Enhanced T-cell activation and differentiation in lymphocytes from transgenic mice expressing ubiquitination-resistant 2KR LAT molecules

Linker for activation of T cells (LAT) is critical for the propagation of T-cell signals upon T-cell receptor (TCR) activation. Previous studies demonstrated that substitution of LAT lysines with arginines (2KR LAT) resulted in decreased LAT ubiquitination and elevated T-cell signaling, indicating that LAT ubiquitination is a molecular checkpoint for attenuation of T-cell signaling. To investigate the role of LAT ubiquitination in vivo, we have generated transgenic mice expressing WT and ubiquitin-defective 2KR LAT. On TCR stimulation of T cells from these mice, proximal signaling and cytokine production was elevated in 2KR versus wild-type (WT) LAT mice. Enhanced cytolytic activity as well as T-helper responses were observed on LAT expression, which were further elevated by 2KR LAT expression. Despite greater T-effector function, WT or 2KR LAT expression did not have any effect on clearance of certain pathogens or tumors. Our data support the model that lack of tumor clearance is due to increased differentiation and acquisition of effector phenotype that is associated with suboptimal immunity in an immunotherapy model. Thus, our data further reinforce the role of LAT ubiquitination in TCR signaling and uncovers a novel role for LAT in driving T-cell differentiation.

Inhibition of TGF-β signaling in genetically engineered tumor antigen-reactive T cells significantly enhances tumor treatment efficacy

Transforming growth factor β (TGF-β) is a cytokine with complex biological functions that may involve tumor promotion or tumor suppression. It has been reported that multiple types of tumors secrete TGF-β, which can inhibit tumor-specific cellular immunity and may represent a major obstacle to the success of tumor immunotherapy. In this study, we sought to enhance tumor immunotherapy using genetically modified antigen-specific T cells by interfering with TGF-β signaling. We constructed three γ-retroviral vectors, one that expressed TGF-β-dominant-negative receptor II (DNRII) or two that secreted soluble TGF-β receptors: soluble TGF-β receptor II (sRII) and the sRII fused with mouse IgG Fc domain (sRIIFc). We demonstrated that T cells genetically modified with these viral vectors were resistant to exogenous TGF-β-induced smad-2 phosphorylation in vitro. The functionality of antigen-specific T cells engineered to resist TGF-β signaling was further evaluated in vivo using the B16 melanoma tumor model. Antigen-specific CD8+ T cells (pmel-1) or CD4+ T cells (tyrosinase-related protein-1) expressing DNRII dramatically improved tumor treatment efficacy. There was no enhancement in the B16 tumor treatment using cells secreting soluble receptors. Our data support the potential application of the blockade of TGF-β signaling in tumor-specific T cells for cancer immunotherapy.

B16 as a mouse model for human melanoma

This unit details protocols for in vivo models of subcutaneous growth and pulmonary metastases of B16 melanoma. Therapeutic approaches include the use of B16.GM-CSF and rVVmTRP-1 to induce autoimmune vitiligo and tumor protection. The induction and use of gp 100-specific therapeutic cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are discussed. Methods are also included for CTL induction, isolation and testing, CTL maintenance, and adoptive transfer. Support protocols detail the testing of mouse sera for presence of MDA-specific antibodies by immunoblotting and ELISA, respectively. Additional sections, including growing B16 melanoma, enumerating pulmonary metastases, and use of recombinant viruses for vaccination, are discussed together with safety concerns.

Mining the melanosome for tumor vaccine targets: P.polypeptide is a novel tumor-associated antigen

To identify novel, tumor-specific target antigens for vaccine development, we studied immune responses to P.polypeptide, an M(r) 110,000 integral melanosomal membrane protein associated with the Prader-Willi syndrome. Together with expressed sequence tag (EST) and serial analyses of gene expression (SAGE) library analyses, reverse transcription-PCR and Northern blotting verified that P.polypeptide expression was limited to melanoma and melanocytes. A single dominant epitope corresponding to positions 427-435 (IMLCLIAAV) was identified using allele-specific epitope forecasting combined with work in HLA-A*0201/K(b) transgenic mice. This epitope was then used to generate de novo human P.polypeptide-specific CD8+ T cells capable of recognizing P.polypeptide expressing human tumor cell lines in an HLA-A*0201-restricted fashion. Thus, P.polypeptide may be valuable in the creation of novel therapeutic anticancer vaccines.

Creating therapeutic cancer vaccines: notes from the battlefield

With the identification of tumor antigens and a knowledge of how to vaccinate against them, the field of tumor immunology faces new challenges. In this article, the authors argue that successful immunotherapies of the future will activate anti-tumor T cells without inducing their anergy or apoptotic death.

Identification of a CD11b(+)/Gr-1(+)/CD31(+) myeloid progenitor capable of activating or suppressing CD8(+) T cells

Apoptotic death of CD8(+) T cells can be induced by a population of inhibitory myeloid cells that are double positive for the CD11b and Gr-1 markers. These cells are responsible for the immunosuppression observed in pathologies as dissimilar as tumor growth and overwhelming infections, or after immunization with viruses. The appearance of a CD11b(+)/Gr-1(+) population of inhibitory macrophages (iMacs) could be attributed to high levels of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) in vivo. Deletion of iMacs in vitro or in vivo reversed the depression of CD8(+) T-cell function. We isolated iMacs from the spleens of immunocompromised mice and found that these cells were positive for CD31, ER-MP20 (Ly-6C), and ER-MP58, markers characteristic of granulocyte/monocyte precursors. Importantly, although iMacs retained their inhibitory properties when cultured in vitro in standard medium, suppressive functions could be modulated by cytokine exposure. Whereas culture with the cytokine interleukin 4 (IL-4) increased iMac inhibitory activity, these cells could be differentiated into a nonadherent population of fully mature and highly activated dendritic cells when cultured in the presence of IL-4 and GM-CSF. A common CD31(+)/CD11b(+)/Gr-1(+) progenitor can thus give rise to cells capable of either activating or inhibiting the function of CD8(+) T lymphocytes, depending on the cytokine milieu that prevails during antigen-presenting cell maturation. (Blood. 2000;96:3838-3846)

Building better vaccines: how apoptotic cell death can induce inflammation and activate innate and adaptive immunity

The immunological consequences of apoptosis have been hotly debated. Apoptosis was originally described as a set of cellular morphological changes that occur in the absence of inflammation but the term has been redefined on the basis of a set of conserved molecular events that include the activation of caspases. Though the apoptosis occurring during normal development is immunologically bland or even tolerizing, the apoptotic death after viral infection or after the ligation of Fas can trigger powerful innate and adaptive immune responses. The molecular machinery at the nexus of apoptosis and inflammation includes caspase-1 --an activator of IL-1beta and IL-18 - as well as the double-stranded-RNA-dependent protein kinase pathway and RNaseL pathway, which are key effectors of antiviral immunity. New proapoptotic vaccines induce immune responses that may be able to prevent or treat infectious disease and cancer.

Identification of CD4+ T cell epitopes from NY-ESO-1 presented by HLA-DR molecules

In previous studies, the shared cancer-testis Ag, NY-ESO-1, was demonstrated to be recognized by both Abs and CD8+ T cells. Gene expression of NY-ESO-1 was detected in many tumor types, including melanoma, breast, and lung cancers, but was not found in normal tissues, with the exception of testis. In this study, we describe the identification of MHC class II-restricted T cell epitopes from NY-ESO-1. Candidate CD4+ T cell peptides were first identified using HLA-DR4 transgenic mice immunized with the NY-ESO-1 protein. NY-ESO-1-specific CD4+ T cells were then generated from PBMC of a patient with melanoma stimulated with the candidate peptides in vitro. These CD4+ T cells recognized NY-ESO-1 peptides or protein pulsed on HLA-DR4+ EBV B cells, and also recognized tumor cells expressing HLA-DR4 and NY-ESO-1. A 10-mer peptide (VLLKEFTVSG) was recognized by CD4+ T cells. These studies provide new opportunities for developing more effective vaccine strategies by using tumor-specific CD4+ T cells. This approach may be applicable to the identification of CD4+ T cell epitopes from many known tumor Ags recognized by CD8+ T cells.

An autologous oral DNA vaccine protects against murine melanoma

We demonstrated that peripheral T cell tolerance toward murine melanoma self-antigens gp100 and TRP-2 can be broken by an autologous oral DNA vaccine containing the murine ubiquitin gene fused to minigenes encoding peptide epitopes gp100(25-33) and TRP-2(181-188). These epitopes contain dominant anchor residues for MHC class I antigen alleles H-2D(b) and H-2K(b), respectively. The DNA vaccine was delivered by oral gavage by using an attenuated strain of Salmonella typhimurium as carrier. Tumor-protective immunity was mediated by MHC class I antigen-restricted CD8(+) T cells that secreted T(H)1 cytokine IFN-gamma and induced tumor rejection and growth suppression after a lethal challenge with B16G3. 26 murine melanoma cells. Importantly, the protective immunity induced by this autologous DNA vaccine against murine melanoma cells was at least equal to that achieved through xenoimmunization with the human gp100(25-33) peptide, which differs in its three NH(2)-terminal amino acid residues from its murine counterpart and was previously reported to be clearly superior to an autologous vaccine in inducing protective immunity. The presence of ubiquitin upstream of the minigene proved to be essential for achieving this tumor-protective immunity, suggesting that effective antigen processing and presentation may make it possible to break peripheral T cell tolerance to a self-antigen. This vaccine design might prove useful for future rational designs of other recombinant DNA vaccines targeting tissue differentiation antigens expressed by tumors.

Not so Fas: Re-evaluating the mechanisms of immune privilege and tumor escape

Based on early studies, it was hypothesized that expression of Fas ligand (FasL) by tumor cells enabled them to counterattack the immune system, and that transplant rejection could be prevented by expressing FasL on transplanted organs. More recent studies have indicated that the notion of FasL as a mediator of immune privilege needed to be reconsidered, and taught a valuable lesson about making broad conclusions based on small amounts of data.

Identification of a MHC class II-restricted human gp100 epitope using DR4-IE transgenic mice

CD4+ T cells play a central role in the induction and persistence of CD8+ T cells in several models of autoimmune and infectious disease. To improve the efficacy of a synthetic peptide vaccine based on the self-Ag, gp100, we sought to provide Ag-specific T cell help. To identify a gp100 epitope restricted by the MHC class II allele with the highest prevalence in patients with malignant melanoma (HLA-DRB1*0401), we immunized mice transgenic for a chimeric human-mouse class II molecule (DR4-IE) with recombinant human gp100 protein. We then searched for the induction of CD4+ T cell reactivity using candidate epitopes predicted to bind to DRB1*0401 by a computer-assisted algorithm. Of the 21 peptides forecasted to bind most avidly, murine CD4+ T cells recognized the epitope (human gp10044-59, WNRQLYPEWTEAQRLD) that was predicted to bind best. Interestingly, the mouse helper T cells also recognized human melanoma cells expressing DRB1*0401. To evaluate whether human CD4+ T cells could be generated from the peripheral blood of patients with melanoma, we used the synthetic peptide h-gp10044-59 to sensitize lymphocytes ex vivo. Resultant human CD4+ T cells specifically recognized melanoma, as measured by tumor cytolysis and the specific release of cytokines and chemokines. HLA class II transgenic mice may be useful in the identification of helper epitopes derived from Ags of potentially great clinical utility.

Antitumor efficacy of tumor-antigen-encoding recombinant poxvirus immunization in Dunning rat prostate cancer: implications for clinical genetic vaccine development

One potential use for prostate-cancer-associated genes discovered through ongoing genetics studies entails the construction of virus- or plasmid-based recombinant vector vaccines encoding these new tumor-associated antigens (TAA) to induce TAA-specific immune responses for the prevention or therapy of prostate cancer. Clinical trials evaluating prototypes of such recombinant vaccines are under way. TAA-encoding recombinant vector vaccines, however, have not previously been evaluated in a prostate-cancer animal model. For assessment of the potential susceptibility of prostate cancer to genetic immunization strategies using TAA-encoding recombinant vectors, the antitumor efficacy of a model recombinant viral vector encoding a TAA was evaluated in rat Dunning prostate cancer. Recombinant vaccinia was chosen as a prototype virus vector encoding a TAA for these studies, and beta-galactosidase was chosen as a model target TAA. Dunning AT-2 cells were transduced with a retroviral vector to express beta-galactosidase, and the susceptibility of tumorigenic AT-2-lacZ cells to immunization with vaccinia-lacZ was measured using protection studies in Copenhagen and nu/nu rats. Stably transduced AT-2-lacZ cells expressing beta-galactosidase as measured by enzymatic substrate-based assays were found to retain their tumorigenicity in vivo despite abundant expression of rat major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I. Immunization with model TAA-encoding recombinant vaccinia-lacZ conferred significant protection against subsequent growth of AT-2-lacZ cells in vivo (P = 0.01); however, the efficacy of such immunization was markedly dependent on the volume of tumor challenge. The antitumor efficacy of TAA-encoding recombinant vaccinia immunization was abrogated in nu/nu rats, suggesting a T-cell-dependent mechanism of activity. These studies suggest that prostate cancer may be a suitable target for immunization strategies using TAA-encoding recombinant vectors. Such immunization strategies may be more effective in settings of minimal cancer burden.

Antiangiogenic gene therapy of cancer utilizing a recombinant adenovirus to elevate systemic endostatin levels in mice

Gene therapy represents a possible alternative to the chronic delivery of recombinant antiangiogenic proteins to cancer patients. Inducing normal host tissues to produce high circulating levels of these proteins may be more effective than targeting antiangiogenic genes to tumor tissue specifically. Previously reported gene therapy approaches in mice have achieved peak circulating endostatin levels of 8-33 ng/ml. Here we report plasma endostatin levels of 1770 ng/ml after administration of a recombinant adenovirus. Growth of MC38 adenocarcinoma, which is relatively resistant to adenoviral infection, was inhibited by 40%. These findings encourage gene delivery approaches that use the host as a "factory" to produce high circulating levels of antiangiogenic agents.

The future of interleukin-2: enhancing therapeutic anticancer vaccines

PURPOSE

The purpose of our efforts is to trigger the immune destruction of established cancer. Interleukin (IL)-2 can mediate the regression of tumors in patients with melanoma and renal cell carcinoma. In animal models, the antitumor effects of IL-2 are mediated by T lymphocytes. Stimulation with specific antigen can enhance the ability of T cells to respond to IL-2 by triggering the rapid upregulation of the high-affinity IL-2 receptor. We are seeking to design recombinant and synthetic vaccines capable of preferentially priming T cells with specificity for tumor cells.

METHODS

The antitumor activity of experimental vaccines is being studied preclinically using recently developed murine models that employ the mouse homologues of human tumor-associated antigens. Once the most effective experimental vaccines are optimized in experimental animals, clinical trials can be conducted. Vaccines are being evaluated for their ability to mediate the regression of established tumors, and a variety of immunologic correlates are being measured.

RESULTS

In animal models, vaccines based on molecularly defined tumor-associated antigens expressed in viral vectors or delivered as "naked" DNA stimulate the expansion of CD4+ and CD8+ tumor-specific T lymphocytes. Coadministration of IL-2 with these vaccines dramatically enhances their ability to mediate the regression of established cancer. In the clinic, treatment of melanoma patients with peptide vaccine and IL-2 resulted in objective responses in approximately 40% of patients, a response rate more than twice that typically achieved with IL-2 alone. Paradoxically, tumor-specific CD8+ T-cell levels were not increased in these patients.

CONCLUSION

The addition of recombinant and synthetic cancer vaccines to a regimen of IL-2 can result in improved antitumor responses in both animal models and melanoma patients. Vaccine-primed, tumor-specific T cells may preferentially proliferate upon administration of IL-2. The apparent lack of increase in CD8+ T-cell numbers in this setting suggests that the vaccine-primed T cells functionally disappear after a transient period of activation. Preventing the disappearance of activated T cells upon IL-2 administration-for example, by blocking proapoptotic signals-may enhance the therapeutic effectiveness of anticancer vaccines.

Genetic vaccination with "self" tyrosinase-related protein 2 causes melanoma eradication but not vitiligo

"Self" melanocyte differentiation antigens are potential targets for specific melanoma immunotherapy. Vaccination against murine tyrosinase-related protein (TRP)-1/gp75 was shown recently to cause melanoma rejection, which was accompanied by autoimmune skin depigmentation (vitiligo). To further explore the linkage between immunotherapy and autoimmunity, we studied the response to vaccination with a related antigen, TRP-2. i.m. inoculation of plasmid DNA encoding murine trp-2 elicited antigen-specific CTLs that recognized the B16 mouse melanoma and protected the mice from challenge with tumor cells. Furthermore, mice bearing established s.c. B16 melanomas rejected the tumor upon vaccination with a recombinant vaccinia virus encoding trp-2. Depletion experiments showed that CD8+ lymphocytes and natural killer cells were crucial for the antitumor activity of the trp-2-encoding vaccines. Mice that rejected the tumor did not develop generalized vitiligo, indicating that protective immunity can be achieved in the absence of widespread autoimmune aggression.

Cutting edge: CD4+ T cell control of CD8+ T cell reactivity to a model tumor antigen

Neoantigens resulting from the inherent genomic instability of tumor cells generally do not trigger immune recognition. Similarly, transfection of tumors with model Ags often fails to elicit CD8+ T cell responses or alter a tumor's growth rate or lethality. We report here that the adoptive transfer of activated Th1-type CD4+ T cells specific for a model tumor Ag results in the de novo generation of CD8+ T cells with specificity to that Ag and concomitant tumor destruction. The anti-tumor effects of the CD4+ T cells required the presence of both MHC class I and class II on host cells, as evidenced by experiments in knockout mice, suggesting that CD4+ T cells enhanced the ability of host APC to activate endogenous CD8+ T cells. These results indicate that the apparent inability of tumor cells expressing highly immunogenic epitopes to activate tumor-specific CD8+ T cells can be altered by activated CD4+ T cells.

Enhancement of tumor-specific immune response with plasmid DNA replicon vectors

To enhance the immunogenicity of nucleic acid vaccines, we used plasmid DNA vectors that contained replicons derived from the prototype alphavirus, Sindbis, and another alphavirus, Semliki Forest virus. When transfected into cells or injected directly into animal muscle, these plasmids launch a self-replicating RNA vector (replicon) which in turn directs the expression of a model tumor antigen. Immunization with plasmid DNA replicons elicited immune responses at doses 100 to 1000-fold lower than conventional DNA plasmids and effectively treated mice bearing an experimental tumor expressing the model antigen. Significantly, replicon-based DNA plasmids did not produce a greater quantity of antigen; instead, antigen production differed qualitatively. Plasmid DNA replicons mediated antigen production that was homogeneous in all transfected cells and associated with the apoptotic death of the host cells. Because of their safety and efficacy, plasmid DNA replicons may be useful in the development of recombinant vaccines for infectious diseases and cancer.

The promise of nucleic acid vaccines

Establishing the effective use of 'naked' nucleic acids as vaccines would undoubtedly be one of the most important advances in the history of vaccinology. While nucleic acids show much promise for use as vaccine vectors in experimental animals, not a single naked nucleic acid vector has been approved for use in humans. Indeed, data from human clinical trials is scant: nucleic acid vaccines have not been clearly demonstrated to have any convincing efficacy in the prevention or treatment of infectious disease or cancer. Here we illustrate possible mechanisms underlying effective nucleic acid vaccination. We focus on progress that has been made in the improvement of their function. Additionally, we identify promising new strategies and try to forecast future developments that could lead to the real success of nucleic acid vaccines in the prevention and treatment of human disease.

Autoimmunity and the immunotherapy of cancer: targeting the "self" to destroy the "other"

It is increasingly clear that immunity to "self"-antigens may result in tumor destruction in mouse and man. But which antigens should be targeted with therapeutic cancer vaccines? In the case of melanoma, recognition of melanocyte differentiation antigens (MDA) can be associated with autoimmune depigmentation (vitiligo). We propose that intersection of protein transport to melanosomes and endosomes allows for the loading of MDA-derived peptides on MHC class II molecules, resulting in the activation of MDA-specific CD4+ "helper" T cells that aid the induction of melanoma-specific CD8+ T cells. Thus, the immunogenicity of MDA may be a consequence of their unique cell biology. Studies of MDA-based vaccines can provide new insight into the development of more effective cancer vaccines.

DNA and RNA-based vaccines: principles, progress and prospects

DNA vaccines were introduced less than a decade ago but have already been applied to a wide range of infectious and malignant diseases. Here we review the current understanding of the mechanisms underlying the activities of these new vaccines. We focus on recent strategies designed to enhance their function including the use of immunostimulatory (CpG) sequences, dendritic cells (DC), co-stimulatory molecules and cytokine- and chemokine-adjuvants. Although genetic vaccines have been significantly improved, they may not be sufficiently immunogenic for the therapeutic vaccination of patients with infectious diseases or cancer in clinical trials. One promising approach aimed at dramatically increasing the immunogenicity of genetic vaccines involves making them 'self-replicating'. This can be accomplished by using a gene encoding RNA replicase, a polyprotein derived from alphaviruses, such as Sindbis virus. Replicase-containing RNA vectors are significantly more immunogenic than conventional plasmids, immunizing mice at doses as low as 0.1 microg of nucleic acid injected once intramuscularly. Cells transfected with 'self-replicating' vectors briefly produce large amounts of antigen before undergoing apoptotic death. This death is a likely result of requisite double-stranded (ds) RNA intermediates, which also have been shown to super-activate DC. Thus, the enhanced immunogenicity of 'self-replicating' genetic vaccines may be a result of the production of pro-inflammatory dsRNA, which mimics an RNA-virus infection of host cells.

The antiviral enzymes PKR and RNase L suppress gene expression from viral and non-viral based vectors

Expression of transfected genes is shown to be suppressed by two intracellular enzymes, RNase L and protein kinase PKR, which function in interferon-treated cells to restrict viral replication. RNase L(-/-) or PKR(-/-) murine embryonic fibroblasts produced enhanced levels of protein from transfected genes compared with wild-type cells. Increased expression of exogenous genes in RNase L(-/-) cells correlated with elevated levels of mRNA and thus appeared to be due to enhanced mRNA stability. Plasmid encoding adenovirus VA RNAs was able to further enhance accumulation of the exogenous gene transcript and protein, even in cells lacking PKR. In contrast to the increased expression of transfected genes in cells lacking RNase L or PKR, expression of endogenous host genes was unaffected by the absence of these enzymes. In addition, a dominant-negative PKR mutant improved expression from a conventional plasmid vector and from a Semliki Forest virus derived, self-replicating vector. These results indicate that viral infections and transfections produce similar stress responses in mammalian cells and suggest strategies for selectively increasing expression of exogenous genes.

Interleukin-10 enhances the therapeutic effectiveness of a recombinant poxvirus-based vaccine in an experimental murine tumor model

Interleukin-10 (IL-10) has a wide range of in vivo biological activities and is a key regulatory cytokine of immune-mediated inflammation. The authors found that murine IL-10 given 12 hours after a recombinant vaccinia virus (rVV) containing the LacZ gene significantly enhanced the treatment of mice bearing 3-day-old pulmonary metastases expressing beta-galactosidase. Because IL-10 has been shown to inhibit the functions of key elements of both innate and acquired immune responses, the authors hypothesized that IL-10 might act by inhibiting clearance of the rVV, thus prolonging exposure to the experimental antigen. However, evidence that IL-10 was not acting primarily through such negative regulatory mechanisms included the following: (a) IL-10 also enhanced the therapeutic effectiveness of a recombinant fowlpox virus, which cannot replicate in mammalian cells; (b) Titers of rVV in immunized mice were lower, not higher; and (c) Although IL-10 did not alter levels of anti-vaccinia anti-bodies or natural killer cell activity, rVV-primed mice treated with IL-10 had enhanced vaccinia-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte activity. Thus, IL-10 enhanced the function of a recombinant poxvirus-based anti-cancer vaccine and may represent a potential adjuvant in the vaccination against human cancers using recombinant poxvirus-based vaccines.

Impact of cytokine administration on the generation of antitumor reactivity in patients with metastatic melanoma receiving a peptide vaccine

Patients with metastatic melanoma were immunized with an immunodominant peptide derived from the gp100 melanoma-melanocyte differentiation Ag that was modified to increase binding to HLA-A+0201. A total of 10 of 11 patients who received the g209-2M peptide alone developed precursors reactive with the native g209 peptide, compared with only 5 of 16 patients who received g209-2M peptide plus IL-2 (p2 = 0.005). Peptide reactivity closely correlated with the recognition of HLA-A+0201 melanoma cells (p < 0. 001). The decrease in immune reactivity when peptide was administered with IL-2 appeared specific for the immunizing peptide, since reactivity to an influenza peptide resulting from prior exposure was not affected. Preexisting antitumor precursors did not decrease when peptide plus IL-2 was administered. The administration of GM-CSF or IL-12 also resulted in a decrease in circulating precursors compared with the administration of peptide alone, though not as great a decrease as that seen with IL-2. Immunization with peptide plus IL-2 did, however, appear to have clinical impact since 6 of the 16 patients (38%) that received peptide plus IL-2 had objective cancer regressions. It thus appeared possible that immunization with peptide plus IL-2 resulted in sequestering or apoptotic destruction of newly activated immune cells at the tumor site. These represent the first detailed studies of the impact of immunization with tumor peptides in conjunction with a variety of cytokines in patients with metastatic cancer.

Cancer therapy using a self-replicating RNA vaccine

'Naked' nucleic acid vaccines are potentially useful candidates for the treatment of patients with cancer, but their clinical efficacy has yet to be demonstrated. We sought to enhance the immunogenicity of a nucleic acid vaccine by making it 'self-replicating'. We accomplished this by using a gene encoding an RNA replicase polyprotein derived from the Semliki forest virus, in combination with a model antigen. A single intramuscular injection of a self-replicating RNA immunogen elicited antigen-specific antibody and CD8+ T-cell responses at doses as low as 0.1 microg. Pre-immunization with a self-replicating RNA vector protected mice from tumor challenge, and therapeutic immunization prolonged the survival of mice with established tumors. The self-replicating RNA vectors did not mediate the production of substantially more model antigen than a conventional DNA vaccine did in vitro. However, the enhanced efficacy in vivo correlated with a caspase-dependent apoptotic death in transfected cells. This death facilitated the uptake of apoptotic cells by dendritic cells, providing a potential mechanism for enhanced immunogenicity. Naked, non-infectious, self-replicating RNA may be an excellent candidate for the development of new cancer vaccines.

Recombinant virus vaccination against "self" antigens using anchor-fixed immunogens

To study the induction of anti-"self" CD8+ T-cell reactivity against the tumor antigen gp100, we used a mouse transgenic for a chimeric HLA-A*0201/H-2 Kb molecule (A2/Kb). We immunized the mice with a recombinant vaccinia virus encoding a form of gp100 that had been modified at position 210 (from a threonine to a methionine) to increase epitope binding to the restricting class I molecule. Immunogens containing the "anchor-fixed" modification elicited anti-self CD8+ T cells specific for the wild-type gp100(209-217) peptide pulsed onto target cells. More important, these cells specifically recognized the naturally presented epitope on the surface of an A2/Kb-expressing murine melanoma, B16. These data indicate that anchor-fixing epitopes could enhance the function of recombinant virus-based immunogens.

Vaccination with a recombinant vaccinia virus encoding a "self" antigen induces autoimmune vitiligo and tumor cell destruction in mice: requirement for CD4(+) T lymphocytes

Many human and mouse tumor antigens are normal, nonmutated tissue differentiation antigens. Consequently, immunization with these "self" antigens could induce autoimmunity. When we tried to induce immune responses to five mouse melanocyte differentiation antigens, gp100, MART-1, tyrosinase, and tyrosinase-related proteins (TRP) 1 and TRP-2, we observed striking depigmentation and melanocyte destruction only in the skin of mice inoculated with a vaccinia virus encoding mouse TRP-1. These mice rejected a lethal challenge of B16 melanoma, indicating the immune response against TRP-1 could destroy both normal and malignant melanocytes. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for TRP-1 could not be detected in depigmented mice, but high titers of IgG anti-TRP-1 antibodies were present. Experiments with knockout mice revealed an absolute dependence on major histocompatibility complex class II, but not major histocompatibility complex class I, for the induction of both vitiligo and tumor protection. Together, these results suggest that the deliberate induction of self-reactivity using a recombinant viral vector can lead to tumor destruction, and that in this model, CD4(+) T lymphocytes are an integral part of this process. Vaccine strategies targeting tissue differentiation antigens may be valuable in cancers arising from nonessential cells and organs such as melanocytes, prostate, testis, breast, and ovary.

Fas-mediated suicide of tumor-reactive T cells following activation by specific tumor: selective rescue by caspase inhibition

CD8+ T lymphocytes that specifically recognize tumor cells can be isolated and expanded ex vivo. While the lytic properties of these cells have been well described, their fate upon encounter with cognate tumor is not known. We performed reverse 51Cr release assays in which the lymphocyte effectors rather than the tumor cell targets were radioactively labeled. We found that melanoma tumor cells caused the apoptotic death of tumor-specific T cells only upon specific MHC class I-restricted recognition. This death was entirely blockable by the addition of an Ab directed against the Fas death receptor (APO-1, CD95). Contrary to the prevailing view that tumor cells cause the death of anti-tumor T cells by expressing Fas ligand (FasL), our data suggested that FasL was instead expressed by T lymphocytes upon activation. While the tumor cells did not express FasL by any measure (including RT-PCR), functional FasL (as well as FasL mRNA) was consistently found on activated anti-tumor T cells. We could successfully block the activation-induced cell death with z-VAD-fmk, a tripeptide inhibitor of IL-1 beta-converting enzyme homologues, or with anti-Fas mAbs. Most importantly, these interventions did not inhibit T cell recognition as measured by IFN-gamma release, nor did they adversely affect the specific lysis of tumor cell targets. These results imply that Fas-mediated activation-induced cell death could be a limiting factor in the in vivo efficacy of adoptive transfer of class I-restricted CD8+ T cells and provide a means of potentially enhancing their growth in vitro as well as their function in vivo.

Induction of tumor antigen-specific immunity in vivo by a novel vaccinia vector encoding safety-modified simian virus 40 T antigen

BACKGROUND

Evidence that simian virus 40 (SV40) is associated with human mesotheliomas, osteosarcomas, and brain tumors suggests that a recombinant vaccine directed against lethal cancers expressing SV40 T antigen (Tag) could have clinical utility. To address this potential need, we designed a novel vaccinia virus construct that encodes an SV40 Tag in which oncogenic domains were excluded and immunogenic domains were preserved. We named this recombinant construct vaccinia-encoding safety-modified SV40 Tag (vac-mTag).

METHODS

Purified vac-mTag was characterized by DNA sequencing, reverse transcription-coupled polymerase chain reaction, western blot analysis, and immunocytochemical techniques. Induction of Tag-specific immunity was examined by cytolytic T-cell assays, and the efficacy of vac-mTag in protecting animals against Tag-expressing tumors and in treating pre-established microscopic tumors was evaluated in vac-mTag-immunized BALB/c mice.

RESULTS

The immune response elicited by vac-mTag in C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice included an SV40 Tag-specific cytolytic T-lymphocyte activity against syngeneic (identical genetic background) SV40 Tag-expressing tumor targets. Immunization of mice with a single dose of vac-mTag resulted in potent protection against subsequent challenge with a lethal mouse cancer expressing SV40 Tag. In addition, single-dose vac-mTag immunization coadministered with interleukin 2 produced a possible therapeutic effect against a preadministered microscopic (but lethal) burden of Tag-expressing tumor cells in vivo.

CONCLUSION

vac-mTag induces an effective immune response in mice that is specific for a tumor-associated antigen. This response protects against a lethal tumor challenge and results in a possible therapeutic effect against Tag-expressing tumors in vivo. Thus, vac-mTag provides a new avenue for the development of therapies for human cancers thought to be associated with SV40.

Human melanoma cells do not express Fas (Apo-1/CD95) ligand

A recent report described the expression of Fas ligand (FasL) by melanoma cells as an important mechanism involved in the immune evasion by tumors [M. Hahne et al., Science (Washington DC), 274: 1363-1366, 1996]. To investigate the expression of FasL by melanomas, we screened a panel of early-passage cell lines by functional assay and reverse transcriptase-PCR. Using conditions designed to replicate those in the original report, we did not find functional FasL on any of the 19 human melanoma lines established at the National Cancer Institute. Furthermore, we additionally evaluated our melanoma lines using reverse transcriptase-PCR and found that 0 of the 26 human melanoma cell lines expressed FasL mRNA. FasL mRNA was abundantly expressed by anti-melanoma T-cell lines after activation. These data do not support a role for FasL expression in the escape of melanoma cells from immune destruction.

Developing recombinant and synthetic vaccines for the treatment of melanoma

To develop new vaccines for the treatment of patients with cancer, target antigens presented on tumor cell surfaces have been cloned. Many of these antigens are non-mutated differentiation antigens and are expressed by virtually all melanomas, making them attractive components for a widely efficacious melanoma vaccine. These antigens are also expressed by melanocytes, however, and are likely to be subject to immune tolerance. A central challenge for tumor immunologists has thus been the breaking of tolerance to cancer antigens. We review recent clinical trials using experimental cancer vaccines, including recent evidence that therapeutic vaccines can induce objective responses in patients with metastatic malignant melanoma. We focus on the foundations of these approaches in new experimental animal models designed to test novel vaccines and report on what these new models predict for the future development of therapeutic vaccines for cancer.

Construction and characterization of a triple-recombinant vaccinia virus encoding B7-1, interleukin 12, and a model tumor antigen

BACKGROUND

Construction of recombinant viruses that can serve as vaccines for the treatment of experimental murine tumors has recently been achieved. The cooperative effects of immune system modulators, including cytokines such as interleukin 12 (IL-12) and costimulatory molecules such as B7-1, may be necessary for activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Thus, we have explored the feasibility and the efficacy of inclusion of these immunomodulatory molecules in recombinant virus vaccines in an experimental antitumor model in mice that uses Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase as a target antigen.

METHODS

We developed a "cassette" system in which three loci of the vaccinia virus genome were used for homologous recombination. A variety of recombinant vaccinia viruses were constructed, including one virus, vB7/beta/IL-12, that contains the following five transgenes: murine B7-1, murine IL-12 subunit p35, murine IL-12 subunit p40, E. coli lacZ (encodes beta-galactosidase, the model antigen), and E. coli gpt (xanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase, a selection gene). The effects of the recombinant viruses on lung metastases and survival were tested in animals that had been given an intravenous injection of beta-galactosidase-expressing murine colon carcinoma cells 3 days before they received the recombinant virus by intravenous inoculation.

RESULTS

Expression of functional B7-1 and IL-12 by virally infected cells was demonstrated in vitro. Lung tumor nodules (i.e., metastases) were reduced in mice by more than 95% after treatment with the virus vB7/beta/IL-12; a further reduction in lung tumor nodules was observed when exogenous IL-12 was also given. Greatest survival of tumor-bearing mice was observed in those treated with viruses encoding beta-galactosidase and B7-1 plus exogenous IL-12.

CONCLUSION

This study shows the feasibility of constructing vaccinia viruses that express tumor antigens and multiple immune cofactors to create unique immunologic microenvironments that can modulate immune responses to cancer.

Immunizing patients with metastatic melanoma using recombinant adenoviruses encoding MART-1 or gp100 melanoma antigens

BACKGROUND

The characterization of the genes encoding melanoma-associated antigens MART-1 or gp100, recognized by T cells, has opened new possibilities for the development of immunization strategies for patients with metastatic melanoma. With the use of recombinant adenoviruses expressing either MART-1 or gp100 to immunize patients with metastatic melanoma, we evaluated the safety, immunologic, and potential therapeutic aspects of these immunizations.

METHODS

In phase I studies, 54 patients received escalating doses (between 10(7) and 10(11) plaque-forming units) of recombinant adenovirus encoding either MART-1 or gp100 melanoma antigen administered either alone or followed by the administration of interleukin 2 (IL-2). The immunologic impact of these immunizations on the development of cellular and antibody reactivity was assayed.

RESULTS

Recombinant adenoviruses expressing MART-1 or gp100 were safely administered. One of 16 patients with metastatic melanoma receiving the recombinant adenovirus MART-1 alone experienced a complete response. Other patients achieved objective responses, but they had received IL-2 along with an adenovirus, and their responses could be attributed to the cytokine. Immunologic assays showed no consistent immunization to the MART-1 or gp100 transgenes expressed by the recombinant adenoviruses. High levels of neutralizing antibody were found in the pretreatment sera of the patients.

CONCLUSIONS

High doses of recombinant adenoviruses could be safely administered to cancer patients. High levels of neutralizing antibody present in patients' sera prior to treatment may have impaired the ability of these viruses to immunize patients against melanoma antigens.

Apoptotic death of CD8+ T lymphocytes after immunization: induction of a suppressive population of Mac-1+/Gr-1+ cells

Following an infection or immunization, a primary CD8+ T cell response generally rises then falls rapidly before giving rise to a "memory" response. When we immunized mice with recombinant viral immunogens optimized to enhance the lytic capability of CD8+ T cells, we measured a profound depression in Ag-specific effector function after early restimulation. Indeed, a "mirror image" cytolytic capability was observed: the most powerful immunogens, as measured by cytolytic capacity 6 days after immunization, elicited the weakest secondary immune response when evaluated following an additional 6 days after restimulation. To understand the mechanism of this suppression, we examined the fate of splenocytes immunized with a vaccinia virus encoding Ag and IL-2 then restimulated ex vivo. We found that these splenocytes underwent an apoptotic cell death, upon early restimulation, that was not dependent on the engagement of the FasR (CD95). Unlike previously described mechanisms of "propriocidal cell death" and "clonal exhaustion," the cell death we observed was not an inherent property of the CD8+ T cells but rather was due to a population of splenocytes that stained positive for both the Mac-1 and Gr-1 surface markers. Deletion of these cells in vitro or in vivo completely abrogated the observed suppression of cytolytic reactivity of Ag-specific CD8+ T cells. These observations could account for the apparent absence of Ag-specific immune responses after some current vaccination regimens employing powerful immunogens. Finally, our results may shed new light on a mechanism for the suppression of CD8+ T cell responses and its effect on vaccine efficacy and on immune memory.

CD40 ligand/trimer DNA enhances both humoral and cellular immune responses and induces protective immunity to infectious and tumor challenge

CD40/CD40 ligand interactions have a central role in the induction of both humoral and cellular immunity. In this study, we examined whether a plasmid expressing CD40 ligand/trimer (CD40LT) could enhance immune responses in vivo. BALB/c mice were injected with plasmid expressing beta-galactosidase DNA with or without CD40LT DNA or IL-12 DNA, and immune responses were assessed. Mice vaccinated with beta-gal DNA plus CD40LT DNA or IL-12 DNA had a striking increase in Ag-specific production of IFN-gamma, cytolytic T cell activity, and IgG2a Ab. The mechanism by which CD40LT DNA enhanced these responses was further assessed by treating vaccinated mice with anti-IL-12 mAb or CTLA-4 Ig (CTLA4Ig). Production of IFN-gamma and CTL activity was abrogated by these treatments, suggesting that CD40LT DNA was mediating its effects on IFN-gamma and CTL activity through induction of IL-12 and enhancement of B7 expression, respectively. Physiologic relevance for the ability of CD40LT DNA to enhance immune responses by the aforementioned pathways was shown in two in vivo models. First, with regard to CTL activity, mice vaccinated with CD40LT DNA did not develop metastatic tumor following challenge with lethal dose of tumor. Moreover, in a mouse model requiring IL-12-dependent production of IFN-gamma, mice vaccinated with soluble Leishmania Ag and CD40LT DNA were able to control infection with Leishmania major. These data suggest that CD40LT DNA could be a useful vaccine adjuvant for diseases requiring cellular and/or humoral immunity.

T cell-tumor cell: a fatal interaction?

Fas (Apo-1/CD95) is a cell-surface protein that is responsible for initiating a cascade of proteases (caspases) culminating in apoptotic cell death in a variety of cell types. The function of the Fas/FasL system in the dampening of immune responses to infectious agents through the autocrine deletion of activated T cells has been well documented. More recently, it has been proposed that tumor cells express FasL, presumably to avoid immune detection. In this review, we focus on the role of the interaction of Fas and FasL in the modulation of antitumor responses. We critically examine the evidence that FasL is expressed by tumor cells and explore alternative explanations for the observed phenomena in vitro and in vivo. By reviewing data that we have generated in our laboratory as well as reports from the literature, we will argue that the Fas/FasL system is a generalized mechanism used in an autocrine fashion to regulate cell survival and expansion in response to environmental and cellular cues. We propose that FasL expression by tumor cells, when present, is indicative of a perturbed balance in the control of proliferation while "immune privilege" is established by "suicide" of activated antitumor T cells, a form of activation-induced cell death.

Predominant role for directly transfected dendritic cells in antigen presentation to CD8+ T cells after gene gun immunization

Cutaneous gene (DNA) bombardment results in substantial expression of the encoded antigen in the epidermal layer as well as detectable expression in dendritic cells (DC) in draining lymph nodes (LNs). Under these conditions, two possible modes of DC antigen presentation to naive CD8+ T cells might exist: (a) presentation directly by gene-transfected DC trafficking to local lymph nodes, and (b) cross-presentation by untransfected DC of antigen released from or associated with transfected epidermal cells. The relative contributions of these distinct modes of antigen presentation to priming for cytotoxic T cell (CTL) responses have not been clearly established. Here we show that LN cells directly expressing the DNA-encoded antigen are rare; 24 h after five abdominal skin bombardments, the number of these cells does not exceed 50-100 cells in an individual draining LN. However, over this same time period, the total number of CD11c+ DC increases more than twofold, by an average of 20,000-30,000 DC per major draining node. This augmentation is due to gold bombardment and is independent of the presence of plasmid DNA. Most antigen-bearing cells in the LNs draining the site of DNA delivery appear to be DC and can be depleted by antibodies to an intact surface protein encoded by cotransfected DNA. This finding of predominant antigen presentation by directly transfected cells is also consistent with data from studies on cotransfection with antigen and CD86-encoding DNA, showing that priming of anti-mutant influenza nucleoprotein CTLs with a single immunization is dependent upon coexpression of the DNAs encoding nucleoprotein and B7.2 in the same cells. These observations provide insight into the relative roles of direct gene expression and cross-presentation in CD8+ T cell priming using gene gun immunization, and indicate that augmentation of direct DC gene expression may enhance such priming.

gp100/pmel 17 is a murine tumor rejection antigen: induction of "self"-reactive, tumoricidal T cells using high-affinity, altered peptide ligand

Many tumor-associated antigens are nonmutated, poorly immunogenic tissue differentiation antigens. Their weak immunogenicity may be due to "self"-tolerance. To induce autoreactive T cells, we studied immune responses to gp100/pmel 17, an antigen naturally expressed by both normal melanocytes and melanoma cells. Although a recombinant vaccinia virus (rVV) encoding the mouse homologue of gp100 was nonimmunogenic, immunization of normal C57BL/6 mice with the rVV encoding the human gp100 elicited a specific CD8(+) T cell response. These lymphocytes were cross-reactive with mgp100 in vitro and treated established B16 melanoma upon adoptive transfer. To understand the mechanism of the greater immunogenicity of the human version of gp100, we characterized a 9-amino acid (AA) epitope, restricted by H-2Db, that was recognized by the T cells. The ability to induce specific T cells with human but not mouse gp100 resulted from differences within the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted epitope and not from differences elsewhere in the molecule, as was evidenced by experiments in which mice were immunized with rVV containing minigenes encoding these epitopes. Although the human (hgp10025-33) and mouse (mgp10025-33) epitopes were homologous, differences in the three NH2-terminal AAs resulted in a 2-log increase in the ability of the human peptide to stabilize "empty" Db on RMA-S cells and a 3-log increase in its ability to trigger interferon gamma release by T cells. Thus, the fortuitous existence of a peptide homologue with significantly greater avidity for MHC class I resulted in the generation of self-reactive T cells. High-affinity, altered peptide ligands might be useful in the rational design of recombinant and synthetic vaccines that target tissue differentiation antigens expressed by tumors.

Immunologic and therapeutic evaluation of a synthetic peptide vaccine for the treatment of patients with metastatic melanoma

The cloning of the genes encoding cancer antigens has opened new possibilities for the treatment of patients with cancer. In this study, immunodominant peptides from the gp100 melanoma-associated antigen were identified, and a synthetic peptide, designed to increase binding to HLA-A2 molecules, was used as a cancer vaccine to treat patients with metastatic melanoma. On the basis of immunologic assays, 91% of patients could be successfully immunized with this synthetic peptide, and 13 of 31 patients (42%) receiving the peptide vaccine plus IL-2 had objective cancer responses, and four additional patients had mixed or minor responses. Synthetic peptide vaccines based on the genes encoding cancer antigens hold promise for the development of novel cancer immunotherapies.

Natural killer cell lines kill autologous beta2-microglobulin-deficient melanoma cells: implications for cancer immunotherapy

Cancer vaccines used to generate specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes are not effective against tumor cells that have lost or suppressed expression of their class I major histocompatibility complex proteins. This loss is common in some cancers and particularly in metastatic lesions. We show that beta2-microglobulin-deficient class I-negative melanoma variants derived from patients undergoing specific T cell therapy are lysed by heterologous as well as autologous natural killer (NK) lines and clones, but not by specific T cells. Moreover, the minor NK cell fraction but not the major T cell fraction derived from heterologous lymphokine activated killer cells kills those tumor cell lines. ICAM-1 expression by the different class I protein deficient tumors was correlated with their sensitivity to lysis by NK cells. Adoptive autologous NK therapy may be an important supplement to consider in the design of new cancer immunotherapies.

Enhancing efficacy of recombinant anticancer vaccines with prime/boost regimens that use two different vectors

BACKGROUND

The identification of tumor-associated antigens and the cloning of DNA sequences encoding them have enabled the development of anticancer vaccines. Such vaccines target tumors by stimulating an immune response against the antigens. One method of vaccination involves the delivery of antigen-encoding DNA sequences, and a number of recombinant vectors have been used for this purpose. To optimize the efficacy of recombinant vaccines, we compared primary and booster treatment regimens that used a single vector (i.e., homologous boosting) with regimens that used two different vectors (i.e., heterologous boosting).

METHODS

Pulmonary tumors (experimental metastases) were induced in BALB/c mice inoculated with CT26.CL25 murine colon carcinoma cells, which express recombinant bacterial beta-galactosidase (the model antigen). Protocols for subsequent vaccination used three vectors that encoded beta-galactosidase--vaccinia (cowpox) virus, fowlpox virus, naked bacterial plasmid DNA. Mouse survival was evaluated in conjunction with antibody and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses to beta-galactosidase.

RESULTS

Heterologous boosting resulted in significantly longer mouse survival than homologous boosting (all P<.0001, two-sided). Potent antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes were generated following heterologous boosting with poxvirus vectors. This response was not observed with any of the homologous boosting regimens. Mice primed with recombinant poxvirus vectors generated highly specific antibodies against viral proteins.

CONCLUSIONS

The poor efficacy of homologous boosting regimens with viral vectors was probably a consequence of the induction of a strong antiviral antibody response. Heterologous boosting augmented antitumor immunity by generating a strong antigen-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response. These data suggest that heterologous boosting strategies may be useful in increasing the efficacy of recombinant DNA anticancer vaccines that have now entered clinical trials.

Dendritic cells infected with poxviruses encoding MART-1/Melan A sensitize T lymphocytes in vitro

Dendritic cells (DC) are potent professional antigen-presenting cells that can activate naive T lymphocytes and initiate cellular immune responses. As adjuvants, DC may be useful in enhancing the immunogenicity of tumor antigens and mediating tumor regression. Endogenous expression of antigen by DC offers the potential advantage of allowing prolonged constitutive presentation of endogenously processed epitopes and exploitation of multiple restriction elements for the presentation of the same antigen. In this report, we show that human DC are (a) capable of infection by recombinant poxviruses encoding melanoma-associated antigen (MAA) genes and (b) capable of efficiently processing and presenting these MAA to cytotoxic T cells. In 6/6 HLA A*0201-expressing melanoma patients tested, the virally driven expression of MART-1/Melan A MAA by DC was sufficient to generate CD8+ T lymphocytes that could recognize naturally processed epitopes on tumor cells. In most cases, specific anti-MART-1 reactivity could be detected after a single stimulation. Analysis of epitope dominance revealed that the amino acid sequence recognized by these cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) corresponded to the MART-1(27-35) residues previously shown to be most commonly recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes expanded from metastatic melanoma lesions. These data show that the virally driven expression of MAA by DC can be exploited for the efficient induction of clinically relevant cytotoxic T-cell responses. This has clinical implications for active immunization therapy, and currently vaccine trials have been proposed for patients with metastatic melanoma.

Identification of a Kb-restricted CTL epitope of beta-galactosidase: potential use in development of immunization protocols for "self" antigens

The use of recombinant and synthetic vaccines in the treatment of cancer has recently been explored using model tumor associated antigens (TAA), many of which do not model the immunological state of affairs in which the TAA is expressed by normal tissues. One potentially useful model Ag is beta-galactosidase (beta-gal). Because the activity of this enzyme is so easily detectable, this gene has been inserted into a large number of recombinant viruses and tumors useful to the cancer vaccinologist. In addition, numerous transgenic mouse colonies that have tissue-specific expression of beta-gal have been developed, enabling the modeling of tolerance to "self" Ags. Since most of these mice have an H-2b background, we generated cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) capable of recognizing beta-gal-expressing tumor cells of C57BL\6 origin and have determined that their restriction element is the K(b) molecule. Using an allele-specific epitope forecast to generate a panel of candidate peptides, we have determined that the K(b)-restricted sequence is DAPIYTNV and corresponds to amino acids 96-103 of the intact beta-gal molecule. A recombinant vaccinia virus (rVV-ES beta-gal96-103) was constructed that encoded the peptide epitope preceded by an endoplasmic reticulum insertion signal sequence. Tumor cells infected with this rVV were recognized by the original CTL that had been used to identify the epitope. Furthermore, splenocytes of mice immunized with a rVV encoding the full-length beta-gal molecule and restimulated with the DAPIYTNV peptide specifically recognized tumor cells expressing beta-gal. The identification of this immunogenic beta-gal sequence enables the modeling of immunization strategies in animal models of malignant disease in which the target antigen is a "self" protein.

Antigen expression by dendritic cells correlates with the therapeutic effectiveness of a model recombinant poxvirus tumor vaccine

Recombinant poxviruses encoding tumor-associated antigens (TAA) are attractive as candidate cancer vaccines. Their effectiveness, however, will depend upon expression of the TAA in appropriate antigen-presenting cells. We have used a murine model in which the TAA is beta-galactosidase (beta-gal) and a panel of recombinant vaccinia viruses (rVV) in which beta-gal was expressed under early or late promoters at levels that varied over 500-fold during productive infections in tissue culture cells. Remarkably, only those rVV employing early promoters were capable of prolonging the survival of mice bearing established tumors expressing the model TAA. Late promoters were ineffective regardless of their determined promoter strength. The best results were obtained when beta-gal was regulated by a strong early promoter coupled to a strong late promoter. When a variety of cell types were infected with the panel of viruses in vitro, dendritic cells were found to express beta-gal only under the control of the early promoters even though late promoters were intrinsically more active in other cell types. Furthermore, in a functional assay, dendritic cells infected in vitro with rVV encoding beta-gal regulated by an early promoter activated beta-gal-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes, whereas similar rVV with a late promoter-regulated gene did not. These data indicate that promoter strength per se is not the most critical quality of a recombinant poxvirus-based tumor vaccine and that the use of promoters capable of driving the production of TAA in "professional" antigen presenting cells may be crucial.

Highly attenuated modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) as an effective recombinant vector: a murine tumor model

Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA), a highly attenuated strain of vaccinia virus (VV) that is unable to replicate in most mammalian cells, was evaluated as an expression vector for a model tumor associated antigen (TAA) and as a potential anti-cancer vaccine. We employed an experimental murine model in which an adenocarcinoma tumor line, CT26.CL25, was stably transfected with a model TAA, beta-galactosidase (beta-gal). Mice injected intramuscularly with a recombinant MVA (rMVA) expressing beta-gal (MVA-LZ), were protected from a lethal intravenous (i.v.) challenge with CT26.CL25. In addition, splenocytes from mice primed with MVA-LZ were therapeutically effective upon adoptive transfer to mice bearing pulmonary metastases of the CT26.CL25 tumor established 3 days earlier. Most importantly, i.v. inoculation with MVA-LZ resulted in significantly prolonged survival of mice bearing three day old pulmonary metastases. This prolonged survival compared favorably to mice treated with a replication competent recombinant VV expressing beta-gal. These findings indicate that rMVA is an efficacious alternative to the more commonly used replication competent VV for the development of new recombinant anti-cancer vaccines.

Enhancement of cellular immunity in melanoma patients immunized with a peptide from MART-1/Melan A

PURPOSE

In this study, we tested the effectiveness of a melanoma-associated antigen-derived peptide, MART-1(27-35), in eliciting cellular immune responses in vivo in the context of a phase I active immunization protocol. This peptide (AAGIGILTV) corresponds to residues 27-35 from the nonmutated melanoma-associated antigen MART-1/Melan A and is recognized by most melanoma-specific, HLA-A*0201-restricted, tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. To test the in vivo induction of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) sensitization, we compared CTL reactivity in vitro from peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) pools obtained before and after vaccination.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

MART-1(27-35) was administered to HLA-A*0201 melanoma patients subcutaneously in an emulsification with incomplete Freund's adjuvant. A vaccination course included four inoculations of peptide at 3-week intervals. PBMC collected by leukapheresis and separated by Ficoll-Hypaque gradient before and after vaccination were analyzed in 18 patients by in vitro sensitization with MART-1(27-35). To induce MART-1(27-35)-specific CTL, PBMC were incubated with 1 microM peptide (on day 0) and interleukin-2 (IL-2) (300 IU/mL, on days 1 and 4 after each stimulation). At weekly intervals, cells were harvested and an aliquot was cryopreserved for later analysis. The remaining cells were replated and restimulated using irradiated autologous PBMC pulsed with 1 microM of relevant peptide. After three restimulations, all samples from one patient were tested simultaneously for HLA-A*0201-restricted anti-MART-1(27-35) reactivity by microcytotoxicity and cytokine (IFN-gamma) release assays.

RESULTS

Toxicities were minimal and consisted of local irritation at the site of vaccine administration. None of the patients sustained a clinical response. The first eight patients were monitored by inducing CTL reactivity from PBMC obtained preimmunization and after two and four vaccinations. Only two prevaccination cultures were reactive to MART-1, compared with five and seven cultures from PBMC obtained after two and four vaccinations, respectively. Thus, an enhancement in cytotoxic activity could be detected in postvaccination CTL cultures, and serial vaccine administrations appeared to boost the detectability of cytotoxicity in vitro. For completeness, the analysis compared prevaccination with postvaccination PBMC cultures. Specific anti-MART-1(27-35) cytotoxicity (> or = 10 lytic units) could be detected in two prevaccination and 12 postvaccination cultures after two in vitro stimulations. In 15 postvaccination CTL cultures, a more than threefold increase in specific release of IFN-gamma was noted, compared with prevaccination.

DISCUSSION

In vivo administration of a melanoma-associated antigen peptide, emulsified in incomplete Freund's adjuvant, could safely augment CTL reactivity against epitopes commonly expressed by melanoma cells. Although the enhancement of CTL reactivity did not achieve tumor regression, it is possible that the use of recombinant immunogens with increased immunomodulatory capabilities in future clinical trials could reach the threshold of CTL activation necessary for tumor regression.

Cloning and characterization of the genes encoding the murine homologues of the human melanoma antigens MART1 and gp100

The recent identification of genes encoding melanoma-associated antigens has opened new possibilities for the development of cancer vaccines designed to cause the rejection of established tumors. To develop a syngeneic animal model for evaluating antigen-specific vaccines in cancer therapy, the murine homologues of the human melanoma antigens MART1 and gp100, which were specifically recognized by tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes from patients with melanoma, were cloned and sequenced from a murine B16 melanoma cDNA library. The open reading frames of murine MART1 and gp100 encode proteins of 113- and 626-amino acids with 68.8 and 77% identity to the respective human proteins. Comparison of the DNA sequences of the murine MART1 genes, derived from normal melanocytes, the immortalized nontumorgenic melanocyte line Melan-a and the B16 melanoma, showed all to be identical. Northern and Western blot analyses confirmed that both genes encoded products that were melanocyte lineage proteins. Mice immunized with murine MART1 or gp100 using recombinant vaccinia virus failed to produce any detectable T-cell responses or protective immunity against B16 melanoma. In contrast, immunization of mice with human gp100 using recombinant adenoviruses elicited T cells specific for hgp100, but these T cells also cross reacted with B16 tumor in vitro and induced significant but weak protection against B16 challenge. Immunization with human and mouse gp100 together [adenovirus type 2 (Ad2)-hgp100 plus recombinant vaccinia virus (rVV)-mgp100], or immunization with human gp100 (Ad2-hgp100) and boosting with heterologous vector (rVV-hgp100 or rVV-mgp100) or homologous vector (Ad2-hgp100), did not significantly enhance the protective response against B16 melanoma. These results may suggest that immunization with heterologous tumor antigen, rather than self, may be more effective as an immunotherapeutic reagent in designing antigen-specific cancer vaccines.

The new vaccines: building viruses that elicit antitumor immunity

Whereas cancer cells are poor immunogens, some viruses are capable of eliciting powerful and lifelong immunity. Recombinant viruses and plasmid DNA encoding tumor-associated antigens can elicit powerful and specific immune responses that can be enhanced by the use of cytokines and costimulatory molecules. These immune responses have destroyed growing tumor cells in experimental animal models. For the first time, immunotherapeutic strategies that employ recombinant viruses are being tested in clinical trials with cancer patients.