Yeast cells as a tool for analysis of HIV-1 protease susceptibility to protease inhibitors, a comparative study

HIV develops drug resistance at a high rate under drug selection pressure. Resistance tests are recommended to help physicians optimize antiretroviral drug therapies. For this purpose, genotypic and phenotypic tests have been developed. In order to propose a new phenotypic test that will be less laborious, expensive, and time consuming than the standard ones, a new procedure to measure HIV-1 protease susceptibility to protease inhibitor (PIs) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeast cells was developed. This procedure is based on HIV-1 protease expression in yeast. While the viral protein induces yeast cell death, its inhibition by PIs in the culture medium allows the cell to grow in a dose-dependent manner. In a comparative study of standard genotypic analysis vs. yeast cell-based phenotypic tests, performed on HIV-1 protease coding DNA in 17 different plasma samples from infected individuals, a clear match was found between the results obtained using the two technologies. This suggests that the yeast-based procedure is at least as accurate as standard genotypic test in defining susceptibility to protease inhibitors. This encouraging result should be the basis for large-scale validation of the new phenotypic resistance test.

In vitro translation to study HIV protease activity

HIV-1 is an etiological agent of AIDS. One of the targets of the current anti-HIV-1 combination chemotherapy, called highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), is HIV-1 protease (PR), which is responsible for the processing of viral structural proteins and, therefore, essential for virus replication. Here, we describe an in vitro transcription/translation-based method of phenotyping HIV-1 PR. In this system, both substrate and PR for the assay can be prepared by in vitro transcription/translation. Protease activity is estimated by the cleavage of a substrate, as measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). This assay is safe, rapid, and requires no special facility to be carried out. Our rapid phenotyping method of HIV-1 PR may help evaluate drug resistance, useful when choosing an appropriate therapeutic regiment, and could potentially facilitate the discovery of new drugs effective against HIV-1 PR.

Establishment of a new cell line inducibly expressing HIV-1 protease for performing safe and highly sensitive screening of HIV protease inhibitors

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR) plays an essential role in processing viral polyproteins into mature proteins. As a result, it is a major target for the development of drugs against AIDS. However, due to the rapid emergence of drug-resistant HIV, the development of novel HIV PR inhibitors is urgently needed. We recently established a new cell line E-PR293 which can be used as a safe, convenient and highly efficient assay system to screen HIV-1 PR inhibitors. In the cells, the HIV-1 PR is expressed in a chimeric protein with the green fluorescence protein (GFP). This assay measures the PR activity as a function of either the fluorescence of GFP or the cytotoxic activity of HIV-1 PR which is expressed in the cell. E-PR293 cells were maintained in the presence of doxycycline, which suppresses the expression of HIV-1 PR. The removal of doxycycline induces the expression of HIV-1 PR, which is used to screen HIV-1 PR inhibitors. In E-PR293 cells, the 50% inhibitory concentration of the cytotoxic effects by nelfinavir and saquinavir were as low as nanomolar levels, almost equal to those found in the HIV-infection assay.

In vitro synthesis of enzymatically active HIV-1 protease for rapid phenotypic resistance profiling

BACKGROUND

Given the expanding antiretroviral therapy, inexpensive and fast HIV drug resistance assays are urgently needed. In this view, we have developed a novel phenotypic resistance test for HIV-1 protease inhibitors (PIs) based on recombinant expression of patient-derived HIV PR in Escherichia coli and subsequent enzymatic testing in a fluorescent readout.

OBJECTIVES

To facilitate and expedite the test procedure, we have introduced coupled in vitro transcription/translation using a commercially available technology called RTS for producing enzymatically active HIV-1 protease (PR).

STUDY DESIGN

We expressed one wild type PR and one highly resistant mutant starting from molecular clones as well as three patient-derived PRs. The amplified PR gene was either ligated into an expression vector or directly used as a template for the in vitro transcription/translation reaction. Enzymatic susceptibility data derived from in vitro expressed PRs were correlated to the respective results from E. coli expression and genotypic evaluation.

RESULTS

All tested enzymes were obtained in sufficient quantities for complete resistance profiling to five PIs. The PRs required no purification prior to the enzymatic assay. Inhibition constants and enzymatic resistance factors compared well to corresponding data from PRs expressed in parallel in E. coli. Enzymatic resistance was in good agreement with the respective PR genotype.

CONCLUSION

The presented in vitro transcription/translation system represents a novel approach for HIV PR expression starting from molecular clones or patient samples. Coupled with the enzyme-kinetic PR assay recently developed in our group it allows to sensitively quantify resistance to PIs. The test system is significantly less laborious and faster than currently available phenotypic drug resistance assays.

In vitro combination of amdoxovir and the inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase inhibitors mycophenolic acid and ribavirin demonstrates potent activity against wild-type and drug-resistant variants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1

Amdoxovir [(-)-beta-d-2,6-diaminopurine dioxolane (DAPD)] is a nucleoside analogue reverse transcriptase inhibitor of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication. DAPD is deaminated by adenosine deaminase to the guanosine analogue dioxolane guanosine (DXG), which is subsequently phosphorylated to the corresponding 5' triphosphate (DXG-TP). DXG-TP competes with the natural substrate dGTP for binding to the enzyme-nucleic acid complex. Mycophenolic acid (MPA) and ribavirin (RBV), inhibitors of inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase (IMPDH), inhibit the de novo synthesis of guanine nucleotides, including dGTP. Reducing the intracellular levels of dGTP would be expected to augment the antiviral activity of analogues of deoxyguanosine. In this study we examined the effect of MPA and RBV on the anti-HIV activity of DAPD and DXG. When tested against wild-type virus, both MPA and RBV decreased the 50% effective concentration (EC(50)) for DXG by at least 10-fold. In contrast, both MPA and RBV increase the EC(50) value for zidovudine. MPA and RBV completely reversed the resistance to DXG observed with HIV isolates containing mutations which confer partial resistance to DAPD and DXG. Similarly, when tested against a mutant virus fully resistant to inhibition by DAPD (K65R/Q151M), MPA and RBV reduced the EC(50) for DAPD to within twofold of that for the wild type. The combination of MPA or RBV with DAPD or DXG did not result in increased cytotoxicity or reduced levels of mitochondrial DNA when tested at physiologically relevant concentrations. These studies suggest a potential role for the use of IMPDH inhibitors in combination therapy with amdoxovir in the treatment of HIV.

Crystallization of a non-B and a B mutant HIV protease

HIV polymorphism is responsible for the selection of variant viruses resistant to inhibitors used in AIDS treatment. Knowledge of the mechanism of resistance of those viruses is determinant to the development of new inhibitors able to stop, or at least slow down, the disease's progress caused by new mutations. In this paper, the crystallization and preliminary crystallographic structure solution for two multi-resistant 99 amino acid HIV proteases, both isolated from Brazilian patients failing intensive anti-AIDS therapy are presented, viz. the subtype B mutant, with mutations Q7K, S37N, R41K, K45R, I54V, L63P, A71V, V82A and L90M, and the subtype F (wild type), naturally carrying mutations Q7K, I15V, E35D, M36I, S37N, R41K, R57K, D60E, Q61N, I62V, L63S, I64L and L89M, with respect to the B consensus sequence. Both proteins crystallized as a complex with the inhibitor TL-3 in space group P6(1)22. X-ray diffraction data were collected from these crystals to resolutions of 2.1 and 2.6 A for the subtype B mutant and subtype F wild type, respectively, and the enzyme structures were solved by molecular replacement. The crystals of subtype F HIV protease are, to the best of the authors' knowledge, the first protein crystals obtained for a non-B HIV protease.

Rapid enzymatic test for phenotypic HIV protease drug resistance

A phenotypic resistance test based on recombinant expression of the active HIV protease in E. coli from patient blood samples was developed. The protease is purified in a rapid one-step procedure as active enzyme and tested for inhibition by five selected synthetic inhibitors (amprenavir, indinavir, nelfinavir, ritonavir, and saquinavir) used presently for chemotherapy of HIV-infected patients. The HPLC system used in a previous approach was replaced by a continuous fluorogenic assay suitable for high-throughput screening on microtiter plates. This reduces significantly the total assay time and allows the determination of inhibition constants (Ki). The Michaelis constant (Km) and the inhibition constant (Ki) of recombinant wild-type protease agree well with published data for cloned HIV protease. The enzymatic test was evaluated with recombinant HIV protease derived from eight HIV-positive patients scored from 'sensitive' to 'highly resistant' according to mutations detected by genotypic analysis. The measured Ki values correlate well with the genotypic resistance scores, but allow a higher degree of differentiation. The non-infectious assay enables a more rapid yet sensitive detection of HIV protease resistance than other phenotypic assays.

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer between unnatural amino acids in a structurally modified dihydrofolate reductase

The cleavage of a substrate protein by HIV-1 protease has been monitored in real time by the use of a dihydrofolate reductase fusion protein in which a fluorescence donor and a fluorescence acceptor were introduced into sites flanking the HIV-1 protease cleavage site. The amino acids 7-azatryptophan and dabcyl-1,2-diaminopropionic acid were introduced into specific sites of the DHFR fusion protein in an in vitro protein biosynthesizing system using two misacylated suppressor tRNAs, each of which recognized a specific, unique codon introduced into the mRNA. Excitation of the fluorescence acceptor in the initially expressed protein afforded no light production, consistent with quenching by fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Treatment of the elaborated protein with HIV-1 protease cleaved the protein between the fluorescence donor and acceptor, affording a time-dependent increase in fluorescence that was equal in magnitude to that produced by admixture of a stoichiometric amount of free 7-azatryptophan to the solution containing the intact protein.

Recombinant protein production driven by the tryptophan promoter is tightly controlled in ICONE 200, a new genetically engineered E. coli mutant

Batch processes for recombinant gene expression in prokaryotic systems should optimally comprise a growth phase with minimal promoter activity followed by a short phase favoring expression. The strong promoter of the tryptophan operon (Ptrp) gives high-level expression of recombinant proteins in E. coli. The inefficiency to control basal expression before induction is however a major obstacle towards the use of Ptrp, especially in the case of toxic proteins. To circumvent this problem, a novel E. coli strain has been generated. This mutant, named ICONE 200 (Improved Cell for Over and Non-leaky Expression), underwent replacement of tnaA, the tryptophanase encoding gene, with the trpR gene encoding the aporepressor of Ptrp. Detailed analysis of ICONE 200 showed that tryptophan, in addition to its natural role of Ptrp co-repressor, was able to induce trpR through the tryptophan-inducible tryptophanase promoter/operator. Consequently, Ptrp-dependent expression was efficiently repressed in the presence of tryptophan and was turned on, as in wild-type E. coli, as soon as tryptophan was exhausted from the medium. ICONE 200 has the capacity to express a wide range of proteins including toxic proteins such as HIV-1 protease and poliovirus 2B protein. ICONE 200 is a new host carrying stable, targeted, and marker-free genetic modifications and a candidate for large-scale applications.

Identification of a key target sequence to block human immunodeficiency virus type 1 replication within the gag-pol transframe domain

Although the full sequence of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genome has been known for more than a decade, effective genetic antivirals have yet to be developed. Here we show that, of 22 regions examined, one highly conserved sequence (ACTCTTTGGCAACGA) near the 3' end of the HIV-1 gag-pol transframe region, encoding viral protease residues 4 to 8 and a C-terminal Vpr-binding motif of p6(Gag) protein in two different reading frames, can be successfully targeted by an antisense peptide nucleic acid oligomer named PNA(PR2). A disrupted translation of gag-pol mRNA induced at the PNA(PR2)-annealing site resulted in a decreased synthesis of Pr160(Gag-Pol) polyprotein, hence the viral protease, a predominant expression of Pr55(Gag) devoid of a fully functional p6(Gag) protein, and the excessive intracellular cleavage of Gag precursor proteins, hindering the processes of virion assembly. Treatment with PNA(PR2) abolished virion production by up to 99% in chronically HIV-1-infected H9 cells and in peripheral blood mononuclear cells infected with clinical HIV-1 isolates with the multidrug-resistant phenotype. This particular segment of the gag-pol transframe gene appears to offer a distinctive advantage over other regions in invading viral structural genes and restraining HIV-1 replication in infected cells and may potentially be exploited as a novel antiviral genetic target.

Sense codon-dependent introduction of unnatural amino acids into multiple sites of a protein

Cell-free protein synthesis, driven by a crude S30 extract from Escherichia coli, has been applied to the preparation of proteins containing unnatural amino acids at specific positions. We have developed methods for inactivating tRNA(Asp) and tRNA(Phe) within a crude E. coli tRNA by an antisense treatment and for digesting most of the tRNA within the S30 extract without essential damage to the ribosomal activity. In the present study, we applied these methods to the substitution of Asp and Phe residues of the HIV-1 protease with unnatural amino acids. With 10 mM Mg(2+), the translation efficiency was higher than that with the other tested concentration, and the misreading efficiency was low. The protease mRNA was translated in the presence of an antisense DNA-treated tRNA mixture and 2-naphthylalanyl- and/or p-phenylazophenylalanyl-tRNA. The results suggest that a good portion of the translation products are substituted at all of the seven positions originally occupied by Asp or Phe.

HIV-1 evolution under pressure of protease inhibitors: climbing the stairs of viral fitness

The human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) has evolved into a viral quasispecies with a high replication capacity or fitness. Antiretroviral drugs potently inhibit replication of the wild-type virus, but HIV-1 responds by selection of drug-resistant variants. Here we review, in brief, the evolution of resistance to protease inhibitors that is characterized by severe fitness losses and an abundance of subsequent repair strategies. The possibility to restrict HIV-1 fitness is discussed in relation to the control of HIV-1 pathogenesis.

[Establishment of a microbial assay for screening anti-human immunodeficiency virus type-1 protease inhibitors]

OBJECTIVE

This study was to establish a microbial assay of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 protease (HIV-1 PR) activity for screening anti-HIV PR inhibitors.

METHODS

A 24 bp synthetic oligonucleotide fragment that encodes the HIV-1 PR recognition sequence was inserted into the tetr gene of pBR322 (mtetr). Escherichia coli containing HIV-1 PR expression vector-pPOLO was transformed with pACYC184M containing modified mtetr gene. The transformant could express both HIV-1 PR and the modified Tet protein.

RESULTS

The growth of engineered E. coli was prevented in the presence of tetracycline because the resistance Tet protein was degraded by HIV-1 PR. However inhibition of the HIV-1 PR restored tetracycline resistance. 31 chemical synthetic compounds were tested by the microbial assay.

CONCLUSIONS

A microbial assay method of HIV-1 PR activity was established through a engineered E. coli. 5 mumol/L saqunavir-a special HIV-1 PR inhibitor showed inhibitory effect on the engineered E. coli. That means this model could be used as a initial screening model for anti-HIV PR agents.

An Escherichia coli expression assay and screen for human immunodeficiency virus protease variants with decreased susceptibility to indinavir

We have developed a recombinant Escherichia coli screening system for the rapid detection and identification of amino acid substitutions in the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease associated with decreased susceptibility to the protease inhibitor indinavir (MK-639; Merck & Co.). The assay depends upon the correct processing of a segment of the HIV-1 HXB2 gag-pol polyprotein followed by detection of HIV reverse transcriptase activity by a highly sensitive, colorimetric enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The highly sensitive system detects the contributions of single substitutions such as I84V, L90M, and L63P. The combination of single substitutions further decreases the sensitivity to indinavir. We constructed a library of HIV protease variant genes containing dispersed mutations and, using the E. coli recombinant system, screened for mutants with decreased indinavir sensitivity. The discovered HIV protease variants contain amino acid substitutions commonly associated with indinavir resistance in clinical isolates, including the substitutions L90M, L63P, I64V, V82A, L24I, and I54T. One substitution, W6R, is also frequently found by the screen and has not been reported elsewhere. Of a total of 12,000 isolates that were screened, 12 protease variants with decreased sensitivity to indinavir were found. The L63P substitution, which is also associated with indinavir resistance, increases the stability of the isolated protease relative to that of the native HXB2 protease. The rapidity, sensitivity, and accuracy of this screen also make it useful for screening for novel inhibitors. We have found the approach described here to be useful for the detection of amino acid substitutions in HIV protease that have been associated with drug resistance as well as for the screening of novel compounds for inhibitory activity.

Design and synthesis of new potent C2-symmetric HIV-1 protease inhibitors. Use of L-mannaric acid as a peptidomimetic scaffold

A study on the use of derivatized carbohydrates as C2-symmetric HIV-1 protease inhibitors has been undertaken. L-Mannaric acid (6) was bis-O-benzylated at C-2 and C-5 and subsequently coupled with amino acids and amines to give C2-symmetric products based on C-terminal duplication. Potent HIV protease inhibitors, 28 Ki = 0.4 nM and 43 Ki = 0.2 nM, have been discovered, and two synthetic methodologies have been developed, one whereby these inhibitors can be prepared in just three chemical steps from commercially available materials. A remarkable increase in potency going from IC50 = 5000 nM (23) to IC50 = 15 nM (28) was observed upon exchanging -COOMe for -CONHMe in the inhibitor, resulting in the net addition of one hydrogen bond interaction between each of the two -NH- groups and the HIV protease backbone (Gly 48/148). The X-ray crystal structures of 43 and of 48 have been determined (Figures 5 and 6), revealing the binding mode of these inhibitors which will aid further design.

Development of HIV-1 protease expression methods using the T7 phage promoter system

New and simple human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease expression methods in Escherichia coli were developed using the T7 phage promoter system. In order to suppress leaky HIV-1 protease expression under the control of the T7 polymerase, two new methods were tested. One involved the introduction of supplementary T7 promoter regions into host cells [E. coli BL-21 (DE3)] containing the HIV-1 protease gene under the control of the T7 promoter. It was expected that the supplementary T7 promoter regions would compete with the HIV-1 protease expression vector for the T7 polymerase binding. The other involved the infection of late-log-phase cultures of E. coli JM109 harboring the same HIV-1 protease expression vector with the M13 phage expressing T7 polymerase. Both methods were effective, and transformants with the mature HIV-1 protease expression vector showed ten times higher HIV-1 protease activity than activities obtained with the autoprocessing vector. The expression systems described here are convenient and are also easily applicable for the expression of other proteins toxic for E. coli.

Proteolytic activity in vivo and encapsidation of recombinant human immunodeficiency virus type 1 proteinase expressed in baculovirus-infected cells

The activity in vivo of HIV-1 proteinase (PR) was analysed in the baculovirus expression system, using eight different constructs of the prt gene under the control of polyhedrin (PH) promoters of various strengths. None of the active PRs was expressed in substantial quantities, and only PH-fused and/or non-functional PR mutants accumulated in high amounts in insect cells. However, enough PR activity was generated from a lengthened PR construct in insect cells to process Gag polyprotein substrate co-expressed in the same cells in trans. Fusion of the first 58 residues from the PH sequence to the PR N terminus did not significantly change its activity and specificity of cleavage of the Gag substrate. When analysed under mild denaturing conditions, PH-fused or unfused full-length PR point mutants, as well as PH-fused or unfused C-terminal deletion mutants, showed a propensity to multimerize, with a predominant occurrence of dimers. The incorporation of PR into Gag particles was studied using eight Gag-PR fusion constructs, all containing a non-functional PR mutant. The PR domain was fused to the C-terminal p6 domain of Gag (p6gag), or translated in frame with NCp7 (as in frameshifted Gag-Pol polyprotein) and followed by downstream sequences of increasing lengths from the Pol domain or the bacterial beta-galactosidase. The results suggested that the presence of the p6gag domain was detrimental to the encapsidation of polyprotein-embedded PR.

Engineering human immunodeficiency virus 1 protease heterodimers as macromolecular inhibitors of viral maturation

Dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease (HIV-1 PR) monomers is an essential prerequisite for viral proteolytic activity and the subsequent generation of infectious virus particles. Disruption of the dimer interface inhibits this activity as does formation of heterodimers between wild-type and defective monomers. A structure-based approach was used to identify amino acid substitutions at the dimer interface of HIV-1 PR that facilitate preferential association of heterodimers and inhibit self-association of the defective monomers. Expression of the designed PR monomers inhibits activity of wild-type HIV-1 PR and viral infectivity when assayed in an ex vivo model system. These results show that it is possible to design PR monomers as macromolecular inhibitors that may provide an alternative to small molecule inhibitors for the treatment of HIV infection.

A transient precursor of the HIV-1 protease. Isolation, characterization, and kinetics of maturation

Recently, the mechanism of autoprocessing of the protease (PR) of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 from the model polyprotein, MBP-DeltaTF-PR-DeltaPol, which contains the protease linked to short native flanking sequences (DeltaTF and DeltaPol) fused to the maltose binding protein (MBP) of Escherichia coli, was reported (Louis, J. M., Nashed, N. T., Parris, K. D., Kimmel, A. R., and Jerina, D. M. (1994) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 91, 7970-7974). According to this mechanism, intramolecular cleavage of the N-terminal strands of the dimeric MBP-DeltaTF-PR-DeltaPol protein leads to the formation of the PR-DeltaPol intermediate, which is subsequently converted to the mature protease by cleavage of the C-terminal strands. We now report the purification and characterization of the PR-DeltaPol intermediate and the kinetics of its processing to the mature protease. Unlike the MBP-DeltaTF-PR-DeltaPol precursor, PR-DeltaPol has proteolytic activity similar to that of the mature enzyme at pH 5.0. The pH rate profile for kcat/Km is similar to that of the mature protease above pH 4.0. Although the PR-DeltaPol is more sensitive than the mature protease toward denaturing reagents, both the enzymatic activity and the intrinsic fluorescence of PR-DeltaPol are linearly dependent on the protein concentration, indicating that the protein is largely in its dimeric form above 10 nM. In contrast to the first-order kinetics observed for the proteolytic reaction at the N terminus of the protease, the proteolytic reaction at the C terminus of the protease is second order in protein concentration. These results are discussed in terms of a mechanism in which the C-terminally located DeltaPol peptide chains are cleaved intermolecularly to release the mature protease.

p6Gag is required for particle production from full-length human immunodeficiency virus type 1 molecular clones expressing protease

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag protein precursor, Pr55Gag, contains at its C-terminal end a proline-rich, 6-kDa domain designated p6. Two functions have been proposed for p6: incorporation of the HIV-1 accessory protein Vpr into virus particles and virus particle production. To characterize the role of p6 in the HIV-1 life cycle and to map functional domains within p6, we introduced a number of nonsense and single and multiple amino acid substitution mutations into p6. Following the introduction of the mutations into the full-length HIV-1 molecular clone pNL4-3, the effects on Gag protein expression and processing, virus particle production, and virus infectivity were analyzed. The production of mutant virus particles was also examined by transmission electron microscopy. The results indicate that (i) p6 is required for efficient virus particle production from a full-length HIV-1 molecular clone; (ii) a Pro-Thr-Ala-Pro sequence, located between residues 7 and 10 of p6, is critical for virus particle production; (iii) mutations outside the Pro-Thr-Ala-Pro motif have little or no effect on virus assembly and release; (iv) the p6 defect is manifested at a late stage in the budding process; and (v) mutations in p6 that severely reduce virion production in HeLa cells also block or significantly delay the establishment of a productive infection in the CEM (12D-7) T-cell line. We further demonstrate that mutational inactivation of the viral protease reverses the p6 defect, suggesting a functional linkage between p6 and the proteolytic processing of the Gag precursor protein during the budding of progeny virions.

An active-site mutation in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 proteinase (PR) causes reduced PR activity and loss of PR-mediated cytotoxicity without apparent effect on virus maturation and infectivity

Infectious retrovirus particles are derived from structural polyproteins which are cleaved by the viral proteinase (PR) during virion morphogenesis. Besides cleaving viral polyproteins, which is essential for infectivity, PR of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) also cleaves cellular proteins and PR expression causes a pronounced cytotoxic effect. Retroviral PRs are aspartic proteases and contain two copies of the triplet Asp-Thr-Gly in the active center with the threonine adjacent to the catalytic aspartic acid presumed to have an important structural role. We have changed this threonine in HIV type 1 PR to a serine. The purified mutant enzyme had an approximately 5- to 10-fold lower activity against HIV type 1 polyprotein and peptide substrates compared with the wild-type enzyme. It did not induce toxicity on bacterial expression and yielded significantly reduced cleavage of cytoskeletal proteins in vitro. Cleavage of vimentin in mutant-infected T-cell lines was also markedly reduced. Mutant virus did, however, elicit productive infection of several T-cell lines and of primary human lymphocytes with no significant difference in polyprotein cleavage and with similar infection kinetics and titer compared with wild-type virus. The discrepancy between reduced processing in vitro and normal virion maturation can be explained by the observation that reduced activity was due to an increase in Km which may not be relevant at the high substrate concentration in the virus particle. This mutation enables us therefore to dissociate the essential function of PR in viral maturation from its cytotoxic effect.

Trans-dominant inhibitory human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease monomers prevent protease activation and virion maturation

Production of infectious human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) requires proper polyprotein processing by the dimeric viral protease. The trans-dominant inhibitory activity of a defective protease monomer with the active site Asp-25 changed to Asn was measured by transient transfection. A proviral plasmid that included the drug-selectable Escherichia coli gpt gene was used to deliver the wild-type (wt) or mutant proteases to cultured cells. Coexpression of the wt proviral DNA (HIV-gpt) with increasing amounts of the mutant proviral DNA (HIV-gpt D25N) results in a concomitant decrease in proteolytic activity monitored by in vivo viral polyprotein processing. The viral particles resulting from inactivation of the protease were mostly immature, consisting predominantly of unprocessed p55gag and p160gag-pol polyproteins. In the presence of HIV-1 gp160 env, the number of secreted noninfectious particles correlated with the presence of increasing amounts of the defective protease. Greater than 97% reduction in infectivity was observed at a 1:6 ratio of wt to defective protease DNA. This provides an estimate of the level of inhibition required for effectively preventing virion processing. Stable expression of the defective protease in monkey cells reduced the yield of infectious particles from these cells by 90% upon transfection with the wt proviral DNA. These results show that defective subunits of the viral protease exert a trans-dominant inhibitory effect resulting from the formation of catalytically compromised heterodimers in vivo, ultimately yielding noninfectious viral particles.

Potent inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication by inducible expression of HIV-1 PR multimers

Constructs were generated in which expression of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR) was placed under control of the HIV-1 long terminal repeat, thus requiring the HIV-1 Tat protein for expression of PR. The activity of PR was assessed by cotransfection with a construct producing a Gag substrate. Expression of PR as an intramolecular multimer resulted in a large increase in PR activity in comparison with the level obtained with the expression of PR as a monomer. A cytotoxic effect of PR expression was also exhibited by the constructs expressing PR multimers. CD4+ T-cell lines were generated with a construct producing PR as a linked tetramer and screened for PR activity and inducibility. The replication of HIV-1 in these cell lines was several orders of magnitude reduced in comparison with that in cell lines not expressing PR. Infection in these cell lines could be detected early after infection but disappeared over time. Infection of the PR-expressing cell lines could be increased several orders of magnitude by the addition of a specific inhibitor of PR, U75875 (Upjohn), after infection of the cells, demonstrating that the potent inhibition of HIV-1 replication in these cells was directly due to the expression of PR.

Analysis of resistance to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease inhibitors by using matched bacterial expression and proviral infection vectors

There are already reports, from clinical trials with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease inhibitors, of the emergence of drug-resistant mutants which have one or more point mutations in their protease genes. To examine roles of individual and multiple amino acid substitutions in terms of altered enzyme and virus drug sensitivities, we have produced matched vectors for bacterial expression and virus production. Both vectors accept the same restriction enzyme fragment, produced by PCR or PCR-mutagenesis of the protease gene, allowing parallel expression of mutant enzymes in Escherichia coli and in recombinant viruses. The utility of this vector system was demonstrated by using protease variants glycine to valine at amino acid 48 (G48V) and leucine to methionine at amino acid 90 (L90M) identified after passage of HIV-1 in the Roche phase II clinical trial protease inhibitor Ro 31-8959 (H. Jacobsen, K. Yasargil, D. L. Winslow, J. C. Craig, A. Krohn, I. B. Duncan, and J. Mous, Virology 206:527, 1995). G48V, L90M, and G48V/L90M exhibited successively less processing in vitro than the wild-type enzyme, and the purified enzymes were 220-, 20-, and 720-fold, respectively, less sensitive to Ro 31-8959. The reduced enzyme sensitivity correlated directly with the sensitivities of the matched recombinant viruses, in that individual mutations L90M and G48V conferred 2-fold and 4- to 6-fold increases in 50% inhibitory concentration, respectively, whereas G48V/L90M was 8 to 10 times less sensitive to Ro 31-8959. A proviral vector with the entire protease gene deleted was constructed for use as an in vivo recombination target for an overlapping protease PCR fragment, generating wild-type infectious virus. Finally, direct ligation of restriction fragments, generated from random PCR mutagenesis, into the proviral vector should provide a library of protease mutations that allow extremely rapid selection of highly resistant viral variants.

Comparison of HIV-1 protease expression in different fusion forms

Earlier observations showed that the expression of recombinant protease of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1 PR) was usually in a low level, and its proteolytic activity and hydrophobicity were believed to be toxic for the host cells. Various constructs were investigated that contained an N-terminal extended HIV-1 PR gene (PR107) in order to find a system which can express this protease in high level. The constructs of PR107 gene expressed as fusion proteins either with glutathione S-transferase (GST) by pGEX-PR107 or with maltose-binding protein (MBP) by pMAL-PR107 showed that the full length of fusion protein exhibited self-cleavage in E. coli. The results from expression experiments indicated that the size of the fusion portion does not affect the self-processing of fused HIV-1 PR to release its mature form, despite the attachment of only one subunit of the dimeric protease to GST or MBP. The construct, pET-PR107, under the control of strong bacteriophage T7 promoter system, did not show clear advantages for expression of this HIV-1 PR. Comparing these three constructs, the pGEX-PR107 system showed the highest expression level. Quantitative immuno-blotting indicated that the amount of HIV-1 PR expressed by pGEX-PR107 was twice that expressed by pMAL-PR107, and thrice that expressed by pET-PR107. More than 1 mg of pure HIV-1 PR from per liter culture of E. coli. DH5 alpha containing pGEX-PR107 can be obtained via the purification procedures [Biochem. Mol. Biol. International, (1995) 35:899-912].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Expression and purification of active form of HIV-1 protease from E.coli

We have subcloned an N-terminal extended protease gene of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 that is encoded in the protease domain of the pol open reading frame into expression vector pGEX-KG. A relatively high level of expression of recombinant HIV-1 protease (PR) was achieved with isopropyl beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG) induction and glucose supplement. An isolation method consisting of denaturation of protein and followed by refolding was developed for releasing this recombinant HIV-1 PR into the soluble phase since most of the expressed protease was initially present in insoluble inclusion bodies. High purity of this recombinant HIV-1 PR was obtained by sequential purification using Sephadex G-50 gel filtration and CM-23 cellulose cation exchange chromatography, yielding the protease more than 1 mg per liter culture. N-terminal amino acid sequence analysis showed that the recombinant HIV-1 PR underwent autocleavage from the fusion protein during expression. SDS-PAGE indicated that the molecular weight of this recombinant HIV-1 PR is 11 kDa. This recombinant HIV-1 PR showed proteolytic activity for the synthetic peptide substrates corresponding to the sequence at the Gag MA/CA and Pol p6*/PR junctions. The purified enzyme whose specific activity for the heptapeptide SQNYPIV was 848.7 nmol*min-1*mg protease-1 also processed recombinant polyprotein Gag41 as its substrate.

Overexpression of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease increases intracellular cleavage of Gag and reduces virus infectivity

Here we have investigated if human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease expressed in trans can interfere with production of infectious HIV-1 particles. Protease produced from a Tat and Rev inducible expression plasmid specifically cleaved HIV-1 p55Gag in a dose-dependent manner. Coexpression of protease and an infectious HIV-1 proviral clone resulted in increased intracellular cleavage of p55Gag. As a consequence, virus production and virus infectivity was significantly reduced. These results suggest that overexpression of HIV-1 protease in HIV-1-infected cells is a powerful way to inhibit production of infectious virions.

Intrinsic activity of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease heterologous fusion proteins in mammalian cells

We have generated various mammalian expression constructs that produce fusion proteins of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR) with the HIV-1 Nef protein. The expression of these proteins is inducible by the HIV-1 Tat protein. High-level expression of proteolytically active PR was produced from PR imbedded into Nef coding sequences, flanked by PR cleavage sites. The fusion protein was cleaved nearly to completion and did not exhibit the regulated processing that is seen with the virally encoded PR. No cytotoxic effect of PR expression was detected. The self-cleavage of PR could be inhibited by a specific inhibitor of HIV-1 PR (U75875). Elimination of the aminoterminal PR cleavage site did not have a measurable effect on cleavage of the precursor fusion protein. The cleaved fusion proteins appeared to be extremely unstable in the transfected cells. These findings demonstrate the intrinsic activity of HIV-1 PR in mammalian cells, in the context of a heterologous fusion protein.

Analysis of HIV type 1 reverse transcriptase expression in a human cell line

The functional analysis of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase (RT) subunits on transient and constitutive expression, in the absence or presence of the HIV-1 protease (PR) expression, in a human cell line is described. HIV-1 RT is a heterodimer composed of a 51-kDa subunit (p51) and a 66-kDa subunit (p66). Cloning and expression of the RT region of the HIV-1 pol gene in the HT-1080 human fibrosarcoma cell line yielded p66 without any detectable p51 and a low level of RT activity could be measured. Transient expression of PR and RT in cis generated p51 and p66, but when RT and PR were expressed in trans only p66 was produced. Attempts to establish a stable cell line expressing the PR-RT region of the pol gene were hampered by an apparent intolerance of HT-1080 cells to the HIV-1 PR expression. Therefore, to generate p51 independent of PR expression, the 51-kDa subunit was cloned separately. p51 lacked detectable RT activity. Coexpression of p51 and p66 resulted in a dramatic increase in RT activity. Stable HT-1080 cells producing both p51 and p66 exhibited on average a 15-fold increase in RT activity compared to the parental cell line. Immunofluorescence revealed a diffuse cytoplasmic localization of p51 and p66. To date, this is the first example of a human cell line that is constitutively expressing HIV-1 RT in the absence of HIV-1 infection.

Kinetics and mechanism of autoprocessing of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease from an analog of the Gag-Pol polyprotein

Upon renaturation, the polyprotein MBP-delta TF-Protease-delta Pol, consisting of HIV-1 protease and short native sequences from the trans-frame protein (delta TF) and the polymerase (delta Pol) fused to the maltose-binding protein (MBP) of Escherichia coli, undergoes autoprocessing to produce the mature protease in two steps. The initial step corresponds to cleavage of the N-terminal sequence to release the protein intermediate Protease-delta Pol, which has enzymatic activity comparable to that of the mature enzyme. Subsequently, the mature enzyme is formed by a slower cleavage at the C terminus. The rate of increase in enzymatic activity is identical to that of the appearance of MBP-delta TF and the disappearance of the MBP-delta TF-Protease-delta Pol. Initial rates are linearly dependent on the protein concentration, indicating that the N-terminal cleavage is first-order in protein concentration. The reaction is competitively inhibited by pepstatin A and has a pH rate profile similar to that of the mature enzyme. These results and molecular modeling studies are discussed in terms of a mechanism in which a dimeric full-length fusion protein must form prior to rate-limiting intramolecular cleavage of the N-terminal sequence that leads to an increase in enzymatic activity.

Kinetic and modeling studies of subsites S4-S3' of Moloney murine leukemia virus protease

The substrate specificity of the Moloney murine leukemia virus protease (Mo-MuLV PR) was analyzed by using the oligopeptide substrate Val-Ser-Gln-Asn-Tyr decreases Pro-Ile-Val-Gln-NH2 and a series of analogs containing single amino acid substitutions in the P4-P3' positions. Mo-MuLV PR appears to act similarly to the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) PRs, except for peptides having substitutions at P4 and P2 positions. Mo-MuLV PR shows a strong preference for the analogs having hydrophobic residues, such as Val or Ile at P4, and Ile and Leu at P2, in contrast to HIV-1 and HIV-2 PRs, which prefer smaller or more polar residues at both positions. We built a molecular model of Mo-MuLV PR on the basis of the crystal structure of the related HIV PR. Although the overall structure of Mo-MuLV PR is predicted to be close to that of HIV-1 PR, almost all of the residues forming the subsites are different. The increased hydrophobicity due to the Pro12 insertion and the presence of more aromatic residues in the S4 subsite of Mo-MuLV PR compared to HIV-1 and HIV-2 PRs can be correlated with the observed differences using P4-substituted analogs of VSQNYPIVQ. The preference of Mo-MuLV PR for larger hydrophobic residues at the P2 position can be correlated with the larger size of its S2 subsite, due in part to the presence of Val39, Ala57, and His84 in Mo-MuLV PR, instead of Ile32, Ile50, and Met76, respectively, as occurs in HIV-2 PR.

Mutational analysis of the substrate binding pockets of the Rous sarcoma virus and human immunodeficiency virus-1 proteases

Mutations, designed by analysis of the crystal structures of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR), were introduced into the substrate binding pocket of RSV PR. The mutations substituted nonconserved residues of RSV PR, located within 10 A of the substrate, for those in structurally equivalent positions of HIV-1 PR. Changes in the activity of purified mutants were detected in vitro by following cleavage of synthetic peptides representing wild-type and modified RSV and HIV-1 gag and pol polyprotein cleavage sites. Substituting threonine for valine 104 (V104T), S107N, I44V, Q63M or deletion of residues 61-63 produced enzymes that were 2.5-7-fold more active than the wild type RSV PR. Substituting I42D, M73V, and A100L produced enzymes with lower activity, whereas a mutant that included both M73V and A100L was as active as wild type. Several substitutions altered the specificity for substrate. These include I42D and I44V, which contribute to the S2 and S2' subsites. These proteins exhibited HIV-1 PR specificity for P2- or P2'-modified peptide substrates but unchanged specificity with P4-, P3-, P1-, P1'-, and P3'-modified substrates. Changes in specificity in the S4 subsite were detected by deletion of residues 61-63. These results confirm the hypothesis that the subsites of the substrate binding pocket of the retroviral protease are capable of acting independently in the selection of substrate amino acids.

Interactions of substrates and inhibitors with a family of tethered HIV-1 and HIV-2 homo- and heterodimeric proteinases

Genes were constructed to encode single-chain tethered human immunodeficiency virus HIV-1/HIV-1 and HIV-2/HIV-2 homodimeric proteinases and two HIV-1/HIV-2 heterodimers which differed in the nature of the interface strands. All four constructs under the control of a heat-inducible promoter were expressed in E. coli and the resultant proteinases were purified therefrom. Kinetic parameters (Km, kcat and kcat/Km) were derived for the interaction of the tethered homo and heterodimeric proteinases with two distinct substrates at a variety of pH values. All four enzymes were comparably active toward one substrate. With the second substrate at pH 4.7, the kcat/Km value was best for the HIV-1/1 tethered homodimer, 15-fold lower for the two heterodimeric proteinases, and was reduced by an additional 6-fold for the HIV-2/2 homodimer. From the Ki values determined for the interactions of the four tethered dimer proteinases with a systematic series of synthetic inhibitors, a parallel trend was observed. Whereas several inhibitors were equipotent against all four enzymes, two were discriminatory in that they inhibited strongly the HIV-1/1 homodimer and the two heterodimeric proteinases but had little effect on the HIV -2/2 tethered homodimer (or its untethered wild-type counterpart from HIV-2). The significance of these findings for active site interaction with HIV-proteinases is considered.

Characterization of HIV replication complexes early after cell-to-cell infection

In this study, we have characterized the HIV DNA-containing replication complexes present in cells early after cell-to-cell infection, using sucrose gradient sedimentation and immunoprecipitation. Six hours after cell-to-cell infection, a cytoplasmic HIV replication complex sedimented as a large structure (320S). This replication complex was precipitated by antisera to three virus-coded enzymes (reverse transcriptase, integrase, protease), to the matrix protein (p17), and to cellular histones but not to the major capsid protein (p24). This replication complex was not associated with cell membranes and could not be dissociated into smaller discrete subunits, using detergents. Nuclear extracts from the same cell-to-cell infection contained a smaller (80S) complex that lacked reverse transcriptase and matrix protein (p17). Cytoplasmic replication complexes from a cell-free virus infection sedimented as 160S structures under identical conditions, as previously reported. Our results indicate that, following cell-to-cell transmission of HIV, all the HIV pol gene products, the matrix protein p17, and cellular histones are present in cytoplasmic replication complexes that are taking part in or have completed reverse transcription. Transportation of the cytoplasmic replication complex to the nucleus is associated with structural changes, including a reduction in size and altered protein composition.

Effect of linker insertion mutations in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gag gene on activation of viral protease expressed in bacteria

We have expressed the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR) in bacteria as a Gag-PR polyprotein (J. Luban and S.P. Goff, J. Virol. 65:3203-3212, 1991). The protein displays enzymatic activity, cleaving the Gag polyprotein precursor Pr55gag to the expected products. The PR enzyme is only active as a dimer, and we hypothesized that PR activation might be used as an indicator of polyprotein multimerization. We constructed 25 linker insertion mutations throughout gag and assessed the PR activity of mutant Gag-PR polyproteins by the appearance of Gag cleavage products in bacterial lysates. All mutant constructs produced stable protein in bacteria. PR activity of the majority of the Gag-PR mutants was indistinguishable from that of the wild type. Six mutants, one with an insertion in the matrix (MA), four with insertions in the capsid (CA), and one with insertions in the nucleocapsid (NC), globally disrupted polyprotein processing. When PR was provided in trans on a separate plasmid, the Gag proteins were cleaved with wild-type efficiency. These results suggest that the gag mutations identified as disruptive of polyprotein processing did not conceal the scissile bonds of the polyprotein. Rather, the mutations prevented PR activation in the context of a Gag-PR polyprotein, perhaps by preventing polyprotein dimerization.

High-level production of active HIV-1 protease in Escherichia coli

High levels of active HIV-1 protease (PR) were produced in Escherichia coli, amounting to 8-10% of total cell protein. High production levels were achieved by altering the following parameters: (1) codon preference of the coding region, (2) A+T-richness at the 5' end of the coding region, and (3) promoter. To circumvent the toxicity of HIV-1 PR in E. coli, the gene was expressed as a fusion protein with two different proteolytic autocleavage sequences. In both the cases, the fusion protein could be cleaved in vivo to give an active molecule with the native sequence at the N terminus.

High-level expression and purification of mature HIV-1 protease in Escherichia coli under control of the araBAD promoter

A 1.3-kb segment of Escherichia coli DNA containing the regulatory gene, araC, and the promoter of the araBAD operon was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and cloned into pUC18, resulting in plasmid pKB130 that produced the alpha fragment of beta-galactosidase upon addition of L-arabinose (L-ara). A synthetic gene for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1 preprotease was placed downstream of the ara-BAD promoter in pKB130 to create a translational fusion inducible by addition of L-ara. The fusion protein correctly autoprocessed in vivo to yield a mature 99-amino-acid HIV-1 protease, which was found predominantly in inclusion bodies. This material could be refolded to an active form, which was purified to homogeneity. A small fraction of the protease was expressed in vivo as a soluble active form, which allowed the monitoring of expression during fermentation by a rapid and simple whole cell assay employing an HIV-1 protease-specific fluorogenic substrate.

Molecular characterization of HIV-2 (ROD) protease following PCR cloning from virus infected H9 cells

A 450 nucleotide sequence corresponding to the nucleotides 1931-2380 of the viral genome (8) was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using template DNA prepared from HIV-2 (ROD) infected H9 cells. The sequence codes for HIV-2 protease and its N-terminal flanking peptide. An identical DNA sequence was obtained from three independent PCR amplifications, which differs from the published sequence of HIV-2 (ROD) in 7 nucleotides scattered throughout the region of the cloned DNA. The cloned DNA was expressed in E. coli cells and resulted in the synthesis of a correctly processed HIV-2 protease, which is enzymatically active. Therefore, none of the seven nucleotide changes, which resulted in two amino acid substitutions, affect the autoproteolytic or trans-cleaving activities of the HIV-2 protease.

Large scale expression and purification of recombinant HIV-1 proteinase from Escherichia coli

The availability of target proteins in sufficient quantity is a limiting factor in crystallographic studies and therefore in rational drug design. Even after optimisation, expression of recombinant proteins may be low and the only way to produce enough protein is by large scale cell growth/purification. HIV-1 proteinase in Escherichia coli, which due to its toxicity is expressed as a soluble protein only at around 0.1% of total protein, is a paradigm for this. In this paper a detailed process for large scale expression and purification of HIV-1 proteinase which delivers material of suitable quantity (30 mg from 500 g of wet weight of cells) and quality for crystallographic studies is described.

Production of cytotoxic proteins in Escherichia coli: a fermentation process for producing enzymatically active HIV-1 protease

Two fermentation processes for the tryptophan-regulated expression of active HIV protease (HIV-1 prt) in Escherichia coli are described. Since overexpression of HIV-1 prt results in cell death, stringent control of product expression was necessary to attain high enzyme levels. Such control was achieved by separation of growth and production phases in a two-step process or by implementation of nutrient feed in a one-step process. When the two-stage process was used, soluble product was detectable only when induction occurred at low culture density (A550 less than 3.5). Short induction periods of 1-2 h and rapid harvesting were necessary to recover active product. Similar results were obtained when the single-stage process was operated at 37 degrees C; however, cultivation and induction at 28 degrees C resulted in active enzyme formation following induction at increased cell density (A550 = 10).

Expression of active human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease by noninfectious chimeric virus particles

To generate nonpathogenic viral particles which express active human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease (PR), plasmids containing sequences from the genomes of HIV-1 and Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) were constructed. Either the PR coding region alone; the gag, PR, and reverse transcriptase protein-coding regions; or the complete gag and pol protein-coding regions from HIV-1 were substituted for the corresponding regions of a full-length M-MuLV clone to yield the chimeric plasmids pMoHIV-I, pMoHIV-III, and pMoHIV-IV, respectively. Cell lines which express the viral gag polyprotein were isolated for hybrids pMoHIV-I and pMoHIV-III. These cells produced viral particles which contained processed core proteins. Cleavage of the gag polyprotein in the viral particles was inhibited by the HIV-1 PR inhibitor L-687908, indicating that the viral PR is responsible for the observed processing. The hybrid virions were not infectious; analyses indicated that the viral particles contained little or no reverse transcriptase activity. In addition, particles produced by pMoHIV-III transfectants failed to package the viral genomic RNA. The cell line which expresses and processes the HIV-1 gag polyprotein is a safe and effective reagent for the in vivo evaluation of potential inhibitors of the HIV-1 PR.