A role for secondary V(D)J recombination in oncogenic chromosomal translocations?

Chromosomal translocations are hallmarks of certain lymphoproliferative disorders. Indeed, in many leukemias and lymphomas, translocations are the transforming event that brings about malignancy. Recurrence of the immunoglobulin (Ig) and T-cell receptor (Tcr) loci at the breakpoints of oncogenic chromosomal translocations has led to speculation that the lymphocyte-specific process of V(D)J rearrangement, which is necessary for the generation of functional Ig and TCR antigen receptors on B and T lymphocytes, mediates translocation. Recent studies have led to a fuller understanding of the molecular mechanisms of V(D)J rearrangement and have revealed that the V(D)J recombinase possesses latent transposase activity. These studies have led to plausible models of illegitimate V(D)J recombination producing chromosomal translocations consistent with those present in lymphomas and leukemias. Errors of V(D)J recombination may even generate lymphomas with the phenotypes of mature cells. For example, follicular and Burkitt's lymphomas have been classified by phenotype and somatic genotype as malignant germinal center (GC) B or post-GC B cells. The GC is a site of affinity maturation where B cells undergo V(D)J hypermutation and Ig class switch; in addition, much evidence has accumulated to suggest that GC B cells may also support secondary V(D)J recombination. Interestingly, all three of these elements, genomic plasticity, mutation, and translocation breakpoints near switch sites or recombinational elements, are characteristic of certain lymphomas. The high frequency of lymphomas carrying these GC markers suggests that the GC reaction may play a significant role in lymphomagenesis.

Spontaneous formation of germinal centers in autoimmune mice

The mechanisms of autoantibody production are not well understood. Germinal centers (GC) may be important sites of immune disregulation in autoimmune diseases. In this study, we document the presence of spontaneous GC formation in the spleens of several autoimmune mouse strains that spontaneously develop autoimmune Type I diabetes and a lupus-like disease. In contrast, mouse strains that do not develop lupus did not exhibit spontaneous formation of GC. In all of the autoimmune strains studied, GC were present at 1-2 months of age, a time that closely parallels the appearance of autoantibodies. Like the GC that develop after purposeful immunization, GC in autoimmune mice contained B220(+), PNA(+), and GL-7(+) B cells, and FDC-M1(+) follicular dendritic cells. In addition, spontaneously formed GC in autoimmunity and those caused by immunization were abrogated in a similar way by a short-term treatment with anti-CD40 ligand antibody. These data indicate that spontaneously forming GC in autoimmunity are similar to those appearing after purposeful immunization.

Studies of the humoral immune response

The humoral immune response arises from a complex choreography of cells and molecules that interact to produce lasting and effective defenses against pathogens. For more than fifteen years, our laboratory has studied how humoral responses are initiated, how they mature, and how they are remembered. This work has come from many hands and in this brief synopsis, I cannot provide the full recognition that my students, postdoctoral fellows, and collaborators merit. I hope that my colleagues can accept this translucence and know that their efforts are recognized and deeply appreciated, nonetheless.

Definition of a novel cellular constituent of the bone marrow that regulates the response of immature B cells to B cell antigen receptor engagement

Previously we defined a Thy1(dull) bone marrow-derived cell population that regulated fate decisions by immature B cells after Ag receptor signaling. The microenvironmental signals provided by this cell population were shown to redirect the B cell Ag receptor -induced apoptotic response of immature B cells toward continued recombination-activating gene (RAG) expression and secondary light chain recombination (receptor editing). Neither the identity of the cell responsible for this activity nor its role in immature B cell development in vivo were addressed by these previous studies. Here we show that this protective microenvironmental niche is defined by the presence of a novel Thy1(dull), DX5(pos) cell that can be found in close association with immature B cells in vivo. Depletion of this cell eliminates the anti-apoptotic effect of bone marrow in vitro and leads to a significant decrease in the number and frequency of bone marrow immature B cells in vivo. We propose that, just as the bone marrow environment is essential for the survival and progression of pro-B and pre-B cells through their respective developmental checkpoints, this cellular niche regulates the progression of immature stage B cells through negative selection.

CD4+Thy1- thymocytes with a Th-type 2 cytokine response

We have identified a small subset of CD3(+), CD4(+), CD8(-) thymocytes that do not express Thy1 (CD90). This Thy1(-) subset represents 1-3.7% of the total number of thymocytes in a naive mouse. CD4(+)Thy1(-) thymocytes express high levels of CD3, intermediate to high levels of heat-stable antigen (HSA), and low levels of CD25, CD45RB, CD69, CD44 and CD62L. They produce high titers of IL-4 and no IFN-gamma upon stimulation in vitro, a response characteristic of T(h)2 cells. In the thymi of mice infected neonatally with a high dose of the retrovirus Cas-Br-E MuLV, the frequency of CD4(+)Thy1(-) cells increased approximately 10-fold. High-dose virus infection resulted in decreased HSA and increased CD44 expression on CD4(+)Thy1(-) cells relative to cells from naive mice. CD4(+)Thy1(-) cells from high-dose infected mice also secreted IL-4 and not IFN-gamma upon in vitro stimulation. We previously reported that infection of newborn mice with a high dose of murine retrovirus results in the induction of a non-protective anti-viral T(h)2 T cell response; CD4(+)Thy1(-) thymocytes with a T(h)2-like cytokine profile may play a role in determining the cytokine bias of this anti-viral response.

Complement C4 inhibits systemic autoimmunity through a mechanism independent of complement receptors CR1 and CR2

The complement system enhances antibody responses to T-dependent antigens, but paradoxically, deficiencies in C1 and C4 are strongly linked to autoantibody production in humans. In mice, disruption of the C1qa gene also results in spontaneous autoimmunity. Moreover, deficiencies in C4 or complement receptors 1 and 2 (CR1/CR2) lead to reduced selection against autoreactive B cells and impaired humoral responses. These observations suggest that C1 and C4 act through CR1/CR2 to enhance humoral immunity and somehow suppress autoimmunity. Here we report high titers of spontaneous antinuclear antibody (ANA) in C4(-/)- mice. This systemic lupus erythematosus-like autoimmunity is highly penetrant; by 10 mo of age, all C4(-)(/)- females and most males produced ANA. In contrast, titers and frequencies of ANA in Cr2(-)(/)- mice, which are deficient in CR1 and CR2, never rose significantly above those in normal controls. Glomerular deposition of immune complexes (ICs), glomerulonephritis, and splenomegaly were observed in C4(-)(/)- but not Cr2(-)(/)- mice. C4(-)(/)-, but not Cr2(-)(/)-, mice accumulate activated T and B cells. Clearance of circulating ICs is impaired in preautoimmune C4(-)(/)-, but not Cr2(-)(/)-, mice. C4 deficiency causes spontaneous, lupus-like autoimmunity through a mechanism that is independent of CR1/CR2.

Regulation of humoral immune responses by CD21/CD35

Before antigen-specific immunity arises, the complement system responds by activation through the classical and/or alternative pathways leading to the covalent deposition of complement fragments. Three models, not mutually exclusive, have been proposed to explain how these complement fragments interact with their receptors, CD21/CD35, to enhance humoral immune responses: i) CD21/CD35 retain and focus antigens for optimal presentation; ii) CD21/CD35 on B cells serve as enhancing co-receptors for B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) signaling; iii) CD21/CD35 regulate B-cell responses, by CD19 aggregation. The coreceptor model led us to predict that CD21/CD3 5 may lower the threshold of BCR affinity to diversify the repertoire of humoral immune responses, but surprisingly, CD21/CD3 5-deficient mice expressing a transgenic BCR with very low affinity (Kalpha approximately =1.2 x 10(5) M(-1)) for the (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl hapten generated significant antibody and germinal center responses to even low doses of antigens in alum. The magnitudes of these responses were much below those of normal controls but higher doses of antigens substantially rectified these deficits. Thus, while CD21/CD35 play important roles in humoral immunity, our observations provide little support to the hypothesis that CD21/CD35 promote clonal diversity in immune responses by helping recruit low-affinity B cells.

Humoral immune responses in Cr2-/- mice: enhanced affinity maturation but impaired antibody persistence

Deficiency in CD21/CD35 by disruption of the Cr2 loci leads to impaired humoral immune responses. In this study, we detail the role of CD21/CD35 on Ab responses to the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl conjugated to chicken gamma-globulin. Surprisingly, Cr2-/- mice generate significant Ab responses and germinal center (GC) reactions to low doses of this Ag in alum, although the magnitude of their responses is much reduced in comparison with those of Cr2+/- and C57BL/6 controls. Increasing Ag dose partially corrected this deficit. In situ study of the somatic genetics of GC B cells demonstrated that VDJ hypermutation does not require CD21/CD35, and Cr2-/- mice exhibited enhanced affinity maturation of serum Ab in the post-GC phase of the primary response. On the other hand, Cr2-/- mice displayed accelerated loss of serum Ab and long-lived Ab-forming cells. These observations suggest that B cell activation/survival signals mediated by CD21 and/or the retention of Ag by CD21/CD35 play important roles in the generation, quality, and maintenance of serum Ab.

RAG2:GFP knockin mice reveal novel aspects of RAG2 expression in primary and peripheral lymphoid tissues

We generated mice in which a functional RAG2:GFP fusion gene is knocked in to the endogenous RAG2 locus. In bone marrow and thymus, RAG2:GFP expression occurs in appropriate stages of developing B and T cells as well as in immature bone marrow IgM+ B cells. RAG2:GFP also is expressed in IgD+ B cells following cross-linking of IgM on immature IgM+ IgD+ B cells generated in vitro. RAG2:GFP expression is undetectable in most immature splenic B cells; however, in young RAG2:GFP mice, there are substantial numbers of splenic RAG2:GFP+ cells that mostly resemble pre-B cells. The latter population decreases in size with age but reappears following immunization of older RAG2:GFP mice. We discuss the implications of these findings for current models of receptor assembly and diversification.

V(D)J hypermutation and receptor revision: coloring outside the lines

At least three mechanisms increase potential genetic diversity in peripheral B lymphocytes: hypermutation, gene conversion and secondary V(D)J rearrangements. These diversifying activities were once believed to be strictly confined to the immunoglobulin loci and B cells. Recent experiments demonstrate that this is not the case. Hypermutation has now been shown to diversify the BCL-6 genes of germinal-center B cells. The role, if any, of these mutations in the immune response remains unknown but the notion that the hypermutation mechanism is targeted solely to immunoglobulin genes is no longer tenable. Peripheral T cells may also diversify their antigen receptors by the reactivation of RAG (recombination-activating gene)1 and RAG2 and secondary V(D)J rearrangements. These new findings suggest a remarkable genetic plasticity in subsets of antigen-reactive lymphocytes and may frame new questions of clonal selection and self tolerance.

Antigen drives very low affinity B cells to become plasmacytes and enter germinal centers

In the first week of the primary immune response to the (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) hapten, plasmacytic foci and germinal centers (GCs) in C57BL/6 mice are comprised of polyclonal populations of B lymphocytes bearing the lambda1 L-chain (lambda1+). The Ig H-chains of these early populations of B cells are encoded by a variety of VH and D exons undiversified by hypermutation while later, oligoclonal populations are dominated by mutated rearrangements of the VH186.2 and DFL16.1 gene segments. To assess directly Ab affinities within these defined splenic microenvironments, representative VDJ rearrangements were recovered from B cells participating in the early immune response to NP, inserted into Ig H-chain expression cassettes, and transfected into J558L (H-; lambda1+) myeloma cells. These transfectoma Abs expressed a remarkably wide range of measured affinities (Ka = 5 x 10(4)-1.3 x 10(6) M(-1)) for NP. VDJs recovered from both foci and early GCs generated comparable affinities, suggesting that initial differentiation into these compartments occurs stochastically. We conclude that Ag normally activates B cells bearing an unexpectedly wide spectrum of Ab affinities and that this initial, promiscuous clonal activation is followed by affinity-driven competition to determine survival and clonal expansion within GCs and entry into the memory and bone marrow plasmacyte compartments.

Predicted and inferred waiting times for key mutations in the germinal centre reaction: evidence for stochasticity in selection

The germinal centre reaction (GCR) is a fundamental component of the immune response to T-dependent antigens, during which the immunoglobulin (Ig) genes of B cells experience somatic hypermutation and selection. A maximum-likelihood method on DNA sequence data from 16 individual germinal centres was used to infer that the waiting time for position 33 key (high-affinity) mutations in the anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl) acetyl (NP) response is 8.3 days. This is in marked contrast to the prediction of a key mutant each generation (waiting time about 1/3 day) obtained from a simple model and parameters available in the literature. This disagreement is resolved in part by the finding that the targeted base occurs in a cold spot for hypermutation, raising the predicted waiting time to 2.3 days, although this value remains significantly lower than that inferred from the sequence data. It is proposed that the remaining disparity is attributable to some further stochastic process in the GCR: many early key mutations arise but fail to 'take root' within the GC, either due to emigration or failure of cognate T cell/B cell interaction. Furthermore, it is argued that the frequency with which position 33 mutations are found in secondary responses to NP indicates the presence of selection after the GCR.

Dependence of germinal center B cells on expression of CD21/CD35 for survival

Affinity-driven selection of B lymphocytes within germinal centers is critical for the development of high-affinity memory cells and host protection. To investigate the role of the CD21/CD35 coreceptor in B cell competition for follicular retention and survival within the germinal center, either Cr2+ or Cr2null lysozyme-specific transgenic B cells were adoptively transferred into normal mice immunized with duck (DEL) or turkey (TEL) lysozyme, which bind with different affinities. In mice injected with high-affinity turkey lysozyme, Cr2null B cells responded by follicular retention; however, they could not survive within germinal centers. This suggests that CD21 provides a signal independent of antigen that is required for survival of B cells in the germinal center.

Immunoglobulin gene hypermutation in germinal centers is independent of the RAG-1 V(D)J recombinase

Antigen-driven somatic hypermutation in immunoglobulin genes coupled with stringent selection leads to affinity maturation in the B-lymphocyte populations present in germinal centers. To date, no gene(s) has been identified that drives the hypermutation process. The site-specific recombination of antigen-receptor gene segments in T and B lymphocytes is dependent on the expression of two recombination activating genes, RAG-1 and RAG-2. The RAG-1 and RAG-2 proteins are essential for the cleavage of DNA at highly conserved recombination signals to make double-strand breaks and their expression is sufficient to confer V(D)J recombination activity to non-lymphoid cells. Until very recently, expression of the V(D)J recombinase in adults was believed to be restricted to sites of primary lymphogenesis. However, several laboratories have now demonstrated expression of RAG-1 and RAG-2 and active V-to-(D)J recombination in germinal center B cells. This observation of active recombinase in germinal centers raises the issue of RAG-mediated nuclease activity as a component of V(D)J hypermutation. Here, we show that a transgenic kappa-light chain gene in a RAG-1-/- genetic background can acquire high frequencies of mutations. Thus, the RAG-1 protein is not essential for the machinery of immunoglobulin hypermutation. The genetic approaches to identifying the genes necessary for somatic hypermutation will require further studies on DNA-repair and immunodeficient models.

In situ studies of the primary immune response to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl. V. Affinity maturation develops in two stages of clonal selection

To examine the role of germinal centers (GCs) in the generation and selection of high affinity antibody-forming cells (AFCs), we have analyzed the average affinity of (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-specific AFCs and serum antibodies both during and after the GC phase of the immune response. In addition, the genetics of NP-binding AFCs were followed to monitor the generation and selection of high affinity AFCs at the clonal level. NP-binding AFCs gradually accumulate in bone marrow (BM) after immunization and BM becomes the predominant locale of specific AFCs in the late primary response. Although the average affinity of NP-specific BM AFCs rapidly increased while GCs were present (GC phase), the affinity of both BM AFCs and serum antibodies continued to increase even after GCs waned (post-GC phase). Affinity maturation in the post-GC phase was also reflected in a shift in the distribution of somatic mutations as well as in the CDR3 sequences of BM AFC antibody heavy chain genes. Disruption of GCs by injection of antibody specific for CD154 (CD40 ligand) decreased the average affinity of subsequent BM AFCs, suggesting that GCs generate the precursors of high affinity BM AFCs; inhibition of CD154-dependent cellular interactions after the GC reaction was complete had no effect on high affinity BM AFCs. Interestingly, limited affinity maturation in the BM AFC compartment still occurs during the late primary response even after treatment with anti-CD154 antibody. Thus, GCs are necessary for the generation of high affinity AFC precursors but are not the only sites for the affinity-driven clonal selection responsible for the maturation of humoral immune responses.

Immunosenescence and germinal center reaction

Dysfunction of the immune system in aged individuals includes at least two important factors: accumulation of immunocytes with reduced function and accumulation of lymphocyte clones with self-reactive potential. Coincidently, there is a profound reduction of the germinal center reaction in the aged. While this reduction is likely the result of age-associated impairment in lymphocyte function (e.g. diminished response to costimulus, altered lymphokine production etc.), the reduction of germinal centers may itself make an important contribution to further immunological dysfunction.

V(D)J recombinase activity in a subset of germinal center B lymphocytes

Reexpression of the V(D)J recombinase-activating genes RAG1 and RAG2 in germinal center B cells creates the potential for immunoglobulin gene rearrangement and the generation of new antigen receptor specificities. Intermediate products of V(D)J recombination are abundant in a subset of germinal center B cells, demonstrating that the kappa immunoglobulin light-chain locus becomes a substrate for renewed V(D)J recombinase activity. This recombinationally active cell compartment contains many heavy-chain VDJ rearrangements that encode low-affinity or nonfunctional antibody. In germinal centers, secondary V(D)J recombination may be induced by diminished binding to antigen ligands, thereby limiting abrupt changes in receptor specificity to B cells that are usually eliminated from the germinal center reaction. This restriction preserves efficient antigen-driven selection in germinal centers while allowing for saltations in the somatic evolution of B cells.

Distinctive characteristics of germinal center B cells

A cardinal property of the immune system is its ability to respond to an antigen that was encountered years before with an accelerated and enhanced secondary response. The property of anamnestic reactions depends upon the formation of long-lived compartments of specialized T and B lymphocytes called memory cells. While the origin of the memory T-cell compartment is not known, germinal centers are the specialized sites for memory B-cell generation and the immunoglobulin V-region hypermutation necessary for the affinity maturation of serum antibody. Interestingly, the peripheral differentiation pathway that leads to this most mature B-cell state begins with the recapitulation of many characters of immature B lymphocytes in bone marrow. This review describes the distinctive cellular basis of germinal center reaction and the characteristics of B cells in germinal centers that later enter the memory pool.

Neoteny in lymphocytes: Rag1 and Rag2 expression in germinal center B cells

The products of the Rag1 and Rag2 genes drive genomic V(D)J rearrangements that assemble functional immunoglobulin and T cell antigen receptor genes. Expression of the Rag genes has been thought to be limited to developmentally immature lymphocyte populations that in normal adult animals are primarily restricted to the bone marrow and thymus. Abundant RAG1 and RAG2 protein and messenger RNA was detected in the activated B cells that populate murine splenic and Peyer's patch germinal centers. Germinal center B cells thus share fundamental characteristics of immature lymphocytes, raising the possibility that antigen-dependent secondary V(D)J rearrangements modify the peripheral antibody repertoire.

Alternative pathways for the selection of antigen-specific peripheral T cells

In the thymus, maturing lymphocytes receive activation signals mediated by the T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) that either promote clonal survival (positive selection) or induce apoptosis (negative selection). This balance between life and death is mirrored by the sensitivity of cortical thymocytes to apoptotic death induced by antibodies against the CD3 component of the TCR signal-transduction complex, bacterial superantigens that bind to the TCR beta-chain, and corticosteroids. In contrast, mature peripheral T cells are positively activated by anti-CD3 antibody or superantigens and are resistant to steroid-induced death. Here we show that in splenic germinal centres, T cells regain thymocyte-like sensitivity to TCR- and steroid-induced apoptosis and undergo antigen-driven positive and negative selection. T-cell responses elsewhere in the spleen are unaccompanied by programmed cell death. Our observations define a new differentiation pathway for peripheral T cells and suggest that germinal centres induce a lymphocyte phenotype necessary for the maintenance of self-tolerance.

Gamma delta T cell help of B cells is induced by repeated parasitic infection, in the absence of other T cells

BACKGROUND

gamma delta T cells, like alpha beta T cells, are components of all well-studied vertebrate immune systems. Yet, the contribution of gamma delta T cells to immune responses is poorly characterized. In particular, it has not been resolved whether gamma delta cells, independent of any other T cells, can help B cells produce immunoglobulin and form germinal centers, anatomical foci of specialized T cell-B cell collaboration.

RESULTS

TCR beta-/- mice, which lack all T cells except gamma delta T cells, routinely displayed higher levels of antibody than fully T cell-deficient mice. Repeated parasitic infection of TCR beta-/- mice, but not of T cell-deficient mice, increased antibody levels and induced germinal centers that contained B cells and monoclonal gamma delta cells in close juxtaposition. However, antibody specificities were more commonly against self than against the challenging pathogen. gamma delta T cell-B cell help was not induced by repeated inoculation of TCR beta-/- mice with mycobacterial antigens.

CONCLUSIONS

In the absence of any other T cells, gamma delta T cell-B cell collaboration can be significantly enhanced by repeated infection. However, the lack of obvious enrichment for antibodies against the challenging pathogen distinguishes gamma delta T cell help from alpha beta T cell help induced under analogous circumstances. The increased production of generalized antibodies may be particularly relevant to the development of autoimmunity, which commonly occurs in patients suffering from alpha beta T cell deficiencies, such as AIDS.

T helper cells in murine germinal centers are antigen-specific emigrants that downregulate Thy-1

After immunization, activated splenic T cells proliferate in periarteriolar lymphoid sheaths (PALS) and subsequently migrate to the lymphoid follicle where they enter nascent germinal centers. Analysis of TCR V(D)J gene rearrangements indicates extensive emigration, frequently involving more than a single white pulp region. These migrants constitute a unique set of T helper cells that express antigen-specific alpha beta TCR, CD3, and CD4, but little or no Thy-1, a differentiation antigen present on the great majority of peripheral murine T lymphocytes. The origin of CD4+ Thy-1 follicular T cells appears to be the Thy+ population in the PALS, as both sets commonly share identical V(D)J rearrangements.

Regulation of the B cell response to T-dependent antigens by classical pathway complement

Mice deficient in complement components C3 (C3 -/-) and C4 (C4 -/-) were found to have a profound defect in their Ab response to a T-dependent Ag (bacteriophage (phi X174). Characterization of the deficient mice demonstrated a diminished level of peanut agglutinin+ germinal centers and a failure in isotype switching despite normal B cell signaling in vitro. The nature of the defect was found to lie at the B cell level, as the T cells were primed in C3- and C4-deficient mice as well as those in wild-type mice. These results, and the finding that the defect could be partly reversed by a 10-fold increase in Ag dose, support the hypothesis that covalent attachment of complement ligands, i.e., C3b and C3d to the Ag-Ab complex, increases its immunogenicity.

Regulation of the B cell response to T-dependent antigens by classical pathway complement

Mice deficient in complement components C3 (C3 -/-) and C4 (C4 -/-) were found to have a profound defect in their Ab response to a T-dependent Ag (bacteriophage (phi X174). Characterization of the deficient mice demonstrated a diminished level of peanut agglutinin+ germinal centers and a failure in isotype switching despite normal B cell signaling in vitro. The nature of the defect was found to lie at the B cell level, as the T cells were primed in C3- and C4-deficient mice as well as those in wild-type mice. These results, and the finding that the defect could be partly reversed by a 10-fold increase in Ag dose, support the hypothesis that covalent attachment of complement ligands, i.e., C3b and C3d to the Ag-Ab complex, increases its immunogenicity.

CD28 is required for germinal center formation

Previous studies have demonstrated that the T cell costimulatory molecule, CD28, is important in the development of humoral immunity. CD28-deficient mice exhibit defects in isotype switching and are more susceptible to pathogens that depend on an effective Ab response. To determine the basis of these defects, we have examined B cell responses of CD28-deficient mice at the microenvironmental level. Early in a normal T-dependent immune response, small numbers of B cells undergo activation in the T cell-rich zone of secondary lymphoid tissues and then migrate to B cell areas. These migrant B cells found developing germinal centers by proliferative expansion, during which individual cells acquire mutations in their rearranged Ig genes. B cell mutants retaining higher affinities for Ag undergo positive selection in germinal centers, resulting in the establishment of the memory B cell compartment. In the present study, we demonstrate that although potentially Ag-reactive cells within the lymphoid follicle accumulate following antigenic challenge, these cells fail to undergo proliferative expansion to form germinal centers and do not acquire somatic mutations in CD28-deficient animals. Thus, the CD28 activation pathway is required for Ab responses to T-dependent Ags. cell compartment. In the present study, we demonstrate that although potentially Ag-reactive cells within the lymphoid follicle accumulate following antigenic challenge, these cells fail to undergo proliferative expansion to form germinal centers and do not acquire somatic mutations in CD28-deficient animals. Thus, the CD28 activation pathway is required for Ab responses to T-dependent Ags.

CD28 is required for germinal center formation

Previous studies have demonstrated that the T cell costimulatory molecule, CD28, is important in the development of humoral immunity. CD28-deficient mice exhibit defects in isotype switching and are more susceptible to pathogens that depend on an effective Ab response. To determine the basis of these defects, we have examined B cell responses of CD28-deficient mice at the microenvironmental level. Early in a normal T-dependent immune response, small numbers of B cells undergo activation in the T cell-rich zone of secondary lymphoid tissues and then migrate to B cell areas. These migrant B cells found developing germinal centers by proliferative expansion, during which individual cells acquire mutations in their rearranged Ig genes. B cell mutants retaining higher affinities for Ag undergo positive selection in germinal centers, resulting in the establishment of the memory B cell compartment. In the present study, we demonstrate that although potentially Ag-reactive cells within the lymphoid follicle accumulate following antigenic challenge, these cells fail to undergo proliferative expansion to form germinal centers and do not acquire somatic mutations in CD28-deficient animals. Thus, the CD28 activation pathway is required for Ab responses to T-dependent Ags. cell compartment. In the present study, we demonstrate that although potentially Ag-reactive cells within the lymphoid follicle accumulate following antigenic challenge, these cells fail to undergo proliferative expansion to form germinal centers and do not acquire somatic mutations in CD28-deficient animals. Thus, the CD28 activation pathway is required for Ab responses to T-dependent Ags.

The germinal center: a crucible for lymphocyte selection

Antigen first activates T and B lymphocytes in the T-cell areas of secondary lymphoid tissues where cognate- and costimulus-dependent proliferation expands the population of reactive lymphocytes. Selected T- and B-cell progeny from this population migrate into B-cell zones to form germinal centers (GC), where intense proliferation, apoptosis, and V(D)J hypermutation takes place. It is now known that each of these processes occur in both compartments of GC lymphocytes and that the GC T-cell represents an unusual Thy-1- subset of alpha beta T-helper cells that may represent a terminally differentiated cell that is lost with the end of the GC reaction.

Germinal center formation, immunoglobulin class switching, and autoantibody production driven by "non alpha/beta" T cells

The production of class-switched antibodies, particularly immunoglobulin (Ig) G1 and IgE, occurs efficiently in T cell receptor (TCR) alpha-/- mice that are congenitally devoid of alpha/beta T cells. This finding runs counter to a wealth of data indicating that IgG1 and IgE synthesis are largely dependent on the collaboration between B and alpha/beta T cells. Furthermore, many of the antibodies synthesized in TCR alpha-/- mice are reactive to a similar spectrum of self-antigens as that targeted by autoantibodies characterizing human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). SLE, too, is most commonly regarded as an alpha/beta T cell-mediated condition. To distinguish whether the development of autoantibodies in TCR alpha-/- mice is due to an intrinsic de-regulation of B cells, or to a heretofore poorly characterized collaboration between B and "non-alpha/beta T" cells, the phenotype has been reconstituted by transfer of various populations of B and non-alpha/beta T cells including cloned gamma/delta T cells derived from TCR alpha-/- mice, to severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice. The results establish that the reproducible production of IgG1 (including autoantibodies) is a product of non-alpha/beta T cell help that can be provided by gamma/delta T cells. This type of B-T collaboration sustains the production of germinal centers, lymphoid follicles that ordinarily are anatomical signatures of alpha/beta T-B cell collaboration. Thus, non-alpha/beta T cell help may drive Ig synthesis and autoreactivity under various circumstances, especially in cases of alpha/beta T cell immunodeficiency.

Antibody response to a T-dependent antigen requires B cell expression of complement receptors

Several lines of evidence indicate that antibody responses to T-dependent antigens require complement receptors expressed on either B lymphocytes or follicular dendritic cells. We have used RAG-2 deficient blastocyst complementation to create mice specifically lacking B cell complement receptors. Despite normal expression of complement receptor 1 (CR1[CD35]) and CR2 (CD21) on follicular dendritic cells, these mice have a profound defect in their capacity to mount a T-dependent antibody response. This is the first direct demonstration in vivo that B cell expression of complement receptors is required for a humoral immune response. This is the first direct demonstration in vivo that B cell expression of complement receptors is required for a humoral immune response. This suggests that CD21 and/or CD35 on B lymphocytes may be required for cellular activation, adsorptive endocytosis of antigen, recruitment to germinal centers, and/or protection from apoptosis during the humoral response to T-dependent antigens.

In situ studies of the primary immune response to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl. IV. Affinity-dependent, antigen-driven B cell apoptosis in germinal centers as a mechanism for maintaining self-tolerance

Germinal centers (GCs) are the sites of antigen-driven V(D)J gene hypermutation and selection necessary for the generation of high affinity memory B lymphocytes. Despite the antigen dependence of this reaction, injection of soluble antigen during an established primary immune response induces massive apoptotic death in GC B cells, but not in clonally related populations of nonfollicular B lymphoblasts and plasmacytes. Cell death in GCs occurs predominantly among light zone centrocytes, is antigen specific, and peaks within 4-8 h after injection. Antigen-induced programmed death does not involve cellular interactions mediated by CD40 ligand (CD40L) or Fas; disruption of GCs by antibody specific for CD40L was not driven by apoptosis and C57BL/6.lpr mice, though unable to express the Fas death trigger, remained fully susceptible to soluble antigen. Single injections of antigen did not significantly decrease GC numbers or average size, but repeated injections during an 18-h period resulted in fewer and substantially smaller GCs. As cell loss appeared most extensive in the light zone, decreased GC cellularity after prolonged exposure to soluble antigen implies that the Ig- centroblasts of the dark zone may require replenishment from light zone cells that have survived antigenic selection. GC cell death is avidity-dependent; oligovalent antigen induced relatively little apoptosis and GC B cells that survived long exposures to multivalent antigen expressed atypical VDJ rearrangements unlikely to encode high affinity antibody. Antigen-induced apoptotic death in GCs may represent a mechanism for the peripheral deletion of autoreactive B cell mutants much as the combinatorial repertoire of immature B lymphocytes is censored in the bone marrow.

Ig VH hypermutation is absent in the germinal centers of aged mice

After injection with immunogenic conjugates of the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP), two distinct B cell populations can be identified in the spleen during the primary response. One of these populations is specialized for Ab production; the other, the germinal centers (GCs), has been identified as the site of Ig somatic hypermutation. Ag-driven selection of GC B cells bearing mutated receptors with higher affinity leads to the affinity maturation of serum Ab and increased protective humoral immunity. Microdissection of GC B cell populations specific for NP and sequencing of the recovered Ig heavy chain variable region genes revealed that the somatic hypermutation process is absent in the GCs of aged C57BL/6 mice. However, selection for Ag appears to occur in the absence of hypermutation in the form of competition between unmutated clones of Ag-activated B lymphocytes. Thus, affinity maturation in these animals is limited to the affinities of Ab encoded by the germline.

Ig VH hypermutation is absent in the germinal centers of aged mice

After injection with immunogenic conjugates of the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP), two distinct B cell populations can be identified in the spleen during the primary response. One of these populations is specialized for Ab production; the other, the germinal centers (GCs), has been identified as the site of Ig somatic hypermutation. Ag-driven selection of GC B cells bearing mutated receptors with higher affinity leads to the affinity maturation of serum Ab and increased protective humoral immunity. Microdissection of GC B cell populations specific for NP and sequencing of the recovered Ig heavy chain variable region genes revealed that the somatic hypermutation process is absent in the GCs of aged C57BL/6 mice. However, selection for Ag appears to occur in the absence of hypermutation in the form of competition between unmutated clones of Ag-activated B lymphocytes. Thus, affinity maturation in these animals is limited to the affinities of Ab encoded by the germline.

Cellular interaction in germinal centers. Roles of CD40 ligand and B7-2 in established germinal centers

Costimulatory interactions between T and B lymphocytes are crucial for T cell activation and B cell proliferation and differentiation. We have compared the roles of CD40L and B7-2 in the initiation and maturation of humoral immunity by administering anti-CD40 ligand (L) or anti-B7-2 Ab during the early (days -1 to 3) or late (days 6-10) phases of primary responses to thymus-dependent (Td) and -independent (Ti) Ags. Germinal center (GC) formation in response to a Td Ag was inhibited completely by the early administration of anti-CD40L or anti-B7-2 Abs. Later in the response, established GCs remained sensitive to anti-CD40L but were resistant to treatment with anti-B7-2. However, Ig hypermutation was reduced dramatically in GCs of anti-B7-2-treated mice and humoral memory was impaired. Early administration of anti-CD40L reduced serum Ab levels to approximately 10% of controls, whereas early treatment with anti-B7-2 reduced Ab production by only 50%. Later treatments with either Ab had no effect on Ab production. Response to a type II Ti Ag was more resistant than Td responses to interruption of costimulatory interactions. Our findings suggest that the costimulatory roles of CD40:CD40L and B7-2:CD28/CTLA-4 differ in the GC; administration of anti-CD40L abrogates an established GC reaction, whereas Ab to B7-2 suppresses Ig hypermutation and entry into the B cell memory compartment. Once B cells have entered the differentiation pathway to Ab production, neither CD40L nor B7-2 is necessary for their continued differentiation and persistence.

Cellular interaction in germinal centers. Roles of CD40 ligand and B7-2 in established germinal centers

Costimulatory interactions between T and B lymphocytes are crucial for T cell activation and B cell proliferation and differentiation. We have compared the roles of CD40L and B7-2 in the initiation and maturation of humoral immunity by administering anti-CD40 ligand (L) or anti-B7-2 Ab during the early (days -1 to 3) or late (days 6-10) phases of primary responses to thymus-dependent (Td) and -independent (Ti) Ags. Germinal center (GC) formation in response to a Td Ag was inhibited completely by the early administration of anti-CD40L or anti-B7-2 Abs. Later in the response, established GCs remained sensitive to anti-CD40L but were resistant to treatment with anti-B7-2. However, Ig hypermutation was reduced dramatically in GCs of anti-B7-2-treated mice and humoral memory was impaired. Early administration of anti-CD40L reduced serum Ab levels to approximately 10% of controls, whereas early treatment with anti-B7-2 reduced Ab production by only 50%. Later treatments with either Ab had no effect on Ab production. Response to a type II Ti Ag was more resistant than Td responses to interruption of costimulatory interactions. Our findings suggest that the costimulatory roles of CD40:CD40L and B7-2:CD28/CTLA-4 differ in the GC; administration of anti-CD40L abrogates an established GC reaction, whereas Ab to B7-2 suppresses Ig hypermutation and entry into the B cell memory compartment. Once B cells have entered the differentiation pathway to Ab production, neither CD40L nor B7-2 is necessary for their continued differentiation and persistence.

Facultative role of germinal centers and T cells in the somatic diversification of IgVH genes

The development of memory B cells takes place in germinal centers (GC) of lymphoid follicles where antigen-driven lymphocytes undergo somatic hypermutation and affinity selection, presumably under the influence of helper T cells. However, the mechanisms that drive this complex response are not well understood. We explored the relationship between GC formation and the onset of hypermutation in response to the hapten phosphorylcholine (PC) coupled to antigenic proteins in mice bearing different frequencies of CD4+ T cells. PC-reactive GC were identified by staining frozen splenic sections with peanut agglutinin (PNA) and with monoclonal Abs against AB1-2, a dominant idiotope of T15+ anti-PC antibody. The nucleotide sequences of rearranged T15 VH1 genes were determined from polymerase chain reaction amplifications of genomic DNA from microdissected GC B cells. T15+ GC became fully developed by day 6-7 after primary immunization of euthymic mice with either PC-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) or PC-chicken gamma globulin (CGG). Yet the VH1 gene segments recovered from the primary GC as late as day 10-14 had low numbers of mutations, in contrast to responses to the haptens nitrophenyl or oxazolone that sustain high levels of hypermutation after GC formation. PC-reactive B cells proliferate in histologically typical GC for considerable periods with no or little somatic hypermutation; the signals for GC formation are independent of those for the activation of hypermutation. We then examined GC 7 d after secondary immunization with PC-KLH in euthymic mice, in nu/nu mice reconstituted with limited numbers of normal CD4+ cells before priming (CD4(+)-nu/nu) and in nu/nu mice. All of these animals develop T15+ GC after antigen priming, however, the patterns of V gene mutations in the secondary GC reflected the levels of CD4+ cells present during the primary response. VDJ sequences from secondary GC of euthymic mice were heavily mutated, but most of these mutations were shared among all related (identical VDJ joints) sequences suggesting the proliferation of mutated, memory B cells, with little de novo somatic hypermutation. In contrast, the patterns of V gene diversity in secondary GC from CD4(+)-nu/nu mice suggested that there was ongoing mutation and clonal diversification during the first week after rechallenge. The secondary GC from T cell-deficient, nu/nu mice showed little evidence for mutational and/or recombinational diversity of T15+ B cells. We conclude that the participation of CD4+ helper cells is required for full activation of the mutator in GC and takes place in a dose-dependent fashion.

The nude mutation results in impaired primary antibody repertoire

We have studied the effect of the nude mutation and/or T lymphocytes on the development of V gene germ-line repertoire in neonatal athymic (nu/nu) and euthymic (+/nu) littermates. A total of 2.35 x 10(6) and 1.47 x 10(6) B lymphocyte clones from nu/nu and +/nu neonates, respectively, were examined for the expression of select VH (J558, J606, S107, 36-60, 7183 and Q52) and Vx (1, 2, 8 and 9) gene families as well as VH (J558, S107) + Vx (1, 9) associations. Data showed that the nude mutation, whether homozygous or heterozygous, significantly affects VH and Vx gene expression as well as VH and Vx pairings and, thus, provide evidence for a defective development of B cell repertoire in both athymic nude (nu/nu) and euthymic (+/nu) mice. In addition, an analysis of 3.34 x 10(6) B lymphocyte clones from adult C57BL/6 mice showed non-stochastic association between VHJ558 + Vx1 gene families that suggests restrictions on clonal population in order to maintain homeostasis in the immune system. Studies outlined here, therefore, describe an hitherto unknown defect in the development of B lymphocyte repertoire as a result of the nude mutation which is independent of thymic dysgenesis.