Immunodetection of lymphocyte subpopulations involved in allograft rejection in a teleost, Dicentrarchus labrax (L.)

Fish Lymphocytes: An Evolutionary Equivalent of Mammalian Innate-Like Lymphocytes?

Lymphocytes are the responsible of adaptive responses, as they are classically described, but evidence shows that subpopulations of mammalian lymphocytes may behave as innate-like cells, engaging non-self rapidly and without antigen presentation. The innate-like lymphocytes of mammals have been mainly identified as γδT cells and B1-B cells, exert their activities principally in mucosal tissues, may be involved in human pathologies and their functions and tissue(s) of origin are not fully understood. Due to similarities in the morphology and immunobiology of immune system between fish and mammals, and to the uniqueness of having free-living larval stages where the development can be precisely monitored and engineered, teleost fish are proposed as an experimental model to investigate human immunity. However, the homology between fish lymphocytes and mammalian innate-like lymphocytes is an issue poorly considered in comparative immunology. Increasing experimental evidence suggests that fish lymphocytes could have developmental, morphological, and functional features in common with innate-like lymphocytes of mammals. Despite such similarities, information on possible links between conventional fish lymphocytes and mammalian innate-like lymphocytes is missing. The aim of this review is to summarize and describe available findings about the similarities between fish lymphocytes and mammalian innate-like lymphocytes, supporting the hypothesis that mammalian γδT cells and B1-B cells could be evolutionarily related to fish lymphocytes.

The development of cellular immune defence in marine medaka Oryzias melastigma

Environmentally induced alterations of the immune system during sensitive developmental stages may manifest as abnormalities in immune organ configuration and/or immune cell differentiation. These not only render the early life stages more vulnerable to pathogens, but may also affect the adult immune competence. Knowledge of these sensitive periods in fish would provide an important prognostic/diagnostic tool for aquatic risk assessment of immunotoxicants. The marine medaka Oryzias melastigma is an emerging seawater fish model for immunotoxicology. Here, the presence and onset of four potentially sensitive periods during the development of innate and adaptive cellular immune defence were revealed in O. melastigma: 1.) initiation of phagocyte differentiation, 2.) migration and expansion of lymphoid progenitor cells, 3.) colonization of immune organs through lymphocyte progenitors and 4.) establishment of immune competence in the thymus. By using an established bacterial resistance assay for O. melastigma, larval immune competence (from newly hatched 1dph to 14dph) was found concomitantly increased with advanced thymus development and the presence of mature T-lymphocytes. A comparison between the marine O. melastigma and the freshwater counterpart Oryzias latipes disclosed a disparity in the T-lymphocyte maturation pattern, resulting in differences in the length of T-lymphocyte maturation. The results shed light on a potential difference between seawater and freshwater medaka in their sensitivity to environmental immunotoxicants. Further, medaka immune system development was compared and contrasted to economically important fish. The present study has provided a strong scientific basis for advanced investigation of critical windows for immune system development in fish.

T cell immunity in the teleost digestive tract

Fish (along with cyclostomes) constitute the most ancient animal group in which an acquired immune system is present. As in higher vertebrates, both B and T lymphocytes cooperate in implementing an adequate response. Although there is still a debate on whether fish possess a true gut associated lymphoid tissue (GALT), the presence of diffuse B and T lymphocytes throughout all mucosal surfaces has been demonstrated in a wide variety of fish species. The lack of antibodies against T lymphocyte markers has hampered the performance of functional assays in both systemic and mucosal compartments. However, most components associated with T lymphocyte function have been identified in fish through extensive genomic research, suggesting similar functionalities for fish and mammalian T lymphocytes. Thus, the aim of this review is to briefly summarize what is known in teleost concerning the characteristics and functionalities of the different T cell subsets, to then focus on what is known to date regarding their presence and role in the gastrointestinal tract, through either direct functional assays or indirectly by conclusions drawn from transcriptomic analysis.

T Cells in Fish

Cartilaginous and bony fish are the most primitive vertebrates with a thymus, and possess T cells equivalent to those in mammals. There are a number of studies in fish demonstrating that the thymus is the essential organ for development of T lymphocytes from early thymocyte progenitors to functionally competent T cells. A high number of T cells in the intestine and gills has been reported in several fish species. Involvement of CD4⁺ and CD8α⁺ T cells in allograft rejection and graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) has been demonstrated using monoclonal antibodies. Conservation of CD4⁺ helper T cell functions among teleost fishes has been suggested in a number studies employing mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) and hapten/carrier effect. Alloantigen- and virus-specific cytotoxicity has also been demonstrated in ginbuna and rainbow trout. Furthermore, the important role of cell-mediated immunity rather than humoral immunity has been reported in the protection against intracellular bacterial infection. Recently, the direct antibacterial activity of CD8α⁺, CD4⁺ T-cells and sIgM⁺ cells in fish has been reported. In this review, we summarize the recent progress in T cell research focusing on the tissue distribution and function of fish T cells.

Kinetics of lymphocyte subpopulations in allogeneic grafted scales of ginbuna crucian carp

In mammals the rejection of allografts is primarily accomplished by cell-mediated immunity including T cells. Recently, considerable studies reveal the existence of helper and cytotoxic T cell subsets in fish. Here we investigate the kinetics of CD4(+) and CD8α(+) T cells along with sIgM(+) cells and phagocytic cells in an allogeneic scale graft model using ginbuna crucian carp for understanding the mechanisms of cell-mediated immune response. The results showed that CD4(+) T cells first infiltrated into allogeneic scales followed by CD8α(+) and sIgM(+) cells, and finally phagocytic cells appeared in the graft. Furthermore, most of the CD8α(+) T cells appeared on the border of the allografted scales at the time of rejection. These results suggest that T cells play crucial roles and work together with other cell types for completion of allograft rejection.

Functional aspects of fish lymphocytes

After almost 40 years of studies in comparative immunology, some light has been shed on the evolutive immunobiology of vertebrates, and experimental evidences have shown that acquired immunity, defined by somatic recombination of antigen-binding molecules and memory, is an achievement as ancient as jawless vertebrates. However, the molecular processes generating antigen receptors evolved independently between jawless and jawed fishes, and produced lymphocytic cells with similar functions but employing different sets of genes. In recent years, data have been provided describing some in vitro and in vivo functional responses of fish lymphocytes. After a long gap, the number of specific markers for fish lymphocytes is increasing, thus allowing a first characterisation of lymphocyte subsets. Overall, in the near future it will be possible to open a new chapter in fish immunology and investigate functional immunity of lymphocyte responses by combining the extensive knowledge on immune gene products with markers for molecules and cells. The present review summarizes current knowledge on functional features of fish lymphocytes.

Teleost T and NK cell immunity

The main function of the immune system is to maintain the organism's homeostasis when invaded by foreign material or organisms. Prior to successful elimination of the invader it is crucial to distinguish self from non-self. Most pathogens and altered cells can be recognized by immune cells through expressed pathogen- or danger-associated molecular patterns (PAMPS or DAMPS, respectively), through non-self (e.g. allogenic or xenogenic cells) or missing major histocompatibility (MHC) class I molecules (some virus-infected target cells), and by presenting foreign non-self peptides of intracellular (through MHC class I-e.g. virus-infected target cells) or extracellular (through MHC class II-e.g. from bacteria) origin. In order to eliminate invaders directly or by destroying their ability to replicate (e.g. virus-infected cells) specialized immune cells of the innate and adaptive responses appeared during evolution. The first line of defence is represented by the evolutionarily ancient macrophages and natural killer (NK) cells. These innate mechanisms are well developed in bony fish. Two types of NK cell homologues have been described in fish: non-specific cytotoxic cells and NK-like cells. Adaptive cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) requires key molecules expressed on cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and target cells. CTLs kill host cells harbouring intracellular pathogens by binding of their T cell receptor (TCR) and its co-receptor CD8 to a complex of MHC class I and bound peptide on the infected host cell. Alternatively, extracellular antigens are taken up by professional antigen presenting cells such as macrophages, dendritic cells and B cells to process those antigens and present the resulting peptides in association with MHC class II to CD4(+) T helper cells. During recent years, genes encoding MHC class I and II, TCR and its co-receptors CD8 and CD4 have been cloned in several fish species and antibodies have been developed to study protein expression in morphological and functional contexts. Functional assays for innate and adaptive lymphocyte responses have been developed in only a few fish species. This review summarizes and discusses recent results and developments in the field of T and NK cell responses with focus on economically important and experimental model fish species in the context of vaccination.

A monoclonal antibody for the CD45 receptor in the teleost fish Dicentrarchus labrax

The CD45 tyrosine phosphatase plays an important role in regulating T lymphocyte activation in vertebrate species. In this study we describe some molecular and functional features of the CD45 receptor molecule from the European sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax. Following immunization with fixed sea bass thymocytes, we obtained a murine monoclonal antibody (mAb) able to stain fish leucocytes both alive, by immunofluorescence of thymus and mucosal tissues, and fixed, by in situ immunohistochemistry of tissue sections. The selected IgG(2) mAb (DLT22) was able to recognise by western blots polypeptides mainly at 180 kDa and 130 kDa in thymus, spleen, intestine and gill leucocyte. Accordingly, a 130 kDa polypeptide immunoprecipitated with DLT22 from thymocytes and analysed by nano-RP-HPLC-ESI-MS/MS, gave peptide sequences homologous to Fugu CD45, that were employed for the homology cloning of a partial sea bass CD45 cDNA sequence. This cDNA sequence was employed to measure by quantitative PCR the transcription of the CD45 gene both in unstimulated and in in vitro stimulated leucocytes, showing that the gene transcription was specifically modulated by LPS, ConA, PHA, IL-1, and poly I:C. When splenocytes were stimulated in vitro with ConA and PHA, a cell proliferation paralleled by an increase of DLT22-positive leucocytes was also observed. These data indicate that the DLT22 mAb recognizes a putative CD45 molecule in sea bass, documenting the presence of CD45-like developing lymphocytes in thymus and CD45-associated functional stages of lymphocytes in this species, thus dating back to teleost fish the functional activities of these cell populations in vertebrates.

Cytotoxic T cells in teleost fish

The presence of antigen-specific cytotoxic T cells has been suggested in a number of in vivo and in vitro studies in fish. Acute allograft rejection with an accelerated response on second-set grafts and the presence of graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) has been reported in teleost. Alloantigen- and virus-specific cytotoxicity has also been demonstrated in ex vivo studies in ginbuna and rainbow trout. In addition, alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T cell clones have been produced in cultures initiated with peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) from an alloantigen-immunized channel catfish. Over the last decade several fish genomes have been sequenced and genetic information is rapidly accumulating. Thanks to these genome data bases and EST analysis, mRNA expression of T cell surface marker genes in alloantigen- or virus-specific effector cells has been reported in some fish species, e.g. TCR α or β and CD8α in ginbuna and rainbow trout, and TCR α, β or γ in channel catfish. These findings suggest the presence of CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) in fish similar to those of higher vertebrates. Recently, monoclonal antibodies against CD8α and CD4 antigens have been produced in some fish species. Investigation on the characteristics of CTL and cell-mediated immune mechanisms is now possible at defined T cell subsets, although identification of T cell subset is limited in a few fish species at present. In this review, we describe the recent progress in this field focusing on cells involved in antigen specific cytotoxicity.

Fish T cells: recent advances through genomics

This brief review is intended to provide a concise overview of the current literature concerning T cells, advances in identifying distinct T cell functional subsets, and in distinguishing effector cells from memory cells. We compare and contrast a wealth of recent progress made in T cell immunology of teleost, elasmobranch, and agnathan fish, to knowledge derived from mammalian T cell studies. From genome studies, fish clearly have most components associated with T cell function and we can speculate on the presence of putative T cell subsets, and the ability to detect their differentiation to form memory cells. Some recombinant proteins for T cell associated cytokines and antibodies for T cell surface receptors have been generated that will facilitate studying the functional roles of teleost T cells during immune responses. Although there is still a long way to go, major advances have occurred in recent years for investigating T cell responses, thus phenotypic and functional characterization is on the near horizon.

Transcription of T cell-related genes in teleost fish, and the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) as a model

In recent years the cloning of genes coding for immuno-regulatory peptides, as well as the sequencing of genomes, provided fish immunologists with a growing amount of information on nucleotide sequences. Research is now also addressed in investigating the functional immunology counterpart of nucleotide sequence transcripts in various fish species. In this respect, studies on functional immunology of T cell activities are still at their beginning, and much work is needed to investigate T cell responses in teleost fish species. In this review we summarise the current knowledge on the group of genes coding for main T cell-related peptides in fish, and the expression levels of these genes in organs and tissues. Particular attention is paid to European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax), a marine species in which some information on functional immunology has been obtained, and we reassume here the expression of some T cell-related genes in basal conditions. In addition, we provide original data showing that T cells purified from the intestinal mucosa of sea bass with a specific mAb, express transcripts for TRβ, TRγ, CD8α, and RAG-1, thus showing similarities with intra-epithelial leucocytes of mammals.

Cell markers and determinants in fish immunology

Despite the impressive increase in the cloning and expression of genes encoding fish immunoregulatory molecules, the knowledge on "in vivo" and "in vitro" functional immunology of the corresponding peptide products is still at an initial stage. This is partly due to the lacking of specific markers for immunoregulatory peptides, that represent an indispensible tool to dissect immune reactions and to trace the fate of cellular events downstream of the activation. In this review we summarise the available information on functional immune activities of some teleost species and discuss the obtained data in an evolutionary and applied context.

What happens to the DNA vaccine in fish? A review of current knowledge

The primary function of DNA vaccines, a bacterial plasmid DNA containing a construct for a given protective antigen, is to establish specific and long-lasting protective immunity against diseases where conventional vaccines fail to induce protection. It is acknowledged that less effort has been made to study the fate, in terms of cellular uptake, persistence and degradation, of DNA vaccines after in vivo administration. However, during the last year some papers have given new insights into the fate of DNA vaccines in fish. By comparing the newly acquired information in fish with similar knowledge from studies in mammals, similarities with regard to transport, blood clearance, cellular uptake and degradation of DNA vaccines have been found. But the amount of DNA vaccine redistributed from the administration site after intramuscular administration seems to differ between fish and mammals. This review presents up-to-date and in-depth knowledge concerning the fate of DNA vaccines with emphasis on tissue distribution, cellular uptake and uptake mechanism(s) before finally describing the intracellular hurdles that DNA vaccines need to overcome in order to produce their gene product.

Molecular cloning and characterization of carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) CD8beta and CD4-like genes

Partial cDNA sequences of both CD8beta and CD4-like (CD4L) genes of common carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) were isolated from thymus cDNA library by the method of suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH). Subsequently the full length cDNAs of carp CD8beta and CD4L were obtained by means of 3' RACE and 5' RACE, respectively. The full length cDNA of carp CD8beta is 1164 bp and encodes 207 amino acids including a signal peptide region of 24 amino acids, a transmembrane region of 23 amino acids from aa 167 to aa189 and an immunoglobulin V-set from aa 19 to aa 141. Similar to other species CD8betas, carp CD8beta also lacks p56(lck) domain in the cytoplasmic region. The full length cDNA of carp CD4L is 2001 bp and encodes 458 amino acids including four immunoglobulin (Ig)-like domains in the extracellular region, a transmembrane region of 23 amino acids at the C-terminal region from aa 402 to aa 424 and a cytoplasmic tail. Similar to mammalian, avian CD4s and fugu CD4L, carp CD4L also has the conserved p56(lck) tyrosine kinase motif (C-X-C) in the cytoplasmic region. RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that carp CD8beta and CD4L genes were both expressed predominantly in thymus. The results from this study can be used to understand the evolution of both the CD8beta and CD4 molecules which can be used as markers for cytotoxic and helper T cells in carp.

Cross-reactivity of human leukocyte differentiation antigen monoclonal antibodies on carp and rainbow trout cells

Three hundred and seventy-seven monoclonal antibodies (mabs) directed against human CD antigens and non-classified human leukocyte surface antigens were assayed for their reactivity with common carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) and thymocytes within the animal homologue section of the 8th International Workshop on Human Leukocyte Differentiation Antigens (HLDA8). Four of the mabs clearly reacted with rainbow trout PBL and two with carp PBL. Positive mabs were investigated further by two-colour flow cytometry with established mabs directed against carp and rainbow trout leukocyte subpopulations. None of these mabs were suitable for Western blotting and immunoprecipitation. Three mabs were found to stain cells in fixed cryostate sections of the lymphatic organs thymus, pronephros and spleen. In this study, for the first time an anti-CD14 mab was found to cross-react with fish cells. This mab could be a valuable tool complementing the limited toolbox of population-specific mabs in fish. The low number of cross-reactive mabs analyzed in this workshop is another indication for the great phylogenetic difference between mammals and osteichthyes.

Cytotoxic activities of fish leucocytes

Like mammalian leucocytes, white blood cells of fish are able to kill altered (e.g. virus-infected) and foreign (allogeneic or xenogeneic) cells. The existence of natural killer (NK)-like and specific cytotoxic cells in fish was first shown using allogeneic and xenogeneic effector/target cell systems. In addition to in vivo and ex vivo studies, very important contributions were made by in vitro analysis using a number of different long-term cytotoxic cell lines established from channel catfish. In mammals, specific cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) as part of the adaptive immune response requires a number of key molecules expressed on effector leucocytes and target cells. CD8+ T lymphocytes kill infected cells only, if their antigen receptor (TCR) matches the MHC class I with bound peptide of the target cell. Expression patterns of the fish gene homologues for TCR, CD8 and MHC class I, as well as related genes, are in agreement with similar function. Convenient systems for the analysis of specific CMC have only recently become available for fish with the combination of clonal fish with syngeneic or allogeneic but MHC class I matching cell lines. It was demonstrated that both, NK- and cytotoxic T (Tc) cells are involved in the killing of virus infected MHC class I matching and mismatching target cells. Analysis of these lymphocyte subsets is only starting for fish. There is also evidence that the different viral proteins trigger different subsets of killer cells. This review further discusses findings on fish CMC with regard to temperature/seasons and ontogeny.

In vivo allograft rejection in a bony fish Dicentrarchus labrax (L.): characterisation of effector lymphocytes

Lymphoid cell subpopulations involved in allograft rejection in the teleost Dicentrarchus labrax were characterised at the ultrastructural level and quantified by using monoclonal antibodies against T- and B-lymphocytes. T-cells positive for T-cell receptor beta-chain (TcR beta) were detected by reverse transcription/polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and in situ hybridisation by using RNA probes for TcR beta. Flow cytometry detected a similar percentage of T- and B-lymphocytes (around 17%) in the leucocyte-enriched fraction from allografts. Two different types of T-lymphocytes (DLT 15-immunoreactive) infiltrating the allografts were identified by cytomorphology: small cells with high nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio and cells with a higher cytoplasmic content. RT-PCR revealed a single band (513 bp) corresponding to the TcR beta. In situ hybridisation showed that TcR beta-positive cells in the grafted muscle fibres were less numerous compared with DLT 15-positive cells, as evidenced in parallel sections, suggesting that cytotoxic cells might express different TcR phenotypes. DLIg 3-immunoreactive Ig-producing lymphocytes had: 1) a high nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio or 2) a larger size similar to that of pre-plasma cells (plasma cells lacked any membrane labelling).

The MHC class I linkage group is a major determinant in the in vivo rejection of allogeneic erythrocytes in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Despite accumulating sequence data, information on the function of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes in fish is scarce. In contrast to the genome organization in higher vertebrates, the polymorphic MHC class I and II genes are not linked in the teleost genome. A previous study found an MHC class II linkage group to be a major determinant in the rejection of allogeneic scales by a teleost species (Cardwell et al. 2001). The present study investigated whether the teleost MHC class I linkage group can be involved in allograft rejection. Erythrocytes were chosen as grafts since they express MHC class I, but do not express class II. Rainbow trout erythrocytes expressing different MHC class I alleles were differentially stained, mixed and injected into recipients that were of the same sibling group as the donors. The MHC class I linkage group was the major determinant for in vivo graft rejection.

Graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) in clonal amago salmon, Oncorhynchus rhodurus

The graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) was demonstrated in a salmonid model system of clonal diploid and triploid amago salmon. Triploid operculum grafts on clonal diploid evoked an acute rejection within 12 days. Grafts exchanged among triploid amago salmon exhibited prolonged survival for 18 days. In contrast, diploid grafts on triploid, and allografts among clonal diploid amago salmon were accepted. A typical GVHR was induced in triploid recipients by intraperitonal injection of head kidney cells from sensitised diploid donors. The clinical signs of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) were observed in the recipients after 1 week of cell injection as a loss of appetite and appearance of solid faeces, followed by haemorrhage, local swelling of ventral skin and an enlarged spleen. Three of six fish died within 1 month. Water temperature and frequency of sensitisation are critical to induce GVHR. Diploid donors had to be sensitised three times at 20 degrees C to induce the typical GVHR. GVHR was most effectively induced by head kidney cells, followed by peripheral blood leucocytes (PBL) and spleen cells. Ploidy analysis by flow cytometry revealed that the donor head kidney cells greatly increased in the recipient liver, head kidney and spleen, and reached the peak after 9 days of donor cell injection. The results in the present study are quite similar to the findings in ginbuna and ginbuna-gold fish hybrid system, suggesting the presence of T cells in salmonid as well as cyprinid fish.

Immunopurification of T-cells from sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax (L.)

The monoclonal antibody DLT15, specific for thymocytes and peripheral T-cells of the teleost fish Dicentrarchus labrax (sea bass), was used to purify immunoreactive cells from blood and gut-associated lymphoid tissue. The purification was performed by immuno-magnetic sorting of leucocyte fractions enriched by Percoll density gradient centrifugation, and the purity of the isolated cells was estimated by cytofluorimetric analysis. Following a single step, the percentage of DLT15-purified cells was 88 +/- 10% for gut-associated lymphoid tissue and 79 +/- 18% for blood leucocytes. DLT15-purified cells from gut-associated lymphoid tissue were employed for RNA extraction and cDNA synthesis. In RT-PCR experiments using as primers degenerate oligonucleotides corresponding to the peptide sequence MYWY and VYFCA of the trout TcR beta chain, a 203 bp product was amplified. When sequenced, the cDNA was found to show 60% nucleotide identity to the trout TcRV beta 3. By 3'-RACE the cDNA was elongated to obtain the TcR constant region, with high similarity to other fish TcR sequences. These results strongly suggest that cells recognised by DLT15 are putative T lymphocytes.