Double-blind, placebo-controlled immunotherapy with mixed grass-pollen allergoids. II. Comparison between parameters assessing the efficacy of immunotherapy

In vitro allergen-induced mRNA expression of signaling lymphocytic activation molecule by PBMC of patients with allergic rhinitis is increased during specific pollen immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Specific immunotherapy (SIT) acts by inducing a shift from T(H)2 to T(H)1 cell response on mucous membranes, reducing allergic inflammation. New genes expressed primarily in T(H)1-type cells have been found. Of these genes, signaling lymphocytic activation molecule (SLAM) promotes T-cell proliferation and IFN-gamma production. Nothing is known about its role in T(H)2-T(H)1 switch during SIT.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to analyze the mRNA expression of SLAM and other T(H)1-associated genes, interleukin-12 receptor beta2 (IL-12Rbeta2) and T-box expressed in T cells (T-bet), and compare them with the clinical outcome of the therapy.

METHODS

PBMC from 30 patients allergic to pollen undergoing SIT were collected during the therapy. Control PBMC were collected from 10 patients with allergic rhinitis not participating in SIT and from 10 nonallergic subjects. Cells were stimulated in vitro with pollen allergen extracts. SLAM, IL-12Rbeta2, and T-bet mRNA expressions were studied by real-time quantitative RT-PCR technique (Taqman). Symptom scoring and medication scoring were registered before commencement of SIT and after 1 year of the therapy.

RESULTS

Before the treatment, in vitro allergen-induced SLAM mRNA expression in PBMC was significantly lower in the patients with allergic rhinitis than in the healthy control subjects. After 1 year of the treatment, SLAM mRNA expression was increased in the patients undergoing SIT and was associated with IFN-gamma mRNA expression and inversely associated with the symptom improvement. At the maintenance dose, an increase in SLAM mRNA expression was associated with the clinical symptom improvement at 1 year. No changes were seen in IL-12Rbeta(2) or T-bet mRNA expressions.

CONCLUSIONS

SLAM mRNA expression in PBMC is modulated during the course of SIT, and an early and transient increase of SLAM mRNA expression is associated with clinical symptom improvement.

A double-blind, placebo-controlled immunotherapy dose-response study with standardized cat extract

BACKGROUND

Allergen immunotherapy with doses of cat extract containing approximately 15 microg of the major allergen, Fel d 1, have been proved clinically effective in several double-blind, placebo-controlled studies. However, the maintenance doses used in allergy practice in the United States are often considerably less than this proven dose.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this investigation was to determine whether maintenance immunotherapy with cat dander extract containing 0.6 microg or 3.0 microg of Fel d 1 was more effective than placebo and similar in efficacy to treatment with extracts containing 15.0 microg Fel d 1, immunologic parameters being used as the outcome.

METHODS

Twenty-eight cat-allergic patients were randomly entered, 7 in each group, into a double-blind, placebo-controlled comparison of the immunologic response to treatment with placebo or cat dander extract containing 0.6 microg, 3.0 microg, or 15.0 microg of Fel d 1. Maintenance doses were achieved in 8 visits over a period of 4 weeks through use of a cluster regimen; each subject then received 1 weekly maintenance injection before posttreatment measurements were made. The response to immunotherapy was assessed before immunotherapy and after the first weekly maintenance injection. Studies included responses to titrated skin prick tests to cat extract and an unrelated allergen and serum allergen-specific IgE and IgG4. Titrated nasal challenges were performed with cat extract; measurement of mRNA and secreted cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, and IFN-gamma) was done at 6 hours. Serum cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, IFN-gamma) were measured, and flow cytometric analysis of intracellular cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, IFN-gamma) was performed. Cat allergen-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation was performed with measurement of cytokines in the supernatant (IL-4, IL-5, IFN-gamma).

RESULTS

All 28 subjects completed the study. Significant and dose-dependent differences were encountered in the titrated skin prick tests (P =.008), the cat-specific IgG(4) (P =.01), and the reduction in CD4+/IL-4+ PBMCs on flow cytometry (P =.03). There were no significant differences between placebo and cat dander extract containing Fel d 1 0.6 microg. Both extracts containing 3.0 microg and 15.0 microg produced significant decreases in skin prick test sensitivity (P =.02 and P =.002, respectively). The extracts containing 3.0 microg and 15.0 microg produced significant increases in cat-specific IgG4 (P =.01 and P =.006, respectively). Only the 15.0-microg-per-dose extract produced a significant reduction in the percent of CD4+/IL-4+ PBMCs (P =.003).

CONCLUSION

In this double-blind, placebo-controlled study, a maintenance dose of cat dander extract containing 15.0 microg Fel d 1 produced the most consistent immunologic response. A dose of 3.0 microg reduced skin prick test sensitivity and increased cat-specific IgG4 but did not reduce the circulating CD4+/IL-4+ PBMCs, a change that is likely related to the clinically significant response to allergen immunotherapy. These findings suggest that a maintenance dose of 15.0 microg of Fel d 1 is most apt to be clinically effective for allergen immunotherapy.

The influence of a residual group in low-molecular-weight allergoids of Artemisia vulgaris pollen on their allergenicity, IgE- and IgG-binding properties

BACKGROUND

Reaction of epsilon-amino groups of lysine with potassium cyanate, maleic, or succinic anhydride leads to allergoids of low molecular weight. No study has been performed to compare their properties and investigate the influence of a residual group on allergenicity and human IgE- and IgG-binding of these derivatives.

METHODS

Allergoids of a pollen extract of Artemisia vulgaris were obtained by means of potassium cyanate, and succinic and maleic anhydride. Biochemical properties were investigated by determination of amino groups, enzyme activity, isoelectric focusing IEF and SDS-PAGE. IgE- and IgG-binding was determined using immunoblots and ELISA inhibition. Allergenicity was investigated by skin prick tests (SPT) on a group of 52 patients, of which 6 were control subjects, 30 were patients with no previous immunotherapy (IT), and 16 were patients undergoing immunotherapy.

RESULTS

The same degree of amino-group modification (more than 85%), residual enzyme activity (less then 15%), IEF, and SDS-PAGE pattern were noted. In the immunoblots of IgE-binding, there was more pronounced reduction in the succinyl and maleyl derivatives than in the carbamyl one. IgG-binding was less affected by carbamylation than by acid anhydride modification. The SPT showed that the succinylated derivative had the most reduced allergenicity (98% showed a reduced wheal diameter when tested with the succinyl derivative, 87% with the maleyl allergoid, and 83% with the carbamyl allergoid). The most significant difference among allergoids could be seen in the group of patients with high skin reactivity (83% of patients showed no reaction to the succinyl derivative when compared to the value of 28% for the carbamyl derivative or 22% for the maleyl derivative).

CONCLUSIONS

According to our results, all three modification procedures yielded allergoids with a similar extent of modification. No single biochemical parameter investigated in the study could predict the degree of reduced allergenicity in vivo. The most reduced allergenicity was seen in the succinyl derivative while the preservation of IgG binding epitopes was of the highest degree for the carbamyl derivative.

Measurement of changes in mRNA for IL-5 in noninvasive scrapings of nasal epithelium taken from patients undergoing nasal allergen challenge

Nasal allergen challenge of patients with allergic rhinitis results in increased numbers of inflammatory cells and increased production of pro-inflammatory cytokines including interleukin 5 (IL-5). We report a sensitive, noninvasive method to measure changes in the amount of mRNA for IL-5 in nasal epithelium and have used this method to detect alterations of IL-5 mRNA from patients undergoing a nasal allergen challenge. Ten grass or ragweed allergic adults were challenged out of season with appropriate pollen extracts at sufficient dose to give a rhinitis total symptom score of 5 on a scale of 12. After allergen exposure, symptoms were recorded hourly. At 0, 3, and 6 h after allergen exposure, secreted proteins were collected on filter paper strips and two superficial scrapings of nasal epithelium were obtained. The scrapings of epithelium were immediately immersed in 100 microl of RNAlater (Ambion, Austin, TX) and stored at 4 degrees C for up to 1 month without loss of RNA quality. Total RNA was isolated and RT-PCR was performed. cDNA for IL-5 was then measured by real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR with Pre-Developed TaqMan Assay Reagents (PE Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Sufficient RNA was isolated from eight subjects to measure IL-5 mRNA. Data were normalized for content of ribosomal RNA. The relative amount of cDNA for IL-5 was calculated by comparison with internal standards prepared from phytohemagluttinin-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Messenger RNA for IL-5 was increased 8.7+/-2.7-fold at 3 h (p<0.01) and 39.5+/-20.9-fold at 6 h (p<0.01). Increased IL-5 mRNA levels at 6 h closely correlate with total symptom scores at 6 h (r=0.88; p=0.007). IL-5 protein was measured by ELISA in eluates from the filter papers. At 6 h, there was increased IL-5 protein (7.7+/-2.8 ng/ml) compared with time zero (1.8+/-0.5 ng/ml) (p=0.02). The levels of IL-5 protein did not correlate significantly with the symptoms score or with changes in the levels of IL-5 protein with IL-5 mRNA. These data show that changes in IL-5 mRNA in patients with allergic rhinitis undergoing an allergen challenge correlate with total symptom scores better than changes in IL-5 protein eluted from filter paper. Furthermore, these changes can be measured quantitatively in very small amounts of tissue.

Clustered schedules in allergen-specific immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Injective immunotherapy is traditionally performed with a build-up phase lasting 3 to 4 months. The costs, decreasing compliance from both patients and clinicians and inconveniences due to this schedule may be overcome using different schedules.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A revision of the published papers with clustered schedules has been made. Attention has been focussed on tolerance and its relationships with relevant parameters such as kind of extract (aqueous or depot), allergens and their pharmaceutical presentation, schedule followed, use or not of a premedication, clinical manifestations of patients before treatment. For a better revision, papers dealing with clustered schedules have been divided into two groups. The first group includes 20 papers not designed to study the clustered schedule but using it to study other parameters affected by specific immunotherapy. The second group includes 9 papers specifically or mainly designed to study the clustered schedule. A huge difference in the rate of side effects could be assessed among different papers, even in studies run with similar allergens from the same producer and with a similar schedule.

CONCLUSIONS

Summarizing the results of the revision, the following conditions seem to lead to the optimal tolerance of the clustered schedule: use of a premedication; use of a depot preparation; use of no more than 4 administrations per cluster; administration of 1-2 clusters per week and of 4 to 6 clusters in total. These results seem promising but further efforts are required to better define the optimal clustered schedule.

Immunotherapy with keyhole lampet hemocyanin-conjugated decapeptide vaccine in cypress pollen allergy

BACKGROUND

Cupressaceae pollen allergy is a world-wide pollinosis but immunotherapy has rarely been tested. Immunotherapy is usually allergen-specific but new forms may be targeted towards IgE.

OBJECTIVES

A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial was carried out to assess the efficacy of a vaccine made of keyhole lampet hemocyanin (KLH)-conjugated decapeptide from the Fc(epsilon4) domain of the IgE in cypress pollinosis.

METHODS

Sixty patients with cypress pollen allergy were studied. They were included on a suggestive clinical history, positive skin tests and nasal challenge to cypress pollen extract. Three intramuscular injections of the vaccine (250 microg) or placebo were administered monthly with a booster injection 5 to 8 weeks later. The primary end-point criterion was the threshold dose inducing a positive nasal challenge. The secondary end-point was the symptom-medication scores measured when cypress pollen grains were over 50 grains/m3.

RESULTS

Nasal challenge before treatment was non-significantly different between the placebo and vaccine groups. After treatment there was no significant difference between the two groups. Pollen counts were over 50 grains/m3 for 8 weeks during the trial. There was no significant difference in total symptom scores between the placebo and vaccine groups. The vaccine was safe.

CONCLUSIONS

The KLH-conjugated decapeptide vaccine was not effective in cypress pollen allergy.

Recombinant Lactobacillus plantarum inhibits house dust mite-specific T-cell responses

Recent evidence suggests that chronic exposure to lactobacilli, which are part of the normal intestinal flora, inhibits the development of allergic disorders. Allergy is mediated by Th2 cells, which produce high levels of IL4 and IL5, and suppressive effects of lactic acid bacteria on the development of allergy have been attributed to their Th1-inducing properties. On the other hand, lactic acid bacteria have also been shown to suppress autoimmune disorders which are mediated by Th1 cells producing high levels of IFNgamma. To study this apparent discrepancy, the immunomodulatory potential of lactobacilli was evaluated using recombinants that express an immunodominant T-cell epitope of Der p 1 of house dust mites. Mucosal immunization of C57BL/6 J mice with such recombinants resulted in the induction of T cells which produced low amounts of IFNgamma. Immunization with the house dust mite peptide followed by treatment with recombinant Lactobacillus plantarum resulted in the inhibition of both IFNgamma and IL5 production. The effect on IFNgamma production was shown to be a non-specific effect of L. plantarum. The effect on IL5 production, however, was only observed when the recombinant expressing the Der p 1 peptide, but not the control recombinant, was used for treatment. Neither of the recombinants had an effect on the antibody response. Taken together, these data suggest that recombinant L. plantarum may be a suitable candidate for the treatment of allergic disorders.

Pollen-specific rush immunotherapy: clinical efficacy and effects on antibody concentrations

BACKGROUND

Studies of rush immunotherapy (RIT) with standardized extracts for the treatment of seasonal pollen allergy are few, especially for birch-pollen RIT.

OBJECTIVE

The study was performed to investigate the efficacy of RIT with standardized birch- or timothy-pollen extracts. Further, the serum antibody levels were evaluated for correlation with clinical efficacy.

METHODS

This open, longitudinal study included 30 allergic patients treated with RIT and 16 allergic patients serving as a control group. The therapy was continued for 3 years and blood samples were collected at regular intervals for antibody measurements using the Pharmacia CAP System.

RESULTS

The RIT was generally well tolerated. An increase in the total and specific IgE concentrations during the early months of RIT was observed, followed by decreased levels. Specific IgG and IgG4 increased continuously for 2 years. The symptom and medication scores were significantly decreased, compared with preRIT, at both the first and third pollen seasons after the start of RIT treatment (P < .0001 and P < .001, respectively). The clinical improvement during RIT was significantly greater compared with the control group (P < .05). The decreased medication and the symptom improvement during the third year of RIT correlated with the relative decrease in specific IgE (rs = .52, P < .05) and with the specific IgG4 level before the start of RIT (rs= -.68, P < .01), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study indicates that RIT with standardized birch- or timothypollen extracts is clinically effective and safe. Measurements of specific antibody levels during treatment may be helpful in monitoring RIT.

The role of allergen-specific T cells in the allergic immune response: relevance to allergy vaccination

Recent research has elucidated many of the immunologic mechanisms that underlie atopic allergies. In particular, it has become clear that the role of CD4+ allergen-specific T cells is crucial for the induction of IgE and eosinophilia, factors that mediate the immediate hypersensitivity reaction and late-phase responses, respectively. Therefore, the reactivity patterns and activation requirements of allergen-specific T cells are important parameters for understanding and manipulating the allergic immune response. This review addresses these issues and discusses their relevance to the further development of allergy vaccines.

Comparison between nasal provocation tests and skin tests in patients treated with loratadine and cetirizine

BACKGROUND

The effect of H1-blockers may differ depending on the target organ.

OBJECTIVE

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study was carried out to compare the effect of a 7-day treatment with loratadine (10 mg daily) or cetirizine (10 mg daily) on nasal challenge with grass pollen grains and skin tests with allergen or histamine.

METHODS

Twenty-four patients were enrolled, but the analysis was carried out on 23. Nasal challenge was carried out by using 5-fold increasing numbers of pollen grains. Skin prick tests were done with serial concentrations of allergens and 1 concentration of histamine. Patients were tested in a cross-over design, with each treatment being administered for the previous 7 days and with a 2-week washout period.

RESULTS

By comparison with placebo, loratadine and cetirizine increased significantly the threshold number of pollen grains required to induce a positive nasal challenge (P <.001). There was no difference between loratadine and cetirizine. Skin test responses to allergen were significantly reduced by loratadine and cetirizine by comparison with placebo. Skin test responses to histamine were significantly decreased by the 2 H1-blockers, but they were more profoundly decreased by cetirizine than by loratadine.

CONCLUSIONS

Both H1-blockers reduced similarly allergen-induced skin test and nasal challenge responses. Cetirizine was more effective on histamine skin test responses.

Repeated allergen challenge as a new research model for studying allergic reactions

Repeated allergen challenge might be a more relevant model for studying symptomatic disease, because it gives more information on the patient's handling of chronic allergen exposure. Thus, this experimental model has more resemblance to the situation of natural allergen exposure, and the allergen load can be standardized. However, the response to repeated allergen challenge in individual patients can show a large variation, that is from a strongly enhanced response to complete diminution of the response. Successful allergen immunotherapy can change the response pattern of repeated allergen challenge in the skin into down-regulation of the late reaction. Chronic or repeated allergen exposure may result in an enhanced allergen-specific allergic response, involving allergen-specific T-cell activation. Different subsets of T cells can exert either activating or suppressive effects on inflammatory cells involved in subsequent allergic reactions. CD8+ T cells might exert suppressive effects, because they seem to be associated with a subsequent down-regulation of the late skin reaction after repeated allergen challenge (Fig. 4). Further studies are needed to compare the responses to repeated allergen challenge with the response to natural seasonal allergen exposure in the same patients and to explore possible underlying mechanisms using, for example, nasal biopsies.

Physicochemical and immunologic characterization of low-molecular-weight allergoids of Dactylis glomerata pollen proteins

BACKGROUND

Orchard grass (Dactylis glomerata) pollen proteins were chemically modified by means of acid anhydrides (maleic and succinic anhydride) to obtain low-molecular-weight allergoids. Chemical modification in both cases led to the replacement of one positive charge (epsilon amino group of Lys) by one negative charge, yielding proteins with changed physicochemical properties in comparison to the native orchard grass-pollen proteins.

METHODS

Physicochemical characterization of derivatives was done by gel chromatography, SDS-PAGE, and isoelectric focusing. To examine the IgE-binding properties of these derivatives, we carried out immunoblotting. To examine the ability of derivatives to induce IgG production, we immunized rabbits. Skin prick testing with the allergoids was performed on 15 individuals allergic to orchard grass pollens and on two healthy subjects.

RESULTS

It was shown that the modified proteins retain their original molecular weights, but change pI to more acidic values. In the case of allergoids, a strong reduction in IgE binding was found. Immunization of rabbits with allergoids showed that the derivatives retain the ability to induce IgG production, and that the antisera obtained in such a way react to native (unmodified) extract. The ability of derivatives to induce allergic reaction was significantly reduced. The patients (86.6%) included in our study exhibited less than 50% of native extract response. Among them, 53.3% had no response to one or both allergoids.

CONCLUSIONS

These modification procedures yield allergoids with a reduced allergenic activity and preserved immunogenic potential suitable for use in immunotherapy.

Changes in skin-test reactivity do not correlate with clinical efficacy of H1-blockers in seasonal allergic rhinitis

New-generation H1-blockers may possess antiallergic properties, and their effect may differ, depending on the target organ. A double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-group study was carried out during the pollen season to compare the clinical effect on nasal and conjunctival symptoms of astemizole (10 mg o.d.) and loratadine (10 mg o.d.) with their effect on skin-test reactivity to allergen and histamine. Thirty-eight patients (12-56 years of age) were studied. Nasal and ocular symptoms were recorded daily from days 4 to 7. Skin prick tests with serial concentrations of allergens and one concentration of histamine were carried out before and at the end of the 7-day treatment period. Parallel-line bioassay, analysis of variance, and covariance were used to analyze skin test data. Loratadine and astemizole significantly decreased symptoms from baseline (P < 0.004 and P < 0.006). Skin-test reactivity to allergen and histamine was more profoundly decreased by astemizole than loratadine. The histamine covariant was more important in the allergen effect of astemizole than in that of loratadine. Two H1-blockers having the same clinical effect on nasal and ocular symptoms during the pollen season have totally different effects on skin-test reactivity. Skin-test reactivity to allergen or histamine is not predictive of the clinical efficacy of H1-blockers during seasonal allergic rhinitis.

Effects of peptide therapy on ex vivo T-cell responses

BACKGROUND

Peptide therapy targets T cells directly with short peptides containing multiple T-cell receptor epitopes. Murine studies suggest T-cell anergy as the mechanism of action; however, changes in T-cell cytokine profiles may be more relevant in human beings.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to study the effects of peptide therapy on ex vivo antigen-specific T-cell responses.

METHODS

Antigen-specific T-cell lines were generated from subjects enrolled in a double-blind, placebo controlled, two-dose study of the ALLERVAX CAT therapeutic, containing Fel d 1 peptides (ImmuLogic Pharmaceutical Corp., Waltham, Mass.) (n = 7, 8, and 7, respectively, for groups receiving placebo, 75 microg, or 750 microg). Each subject had three lines propagated before and after receiving peptide therapy; antigens used were cat hair extract, Fel d 1 peptides, and tetanus toxoid (negative control). Proliferative responses and cytokine generation from each line were assessed after two restimulations with antigen and autologous antigen-presenting cells.

RESULTS

The Fel d 1 peptide lines showed a dose-dependent decrease of IL-4 production (p = 0.02 and 0.025, respectively, for the 750 microg group vs both the 75 microg and placebo groups). IL-4 production from the cat hair allergen extract lines and interferon-gamma production from both the Fel d 1 peptide lines and cat hair allergen extract lines showed no statistically significant changes. The control tetanus toxoid lines showed no changes in cytokine production; there were no significant changes in proliferation with any of the antigens in any of the treatment groups. In the clinical arm of the trial, only the 750 microg dose of peptides produced a significant response.

CONCLUSIONS

Peptide therapy induces a significant, dose-dependent decrease in peptide-stimulated IL-4 production, consistent with either a shift in T-cell phenotype or peptide-specific T-cell tolerance.

Allergen-specific increase in interleukin (IL)-4 and IL-5 secretion from peripheral blood mononuclear cells during birch-pollen immunotherapy

The mechanisms behind the effects of immunotherapy (IT) with birch-pollen extract are largely unknown. In this pilot study, we measured the cytokine secretion in vitro from peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) obtained from birch-pollen-allergic patients undergoing IT treatment (n = 4) or placebo administration (n = 4), collected before treatment, 1 and 4 weeks after start of treatment, and during and just after the pollen season (12-14 weeks after start of treatment). The PBMC were stimulated with birch-pollen extract in vitro for 7 days, followed by restimulation with the mitogens phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) for 24 h, to enhance the production of cytokines. The supernatants were analyzed with ELISA and radioimmunoassay for interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), interleukin (IL)-4, and IL-5. In the therapy group, we noted an increased secretion of IL-4 and IL-5 from PBMC collected at 4 weeks after the start of treatment (IL-4: 29 +/- 21 pg/ml [day 0] to 374 +/- 448 pg/ml [week 4], mean +/- SD; IL-5: 95 +/- 48 pg/ml to 1147 +/- 697 pg/ml). No increase was seen in the placebo group. During the pollen season, we noted a trend toward increased IL-4 and IL-5 secretion in both groups. We conclude that the temporary increase in serum IgE observed in many IT studies may be a consequence of increased IL-4 production due to the allergen exposure.

Immunotherapy with standardized extract of Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus in bronchial asthma: a dose-titration study

According to the maximum tolerated dose (MTD) achieved, we assessed the changes in clinical and laboratory parameters, induced by specific immunotherapy (SIT), in a group of 43 asthmatic patients sensitized to Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus, over a period of 18 months. A standardized extract (100 Bu/ml; 40 micrograms/ml of Der p 1; 20 micrograms/ml of Der p 2) was used. The patients were divided into two groups: the high-dose immunotherapy (HDI) group (MTD > or = 4 micrograms Der p I) and the conventional immunotherapy (CI) group (MTD < 4 micrograms Der p 1). Changes in clinical severity index, medication, and symptom scores; in cutaneous and conjunctival reactivity; and in the levels of specific IgE, IgG, IgG1, and IgG4 to D. pteronyssinus (Der p 1 and Der p 2) were measured (ELISA monoclonal antibodies). Safety was monitored according to the EAACI guidelines. The range of the MTD was 0.8-16 micrograms of Der p 1. Ninety percent of the patients tolerated a dose of 3.2 micrograms, but only 18% of the patients reached a maintenance dose of 16 micrograms. The medians of the accumulated dose were 197 micrograms of Der p 1 for the HDI group, and 50 micrograms for the CI group. Conjunctival and cutaneous reactivity was significantly lowered (P < 0.001) after SIT, as were the clinical severity score and medication score in both groups, without significant differences between the groups, except for cutaneous reactivity. Levels of specific IgE decreased significantly (P < 0.01) in both groups, again without significant differences between the groups. The range of the increase in medians of specific IgG, IgG1, and IgG4 was 4.4-120-fold for the HDI group and 3-24-fold for the CI group (P < 0.01). The increase in the levels of Der p 1 and Der p 2 IgG4 were correlated to the changes in cutaneous and conjunctival reactivity (P < 0.01). These results show that a maintenance dose of 3.2 micrograms Der p 1 (8 BU) can induce pronounced clinical and immunologic changes with an excellent safety profile.

Immunotherapy with an alum-adsorbed Parietaria-pollen allergoid: a 2-year, double-blind, placebo-controlled study

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study was performed in order to confirm the safety, suitability, and efficacy of an alum-adsorbed Parietaria judaica-pollen allergoid, Allergovit, for allergen-specific immunotherapy. Parietaria pollen is an important cause of pollinosis, particularly in the Mediterranean zone, where it may be encountered for up to 8-9 months of the year. It is an aggressive allergen, and the doses tolerated during immunotherapy are less than those achieved with grass pollen. This factor increases the desirability of using therapeutic preparations with minimal IgE-binding activity, such as allergoids, in order to reduce the risk of side-effects and enable patients to tolerate a higher dose of allergen, thereby increasing the chances of successful specific immunotherapy. Forty patients with rhinitis and/or asthma were allocated at random to active- or placebo-treatment groups at the beginning of the study. All patients received the active preparation during the second year of the study. Immunotherapy was well tolerated by all patients and the incidence of side-effects was low. Treatment resulted in significant reductions in specific cutaneous reactivity and increases in nasal tolerance. A progressive improvement in nasal inspiratory peak flow in association with the immunotherapy indicated a reduction in nasal inflammation. These objective assessments of efficacy endorsed the results from the patients' diary cards, which indicated significant improvements in symptoms and reductions in the use of medication. The immunologic activity of the therapeutic preparation was demonstrated by the induction of a significant specific-IgG antibody response, with increases in IgG4 during the second year of treatment. We conclude that the safety and efficacy of immunotherapy with the Parietaria allergoid make it suitable for consideration in the treatment of patients with Parietaria-pollen-induced rhinitis or asthma.

Efficacy of immunotherapy to ragweed antigen tested by controlled antigen exposure

BACKGROUND

Immunotherapy is a recognized component in the management of allergic rhinitis. Its efficacy has been evaluated in a number of clinical field trials. These methods of evaluation are limited by control of antigen exposure.

OBJECTIVE

A study was designed to evaluate the efficacy of immunotherapy in ragweed-induced rhinoconjunctivitis using an environmental exposure unit.

METHODS

Forty-three subjects were grouped into (1) immunotherapy group: ragweed-allergic subjects on maintenance ragweed immunotherapy for at least 2 years (N = 16), (2) positive control group: ragweed-allergic subjects who had never received immunotherapy (n = 16), and (3) negative control group: ragweed-nonallergic subjects (N = 11). Ragweed specific skin tests and ragweed IgE levels were obtained prior to exposure. The study was done in a room where levels of 2,500 to 3,000 grains m3 of ragweed were maintained over three hours. Symptoms were recorded every 15 minutes.

RESULTS

Nasal symptoms in the immunotherapy group were significantly less than in the positive control group after 45 minutes (P = .025). Significant differences were not observed for ocular symptoms. Combined nasal and ocular scores were 50% less in the immunotherapy group than in the positive control group by 75 minutes (P = .039). Ragweed-specific skin tests and IgE were significantly less in the immunotherapy group than in the positive control group. Rhinoconjunctivitis symptoms in the negative control group were absent throughout.

CONCLUSIONS

Controlled ragweed pollen exposure in this setting demonstrated that ragweed immunotherapy significantly reduced symptoms of ragweed-allergic rhinitis but had no significant effect on ocular symptoms. This system presents opportunities for additional studies on immunotherapy for allergic respiratory conditions.

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study of immunotherapy with grass-pollen extract Alutard SQ during a 3-year period with initial rush immunotherapy

Thirty patients with asthma and/or monosensitized allergic rhinitis caused by grass pollen whose ages ranged from 15 to 35 years were selected. Two groups were established at random: an active group and a placebo group, and a double-blind study was done on treatment with immunotherapy for a period of 3 continuous years, with initiation doses administered according to the rush immunotherapy technique. Grass-pollen allergen extract Alutard SQ and histamine as a placebo were used. The objective parameters of efficacy evaluated were end-point cutaneous tests, conjunctival provocation, bronchial provocation, and symptom/medication scores, as well as specific immunoglobulin determinations. The statistical evaluation of the results was significant for the differences existing between the initial and final time of the active group, and there were significant differences between the two groups for all of the parameters considered. We found no relationship between clinical improvement and the range of specific immunoglobulin E values. Regarding the safety of the treatment, systemic adverse effects were manifested only in the initial phase (rush immunotherapy), and were easily controlled by treatment. We conclude that the efficacy and safety of immunotherapy with grass pollen make it possible to consider this treatment fundamental in these patients.

Immunotherapy with a standardized Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus extract. V. Duration of the efficacy of immunotherapy after its cessation

Specific immunotherapy (SIT) using a standardized mite extract is effective and safe when administered under optimal conditions. However, the duration of its effectiveness after cessation of treatment remains unknown. Forty asthmatic subjects who had received SIT with a standardized Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Der p) extract under the same protocol were studied. All had received SIT for a period of 12-96 months and were not receiving pharmacologic treatment. The FEV1 was within normal range in all patients. After cessation of treatment, patients were followed for up to 3 years at 6-month intervals. The patient was considered to have relapsed when symptoms of asthma and/or rhinitis occurred and/or when pulmonary function tests were impaired. Skin tests with increasing concentrations of Der p were carried out before and at the end of SIT. Forty-five percent of the patients did not relapse. The duration of efficacy of SIT was related to the duration of SIT itself (P < 0.04). Most patients who did not relapse had a decrease in skin test reactivity at the end of SIT, whereas most patients who relapsed did not show any change (P < 0.003). The duration of efficacy of SIT after its cessation depends upon the duration of SIT and may be predicted by the effect of SIT on skin tests.

An assessment of the role of intradermal skin testing in the diagnosis of clinically relevant allergy to timothy grass

BACKGROUND

Immediate skin testing is generally the preferred method for establishing the presence of allergy in clinical practice. There is no agreement, however, as to whether intradermal testing should be routinely performed if skin prick test results are negative.

PURPOSE

The study was done to address the value of intradermal skin testing in the diagnosis of clinically significant sensitivity to grass pollen in patients exhibiting negative skin prick test responses to timothy extract.

METHODS

Four groups were studied. Group I had a history of seasonal allergic rhinitis, negative skin prick test responses to timothy and Bermuda grass, but positive intradermal skin test responses to timothy grass. Group II had a history of seasonal allergic rhinitis and positive skin prick test responses to timothy grass. Group III had a history of seasonal allergic rhinitis but had negative responses to both prick and intradermal testing with timothy and Bermuda grass. Group IV had no history of rhinitis, had negative responses to skin testing with a panel of locally important allergens, as well as Bermuda and timothy grass, and had a serum IgE value of less than 20 IU/ml. Clinical sensitivity to grass was assessed by two methods: (1) nasal challenge with threefold increasing amounts of timothy pollen performed out of the pollen season and (2) correlation of subjects' daily symptom and medication scores with daily grass pollen counts during the grass pollen season.

RESULTS

On the basis of nasal challenge with timothy grass, pollen allergic reactions were present in 11% of group I, 68% of group II, 11% of group III, and 0% of group IV. As determined by correlation of symptoms during the grass pollen season with grass pollen counts, 22% of group I, 64% of group II, 21% of group III, and 0% of group IV were considered allergic. If both criteria were required for a diagnosis of clinical allergy to grass, the percent positive was 0 for group I, 46 for group II, 0 for group III, and 0 for group IV.

CONCLUSION

Under the conditions of this study the presence of a positive intradermal skin test response to timothy grass (1000 AU/ml) in the presence of a negative skin prick test response to timothy grass (100,000 AU/ml) did not indicate the presence of clinically significant sensitivity to timothy grass, and by inference, to other cross-reacting grasses.

Double-blind trial of house-dust mite immunotherapy in asthmatic children resident at high altitude

Twenty-three Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Dpt)-sensitive asthmatic children aged 7-14 years entered a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of standardized immunotherapy (IT) (Alpare) while resident at high altitude. Dpt sensitivity was evaluated by skin prick tests at different allergen concentrations at the enrollment and after 6 and 12 months of treatment. Bronchial hyperreactivity was evaluated at the same time points, and on each occasion, histamine challenge and, the following day, Dpt bronchial challenge were performed. All patients, irrespective of active treatment, improved clinically and in lung function with increased PC20 and Dpt-PD20. Alpare-treated patients had a significantly decreased sensitivity on Dpt skin testing (P < 0.009) and felt that their asthma had improved (P < 0.001) compared with placebo-treated subjects, but there was no difference between the treatment groups in lung function or bronchial challenge response. IT neither increased nor decreased bronchial histamine sensitivity. Our results indicate that Dpt IT benefits asthmatic children, but improvement by allergen avoidance at high altitude is even greater.

Grass pollen immunotherapy: efficacy and safety during a 4-year follow-up study

Grass pollen immunotherapy is effective, although efficacy must be balanced against side-effects. In a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 40 adult patients with summer hay fever, immunotherapy with a depot grass pollen extract (Phleum pratense, Alutard SQ) reduced symptoms and medication requirements with an acceptable minimal level of side-effects (31). The original placebo group, as well as the actively treated group, have now received active immunotherapy in an open fashion for a further 3 years. An important question was whether continued injection treatment was accompanied by maintained clinical improvement. By analysis of diary symptoms, rescue medication, and visual analogue scores during the pollen season, we show that efficacy was maintained throughout the 3-4-year study period. Clinical improvement was accompanied by a sustained and marked decrease in immediate conjunctival allergen sensitivity and a further significant decrease in the size of the allergen-induced late cutaneous response. In contrast, an initial decrease in the allergen-induced immediate cutaneous response was not maintained at 3-4 years. Of the patients, 37/40 completed the first year, 33/40 the second year, and 32/40 the third year of treatment. Patients dropped out for reasons other than the outcome of immunotherapy. During a total of 2598 injections, five immediate systemic reactions were observed, all during the induction (not maintenance) phase, and all occurred within 10 min of injection and responded promptly to adrenaline. Grass pollen immunotherapy is effective and safe, provided it is performed on carefully selected patients by trained physicians with immediate access to resuscitative measures.

Nasal histamine challenge in nonallergic and allergic subjects evaluated by acoustic rhinometry

Nasal patency shows spontaneous variations but is influenced by a number of factors like exercise and allergic conditions. Nasal histamine challenge has been used to define nasal hypersensitivity. We have applied acoustic rhinometry as a new objective method to study the spontaneous variations of the nasal mucosa and its response to histamine challenge in 12 nonallergic subjects and 12 subjects with nasal allergy to pollen, but out of the pollen season. Measurements of the minimum cross-sectional area and the volume of the nasal cavities were done every 15 min for 6 h. More pronounced spontaneous variations, defined by the coefficient of variation of the measurements, were encountered in the allergic than in the nonallergic subjects, especially with regard to the minimum cross-sectional areas in the nasal cavities (P < 0.02). Allergic subjects showed increased sensitivity to histamine, as compared with nonallergic subjects, during low-concentration (0.1%) challenge (P < 0.05) and a prolonged effect of histamine challenge (P = 0.01). Antihistamine (cetirizine) had a significant effect on the histamine-induced symptoms and decrease of nasal dimensions during histamine challenge, but no significant effect on pollen-induced changes. In the allergic group, the decrease in minimum area during allergen provocation correlated with the level of specific IgE (r = 0.81; P = 0.0015).

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study of immunotherapy with an alginate-conjugated extract of Parietaria judaica in patients with Parietaria hay fever

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study was conducted to evaluate the efficacy and safety of immunotherapy (IT) with a partially purified alginate-conjugated extract of Parietaria judaica (Conjuvac Parietaria, Dome/Hollister-Stier) in patients suffering from rhinoconjunctivitis caused by Parietaria pollen. Eighteen patients (10 women, 8 men, mean age 35 years) received active treatment and 17 (10 women, 7 men, mean age 42.5 years) received placebo. Actively treated patients had significantly lower nasal symptom/medication scores (running nose P = 0.0087 and sneezing P = 0.048) during the Parietaria pollen season. Significant decreases in specific skin (P < 0.01), nasal (P < 0.05), and conjunctival (P < 0.01) reactivity to the Parietaria extract and significant increases of specific IgG (P < 0.001), IgG1 (P < 0.001), and IgG4 (P < 0.001) in actively treated patients, but not in placebo, were found. IT was well tolerated, the active extract inducing five mild systemic reactions (four rhinitis and one urticaria) and placebo two (rhinitis). A significant correlation was found between low skin reactivity and high specific IgG (P = 0.0002) and IgG4 (P = 0.036). These findings indicate that IT with a partially purified P. judaica extract is an effective and safe treatment for Parietaria pollen allergy. The correlation between low immediate skin reactivity and high specific IgG and IgG4 suggests that, at least in the studied cutaneous model, these antibodies may exert a blocking effect.

Precise area determination of skin-prick tests: validation of a scanning device and software for a personal computer

When skin-prick tests (SPTs) are used quantitatively, the circumference of the weal and/or the flare is outlined using a felt tip pen, and transferred to paper by adhesive tape. The aim of the study was to develop and validate a procedure, objectively and precisely determining these areas after transfer to paper. A system was developed enabling the drawing of the area of weal or flare to be read by a hand-held scanner and calculated on a personal computer. Areas in the 5-500 mm2 range could be determined with day-to-day and interoperator coefficients of variation (CVs) of 3.1% and 1.8%, respectively. Accuracy was determined in two ways: by correlation to cutting/weighing of four times enlarged SPT areas (r2 = 0.999, P < 0.001) and by measuring standardized areas (deviations less than intra-assay CV, i.e. 1-2%). For comparison, CV of alternative methods were also determined: eight different areas (9-76 mm2) were evaluated in quadruplicate using the SPT-scanner (CV = 1.4%), by cutting/weighing of paper (CV = 2.3%), by digitizing (CV = 4.4%) or by measuring longest and orthogonal diameters (CV = 13.6%). In conclusion, the scanning device and software provides an objective and reproducible procedure for rapid determination of SPT areas. When areas are determined by scanning, digitizing or cutting/weighing the variations in area determination becomes negligible compared to the variations of the entire skin test procedure.

Indirect evidence of nasal inflammation assessed by titration of inflammatory mediators and enumeration of cells in nasal secretions of patients with chronic rhinitis

Pathophysiologic mechanisms of perennial rhinitis are poorly understood. The characterization of inflammation was studied in nasal lavage of patients with perennial rhinitis by the enumeration of cells involved in the allergic inflammation and the measurement of six mediators released in nasal secretions to determine whether some mediators were relevant for the etiologic diagnosis and the occurrence of symptoms. Ten healthy subjects and 57 patients with perennial rhinitis were placed into four groups according to the symptoms they presented at the time of the study and the origin of the allergy. Allergy was characterized by the history, skin prick tests to standardized allergens, and RAST. Eosinophil protein X (EPX), tryptase, histamine, myeloperoxidase, prostaglandin D2, and leukotriene C4/D4 (LTC4/D4) were measured in nasal lavage by enzyme assay or radioimmunoassay. Eosinophils and neutrophils were enumerated after cytocentrifugation of the lavage fluid and May Grunwald Giemsa staining. Tryptase, myeloperoxidase and EPX but not histamine levels were increased in all four patient groups. Eosinophils, LTC4/D4, and prostaglandin D2 were significantly (p < 0.001, p < 0.03, and p < 0.01) increased in allergic and symptomatic patients. EPX was significantly increased in symptomatic allergic and nonallergic patients. This study suggests the involvement of mast cells, neutrophils, and eosinophils, but the latter cells appear to have a more prominent role. The importance of EPX and LTC4/D4 in the characterization of chronic symptomatic rhinitis was also observed.

Clinical and immunological effects of immunotherapy with alum-absorbed grass allergoid in grass-pollen-induced hay fever

A double-blind, placebo-controlled study of immunotherapy was conducted in 19 patients with grass-pollen hay fever to evaluate the efficacy and safety of a formalinized depot grass allergoid. The patients were assessed before and during IT by clinical (symptom-medication scores during the grass- pollen season, specific nasal and skin reactivity) and immunological (specific IgE, IgG, IgG1 and IgG4 antibodies) parameters. High doses of grass allergoid, corresponding to a cumulative pre-seasonal dosage of 46,050 PNU, were administered, with only one systemic reaction. The actively treated patients had significantly lower symptom-medication scores than placebo (p less than 0.01) during the month of May and showed a significant decrease in specific skin (p less than 0.01) and nasal (p less than 0.05) reactivity, and a significant early increase in specific IgE (p less than 0.01), IgG (p less than 0.0005), IgG1 (p less than 0.001) and IgG4 (p less than 0.05), with a subsequent decrease of IgE and IgG1. No differences were detected in any of these parameters in the placebo group. A correlation was found between high IgG4/IgG1 ratio and the specific skin reactivity decrease (r = 0.691, p less than 0.05), whereas a high IgG4/IgG1 ratio was associated with higher symptom-medication scores (r = 0.654, p less than 0.05). Possible explanations of these apparent discrepancies are proposed.

Titration of immunotherapy by periodical nasal allergic challenges in the treatment of allergic rhinitis

OBJECTIVE

To determine the benefits of nasal allergen challenge (NAC) in monitoring immunotherapy for allergic rhinitis in a clinical setting.

DESIGN

Two hundred consecutive courses of immunotherapy, with pyridine-extracted alum-precipitated allergen extracts (Allpyral), were personally carried out by the writer and analysed. Diagnosis before treatment was confirmed by NAC and the duration of treatment determined by periodical NAC.

SETTING

Consultant allergist's clinical practice.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with allergic rhinitis who were referred for treatment; 79 patients were allergic to grass, 70 to the house dust mite, 30 to plantain and 21 to miscellaneous allergens.

RESULTS

The mean protein nitrogen units (pnu) required to reverse an NAC was 145 467 pnu for grass, 93 771 pnu for mite, 103 137 pnu for plantain, and 121 030 pnu for miscellaneous allergen patients. The range of injections to obtain conversion to a negative NAC was wide. For grass it was 9-58 injections, for mite 6-47 injections, for plantain 4-39 injections, and for miscellaneous allergens 10-79 injections. Ten grass-sensitive patients who received an average of 477 807 pnu failed to convert to a negative NAC result. Similarly, two mite-sensitive patients who received 467 370 PNU, and one plantain-sensitive patient, one cat-sensitive patient and one horse-sensitive patient, who had 389 240 pnu, 148 520 pnu and 719 540 pnu respectively, failed to convert. One patient who was very sensitive to grass pollen developed urticaria which required an injection of adrenaline.

CONCLUSION

Immunotherapy for allergic rhinitis with Allpyral is effective--as determined by the conversion of NAC results from positive to negative--providing a sufficient dose is given. The manufacturer's recommended dose is inadequate. The procedure is safe for mite, plantain and miscellaneous allergens, and only one reaction occurred with grass given in a high dosage protocol, which has subsequently been altered. Considering that the British Committee of Safety of Medicines reported no deaths from Allpyral injections, its recommendations appear over cautious for this make of extract.

Allergen immunotherapy. Review of efficacy and current practice

The modern use of allergen immunotherapy is described. Evidence for efficacy in inhalant allergy and insect sting allergy is reviewed. Current indications for allergen immunotherapy are discussed.