Mixed chimerism as an approach to transplantation tolerance

Progress in Xenotransplantation: Immunologic Barriers, Advances in Gene Editing, and Successful Tolerance Induction Strategies in Pig-To-Primate Transplantation

Organ transplantation is the most effective treatment for end stage organ failure, but there are not enough organs to meet burgeoning demand. One potential solution to this organ shortage is xenotransplantation using pig tissues. Decades of progress in xenotransplantation, accelerated by the development of rapid genome editing tools, particularly the advent of CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing technologies, have enabled remarkable advances in kidney and heart xenotransplantation in pig-to-nonhuman primates. These breakthroughs in large animal preclinical models laid the foundation for three recent pig-to-human transplants by three different groups: two kidney xenografts in brain dead recipients deemed ineligible for transplant, and one heart xenograft in the first clinical grade study of pig-to-human transplantation. However, despite tremendous progress, recent data including the first clinical case suggest that gene-modification alone will not overcome all xenogeneic immunologic barriers, and thus an active and innovative immunologic strategy is required for successful xenotransplantation. This review highlights xenogeneic immunologic barriers, advances in gene editing, and tolerance-inducing strategies in pig-to-human xenotransplantation.

The Mandible Ameliorates Facial Allograft Rejection and Is Associated with the Development of Regulatory T Cells and Mixed Chimerism

Vascularized composite allografts contain various tissue components and possess relative antigenicity, eliciting different degrees of alloimmune responses. To investigate the strategies for achieving facial allograft tolerance, we established a mouse hemiface transplant model, including the skin, muscle, mandible, mucosa, and vessels. However, the immunomodulatory effects of the mandible on facial allografts remain unclear. To understand the effects of the mandible on facial allograft survival, we compared the diversities of different facial allograft-elicited alloimmunity between a facial osteomyocutaneous allograft (OMC), including skin, muscle, oral mucosa, and vessels, and especially the mandible, and a myocutaneous allograft (MC) including the skin, muscle, oral mucosa, and vessels, but not the mandible. The different facial allografts of a BALB/c donor were transplanted into a heterotopic neck defect on fully major histocompatibility complex-mismatched C57BL/6 mice. The allogeneic OMC (Allo-OMC) group exhibited significant prolongation of facial allograft survival compared to the allogeneic MC group, both in the presence and absence of FK506 immunosuppressive drugs. With the use of FK506 monotherapy (2 mg/kg) for 21 days, the allo-OMC group, including the mandible, showed prolongation of facial allograft survival of up to 65 days, whereas the myocutaneous allograft, without the mandible, only survived for 34 days. The Allo-OMC group also displayed decreased lymphocyte infiltration into the facial allograft. Both groups showed similar percentages of B cells, T cells, natural killer cells, macrophages, and dendritic cells in the blood, spleen, and lymph nodes. However, a decrease in pro-inflammatory T helper 1 cells and an increase in anti-inflammatory regulatory T cells were observed in the blood and lymph nodes of the Allo-OMC group. Significantly increased percentages of donor immune cells were also observed in three lymphoid organs of the Allo-OMC group, suggesting mixed chimerism induction. These results indicated that the mandible has the potential to induce anti-inflammatory effects and mixed chimerism for prolonging facial allograft survival. The immunomodulatory understanding of the mandible could contribute to reducing the use of immunosuppressive regimens in clinical face allotransplantation including the mandible.

An overview of the necessary thymic contributions to tolerance in transplantation

The thymus is important for the development of the immune system. However, aging leads to predictable involution of the thymus and immunodeficiency. These immunodeficiencies may be rectified with thymic rejuvenation. Atrophy of the thymus is governed by a complex interplay of molecular, cytokine and hormonal factors. Herein we review the interaction of these factors across age and how they may be targeted for thymic rejuvenation. We further discuss the growing pre-clinical evidence defining the necessary and sufficient contributions of the thymus to successful tolerance induction in transplantation.

Naturally acquired microchimerism: implications for transplantation outcome and novel methodologies for detection

Microchimerism represents a condition where one individual harbors genetically distinct cell populations, and the chimeric population constitutes <1% of the total number of cells. The most common natural source of microchimerism is pregnancy. The reciprocal cell exchange between a mother and her child often leads to the stable engraftment of hematopoietic and non-hematopoietic stem cells in both parties. Interaction between cells from the mother and those from the child may result in maternal immune cells becoming sensitized to inherited paternal alloantigens of the child, which are not expressed by the mother herself. Vice versa, immune cells of the child may become sensitized toward the non-inherited maternal alloantigens of the mother. The extent of microchimerism, its anatomical location, and the sensitivity of the techniques used for detecting its presence collectively determine whether microchimerism can be detected in an individual. In this review, we focus on the clinical consequences of microchimerism in solid organ and hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, and propose concepts derived from data of epidemiologic studies. Next, we elaborate on the latest molecular methodology, including digital PCR, for determining in a reliable and sensitive way the extent of microchimerism. For the first time, tools have become available to isolate viable chimeric cells from a host background, so that the challenges of establishing the biologic mechanisms and function of these cells may finally be tackled.

Xenotransplantation-associated infectious risk: a WHO consultation

Xenotransplantation carries the potential risk of the transmission of infection with the cells or tissues of the graft. The degree of risk is unknown in the absence of clinical trials. The clinical application of xenotransplantation has important implications for infectious disease surveillance, both at the national and international levels. Preclinical data indicate that infectious disease events associated with clinical xenotransplantation from swine, should they occur, will be rare; data in human trials are limited but have demonstrated no transmission of porcine microorganisms including porcine endogenous retrovirus. Xenotransplantation will necessitate the development of surveillance programs to detect known infectious agents and, potentially, previously unknown or unexpected pathogens. The development of surveillance and safety programs for clinical trials in xenotransplantation is guided by a "Precautionary Principle," with the deployment of appropriate screening procedures and assays for source animals and xenograft recipients even in the absence of data suggesting infectious risk. All assays require training, standardization and validation, and sharing of laboratory methods and expertise to optimize the quality of the surveillance and diagnostic testing. Investigation of suspected xenogeneic infection events (xenosis, xenozoonosis) should be performed in collaboration with an expert data safety review panel and the appropriate public health and competent authorities. It should be considered an obligation of performance of xenotransplantation trials to report outcomes, including any infectious disease transmissions, in the scientific literature. Repositories of samples from source animals and from recipients prior to, and following xenograft transplantation are essential to the investigation of possible infectious disease events. Concerns over any potential hazards associated with xenotransplantation may overshadow potential benefits. Careful microbiological screening of source animals used as xenotransplant donors may enhance the safety of transplantation beyond that of allotransplant procedures. Xenogeneic tissues may be relatively resistant to infection by some human pathogens. Moreover, xenotransplantation may be made available at the time when patients require organ replacement on a clinical basis. Insights gained in studies of the microbiology and immunology of xenotransplantation will benefit transplant recipients in the future. This document summarizes approaches to disease surveillance in individual recipients of nonhuman tissues.

New strategies in immune tolerance induction

Induction of tolerance in clinical organ transplantation that will obviate the use of chronic immunosuppression and preserve host immune response to other antigens remains the goal of transplant research. The thymus plays a critical role in the ability of the immune system to discriminate between self- and nonself-antigens or harmful and harmless alloantigens. We now know that multiple factors determine how the immune system responds to a self-antigen or foreign antigen. These determinants include developmental stage of the host, stage of T-cell maturity, site of antigen encounter, type and maturity of antigen-presenting cells, and presence and type of costimulatory molecules. Our understanding of the mechanisms of T-cell interactions with peptide/ major histocompatibility complex in peripheral lymphoid organs has led to experiments that translate into peripheral T-cell tolerance. The induction of high-avidity peripheral alloreactive T cells in the early phase of organ transplantation makes it difficult to achieve long-term alloantigen-specific tolerance without the use of transient perioperative immunosuppression. Therefore, protocols that induce robust tolerance in rodent and nonhuman primate models involve the use of donor antigen combined with a short course of perioperative immunosuppression. These studies suggest that the underlying mechanisms of peripheral tolerance include deletion, anergy, immune deviation, and regulatory T cells. This review focuses on recent advances in tolerance induction in experimental animal models and discusses their relevance to the development of protocols for the induction and maintenance of clinical transplant tolerance.

Rapamycin, mycophenolate mofetil, methylprednisolone, and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 immunoglobulin-based conditioning regimen to induce partial tolerance to hind limb allografts without cytoreductive conditioning

BACKGROUND

Composite tissue allograft transplantation may represent the next frontier in the field of reconstructive surgery. However, the main obstacles precluding the routine use of composite tissue allotransplants are rejection and toxicity associated with life-long immunosuppressive therapy. In this study, we investigated a nontoxic immunosuppressant and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 immunoglobulin (CTLA4-Ig)-based protocol to induce donor-specific tolerance to hind limb allografts in rats.

METHODS

Fully mismatched, 4- to 10-week-old Brown Norway (BN, RT1n) and Lewis (RT1) rats were used as cell/organ donors and recipients, respectively. Recipients were treated with CTLA4-Ig (2 mg/kg/d) on days -30, -28, -26, -24, and -22, rapamycin, mycophenolate mofetil, and methylprednisolone (RAPA/MMF/MP) combined therapy (from days -30 to day 100), a single dose of anti-lymphocyte serum (10 mg, on day -30), and donor bone marrow (10 x 10(7) T-cell-depleted cells) transplantation (BMT, on day -30). Thirty days after BMT, chimeric animals received hind limb allotransplantations (on day 0). The RAPA/MMF/MP combined therapy was changed to Cyclosporine (CsA, 8 mg/kg/d) on day 100 and maintained thereafter at this level.

RESULTS

Hematopoietic chimerism of 17.6 +/- 9.5% at day 0, was stable (15.2 +/- 5.6%) at 230 days post-BMT; there was no sign of graft-versus-host disease. Chimeric recipients (Lewis) permanently accepted (>200 days) donor (BN)-specific (RT11, n = 6) hind limbs, yet rapidly rejected (20 +/- 2 days) third-party hind limbs (Wistar Furth [WF]). Lymphocytes of graft-tolerant animals demonstrated hyporesponsiveness in mixed lymphocyte cultures in a donor-specific manner. Tolerant graft histology showed no signs of acute and chronic rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

The immunosuppressant and CTLA4-Ig-based conditioning regimen with donor BMT produced mixed chimerism and induced partial donor-specific tolerance to hind limb allografts.

Formation of composite endothelial cell-mesenchymal stem cell islets: a novel approach to promote islet revascularization

OBJECTIVE

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) contribute to endothelial cell (EC) migration by producing proteases, thereby paving the way into the tissues for ECs. MSCs were added to our previously described composite EC islets as a potential means to improve their capacity for islet angiogenesis.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Human islets were coated with primary human bone marrow-derived MSCs and dermal microvascular ECs. The capacity of ECs, with or without MSCs, to adhere to and grow into human islets was analyzed. The survival and functionality of these composite islets were evaluated in a dynamic perifusion assay, and their capacity for angiogenesis in vitro was assessed in a three-dimensional fibrin gel assay.

RESULTS

ECs proliferated after culture in MSC-conditioned medium, and MSCs improved the EC coverage threefold compared with EC islets alone. Islet survival in vitro and the functionality of the composite islets after culture were equal to those of control islets. The EC-MSC islets showed a twofold increase in total sprout formation compared with EC islets, and vascular sprouts emanating from the EC-MSC-islet surface showed migration of ECs into the islets and also into the surrounding matrix, either alone or in concert with MSCs.

CONCLUSIONS

EC proliferation, sprout formation, and ingrowth of ECs into the islets were enhanced by MSCs. The use of composite EC-MSC islets may have beneficial effects on revascularization and immune regulation. The technique presented allows for pretreatment of donor islets with recipient-derived ECs and MSCs as a means of improving islet engraftment.

Induction of chimerism in rhesus macaques through stem cell transplant and costimulation blockade-based immunosuppression

A strategy for producing high-level hematopoietic chimerism after non-myeloablative conditioning has been established in the rhesus macaque. This strategy relies on hematopoietic stem cell transplantation after induction with a non-myeloablative dose of busulfan and blockade of the IL2-receptor in the setting of mTOR inhibition with sirolimus and combined CD28/CD154 costimulation blockade. Hematopoietic stem cells derived from bone marrow and leukopheresis products both were found to be successful in inducing high-level chimerism. Mean peripheral blood peak donor chimerism was 81% with a median chimerism duration of 145 days. Additional immune modulation strategies, such as pre-transplant CD8 depletion, donor-specific transfusion, recipient thymectomy or peritransplant deoxyspergualin treatment did not improve the level or durability of chimerism. Recipient immunologic assessment suggested that chimerism occurred amidst donor-specific down-regulation of alloreactive T cells, and the reappearance of vigorous T-mediated alloreactivity accompanied rejection of the transplants. Furthermore, viral reactivation constituted a significant transplant-related toxicity and may have negatively impacted the ability to achieve indefinite survival of transplanted stem cells. Nevertheless, this chimerism-induction regimen induced amongst the longest-lived stem cell chimerism reported to date for non-human primates and thus represents a platform upon which to evaluate emerging tolerance-induction strategies.

Monitoring tolerance after human liver transplantation

The validation of reliable, non-invasive immunological assays evaluating anti-donor responsiveness in allograft recipients would provide a clinically relevant tool for the early detection of ongoing rejection process as well as for the identification of operational tolerance in the long term. A sequential approach towards immunological monitoring of allografts is proposed in this review: (i) investigations exploring the initial donor-recipient alloresponses, including the analysis of the cytokine network; (ii) investigations regarding graft acceptance and operational tolerance in long-term transplant patients, consisting in the analysis of regulatory T cells and of circulating precursors of dendritic cells, in the measurement of T cell alloreactivity as well as in the study of T cell receptor repertoires. Beside the conventional in vivo and in vitro immunological techniques, the potential applications of molecular imaging in transplantation also deserve further exploration, with particular respect to allograft immune monitoring. Enforced collaboration between transplant clinicians and immunologists will be required to develop the translational research protocols required for the development of immunological monitoring, within an international multicentric network.

Induction of regulatory T cells from mature T cells by allogeneic thymic epithelial cells in vitro

The ability of thymic epithelial cells (TEC) to re-educate mature T cells to be regulatory T cells has not been addressed. In the present study, this issue was directly investigated by co-culturing of mature T cells and allo-TECs. B6 macrophage cell line 1C21-cultured BALB/c splenocytes responded to B6 antigens in vitro. However, BALB/c splenocytes precultured with B6-derived TECs 1-4C18 or 1C6 did not proliferate to B6 antigens, but responded to rat antigens. Exogenous interleukin-2 (IL-2) failed to revise the unresponsiveness of these T cells. Allo-TEC-cultured T cells predominantly expressed Th2 cytokines (IL-4 and IL-10). B6 TEC-cultured BALB/c splenocytes markedly inhibited the immune responses of naïve BALB/c splenocytes to B6 antigens, but not to rat or the third-party mouse antigens. BALB/c nude mice that received naïve syngeneic splenocytes rejected B6 or rat skin grafts by 17 days postskin grafting; however, co-injection of B6 TEC-cultured BALB/c splenocytes significantly delayed B6 skin graft rejection (P < 0.01), with the unchanged rejection of rat skin grafts. These studies demonstrate that allo-TECs are able to 'educate' mature T cells to be regulatory cells, and suggest that regulatory cells derived from mature T cells by TECs may play an important role in T cell tolerance to allo- and auto-antigens.

The immunological monitoring of alloreactive responses in liver transplant recipients: a review

The aim of this work is to review the current knowledge in the field of immunological monitoring of allogenic responsiveness in clinical liver transplantation. When compared to other solid-organ transplants, liver allografts are considered as immunologically privileged, and, accordingly, constitute a favorable setting to develop experimental as well as clinical strategies for minimization of immunosuppression and even induction of operational tolerance. The validation of simple, reliable, noninvasive assays exploring antidonor alloreactivity will constitute a crucial step toward implementing such approaches in the clinic. In contrast to research in rodents claiming the development of donor-specific tolerance in case of graft survivals of over 100 days without immunosuppression, it is impractical to confirm tolerance induction in this way in humans. Promising candidate assays include the detection of post-transplant immune deviation, of circulating precursors of dendritic cells subtypes, and of regulatory T cells. A conceptual framework for the development of tolerance assays in clinical liver transplantation is also proposed.

Strategies for Tolerance Induction in Nonhuman Primates

Recent advances in the field of reconstructive surgery and immunology resulted in increased interest in composite tissue allograft (CTA) transplantation. Up to date, more than 50 CTA transplants have been reported in humans. A significant number of experimental studies on CTA transplants under different protocols of tolerance-inducting strategies have been reported in small-animal models. There is however, a limited number of CTA transplants performed in nonhuman primates. To reach the ultimate clinical success in CTA transplantation, more experimental studies on tolerance induction in nonhuman primates are needed to apply these immunomodulatory protocols to CTA transplants in humans. In this review, strategies for tolerance induction in the nonhuman primate model in solid organ and CTA transplants are presented in 3 major categories: chimerism induction, T-cell depletion, and costimulatory receptor blockade.

Perspectives on Hand Transplantation

The early experience of hand transplantation has yielded a mixture of successes and failures. No life-threatening adverse effects have been encountered from immunosuppression, yet additional medications were required in some cases with unknown long-term efficacy or side effects. Limited functional returns have been observed, but any effect of chronic rejection is too early to determine. Although the experience has confirmed the benefits of hand transplantation to patients and their families, the future of hand transplantation on a wide scale is dependent on further research to alter its risk-benefit balance.

Lung transplantation: opportunities for research and clinical advancement

Lung transplantation is the only definitive therapy for many forms of end-stage lung diseases. However, the success of lung transplantation is limited by many factors: (1) Too few lungs available for transplantation due to limited donors or injury to the donor lung; (2) current methods of preservation of excised lungs do not allow extended periods of time between procurement and implantation; (3) acute graft failure is more common with lungs than other solid organs, thus contributing to poorer short-term survival after lung transplant compared with that for recipients of other organs; (4) lung transplant recipients are particularly vulnerable to pulmonary infections; and (5) chronic allograft dysfunction, manifest by bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome, is frequent and limits long-term survival. Scientific advances may provide significant improvements in the outcome of lung transplantation. The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute convened a working group of investigators on June 14-15, 2004, in Bethesda, Maryland, to identify opportunities for scientific advancement in lung transplantation, including basic and clinical research. This workshop provides a framework to identify critical issues related to clinical lung transplantation, and to delineate important areas for productive scientific investigation.

Measurement of chimerism in cynomolgus monkeys using human-specific short tandem repeat-based assay

Preclinical testing of a mixed chimerism mediated organ transplant tolerance strategy, in a cynomolgus macaque model, would be facilitated by the establishment of a reliable technique for quantitative assessment of chimerism. Among various techniques used for measurement of chimerism in humans, microsatellite DNA profiling has been considered the most versatile one that can discriminate between two individuals. We adopted a commercially available short tandem repeat profiling methodology to cynomolgus monkeys using two human specific alleles, TPOX and CSF1PO. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify these alleles, and the analysis of the PCR products was performed by capillary electrophoresis. Of 54 cynomolgus macaques investigated, only one pair with the same ABO blood type demonstrated identity at both alleles. This implies that this technique should interfere minimally with the assignment of donor-recipient pairs based upon molecular tissue typing or mixed lymphocyte cultures.

Treatment with anti-MHC-class-II antibody postpones kidney allograft rejection in primates but increases the risk of CMV activation

Treatment of kidney graft recipients with antibodies that may specifically suppress the anti-donor response would be an ideal situation to prevent graft rejection. MHC class-II-specific antibodies and, in particular, DR specific antibodies have often been proposed as treatment to prevent antigen presentation, and thus graft destruction. Here we report an attempt to prevent graft rejection using a humanized MHC class-II-specific monoclonal antibody CDP855 in a cynomolgus monkey kidney graft model. A modest delay in graft rejection was observed when the antibody was given only on days 0, 1 and 2 after transplantation. Unexpectedly 50% of the animals succumbed of a viral infection, most likely CMV in two of three cases, prior to graft rejection in the first week post-transplantation. We speculate that the antibody treatment triggered CMV activation, possibly as a consequence of the activation of factors such as NF-kappab by the interaction of the antibody and its target cells.

Xenotransplantation: infectious risk revisited

Xenotransplantation is a possible solution for the shortage of tissues for human transplantation. Multiple hurdles exist to clinical xenotransplantation, including immunologic barriers, metabolic differences between pigs--the source species most commonly considered--and humans, and ethical concerns. Since clinical trials were first proposed almost 10 years ago, the degree of risk for infection transmitted from the xenograft donor to the recipient has been extensively investigated. A number of potential viral pathogens have been identified including porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV), porcine cytomegalovirus (PCMV), and porcine lymphotropic herpesvirus (PLHV). Sensitive diagnostic assays have been developed for each virus. Human-tropic PERV are exogenous recombinants between PERV-A and PERV-C sequences and are present in only a subset of swine. Porcine cytomegalovirus can be excluded from herds of source animals by early weaning of piglets. In contrast, the risks associated with PLHV remain undefined. Microbiologic studies and assays for potential xenogeneic pathogens have furthered understanding of risks associated with xenotransplantation. Thus far, clinical xenotransplantation of pig tissues has not resulted in transmission of viral infection to humans; significant risks for disease transmission from swine to humans have not been confirmed. If immunologic hurdles can be overcome, it is reasonable to initiate carefully monitored clinical trials.

Protochordate concordant xenotransplantation settings reveal outbreaks of donor cells and divergent life span traits

If fulminate rejection in allogeneic and xenogeneic engraftments is not an evolutionary relict feature, then any treatment that ablates the host surveillance's effector arms capabilities and eliminates graft vs. host reactivity should induce donor chimerism in transplant settings. We demonstrate here marked proliferative response of Botryllus (Urochordata) blood cells months following their infusions (2x10(4)-10(5) blood cells per host) into the concordant xenogeneic environment of irradiated Botrylloides soma. The state of infused cells was followed by Botryllus specific microsatellite alleles on DNA samples from host zooids and vascular system. Increased growth rates and life spans of engrafted hosts in some cases, and sudden chimerical death following the outbreak of donor cells in others, indicate a 'double-edged sword' expression of concurrent evolutionary selected mechanisms. This DES phenomenon in immunity underlies divergent stem cell competition phenomena in multicellular organisms, leading in mammals, to cases of autoimmune diseases vis-à-vis long-lasting microchimerism events following an iatrogenic transplantation.

Pulmonary xenotransplantation: rapidly progressing into the unknown

As one approach to circumventing the dire shortage of human lungs for transplantation, a handful of investigators have begun to probe the possibility of pulmonary xenotransplantation. The immunologic and perhaps physiologic barriers encountered by these investigators are considerable and progress in pulmonary xenotransplantation has lagged behind progress in cardiac and kidney xenotransplantation. However, during the last few years there have been substantial advances in the field of pulmonary xenotransplantation including, most noticeably, significant progress in attenuating hyperacute dysfunction. Progress has been made in understanding the barriers imposed by xenoreactive antibodies, complement, coagulation incompatibility and porcine pulmonary intravascular macrophages. Although our understanding of the barriers to pulmonary xenotransplantation is far from complete and the clinical application of pulmonary xenotransplantation is not yet in sight, current progress is fast paced. This progress provides a basis for future work and for a hope that the shortage of human lungs for transplantation will not always be a matter of life and death.

Xenografts are an achievable breakthrough

The objective of this communication is to show that pig-to-human organ transplantation could be feasible through genetic engineering. By introducing into donor pigs several different tolerance promoting genetic modifications there can be a synergistic effect to produce extended tolerance for xenografted organs in human recipients. Nuclear-transfer cloning allows production of pigs with knockout mutations in the galactose-alpha-1,3-galactosyl transferase gene, in principle eliminating hyperacute rejection. Once hyperacute rejection is circumvented, long-term tolerance of xenografted organs should be possible through a combination of transgenic immunomodulating molecule, bone marrow chimerism and short to intermediate term use of immunosuppressive drugs. If immunomodulating transgenes are deleterious during pig development, inducible cre-recombinase excision of stop codons provides a means to delay expression of such transgenes until after transplantation. Zoonotic diseases can be circumvented via pathogen-free colonies and additional knockout mutations to disable porcine endogenous retrovirus and prion disease. Thus, there is now a technical and theoretical framework for serious efforts at cross-species transplantation.

Tolerance: is it achievable in pediatric solid organ transplantation?

Significant advances have been made in the understanding of allograft rejection. There is growing awareness that allograft acceptance, or tolerance, is also an active process rather than a passive absence of rejection. Mechanistic awareness of this process has spawned many preclinical strategies for the prevention of allograft rejection without the need for chronic immunosuppression. These therapies are currently entering clinical trials. This article reviews the prevailing therapies that hold promise for future clinical application. In particular, their application in children is discussed, as are biologic aspects of childhood immunity that may play a role in the success or failure of these strategies.

Facilitating cells as a venue to establish mixed chimerism and tolerance

Graft rejection and the toxicity associated with the use of non-specific immunosuppression remain the major limitations in pediatric solid organ transplantation. The induction of tolerance in transplant recipients is an elusive but achievable goal that will decrease the dependence on immunosuppressive agents. BMT is associated with a robust form of donor-specific transplantation tolerance. It achieves a state of chimerism, defined as the presence of donor marrow cells in the recipient. The two major toxicities in conventional bone marrow transplantation that have prevented its clinical application to induce tolerance are the toxicity of ablative conditioning and GVHD. Two forms of chimerism exist: full chimerism and mixed chimerism. In full chimerism, the hematopoietic system of the recipient is replaced by that of the donor following ablative conditioning. Full chimerism is associated with a relatively impaired immunocompetence for primary immune responses and an increased risk of GVHD. In addition, the 7-10% regimen-related mortality associated with ablation could not be accepted in solid organ allograft recipients. In mixed chimerism the donor hematopoietic system co-exists with that of the recipient. Mixed chimerism induces donor-specific tolerance and is associated with superior immunocompetence and a relative resistance to GVHD compared with full chimerism. Moreover, it can be achieved with partial conditioning, thereby reducing the regimen-related morbidity associated with myeloablation. Approaches to establish mixed chimerism using non-myeloablative-conditioning regimens have been aggressively pursued over the past decade. Mixed chimerism can be safely established with minimal conditioning, resulting in a significant reduction in risk compared with ablative conditioning. GVHD is the final hurdle that has prevented the widespread application of chimerism to induce tolerance. Donor T cells are the primary effector cells for GVHD. Although T cell depletion of the donor marrow avoids GVHD, it results in an increase in the rate of graft failure in MHC-disparate recipients. The dichotomy between GVHD and T cell depletion graft failure has recently been dissociated by the discovery of CD8+/TCR- graft FC. Purified HSC engraft readily in syngeneic recipients but not in MHC-disparate allogeneic recipients. The addition of small numbers of facilitating cells permits durable HSC engraftment in allogeneic recipients and avoids GVHD. Using FC to promote HSC engraftment following non-myeloablative conditioning could be a promising approach to establish tolerance in solid organ transplantation. This invited review focuses on recent developments in stem cell chimerism and tolerance that could bring the use of this approach to induce tolerance to solid organ transplantation one step closer to reality.

Tolerance induction in clinical transplantation: the pending questions

Despite the dramatic improvement of early graft survival due to the introduction of cyclosporin, late graft loss caused by chronic rejection and the lethal consequences of long-term immunosuppression, such as infection and cancer, remain major concerns for the transplantation community. Tolerance induction would avoid these complications. The ways to go are controversial, reflecting the redundancy of rejection pathways. They include the induction of central tolerance by establishment of mixed chimerism through hematopoietic stem cell transplantation and the induction of "operational tolerance" through immunodeviation involving dendritic or regulatory T cells. Major advances have been made in animal models exploring these strategies and, some preliminary data are even now available in humans, allowing the initiation of pilot clinical trials. In this article, we discuss the key questions that these trials will have to address.

A substantial level of donor hematopoietic chimerism is required to protect donor-specific islet grafts in diabetic NOD mice

BACKGROUND

Mixed chimerism can induce tolerance to alloantigens and restore self-tolerance to autoantigens, thereby permitting islet transplantation. However, the minimal level of donor chimerism that is required to prevent islet allograft rejection and recurrence of autoimmune diabetes has not been established.

METHODS

We investigated whether allogeneic Balb/c donor chimerism can be induced in C57BL/6 mice, in prediabetic NOD mice, and in diabetic NOD mice after transplantation of a modest dose of bone marrow by using purine nucleoside analogue, fludarabine phosphate and cyclophosphamide conditioning therapy, followed by short-term anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody and rapamycin posttransplant treatment. We also investigated whether the induced donor chimerism is sufficient to prevent the onset of diabetes in prediabetic NOD mice and protect donor islet grafts in diabetic NOD mice.

RESULTS

Allogeneic donor chimerism could be induced under the authors' approach that is nonmyeloablative and radiation-free. Diabetes onset was prevented in chimeric prediabetic NOD mice. The induction of mixed chimerism protected donor-specific islet grafts in diabetic NOD mice. At 60 days after islet transplantation, all donor Balb/c islet grafts survived in diabetic NOD mice whose level of donor-derived lymphocytes was higher than 30% at the time of islet transplantation (n=8). In contrast, Balb/c islet grafts were rejected in five of seven diabetic NOD mice whose level was lower than 30%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data demonstrate that a donor lymphocyte chimerism (>30%) at the time of islet transplantation is required to protect donor-specific islet grafts, and indicate that a strictly non-irradiation-based protocol can be used to achieve this goal.

Heart xenograft survival with chimeric pig donors and modest immune suppression

OBJECTIVE

To assess the use of donor pigs with cellular chimerism for prevention of acute rejection with modest immune suppression. The clinical use of pig organ xenografts is currently precluded by severe acute rejection, which resists standard immune suppression.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

For long-term survival of pig organ xenografts, immune suppression significantly greater than used with allografts would currently be necessary, leaving the recipient immune deficient and at increased risk for infections. Induction of immune tolerance and tissue accommodation could enhance xenograft survival but would lead to complications and frequent graft failure. Induction of cellular chimerism within the donor pigs, however, could accomplish these goals before transplantation, significantly reducing the risk.

METHODS

Marrow cells from sheep were infused into fetal pigs. Heart xenografts from chimeric or nonchimeric pigs were transplanted heterotopically into recipient sheep, simultaneous with infusion of splenocytes. Posttransplant suppression consisted of cyclosporine and tapered corticosteroids, comparable with allotransplants.

RESULTS

All of the control grafts (n = 12) were rejected by acute vascular rejection in 4 to 8 days. In contrast, only one episode of vascular rejection was observed in the experimental group (n = 13). Four experimental recipients had an episode of moderate diffuse cellular rejection (grade 3) and one had moderate focal cellular rejection (grade 2). Each episode responded to pulse steroids. Seven grafts showed no significant rejection. There was little evidence of immune deficiency, infection, or toxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

Acute vascular rejection was prevented in a large animal model without the need for severe immune suppression.

Inducing tolerance to MHC-matched allogeneic islet grafts in diabetic NOD mice by simultaneous islet and bone marrow transplantation under nonirradiative and nonmyeloablative conditioning therapy

BACKGROUND

Human type 1 diabetes is associated with defects in the hematopoietic stem cells. Simultaneous donor islet and bone marrow transplantation may be an ideal therapeutic approach for inducing tolerance to islet allogeneic antigens and restoring self-tolerance to islet autoimmune antigens.

METHODS

Using a nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse model of human type 1 diabetes, we investigated whether tolerance to MHC-matched allogeneic islet grafts from male nonobese diabetes-resistant (NOR) donors can be induced in female NOD recipients by simultaneous islet and bone marrow transplantation under fludarabine phosphate-based nonmyeloablative and irradiation-free conditioning therapy. Donor-specific chimerism in the peripheral blood of tolerant mice (n=7) was measured by semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction for a male-specific marker (SRY).

RESULTS

Donor-specific tolerance to NOR islet grafts was induced in all diabetic NOD mice after simultaneous islet and bone marrow transplantation and treated with fludarabine phosphate, cyclophosphamide, anti-mouse lymphocyte serum, and rapamycin. At 100 days and 200 days after transplantation, the average percentage of male NOR marker in DNA derived from the peripheral blood of NOD recipients that had long-term islet graft survival was over 10%.

CONCLUSION

Our data suggest that this approach may induce donor-specific tolerance in clinical islet transplantation and living-related donor solid organ transplantation.

Comparison of bone marrow cells harvested from various bones of cynomolgus monkeys at various ages by perfusion or aspiration methods: a preclinical study for human BMT

Using cynomolgus monkeys, we have previously established a new method for harvesting bone marrow cells (BMCs) with minimal contamination of the BMCs with T cells from the peripheral blood. We originally conducted this new "perfusion method" in the long bones (the humerus, femur, and tibia) of cynomolgus monkeys. Here, we apply the perfusion method to obtain BMCs from the ilium of cynomolgus monkeys, since BMCs are usually collected from the ilium by the conventional aspiration method in humans. The perfusion method consists of two approaches: transverse iliac perfusion and longitudinal iliac perfusion. BMCs harvested by the perfusion method from the long bones and ilium were compared with those collected from the ilium by the aspiration method. The contamination of BMCs with peripheral blood, determined by the frequencies of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, was significantly lower in BMCs obtained from the ilium or long bones by the perfusion method (CD4+ plus CD8+ T cells <4%) than in those obtained by the iliac aspiration method (CD4+ plus CD8+ T cells >20%). However, the numbers of immature myeloid cells, such as myeloblasts, promyelocytes, myelocytes, and metamyelocytes, were higher in BMCs obtained by the iliac perfusion method than in those obtained by the iliac aspiration method. The assays for in vitro colony-forming unit in culture revealed that progenitor activity was significantly higher in BMCs obtained by the perfusion method than in those obtained by the aspiration method. These findings suggest that the contamination of BMCs with peripheral blood is much less when using the perfusion method than when using the aspiration method. To determine the best site for harvesting BMCs by the perfusion method, age-dependent changes in BMCs harvested by the perfusion method from the long bones and ilium were examined. The numbers of BMCs varied in the long bones (humerus > femur > tibia) and showed age-dependent decreases, whereas they remained similar in the ilium of cynomolgus monkeys from 3 years to 6 years of age. However, in cynomolgus monkeys, BMC harvesting by the perfusion method from the ilium (but not from the long bones) is found to involve the risk of fat emboli, particularly when the BMCs are quickly perfused under high pressure. These findings suggest, even in humans, that the perfusion method is better than the aspiration method, and that the best site for collection of BMCs is the humerus.

Rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockade as post-transplant treatment promote fully MHC-mismatched allogeneic bone marrow engraftment under irradiation-free conditioning therapy

Hematopoietic macrochimerism, established by bone marrow transplantation, can be used as an approach for treating autoimmune disease and inducing transplant tolerance. In this study, we investigated whether a stable, high level of fully MHC-mismatched hematopoietic macrochimerism can be induced by using irradiation-free protocols, and whether rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockades (anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) and CTLA4Ig) as post-transplant treatment promote bone marrow engraftment. Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST), anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS), busulfan, and cyclophosphamide were given pretransplantation. Balb/c (H-2(d)) bone marrow cells, at a dose of 4 x 10(7), were infused into each C57BL/6 mouse (H-2(b)). Rapamycin, anti-CD40L mAb, and CTLA4Ig were then administered, either alone or in combination. Without ALS or busulfan and cyclophosphamide, macrochimerism can only rarely be induced. Donor-specific transfusion (DST) enhances induction of hematopoietic macrochimerism. Rapamycin, anti-CD40L mAb and CTLA4Ig, alone or in combination, induce a stable and high level of hematopoietic macrochimerism. In the chimeric mice, donor-derived cells were detected in all lymphohematopoietic tissues and donor-specific tolerance was induced in vitro. We conclude that a stable and high level of fully MHC-mismatched hematopoietic macrochimerism can be induced in mice after transplanting a single modest dose of bone marrow cells without irradiation. Rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockade as post-transplant treatment promote bone marrow engraftment.

Will the pig solve the transplantation backlog?

The increasing shortage of human cadaveric organs for purposes of transplantation has become the critical limiting factor in the number of transplants performed each year. Some of this deficit is being met by the use of organs or partial organs from living donors, but this source is insufficient. Xenotransplantation-the transplantation of organs between species, namely from the pig to human-could provide a solution if immunologic and other associated problems could be solved. When a pig organ is transplanted into a primate, hyperacute rejection, induced by anti-pig antibody and mediated by complement and the coagulation system, develops rapidly. This immediate problem can now be overcome, but the return or persistence of anti-pig antibody leads to a delayed form of humoral rejection, acute humoral xenograft rejection, which leads to destruction of the organ within days or weeks. We review the various approaches being investigated to overcome this barrier. Whether they will also prevent subsequent acute cellular rejection remains unknown. Brief mention is made of the potential physiologic incompatibilities between pig and human organs, as well as the microbiologic safety aspects of xenotransplantation. Finally, the question of patient and societal acceptance of xenotransplantation is discussed.

Genetically modified HLA class I molecules able to inhibit human NK cells without provoking alloreactive CD8+ CTLs

Human NK cells are likely to be important effectors of xenograft rejection. Expression of HLA class I molecules by transfected porcine cells can protect them from human NK cell-mediated lysis; however, this strategy has the potential to augment the anti-graft response by recipient CD8(+) T cells recognizing foreign pig peptides presented by HLA. In this study we show that the introduction of a mutation (D227K) in the alpha(3) domain of HLA-Cw3 abrogates its recognition by CD8-dependent T cells but leaves intact its ability to function as an inhibitory ligand for NK cells. Such genetically modified molecules may have potential therapeutic applications in the prevention of delayed xenograft rejection and in the facilitation of allogeneic and xenogeneic bone marrow engraftment.

Long-term kidney graft survival by delayed T cell ablative treatment in rhesus monkeys

BACKGROUND

Tolerance to organ allografts in primates including man has been elusive, although in rodents and pigs tolerance can be achieved to organ allografts with relatively short courses of immunosuppressive treatment. In all varieties of graft acceptance that do not require full-dose maintenance immunosuppression, immunological engagement of donor and recipient and an early unstable period have been observed. On the basis of the hypothesis that elimination of aggressive T cell function should tip the balance in favor of an operationally tolerant state, experiments have been performed in monkeys allowing recipient-donor interaction before T-cell ablation and a short course of immunosuppression.

METHODS

Rhesus monkeys received an allogeneic kidney graft from a MHC-mismatched donor. The animals either received anti-CD3 immunotoxin (FN18-CRM9) alone, started 2 days after transplantation, or in combination with a short course of cyclosporine (CsA) and/or rapamycin (RAPA), started at 5 days after transplantation. Kidney function was followed by monitoring serum creatinine levels and regular biopsies. Humoral and cellular antidonor immunity was tested in vitro before and at several time points after transplantation.

RESULTS

Graft survival of monkeys that received CsA alone (mean survival time (MST)=29.3) was significantly prolonged compared with the controls (MST=6). FN18-CRM9 treatment alone also resulted in prolonged graft survival (MST=29.4). The combined treatment of FN18-CRM9 and CsA and/or RAPA resulted in prolonged graft survival after all immunosuppression was stopped (MST=207.8).

CONCLUSIONS

It seems feasible to postpone immunosuppression posttransplantation and yet prevent allograft rejection without the need of permanent immunosuppression.

Kidney transplantation after liver transplantation from the same donor: four cases of successful steroid withdrawal

BACKGROUND

Administration of corticosteroids to kidney recipients has hampered the complete clinical success of kidney transplantation. Because most organ transplantation in Japan is living-related, we had the experience of performing kidney transplantation (KT) after liver transplantation (LT) from the same donor in four patients and successfully withdrew corticosteroid administration.

METHODS

Three pediatric and one adult patient received kidney allografts from 3 to 10 months after LT from the same donor. The immunosuppressive regimen consisted of a corticosteroid and tacrolimus. The steroid was withdrawn after KT in all four patients. After complete withdrawal of the steroid, DNA was extracted from two recipients and examined by polymerase chain reaction to detect microchimerism. A mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity assay (CML) were performed to test for donor-specific hyporesponsiveness.

RESULTS

Steroid withdrawal was successfully accomplished after KT in every patient. No steroid-withdrawal-associated complications were observed. In the three pediatric patients, remarkable catch-up growth was observed after steroid withdrawal. In the two patients tested, donor DNA was not detected by polymerase chain reaction, suggesting the absence of microchimerism. MLR and CML showed that recipient lymphocytes reacted against donor lymphocytes at the same level as against the third-party lymphocytes.

CONCLUSION

Steroid withdrawal was successfully achieved in four kidney recipients who had received a liver allograft from the same donor. The MLR and CML findings indicated the absence of donor-specific hyporesponsiveness in vitro. Although the precise mechanism is not yet clear, KT after LT from the same donor should be considered as a method that allows steroids to be withdrawn from the immunosuppressive regimen of KT.

Porcine hematopoiesis on primate stroma in long-term cultures: enhanced growth with neutralizing tumor necrosis factor-alpha and tumor growth factor-beta antibodies

BACKGROUND

Donor hematopoiesis is at a competitive disadvantage when bone marrow transplantation is across species barriers. This could present major limitations to xenogeneic stem cell transplantation as an approach to tolerance induction. An in vitro model of xenogeneic engraftment was established to identify inhibitors of porcine hematopoiesis in a primate environment.

METHODS

Porcine bone marrow cells (BMC), in the presence or absence of primate CD34+ positive cells, were cultured for 4-6 weeks on primate stroma with porcine cytokines. Cellularity and growth of colony-forming cells were indicators of hematopoietic growth. Effects of soluble factors were determined by using Transwell inserts to separate porcine cells from stroma. Neutralizing antibodies for human transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) were added to cultures.

RESULTS

Porcine hematopoiesis can be maintained in long-term cultures on primate stroma with pig cytokines. Adding BMC to the stroma below Transwell-containing porcine cells dramatically inhibited porcine hematopoiesis, showing an inhibitory role for soluble factors. Neutralizing antibodies against TNF-alpha or TGF-beta caused a modest enhancement of porcine hematopoiesis; however, the combination of both led to a substantial increase. Inhibitory effects of these cytokines were confirmed by adding TNF-alpha and TGF-beta to porcine cultures.

CONCLUSIONS

Porcine cells may be more sensitive to inhibitory effects of TNF-alpha and TGF-beta than primate cells and are at a disadvantage when in a primate environment. Potential implications of this observation are discussed in the context of establishing specific immune tolerance via mixed chimerism to facilitate xenotransplantation.

Immunomodulation by intrathymic injection of donor leukocytes in rhesus monkeys

BACKGROUND

Several studies have demonstrated that intrathymic injection of donor cells into adult rodents can result in long-term allograft survival. The rationale for using the intrathymic route of donor cell administration is that in the thymic environment immature T cells are educated to discriminate between self and non-self antigens. The validity of this approach was tested in non-human primates.

METHODS

The effect of the intrathymic injection of allogeneic donor cells was investigated in rhesus monkeys and compared with IV and intracutaneous administration of donor cells. Intrathymic injections were carried out without and with antithymocyte globulin. All animals received subsequently an allogeneic skin graft of the same donor and no immunosuppression post transplantation.

RESULTS

Skin graft survival was slightly shorter in animals treated with IC donor cell injections (mean survival time [MST]=8.9+/-0.52) than untreated control animals (MST=10.0+/-0.44), indicating that this route caused sensitisation. Intravenous donor cell injection showed prolongation of graft survival times (MST=11.6+/-1.69). Intrathymic donor cell injection resulted in a graft survival of 9.2+/-1.44 days although addition of antithymocyte globulin slightly prolonged graft survival to 10.3+/-2.84 (not significant). Whereas the cellular responses after intrathymic and intravenous donor cell injections increased, antithymocyte globulin treated animals did not show an increased cellular response. Recipients of intrathymic donor cells showed a significantly decreased humoral anti-donor response as compared to other groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Donor cell pretreatment alters the subsequent response to an allogeneic skin graft in monkeys and is dependent on the route of donor cell administration. This is also reflected in the alloantibody response and the in vitro cellular reactivity. Intrathymic administration of donor cells does not lead to prolonged skin graft acceptance.

Nonmyeloablative transplantation in children. Current status and future prospects

Over the last few years a variety of conditioning regimens have been developed that allow allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell engraftment with significantly decreased transplant related-toxicity. While these reduced-intensity regimens have offered hope for patients with malignancies formerly not eligible for myeloablative transplantation due to excessive morbidity (older patients and patients with significant organ toxicity), the role of nonmyeloablative hematopoietic cell transplantation (NM-HCT) in children is unclear. A review of the available literature for pediatric and adult studies shows several malignancies in which approaches designed to limit long-term complications in children may be appropriate. In addition, NM-HCT may offer a safer approach for children with inherited disorders curable by marrow transplantation, such as immunodeficiencies, hemoglobinopathies, or storage diseases. Finally, use of this approach to establish partial donor chimerism may provide an immunologic platform that will allow specific cellular therapies, targeted gene therapy, or immunologic tolerance in solid organ transplantation.

A new method for bone marrow cell harvesting

To minimize contamination of bone marrow cells (BMCs) with T cells from the peripheral blood, a new "perfusion method" for collecting BMCs is proposed using cynomolgus monkeys. Two BM puncture needles are inserted into a long bone such as the humerus, femur, or tibia. One needle is connected to an extension tube and the end of the tube is inserted into a culture flask to collect the BM fluid. The other needle is connected to a syringe containing 30 ml of phosphate-buffered saline. The solution is pushed gently from the syringe into the medullary cavity, and the medium containing the BM fluid is collected into the culture flask. There is significantly less contamination with peripheral blood, determined from the frequencies of CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells, when using this method (<6%) than when using the conventional method (>20%) consisting of multiple BM aspirations from the iliac crest. Furthermore, the number and progenitor activities of the cells harvested using this "perfusion method" are greater than those harvested using the conventional aspiration method. This perfusion method was carried out 42 times using 15 cynomolgus monkeys, and no complications such as pulmonary infarction or paralysis were observed. These findings suggest that the "perfusion method" is safe and simple and would be of great advantage in obtaining pure BMCs, resulting in a less frequent occurrence of acute graft-versus-host-disease in allogeneic BM transplantation.

Tacrolimus-FK506 induced immunosuppression in gnotobiotic piglets

Tacrolimus (FK506), an inhibitor of calcineurin, is an immunosuppressive agent used in clinical trials of transplant patients. Although FK506 targets Ca(2+)-mediated T-cell signaling, phenotype(s) of the specific target cells and the corresponding cytokine pathways are not well known. In this study, the impact of FK506 on number and characteristic of T-cells in selected lymphoid tissues of gnotobiotic (GB) piglets was determined. FK506-treated GB piglets were compared with untreated GB and conventional piglets. The T-helper, cytotoxic, natural killer, double-positive, and activated T-cell populations were analyzed in suspensions of mononuclear cells isolated from thymus, mesenteric lymph nodes and peripheral blood. In vitro secretion of interleukin-8 and interferon-gamma in concanavalin A-stimulated lymphoid cell-cultures was measured by ELISA. Daily intramuscular treatment of GB piglets with 1mg/kg of FK506 from birth for 4 weeks resulted in lowered (P<0.05) in vitro secretion of interferon-gamma and interleukin-8. Moreover, depletions of MNC in systemic and mucosa-associated lymphoid tissues were observed in piglets treated with FK506. The depletions of mononuclear cells and low levels of interferon-gamma and interleukin-8 in piglets treated with FK506 were accompanied by lower proportion of CD3+, CD2+CD4+ and CD2+CD8+ T-cell phenotypes in peripheral blood but not in thymus and mesenteric lymph nodes. These results indicate that FK506-treatment causes immunosuppression in GB piglet, and this effect could be exploited further to study opportunistic pathogens in pig model.