1.C gene products. This conclusion is based on bulk culture assays including cold target inhibition tests and limiting dilution experiments using recombinants between the RT1a and RT1u haplotypes. The possibility that class I MHC antigens exist which have no major restriction function is discussed.