Deficiency of the HGF/Met pathway leads to thyroid dysgenesis by impeding late thyroid expansion

The mechanisms of bifurcation, a key step in thyroid development, are largely unknown. Here we find three zebrafish lines from a forward genetic screening with similar thyroid dysgenesis phenotypes and identify a stop-gain mutation in hgfa and two missense mutations in met by positional cloning from these zebrafish lines. The elongation of the thyroid primordium along the pharyngeal midline was dramatically disrupted in these zebrafish lines carrying a mutation in hgfa or met. Further studies show that MAPK inhibitor U0126 could mimic thyroid dysgenesis in zebrafish, and the phenotypes are rescued by overexpression of constitutively active MEK or Snail, downstream molecules of the HGF/Met pathway, in thyrocytes. Moreover, HGF promotes thyrocyte migration, which is probably mediated by downregulation of E-cadherin expression. The delayed bifurcation of the thyroid primordium is also observed in thyroid-specific Met knockout mice. Together, our findings reveal that HGF/Met is indispensable for the bifurcation of the thyroid primordium during thyroid development mediated by downregulation of E-cadherin in thyrocytes via MAPK-snail pathway.

Borealin/CDCA8 deficiency alters thyroid development and results in papillary tumor-like structures

Background

BOREALIN/CDCA8 mutations are associated with congenital hypothyroidism and thyroid dysgenesis. Borealin is involved in mitosis as part of the Chromosomal Passenger Complex. Although BOREALIN mutations decrease thyrocyte adhesion and migration, little is known about the specific role of Borealin in the thyroid.

Methods

We characterized thyroid development and function in Borealin-deficient (Borealin +/-) mice using histology, transcriptomic analysis, and quantitative PCR.

Results

Thyroid development was impaired with a hyperplastic anlage on embryonic day E9.5 followed by thyroid hypoplasia from E11.5 onward. Adult Borealin +/- mice exhibited euthyroid goiter and defect in thyroid hormone synthesis. Borealin +/- aged mice had disorganized follicles and papillary-like structures in thyroids due to ERK pathway activation and a strong increase of Braf-like genes described by The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) network of papillary thyroid carcinoma. Moreover, Borealin +/- thyroids exhibited structural and transcriptomic similarities with papillary thyroid carcinoma tissue from a human patient harboring a BOREALIN mutation, suggesting a role in thyroid tumor susceptibility.

Conclusion

These findings demonstrate Borealin involvement in critical steps of thyroid structural development and function throughout life. They support a role for Borealin in thyroid dysgenesis with congenital hypothyroidism. Close monitoring for thyroid cancer seems warranted in patients carrying BOREALIN mutations.

A Novel Pathogenic Variant in PAX8 Leads to Familial Congenital Hypothyroidism

We report a 10-month-old girl with familial congenital hypothyroidism harboring a novel heterozygous pathogenic variant in the paired DNA-binding domain of PAX8 (NM_003466:c.110T>C:p.Leu37Pro). Genotype-phenotype correlation revealed complete penetrance of this PAX8 defect in this family, in which the affected father and half-brother carry the same mutation. This deleterious variant has not been reported in any of the available databases [MAFgnomAD = 0, dbSNP (-)], and the amino acid leucine at position 37 is highly conserved across species. Establishing the molecular diagnosis expands our knowledge on the cause of thyroid dysgenesis and provides a guide for counseling and early treatment.

Whole-Exome Sequencing in Congenital Hypothyroidism Due to Thyroid Dysgenesis

Context: Congenital hypothyroidism due to thyroid dysgenesis (CHTD) is a predominantly sporadic and nonsyndromic (NS) condition of unknown etiology. NS-CHTD shows a 40-fold increase in relative risk among first-degree relatives (1 in 100 compared with a birth prevalence of 1 in 4000 in the general population), but a discordance rate between monozygotic (MZ) twins of 92%. This suggests a two-hit mechanism, combining a genetic predisposition (incomplete penetrance of inherited variants) with postzygotic events (accounting for MZ twin discordance). Objective: To evaluate whether whole-exome sequencing (WES) allows to identify new predisposing genes in NS-CHTD. Methods: We performed a case-control study by comparing the whole exome of 36 nonconsanguineous cases of NS-CHTD (33 with lingual thyroid ectopy and 3 with athyreosis, based on technetium pertechnetate scintigraphy at diagnosis) with that of 301 unaffected controls to assess for enrichment in rare protein-altering variants. We performed an unbiased approach using a gene-based burden with a false discovery rate correction. Moreover, we identified all rare pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants, based on in silico prediction tools, in 27 genes previously associated with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) (thyroid dysgenesis [TD] and dyshormonogenesis). Results: After correction for multiple testing, no enrichment in rare protein-altering variants was observed in NS-CHTD. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants (21 variants in 12 CH genes) were identified in 42% of cases. Eight percent of cases had variants in more than one gene (oligogenic group); these were not more severely affected than monogenic cases. Moreover, cases with protein-altering variants in dyshormonogenesis-related genes were not more severely affected than those without. Conclusions: No new predisposing genes were identified following an unbiased analysis of WES data in a well-characterized NS-CHTD cohort. Nonetheless, the discovery rate of rare pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants was 42%. Eight percent of the cases harbored multiple variants in genes associated with TD or dyshormonogenesis, but these variants did not explain the variability of hypothyroidism observed in dysgenesis. WES did not identify a genetic cause in NS-CHTD cases, confirming the complex etiology of this disease. Additional studies in larger cohorts and/or novel discovery approaches are required.

The mutation screening in candidate genes related to thyroid dysgenesis by targeted next-generation sequencing panel in the Chinese congenital hypothyroidism

OBJECTIVE

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is known to be due to thyroid dyshormonogenesis (DH), which is mostly inherited in an autosomal recessive inheritance pattern or thyroid dysgenesis (TD), whose inheritance pattern is controversial and whose molecular etiology remains poorly understood.

DESIGN AND METHODS

The variants in 37 candidate genes of CH, including 25 genes related to TD, were screened by targeted exon sequencing in 205 Chinese patients whose CH cannot be explained by biallelic variants in genes related to DH. The inheritance pattern of the genes was analyzed in family trios or quartets.

RESULTS

Of the 205 patients, 83 patients carried at least one variant in 19 genes related to TD, and 59 of those 83 patients harbored more than two variants in distinct candidate genes for CH. Biallelic or de novo variants in the genes related to TD in Chinese patients are rare. We also found nine probands carried only one heterozygous variant in the genes related to TD that were inherited from a euthyroid either paternal or maternal parent. These findings did not support the monogenic inheritance pattern of the genes related to TD in CH patients. Notably, in family trio or quartet analysis, of 36 patients carrying more than two variants in distinct genes, 24 patients carried these variants inherited from both their parents, which indicated that the oligogenic inheritance pattern of the genes related to TD should be considered in CH.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study expanded the variant spectrum of the genes related to TD in Chinese CH patients. It is rare that CH in Chinese patients could be explained by monogenic germline variants in genes related to TD. The hypothesis of an oligogenic origin of the CH should be considered.

Genetics of primary congenital hypothyroidism-a review

PURPOSE

Congenital primary hypothyroidism (CH) is a state of inadequate thyroid hormone production detected at birth, caused either by absent, underdeveloped or ectopic thyroid gland (dysgenesis), or by defected thyroid hormone biosynthesis (dyshormonogenesis). A genetic component has been identified in many cases of CH. This review summarizes the clinical and biochemical features of the genetic causes of primary CH.

METHODS

A literature review was conducted of gene defects causing congenital hypothyroidism.

RESULTS

Mutations in five genes have predominantly been implicated in thyroid dysgenesis (TSHR, FOXE1, NKX2-1, PAX8, and NKX2-5), the primary cause of CH (85%), and mutations in seven genes in thyroid dyshormonogenesis (SLC5A5, TPO, DUOX2, DUOXA2, SLC6A4, Tg, and DEHAL1). These genes encode for proteins that regulate genes expressed during the differentiation of the thyroid, such as TPO and Tg genes, or genes that regulate iodide organification, thyroglobulin synthesis, iodide transport, and iodotyrosine deiodination. Besides thyroid dysgenesis and dyshormonogenesis, additional causes of congenital hypothyroidism, such as iodothyronine transporter defects and resistance to thyroid hormones, have also been associated with genetic mutations.

CONCLUSION

The identification of the underlying genetic defects of CH is important for genetic counseling of families with an affected member, for identifying additional clinical characteristics or the risk for thyroid neoplasia and for diagnostic and management purposes.

Enhanced Canonical Wnt Signaling During Early Zebrafish Development Perturbs the Interaction of Cardiac Mesoderm and Pharyngeal Endoderm and Causes Thyroid Specification Defects

Background: Congenital hypothyroidism due to thyroid dysgenesis is a frequent congenital endocrine disorder for which the molecular mechanisms remain unresolved in the majority of cases. This situation reflects, in part, our still limited knowledge about the mechanisms involved in the early steps of thyroid specification from the endoderm, in particular the extrinsic signaling cues that regulate foregut endoderm patterning. In this study, we used small molecules and genetic zebrafish models to characterize the role of various signaling pathways in thyroid specification. Methods: We treated zebrafish embryos during different developmental periods with small-molecule compounds known to manipulate the activity of Wnt signaling pathway and observed effects in thyroid, endoderm, and cardiovascular development using whole-mount in situ hybridization and transgenic fluorescent reporter models. We used the antisense morpholino (MO) technique to create a zebrafish acardiac model. For thyroid rescue experiments, bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) pathway induction in zebrafish embryos was obtained by manipulation of heat-shock inducible transgenic lines. Results: Combined analyses of thyroid and cardiovascular development revealed that overactivation of Wnt signaling during early development leads to impaired thyroid specification concurrent with severe defects in the cardiac specification. When using a model of MO-induced blockage of cardiomyocyte differentiation, a similar correlation was observed, suggesting that defective signaling between cardiac mesoderm and endodermal thyroid precursors contributes to thyroid specification impairment. Rescue experiments through transient overactivation of BMP signaling could partially restore thyroid specification in models with defective cardiac development. Conclusion: Collectively, our results indicate that BMP signaling is critically required for thyroid cell specification and identify cardiac mesoderm as a likely source of BMP signals.

New genetics in congenital hypothyroidism

INTRODUCTION

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is the most frequent neonatal endocrine disorder and one of the most common preventable forms of mental retardation worldwide. CH is due to thyroid development or thyroid function defects (primary) or may be of hypothalamic-pituitary origin (central). Primary CH is caused essentially by abnormal thyroid gland morphogenesis (thyroid dysgenesis, TD) or defective thyroid hormone synthesis (dyshormonogenesis, DH). TD accounts for about 65% of CH, however a genetic cause is identified in less than 5% of patients.

PURPOSE

The pathogenesis of CH is largely unknown and may include the contribution of individual and environmental factors. During the last years, detailed phenotypic description of patients, next-generation sequence technologies and use of animal models allowed the discovery of novel candidate genes in thyroid development, function and pathways.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

We provide an overview of recent genetic causes of primary and central CH. In addition, mode of inheritance and the oligogenic model of CH are discussed.

Compound heterozygous GLI3 variants in siblings with thyroid hemiagenesis

PURPOSE

Thyroid hemiagenesis (THA) is an inborn absence of one thyroid lobe of largely unknown etiopathogenesis, affecting 0.05-0.5% population. The aim of the study was an identification of genetic factors responsible for thyroid maldevelopment in two siblings with THA.

METHODS

We evaluated a three-generation THA family with two sisters presenting the disorder. Proband (Patient II:3) was diagnosed at the age of 45 due to neck asymmetry. Left lobe agenesis and nontoxic multinodular goiter were depicted. Proband's sister (Patient II:6) was euthyroid, showed up at the age of 39 due to neck discomfort and left-sided THA was demonstrated. Affected individuals were subjected to whole-exome sequencing (WES) (Illumina, TruSeq Exome Kit) and all identified variants were evaluated for pathogenicity. Sanger sequencing was used to confirm WES data and check segregation among first-degree relatives.

RESULTS

In both siblings, a compound heterozygous mutations NM_000168.6: c.[2179G>A];[4039C>A] (NP_000159.3: p.[Gly727Arg];[Gln1347Lys]) were identified in the GLI3 gene, affecting exon 14 and 15, respectively. According to the American College of Medical Genetics, variants are classified as of uncertain significance, and were found to be very rare (GnomAD MAF 0.007131 and 0.00003187). The segregation mapping and analysis of relatives indicated causativeness of compound heterozygosity.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated for the first time a unique association of THA phenotype and the presence of compound heterozygous mutations p.[Gly727Arg];[Gln1347Lys] of GLI3 gene in two siblings.

Metastatic-prone telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) promoter and v-Raf murine sarcoma viral oncogene homolog B (BRAF) mutated tall cell variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma arising in ectopic thyroid tissue: A case report

RATIONALE

Mutations of the v-Raf murine sarcoma viral oncogene homolog B (BRAF) oncogene and telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) promoter region are indicators of poor prognosis in papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) and might predict future occurrences of distant metastases. However, the clinical significance of these genetic aberrancies in PTCs arising in ectopic locations is not well established.

PATIENT CONCERNS

We describe a patient with a previous history of radioiodine (RAI)-treated hyperthyroidism and a surgically resected right-sided follicular thyroid adenoma. In 2013, a 6 mm follicular variant papillary thyroid carcinoma was diagnosed following a left-sided thyroid lobectomy. The central compartment displayed 9 tumor-free lymph nodes, and no adjuvant treatment was planned.

DIAGNOSES

Three years later, a 26 mm pre-tracheal relapse was noted, however, the excised lesion was consistent with a tall cell variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma (TCV-PTC) arising in ectopic thyroid tissue. RAI treatment was commenced. Four years later, a 5 mm subcutaneous lesion in the anterior neck was surgically removed and diagnosed as metastatic TCV-PTC with a codon 600 BRAF mutation and a C228T TERT promoter mutation.

INTERVENTIONS

RAI treatment was re-initiated. Molecular re-examination of the primary follicular variant papillary thyroid carcinoma demonstrated a codon 600 BRAF mutation and a TERT promoter wildtype sequence, while the primary TCV-PTC was positive for mutations in both codon 600 of BRAF as well as the TERT promoter.

OUTCOMES

The patient is alive and well without signs of relapse 7 months after the latest round of RAI.

LESSONS

We conclude that the occurrence of combined BRAF and TERT promoter mutations in the primary lesion from 2016 was associated to the manifestation of distant metastases 4 years later, strengthening the benefit of mutational screening of these genes in clinical routine for thyroid carcinomas arising in aberrant locations.

Genetics of Gland-in-situ or Hypoplastic Congenital Hypothyroidism in Macedonia

Neonatal screening in Macedonia detects congenital hypothyroidism (CH) with an incidence of 1 in 1,585, and more than 50% of cases exhibit a normally located gland-in-situ (GIS). Monogenic mutations causing dyshormonogenesis may underlie GIS CH; additionally, a small proportion of thyroid hypoplasia has a monogenic cause, such as TSHR and PAX8 defects. The genetic architecture of Macedonian CH cases has not previously been studied. We recruited screening-detected, non-syndromic GIS CH or thyroid hypoplasia cases (n = 40) exhibiting a spectrum of biochemical thyroid dysfunction ranging from severe permanent to mild transient CH and including 11 familial cases. Cases were born at term, with birth weight >3,000 g, and thyroid morphologies included goiter (n = 11), thyroid hypoplasia (n = 6), and apparently normal-sized thyroid. A comprehensive, phenotype-driven, Sanger sequencing approach was used to identify genetic mutations underlying CH, by sequentially screening known dyshormonogenesis-associated genes and TSHR in GIS cases and TSHR and PAX8 in cases with thyroid hypoplasia. Potentially pathogenic variants were identified in 14 cases, of which four were definitively causative; we also detected digenic variants in three cases. Seventeen variants (nine novel) were identified in TPO (n = 4), TG (n = 3), TSHR (n = 4), DUOX2 (n = 4), and PAX8 (n = 2). No mutations were detected in DUOXA2, NIS, IYD, and SLC26A7. The relatively low mutation frequency suggests that factors other than recognized monogenic causes (oligogenic variants, environmental factors, or novel genes) may contribute to GIS CH in this region. Future non-hypothesis-driven, next-generation sequencing studies are required to confirm these findings.

DUOX2 and DUOXA2 Variants Confer Susceptibility to Thyroid Dysgenesis and Gland-in-situ With Congenital Hypothyroidism

Background: Thyroid dysgenesis (TD), which is caused by gland developmental abnormalities, is the most common cause of congenital hypothyroidism (CH). In addition, advances in diagnostic techniques have facilitated the identification of mild CH patients with a gland-in-situ (GIS) with normal thyroid morphology. Therefore, TD and GIS account for the vast majority of CH cases. Methods: Sixteen known genes to be related to CH were sequenced and screened for variations by next-generation sequencing (NGS) in a cohort of 377 CH cases, including 288 TD cases and 89 GIS cases. Results: In our CH cohort, we found that DUOX2 (21.22%) was the most commonly variant pathogenic gene, while DUOXA2 was prominent in TD (18.75%) and DUOX2 was prominent in GIS (34.83%). Both biallelic and triple variants of DUOX2 were found to be most common in children with TD and children with GIS. The most frequent combination was DUOX2 with DUOXA1 among the 61 patients who carried digenic variants. We also found for the first time that biallelic TG, DUOXA2, and DUOXA1 variants participate in the pathogenesis of TD. In addition, the variant p.Y246X in DUOXA2 was the most common variant hotspot, with 58 novel variants identified in our study. Conclusion: We meticulously described the types and characteristics of variants from sixteen known gene in children with TD and GIS in the Chinese population, suggesting that DUOXA2 and DUOX2 variants may confer susceptibility to TD and GIS via polygenic inheritance and multiple factors, which further expands the genotype-phenotype spectrum of CH in China.

Generation of Thyroid Tissues From Embryonic Stem Cells via Blastocyst Complementation In Vivo

The generation of mature, functional, thyroid follicular cells from pluripotent stem cells would potentially provide a therapeutic benefit for patients with hypothyroidism, but in vitro differentiation remains difficult. We earlier reported the in vivo generation of lung organs via blastocyst complementation in fibroblast growth factor 10 (Fgf10), compound, heterozygous mutant (Fgf10 Ex1^mut/Ex3^mut) mice. Fgf10 also plays an essential role in thyroid development and branching morphogenesis, but any role thereof in thyroid organogenesis remains unclear. Here, we report that the thyroids of Fgf10 Ex1^mut/Ex3^mut mice exhibit severe hypoplasia, and we generate thyroid tissues from mouse embryonic stem cells (ESCs) in Fgf10 Ex1^mut/Ex3^mut mice via blastocyst complementation. The tissues were morphologically normal and physiologically functional. The thyroid follicular cells of Fgf10 Ex1^mut/Ex3^mut chimeric mice were derived largely from GFP-positive mouse ESCs although the recipient cells were mixed. Thyroid generation in vivo via blastocyst complementation will aid functional thyroid regeneration.

Small-Molecule Screening in Zebrafish Embryos Identifies Signaling Pathways Regulating Early Thyroid Development

Background: Defects in embryonic development of the thyroid gland are a major cause for congenital hypothyroidism in human newborns, but the underlying molecular mechanisms are still poorly understood. Organ development relies on a tightly regulated interplay between extrinsic signaling cues and cell intrinsic factors. At present, however, there is limited knowledge about the specific extrinsic signaling cues that regulate foregut endoderm patterning, thyroid cell specification, and subsequent morphogenetic processes in thyroid development. Methods: To begin to address this problem in a systematic way, we used zebrafish embryos to perform a series of in vivo phenotype-driven chemical genetic screens to identify signaling cues regulating early thyroid development. For this purpose, we treated zebrafish embryos during different developmental periods with a panel of small-molecule compounds known to manipulate the activity of major signaling pathways and scored phenotypic deviations in thyroid, endoderm, and cardiovascular development using whole-mount in situ hybridization and transgenic fluorescent reporter models. Results: Systematic assessment of drugged embryos recovered a range of thyroid phenotypes including expansion, reduction or lack of the early thyroid anlage, defective thyroid budding, as well as hypoplastic, enlarged, or overtly disorganized presentation of the thyroid primordium after budding. Our pharmacological screening identified bone morphogenetic protein and fibroblast growth factor signaling as key factors for thyroid specification and early thyroid organogenesis, highlighted the importance of low Wnt activities during early development for thyroid specification, and implicated drug-induced cardiac and vascular anomalies as likely indirect mechanisms causing various forms of thyroid dysgenesis. Conclusions: By integrating the outcome of our screening efforts with previously available information from other model organisms including Xenopus, chicken, and mouse, we conclude that signaling cues regulating thyroid development appear broadly conserved across vertebrates. We therefore expect that observations made in zebrafish can inform mammalian models of thyroid organogenesis to further our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of congenital thyroid diseases.

[TUBB1 mutation in children with congenital hypothyroidism and thyroid dysgenesis in Shandong, China]

OBJECTIVE

To study the types and characteristics of TUBB1 mutation in children with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) and thyroid dysgenesis (TD) in Shandong, China.

METHODS

Mutations of the whole coding region of the TUBB1 gene were analyzed for 289 children with CH and TD in Shandong. Whole-genome DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes. PCR multiplication was performed for the whole coding region of the TUBB1 gene. Sanger sequencing was performed for the PCR products, and a biological information analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Among the 289 children with CH and TD, 4 (1.4%) were found to have a c.952C>T(p.R318W) heterozygous mutation in the TUBB1 gene, resulting in the change of tryptophan into arginine at codon 318 of TUBB1 protein. This mutation was evaluated as "potentially pathogenic" based on the classification criteria and guidelines for genetic variation by American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics.

CONCLUSIONS

A novel mutation is detected in the exon of the TUBB1 gene in children with CH and TD in Shandong, suggesting that the TUBB1 gene may be a candidate pathogenic gene for CH children with TD.

Genetics and management of congenital hypothyroidism

Several evidences support a relevant genetic origin for Congenital Hypothyroidism (CH), however familial forms are uncommon. CH can be due to morphogenetic or functional defects and several genes have been originally associated either with thyroid dysgenesis or dyshormonogenesis, with a highly variable expressivity and a frequently incomplete penetrance of the genetic defects. The phenotype-driven genetic analyses rarely yielded positive results in more than 10% of cases, thus raising doubts on the genetic origin of CH. However, more recent unsupervised approaches with systematic Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) analysis revealed the existence of hypomorphic alleles of these candidate genes whose combination can explain a significant portion of CH cases. The co-segregation studies of the hypothyroid phenotype with multiple gene variants in pedigrees confirmed the potential oligogenic origin of CH, which finally represents a suitable explanation for the frequent sporadic occurrence of this disease.

Thyroid Hypoplasia in Congenital Hypothyroidism Associated with Thyroid Peroxidase Mutations

BACKGROUND

Primary congenital hypothyroidism (CH) affects about 1:3000 newborns worldwide and is mainly caused by defects in thyroid gland development (thyroid dysgenesis [TD]) or hormone synthesis. A genetic cause is identified in <10% of TD patients. The aim was to identify novel candidate genes in patients with TD using next-generation sequencing tools.

PATIENT FINDINGS

Whole exome sequencing was used to study two families: a consanguineous Tunisian family (one child with severe thyroid hypoplasia) and a French family (two newborn siblings, with a thyroid in situ that was not enlarged on ultrasound at diagnosis). Variants in candidate genes were filtered according to type of variation, frequency in public and in-house databases, in silico prediction tools, and inheritance mode. Unexpectedly, three different variants of the thyroid peroxidase (TPO) gene were identified. A homozygous missense mutation (c.875C>T, p.S292F) was found in the Tunisian patient with severe thyroid hypoplasia. The two French siblings were compound heterozygotes (c.387delC/c.2578G>A, p.N129Kfs*80/p.G860R) for TPO mutations. All three mutations have been previously described in patients with goitrous CH. In these patients, treatment was initiated immediately after diagnosis, and the effect, if any, of thyrotropin stimulation of these thyroids remains unclear.

CONCLUSIONS

The first cases are reported of thyroid hypoplasia at diagnosis during the neonatal period in patients with CH and TPO mutations. These cases highlight the importance of screening for TPO mutations not only in goitrous CH, but also in normal or small-size thyroids, and they broaden the clinical spectrum of described phenotypes.

The genetic characteristics of congenital hypothyroidism in China by comprehensive screening of 21 candidate genes

OBJECTIVE

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH), the most common neonatal metabolic disorder, is characterized by impaired neurodevelopment. Although several candidate genes have been associated with CH, comprehensive screening of causative genes has been limited.

DESIGN AND METHODS

One hundred ten patients with primary CH were recruited in this study. All exons and exon-intron boundaries of 21 candidate genes for CH were analyzed by next-generation sequencing. And the inheritance pattern of causative genes was analyzed by the study of family pedigrees.

RESULTS

Our results showed that 57 patients (51.82%) carried biallelic mutations (containing compound heterozygous mutations and homozygous mutations) in six genes (DUOX2, DUOXA2, DUOXA1, TG, TPO and TSHR) involved in thyroid hormone synthesis. Autosomal recessive inheritance of CH caused by mutations in DUOX2, DUOXA2, TG and TPO was confirmed by analysis of 22 family pedigrees. Notably, eight mutations in four genes (FOXE1, NKX2-1, PAX8 and HHEX) that lead to thyroid dysgenesis were identified in eight probands. These mutations were heterozygous in all cases and hypothyroidism was not observed in parents of these probands.

CONCLUSIONS

Most cases of congenital hypothyroidism in China were caused by thyroid dyshormonogenesis rather than thyroid dysgenesis. This study identified previously reported causative genes for 57/110 Chinese patients and revealed DUOX2 was the most frequently mutated gene in these patients. Our study expanded the mutation spectrum of CH in Chinese patients, which was significantly different from Western countries.

High-resolution melting analysis (HRM) for mutational screening of Dnajc17 gene in patients affected by thyroid dysgenesis

BACKGROUND

Congenital hypothyroidism is a frequent disease occurring with an incidence of about 1/1500 newborns/year. In about 75% of the cases, CH is caused by alterations in thyroid morphogenesis, defined "thyroid dysgenesis" (TD). TD is generally a sporadic disease but in about 5% of the cases a genetic origin has been demonstrated. Previous studies indicate that Dnajc17 as a candidate modifier gene for hypothyroidism, since it is expressed in the thyroid bud, interacts with NKX2.1 and PAX8 and it has been associated to the hypothyroid phenotype in mice carrying a single Nkx2.1 and Pax8 genes (double heterozygous knock-out).

PURPOSE

The work evaluates the possible involvement of DNAJC17 in the pathogenesis of TD.

METHODS

High-resolution DNA melting analysis (HRM) and direct sequencing have been used to screen for mutations in the DNAJC17 coding sequence in 89 patients with TD.

RESULTS

Two mutations have been identified in the coding sequence of DNAJC17 gene, one in exon 5 (c.350A>C; rs79709714) and one in exon 9 (c.610G>C; rs117485355). The last one is a rare variant, while the rs79709714 is a polymorphism. Both are present in databases and the frequency of the alleles is not different between TD patients and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

DNAJC17 mutations are not frequently present in patients with TD.

Molecular Analysis of Congenital Hypothyroidism in Saudi Arabia: SLC26A7 Mutation Is a Novel Defect in Thyroid Dyshormonogenesis

CONTEXT

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is the most common neonatal endocrine disorder, affecting one in 3000 to 4000 newborns. Since the introduction of a newborn screening program in 1988, more than 300 cases have been identified. The underlying genetic defects have not been systematically studied.

OBJECTIVE

To identify the mutation spectrum of CH-causing genes.

METHODS

Fifty-five patients from 47 families were studied by next-generation exome sequencing.

RESULTS

Mutations were identified in 52.7% of patients (29 of 55) in the following 11 genes: TG, TPO, DUOX2, SLC26A4, SLC26A7, TSHB, TSHR, NKX2-1, PAX8, CDCA8, and HOXB3. Among 30 patients with thyroid dyshormonogenesis, biallelic TG mutations were found in 12 patients (40%), followed by biallelic mutations in TPO (6.7%), SLC26A7 (6.7%), and DUOX2 (3.3%). Monoallelic SLC26A4 mutations were found in two patients, one of them coexisting with two tandem biallelic deletions in SLC26A7. In 25 patients with thyroid dysgenesis, biallelic mutations in TSHR were found in six patients (24%). Biallelic mutations in TSHB, PAX 8, NKX2-1, or HOXB3 were found once in four different patients. A monoallelic CDCA8 mutation was found in one patient. Most mutations were novel, including three TG, two TSHR, and one each in DUOX2, TPO, SLC26A7, TSHB, NKX2-1, PAX8, CDCA8, and HOXB3. SLC26A7 and HOXB3 were novel genes associated with thyroid dyshormonogenesis and dysgenesis, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

TG and TSHR mutations are the most common genetic defects in Saudi patients with CH. The prevalence of other disease-causing mutations is low, reflecting the consanguineous nature of the population. SLC26A7 mutations appear to be associated with thyroid dyshormonogenesis.

DUOX2 Mutations Are Associated With Congenital Hypothyroidism With Ectopic Thyroid Gland

CONTEXT

Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) is the leading cause of congenital hypothyroidism (CH). The etiology of TD remains unknown in ∼90% of cases, the most common form being thyroid ectopia (TE) (48% to 61%).

OBJECTIVE

To search for candidate genes in hypothyroid children with TE.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

We followed a cohort of 268 children with TD and performed whole-exome sequencing (WES) in three children with CH with TE (CHTE) and compared them with 18 thyroid-healthy controls. We then screened an additional 41 children with CHTE by Sanger sequencing and correlated the WES and Sanger molecular findings with in vitro functional analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Genotyping, mutation prediction analysis, and in vitro functional analysis.

RESULTS

We identified seven variants in the DUOX2 gene, namely G201E, L264CfsX57, P609S, M650T, E810X, M822V, and E1017G, and eight known variations. All children carrying DUOX2 variations had high thyroid-stimulating hormone levels at neonatal diagnosis. All mutations were localized in the N-terminal segment, and three of them led to effects on cell surface targeting and reactive oxygen species generation. The DUOX2 mutants also altered the interaction with the maturation factor DUOXA2 and the formation of a stable DUOX2/DUOXA2 complex at the cell surface, thereby impairing functional enzymatic activity. We observed no mutations in the classic genes related to TD or in the DUOX1 gene.

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that, in addition to thyroid hormonogenesis, the DUOX2 N-terminal domain may play a role in thyroid development.

Mutations in proteasome-related genes are associated with thyroid hemiagenesis

PURPOSE

Human thyroid development is a complex and still unexplained process. Thyroid hemiagenesis is a congenital anomaly, where one of the thyroid lobes fails to develop. In the majority of patients with thyroid hemiagenesis, the genetic background remains unknown. The aim of the study was to search for novel genetic contributors to the etiology of thyroid hemiagenesis.

METHODS

A cohort of 34 sporadic patients diagnosed with thyroid hemiagenesis and one three-generation family were subjected to comprehensive genomic examination. Initially, targeted screening of associated transcription factors, known to be linked to thyroid development, was performed. As a next step, genomic examinations were applied using high-resolution microarrays, whereas for the thyroid hemiagenesis family, additionally the whole exome sequencing was performed.

RESULTS

Screening of transcription factors revealed no causative mutations in the studied cohort. Genomic examinations revealed the presence of four recurrent defects (three deletions and one duplication) affecting highly conservative proteasome genes PSMA1, PSMA3, and PSMD3. In a thyroid hemiagenesis family a splice site mutation in a proteasome gene PSMD2 (c.612T > C cDNA.1170T > C, g.3271T > C) was found in both affected mother and daughter.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results shed a new light on etiology of thyroid hemiagenesis, so far suspected to be linked only to mutations in the genes directly involved in the thyroid development. We demonstrated, for the first time, that genomic alterations in proteasome-associated genes co-occur in patients presenting this developmental anomaly.

Next-generation sequencing of NKX2.1, FOXE1, PAX8, NKX2.5, and TSHR in 100 Chinese patients with congenital hypothyroidism and athyreosis

BACKGROUND

The abnormal expression of certain transcription factors (NKX2.1, FOXE1, NKX2.5, and PAX8) and thyroid stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) genes has been associated with athyreosis, which is a form of thyroid dysgenesis (TD). We aimed to identify candidate gene mutations in CH patients with athyreosis and to establish the genotype-phenotype correlations in a Chinese population.

METHODS

The exons and flanking sequences of NKX2.1, FOXE1, NKX2.5, PAX8, and TSHR were screened by next-generation sequencing and further confirmed by direct Sanger sequencing. The mutation frequencies were calculated and compared against databases. The relationship between genotype and phenotype was also determined.

RESULTS

Seven variants were detected in TSHR-p.P52T, p.G132R, p.M164K, p.R450H, p.C700E, p.A522V, and p.R528S. The p. G132R, p. M164K and p. R528S variants were first identified in public databases. Five variants (p.G44D, p.G360V, p.R401Q, p.L418I, and p.E453Q) were found in NKX2.1 and one variant (p.P243T) was detected in FOXE1. In addition, one variant (p.N291I) was found in NKX2.5 and two variants (p.A355V and c.-26G>A) were detected in PAX8.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study indicated that TSHR mutations have phenotypic variability and has further expanded the mutation spectrum of TSHR. We also revealed that the rate of NKX2.1, FOXE1, NKX2.5, and PAX8 mutations were low in patients with CH and athyreosis, in contrast to the higher rate of TSHR mutations.

Disorders of thyroid morphogenesis

Developmental anomalies of the thyroid gland, defined as thyroid dysgenesis, underlie the majority of cases of congenital hypothyroidism. Thyroid dysgenesis is predominantly a sporadic disorder although a reported familial enrichment, variation of incidence by ethnicity and the monogenic defects associated mainly with athyreosis or orthotopic thyroid hypoplasia, suggest a genetic contribution. Of note, the most common developmental anomaly, thyroid ectopy, remains unexplained. Ectopy may result from multiple genetic or epigenetic variants in the germline and/or at the somatic level. This review provides a brief overview of the monogenic defects in candidate genes that have been identified so far and of the syndromes which are known to be associated with thyroid dysgenesis.

Resistance to thyrotropin

Resistance to thyrotropin (RTSH) is broadly defined as reduced sensitivity of thyroid follicle cells to stimulation by biologically active TSH due to genetic defects. Affected individuals have elevated serum TSH in the absence of goiter, with the severity ranging from nongoitrous isolated hyperthyrotropinemia to severe congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia. Conceptually, defects leading to RTSH impair both aspects of TSH-mediated action, namely thyroid hormone synthesis and gland growth. These include inactivating mutations in the genes encoding the TSH receptor and the PAX8 transcription factor. A common third cause has been genetically mapped to a locus on chromosome 15, but the underlying pathophysiology has not yet been elucidated. This review provides a succinct overview of currently defined causes of nonsyndromic RTSH, their differential diagnoses (autoimmune; partial iodine organification defects; syndromic forms of RTSH) and implications for the clinical approach to patients with RTSH.

Coexistence of resistance to thyroid hormone and ectopic thyroid: ten-year follow-up

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) coexisting with ectopic thyroid is rare. Here we report a case of RTH with ectopic thyroid. A ten-year-old girl had been misdiagnosed as congenital hypothyroidism and treated with levothyroxine since she was born. Ten-year follow-up showed that the elevated thyrotropin was never suppressed by levothyroxine and no signs indicating hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism despite elevated FT3 and FT4 levels. Therefore the girl developed no defects in physical and cognitive development. Pituitary adenoma was excluded by magnetic resonance imaging. Ultrasonography did not find the thyroid gland in the normal place, while the thyroid scan found a large lingual thyroid gland. The octreotide inhibition test showed a reduction in thyrotropin by 41.98%. No mutation was detected in the thyroid hormone receptor (THR) β, THRα, thyrotropin receptor (TSHR), and GNAS1 genes. To our knowledge, it is an interesting RTH case coexisting with lingual thyroid.

Update of Thyroid Developmental Genes

Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) is the most common cause of congenital hypothyroidism in iodine-sufficient regions and includes a spectrum of developmental anomalies. The genetic components of TD are complex. Although a sporadic disease, advances in developmental biology have revealed monogenetic forms of TD. Inheritance is not based on a simple Mendelian pattern and additional genetic elements might contribute to the phenotypic spectrum. This article summarizes the key steps of normal thyroid development and provides an update on responsible genes and underlying mechanisms of TD. Up-to-date technologies in genetics and biology will allow us to advance in our knowledge of TD.

JAG1 Loss-Of-Function Variations as a Novel Predisposing Event in the Pathogenesis of Congenital Thyroid Defects

CONTEXT

The pathogenesis of congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is still largely unexplained. We previously reported that perturbations of the Notch pathway and knockdown of the ligand jagged1 cause a hypothyroid phenotype in the zebrafish. Heterozygous JAG1 variants are known to account for Alagille syndrome type 1 (ALGS1), a rare multisystemic developmental disorder characterized by variable expressivity and penetrance.

OBJECTIVE

Verify the involvement of JAG1 variants in the pathogenesis of congenital thyroid defects and the frequency of unexplained hypothyroidism in a series of ALGS1 patients.

DESIGN, SETTINGS, AND PATIENTS

A total of 21 young ALGS1 and 100 CH unrelated patients were recruited in academic and public hospitals. The JAG1 variants were studied in vitro and in the zebrafish.

RESULTS

We report a previously unknown nonautoimmune hypothyroidism in 6/21 ALGS1 patients, 2 of them with thyroid hypoplasia. We found 2 JAG1 variants in the heterozygous state in 4/100 CH cases (3 with thyroid dysgenesis, 2 with cardiac malformations). Five out 7 JAG1 variants are new. Different bioassays demonstrate that the identified variants exhibit a variable loss of function. In zebrafish, the knock-down of jag1a/b expression causes a primary thyroid defect, and rescue experiments of the hypothyroid phenotype with wild-type or variant JAG1 transcripts support a role for JAG1 variations in the pathogenesis of the hypothyroid phenotype seen in CH and ALGS1 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

clinical and experimental data indicate that ALGS1 patients have an increased risk of nonautoimmune hypothyroidism, and that variations in JAG1 gene can contribute to the pathogenesis of variable congenital thyroid defects, including CH.

Thyroid Hemiagenesis from Childhood to Adulthood: Review of Literature and Personal Experience

Thyroid hemiagenesis (TH) is a rare congenital abnormality of the thyroid gland, characterised by the absence of one lobe. The true prevalence of this congenital abnormality is not known because the absence of one thyroid lobe usually does not cause clinical symptoms by itself. Between 1970 and 2010, 329 cases of TH have been reported. It is interesting to note that most cases have an agenesis of the left lobe (80% of cases) followed by the isthmus (44-50% of cases). Although the female to male ratio was 1:1.4 in 24,032 unselected 11-to 14-yr-old schoolchildren from South-eastern Sicily, several other reports have documented a higher prevalence in women, which may indicate a possible gender association. Most cases of TH are diagnosed when patients present a lesion in the functioning lobe. The functioning lobe of the thyroid gland can be a site of pathological changes similar to a normally developed gland and may present a spectrum of diseases like multinodular goiter, colloid goiter, follicular adenoma, thyroiditis, hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism. In three of our patients, TH was associated with Hashimoto thyroiditis (n = 1) and with subclinical hypothyroidism (n = 2). The frequency of thyroid abnormalities in patients with TH varies with age, due to the longer exposure of the hemi-agenetic gland to TSH overstimulation in older patients. This could explain the controversy about the benign character of this anomaly. Other extrathyroidal lesions, such as parathyroid adenoma or hyperplasia, cervical thymic cysts, ectopic sublingual thyroid gland and thyroglossal duct cyst have been reported with TH. Therefore, systematic follow-up of all identified cases is recommended.

A De novo PAX8 mutation in a Chinese child with congenital thyroid dysgenesis

BACKGROUND

Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) is the most frequent cause of congenital hypothyroidism (CH), but its pathogenesis remains unclear. As a thyroid transcription factor, paired box transcription factor 8 (PAX8) is essential for thyroid organogenesis and development.

AIM

To screen PAX8 mutations and characterize the features of these mutations in Chinese TD patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Blood samples were collected from 63 TD patients in Shandong Province, China, and genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes. Exon 3~4 of PAX8 were analyzed by PCR and direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Direct sequencing of PAX8 revealed a heterozygous missense mutation (c.155G/C, P.Arg52Pro) in one child with agenesis. Genetic screening of the child's family revealed that the clinically unaffected parents do not carry the mutation, suggesting that the identified sequence change is a de novo mutation.

CONCLUSION

We report a heterozygous missense de novo mutation in PAX8 in one out of 63 unrelated Chinese TD patients, showing that the PAX8 mutation rate is very low in TD patients in China. However, de novo mutation and epigenetic mechanisms need to be considered in the future study.

Functional characterization of the novel sequence variant p.S304R in the hinge region of TSHR in a congenital hypothyroidism patients and analogy with other formerly known mutations of this gene portion

CONTEXT

Thyroid dysgenesis may be associated with loss-of-function mutations in the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) gene.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to characterize a novel TSHR gene variant found in one patient harboring congenital hypothyroidism (CH) from a cohort of patients with various types of thyroid defects.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This cross-sectional cohort study involved 118 patients with CH and their family members, including 45 with familial and 73 with sporadic diseases. The thyroid gland was normal in 23 patients, 25 patients had hypoplasia, 25 hemithyroid agenesis, 21 had athyreosis, and 21 had ectopy. Genomic DNA was extracted, and 10 exons of the TSHR gene were amplified and sequenced. Mutations in other candidate genes were investigated. Ortholog alignment was performed, and TSHR functional assays were evaluated.

RESULTS

We identified one previously unknown missense variation in the hinge region (HinR) of the TSHR gene (p.S304R) in one patient with thyroid hypoplasia. This variant is conserved in our ortholog alignment. However, the p.S304R TSHR variant presented a normal glycosylation pattern and signal transduction activity in functional analysis.

CONCLUSION

We report the ocurrence of a novel nonsynonymous substitution in the HinR of the large N-terminal extracellular domain of the TSHR gene in a patient with thyroid hypoplasia. In contrast with four others in whom TSHR mutations of the hinge portion were previously identified, the p.S304R TSHR variation neither affected TSH binding nor cAMP pathway activation. This TSHR gene variant was documented in a CH patient, but the current data do not support its role in the clinical phenotype.

Genetic analysis of the paired box transcription factor (PAX8) gene in a cohort of Polish patients with primary congenital hypothyroidism and dysgenetic thyroid glands

BACKGROUND

The morphological and biochemical phenotype of PAX8 mutation in patients with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is variable. The contribution of mutations in PAX8 gene in children with CH and dysgenetic thyroid glands still remains a subject of interest for researchers.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Some 48 children (37 girls and 11 boys) with CH associated with thyroid ectopy (n=22), agenesis (n=10), hypoplasia (n=6), or thyroid dysgenesis of unknown cause (n=10) were enrolled. The study participants were born in south-eastern Poland in the years 1993-2012 and were selected for neonatal mass screening for CH. DNA was extracted from peripheral blood samples using Master Pure DNA Purification Kit (Epicentre Biotechnologies, Madison, WI, USA). The 12 exons of the PAX8 gene along with their exon-intron boundaries were amplified and sequenced by the Sanger method. Capillary electrophoresis was run on ABI 3500 (Applied Biosystems, Carlsbad, CA, USA).

RESULTS

Novel heterozygous transition in exon 3 (c.68G>A) was detected in a 3-year-old girl with a thyroid hypoplasia. This substitution was not identified in the patient's parents (de novo event). Additionally, a novel genetic variant in 3'UTR region of exon 12 (c.*416C>T) occurred in a 3-year-old boy with ectopic thyroid tissue and concomitant congenital urogenital malformation. This heterozygous variant was also detected in other healthy family members. Thirteen well-described single nucleotide polymorphisms were revealed in the PAX8 gene.

CONCLUSIONS

The study reports on the occurrence of two novel heterozygous substitutions in the PAX8 gene. Estimation of the contribution of the revealed c.68G>A variant to the etiology of CH in a girl with hypoplastic thyroid requires further functional analysis.

DYRK1A BAC transgenic mouse: a new model of thyroid dysgenesis in Down syndrome

The most common thyroid abnormality among Down syndrome (DS) children corresponds to a mildly elevated TSH, with T4 decreased or in the normal range and thyroid hypoplasia, from the neonatal period onward, which aggravate their mental impairment. Transgenic Dyrk1A mice, obtained by bacterial artificial chromosome engineering (mBACTgDyrk1A), have 3 copies of the Dyrk1A gene. The objective is to determine whether this transgenic Dyrk1A (Dyrk1A(+/++)) mouse is an adequate murine model for the study of thyroid dysgenesis in DS. Embryonic thyroid development from embryonic day 13.5 (E13.5) to E17.5 was analyzed in wild-type (WT) and Dyrk1A(+/++) mice by immunofluorescence with anti-Nkx2-1, anti-thyroglobulin, and anti-T4 antibodies, markers of early thyroid development, hormonogenesis, and final differentiation, respectively. The expression of transcription factors Nkx2-1, Pax8, and Foxe1 involved in thyroidogenesis were studied by quantitative RT-PCR at the same embryonic stages. We then compared the adult phenotype at 8 to 12 weeks in Dyrk1A(+/++) and WT mice for T4 and TSH levels, thyroidal weight, and histological analysis. Regarding thyroidal development, at E15.5, Dyrk1A(+/++) thyroid lobes are double the size of WT thyroids (P = .01), but the thyroglobulin stained surface in Dyrk1A(+/++) thyroids is less than a third as large at E17.5 (P = .04) and their differentiated follicular surface half the size (P = .004). We also observed a significant increase in Nkx2-1, Foxe1, and Pax8 RNA levels in E13.5 and E17.5 Dyrk1A(+/++) embryonic thyroids. Dyrk1A(+/++) young adult mice have significantly lower plasma T4 (2.4 ng/mL versus WT, 3.7 ng/mL; P = 0.019) and nonsignificantly higher plasma TSH (114 mUI/L versus WT, 73mUI/L; P = .09). In addition, their thyroids are significantly heavier (P = .04) and exhibit large disorganized regions. Dyrk1A overexpression directly leads to thyroidal embryogenetic, functional and morphological impairment. The young adult thyroid phenotype is probably a result of embryogenetic impairment. The Dyrk1A(+/++) mouse can be considered a suitable study model for thyroid dysgenesis in DS.

Identification of deletions in children with congenital hypothyroidism and thyroid dysgenesis with the use of multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification

INTRODUCTION

Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) is the most common cause of congenital hypothyroidism (CH). Important genetic factors possibly contributing to TD etiologies include mutations of thyroid transcription factors and TSHR-encoding genes.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to determine multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA) utility in detecting the copy number changes in patients with CH and TD.

METHODS

The study included 45 children from southeastern Poland selected via already established neonatal screening for CH. Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood samples and used in MLPA analysis. Genetic variations were analyzed within selected fragments of the PAX8, FOXE1, NKX2-1, thyroid stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR), and TPO genes.

RESULTS

Three heterozygous deletion types in probe hybridization regions were identified for the following genes: PAX8 (exon 7), TSHR (exon 2), and FOXE1 (exon 1). Monoallelic deletions were identified in 5/45 TD subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

MLPA is a useful tool for copy number changes detection and might both improve and expand genetic analysis for CH and TD.

TSH resistance revisited

Genetic defects of hormone receptors are the most common form of end-organ hormone resistance. One example of such defects is TSH resistance, which is caused by biallelic inactivating mutations in the TSH receptor gene (TSHR). TSH, a master regulator of thyroid functions, affects virtually all cellular processes involving thyroid hormone production, including thyroidal iodine uptake, thyroglobulin iodination, reuptake of iodinated thyroglobulin and thyroid cell growth. Resistance to TSH results in defective thyroid hormone production from the neonatal period, namely congenital hypothyroidism. Classically, clinical phenotypes of TSH resistance due to inactivating TSHR mutations were thought to vary depending on the residual mutant receptor activity. Nonfunctional mutations in the two alleles produce severe thyroid hypoplasia with overt hypothyroidism (uncompensated TSH resistance), while hypomorphic mutations in at least one allele produce normal-sized thyroid gland with preserved hormone-producing capacity (compensated TSH resistance). More recently, a new subgroup of TSH resistance (nonclassic TSH resistance) that is characterized by paradoxically high thyroidal iodine uptake has been reported. In this article, the pathophysiology and clinical features of TSH resistance due to inactivating TSHR mutations are reviewed, with particular attention to the nonclassic form.

Functional zebrafish studies based on human genotyping point to netrin-1 as a link between aberrant cardiovascular development and thyroid dysgenesis

Congenital hypothyroidism caused by thyroid dysgenesis (CHTD) is a common congenital disorder with a birth prevalence of 1 case in 4000 live births, and up to 8% of individuals with CHTD have co-occurring congenital heart disease. Initially we found nine patients with cardiac and thyroid congenital disorders in our cohort of 158 CHTD patients. To enrich for a rare phenotype likely to be genetically simpler, we selected three patients with a ventricular septal defect for molecular studies. Then, to assess whether rare de novo copy number variants and coding mutations in candidate genes are a source of genetic susceptibility, we used a genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphism array and Sanger sequencing to analyze blood DNA samples from selected patients with co-occurring CHTD a congenital heart disease. We found rare variants in all three patients, and we selected Netrin-1 as the biologically most plausible contributory factor for functional studies. In zebrafish, ntn1a and ntn1b were not expressed in thyroid tissue, but ntn1a was expressed in pharyngeal arch mesenchyme, and ntn1a-deficient embryos displayed defective aortic arch artery formation and abnormal thyroid morphogenesis. The functional activity of the thyroid in ntn1a-deficient larvae was, however, preserved. Phenotypic analysis of affected zebrafish indicates that abnormal thyroid morphogenesis resulted from a lack of proper guidance exerted by the dysplastic vasculature of ntn1a-deficient embryos. Hence, careful phenotyping of patients combined with molecular and functional studies in zebrafish identify Netrin-1 as a potential shared genetic factor for cardiac and thyroid congenital defects.

Extreme phenotypic variability of thyroid dysgenesis in six new cases of congenital hypothyroidism due to PAX8 gene loss-of-function mutations

CONTEXT

Within the last two decades, heterozygous loss-of-function PAX8 mutations have been reported in patients with a wide degree of thyroid gland dysfunction and growth despite the presence of identical mutations.

OBJECTIVES

To search for PAX8 mutations in a cohort of patients with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) and various types of thyroid gland defects.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional study was conducted in a cohort of patients.

SETTING

The French neonatal screening program was used for recruiting patients.

PATIENTS

A total of 118 patients with CH, including 45 with familial and 73 with sporadic diseases, were included in this study. The thyroid gland was normal in 23 patients had hypoplasia, 25 had hemithyroid agenesis, 21 had athyreosis, and 21 had ectopy.

RESULTS

We found four different PAX8 mutations (p.R31C, p.R31H, p.R108X, and p.I47T) in ten patients (six patients with CH and four family members), two with sporadic and eight with familial diseases. Imaging studies performed in the index cases showed ectopic thyroid gland (n=2), hypoplasia (n=2), eutopic lobar asymmetry (n=1), and eutopic gland compatible with dyshormonogenesis (n=1). The previously reported p.R31C and the novel p.I47T PAX8 mutations are devoid of activity.

CONCLUSION

Four different PAX8 mutations were detected in six index patients with CH (ten total subjects). The p.R31C, p.R31H, and p.R108X mutations have been reported. The novel p.I47T PAX8 mutation presented loss of function leading to CH. Thyroid ectopy was observed in two cases of PAX8 (p.R31H) mutation, a finding that has not been reported previously. We observed a high inter-individual and intra-familial variability of the phenotype in PAX8 mutations, underlining that population genetic studies for CH should include patients with various clinical presentations.

An essential splice site mutation (c.317+1G>A) in the TSHR gene leads to severe thyroid dysgenesis

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is the most common neonatal endocrine disorder and 2% of cases have familial origin. Our aim in this study was to determine the genetic alterations in two siblings with CH coming from a consanguineous family. Because CH is often inherited in autosomal recessive manner in consanguineous/multicase-families, we first performed genetic linkage studies to all known causative CH loci followed by conventional sequencing of the linked gene. The family showed potential linkage to the TSHR locus, and we detected an essential splice site mutation (c.317+1G>A) in both siblings. RT-PCR analysis confirmed the functionality of the mutation. The mutation was homozygous in the cases whereas heterozygous in carrier parents and an unaffected sibling. Here we conclude that thyroid agenesis in both siblings in this study originates from c.317+1G>A splice site mutation in the TSHR gene, and this study underlines the importance of detailed molecular genetic studies in the definitive diagnosis and classification of CH.

Identification of a novel pax8 gene sequence variant in four members of the same family: from congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia to mild subclinical hypothyroidism

BACKGROUND

Congenital hypothyroidism is often secondary to thyroid dysgenesis, including thyroid agenesis, hypoplasia, ectopic thyroid tissue or cysts. Loss of function mutations in TSHR, PAX8, NKX2.1, NKX2.5 and FOXE1 genes are responsible for some forms of inherited congenital hypothyroidism, with or without hypoplastic thyroid. The aim of this study was to analyse the PAX8 gene sequence in several members of the same family in order to understand whether the variable phenotypic expression, ranging from congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia to mild subclinical hypothyroidism, could be associated to the genetic variant in the PAX8 gene, detected in the proband.

METHODS

We screened a hypothyroid child with thyroid hypoplasia for mutations in PAX8, TSHR, NKX2.1, NKX2.5 and FOXE1 genes. We studied the inheritance of the new variant R133W detected in the PAX8 gene in the proband's family, and we looked for the same substitution in 115 Caucasian European subjects and in 26 hypothyroid children. Functional studies were performed to assess the in vitro effect of the newly identified PAX8 gene variant.

RESULTS

A new heterozygous nucleotide substitution was detected in the PAX8 DNA-binding motif (c.397C/T, R133W) in the proband, affected by congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia, in his older sister, displaying a subclinical hypothyroidism associated with thyroid hypoplasia and thyroid nodules, in his father, affected by hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia and thyroid nodules, and his first cousin as well, who revealed only a subclinical hypothyroidism. Functional studies of R133W-PAX8 in the HEK293 cells showed activation of the TG promoter comparable to the wild-type PAX8.

CONCLUSIONS

In vitro data do not prove that R133W-PAX8 is directly involved in the development of the thyroid phenotypes reported for family members carrying the substitution. However, it is reasonable to conceive that, in the cases of transcriptions factors, such as Pax8, which establish several interactions in different protein complexes, genetic variants could have an impact in vivo.

A deletion including exon 2 of the TSHR gene is associated with thyroid dysgenesis and severe congenital hypothyroidism

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is the most common neonatal endocrine disorder and 2% of cases have a familial origin. Our aim in this study was to determine the genetic alterations in two siblings with CH coming from a consanguineous family. As CH is often inherited in an autosomal recessive manner in consanguineous/multi case-families, we first performed genetic linkage studies to all known causative CH loci followed by conventional sequencing of the linked gene. The family showed potential linkage to the TSHR locus and our attempts to amplify and sequence exon 2 of the TSHR gene continuously failed. Subsequent RT-PCR analysis using mRNA and corresponding cDNA showed a large deletion including the exon 2 of the gene. The deletion was homozygous in affected cases whilst heterozygous in carrier parents. Here we conclude that CH in both siblings of this study originates from a large deletion including the exon 2 of the TSHR gene. This study demonstrates that full sequence analysis in a candidate CH gene might not always be enough to detect genetic alterations, and additional analyses such as RT-PCR and MLPA might be necessary to describe putative genetic causes of the disease in some cases. It also underlines the importance of detailed molecular genetic studies in the definitive diagnosis and classification of CH.

A new mutation in the promoter region of the PAX8 gene causes true congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid hypoplasia in a girl with Down's syndrome

BACKGROUND

Thyroid dysfunction is common in newborn infants with Down's syndrome (DS), but defects causing classic thyroid dysgenesis (TD) with permanent congenital hypothyroidism (CH) have not been described.

OBJECTIVE

We studied a girl with DS and CH who had a mutation in the promoter sequence of the PAX8 gene.

RESULTS

A female infant was found to have trisomy 21 and CH, with a venous thyrotropin (TSH) of >150 mU/L and a free thyroxine (fT4) of 15.1 pmol/L (day 12). Thyroid peroxidase antibodies and thyroglobulin antibodies were elevated. Scintigraphy showed normal uptake, but ultrasound identified a small gland with heterogenous echotexture and cystic changes. Sequence analysis of the PAX8 gene revealed a new heterozygous maternally inherited mutation (-3C>T) close to the transcription initiation site. Electromobility shift assay studies of the wild type and the mutant PAX8 sequence incubated with nuclear extracts from PCCL3 cells exhibited that the sequence at position -3 is not involved in specific protein binding. However, the mutant PAX8 promoter showed a significantly reduced transcriptional activation of a luciferase reporter gene in vitro tested in HEK, PCCL3, as well as in HeLa cells, indicating that this mutation is very likely to lead to reduced PAX8 expression.

CONCLUSIONS

The persistent CH in this patient with DS is likely to be attributable to the diminished PAX8 expression due to a new heterozygous mutation in the PAX8 promoter sequence. Our case shows that true CH may occur in DS, as in the general population. Furthermore, it is possible that the trisomy 21 itself may have resulted in a more severe phenotypic expression of the PAX8 mutation in the child than the mother.

A novel FOXE1 mutation (R73S) in Bamforth-Lazarus syndrome causing increased thyroidal gene expression

BACKGROUND

Homozygous loss-of-function mutations in the FOXE1 gene have been reported in several patients with partial or complete Bamforth-Lazarus syndrome: congenital hypothyroidism (CH) with thyroid dysgenesis (usually athyreosis), cleft palate, spiky hair, with or without choanal atresia, and bifid epiglottis. Here, our objective was to evaluate potential functional consequences of a FOXE1 mutation in a patient with a similar clinical phenotype.

METHODS

FOXE1 was sequenced in eight patients with thyroid dysgenesis and cleft palate. Transient transfection was performed in HEK293 cells using the thyroglobulin (TG) and thyroid peroxidase (TPO) promoters in luciferase reporter plasmids to assess the functional impact of the FOXE1 mutations. Primary human thyrocytes transfected with wild type and mutant FOXE1 served to assess the impact of the mutation on endogenous TG and TPO expression.

RESULTS

We identified and characterized the function of a new homozygous FOXE1 missense mutation (p.R73S) in a boy with a typical phenotype (athyreosis, cleft palate, and partial choanal atresia). This new mutation located within the forkhead domain was inherited from the heterozygous healthy consanguineous parents. In vitro functional studies in HEK293 cells showed that this mutant gene enhanced the activity of the TG and TPO gene promoters (1.5-fold and 1.7-fold respectively vs. wild type FOXE1; p<0.05), unlike the five mutations previously reported in Bamforth-Lazarus syndrome. The gain-of-function effect of the FOXE1-p.R73S mutant gene was confirmed by an increase in endogenous TG production in primary human thyrocytes.

CONCLUSION

We identified a new homozygous FOXE1 mutation responsible for enhanced expression of the TG and TPO genes in a boy whose phenotype is similar to that reported previously in patients with loss-of-function FOXE1 mutations. This finding further delineates the role for FOXE1 in both thyroid and palate development, and shows that enhanced gene activity should be considered among the mechanisms underlying Bamforth-Lazarus syndrome.

The absence of mutations in homeobox candidate genes HOXA3, HOXB3, HOXD3 and PITX2 in familial and sporadic thyroid hemiagenesis

BACKGROUND

The molecular mechanisms leading to the formation of the two thyroid symmetrical lobes, which are impaired in thyroid hemiagenesis (TH), are little known.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this work was to search for mutations in thyroid developmental candidate genes HOXA3, HOXB3, HOXD3 and PITX2.

METHODS

Total DNA from peripheral blood was extracted and then the entire coding region of all these genes was amplified by polymerase chain reaction and direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Herein we describe familial cases of TH in two generations (proband and his father), in addition to other two sporadic cases. We have found polymorphisms in the HOXB3 (rs2229304), HOXD3 (rs34729309, rs1051929, c.543-199G>T and c.543-34G>A; and a new synonymous variant, NP_008829.3:p.314;C>G) and PITX2 (c.45+76C>T) genes, but no deleterious mutations.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest the existence of other left-right thyroid asymmetry candidate genes in humans such as classical Mendelian mutation-causing disease, as well as other etiopathogenic mechanisms such as epigenetic modifications, especially for sporadic hemiagenesis.

Genetics of normal and abnormal thyroid development in humans

The most frequent cause of congenital hypothyroidism is thyroid dysgenesis. Thyroid dysgenesis summarizes a spectrum of developmental abnormalities of the embryonic thyroid ranging from complete absence of the thyroid gland (athyreosis), to a normally located but too small thyroid (hypoplasia), or an abnormally located thyroid gland (ectopy). Although considered a sporadic disease, distinct genetic forms of isolated or syndromic thyroid dysgenesis have been described in recent years. However, genetics of thyroid dysgenesis (TD) are mostly not following simple Mendelian patterns, and beside monogenic, multigenic and epigenetic mechanisms need to be considered. The review will highlight the molecular mechanisms of thyroid organogenesis, clinical and genetic features of the different monogenetic forms of thyroid dysgenesis, the aspects relevant for diagnosis and counseling of affected families and current research strategies to get more insight into the non-Medelian mechanisms of normal and abnormal thyroid development.

Clinical genetics of congenital hypothyroidism

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is a state of insufficient thyroid hormone supply to the organism, starting in utero. Two forms of permanent primary or thyroidal CH are known. Thyroid dysgenesis (TD) describes a spectrum of defects of thyroid organogenesis. Five monogenetic forms due to mutations in TSHR, PAX8, NKX2-1, FOXE1 and NKX2-5 have been identified so far. Thyroid dyshormonogenesis comprises defects at every step of thyroid hormone synthesis. Mutations in 7 genes are well described causing iodine transport defect (SLC5A5), iodine organification defect (TPO, DUOX2, DUOXA2, SLC26A4), thyroglobulin (TG) synthesis or transport defect or iodotyrosine deiodinase (IYD/DEHAL1) deficiency. The new consensus guidelines for CH recommend genetic counseling for each family with an affected child. Mode of inheritance, recurrence rate and possible associated malformations in the context of syndromic forms should be outlined. Molecular genetic studies should be preceded by a detailed phenotypic description of the patient's thyroid disease and a detailed family history. This review summarizes clinical, biochemical and radiological phenotypes and molecular aspects of the known genetic forms of TD and thyroid dyshormonogenesis relevant for genetic counseling and molecular studies.

Identification of PENDRIN (SLC26A4) mutations in patients with congenital hypothyroidism and "apparent" thyroid dysgenesis

CONTEXT

Congenital hypothyroidism, the most frequent endocrine congenital disease, can occur either based on a thyroid hormone biosynthesis defect or can predominantly be due to thyroid dysgenesis. However, a genetic cause could so far only be identified in less than 10% of patients with a thyroid dysgenesis.

OBJECTIVES

Exome sequencing was used for the first time to find additional genetic defects in thyroid dysgenesis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a consanguineous family with thyroid dysgenesis, exome sequencing was applied, and findings were further validated by Sanger sequencing in a cohort of 94 patients with thyroid dysgenesis.

RESULTS

By exome sequencing we identified a homozygous missense mutation (p.Leu597Ser) in the SLC26A4 gene of a patient with hypoplastic thyroid tissue, who was otherwise healthy. In the cohort of patients with thyroid dysgenesis, we observed a second case with a homozygous missense mutation (p.Gln413Arg) in the SLC26A4 gene, who was additionally affected by severe hearing problems. Both mutations were previously described as loss-of-function mutations in patients with Pendred syndrome and nonsyndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct.

CONCLUSION

We unexpectedly identified SLC26A4 mutations that were hitherto diagnosed in thyroid dyshormonogenesis patients, now for the first time in patients with structural thyroid defects. This result resembles the historic description of thyroid atrophy in patients with the so-called myxedematous form of cretinism after severe iodine deficiency. Most likely the thyroid defect of the two homozygous SLC26A4 gene mutation carriers represents a kind of secondary thyroid atrophy, rather than a primary defect of thyroid development in the sense of thyroid agenesis. Our study extends the variable clinical spectrum of patients with SLC26A4 mutations and points out the necessity to analyze the SLC26A4 gene in patients with apparent thyroid dysgenesis in addition to the known candidate genes TSHR, PAX8, NKX2.1, NKX2.5, and FOXE1.

The molecular causes of thyroid dysgenesis: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is a frequent disease occurring with an incidence of about 1/2500 newborns/year. In 80-85% of the cases CH is caused by alterations in thyroid morphogenesis, generally indicated by the term "thyroid dysgenesis" (TD). TD is generally a sporadic disease, but in about 5% of the cases a genetic origin has been demonstrated. In these cases, mutations in genes playing a role during thyroid morphogenesis (NKX2-1, PAX8, FOXE1, NKX2-5, TSHR) have been reported.

AIM

This work reviews the main steps of thyroid morphogenesis and all the genetic alterations associated with TD and published in the literature.

Two cases of thyroid dysgenesis caused by different novel PAX8 mutations in the DNA-binding region: in vitro studies reveal different pathogenic mechanisms

BACKGROUND

Mutations in PAX8, a transcription factor gene, cause thyroid dysgenesis (TD). The extreme variability of the thyroid phenotype makes it difficult to identify individuals harboring PAX8 gene mutations. Here we describe two patients with TD and report two novel PAX8 gene mutations (S54R and R133Q). We performed in vitro studies to functionally characterize these mutations.

METHODS

Using PAX8 expression vectors, we investigated whether the PAX8 mutants localized correctly to the nucleus. To analyze the DNA-binding properties of S54R and R133Q, electrophoretic mobility shift assays were performed. Furthermore, we measured whether the mutant PAX8 proteins were able to activate the thyroglobulin (TG)- and the thyroperoxidase (TPO)-promoters.

RESULTS

S54R had an impaired binding to DNA and a negligible activity on the TG- and the TPO-promoters. The DNA-binding property of R133Q, which is located in the highly conserved terminal portion of the PAX8 DNA-binding domain, was normal. Interestingly, it also exhibited dramatically impaired activation of the TG- and TPO-promoters. However, R133Q has no dominant negative effect on the WT protein in vitro. Thus, the underlying molecular mechanism by which the function of R133Q is impaired remains to be elucidated.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified and functionally characterized two novel mutations of the PAX8 gene that lead to TD by distinct mechanisms. A structural defect of the mutant R133Q leading to a reduced capability for induced fit upon DNA interaction might explain the disparity between its apparently normal binding to DNA, but lack of promoter activation.

Novel heterozygous thyrotropin receptor mutation presenting with neonatal hyperthyrotropinaemia, mild thyroid hypoplasia and absent uptake on radioisotope scan

Hyperthyrotropinaemia [mildly elevated thyrotropin (TSH) with normal thyroxine (T4) levels] demands a full assessment, including clinical examination, thyroid imaging and, where indicated, molecular genetic investigations. A male infant, both of whose parents were on T4 treatment, was referred at age 57 days with mild but persistent TSH elevation (12.7 mU/L) and normal free T4 (19.6 pmol/L), following notification by the screening laboratory of a capillary TSH of 10.7 mU/L (reference range, 1.7-9.1 mU/L) on day 8. Assessment showed a venous free T4 level of 15 pmol/L, venous TSH of 20.9 mU/L, serum thyroglobulin of 63 μg/L (reference range, <50 μg/L), and negative thyroglobulin and thyroid peroxidase antibodies. Thyroid ultrasound showed a eutopic, slightly small gland with heterogeneous texture; however, there was no uptake on radioisotope scan. Molecular genetic studies demonstrated a novel missense heterozygous mutation in the TSH receptor (TSHR) gene (c.1169G>T;p.Cys390Phe) in the child, mother and maternal grandmother, but not in the father. The infant was treated with T4 but this was discontinued at age 3 years when repeat testing showed a free T4 of 16.7 pmol/L (reference range, 9-23 pmol/L) and TSH of 8.5 mU/L (reference range, 0.3-5.5 mU/L). A heterozygous TSHR mutation should be considered in the context of hyperthyrotropinaemia and reduced/absent uptake on radioisotope scan. Detection of this mutation has allowed our patient to discontinue T4 treatment for the moment, with a view to staying off treatment in the long-term.