The importance of framework residues H6, H7 and H10 in antibody heavy chains: experimental evidence for a new structural subclassification of antibody V(H) domains

A systemic approach to identifying sequence frameworks that decrease mAb production in a transient Chinese hamster ovary cell expression system

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are often engineered at the sequence level for improved clinical performance yet are rarely evaluated prior to candidate selection for their "developability" characteristics, namely expression, which can necessitate additional resource investments to improve the manufacturing processes for problematic mAbs. A strong relationship between primary sequence and expression has emerged, with slight differences in amino acid sequence resulting in titers differing by up to an order of magnitude. Previous work on these "difficult-to-express" (DTE) mAbs has shown that these phenotypes are driven by post-translational bottlenecks in antibody folding, assembly, and secretion processes. However, it has been difficult to translate these findings across cell lines and products. This work presents a systematic approach to study the impact of sequence variation on mAb expression at a larger scale and under more industrially relevant conditions. The analysis found 91 mutations that decreased transient expression of an IgG1κ in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and revealed that mutations at inaccessible residues, especially those leading to decreases in residue hydrophobicity, are not favorable for high expression. This workflow can be used to better understand sequence determinants of mAb expression to improve candidate selection procedures and reduce process development timelines.

The VH framework region 1 as a target of efficient mutagenesis for generating a variety of affinity-matured scFv mutants

In vitro affinity-maturation potentially generates antibody fragments with enhanced antigen-binding affinities that allow for developing more sensitive diagnostic systems and more effective therapeutic agents. Site-directed mutagenesis targeting “hot regions,” i.e., amino acid substitutions therein frequently increase the affinities, is desirable for straightforward discovery of valuable mutants. We here report two “designed” site-directed mutagenesis (A and B) targeted the N-terminal 1–10 positions of the V_H framework region 1 that successfully improved an anti-cortisol single-chain Fv fragment (K_a, 3.6 × 10⁸ M⁻¹). Mutagenesis A substituted the amino acids at the position 1–3, 5–7, 9 and 10 with a limited set of substitutions to generate only 1,536 different members, while mutagenesis B inserted 1–6 random residues between the positions 6 and 7. Screening the resulting bacterial libraries as scFv-phage clones with a clonal array profiling system provided 21 genetically unique scFv mutants showing 17–31-fold increased affinity with > 10⁹ M⁻¹K_a values. Among the mutants selected from the library A and B, scFv mA#18 (with five-residue substitutions) and mB_1-3#130 (with a single residue insertion) showed the greatest K_a value, 1.1 × 10¹⁰ M⁻¹.

Clonal array profiling of scFv-displaying phages for high-throughput discovery of affinity-matured antibody mutants

"Antibody-breeding" approach potentially generates therapeutic/diagnostic antibody mutants with greater performance than native antibodies. Therein, antibody fragments (e.g., single-chain Fv fragments; scFvs) with a variety of mutations are displayed on bacteriophage to generate diverse phage-antibody libraries. Rare clones with improved functions are then selected via panning against immobilized or tagged target antigens. However, this selection process often ended unsuccessful, mainly due to the biased propagation of phage-antibody clones and the competition with a large excess of undesirable clones with weaker affinities. To break radically from such panning-inherent problems, we developed a novel method, clonal array profiling of scFv-displaying phages (CAP), in which colonies of the initial bacterial libraries are examined one-by-one in microwells. Progenies of scFv-displaying phages generated are, if show sufficient affinity to target antigen, captured in the microwell via pre-coated antigen and detected using a luciferase-fused anti-phage scFv. The advantage of CAP was evidenced by its application with a small error-prone-PCR-based library (~ 10⁵ colonies) of anti-cortisol scFvs. Only two operations, each surveying only ~ 3% of the library (9,400 colonies), provided five mutants showing 32–63-fold improved K_a values (> 10¹⁰ M⁻¹), compared with the wild-type scFv (K_a = 3.8 × 10⁸ M⁻¹), none of which could be recovered via conventional panning procedures operated for the entire library.

Humanization and Simultaneous Optimization of Monoclonal Antibody

Antibody humanization is an essential technology for reducing the potential risk of immunogenicity associated with animal-derived antibodies and has been applied to a majority of the therapeutic antibodies on the market. For developing an antibody molecule as a pharmaceutical at the current biotechnology level, however, other properties also have to be considered in parallel with humanization in antibody generation and optimization. This section describes the critical properties of therapeutic antibodies that should be sufficiently qualified, including immunogenicity, binding affinity, physicochemical stability, expression in host cells and pharmacokinetics, and the basic methodologies of antibody engineering involved. By simultaneously optimizing the antibody molecule in light of these properties, it should prove possible to shorten the research and development period necessary to identify a highly qualified clinical candidate and consequently accelerate the start of the clinical trial.

Determinants of the assembly and function of antibody variable domains

The antibody Fv module which binds antigen consists of the variable domains V_L and V_H. These exhibit a conserved ß-sheet structure and comprise highly variable loops (CDRs). Little is known about the contributions of the framework residues and CDRs to their association. We exchanged conserved interface residues as well as CDR loops and tested the effects on two Fvs interacting with moderate affinities (K_Ds of ~2.5 µM and ~6 µM). While for the rather instable domains, almost all mutations had a negative effect, the more stable domains tolerated a number of mutations of conserved interface residues. Of particular importance for Fv association are V_LP44 and V_HL45. In general, the exchange of conserved residues in the V_L/V_H interface did not have uniform effects on domain stability. Furthermore, the effects on association and antigen binding do not strictly correlate. In addition to the interface, the CDRs modulate the variable domain framework to a significant extent as shown by swap experiments. Our study reveals a complex interplay of domain stability, association and antigen binding including an unexpected strong mutual influence of the domain framework and the CDRs on stability/association on the one side and antigen binding on the other side.

Deep sequencing in library selection projects: what insight does it bring?

High throughput sequencing is poised to change all aspects of the way antibodies and other binders are discovered and engineered. Millions of available sequence reads provide an unprecedented sampling depth able to guide the design and construction of effective, high quality naïve libraries containing tens of billions of unique molecules. Furthermore, during selections, high throughput sequencing enables quantitative tracing of enriched clones and position-specific guidance to amino acid variation under positive selection during antibody engineering. Successful application of the technologies relies on specific PCR reagent design, correct sequencing platform selection, and effective use of computational tools and statistical measures to remove error, identify antibodies, estimate diversity, and extract signatures of selection from the clone down to individual structural positions. Here we review these considerations and discuss some of the remaining challenges to the widespread adoption of the technology.

Molecular design of recombinant scFv antibodies for site-specific photocoupling to β-cyclodextrin in solution and onto solid support

The ability to design and tailor-make antibodies to meet the biophysical demands required by the vast range of current and future antibody-based applications within biotechnology and biomedicine will be essential. In this proof-of-concept study, we have for the first time tailored human recombinant scFv antibodies for site-specific photocoupling through the use of an unnatural amino acid (UAA) and the dock'n'flash technology. In more detail, we have successfully explored the possibility to expand the genetic code of E. coli and introduced the photoreactive UAA p-benzoyl-L-phenylalanine (pBpa), and showed that the mutated scFv antibody could be expressed in E. coli with retained structural and functional properties, as well as binding affinity. The pBpa group was then used for affinity capture of the mutated antibody by β-cyclodextrin (β-CD), which provided the hydrogen atoms to be abstracted in the subsequent photocoupling process upon irradiation at 365nm. The results showed that the pBpa mutated antibody could be site-specifically photocoupled to free and surface (array) immobilized β-CD. Taken together, this paves the way for novel means of tailoring recombinant scFv antibodies for site-specific photochemical-based tagging, functionalization and immobilization in numerous applications.

Protease-resistant single-domain antibodies inhibit Campylobacter jejuni motility

Camelid heavy-chain antibody variable domains (VHHs) are emerging as potential antimicrobial reagents. We have engineered a previously isolated VHH (FlagV1M), which binds Campylobacter jejuni flagella, for greater thermal and proteolytic stability. Mutants of FlagV1M were obtained from an error-prone polymerase chain reaction library that was panned in the presence of gastrointestinal (GI) proteases. Additional FlagV1M mutants were obtained through disulfide-bond engineering. Each approach produced VHHs with enhanced thermal stability and protease resistance. When the beneficial mutations from both approaches were combined, a hyperstabilized VHH was created with superior stability. The hyperstabilized VHH bound C. jejuni flagella with wild-type affinity and was capable of potently inhibiting C. jejuni motility in assays performed after sequential digestion with three major GI proteases, demonstrating the remarkable stability imparted to the VHH by combining our engineering approaches.

Humanization and simultaneous optimization of monoclonal antibody

Antibody humanization is an essential technology for reducing the potential risk of immunogenicity associated with animal-derived antibodies and has been applied to a majority of the therapeutic antibodies on the market. For developing an antibody molecule as a pharmaceutical at the current biotechnology level, however, other properties also have to be considered in parallel with humanization in antibody generation and optimization. This section describes the critical properties of therapeutic antibodies that should be sufficiently qualified, including immunogenicity, binding affinity, physiochemical stability, expression in host cells and pharmacokinetics, and the basic methodologies of antibody engineering involved. By simultaneously optimizing the antibody molecule in the light of these properties, it should prove possible to shorten the research and development period necessary to identify a highly qualified clinical candidate and consequently accelerate the start of the clinical trial.

Generation of recombinant antibodies and means for increasing their affinity

Highly specific interaction with foreign molecules is a unique feature of antibodies. Since 1975, when Keller and Milstein proposed the method of hybridoma technology and prepared mouse monoclonal antibodies, many antibodies specific to various antigens have been obtained. Recent development of methods for preparation of recombinant DNA libraries and in silico bioinformatics approaches for protein structure analysis makes possible antibody preparation using gene engineering approaches. The development of gene engineering methods allowed creating recombinant antibodies and improving characteristics of existing antibodies; this significantly extends the applicability of antibodies. By modifying biochemical and immunochemical properties of antibodies by changing their amino acid sequences it is possible to create antibodies with properties optimal for certain tasks. For example, application of recombinant technologies resulted in antibody preparation of high affinity significantly exceeding the initial affinity of natural antibodies. In this review we summarize information about the structure, modes of preparation, and application of recombinant antibodies and their fragments and also consider the main approaches used to increase antibody affinity.

Antibody engineering using phage display with a coiled-coil heterodimeric Fv antibody fragment

A Fab-like antibody binding unit, ccFv, in which a pair of heterodimeric coiled-coil domains was fused to V_H and V_L for Fv stabilization, was constructed for an anti-VEGF antibody. The anti-VEGF ccFv showed the same binding affinity as scFv but significantly improved stability and phage display level. Furthermore, phage display libraries in the ccFv format were constructed for humanization and affinity maturation of the anti-VEGF antibody. A panel of V_H frameworks and V_H-CDR3 variants, with a significant improvement in affinity and expressibility in both E. coli and yeast systems, was isolated from the ccFv phage libraries. These results demonstrate the potential application of the ccFv antibody format in antibody engineering.

Generation of a humanized anti-glypican 3 antibody by CDR grafting and stability optimization

Glypican 3 (GPC3), a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored heparan sulfate proteoglycan, is expressed in a majority of hepatocellular carcinoma tissues. The murine monoclonal antibody GC33 that specifically binds to the COOH-terminal part of GPC3 causes strong antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity against hepatocellular carcinoma cells and exhibits strong antitumor activity in the xenograft models. To apply GC33 for clinical use, we generated a humanized GC33 from complementarity-determining region grafting with the aid of both the hybrid variable region and two-step design methods. The humanized antibody bound to GPC3 specifically and induced antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity as effectively as a chimeric GC33 antibody. To improve stability of the humanized GC33, we further optimized humanized GC33 by replacing the amino acid residues that may affect the structure of the variable region of a heavy chain. Substitution of Glu6 with Gln in the heavy chain significantly improved the stability under high temperatures. GC33 also has the risk of deamidation of the -Asn-Gly- sequence in the complementarity-determining region 1 of the light chain. As substitution of Asn diminished the antigen binding, we changed the neighboring Gly to Arg to avoid deamidation. The resulting humanized anti-GPC3 antibody was as efficacious as chimeric GC33 against the HepG2 xenograft and is now being evaluated in clinical trials.

Generation and characterization of a scFv against recombinant coat protein of the geminivirus tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus

We report the establishment of a hybridoma cell line secreting the monoclonal antibody (mAb) HAV, which recognizes the coat (AV1) protein of tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus (ToLCNDV), a begomovirus. The cell line was obtained following immunization of mice with purified recombinant AV1 fused to glutathione S-transferase (GST). A single-chain variable fragment (scFv-SAV) was assembled from hybridoma cDNA, but sequence analysis revealed a single nucleotide deletion causing a frame shift that resulted in a 21-residue N-terminal truncation. The missing nucleotide was restored by in vitro site-directed mutagenesis to create scFv-RWAV. The binding properties of mAb HAV and the corresponding scFvs were characterized by western blot, ELISA and surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy. MAb HAV bound to AV1 with nanomolar affinity but reacted neither with the N-terminal region of the protein nor with the GST fusion partner. This suggested that the antibody recognized a linear epitope in a region of the coat protein that is conserved among begomoviruses. Both scFvs retained the antigen specificity of mAb HAV, although the dissociation rate constant of scFv-RWAV was tenfold greater than that of scFv-SAV, showing the importance of restoring the 21 N-terminal amino acids.

Efficient isolation of soluble intracellular single-chain antibodies using the twin-arginine translocation machinery

One of the most commonly used recombinant antibody formats is the single-chain variable fragment (scFv) that consists of the antibody variable heavy chain connected to the variable light chain by a flexible linker. Since disulfide bonds are often necessary for scFv folding, it can be challenging to express scFvs in the reducing environment of the cytosol. Thus, we sought to develop a method for antigen-independent selection of scFvs that are stable in the reducing cytosol of bacteria. To this end, we applied a recently developed genetic selection for protein folding and solubility based on the quality control feature of the Escherichia coli twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway. This selection employs a tripartite sandwich fusion of a protein-of-interest with an N-terminal Tat-specific signal peptide and C-terminal TEM1 beta-lactamase, thereby coupling antibiotic resistance with Tat pathway export. Here, we adapted this assay to develop intrabody selection after Tat export (ISELATE), a high-throughput selection strategy for the identification of solubility-enhanced scFv sequences. Using ISELATE for three rounds of laboratory evolution, it was possible to evolve a soluble scFv from an insoluble parental sequence. We show also that ISELATE enables focusing of an scFv library in soluble sequence space before functional screening and thus can be used to increase the likelihood of finding functional intrabodies. Finally, the technique was used to screen a large repertoire of naïve scFvs for clones that conferred significant levels of soluble accumulation. Our results reveal that the Tat quality control mechanism can be harnessed for molecular evolution of scFvs that are soluble in the reducing cytoplasm of E. coli.

Anti-D and anti-i activities are inseparable in V4-34-encoded monoclonal anti-D: the same framework 1 residues are required for both reactivities

BACKGROUND

The heavy-chain V4-34 germline gene segment is mandatory for pathologic cold-reacting autoantibodies with anti-I/i specificity (cold agglutinins) and is also preferentially used by monoclonal immunoglobulin M alloantibodies against D and other Rh antigens. The use of the V4-34 segment by monoclonal anti-D has previously been shown to also confer anti-I/i reactivity (cold agglutinin activity), which has implications for the use of such antibodies for Rh blood typing. V4-34 framework 1 (FR1) sequence is believed to be critical for cold agglutinin activity of cold agglutinins.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The aim of this investigation was to use site-directed mutagenesis of a recombinant V4-34-encoded anti-D to determine the contribution of V4-34 FR1 sequence to anti-D activity and whether mutational modifications in the FR1 region could separately alter anti-D and anti-i activities.

RESULTS

The results show that amino acid changes in V4-34 FR1 at W7, A23, and Y25 have a profound effect on anti-D activity as well as on anti-i activity. It was not possible to substantially reduce or remove anti-i activity without reducing anti-D activity to a comparable extent.

CONCLUSIONS

The same nonpolar hydrophobic amino acids in FR1 are critical for maintaining both anti-D and anti-i activity. It is proposed that these residues influence the conformation of the antigen-binding site.

Expression and detection strategies for an scFv fragment retaining the same high affinity than Fab and whole antibody: Implications for therapeutic use in prion diseases

Since antibodies currently constitute the most rapidly growing class of human therapeutics, the high-yield production of recombinant antibodies and antibody fragments is a real challenge. Using as model a monoclonal antibody directed against the human prion protein that we prepared previously and tested for its therapeutic value, we describe here experimental conditions allowing the production of large quantities (up to 35 mg/l of bacterial culture) of correctly refolded and totally functional single chain fragment variable (scFv). These quantities were sufficient to characterize the binding properties of this small recombinant fragment through in vitro and ex vivo approaches. Interestingly, this scFv retains full binding capacity for its antigen, i.e. the human prion protein, when compared with the corresponding Fab or whole antibody, and recognizes soluble, solid-phase-adsorbed, and membrane-bound prion protein. This strongly suggests that from the mAb cloning step to the refolding of the recombinant fragment, each stage is well controlled, leading to almost 100% functional scFv. These results are of interest not only in view of possible immunotherapy for prion diseases, but also more generally in emphasizing the great promise of these small recombinant molecules in the context of targeted therapies.

The indirect generation of long-distance structural changes in antibodies upon their binding to antigen

An allosteric mechanism for the generation of long-distance structural alterations in Fab fragments of antibodies in immune complexes has been postulated and tested in theoretical and experimental analysis. The flexing and/or torsion-derived forces exerted on the elbow region in Fab arms of bivalent antibodies upon binding to antigen were assumed to drive the disruption of hydrogen bonds which stabilize N- and C-terminal chain fragments in V-domains. This allows an extra movement in the elbow followed by a relaxation in the Fab arm and may generate long-distance effects if, in particular, the structural changes are generated asymmetrically involving one chain of the Fab arm only. This mechanism was studied by simulation of molecular dynamics. The local instability in the area involving the site of packing of the N-terminal chain fragment allows penetration and binding of the supramolecular dye Congo red that hence becomes an indicator of the initiated relaxation process and is also the prospective ligand in studies of designing drugs. The susceptibility to dye binding was observed in complexation of bivalent antibodies only, supplying the evidence that constraints associating the interaction with randomly distributed antigenic determinants drive the local structural changes in the V-domain followed by long-distance effects.

A study of the structural correlates of affinity maturation: Antibody affinity as a function of chemical interactions, structural plasticity and stability

Mutations introduced in an antibody germline sequence as a result of somatic hypermutation could cause its derivatives to have an altered affinity for its target. Affinity maturation favors the selection of the antibodies which exhibit increased affinity. The mutations in 80 high affinity anti-thyroid peroxidase sequences derived from six germlines were analysed in terms of the physicochemical properties of the replacement residues, namely hydrophilicity, size and polarizability, and charge and polarity, in the context of its position and probable solvent accessibility. The effects of these substitutions were evaluated in terms of the resultant increased chemical interactivity potential of the affinity-matured antibodies relative to the germline. The results of the analysis would be useful in the rational design of antibodies and of other proteins for improved binding properties.

Efficient expression of recombinant human monoclonal antibodies in Drosophila S2 cells

We have explored the Drosophila S2 cell line for expression of Ig molecules isolated as Fab or scFv cDNA from phage-displayed libraries. We present a series of vectors for inducible expression and secretion of human Ig heavy (HC) and light chains (LC), both on separate plasmids and in combination constructs. Both HC (tested as human gamma(1)) and LC (human kappa) could be expressed separately and were secreted into the medium, confirming previous reports. When the combination vector carrying both the HC and LC cDNA, as well as when the HC and LC vectors were co-transfected, complete IgG1 was found in the medium. Transient transfection resulted in production levels of 0.5-1 mg/l. Stable cell lines could be established within 2-3 weeks. After 10-12 days of expression from such cell lines, Ig molecules accumulated and the medium contained typically 5-35 mg/l of IgG1. The IgG in these preparations was purified to more than 90% purity on protein G columns. Binding characteristics for IgG of the same clone expressed in S2 cells or mammalian cells were indistinguishable. The main advantages with this system compared to mammalian expression were its robustness and the much faster establishment of stable, high level producing cell lines.

Latest technologies for the enhancement of antibody affinity

High affinity antibodies are crucial both for the discovery and validation of biomarkers for human health and disease and as clinical diagnostic and therapeutic reagents. This review describes some of the latest technologies for the design, mutation and selection of high affinity antibodies that provide a paradigm for molecular evolution of a far wider range of proteins including enzymes. Strategies include both in vivo and in vitro methods and embrace the latest concepts for antibody display and selection. Specifically, affinity enhancement can be tailored to the target-binding surface, typically the complementary determining region (CDR) loops in antibodies, whereas enhanced stability, expression or catalytic properties can be affected by selected changes to the core protein scaffold. Together, these technologies provide a rapid and powerful strategy to drive the next generation of protein-based reagents for numerous clinical, environmental and agribusiness applications.

Analysis of correlated domain motions in IgG light chain reveals possible mechanisms of immunological signal transduction

It was shown experimentally that binding of a micelle composed of Congo red molecules to immunological complexes leads to the enhanced stability of the latter, and simultaneously prevents binding of a complement molecule (C1q). The dye binds in a cavity created by the removal of N-terminal polypeptide chain, as observed experimentally in a model system-immunoglobulin G (IgG) light chain dimer. Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of three forms of IgG light chain dimer, with and without the dye, were performed to investigate the role of N-terminal fragment and self-assembled ligand in coupling between V and C domains. Root-mean-square distance (RMSD) time profiles show that removal of N-terminal fragment leads to destabilization of V domain. A micelle composed of four self-assembled dye molecules stabilizes and fixes the domain. Analysis of root-mean-square fluctuation (RMSF) values and dynamic cross-correlation matrices (DCCM) reveals that removal of N-terminal fragment results in complete decoupling between V and C domains. Binding of self-assembled Congo red molecules improves the coupling, albeit slightly. The disruption of a small beta-sheet composed of N- and C-terminal fragments of the domain (NC sheet) is the most likely reason for the decoupling. Self-assembled ligand, bound in the place originally occupied by N-terminal fragment, is not able to take over the function of the beta-sheet. Lack of correlation of motions between residues in V and C domains denotes that light chain-Congo red complexes have hampered ability to transmit conformational changes between domains. This is a likely explanation of the lack of complement binding by immunological complexes, which bind Congo red, and supports the idea that the NC sheet is the key structural fragment taking part in immunological signal transduction.

Directed evolution for the development of conformation-specific affinity reagents using yeast display

Yeast display is a powerful tool for increasing the affinity and thermal stability of scFv antibodies through directed evolution. Mammalian calmodulin (CaM) is a highly conserved signaling protein that undergoes structural changes upon Ca(2+) binding. In an attempt to generate conformation-specific antibodies for proteomic applications, a selection against CaM was undertaken. Flow cytometry-based screening strategies to isolate easily scFv recognizing CaM in either the Ca(2+)-bound (Ca(2+)-CaM) or Ca(2+)-free (apo-CaM) states are presented. Both full-length scFv and single-domain VH only clones were isolated. One scFv clone having very high affinity (K(d) = 0.8 nM) and specificity (>1000-fold) for Ca(2+)-CaM was obtained from de novo selections. Subsequent directed evolution allowed the development of antibodies with higher affinity (K(d) = 1 nM) and specificity (>300-fold) for apo-CaM from a parental single-domain clone with both a modest affinity and specificity for that particular isoform. CaM-binding activity was unexpectedly lost upon conversion of both conformation-specific clones into soluble fragments. However, these results demonstrate that conformation-specific antibodies can be quickly and easily isolated by directed evolution using the yeast display platform.

Humanization and epitope mapping of the H23 anti-MUC1 monoclonal antibody reveals a dual epitope specificity

The tumor-associated antigen MUC1 is a cell surface mucin that is expressed on the apical surface of most glandular epithelial cells, including the ducts of the breast, ovary, pancrease, lung and colon. During malignancy, epithelial tissues regularly display elevated levels of MUC1 in a non-polar fashion and in an underglycosylated form, exposing cryptic peptide and carbohydrate epitopes. As such, MUC1 is regarded a potential target for immunotherapeutical intervention. Murine monoclonal H23 antibody specifically recognizes a MUC1 epitope on the surface of human breast cancer cells. We describe the cloning of the variable domains of H23 and their expression in (Escherichia coli) E. coli as maltose-binding protein-scFv (MBP-scFv) fusions. We humanized H23 and evaluated the binding properties of the murine and the humanized recombinant forms, which were similar in affinity and specificity, but lower in apparent affinity in comparison to the original monoclonal IgG. We mapped the epitope of humanized H23 by affinity-selecting a phage-displayed random peptide library on humanized H23 scFv-displaying bacteria. Our results show that humanized H23 binds an epitope corresponding to the MUC1 tandem repeat and an additional epitope not related to MUC1. These epitopes are competitive, bound with similar affinities and are recognized by the original murine H23 monoclonal antibody as well.

Expression improvement and mechanistic study of the retro-Diels-Alderase catalytic antibody 10F11 by site-directed mutagenesis

Antibody 10F11 catalyzes the retro-Diels-Alder reaction of the bicyclic prodrug 1 releasing HNO and anthracene 4 (kcat/kuncat=2500). Earlier X-ray crystal structures of Fab 10F11 showed that tryptophan H104 at the bottom of the binding pocket interacts by pi-stacking with the aromatic ring of the substrate. Antibody 10F11 was expressed as a chimeric Fab and subjected to site-directed mutagenesis. Expression was improved by substituting a serine for a phenylalanine residue on the Fv-domain surface. Nine active-site mutants were then prepared including replacements at TrpH104, PheH101 and SerH100. Catalysis depends mainly on TrpH104 and PheH101. Catalysis is most likely caused by a combination of shape complementarity and specific electronic interactions between transition state and the aromatic residue H104. Medium and de-solvation effects have no effect on the reaction rate. Catalysis was improved to (kcat/kuncat=6300) by substituting phenylalanine for LeuL101 to indirectly enhance pi-stacking between transition state and TrpH104.

Domain swapping of a llama VHH domain builds a crystal-wide beta-sheet structure

Among mammals, camelids have a unique immunological system since they produce functional antibodies devoid of light chains and CH1 domains. To bind antigens, whether they are proteins or haptens, camelids use the single domain VH from their heavy chain (VHH). We report here on such a llama VHH domain (VHH-R9) which was raised against a hapten, the RR6 red dye. This VHH possesses the shortest complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) among all the known VHH sequences and nevertheless binds RR6 efficiently with a K(d) value of 83 nM. However, the crystal structure of VHH-R9 exhibits a striking feature: its CDR3 and its last beta-strand (beta9) do not follow the immunoglobulin VH domain fold, but instead extend out of the VHH molecular boundary and associate with a symmetry-related molecule. The two monomers thus form a domain-swapped dimer which establishes further contacts with symmetry-related molecules and build a crystal-wide beta-sheet structure. The driving force of the dimer formation is probably the strain induced by the short CDR3 together with the cleavage of the first seven residues.

Directed in Vitro Evolution and Crystallographic Analysis of a Peptide-binding Single Chain Antibody Fragment (scFv) with Low Picomolar Affinity

We generated a single chain Fv fragment of an antibody (scFv) with a binding affinity of about 5 pm to a short peptide by applying rigorous directed evolution. Starting from a high affinity peptide binder, originally obtained by ribosome display from a murine library, we generated libraries of mutants with error-prone PCR and DNA shuffling and applied off-rate selection by using ribosome display. Crystallographic analysis of the scFv in its antigen-bound and free state showed that only few mutations, which do not make direct contact to the antigen, lead to a 500-fold affinity improvement over its potential germ line precursor. These results suggest that the affinity optimization of very high affinity binders is achieved by modulating existing interactions via subtle changes in the framework rather than by introducing new contacts. Off-rate selection in combination with ribosome display can evolve binders to the low picomolar affinity range even for peptide targets.

A general method allowing the design of oligonucleotide primers to amplify the variable regions from immunoglobulin cDNA

The amplification of variable regions of immunoglobulins by reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) has become an invaluable technique either for the cloning of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), or for the building of single-chain fragment variable (ScFv) libraries. Numerous applications have been described either for studying the antigen-antibody interactions or for medical purposes, with the recent development of recombinant antibodies for therapeutic use. Several publications by different groups have reported primer sequences to perform such amplification, but the strategy used to design these primers, and particularly the way of performing the necessary alignments, generally appear poorly detailed. In the present work, we propose a rational method of designing primers in order to amplify the variable region of heavy chain (VH) and variable region of light chain (VL) domains for framework 1 (FR1) of immunoglobulins. The described sets of primers have been designed to hybridize with the entire VH and VL mouse repertory without modification of amino acids since amino acids of framework 1 play a role in the folding, and thus in the functionality, of recombinant antibody. These primers have been applied to the cloning of monoclonal antibodies previously produced in the laboratory. This approach can be extended to other species or members of the immunoglobulin superfamily.

Local and long-range structural effects caused by the removal of the N-terminal polypeptide fragment from immunoglobulin L chain lambda

The role of the N-terminal polypeptide fragment of the immunoglobulin l-chain in V domain packing stability, and the flexibility of the whole chain was approached by molecular dynamics simulation. The observations were supported by experimental analysis. The N-terminal polypeptide fragment appeared to be the low-stability packing element in the V domain. At moderately elevated temperature it may be replaced at its packing locus by Congo red and then removed by proteolysis. After removal of Congo red by adsorption to (diethylamino)ethyl (DEAE) cellulose, the stability of complete L chain and of L chain devoid of the N-terminal polypeptide fragment were compared. The results indicated that the N-terminal polypeptide fragment plays an essential role in the stability of the V domain. Its removal makes the domain accessible for ANS and Congo red dye binding without heating. The decreased domain stability was registered in particular as increased root mean square (RMS) fluctuation and higher susceptibility to proteolytic attack. The long-range effect was most clearly manifested at 340 K as independent V and C domain fluctuation in the l-chain devoid of the N-terminal polypeptide fragment. This is likely due to the lack of direct connections between the N- and C-termini of the V domain polypeptide. In a complete V domain the connection involves residues 8-12 and 106-110 in particular. Partial or complete disruption of this connection increases the freedom of V domain rotation, while its increased cohesion strengthens the coupling of the V and C domains, making the whole L chain less flexible.

Repertoire shift in the humoral response to phosphocholine-keyhole limpet hemocyanin: VH somatic mutation in germinal center B cells impairs T15 Ig function

Phosphocholine (PC) is a naturally occurring Ag common to many pathogenic microorganisms. Early in the primary response to PC conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), T15 Id(+) Abs constitute >90% of the serum Ig in BALB/c mice. During the late primary and memory response to PC-protein, a shift in the repertoire occurs and T15 Id(+) Abs lose dominance. In this study, we use immunohistochemistry and single germinal center microdissection to locate T15 Id(+) cells in the spleen in a primary response to PC-KLH. We demonstrate T15 Id(+) B cells and V(H)1-DFL16.1-JH1 and V kappa 22-J kappa 5 rearrangements in germinal centers early in the immune response; thus loss of T15 dominance is not due to lack of T15 cells within germinal centers. One-hundred thirty one V(H)1 and 57 V kappa 22 rearrangements were cloned and sequenced. Thirty four percent of the V(H)1 clones and 37% of the V kappa 22 clones contained somatic mutations indicating participation in the germinal center response. Six variant T15 H clones were expressed with wild-type T15 L chain in vitro. Two of these Abs were defective in secretion providing the first evidence that mutation occurring in vivo can disrupt Ig assembly and secretion. Of the four secretion-competent Abs, two failed to display binding to PC-protein, while the other two displayed altered carrier recognition. These results indicate that somatic mutation of T15 in vivo can result in the loss of binding and secretion, potentially leading to B cell wastage. The failure of T15 to gain affinity enhancing mutations in the face of these detrimental changes may contribute to repertoire shift.

Intrabodies based on intracellular capture frameworks that bind the RAS protein with high affinity and impair oncogenic transformation

We have applied in vivo intracellular antibody capture (IAC) technology to isolate human intrabodies which bind to the oncogenic RAS protein. IAC facilitates the capture of antibody fragments, in this case single-chain Fvs (scFvs), which tolerate reducing environments, such as the cytoplasm of cancer cells. Three anti-RAS scFvs with different affinity, solubility and intracellular binding activity were characterized. The anti-RAS scFvs with highest affinity were expressed relatively poorly in mammalian cells, and greater soluble expression was achieved by mutating the antibody framework to canonical consensus scaffolds, previously derived from IAC, without losing antigen specificity. Mutagenesis experiments showed that the consensus scaffolds are functional as intrabody fragments without an intra-domain disulfide bond. Furthermore, we could convert an intrabody which does not bind RAS in mammalian cells into a high-affinity reagent capable of inhibiting RAS-mediated NIH 3T3 transformation by exchanging VH and VL complementarity-determining regions onto its consensus scaffold. These data show that the consensus scaffold is a robust framework by which to improve intrabody function.

Structure-based improvement of the biophysical properties of immunoglobulin VH domains with a generalizable approach

In a systematic study of V gene families carried out with consensus V(H) and V(L) domains alone and in combinations in the scFv format, we found comparatively low expression yields and lower cooperativity in equilibrium unfolding in antibody fragments containing V(H) domains of human germline families 2, 4, and 6. From an analysis of the packing of the hydrophobic core, the completeness of charge clusters, the occurrence of unsatisfied hydrogen bonds, and residues with low beta-sheet propensities, positive Phi angles, and exposed hydrophobic side chains, we pinpointed residues potentially responsible for the unsatisfactory properties of these germline-encoded sequences. Several of those are in common between the domains of the even-numbered subgroups, but do not occur in the odd-numbered ones. In this study, we have systematically exchanged those residues alone and in combination in two different scFvs using the V(H)6 framework, and we describe their effect on equilibrium stability and folding yield. We improved the stability by 20.9 kJ/mol and the expression yield by a factor of 4 and can now use these data to rationally engineer antibodies derived from this and similar germline families for better biophysical properties. Furthermore, we provide an improved design for libraries exploiting the significant additional diversity provided by these frameworks. Both antibodies studied here completely retain their binding affinity, demonstrating that the CDR conformations were not affected.

Biophysical properties of human antibody variable domains

There are great demands on the stability, expression yield and resistance to aggregation of antibody fragments. To untangle intrinsic domain effects from domain interactions, we present first a systematic evaluation of the isolated human immunoglobulin variable heavy (V(H)) and light (V(L)) germline family consensus domains and then a systematic series of V(H)-V(L) combinations in the scFv format. The constructs were evaluated in terms of their expression behavior, oligomeric state in solution and denaturant-induced unfolding equilibria under non-reducing conditions. The seven V(H) and seven V(L) domains represent the consensus sequences of the major human germline subclasses, derived from the Human Combinatorial Antibody Library (HuCAL). The isolated V(H) and V(L) domains with the highest thermodynamic stability and yield of soluble protein were V(H)3 and V(kappa)3, respectively. Similar measurements on all domain combinations in scFv fragments allowed the scFv fragments to be classified according to thermodynamic stability and in vivo folding yield. The scFv fragments containing the variable domain combinations H3kappa3, H1bkappa3, H5kappa3 and H3kappa1 show superior properties concerning yield and stability. Domain interactions diminish the intrinsic differences of the domains. ScFv fragments containing V(lambda) domains show high levels of stability, even though V(lambda) domains are surprisingly unstable by themselves. This is due to a strong interaction with the V(H) domain and depends on the amino acid sequence of the CDR-L3. On the basis of these analyses and model structures, we suggest possibilities for further improvement of the biophysical properties of individual frameworks and give recommendations for library design.

Single-chain Fv multimers of the anti-neuraminidase antibody NC10: the residue at position 15 in the V(L) domain of the scFv-0 (V(L)-V(H)) molecule is primarily responsible for formation of a tetramer-trimer equilibrium

Single-chain variable fragment of the murine monoclonal antibody NC10 specific to influenza virus N9 neuraminidase, joined directly in the V(L) to V(H) orientation (scFv-0), forms an equilibrium mixture of tetramer and trimer with the tetramer as the preferred multimeric species. In contrast, the V(H)-V(L) isomer was previously shown to exist exclusively as a trimer. Computer-generated trimeric and tetrameric scFv models, based on the refined crystal structure for NC10 Fv domain, were constructed and used to evaluate factors influencing the transition between V(L)-V(H) trimer and tetramer. These model structures indicated that steric restrictions between loops spanning amino acid residues L55-L59 and L13-L17 from the two adjacent V(L) domains within the V(L)-V(H) trimer were responsible for four scFv-0 molecules assembling to form a tetramer. In particular, leucine at position L15 and glutamate at position L57 appeared to interfere significantly with each other. To minimize this steric interference, the site-directed mutagenesis technique was used to construct several NC10 scFv-0 clones with mutations at these positions. Size-exclusion chromatographic analyses revealed that several of these mutations resulted in the production of NC10 scFv-0 proteins with significantly altered tetramer-trimer equilibrium ratios. In particular, introduction of a polar residue, such as asparagine or threonine, at position L15 generated a highly stable NC10 scFv-0 trimer.

Comparison of three microbial hosts for the expression of an active catalytic scFv

Antibodies represent an interesting protein framework on which catalytic functions can be grafted. In previous studies, we have reported the characterization of the catalytic antibody 4B2 obtained on the basis of the "bait and switch" strategy which catalyzes two different chemical reactions: the allylic isomerization of beta,gamma-unsaturated ketones and the Kemp elimination. We have cloned the antibody 4B2 and expressed it as a single-chain Fv (scFv) fragment in different expression systems, Escherichia coli and two yeasts species, in order to elicit the most suitable system to study its catalytic activity. The scFv4B2 was secreted as an active form in the culture medium of Pichia pastoris and Kluyveromyces lactis, which led respectively to 4 and 1.3mg/l after purification. In E. coli, different strategies were investigated to increase the cytoplasmic soluble fraction, which resulted, in all cases, in the expression of a low amount of functional antibodies. By contrast, substantial amount of scFv4B2 could be purified when it was expressed as inclusion bodies (12mg/l) and submitted to an in vitro refolding process. Its catalytic activity was measured and proved to be comparable to that of the whole IgG. However, the instability of the scFv4B2 in solution prevented from an exhaustive characterization of its activity and stabilization of this protein appears to be essential before designing strategies to improve its catalytic activity.

Functional aspects of co-variant surface charges in an antibody fragment

A mutational analysis of three co-variant pairs of residues, located at the surface of a single-chain fragment, variable (scFv), remote from the antigen-binding site, was performed to investigate the tolerance of these positions to amino acid changes. The replacements consisted of the elimination or addition of charges, or in their replacement by a charge of opposite sign. As measured by Biacore, antigen-binding kinetics and specificity were essentially unaffected by the mutations. The purified scFvs remained mostly 100% active for 14 h, and their sensitivity to guanidinium-chloride denaturation was similar. These observations indicate that the mutations did not affect antigen-binding properties and that protein folding was conserved. However, the various scFvs differed greatly in half-life in periplasmic extracts (<4 h to >16 h at 25 degrees C). The deleterious effect on half-life produced by single mutations could be reversed by introducing a second mutation that restores the natural combination of amino acids in the co-variant pair, indicating that the consequence of charge modifications at these locations depends on the sequence context. We propose that the differences in half-life result from differences in aggregation propensities with other periplasmic proteins, related to the presence of charged patches at the surface of the scFvs. The practical implication is that changes in surface charge may drastically affect the level of active molecules in complex protein mixtures, a potentially important consideration in engineering scFvs for biotechnological or medical purposes.

The influence of the buried glutamine or glutamate residue in position 6 on the structure of immunoglobulin variable domains

Immunoglobulin V(H) domain frameworks can be grouped into four distinct types, depending on the main-chain conformation of framework 1. Based on the analysis of over 200 X-ray structures representing more than 100 non-redundant V(H) domain sequences, we have come to the conclusion that the marked structural variability of the V(H) framework 1 region is caused by three residues: the buried side-chain of H6, which can be either a glutamate or a glutamine residue, the residue in position H7, which may be proline only if H6 is glutamine, and by H9 (H10 according to a new consensus nomenclature), which has to be either glycine or proline if H6 is a glutamate residue. In natural antibodies, these three residues are encoded in combinations that are compatible with each other and with the rest of the structure and therefore will yield functional molecules. However, the degenerate primer mixtures commonly used for PCR cloning of antibody fragments can and frequently do introduce out-of-context mutations to combinations that can lead to severe reduction of stability, production yield and antigen affinity.

Yet another numbering scheme for immunoglobulin variable domains: an automatic modeling and analysis tool

A common residue numbering scheme for all immunoglobulin variable domains (immunoglobulin light chain lambda (V(lambda)) and kappa (V(kappa)) variable domains, heavy chain variable domains (V(H)) and T-cell receptor alpha (V(alpha)), beta (V(beta)), gamma (V(gamma)) and delta (V(delta)) variable domains) has been devised. Based on the spatial alignment of known three-dimensional structures of immunoglobulin domains, it places the alignment gaps in a way that minimizes the average deviation from the averaged structure of the aligned domains. This residue numbering scheme was applied to the immunoglobulin variable domain structures in the PDB database to automate the extraction of information on structural variations in homologous positions of the different molecules. A number of methods are presented that allow the automated projection of information derived from individual structures or from the comparison of multi-structure alignments onto a graphical representation of the sequence alignment.