Acute inflammatory response to cowpox virus infection of the chorioallantoic membrane of the chick embryo

Tumor grafted - chick chorioallantoic membrane as an alternative model for biological cancer research and conventional/nanomaterial-based theranostics evaluation

Introduction: Advancements in cancer management and treatment are associated with strong preclinical research data, in which reliable cancer models are demanded. Indeed, inconsistent preclinical findings and stringent regulations following the 3Rs principle of reduction, refinement, and replacement of conventional animal models currently pose challenges in the development and translation of efficient technologies. The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) is a system for the evaluation of treatment effects on the vasculature, therefore suitable for studies on angiogenesis. Apart from vascular effects, the model is now increasingly employed as a preclinical cancer model following tumor-grafting procedures.Areas covered: The broad application of CAM tumor model is highlighted along with the methods for analyzing the neoplasm and vascular system. The presented and cited investigations focus on cancer biology and treatment, encompassing both conventional and emerging nanomaterial-based modalities.Expert opinion: The CAM tumor model finds increased significance given the influences of angiogenesis and the tumor microenvironment in cancer behavior, then providing a qualified miniature system for oncological research. Ultimately, the establishment and increased employment of such a model may resolve some of the limitations present in the standard preclinical tumor models, thereby redefining the preclinical research workflow.

Insights into pathological and molecular characterization of avipoxviruses circulating in Egypt

1. Avipoxvirus (APV) infections are one of many threats inflicting economic losses within the poultry industry, particularly in tropical and subtropical countries. A proper and comprehensive study for APVs is needed to increase the knowledge concerning the diversity and evolution of the virus.2. For this purpose, 136 bird flocks of different species and breeding types were examined for APV infection between October 2016 and November 2017. One hundred and thirty samples had visible pocks on the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) which were designated as fowl pox-like viruses via amplification of 578 bp from the P4b gene and 1800 bp from the fpv140 locus.4. A comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of fpv167 locus (P4b), fpv140 locus (fpv139 and fpv140) and fpv94 (DNA polymerase) revealed that all the analysed strains belong to fowl pox-like viruses (clade A; subclade A1 and A2). Based on the fpv140 locus full nucleotide sequence, three turkey originated strains were seen to be divergent from chicken originated sequences and branched into novel subclade A1.b.5. Trees comparison, within the term of speculation of virus-host specificity, clearly highlighted a high order specific subgrouping among subclades in the case of the fpv140 locus (including fpv139 and fpv140). Hence, the fowl poxvirus, turkey poxvirus and pigeon poxvirus strains clustered into distinct host-specific subclades A1a, A1.b and A2, respectively, which could not be seen in the FWPV-P4b and DNA polymerase phylogeny.

Tracking Modified Vaccinia Virus Ankara in the Chicken Embryo: In Vivo Tropism and Pathogenesis of Egg Infections

The Modified Vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is a highly attenuated vaccinia virus serving as a promising vector vaccine platform to develop vaccines against infectious diseases. In contrast to the well-established replication deficiency and safety of MVA in mammals, much less is known about MVA infection in avian hosts. Here, we used a recombinant MVA expressing fluorescent reporter proteins under transcriptional control of specific viral early and late promoters to study in vivo tropism, distribution, and pathogenesis of MVA infections in embryonated chicken eggs. The chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) of embryonated chicken eggs was inoculated with recombinant MVA, MVA or phosphate-buffered saline. The infection was analyzed by fluorescence microscopy, histology, immunohistochemistry, and virus titration of embryonic tissues. After infection of the CAM, MVA spread to internal and external embryonic tissues with the liver as a major target organ. Macrophages and hematopoietic cells were identified as primary target cells of MVA infection and may be involved in virus spread. Increasing doses of MVA did not result in increased lesion severity or embryonic death. Despite MVA generalization to embryonic tissues, the CAM seems to be the major site of MVA replication. The absence of considerable organ lesions and MVA-associated mortality highlights an excellent safety profile of MVA in chicken hosts.

Phylogenetic and histological variation in avipoxviruses isolated in South Africa

Thirteen novel avipoxviruses were isolated from birds from different regions of South Africa. These viruses could be divided into six groups, according to gross pathology and pock appearance on chick chorioallantoic membranes (CAMs). Histopathology revealed distinct differences in epidermal and mesodermal cell proliferation, as well as immune cell infiltration, caused by the different avipoxviruses, even within groups of viruses causing similar CAM gross pathology. In order to determine the genetic relationships among the viruses, several conserved poxvirus genetic regions, corresponding to vaccinia virus (VACV) A3L (fpv167 locus, VACV P4b), G8R (fpv126 locus, VLTF-1), H3L (fpv140 locus, VACV H3L) and A11R–A12L (fpv175–176 locus) were analysed phylogenetically. The South African avipoxvirus isolates in this study all grouped in clade A, in either subclade A2 or A3 of the genus Avipoxvirus and differ from the commercial fowlpox vaccines (subclade A1) in use in the South African poultry industry. Analysis of different loci resulted in different branching patterns. There was no correlation between gross morphology, histopathology, pock morphology and phylogenetic grouping. There was also no correlation between geographical distribution and virus phenotype or genotype.

Poxvirus immune modulators: functional insights from animal models

Poxviruses express several different classes of immune modulators that suppress the host response to infection, including soluble cytokine binding proteins, serpins, chemokine binding proteins, a complement control protein, and members of the semaphorin and Toll/IL-1 receptor families. Biochemical activity of these proteins has been demonstrated by many in vitro studies. Conservation in evolution of poxvirus immune modulators implies that these genes are functional in vivo, but the results of infecting animals with knockout viruses have not always been clear cut. Studies involving different animal models are reviewed, and the criteria for suitable models are discussed. Challenges include finding an appropriate animal host, and using an inoculation route that resembles the process of natural infection. The fact that multiple immune modulators can target the same pathway at different steps may explain why single knockout mutants are not always attenuated in animals.

Analysis of host response modifier ORFs of ectromelia virus, the causative agent of mousepox

From the right-hand end of the ectromelia virus (strain Moscow) genome, 32318 bps have been sequenced, and characterized to include a total of 18 open reading frames (ORFs) and six regions which apparently no longer code for functional proteins. At least six of the ORFs appear to be involved in blocking the inflammatory/immune host response to infection, and therefore probably contribute significantly to the virulence of this virus in its natural host, the mouse. One of these genes encoded an isolog of the poxvirus chemokine binding protein, and was shown to be the most abundant protein secreted from ectromelia virus infected cells. Two regions were found to have significant similarity to poxvirus genes encoding tumor necrosis factor (TNF) binding proteins. Both are distinct from cytokine response modifier (crm)B and crmC but only one is predicted to encode a functional TNF binding protein. A novel similarity between the C-terminal domain of poxvirus TNF binding proteins and several other poxvirus proteins is also presented. The results are discussed in the context of ectromelia virus pathogenesis of mice.

Serpins and regulation of cell death

Proteolysis is a key feature of programmed cell death. Extracellular proteinases can activate cell surface receptors which trigger apoptosis, and the effector machinery requires the activation and activity of numerous intracellular proteinases (primarily caspases). Effective control of proteolysis is essential for homeostasis and can occur at two levels: regulation of proteinase activation, and regulation of the activated proteinase. Serpins control activated proteinases and several have been implicated in the regulation of cell death. Serpins that inhibit intracellular processes include the viral proteins CrmA and SPI-1, as well as the granzyme B inhibitor, PI-9. Another endogenous serpin, PN-I, prevents the delivery of an apoptotic signal by inhibiting an extracellular proteinase from cleaving a cell surface receptor. There is evidence to suggest that PAI-2 may target an extracellular as well as an intracellular proteinase. Much of our knowledge of proteolysis within apoptotic cells has come from studies using the poxvirus serpin CrmA/SPI-2. CrmA prevents cytokine processing by inhibiting caspase-1, and protects against Fas-, TNF- and TRAIL-mediated apoptosis by inhibiting an unidentified proteinase specific to these pathways. Work with CrmA has also clearly demonstrated that there are separable effector mechanisms within cells, and that those triggered by growth factor withdrawal, matrix dissociation or cytotoxic ligands are different in several respects to those triggered by radiation, chemicals or steroid hormones. It is likely that analysis of other poxvirus serpins with different inhibitory profiles (especially SPI-1) will yield further insights into these processes. Prospecting for intracellular serpin genes in other virus species may also be fruitful. Finally, all of the serpins known to regulate intracellular proteolysis are members of the ovalbumin subgroup. It remains to be seen whether the more recently described "orphan" ovalbumin serpins (Riewald and Schleef 1995; Sprecher et al. 1995; Sun et al. 1997) also have roles in the regulation of cell death.

Subversion of cytokine networks by viruses

Viruses and the immune system have been competitors throughout their co-evolution. It is therefore not surprising that the viruses in circulation today possess a variety of strategies to counteract those aspects of the immune system that are involved in virus clearance. Examination of these virus encoded functions provides an important view of immune function and an appreciation of the complexity of the virus-host interaction. It is clear that viruses, seeking to subvert the immune system, have become adept in blocking the communication channels of the immune system. There are numerous examples of viral proteins that target the cytokine networks, disrupting the processes by which the delicately balanced immune system is regulated. This review focuses on the gene products of poxviruses, adenoviruses and herpesviruses that function primarily as immune-modulators.

Serp2, an inhibitor of the interleukin-1beta-converting enzyme, is critical in the pathobiology of myxoma virus

Recently, myxoma virus was shown to encode an additional member of the serpin superfamily. The viral gene, called serp2, was cloned, and the Serp2 protein was shown to specifically bind to interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta)-converting enzyme (ICE), thus inhibiting the cleavage of pro-IL-1beta by the protease (F. Petit, S. Bertagnoli, J. Gelfi, F. Fassy, C. Boucraut-Baralon, and A. Milon, J. Virol. 70:5860-5866, 1996). Here, we address the role of Serp2 in the development of myxomatosis, a lethal infectious disease of the European rabbit. A Serp2 mutant myxoma virus was constructed by disruption of the single-copy serp2 gene and insertion of the Escherichia coli gpt gene serving as the selectable marker. A revertant virus was obtained by replacing the E. coli gpt gene by the intact serp2 open reading frame. The Serp2(-) mutant virus replicated with wild-type kinetics both in rabbit fibroblasts and a rabbit CD4(+) T-cell line (RL5). Moderate reduction of cell surface levels of major histocompatibility complex I was observed after infection with wild-type or Serp2(-) mutant myxoma virus, and both produced white pocks on the chorioallantoic membrane of the chick embryo. After the infection of European rabbits, the Serp2(-) mutant virus proved to be highly attenuated compared to wild-type myxoma virus, as demonstrated by the clinical course of myxomatosis and the survival rates of infected animals. Pathohistological examinations revealed that infection with wild-type myxoma virus resulted in a blockade of the inflammatory response at the vascular level. In contrast, rapid inflammatory reactions occurred upon infection with the Serp2(-) mutant virus. Furthermore, lymphocytes in lymph nodes derived from animals inoculated with Serp2 mutant virus were shown to rapidly undergo apoptosis. We postulate that the virulence of myxoma virus in the European rabbit can be partially attributed to an impairment of host inflammatory processes and to the prevention of apoptosis in lymphocytes. The weakening of host defense is directly linked to serp2 gene function and is likely to involve the inhibition of IL-1beta-converting-enzyme-dependent pathways.

Activation of caspases in pig kidney cells infected with wild-type and CrmA/SPI-2 mutants of cowpox and rabbitpox viruses

The cowpox virus (CPV) CrmA and the equivalent rabbitpox virus (RPV) SPI-2 proteins have anti-inflammatory and antiapoptosis activity by virtue of their ability to inhibit caspases, including the interleukin-1beta-converting enzyme (ICE; caspase-1). Infection of LLC-PK1 pig kidney cells with a CPV CrmA mutant, but not with wild-type (wt) CPV, results in the induction of many of the morphological features of apoptosis (C. A. Ray and D. J. Pickup, Virology 217:384-391, 1996). In our study, LLC-PK1 cells infected with CPV delta crmA, but not those infected with wt CPV, showed induction of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP)- and lamin A-cleaving activities and processing of the CPP32 (caspase-3) precursor to a mature 18-kDa form. Surprisingly, infection of LLC-PK1 cells with either wt RPV (despite the presence of the SPI-2 protein) or RPV delta SPI-2 resulted in cleavage activity against PARP and lamin A and the appearance of the mature subunit of CPP32/caspase-3. The biotinylated specific peptide inhibitor Ac-Tyr-Val-Lys(biotinyl)-Asp-2,6-dimethylbenzoyloxymethylketone [AcYV(bio)KD-aomk] labeled active caspase subunits of 18, 19, and 21 kDa in extracts from LLC-PK1 cells infected with CPV delta crmA, wt RPV, or RPV delta SPI-2 but not wt CPV. Mixed infection of LLC-PK1 cells with wt RPV and wt CPV gave no PARP-cleaving activity, and all PARP cleavage mediated by SPI-2 and CrmA mutants of RPV and CPV, respectively, could be eliminated by coinfection with wt CPV. These results suggest that the RPV SPI-2 and CPV CrmA proteins are not functionally equivalent and that CrmA, but not SPI-2 protein, can completely prevent apoptosis in LLC-PK1 cells under these conditions.

Attenuation of B5R mutants of rabbitpox virus in vivo is related to impaired growth and not an enhanced host inflammatory response

The rabbitpox virus (RPV) B5R protein, synthesized late in infection, is found as a 45-kDa membrane-associated protein of the envelope of infectious extracellular enveloped virus (EEV) and as a 38-kDa protein secreted from the cell by a process independent of morphogenesis. The protein is not found associated with intracellular mature virus (IMV). Deletion of the gene attenuates the virus (RPV delta B5R) in animals (mice and rabbits), has relatively little effect on formation of IMV, prevents EEV formation in some but not all cells, and leads to a reduced host range. Analysis of the sequence of the protein suggests relatedness to factor H of the complement cascade. Collectively, these observations suggest that attenuation of the virus in vivo could be linked to an inhibition of the inflammatory response, a deficiency in growth, or both. In this report we have analyzed the behavior of RPV delta B5R in infected mice and rabbits and conclude that attenuation of the mutant virus likely results from simple failure to grow within the infected animal and that the inflammatory response probably contributes little to the observed attenuation.

Microbial/host interactions in health and disease: who controls the cytokine network?

The interacting cellular and molecular systems which we classify as immunity and inflammation evolved to protect the organism from exogenous parasites including viruses and bacteria. Cytokines play a pivotal, but paradoxical, role both in immunity and inflammation. These local peptide hormone-like molecules form a major arm of the organisms, defenses against infectious microorganisms but they are also implicated as potent mediators of the pathology of infectious diseases. The apparently lethal effects of interleukin-1 and tumor necrosis factor in experimental septic shock testify to the latter. In the current paradigm, cytokine induction, as a protective or pathological mechanism, is a direct response to the presence of infectious microorganisms. Evidence is now accumulating that cytokines play a much more complex role in the interplay between exogenous microorganisms and the host. For example, it has been established that viruses have evolved pro-active methods of subverting the cytokine network by producing: (i) soluble cytokine receptors which bind and inactivate cytokines, (ii) immunomodulatory cytokine homologues, and (iii) ICE inhibitors. The possibility exists that the major role of these 'viral cytokines' is to neutralize certain host responses. Recent cytokine transgenic knockouts demonstrate that the normal benign response to commensal gut microflora becomes a lethal inflammatory state in the absence of the cytokines interleukin 2 or interleukin 10. The human body contains an enormous number of microorganisms which constitute the normal microflora. It is estimated that the average human contains 10(13) eukaryotic cells but 10(14) bacteria. We propose that the ability of the multicellular organism to live harmoniously with its commensal microflora must depend on mutual signalling involving eukaryotic cytokines and prokaryotic cytokine-like molecules. Such interactive signalling sets up non-inflammatory cytokine networks in tissues which form the background on which responses to infectious microorganisms must be built and related. The capacity of bacteria to induce cytokine synthesis was believed to be due to a small number of components, such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS), which is only active as a complex with host factors (lipopolysaccharide binding protein and CD14). However, it is now clear that bacteria contain and produce a large number of diverse molecules which can selectively induce the synthesis of both pro-inflammatory and immunomodulatory/anti-inflammatory cytokines. Many toxins are potent inducers of cytokine release or synthesis and some can inhibit LPS-induced cell activation. We have introduced the term bacteriokine to describe these bacterial cytokine inducers. The question that has to be addressed therefore is - who controls the cytokine network (eukaryotic or prokaryotic cells) and how is it controlled? It is proposed that an understanding of this question will bring with it an understanding of how to control the pathological inflammatory response and may allow the development of truly effective anti-inflammatory agents.

Orthopoxvirus fusion inhibitor glycoprotein SPI-3 (open reading frame K2L) contains motifs characteristic of serine proteinase inhibitors that are not required for control of cell fusion

The cowpox virus (CPV) SPI-3 gene (open reading frame K2L in vaccinia virus) is one of three orthopoxvirus genes whose products are members of the serpin (serine proteinase inhibitor) superfamily. The CPV SPI-3 gene, when overexpressed by using the vaccinia virus/T7 expression system, synthesized two proteins of 50 and 48 kDa. Treatment with the N glycosylation inhibitor tunicamycin converted the two SPI-3 proteins to a single 40-kDa protein, close to the size of 42 kDa predicted from the DNA sequence, suggesting that the SPI-3 protein, unlike the other two orthopoxvirus serpins, is a glycoprotein. Immunoblotting with an anti-SPI-3 antibody showed that the SPI-3 protein is synthesized early in infection prior to DNA replication. SPI-3 inhibits cell-cell fusion during infections with both CPV and vaccinia virus. A transfection assay was devised to test engineered mutants of SPI-3 for the ability to inhibit fusion. Two mutants with C-terminal deletions of 156 and 70 amino acids were completely inactive in fusion inhibition. Site-directed mutations were constructed near the C terminus of SPI-3, in or near the predicted reactive-site loop which is conserved in inhibitory serpins. Substitutions within the loop at the P1 to P1' positions and P5 to P5' positions, inclusive, did not result in any loss of activity, nor did changes at the P17 to P10 residues in the stalk of the reactive loop. Therefore, SPI-3 does not appear to control cell fusion by acting as a serine proteinase inhibitor.

Analysis of the nucleotide sequence of 53 kbp from the right terminus of the genome of variola major virus strain India-1967

Sequencing and computer analysis of a variola major virus strain India-1967 (VAR-IND) genome segment (53,018 bp) from the right terminal region has been carried out. Fifty-nine potential open reading frames (ORFs) of over 60 amino acid residues were identified. Structure-function organization of the VAR-IND DNA segment was compared with the previously reported sequences from the analogous genomic regions of vaccinia virus strains Copenhagen (VAC-COP) and Western Reserve (VAC-WR) and variola virus strain Harvey (VAR-HAR). Multiple differences between VAR-IND and the strains of VAC but the high identity of VAR-IND with VAR-HAR in the genetic maps are revealed. Possible functions of the predicted viral proteins and the effect of their differences on the features of orthopoxviruses are discussed.

Multigenic evasion of inflammation by poxviruses

Analyses of different cowpox virus (Brighton Red strain [CPV-BR]) mutants indicate that there is a minimum of three genes encoded by CPV-BR that are nonessential for virus replication in tissue culture but are involved in inhibiting the generation of an inflammatory response in the chicken embryo chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) model. The CPV-BR-encoded anti-inflammatory genes include the gene encoding the 38-kDa protein (also called 38K, crmA, SPI-2, or VV-WR-ORF-B13R), a tumor necrosis factor receptor homolog, and an unidentified gene that maps to the right end of the CPV genome. The kinetics of triggering of an inflammatory response at the site of virus infection as well as the magnitude of the response is dependent on the virus-encoded inhibitor that is deleted. Virus yields recovered from pocks decreased in proportion to the magnitude of the inflammatory response. The deletion of these identified inhibitors of inflammation was associated with attenuation of the mutant viruses in mice. These data confirm the existence of multiple poxvirus-encoded host defense modifiers whose function is to block the generation of an inflammatory response at the site of virus infection, which allows enhanced virus replication and potentially facilitates virus transmission.

The ps/hr gene (B5R open reading frame homolog) of rabbitpox virus controls pock color, is a component of extracellular enveloped virus, and is secreted into the medium

Wild-type rabbitpox virus (RPV) produces red hemorrhagic pocks on the chorioallantoic membranes (CAMs) of embryonated chicken eggs. Like the crmA (SPI-2) gene of cowpox virus, disruption of the RPV ps/hr gene results in a mutant which produces white pocks on the CAMs. An examination of the properties of the RPV(ps/hr) mutant in cell culture also reveals a significantly reduced host range, defined as the inability to form plaques, compared with wild-type virus. One of several cell types on which RPV(ps/hr) mutants fail to produce plaques is chicken embryo fibroblasts, cells which have been traditionally used to propagate spontaneously arising white pock mutants isolated from CAMs. The inability of the RPV(ps/hr) mutant to form plaques in chicken embryo fibroblasts correlates with a failure of a low multiplicity of infection to spread to neighboring cells and to form extracellular enveloped virus (EEV), although the formation and yields of infectious intracellular naked virus appear relatively normal. The gene product of the ps/hr gene, initially synthesized as a 45-kDa glycoprotein, is found as a component of EEV, but not intracellular naked virus, and as a smaller, secreted soluble protein of 35 kDa. Production of the secreted 35-kDa protein was found to be independent of any viral morphogenesis, suggesting two distinct pathways for release of the ps/hr gene product from the cell, i.e., as a component of the EEV particle and as a separately secreted glycoprotein.

Poxvirus-induced alteration of arachidonate metabolism

Recent evidence suggests that orthopoxviruses have an obligate requirement for arachidonic acid metabolites during replication in vivo and in vitro. Our report indicates that a virus family (Poxviridae) possesses multiple genes that function to regulate arachidonate metabolism. Analyses of BS-C-1 cells infected with cowpox virus or vaccinia virus detected enhanced arachidonate product formation from both the cyclooxygenase (specifically prostaglandins E2 and F2 alpha) and lipoxygenase (specifically 15-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid and 12-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid) pathways. In contrast, human parainfluenza type 3 or herpes simplex virus type 1 infections did not increase arachidonate metabolism. Results were consistent with a virus early-gene product either directly mediating or inducing a host factor that mediated the up-regulation of arachidonate metabolism, although vaccinia growth factor was not responsible. In addition, the cowpox virus 38-kDa protein-encoding gene, which is associated with inhibition of an inflammatory response, correlated with inhibition of formation of a product biochemically characteristic of (14R,15S)-dihydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid. We propose that orthopoxvirus-induced up-regulation of arachidonic acid metabolism during infection renders the infected cells susceptible to generation of inflammatory mediators from both the cyclooxygenase and the lipoxygenase pathways, and poxviruses, therefore, possess at least one gene (38K) that can alter the lipoxygenase-metabolite spectrum.

Viral inhibition of inflammation: cowpox virus encodes an inhibitor of the interleukin-1 beta converting enzyme

Cowpox virus effectively inhibits inflammatory responses against viral infection in the chick embryo. This study demonstrates that one of the viral genes necessary for this inhibition, the crmA gene (a cytokine response modifier gene), encodes a serpin that is a specific inhibitor of the interleukin-1 beta converting enzyme. This serpin can prevent the proteolytic activation of interleukin-1 beta, thereby suppressing an interleukin-1 beta response to infection. However, the modification of this single cytokine response is not sufficient to inhibit inflammatory responses. This suggests that cowpox virus encodes several cytokine response modifiers that act together to inhibit the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines in response to infection. These viral countermeasures to host defenses against infection may contribute significantly to the pathology associated with poxvirus infections.