A novel membrane bioreactor inoculated with symbiotic sludge bacteria and algae: Performance and microbial community analysis

M-ALBA: A modelling framework to guide the optimization of membrane-assisted algae-bacteria systems

Biological systems combining microalgae and bacteria have been identified as a system with great potential to provide sustainable sanitation solutions. This consortium has been conceived to be normally implemented in the form of high-rate algal-bacteria ponds (HRABP). However, these systems face limitations, associated with effluent clarification and limited loads. Application of membrane filtration to induce biomass retention and effluent clarification have been identified as way to overcome such constraints. However, the effects of decoupling solid retention time (SRT) from hydraulic retention time (HRT) are complex and sometimes difficult to determine or predict. In this study, a model (M-ALBA) was used to predict the performance of a membrane-assisted HRABP. M-ALBA represents an extension of the previously validated ALBA model, by incorporating a compartment providing membrane separation. M-ALBA considers the action of microalgae, heterotrophic bacteria, and nitrifying bacteria (ammonium oxidizers and nitrite oxidizers), including 34 state variables, 19 biological processes and gas-liquid mass transfer of O2, CO2, and NH3. Experimental data from previous study were used to evaluate the model accuracy. Different scenarios were simulated and analysed, using mass balances, considering SRT and HRT in the ranges 4.5-22.5 and 0.5-4.5 days, respectively. Results show how decoupling SRT from HRT improves effluent quality, by increasing nitrogen removal, while avoiding ammonia volatilization. Additionally, it allows operation at lower HRT values, achieving the best performance at HRT 1.5 days. The results obtained in this study contributed to a better understanding of the complex microalgae-bacteria dynamics in membrane-assisted HRABPs.

Sulfamethoxazole removal and ammonium conversion in microalgae consortium: Physiological responses and microbial community changes

Microalgae (Mychonastes sp.) consortium was investigated for nutrient and antibiotics removal and its responses to varying sulfamethoxazole (SMX) concentrations (0-1000 μg/L) in ammonia-rich wastewater. The results showed that the introduction of SMX (100-1000 μg/L) slightly improved ammonium nitrogen removal efficiency instead of inhibition. Swift SMX degradation was observed across all SMX-treated systems, with the highest SMX removal efficiency (96 %) at an SMX concentration of 100 μg/L. Biodegradation remained the dominant SMX removal mechanism, contributing 78 % of SMX removal at an SMX concentration of 800 μg/L, while adsorption and photolysis played minor roles. Addition of SMX augmented biomass and lipid productivity, but decreased chlorophyll contents in the microalgae consortium. Furthermore, extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) production correlated positively with SMX input concentration, with the microalgae consortium exposed to 800 μg/L SMX displaying the most pronounced stimulation of protein production (51.5 ± 2.0 mg/g DCW) and polysaccharides production (74.8 ± 3.9 mg/g DCW). In response to an increase in SMX concentrations, enzyme activities associated with antioxidant defense, such as superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD) and malondialdehyde (MDA) increased, the catalase (CAT) decreased, indicating an initial defense mechanism. Concurrently, the relative abundance of Mychonastes sp. within the consortium rose from 87 % at 300 μg/L SMX to 99.9 % at 800 μg/L SMX. while Shannon indices of the bacterial community increased from 1.415 to 2.867. This shift inhibited the initially dominant Saprospiraceae bacteria, facilitating the profound increase of adapted Aquimonas. These findings demonstrate the feasibility of the simultaneous removal of antibiotics and nutrients from wastewater with a microalgae consortium system.

An overview of deploying different treatment processes with membrane bioreactor for enhanced treatment of wastewaters: synergistic performances and reduced fouling of membrane

The membrane bioreactor (MBR) process synergistically combines biological treatment with membrane filtration, offering a compact design and enhanced operational flexibility. However, membrane fouling remains a critical bottleneck, limiting its widespread application, particularly in treating high-strength wastewater. Recent advances have demonstrated that integrating MBR systems with auxiliary processes such as adsorption, electrochemical treatments, algal-assisted systems, and others can significantly mitigate fouling and enhance treatment efficacy. This paper critically reviews various MBR hybrid configurations, examining their mechanisms, advantages, and limitations in terms of treatment performance and fouling control, while highlighting their potential to extend conventional MBR's applicability to challenging wastewaters and addressing operational challenges like economic viability and sustainability. Elaborated tables incorporating a wide variety of research studies within the realm of synchronization have been meticulously compiled to generate a comprehensive literature review.

Mini critical review: Membrane fouling control in membrane bioreactors by microalgae

Membrane bioreactors (MBRs) hold significant promise for wastewater treatment, yet the persistent challenge of membrane fouling impedes their practical application. One promising solution lies in the synergy between microalgae and bacteria, offering efficient nutrient removal, reduced energy consumption, and potential mitigation of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) concentrations. Inoculating microalgae presents a promising avenue to address membrane fouling in MBRs. This review marks the first exploration of utilizing microalgae for membrane fouling control in MBR systems. The review begins with a comprehensive overview of the evolution and distinctive traits of microalgae-MBRs. It goes further insight into the performance and underlying mechanisms facilitating the reduction of membrane fouling through microalgae intervention. Moreover, the review not only identifies the challenges inherent in employing microalgae for membrane fouling control in MBRs but also illuminates prospective pathways for future advancement in this burgeoning field.

Sustainable treatment of aquaculture water employing fungi-microalgae consortium: Nutrients removal enhancement, bacterial communities optimization, emerging contaminants elimination, and mechanism analysis

Fungi-microalgae consortium (FMC) has emerged as a promising system for advanced wastewater treatment due to its high biomass yield and environmental sustainability. This study aimed to investigate the nutrients removal, bacterial community shift, emerging contaminants elimination, and treatment mechanism of a FMC composed of Cordyceps militaris and Navicula seminulum for aquaculture pond water treatment. The fungi and microalgae were cultured and employed either alone or in combination to evaluate the treatment performance. The results demonstrated that the FMC could improve water quality more significantly by reducing nutrient pollutants and optimizing the bacterial community structures. Furthermore, it exhibited stronger positive correlation between the enrichment of functional bacteria for water quality improvement and pollutants removal performance than the single-species treatments. Moreover, the FMC outperformed other groups in eliminating emerging contaminants such as heavy metals, antibiotics, and pathogenic Vibrios. Superiorly, the FMC also showed excellent symbiotic interactions and cooperative mechanisms for pollutants removal. The results collectively corroborated the feasibility and sustainability of using C. militaris and N. seminulum for treating aquaculture water, and the FMC would produce more mutualistic benefits and synergistic effects than single-species treatments.

A review of emerging membrane-based microalgal-bacterial processes for wastewater treatment: Process configurations, biological and membrane performance, and perspectives

Microalgal-bacterial (MB) consortia create an excellent eco-system for simultaneous COD/BOD and nutrients (N and P) removals in a single step with significant reduction in or complete elimination of aeration and carbonation in the biological wastewater treatment processes. The integration of membrane separation technology with the MB processes has created a new paradigm for research and development. This paper focuses on a comprehensive and critical literature review of recent advances in these emerging processes. Novel membrane process configurations and process conditions affecting the biological performance of these novel systems have been systematically reviewed and discussed. Membrane fouling issues and control of MB biofilm formation and thickness associated with these emerging suspended growth or immobilized biofilm processes are addressed and discussed. The research gaps, challenges, outlooks of these emerging processes are identified and discussed in-depth. The findings from the literature suggest that the membrane-based MB processes are advanced biotechnologies with a significant reduction in energy consumption and process simplification and high process efficiency that are not achievable with current technologies in wastewater treatment. There are endless opportunities for research and development of these novel and emerging membrane-based MB processes.

Mechanistic insights into different illumination positions control algae production in anaerobic dynamic membrane filtration (AnDM) during decentralized wastewater treatment

Sunlight illumination has the potential to control the stability and sustainability of dynamic membrane (DM) systems. In this study, an up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactor was combined with DM under different illumination positions (direct, indirect and no illumination) to treat wastewater. Results indicated that the UASB achieved a COD removal up to 87.05 % with an average methane production of 0.28 L/d. Following treatment by the UASB, it was found that under illumination, the removal of organic substances by DM exhibited poor performance due to algal proliferation. However, the DM systems demonstrated efficient removal of ammonia nitrogen, ranging from 96.21 % to 97.67 % after stabilization. Total phosphorus removal was 45.72 %, and membrane flux remained stable when directly illuminated. Conversely, the DM system subjected to indirect illumination showed unstable membrane flux and severe fouling resistance. These findings offer valuable insights into optimizing illumination positions in DM systems under anaerobic conditions.

Performance enhancement, bacterial communities optimization and emerging pollutants elimination by microalgal-bacterial consortium for treating aquaculture pond sediments

Aquaculture pond sediments have a notable influence on the ecosystem balance and farmed animal health. In this study, microalgal-bacterial immobilization (MBI) was designed to improve aquaculture pond sediments via synergistic interactions. The physicochemical characteristics, bacterial communities, and the removal efficiencies of emerging pollutants were systematically investigated. The consortium containing diatom Navicula seminulum and Alcaligenes faecalis was cultivated and established in the free and immobilized forms for evaluating the treatment performance. The results indicated that the immobilized group exhibited superior performance in controlling nutrient pollutants, shaping and optimizing the bacterial community compositions with the enrichment of functional bacteria. Additionally, it showed a stronger positive correlation between the bacterial community shifts and nutrient pollutants removal compared to free cells. Furthermore, the immobilized system maintained the higher removal performance of emerging pollutants (heavy metals, antibiotics, and pathogenic Vibrios) than free group. These findings confirmed that the employment of immobilized N. seminulum and A. faecalis produced more synergistic benefits and exerted more improvements than free cells in ameliorating aquaculture pond sediments, suggesting the potential for engineering application of functional microalgal-bacterial consortium in aquaculture.

Biological performance and membrane fouling of a microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor for wastewater treatment without external aeration and carbonation

Biological nutrient removal processes involving the use of activated sludge (AS) to treat municipal wastewater normally result in high aeration energy consumption and significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Therefore, developing cost-efficient and environmentally friendly processes for wastewater treatment is vital. In this work, a novel non-aerated microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor (MB-MPBR) was proposed, and its feasibility for organic contaminant and nutrient removals was evaluated, for the first time. The effects of inoculation ratio (microalgae to bacteria (M/B)) on the biological performance and membrane fouling were systematically investigated. The results showed that 95.9% of the chemical oxygen demand (COD), 74.5% of total nitrogen (TN), 98.5% of NH4+-N and 42.0% of total phosphorus (TP) were removed at an inoculation M/B ratio of 3:2 at steady state, representing a significant improvement compared to the M/B inoculation ratio of 1:3. Additionally, the higher inoculation M/B ratio (3:2) significantly promoted the biomass production owing to the favorable mutual exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide between microalgae and bacteria. Cake layer formation was the primary fouling mechanism owing to the absence of aeration scouring on the membrane surface. The membrane fouling rate was slightly higher at the higher inoculation ratio (M/B = 3:2) owing to the increased biomass and extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) productions, despite the larger particle size. These results demonstrated that the non-aerated MB-MPBR could achieve superior biological performance, of which the inoculation M/B ratio was of critical importance for the initiation and maintenance of microalgal-bacterial symbiotic system, yet possibly caused severer membrane fouling in the absence of external aeration and carbonation. This study provides a new perspective for further optimizing and applying non-aerated MB-MPBR to enhance municipal wastewater treatment.

Mg2+ addition: Unlocking optimized treatment performance and anti-fouling property in microalgal-bacterial membrane bioreactors

While microalgal-bacterial membrane bioreactors (microalgal-bacterial MBRs) have risen as an important technique in the realm of sustainable wastewater treatment, the membrane fouling caused by free microalgae is still a significant challenge to cost-effective operation of the microalgal-bacterial MBRs. Addressing this imperative, the current study investigated the influence of magnesium ion (Mg2+) addition on the biological dynamics and membrane fouling characteristics of the laboratory-scale submerged microalgal-bacterial MBRs. The results showed that Mg2+, important in augmenting photosynthetic process, yielded a biomass concentration of 2.92 ± 0.06 g/L and chlorophyll-a/MLSS (mixed liquor suspended solids) of 33.95 ± 1.44 mg/g in the RMg (Mg2+ addition test group). Such augmentation culminated in elevated total nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiencies, clocking 81.73 % and 80.98 % respectively in RMg. Remarkably, despite the enhanced microalgae activity and concentration in RMg, the TMP growth rate declined by a significant 46.8 % compared to R0. Detailed characterizations attributed reduced membrane fouling of RMg to a synergy of enlarged floc size and reduced EPS contents. This transformation is intrinsically linked to the bridging action of Mg2+ and its role in creating a non-stressed ecological environment for the microalgal-bacterial MBR. In conclusion, the addition of Mg2+ in the microalgal-bacterial MBR appears an efficient approach, improving the efficiency of pollutant treatment and mitigating fouling, which potentially revolutionizes cost-effective applications and propels the broader acceptance of microalgal-bacterial MBRs. It also of great importance to promote the development and application of microalgal-bacterial wastewater treatment technology.

In situ assessment of the initial phase of wastewater biofilm formation: Effect of the presence of algae in an aerobic bacterial biofilm system

The initial start-up attachment stage that dominates biofilm formation is an unstable process and is time-consuming. In the present study, Chlorella sp. was introduced into a general aerobic biofilm system to explore whether the addition of algae improved the initial attachment phase of biofilm. Compared with those of the bacterial biofilms, the initial algal-bacterial biofilms were more stable and had a thicker, denser, and rougher surface. Further investigation suggested that the concentration of extracellular polymeric substances (EPSs) in the algal-bacterial biofilm was 31.33 % greater than that in the bacterial biofilm. Additionally, the algal-bacterial flocs had greater free energies of absolute cohesion (ΔGcoh) and adhesion energy (∆Gadh) than did the bacterial flocs. These phenomena contribute to the speediness and stabilization of initial algal-bacterial start-up biofilms. Specifically, algae inoculation increased microbial community diversity and promoted the growth of bacterial members related to biofilm development. In conclusion, both physicochemical interactions and biological processes strongly influence microbial attachment during the initial biofilm formation process and further promote strengthening.

Interplay role of microalgae and bio-carriers in hybrid membrane bioreactors on wastewater treatment, membrane fouling, and microbial communities

Algal membrane bioreactors (algae-MBRs) and advanced hybrid biocarrier algal membrane bioreactors (hybrid algae-MBRs) have been investigated to improve the performance of conventional MBRs (C-MBRs). Maximum chemical oxygen demand and nutrient removal efficiencies, similar to the maximum biomass growth rate, chlorophyll-a concentration, and balanced microbial growth, were achieved in the hybrid algae-MBR inoculated with polyethylene biocarriers and algal cells. During the 90 days of operation, the hybrid algae-MBR demonstrated lower membrane fouling without membrane washing, whereas the C-MBR and algae-MBR were washed seven and four times, respectively. Compared to the C-MBR, both the algal MBR and hybrid algal MBR exhibited higher levels of nitrification, with 6 and 10 % greater rates, respectively. In addition, they displayed significant improvements in ammonium biomass uptake compared to the C-MBR, with increases of 30 and 37 %, respectively. In the algae-MBR, the chlorophyll-a results showed proliferation of algae over time. However, biocarriers that provide an additional surface for microbial growth, particularly algal strains, inhibit algal proliferation and result in balanced microbial growth (based on chlorophyll-a/MLVSS) in the bulk solution of the hybrid algae-MBR. In addition, the oxygen mass balance estimated that photosynthesis provided 45 % of the dissolved oxygen required in the studied algal reactors, whereas mixing provided the remainder. Additionally, microbial sequencing results indicated that the microbial communities (e.g., Candidatus, Cloacibacterium, and Falavobacterium) were altered by introducing microalgae and biocarriers that affected the activity of different microorganisms, changed the sludge and fouling layer properties, and improved the performance of the C-MBRs.

The effects of carbon nitrogen ratio and salinity on the treatment of swine digestion effluent simultaneously producing bioenergy by microalgae biofilm

In order to remove high concentrations of ammonia nitrogen (NH4+-N) and refractory sulfamethazine (SM2) from swine digestion effluent, different carbon/nitrogen (C/N) ratios and salinity were used to determine the effects of pollutants removal in the microalgae biofilm system. Microalgae biofilm treatment under optimal environmental conditions in synthetic swine digestion effluent were C/N ratio of 20 and salinity of 140 mM. In order to make the actual swine digestion effluent discharge up to the standard, three different two-cycle treatments (suspended microalgae, microalgae biofilm, microalgae biofilm under the optimal conditions) were studied. The results showed that after two-cycle treatment with microalgae biofilm under the optimal conditions, the actual swine digestion effluent levels of total nitrogen (TN), NH4+-N, total phosphorus (TP), chemical oxygen demand (COD), SM2 were 22.65, 9.32, 4.11, 367.28, and 0.99 mg L-1, respectively, which could satisfy the discharge standards for livestock and poultry wastewater in China. At the same time, first-order kinetic simulation equations suggested a degradation half-life of 4.85 d for SM2 under optimal conditions in microalgae biofilm, and microbial community analysis indicated that the dominant genus was Halomonas. Furthermore, 35.66% of lipid, 32.56% of protein and 18.44% of polysaccharides were harvested after two-cycle in microalgae biofilm treatment under optimal environmental conditions. These results indicated that the regulation of C/N and salinity in microalgae biofilm for the treatment of swine digestion effluent was a high-efficiency strategy to simultaneously achieve wastewater treatment and bioenergy production.

Bacteria and microalgae associations in periphyton-mechanisms and biotechnological opportunities

Phototrophic and heterotrophic microorganisms coexist in complex and dynamic structures called periphyton. These structures shape the biogeochemistry and biodiversity of aquatic ecosystems. In particular, microalgae-bacteria interactions are a prominent focus of study by microbial ecologists and can provide biotechnological opportunities for numerous applications (i.e. microalgal bloom control, aquaculture, biorefinery, and wastewater bioremediation). In this review, we analyze the species dynamics (i.e. periphyton formation and factors determining the prevalence of one species over another), coexisting communities, exchange of resources, and communication mechanisms of periphytic microalgae and bacteria. We extend periphyton mathematical modelling as a tool to comprehend complex interactions. This review is expected to boost the applicability of microalgae-bacteria consortia, by drawing out knowledge from natural periphyton.

Removal of parabens from wastewater by Chlorella vulgaris-bacteria co-cultures

Anthropogenic activities have increased the dispersal of emerging contaminants (ECs), particularly of parabens, causing an escalation of their presence in wastewater (WW). Current WW technologies do not present satisfactory efficiency or sustainability in removing these contaminants. However, bioremediation with microalgae-based systems is proving to be a relevant technology for WW polishing, and the use of microalgae-bacteria consortia can improve the efficiency of WW treatment. This work aimed to study dual cultures of selected bacteria (Raoultella ornithinolytica, Acidovorax facilis, Acinetobacter calcoaceticus, Leucobacter sp. or Rhodococcus fascians) and the microalga Chlorella vulgaris in microbial growth and WW bioremediation - removal of methylparaben (MetP) and nutrients. The association with the bacteria was antagonistic for C. vulgaris biomass productivity as a result of the decreased growth kinetics in comparison to the axenic microalga. The presence of MetP did not disturb the growth of C. vulgaris under axenic or co-cultured conditions, except when associated with R. fascians, where growth enhancement was observed. The removal of MetP by the microalga was modest (circa 30 %, with a removal rate of 0.0343 mg/L.d), but increased remarkably when the consortia were used (> 50 %, with an average removal rate > 0.0779 mg/L.d), through biodegradation and photodegradation. For nutrient removal, the consortia were found to be less effective than the axenic microalga, except for nitrogen (N) removal by C. vulgaris w/ R. fascians. The overall results propose that C. vulgaris co-cultivation with bacteria can increase MetP removal, while negatively affecting the microalga growth and the consequent reduction of sludge production, highlighting the potential of microalgae-bacteria consortia for the effective polishing of WW contaminated with parabens.

Effects of monospecific and mixed-algae culture on performance of algae-sludge membrane bioreactors

To increase wastewater treatment efficiency and biofuel production, seven microalgae were mixed with activated sludge in batch bioreactors. Based on batch results, two microalgae (Chlamydomonas and Selenastrum) and their mixture were inoculated into conventional-membrane-bioreactors (CMBRs) to evaluate effects of monospecific and mixed-algae culture on the performance of algae-sludge-MBRs. The best nutrient removal, highest chlorophyll-a, and lowest membrane fouling were achieved by the mixed-algae membrane bioreactor. In comparison to activated sludge, the algae-sludge mixture had fivefold higher lipid contents during batch experiments. Additionally, using confocal microscopy, autofluorescence and staining were combined to distinguish algae from bacteria on membrane surfaces, revealing a greater role for bacteria in membrane fouling. Furthermore, sequencing analysis showed that the microbial community (e.g. Nitrospira and Falavobacterium) changed by inoculating algae which benefits CMBRs. Consequently, the stimulation or inhibition of different species might be the reason that the mixed-algae-MBR achieves superior performance compared to CMBR and single-algae-MBRs.

Pollutants removal, microbial community shift and oleic acid production in symbiotic microalgae-bacteria system

The functional interaction between microorganisms is key in symbiotic microalga-bacteria systems; however, evaluations of fungi and pathogenic microorganisms are not clear. In this study, the roles of three groups (i.e., microalgae-activated sludge (MAS), Microalgae, and activated sludge) in pollutant removal and biomass recovery were comparatively studied. The data implied that microalgal assimilation and bacterial heterotrophic degradation were the major approaches for degradation of nutrients and organic matter, respectively. According to 16S rRNA and internal transcribed spacer sequencing, the relative abundance of Rhodotorula increased remarkably, favoring nutrient exchange between the microalgae and bacteria. The abundances of two types of pathogenic genes (human pathogens and animal parasites) were reduced in the MAS system. The oleic acid content in the MAS system (51.2 mg/g) was 1.7 times higher than that in the Microalgae system. The results can provide a basis for practical application and resource utilization of symbiotic microalgae-bacteria systems.

Efficient removal of Imidacloprid and nutrients by algae-bacteria biofilm reactor (ABBR) in municipal wastewater: Performance, mechanisms and the importance of illumination

Neonicotinoids, such as Imidacloprid (IMI), are frequently detected in water and wastewater, posing a threat on both the environment and the health of living things. In this work, a novel algae-bacteria biofilm reactor (ABBR) was constructed to remove IMI and conventional nutrients from municipal wastewater, aiming to explore the removal effect and advantage of ABBR. Results showed that ABBR achieved 74.9% removal of IMI under 80 μmol m^-2·s^-1 light, higher than photobioreactor (PBR) without biofilm (61.2%) or ABBR under 40 μmol m^-2·s^-1 light (48.4%) after 16 days of operation. Moreover, it also showed that ABBR allowed a marked improvement on the removal of total dissolved nitrogen (TDN), total dissolved phosphorus (TDP) and soluble chemical oxygen demand (sCOD). ABBR showed different IMI removal efficiencies and bacterial communities under different light conditions, indicating that light played an important role in driving ABBR. The merits of ABBR are including (i) ABBR showed rapid pollutant removal in a short time, (ii) in ABBR, stable consortiums were formed and chlorophyll content in effluent was very low, (iii) compared with PBR, degradation products in ABBR showed lower biological toxicity. Our study highlights the benefits of ABBR on IMI removing from municipal wastewater and provides an effective and environment-friendly engineering application potential of IMI removal.

High stability of autochthonous dissolved organic matter in karst aquatic ecosystems: Evidence from fluorescence

Biological carbon pump (BCP) in karst areas has received intensive attention for years due to their significant contribution to the global missing carbon sink. The stability of autochthonous dissolved organic matter (Auto-DOM) produced by BCP in karst aquatic ecosystems may play a critical role in the missing carbon sink. However, the source of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in inland waters and its consumption by planktonic bacteria have not been thoroughly examined. Recalcitrant dissolved organic matter (RDOM) may exist in karst aquatic ecosystem as in the ocean. Through the study of the chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDOM) and the interaction between CDOM and the planktonic bacterial community under different land uses at the Shawan Karst Water-carbon Cycle Test Site, SW China, we found that C2, as the fluorescence component of Auto-DOM mineralised by planktonic bacteria, may have some of the characteristics of RDOM and is an important DOM source in karst aquatic ecosystems. The stability ratio (Fmax_(C2/(C1+C2))) of Auto-DOM reached 89.6 ± 6.71% in winter and 64.1 ± 7.19% in spring. Moreover, correlation-based network analysis determined that the planktonic bacterial communities were controlled by different fluorescence types of CDOM, of which C1 (fresh Auto-DOM), C3 (conventional allochthonous DOM (Allo-DOM)) and C4 (the Allo-DOM mineralised by bacteria) were clustered in one module together with prevalent organic-degrading planktonic bacteria; C2 was clustered in another tightly combined module, suggesting specific microbial utilization strategies for the C2 component. In addition, some important planktonic bacterium and functional genes (including chemotrophic heterotrophs and photosynthetic bacteria) were found to be affected by high Ca²⁺ and dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) concentrations in karst aquatic ecosystems. Our research showed that Auto-DOM may be as an important carbon sink as the Allo-DOM in karst ecosystems, the former generally being neglected based on a posit that it is easily and first mineralized by planktonic bacteria.

Magnetic/electric field intervention on oil-rich filamentous algae production in the application of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene based wastewater treatment

Globally, the release of acrylonitrile-butadienestyrene (ABS) wastewater from numerous industries is a serious concern. Recently, oil-rich filamentous algae Tribonema sp has been grown utilizing toxic but nutrient-rich ABS effluent. Here, Tribonema sp. was cultivated under intervention of different magneto-electric combinatory fields (MCFs) (control, 0.6 V/cm, 1 h/d-1.2 V/cm, 1 h/d-0.6 V/cm, and 1 h/d-1.2 V/cm). Results showed MCF (1 h/d-0.6 V/cm) intervention increased the biomass by 9.7% (2.4 g/L) combined with high removal efficiencies (95% and 99%) of ammonium nitrogen and total phosphorus. The chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal rate increased to 82%, 6% higher than the control. Moreover, MCF of 1 h/d-0.6 V/cm significantly increased lipid and carbohydrate by 7.71% and 4.73% respectively. MCF increased premium fatty acid content such as palmitic acid (C16:0), myristic acid (C14: 0), and hexadecenoic acid (C16:1). MCF intervention also supported a diverse microbial flora, offering a favorable solution for ABS wastewater treatment.

Enhanced removal of tetracycline from synthetic wastewater using an optimal ratio of co-culture of Desmodesmus sp. and Klebsiella pneumoniae

A sustainable approach of Desmodesmus sp. GIEC-179: Klebsiella pneumoniae (DUT-XJR-t-1.2) co-culture ratios were optimized to remove tetracycline (TET) from synthetic wastewater. To enhance the tetracycline removal performance, the effect of microalgae-bacterial co-culture ratio, maximum TET concentration, effective inoculum amount, growth temperature and pH were studied. The optimized ratio 1:2 of Desmodesmus sp.: K. pneumoniae showed the optimal removal percentage at the temperature of 25 °C, pH 7 and 10% inoculum amount; and the removal of TET was recorded as 95%. Moreover, this study explored the Desmodesmus sp.: K. pneumoniae (1:2) nutrient (COD, NH₄⁺ and PO₄^3-) exchange relationship and their interaction of TET removal to better understand their fundamental mechanism. According to the results of this study, Desmodesmus sp.: K. pneumoniae co-culture could be a green option for bio-removal of tetracycline from wastewater.

Insights into the microalgae-bacteria consortia treating swine wastewater: Symbiotic mechanism and resistance genes analysis

This study investigated the effects of microalgae-bacteria consortia (MBC) (Chlorella pyrenoidosa-activated sludge (AS)) treating swine wastewater with low C/N ratios. After co-culture, the removal rates of NH₄⁺-N and PO₄^3--P increased by 53.84% and 43.52%. Furthermore, the sulfamethoxazole (SMX) degradation rates in MBC were slightly higher than in the activated sludge process. Interestingly, the absolute abundance of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in effluent from MBC is relatively less than in the AS process. C. pyrenoidosa has a negative zeta potential that allows bacteria to adhere to its surface. The concentrations of carbohydrates and proteins in extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) of MBC dramatically increased compared with the AS process. At the phylum level, Proteobacteria, Bacteroidota, and Cyanobacteria were the main bacteria, while Ascomycota and Basidiomycota were the primary fungi in MBC. Overall, those findings lead to a better understanding of the swine wastewater containing antibiotic treatment by MBC.

Research on the treatment mechanism of anthraquinone dye wastewater by algal-bacterial symbiotic system

This study analyzed the role of algae and bacteria in algal-bacterial symbiotic systems for the treatment of dyeing wastewater. The mechanism was investigated by constructing an algae-bacteria tandem system (A system) and a bacteria-algae tandem system (B system). The results showed that the chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal and decolorization rates of A system reached 91% and 90%, respectively, under optimal conditions, which were higher than that of B system. The degradation pathways of A and B systems differed according the degradation product analysis. High-throughput sequencing analysis revealed that Proteobacteria were the dominant bacteria in A and B systems. Armatimonadetes increased considerably in A system. These results show that algae mainly contributed to the preliminary degradation of anthraquinone dye, and resulting products were easily degraded by bacteria. This study provides guidance on the optimization of the system. It can be better adapted to the actual needs of wastewater treatment plants.

Membrane fouling in a microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor: Effects of P-availability controlled by N:P ratio

Microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor (MB-MPBR) is a promising technology to simultaneously remove organics and nutrients from wastewater. However, membrane fouling in MB-MPBR was seldom studied. In this study, potential effects of P-availability on biomass properties and membrane fouling in MB-MPBR were investigated. Under a nitrogen sufficient condition, a lower N:P ratio of 3.9:1 (P-rich) caused more severe membrane fouling. The dominant fouling mechanism was cake layer formation. Serial characterization showed a smaller particle size distribution (PSD), more free microalgae and significantly different surface composition of microalgal-bacterial flocs at N:P ratio of 3.9:1 compared with that of 9.7:1. The variations on PSD and surface composition were fully consistent with that of filtration resistance and thus considered as the primary contributors to the different fouling performance. The above results suggested that controlling microalgae/bacteria consortium in a good ratio by optimizing operating conditions is the key event for membrane fouling control in MB-MPBRs.

The biological performance of a novel microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor: Effects of HRT and N/P ratio

A microalgal-bacterial membrane photobioreactor (MB-MPBR) was developed for simultaneous COD and nutrients (N and P) removals from synthetic municipal wastewater in a single stage for a long-term operation over 350 days. The effects of hydraulic retention time (HRT) and N/P ratio on the biological performance were systematically evaluated for the first time. The results showed that a lower N/P ratio (3.9:1) and shorter HRT (2 d) promoted more biomass production, as compared to a high HRT (3 d) and a high N/P ratio (9.7:1). The highest biomass concentration (2.55 ± 0.14 g L^-1) and productivity (127.5 mg L^-1·d^-1) were achieved at N/P ratio of 3.9:1 and HRT of 2 d due to the highest nitrogen and phosphorus loadings under such conditions. A COD and ammonia-N removal efficiency of over 96% and 99%, respectively, were achieved regardless of HRTs and N/P ratios. In the absence of nitrogen or phosphorus deficiency, shorter HRT (2 d) yielded a higher nitrogen and phosphorus uptake but lower removal efficiency. In addition, the imbalance N/P ratio (9.7:1) would decrease nitrogen or phosphorus removal. Overall, the results suggested that it was feasible to simultaneously achieve complete or high removal of COD, nitrogen, and phosphorous in MB-MPBR under the appropriate conditions. This study demonstrated for the first time that MB-MPBR is a promising technology that could achieve a high-quality effluent meeting the discharge standards of COD and nutrients in one single step.

Strong linkages between dissolved organic matter and the aquatic bacterial community in an urban river

Aquatic bacterial communities play an important role in biogeochemical cycling in river ecosystems; however, knowledge of the linkages between bacterial communities and dissolved organic matter (DOM) in urban rivers is limited. Here, 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing and parallel factor (PARAFAC) modeling of excitation-emission fluorescence spectroscopy were used to analyze the compositions, co-occurrence patterns, and interactions with chromophoric DOM (CDOM) of bacterial communities in urban river water samples influenced by different human activities. The results revealed that two protein-like components accounted for 65.2 ± 9.56% of the total variability in all three fluorescence components, which suggests that CDOM in urban rivers is mainly a microbial source. In addition to pH and DO, CDOM is also an important factor affecting bacterial community structure, and the main classes (Gammaproteobacteria and Clostridia) and genera (Limnohabitans and Alpinimonas) showed strong positive correlations with terrestrial humic-like C1 and tryptophan-like C2, respectively. When autotrophic and heterotrophic bacteria coexist in urban rivers, the production and degradation of CDOM will occur simultaneously. Furthermore, the riverine bacterial co-occurrence network had a nonrandom modular structure, which was mainly driven by classification correlation and bacterial function. The high abundance of genes related to xenobiotic metabolism, carbon metabolism and nitrogen metabolism in the urban river indicated that anthropogenic activity may be the dominant selective force altering the bacterial communities. Overall, our results provide a novel view for the assembly of bacterial communities in urban river ecosystems under the influence of different human activities.

Membrane processes

This literature review provides a review for publications in 2018 and 2019 and includes information membrane processes findings for municipal and industrial applications. This review is a subsection of the annual Water Environment Federation literature review for Treatment Systems section. The following topics are covered in this literature review: industrial wastewater and membrane. Bioreactor (MBR) configuration, membrane fouling, design, reuse, nutrient removal, operation, anaerobic membrane systems, microconstituents removal, membrane technology advances, and modeling. Other sub-sections of the Treatment Systems section that might relate to this literature review include the following: Biological Fixed-Film Systems, Activated Sludge, and Other Aerobic Suspended Culture Processes, Anaerobic Processes, and Water Reclamation and Reuse. This publication might also have related information on membrane processes: Industrial Wastes, Hazardous Wastes, and Fate and Effects of Pollutants.

An integrated approach for tannery effluent treatment with ozonation and phycoremediation: A feasibility study

For the exploration of an effective and economical method to treat composite raw tannery effluent, the integrated approach of Ozonation and phycoremediation was followed. In a lab-scale Ozone reactor, the highest performance index was attained, when it was operated at a low O₃ flowrate (2 g/h) condition. The tannery effluent partially treated by Ozonation (≈60% COD removed in 90 min) with the ozone consumption of 1.5 g of O₃/g of COD, at pH 7.6, coupled with phycoremediation had improved the tannery effluent characteristics to a considerable extent. Overall, the maximum reduction in pollutant concentration attained with the combined treatment was 84% for COD, 60% for colour, 100% for odour, 90% for inorganic carbon, 82% for NH₄⁺- N, 100% for PO₄-P, 97% for chromium and 10% for TDS. In phycoremediation, microalgae Nannochloropsis oculata had shown an enhanced growth (μ = 0.255 day^-1) with a maximum cell density of 5.2 × 10⁷ cells/mL, dry biomass of 0.86 g L^-1 and cell division rate of 0.369 day^-1. Elemental analysis of biomass validated the chromium remediation along with other elements such as calcium, magnesium, sodium, potassium, zinc, and iron from the tannery effluent. Therefore, the phycoremediation integrated ozone process can be considered as a feasible treatment method for tannery effluent along with value-added biomass production.

Nitrogen removal in a combined aerobic granular sludge and solid-phase biological denitrification system: System evaluation and community structure

In the present study, the feasibility of treating high ammonia wastewater was evaluated in a combination of aerobic granular sludge nitrification reactor (AGS-SBR) and poly(butylene succinate) solid denitrification reactor (PBS-SBR). After 90 days operation, the effluent NH₄⁺-N and total nitrogen (TN) removal efficiencies were high of 99.6% and 99.7%, respectively. According to typical cycle, N₂O emission rate in AGS nitrification process was much higher than PBS denitrification process. It was found from EEM-PARAFAC that the fluorescence intensity scores (protein-like and humic like substances) of soluble microbial products (SMP) in AGS-SBR were the significant higher than in PBS-SBR. Microbial community analysis showed that Thauera was main genus in AGS-SBR and Hydrogenophaga Simplicispira and Thiomonas were dominant genus in PBS-SBR. The obtained result implied that the combined technology is feasible to remove nitrogen compounds from wastewater to meet the stringent emission standards.

Enhancement of anaerobic digestion effluent treatment by microalgae immobilization: Characterized by fluorescence excitation-emission matrix coupled with parallel factor analysis in the photobioreactor

The bacterial-microalgal consortium has been investigated to anaerobic digestion effluent (ADE) treatment in the photobioreactor (PBR). However, the high concentrations of nutrients reduced the ADE treatment efficiency and the transformation of organic pollutants in PBR was still unclear. In this study, two-sequencing batch PBRs were operated with suspended Microcystis aeruginosa (M. aeruginosa, SMA) and immobilized M. aeruginosa (IMA) to compare the ADE treatment performance. Fluorescence excitation-emission matrix coupled with parallel factor analysis (EEM-PARAFAC) was conducted to identify organics degradations. The results showed that the proportion of living M. aeruginosa cell (86.4%) in PBR (IMA) was highly significant (p < 0.05) higher than that in PBR (SMA) (75.2%). This indicated immobilized microalgae beads enhanced the resistance to the high concentration of nutrients in PBR (IMA). EEM-PARAFAC analysis displayed the biodegradation order in the bacterial-microalgal consortium system was humic-like substances > tyrosine-like substances > tryptophan-like substances. The removals of humic-like matters (94.05 ± 0.92%) and tyrosine-like matters (91.13 ± 2.49%) in PBR (IMA) were significantly (p < 0.01) higher than those in PBR (SMA). Notably, the average removals of nutrients in PBR (IMA) were significantly (p < 0.05) higher than those in PBR (SMA). This result verified that microalgae immobilization benefitted nutrients removals with 93.05 ± 1.45% of NH₄⁺-N and complete PO₄^3--P removal in PBR (IMA). Moreover, the enrichment of functional genera Flavobacterium and Opitutus contributed to decreasing the organics loadings and strengthening the ADE treatment performance. Therefore, this study verified microalgae immobilization enhanced the actual ADE treatment. Additionally, fluorescent organic pollutants degradations were further evaluated by EEM-PARAFAC analysis in the bacterial-microalgal consortium.

Cultivation of Chlorella vulgaris on unsterilized dairy-derived liquid digestate for simultaneous biofuels feedstock production and pollutant removal

In order to assess viability of microalgae cultivation using unsterilized dairy-derived liquid digestate (DLD) for simultaneous biofuels feedstock production and contaminant removal, four DLD concentrations (25%, 50%, 75% and 100%) were used to grow Chlorella vulgaris in batch photobioreactors (PBRs). The 25% DLD was an ideal alternative medium in that high growth rate (0.69 d^-1), high lipid productivity (112.9 mg L^-1 d^-1) as well as high nutrient removal were attained. The high DLD concentration caused inhibition of microalgal growth, where COD was more inhibitive than ammonium. The presence of bacteria did not influence microalgae production because of limited growth. Microalgal growth reduced the richness and diversity of bacterial community. Furthermore, the species of Bacteroidetes, Candidatus Saccharibacteria, and Chlamydiae rather than Proteobacteria benefited microalgal-bacterial symbiosis. These findings contribute to better application of microalgal-bacterial system for large-scale microalgae cultivation as well as environmental sustainability.

Green microalgae for combined sewage and tannery effluent treatment: Performance and lipid accumulation potential

Microalgae have considerable interest owing to its phycoremediation potential and raw material for sustainable biofuel production. In this study, the performance of green algae Chlorella vulgaris (NRMCF0128) and Pseudochlorella pringsheimii (VIT_SDSS) was evaluated for the remediation of combined sewage and tannery effluent under different dilutions. Significant reduction in pollutant concentration was observed in the effluent: >65% for NH₃-N, 100% for PO₄-P, >63% for COD & >80% for total chromium, at higher dilutions (up to 30%) of tannery effluent (T) for both species. EDAX analysis confirms the intracellular accumulation of heavy metal chromium and other elements such as aluminum, zinc, and iron by both microalgae. In addition, the maximum yield of biomass achieved was 3.51 g/L (for 30% Tannery effluent) and 2.84 g/L (for 20% Tannery effluent) for Chlorella vulgaris &Pseudochlorella pringsheimii, respectively. Between the two species, Pseudochlorella pringsheimii has shown high lipid accumulation potential of 25.4% compared to Chlorella vulgaris (9.3%) at 20% Tannery effluent. Hence, it is evident that the green microalgae Pseudochlorella pringsheimii is promising for the sustainable treatment of combined sewage and tannery effluent along with biofuel production.

Effects of microphytobenthos Cylindrotheca closterium on the fate of di-n-butyl phthalate in an aquatic microcosm

Effects of Cylindrotheca closterium, a marine benthic diatom, on the fate of di-n-butyl phthalate (DBP) in a water-sediment system were investigated. Model calculation results showed that DBP residue was 38.5% lower in the system with C. closterium than in the system without C. closterium. The net flux from water to sediment increased by 7.3 times in the presence of C. closterium. As a result, the total biodegradation flux of DBP in the system with C. closterium was increased by 25.6%. According to the 16 s rDNA sequencing, the presence of C. closterium decreased the bacterial population as well as bacterial community diversity in sediments. Moreover, the population of C. closterium, capable of efficiently degrading DBP, was much higher than that of the dominant DBP-degrading bacteria, demonstrating that degradation of DBP by C. closterium should be the main reason for the degradation enhancement in sediments.

Microalgae cultivation and nutrients removal from sewage sludge after ozonizing in algal-bacteria system

The feasibility of growing algae in concentrated wastewater generated from sludge ozonation for simultaneous nutrients removal and biomass production was studied. The effects of bacteria addition into microalgae on nutrients removal, biomass yield and settleability, the growth rate of algae and concentrations of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and soluble microbial products (SMP) were investigated. The results showed that the growth rate of algae in algal-bacteria system (0.2182) was improved than in algae-only system (0.1852), while both of them are comparable with others reported previously. And the addition of bacteria enhanced COD, NH₄⁺-N, TN and TP removal rate by 23.9 ± 3.3%, 27.7 ± 3.6%, 16.6 ± 1.8% and 14.9 ± 2.2%, respectively. And 32.8 ± 0.7% of the TN and 50.3 ± 1.8% of the TP were recycled from ozonated sludge-supernatant (OSS) being absorbed into algal-bacterial biomass. The algal-bacteria system also demonstrated advantages on biomass settleability and heavy metals removal. Finally, the mechanism involving matter exchange and algal-bacteria system on OSS treatment in this study were discussed through evaluation of nutrients, SMP and EPS contents, nitrogen and phosphorus balance.

Removal and degradation mechanisms of sulfonamide antibiotics in a new integrated aerobic submerged membrane bioreactor system

A novel laboratory-scale aerobic submerged membrane bioreactor integrating sponge-plastic biocarriers (SPSMBR) was conducted to study the removal and degradation mechanisms of sulfonamide antibiotics (SAs). Experimental results indicated that SPSMBR had a better removal of sulfadiazine (91% SDZ) and sulfamethoxazole (88% SMZ) than that of a conventional aerobic submerged membrane bioreactor (CSMBR) (76% SDZ and 71% SMZ, respectively). Material balance calculations suggested that biodegradation is the primary removal mechanism of SDZ and SMZ. Protein (tyrosine-like materials) significantly affected the removal of SAs. Moreover, the SPSMBR exhibited its better performance in removing SAs due to more abundance of tyrosine-like materials. The 16S rRNA sequencing showed that biocarriers could promote the enrichment of slow growing bacteria, especially Thermomonas, associated with the removal of SAs. Valuable insights into the removal and degradation mechanisms of SAs in the SPSMBR systems are documented here.

Immobilized microalgae for anaerobic digestion effluent treatment in a photobioreactor-ultrafiltration system: Algal harvest and membrane fouling control

A photobioreactor (PBR) coupled with ultrafiltration (UF) system was developed with goals of microalgae cultivation, harvest, and membrane fouling control in the anaerobic digestion effluent purification. Firstly, three-sequencing batch PBRs were started-up with suspended Chlorella vulgaris (C. vulgaris, SCV), immobilized C. vulgaris (ICV) and immobilized C. vulgaris with powdered activated carbon (ICV + PAC). The results exhibited high DOC degradation (66.61%-84.35%) and completely nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) removals were attained in PBRs. This indicated bacterial-microalgal consortiums enhanced biodegradation and PAC adsorption accelerated photodegradation. During the microalgae harvest by UF, immobilized microalgae beads protected cells integrity with less debris and intracellular/extracellular organic matters lysis. Moreover, the cake layer in ICV + PAC could even serve as a dynamic layer to entrap the residual pollutants and control membrane fouling. Hence, membrane fouling mitigation and ADE purification were realized during the microalgae harvest process in the ICV + PAC.

A review of membrane fouling and its control in algal-related membrane processes

Membrane technologies have received much attention in microalgae biorefinery for nutrients removal from wastewater, carbon dioxide abatement from the air as well as the production of value-added products and biofuel in recent years. This paper provides a state-of-the-art review on membrane fouling issues and its control in membrane photobioreactors (MPBRs) and other algal-related membrane processes (harvesting, dewatering, and biofuel production). The mechanisms of membrane fouling and factors affecting membrane fouling in algal-related membrane processes are systematically reviewed. Also, strategies to control membrane fouling in algal-related membrane processes are summarized and discussed. Finally, the gaps, challenges, and opportunities in membrane fouling control in algal-related membrane technologies are identified and discussed.

The effect of the algal microbiome on industrial production of microalgae

Microbes are ubiquitously distributed, and they are also present in algae production systems. The algal microbiome is a pivotal part of the alga holobiont and has a key role in modulating algal populations in nature. However, there is a lack of knowledge on the role of bacteria in artificial systems ranging from laboratory flasks to industrial ponds. Coexisting microorganisms, and predominantly bacteria, are often regarded as contaminants in algal research, but recent studies manifested that many algal symbionts not only promote algal growth but also offer advantages in downstream processing. Because of the high expectations for microalgae in a bio‐based economy, better understanding of benefits and risks of algal–microbial associations is important for the algae industry. Reducing production cost may be through applying specific bacteria to enhance algae growth at large scale as well as through preventing the growth of a broad spectrum of algal pathogens. In this review, we highlight the latest studies of algae–microbial interactions and their underlying mechanisms, discuss advantages of large‐scale algal–bacterial cocultivation and extend such knowledge to a broad range of biotechnological applications.