Pretreatment and prophylaxis against nerve agent poisoning: Are undesirable behavioral side effects unavoidable?

Click-chemistry-derived oxime library reveals efficient reactivators of nerve agent-inhibited butyrylcholinesterase suitable for pseudo-catalytic bioscavenging

A library of 100 click-chemistry-derived oximes was evaluated as reactivators of butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) inhibited by the nerve agents (NAs) sarin, cyclosarin, VX, and tabun. While reactivation efficiency was highly dependent on the structure of both the NA and the oxime, for each NA-BChE conjugate, we identified reactivators more effective than currently approved oximes for NA poisoning. Detailed kinetic analysis indicated that this enhancement results from both improved molecular recognition-specifically, enhanced binding affinity of the phosphylated conjugates for the oximes-and increased maximal reactivation rates. Molecular modeling of oximes in a near-attack conformation within inhibited BChE revealed critical interactions for productive reactivation. Among all tested oximes, 5B [1-hexyl-2-((hydroxyimino)methyl)pyridinium chloride] emerged as a particularly efficient reactivator for BChE phosphorylated with cyclosarin, with the highest observed overall reactivation rate of 34,120 M-1 min-1, which is 525-fold and 44-fold higher than the reference oximes 2-PAM and HI-6, respectively. In general, three mono-pyridinium mono-oximes demonstrated more efficient recovery of BChE activity than bis-pyridinium triazole-annulated click-chemistry bis-oximes, which were previously identified as potent reactivators for inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Ex vivo assessment of reactivation potency demonstrated that the combined addition of BChE with one efficient reactivator for BChE and another for AChE achieved > 90% reactivation of cyclosarin-inhibited cholinesterases in whole blood (WB), demonstrating near-complete degradation of a 100-fold excess of cyclosarin within 6 min. These results confirm that oxime-assisted catalysis is feasible for NA bioscavenging in blood and underscore BChE's potential as a target for developing therapies against NA poisoning.

Prophylaxis by a reversible cholinesterase inhibitor and the NMDA receptor antagonist treatment as combinatorial countermeasure against nerve agent poisoning in mice model

The current pharmacological pretreatment and medical treatment of nerve agent poisoning is an insufficiently addressed medical task. The prophylactic efficacy of a novel compound acting dually as an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor and NMDA receptor antagonist (K1959) and the therapeutic efficacy of a novel NMDA receptor antagonist (K2060) were evaluated in the NMRI mice model of nerve agent poisoning by tabun, soman and sarin. Their added value to the standard antidotal treatment (a combination of oxime reactivator and atropine) was also analyzed. The novel dually acting prophylactic drug (K1959) did not bring any additional benefit compared to the commonly used pyridostigmine. By contrast, an increase in the therapeutic efficacy of classic antidotal treatment was observed when the novel NMDA receptor antagonist (K2060) was combined with commonly used antidotes (oxime reactivator in combination with atropine). This novel combination reduced the acute toxicity of tabun, soman, and sarin more than two-fold, four-fold, and five-fold, respectively. These results highlight the possibility of NMDA antagonists such as K2060 as a supportive drug for the classic therapy of organophosphorus poisoning.

Effective parallel evaluation of molecular design, expression and bioactivity of novel recombinant butyrylcholinesterase medical countermeasures

Current medical countermeasures (MCMs) for nerve agent poisoning have limited efficacy, and can cause serious adverse effects, prompting the requirement for new broad-spectrum therapeutics. Human plasma-derived butyrylcholinseterase (huBChE) is a promising novel bioscavenger MCM which has shown potential in animal studies, however, is economically prohibitive to manufacture at scale. This study addresses current challenges for the economical production of a bioactive and long-acting recombinant huBChE (rBChE) in mammalian cells by being the first to directly compare novel rBChE design strategies. These include co-expression of a proline rich attachment domain (PRAD) and fusion of BChE with a protein partner. Additionally, a pre-purification screening method developed in this study enables parallel comparison of the expression efficiency, activity and broad-spectrum binding to nerve agents for ten novel rBChE molecular designs. All designed rBChE demonstrated functionality to act as broad-spectrum MCMs to G, V and A series nerve agents. Expression using the ExpiCHO™ Max protocol provided greatest expression levels and activity for all constructs, with most rBChE expressing poorly in Expi293™. Fc- or hSA-fused rBChE significantly outperformed constructs designed to mimic huBChE, including PRAD-BChE, and proved an effective strategy to significantly improve enzyme activity and expression. Choice of protein partner, directionality and the addition of a linker also impacted fusion rBChE activity and expression. Overall, hSA fused rBChE provided greatest expression yield and activity, with BChE-hSA the best performing construct. The purified and characterised BChE-hSA demonstrated similar functionality to huBChE to be inhibited by GD, VX and A-234, supporting the findings of the pre-screening study and validating its capacity to assess and streamline the selection process for rBChE constructs in a cost-effective manner. Collectively, these outcomes contribute to risk mitigation in early-stage development, providing a systematic method to compare rBChE designs and a focus for future development.

Warfare Nerve Agents and Paraoxonase-1 as a Potential Prophylactic Therapy against Intoxication

Nerve agents are a class of lethal neurotoxic chemicals used in chemical warfare. In this review, we have discussed a brief history of chemical warfare, followed by an exploration of the historical context surrounding nerve agents. The article explores the classification of these agents, their contemporary uses, their toxicity mechanisms, and the disadvantages of the current treatment options for nerve agent poisoning. It then discusses the possible application of enzymes as prophylactics against nerve agent poisoning, outlining the benefits and drawbacks of paraoxonase- 1. Finally, the current studies on paraoxonase-1 are reviewed, highlighting that several challenges need to be addressed in the use of paraoxonase-1 in the actual field and that its potential as a prophylactic antidote against nerve agent poisoning needs to be evaluated. The literature used in this manuscript was searched using various electronic databases, such as PubMed, Google Scholar, Web of Science, Elsevier, Springer, ACS, Google Patent, and books using the keywords chemical warfare agent, butyrylcholinesterase, enzyme, nerve agent, prophylactic, and paraoxonase-1, with the time scale for the analysis of articles between 1960 to 2023. The study has suggested that concerted efforts by researchers and agencies must be made to develop effective countermeasures against NA poisoning and that paraoxonase-1 has suitable properties for the development of efficient prophylaxis against NA poisoning.

Drug and pro-drug substrates and pseudo-substrates of human butyrylcholinesterase

Butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) is present in plasma and numerous cells and organs. Its physiological function(s) is(are) still unclear. However, this enzyme is of pharmacological and toxicological importance. It displays a broad specificity and is capable of hydrolyzing a wide range of substrates with turnovers differing by several orders of magnitude. Nowaday, these substrates include more than two dozen carboxyl-ester drugs, numerous acetylated prodrugs, and transition state analogues of acetylcholine. In addition, BChE displays a promiscuous hydrolytic activity toward amide bonds of arylacylamides, and slowly hydrolyzes carbamyl- and phosphoryl-esters. Certain pseudo-substrates like carbamates and organophosphates are major drugs of potential medical interest. The existence of a large genetic poly-allelism, affecting the catalytic properties of BChE is at the origin of clinical complications in the use of certain drugs catabolized by BChE. The number of drugs and prodrugs hydrolyzed by BChE is expected to increase in the future. However, very few quantitative data (Km, kcat) are available for most marketed drugs, and except for myorelaxants like succinylcholine and mivacurium, the impact of BChE genetic mutations on catalytic parameters has not been evaluated for most of these drugs.

Pharmacological prophylaxis with pyridostigmine bromide against nerve agents adversely impact on airway function in an ex vivo rat precision-cut lung slice model

The carbamate pyridostigmine bromide (PB) is the only fielded pharmacological prophylaxis for military use against nerve agents. Previous studies have shown differences in the PB-pretreatment efficacy for various nerve agents and in the influence of post-exposure treatment with common antidotes. In the present study, the aim was to evaluate the possibility of using an ex vivo rat precision-cut lung slice model to determine the impact of PB pretreatment on VX-induced bronchoconstriction. In addition, the efficacy of post-exposure treatment with atropine sulfate following PB-prophylaxis was investigated.Bronchoconstriction was induced by electric-field stimulation and was significantly aggravated by 10 µM PB. Airway recovery was decreased by both 1 and 10 µM PB. Evaluation of acetylcholineesterese inhibition by PB showed that the lower concentration met the clinical criteria of residual enzyme activity while the higher concentration completely inhibited the activity. Exposure to VX with or without pretreatment demonstrated similar contractions. However, VX-incubation following pretreatment caused decreased airway relaxation compared to pretreatment alone. Atropine treatment following PB- and VX-exposure significantly decreased the maximum airway contraction and increased the relaxation.In conclusion, no beneficial effect of PB-prophylaxis on VX-induced contractions was observed. The atropine efficacy to relax airways was significant demonstrating the importance of efficient post-exposure therapeutics to protect against the life-threatening respiratory contractions.

Combination of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and NMDA receptor antagonists increases survival rate in soman-poisoned mice

Organophosphorus nerve agents pose a global threat to both military personnel and civilian population, because of their high acute toxicity and insufficient medical countermeasures. Commonly used drugs could ameliorate the intoxication and overall medical outcomes. In this study, we tested the drugs able to alleviate the symptoms of Alzheimer's disease (donepezil, huperzine A, memantine) or Parkinson's disease (procyclidine). They were administered to mice before soman intoxication in terms of their: i) protection potential against soman toxicity and ii) influence on post-exposure therapy consisting of atropine and asoxime (also known as oxime HI-6). Their pretreatment effect was not significant, when administered alone, but in combination (acetylcholinesterase inhibitor such as denepezil or huperzine A with NMDA antagonist such as memantine or procyclidine) they lowered the soman toxicity more than twice. These combinations also positively influenced the efficacy of post-exposure treatment in a similar fashion; the combinations increased the therapeutic effectiveness of antidotal treatment. In conclusion, the most effective combination - huperzine A and procyclidine - lowered the toxicity three times and improved the post-exposure therapy efficacy more than six times. These results are unprecedented in the published literature.

A complete, evidence-based review on novichok poisoning based on epidemiological aspects and clinical management

Background: The whole world has learned about the existence of a highly toxic neuro-paralytic substance called Novichok. A wide range of neuro-paralytic toxins were used during the wars of decades ago, which also had harmful and irreversible effects. Fortunately, the establishment of conventions prohibiting the use of these weapons prevented the adverse clinical consequences of these compounds. What we did in the present study was to evaluate the clinical features of Novichok, how to manage exposure to it, and to evaluate the prognostic aspects associated with this poisoning agent. Methods: The manuscript especial databases including Medline, Web of knowledge, Google scholar, and Scopus were deeply searched by the two blinded investigators for all eligible studies based on the considered keywords. Initially 98 articles were initially collected by database searching that considering eligibility criteria, 83 articles were finally eligible for the final assessment. There is a lack of clinical trials and case-cohort studies on general population about treatment and side effects when it comes to human nerve agents and most of the data in our search is based on animal studies. Results: In evaluating various clinical, auto physiological and prognostic aspects of exposure to these substances, special attention was necessary to the following points. First, Novichok agents are considered more potent than other toxic agents. Pathophysiologically, these agents irreversibly bind acetylcholinesterase and produce a rapid cholinergic toxidrome which is responsible for the clinical manifestations as well as the potential dangerous and life threatening side effects caused by these agents. Uniquely, these agents are thought to also target every neuron in the central and peripheral nervous system. As a managerial and therapeutic approach, early and timely treatment of its related complication along with prevents massive exposure and decontamination in addition to rapid resuscitation can prohibit debilitating neuropathy and death due to facing it. Conclusion: The present review highlights the importance of recognizing the potential acute toxic effects of Novichok agents, diagnostic and therapeutic approaches (life-saving antidotal therapy) to complications and ultimately the application of guidelines to improve the prognosis of exposure to these agents for both victims and medical community.

Design and production strategies for developing a recombinant butyrylcholinesterase medical countermeasure for Organophosphorus poisoning

Organophosphorus nerve agents represent a serious chemical threat due to their ease of production and scale of impact. The recent use of the nerve agent Novichok has re-emphasised the need for broad-spectrum medical countermeasures (MCMs) to these agents. However, current MCMs are limited. Plasma derived human butyrylcholinesterase (huBChE) is a promising novel bioscavenger MCM strategy, but is prohibitively expensive to isolate from human plasma at scale. Efforts to produce recombinant huBChE (rBChE) in various protein expression platforms have failed to achieve key critical attributes of huBChE such as circulatory half-life. These proteins often lack critical features such as tetrameric structure and requisite post-translational modifications. This review evaluates previous attempts to generate rBChE and assesses recent advances in mammalian cell expression and protein engineering strategies that could be deployed to achieve the required half-life and yield for a viable rBChE MCM. This includes the addition of a proline-rich attachment domain, fusion proteins, post translational modifications, expression system selection and optimised downstream processes. Whilst challenges remain, a combinatorial approach of these strategies demonstrates potential as a technically feasible approach to achieving a bioactive and cost effective bioscavenger MCM.

Electrochemical detection of methyl-paraoxon based on bifunctional cerium oxide nanozyme with catalytic activity and signal amplification effect

A new electrochemical sensor for organophosphate pesticide (methyl-paraoxon) detection based on bifunctional cerium oxide (CeO₂) nanozyme is here reported for the first time. Methyl-paraoxon was degraded into p-nitrophenol by using CeO₂ with phosphatase mimicking activity. The CeO₂ nanozyme-modified electrode was then synthesized to detect p-nitrophenol. Cyclic voltammetry was applied to investigate the electrochemical behavior of the modified electrode, which indicates that the signal enhancement effect may attribute to the coating of CeO₂ nanozyme. The current research also studied and discussed the main parameters affecting the analytical signal, including accumulation potential, accumulation time, and pH. Under the optimum conditions, the present method provided a wider linear range from 0.1 to 100 μmol/L for methyl-paraoxon with a detection limit of 0.06 μmol/L. To validate the proof of concept, the electrochemical sensor was then successfully applied for the determination of methyl-paraoxon in three herb samples, i.e., Coix lacryma-jobi, Adenophora stricta and Semen nelumbinis. Our findings may provide new insights into the application of bifunctional nanozyme in electrochemical detection of organophosphorus pesticide.

•

A new electrochemical method for methyl-paraoxon detection by using bifunctional nanozyme was presented.

•

The cerium oxide nanozyme modified glassy carbon electrode was prepared to improve the sensitivity.

•

The developed method has been successfully applied in three herbal plant samples.

Memantine and Its Combination with Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors in Pharmacological Pretreatment of Soman Poisoning in Mice

Nerve agents pose a real threat to both the military and civil populations, but the current treatment of the poisoning is unsatisfactory. Thus, we studied the efficacy of prophylactic use of memantine alone or in combination with clinically used reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (pyridostigmine, donepezil, rivastigmine) against soman. In addition, we tested their influence on post-exposure therapy consisting of atropine and asoxime. Pyridostigmine alone failed to decrease the acute toxicity of soman. But all clinically used acetylcholinesterase inhibitors administered alone reduced the acute toxicity, with donepezil showing the best efficacy. The combination of memantine with reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors attenuated soman acute toxicity significantly. The pretreatment administered alone or in combinations influenced the efficacy of post-exposure treatment in a similar fashion: (i) pyridostigmine or memantine alone did not affect the antidotal treatment, (ii) centrally acting reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors alone increased the antidotal treatment slightly, (iii) combination of memantine with reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors increased the antidotal treatment more markedly. In conclusion, memantine alone failed to decrease the acute toxicity of soman or increase post-exposure antidotal treatment efficacy. The combination of memantine with donepezil significantly increased post-exposure effectiveness (together 5.12, pretreatment alone 1.72). Both drugs, when applied together, mitigate soman toxicity and boost post-exposure treatment.

Efficacy of atropine and scopolamine on airway contractions following exposure to the nerve agent VX

Nerve agents are highly toxic organophosphorus compounds that inhibit acetylcholinesterase resulting in rapid accumulation of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine (ACh) causing a cholinergic syndrome including respiratory failure. In the present study, respiratory responses and antimuscarinic treatment efficacy was evaluated ex vivo using rat precision-cut lung slices (PCLS) exposed to the nerve agent VX. The respiratory effects were evaluated either by adding exogenous ACh directly to the culture medium or by applying electric-field stimulation (EFS) to the PCLS to achieve a release of endogenous ACh from neurons in the lung tissue. The airway contraction induced by both methods was enhanced by VX and resulted in lingering airway recovery, in particular when airways were exposed to a high VX-dose. Both contractions induced by EFS and exogenously added ACh were significantly reduced by administration of the antimuscarinic drugs atropine or scopolamine. Two additions of atropine or scopolamine after maximal ACh-induced airway response was demonstrated effective to reverse the contraction. By adding consecutive doubled doses of antimuscarinics, high efficiency to reduce the cholinergic airway response was observed. However, the airways were not completely recovered by atropine or scopolamine, indicating that non-muscarinic mechanisms were involved in the smooth muscle contractions. In conclusion, it was demonstrated that antimuscarinic treatment reversed airway contraction induced by VX but supplemental pharmacological interventions are needed to fully recover the airways. Further studies should therefore clarify the mechanisms of physiological responses in lung tissue following nerve agent exposures to improve the medical management of poisoned individuals.

Counteracting poisoning with chemical warfare nerve agents

Phosphylation of the pivotal enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE) by nerve agents (NAs) leads to irreversible inhibition of the enzyme and accumulation of neurotransmitter acetylcholine, which induces cholinergic crisis, that is, overstimulation of muscarinic and nicotinic membrane receptors in the central and peripheral nervous system. In severe cases, subsequent desensitisation of the receptors results in hypoxia, vasodepression, and respiratory arrest, followed by death. Prompt action is therefore critical to improve the chances of victim's survival and recovery. Standard therapy of NA poisoning generally involves administration of anticholinergic atropine and an oxime reactivator of phosphylated AChE. Anticholinesterase compounds or NA bioscavengers can also be applied to preserve native AChE from inhibition. With this review of 70 years of research we aim to present current and potential approaches to counteracting NA poisoning.

Slow-binding reversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase with long-lasting action for prophylaxis of organophosphate poisoning

Organophosphorus (OP) compounds represent a serious health hazard worldwide. The dominant mechanism of their action results from covalent inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Standard therapy of acute OP poisoning is partially effective. However, prophylactic administration of reversible or pseudo-irreversible AChE inhibitors before OP exposure increases the efficiency of standard therapy. The purpose of the study was to test the duration of the protective effect of a slow-binding reversible AChE inhibitor (C547) in a mouse model against acute exposure to paraoxon (POX). It was shown that the rate of inhibition of AChE by POX in vitro after pre-inhibition with C547 was several times lower than without C547. Ex vivo pre-incubation of mouse diaphragm with C547 significantly prevented the POX-induced muscle weakness. Then it was shown that pre-treatment of mice with C547 at the dose of 0.01 mg/kg significantly increased survival after poisoning by 2xLD50 POX. The duration of the pre-treatment was effective up to 96 h, whereas currently used drug for pre-exposure treatment, pyridostigmine at a dose of 0.15 mg/kg was effective less than 24 h. Thus, long-lasting slow-binding reversible AChE inhibitors can be considered as new potential drugs to increase the duration of pre-exposure treatment of OP poisoning.

Oral Pretreatment with Galantamine Effectively Mitigates the Acute Toxicity of a Supralethal Dose of Soman in Cynomolgus Monkeys Posttreated with Conventional Antidotes

Earlier reports suggested that galantamine, a drug approved to treat mild-to-moderate Alzheimer's disease (AD), and other centrally acting reversible acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibitors can serve as adjunct pretreatments against poisoning by organophosphorus compounds, including the nerve agent soman. The present study was designed to determine whether pretreatment with a clinically relevant oral dose of galantamine HBr mitigates the acute toxicity of 4.0×LD50 soman (15.08 µg/kg) in Macaca fascicularis posttreated intramuscularly with the conventional antidotes atropine (0.4 mg/kg), 2-pyridine aldoxime methyl chloride (30 mg/kg), and midazolam (0.32 mg/kg). The pharmacokinetic profile and maximal degree of blood AChE inhibition (∼25%-40%) revealed that the oral doses of 1.5 and 3.0 mg/kg galantamine HBr in these nonhuman primates (NHPs) translate to human-equivalent doses that are within the range used for AD treatment. Subsequent experiments demonstrated that 100% of NHPs pretreated with either dose of galantamine, challenged with soman, and posttreated with conventional antidotes survived 24 hours. By contrast, given the same posttreatments, 0% and 40% of the NHPs pretreated, respectively, with vehicle and pyridostigmine bromide (1.2 mg/kg, oral), a peripherally acting reversible AChE inhibitor approved as pretreatment for military personnel at risk of exposure to soman, survived 24 hours after the challenge. In addition, soman caused extensive neurodegeneration in the hippocampi of saline- or pyridostigmine-pretreated NHPs, but not in the hippocampi of galantamine-pretreated animals. To our knowledge, this is the first study to demonstrate the effectiveness of clinically relevant oral doses of galantamine to prevent the acute toxicity of supralethal doses of soman in NHPs. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: This is the first study to demonstrate that a clinically relevant oral dose of galantamine effectively prevents lethality and neuropathology induced by a supralethal dose of the nerve agent soman in Cynomolgus monkeys posttreated with conventional antidotes. These findings are of major significance for the continued development of galantamine as an adjunct pretreatment against nerve agent poisoning.

Slow-binding inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase of medical interest

Certain ligands slowly bind to acetylcholinesterase. As a result, there is a slow establishment of enzyme-inhibitor equilibrium characterized by a slow onset of inhibition prior reaching steady state. Three mechanisms account for slow-binding inhibition: a) slow binding rate constant k_on, b) slow ligand induced-fit following a fast binding step, c) slow conformational selection of an enzyme form. The slow equilibrium may be followed by a chemical step. This later that can be irreversible has been observed with certain alkylating agents and substrate transition state analogs. Slow-binding inhibitors present long residence times on target. This results in prolonged pharmacological or toxicological action. Through several well-known molecules (e.g. huperzine) and new examples (tocopherol, trifluoroacetophenone and a 6-methyluracil alkylammonium derivative), we show that slow-binding inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase are promising drugs for treatment of neurological diseases such as Alzheimer disease and myasthenia gravis. Moreover, they may be of interest for neuroprotection (prophylaxis) against organophosphorus poisoning. This article is part of the special issue entitled 'Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors: From Bench to Bedside to Battlefield'.

Combined Pre- and Posttreatment of Paraoxon Exposure

AIMS

Organophosphates (OPCs), useful agents as pesticides, also represent a serious health hazard. Standard therapy with atropine and established oxime-type enzyme reactivators is unsatisfactory. Experimental data indicate that superior therapeutic results can be obtained when reversible cholinesterase inhibitors are administered before OPC exposure. Comparing the protective efficacy of five such cholinesterase inhibitors (physostigmine, pyridostigmine, ranitidine, tacrine, or K-27), we observed best protection for the experimental oxime K-27. The present study was undertaken in order to determine if additional administration of K-27 immediately after OPC (paraoxon) exposure can improve the outcome.

METHODS

Therapeutic efficacy was assessed in rats by determining the relative risk of death (RR) by Cox survival analysis over a period of 48 h. Animals that received only pretreatment and paraoxon were compared with those that had received pretreatment and paraoxon followed by K-27 immediately after paraoxon exposure.

RESULTS

Best protection from paraoxon-induced mortality was observed after pretreatment with physostigmine (RR = 0.30) and K-27 (RR = 0.34). Both substances were significantly more efficacious than tacrine (RR = 0.67), ranitidine (RR = 0.72), and pyridostigmine (RR = 0.76), which were less efficacious but still significantly reduced the RR compared to the no-treatment group (paraoxon only). Additional administration of K-27 immediately after paraoxon exposure (posttreatment) did not further reduce mortality. Statistical analysis between pretreatment before paraoxon exposure alone and pretreatment plus K-27 posttreatment did not show any significant difference for any of the pretreatment regimens.

CONCLUSIONS

Best outcome is achieved if physostigmine or K-27 are administered prophylactically before exposure to sublethal paraoxon dosages. Therapeutic outcome is not further improved by additional oxime therapy immediately thereafter.

Oximes as pretreatment before acute exposure to paraoxon

Organophosphates, useful agents as pesticides, also represent a serious danger due to their high acute toxicity. There is indication that oximes, when administered before organophosphate exposure, can protect from these toxic effects. We have tested at equitoxic dosage (25% of LD₀₁ ) the prophylactic efficacy of five experimental (K-48, K-53, K-74, K-75, K-203) and two established oximes (pralidoxime and obidoxime) to protect from mortality induced by the organophosphate paraoxon. Mortalities were quantified by Cox analysis and compared with those observed after pretreatment with a strong acetylcholinesterase inhibitor (10-methylacridine) and after the FDA-approved pretreatment compound pyridostigmine. All nine tested substances statistically significantly reduced paraoxon-induced mortality. Best protection was conferred by the experimental oxime K-48, reducing the relative risk of death (RR) to 0.10, which was statistically significantly superior to pyridostigmine (RR = 0.31). The other oximes reduced the RR to 0.13 (obidoxime), 0.20 (K-203), 0.21 (K-74), 0.24 (K-75) and 0.26 (pralidoxime), which were significantly more efficacious than 10-methylacridine (RR = 0.65). These data support the hypothesis that protective efficacy is not primarily due to cholinesterase inhibition and indicate that the tested experimental oximes may be considered promising alternatives to the established pretreatment compound pyridostigmine.

The Experimental Oxime K027-A Promising Protector From Organophosphate Pesticide Poisoning. A Review Comparing K027, K048, Pralidoxime, and Obidoxime

Poisoning with organophosphorus compounds (OPCs) is a major problem worldwide. Standard therapy with atropine and established oxime-type enzyme reactivators (pralidoxime, obidoxime) is unsatisfactory. In search of more efficacious broad-spectrum oximes, new bispyridinium (K-) oximes have been synthesized, with K027 being among the most promising. This review summarizes pharmacokinetic characteristics of K027, its toxicity and in vivo efficacy to protect from OPC toxicity and compares this oxime with another experimental bisquaternary asymmetric pyridinium aldoxime (K048) and two established oximes (pralidoxime, obidoxime). After intramuscular (i.m.) injection, K027 reaches maximum plasma concentration within ∼30 min; only ∼2% enter the brain. Its intrinsic cholinesterase inhibitory activity is low, making it relatively non-toxic. In vitro reactivation potency is high for ethyl-paraoxon-, methyl-paraoxon-, dichlorvos-, diisopropylfluorophosphate (DFP)- and tabun-inhibited cholinesterase. When administered in vivo after exposure to the same OPCs, K027 is comparable or more efficacious than pralidoxime and obidoxime. When given as a pretreatment before exposure to ethyl-paraoxon, methyl-paraoxon, DFP, or azinphos-methyl, it is superior to the Food and Drug Administration-approved compound pyridostigmine and comparable to physostigmine, which because of its entry into the brain may cause unwanted behavioral effects. Because of its low toxicity, K027 can be given in high dosages, making it a very efficacious oxime not only for postexposure treatment but also for prophylactic administration, especially when brain penetration is undesirable.

Reversible cholinesterase inhibitors as pretreatment for exposure to organophosphates. A review

Organophosphorus compounds (OPCs), inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (AChE), are useful agents as pesticides, but also represent a serious health hazard. Standard therapy with atropine and established oxime-type enzyme reactivators (pralidoxime, obidoxime) is unsatisfactory. Better therapeutic results are obtained, when reversible AChE inhibitors are administered before OPC exposure. This review summarizes the history of such a pretreatment approach and sums up a set of experiments undertaken in search of compounds that are efficacious when given before a broad range of OPCs. The prophylactic efficacy of 10 known AChE inhibitors, either already used clinically for different indications (physostigmine, pyridostigmine, ranitidine, tiapride, tacrine, amiloride, metoclopramide, methylene blue) or developed for possible therapeutic use in the future (7-methoxytacrine, K-27) was compared, when administered before exposure to six chemically diverse OPCs in the same experimental setting: ethyl-paraoxon, methyl-paraoxon, diisopropylfluorophosphate, terbufos sulfone, azinphos-methyl and dicrotophos. The experimental oxime K-27 was the most efficacious compound, affording best protection, when administered before terbufos sulfone, azinphos-methyl and dicrotophos, second best before ethyl- and methyl-paraoxon exposure and third best before diisopropylfluorophosphate administration. This ranking was similar to that of physostigmine, which was superior to the Food and Drug Administration-approved pretreatment for soman with pyridostigmine. Tiapride, amiloride, metoclopramide, methylene blue and 7-methoxytacrine did not achieve protection. No correlation was observed between the IC₅₀ of the reversible AChE inhibitors and their protective efficacy. These studies indicate that K-27 can be considered a very promising broad-spectrum prophylactic agent in case of imminent organophosphate exposure, which may be related to its AChE reactivating activity rather than its AChE inhibition.

Cholinesterases and the fine line between poison and remedy

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE, EC 3.1.1.7) and butyrylcholinesterase (BChE, EC 3.1.1.8) are related enzymes found across the animal kingdom. The critical role of acetylcholinesterase in neurotransmission has been known for almost a century, but a physiological role for butyrylcholinesterase is just now emerging. The cholinesterases have been deliberately targeted for both therapy and toxicity, with cholinesterase inhibitors being used in the clinic for a variety of disorders and conversely for their toxic potential as pesticides and chemical weapons. Non-catalytic functions of the cholinesterases (ChEs) participate in both neurodevelopment and disease. Manipulating either the catalytic activities or the structure of these enzymes can potentially shift the balance between beneficial and adverse effect in a wide number of physiological processes.

Optimization of Cholinesterase-Based Catalytic Bioscavengers Against Organophosphorus Agents

Organophosphorus agents (OPs) are irreversible inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (AChE). OP poisoning causes major cholinergic syndrome. Current medical counter-measures mitigate the acute effects but have limited action against OP-induced brain damage. Bioscavengers are appealing alternative therapeutic approach because they neutralize OPs in bloodstream before they reach physiological targets. First generation bioscavengers are stoichiometric bioscavengers. However, stoichiometric neutralization requires administration of huge doses of enzyme. Second generation bioscavengers are catalytic bioscavengers capable of detoxifying OPs with a turnover. High bimolecular rate constants (k_cat/K_m > 10⁶ M⁻¹min⁻¹) are required, so that low enzyme doses can be administered. Cholinesterases (ChE) are attractive candidates because OPs are hemi-substrates. Moderate OP hydrolase (OPase) activity has been observed for certain natural ChEs and for G117H-based human BChE mutants made by site-directed mutagenesis. However, before mutated ChEs can become operational catalytic bioscavengers their dephosphylation rate constant must be increased by several orders of magnitude. New strategies for converting ChEs into fast OPase are based either on combinational approaches or on computer redesign of enzyme. The keystone for rational conversion of ChEs into OPases is to understand the reaction mechanisms with OPs. In the present work we propose that efficient OP hydrolysis can be achieved by re-designing the configuration of enzyme active center residues and by creating specific routes for attack of water molecules and proton transfer. Four directions for nucleophilic attack of water on phosphorus atom were defined. Changes must lead to a novel enzyme, wherein OP hydrolysis wins over competing aging reactions. Kinetic, crystallographic, and computational data have been accumulated that describe mechanisms of reactions involving ChEs. From these studies, it appears that introducing new groups that create a stable H-bonded network susceptible to activate and orient water molecule, stabilize transition states (TS), and intermediates may determine whether dephosphylation is favored over aging. Mutations on key residues (L286, F329, F398) were considered. QM/MM calculations suggest that mutation L286H combined to other mutations favors water attack from apical position. However, the aging reaction is competing. Axial direction of water attack is not favorable to aging. QM/MM calculation shows that F329H+F398H-based multiple mutants display favorable energy barrier for fast reactivation without aging.

Cholinesterase reactivators and bioscavengers for pre- and post-exposure treatments of organophosphorus poisoning

Organophosphorus agents (OPs) irreversibly inhibit acetylcholinesterase (AChE) causing a major cholinergic syndrome. The medical counter-measures of OP poisoning have not evolved for the last 30 years with carbamates for pretreatment, pyridinium oximes-based AChE reactivators, antimuscarinic drugs and neuroprotective benzodiazepines for post-exposure treatment. These drugs ensure protection of peripheral nervous system and mitigate acute effects of OP lethal doses. However, they have significant limitations. Pyridostigmine and oximes do not protect/reactivate central AChE. Oximes poorly reactivate AChE inhibited by phosphoramidates. In addition, current neuroprotectants do not protect the central nervous system shortly after the onset of seizures when brain damage becomes irreversible. New therapeutic approaches for pre- and post-exposure treatments involve detoxification of OP molecules before they reach their molecular targets by administrating catalytic bioscavengers, among them phosphotriesterases are the most promising. Novel generation of broad spectrum reactivators are designed for crossing the blood-brain barrier and reactivate central AChE. This is an article for the special issue XVth International Symposium on Cholinergic Mechanisms.

The Evaluation of Benefit of Newly Prepared Reversible Inhibitors of Acetylcholinesterase and Commonly Used Pyridostigmine as Pharmacological Pretreatment of Soman-Poisoned Mice

AIM

The ability of four newly prepared reversible inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (6-chlorotacrine, 7-phenoxytacrine, compounds 1 and 2) and currently used carbamate pyridostigmine to increase the resistance of mice against soman and the efficacy of antidotal treatment of soman-poisoned mice was evaluated.

METHODS

The evaluation of the effect of pharmacological pretreatment is based on the identification of changes of soman-induced toxicity that was evaluated by the assessment of its LD50 value and its 95% confidence limit using probitlogarithmical analysis of death occurring within 24 h after administration of soman.

RESULTS

6-chlorotacrine was only able to markedly protect mice against acute toxicity of soman. In addition, the pharmacological pretreatment with 6-chlorotacrine or compound 2 was able to increase the efficacy of antidotal treatment (the oxime HI-6 in combination with atropine) of soman-poisoned mice. The other newly prepared reversible inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (7-phenoxytacrine, compound 1) as well as commonly used pyridostigmine did not influence the efficacy of antidotal treatment.

CONCLUSION

These findings demonstrate that pharmacological pretreatment of somanpoisoned mice can be promising and useful in the case of administration of 6-chlorotacrine and partly compound 2.

Dose Dependent Prophylactic Efficacy of 6-Chlorotacrine in Soman-Poisoned Mice

AIM

The influence of the dose on the ability of promising newly prepared reversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase (6-chlorotacrine) to increase the resistance of mice against soman and the efficacy of antidotal treatment of soman-poisoned mice was evaluated.

METHODS

The evaluation of the effect of pharmacological pretreatment is based on the identification of changes of soman-induced toxicity that was evaluated by the assessment of its LD50 value and its 95% confidence limit using probit-logarithmical analysis of death occurring within 24 hrs after administration of soman.

RESULTS

The dose of 6-chlorotacrine significantly influences the prophylactic efficacy of 6-chlorotacrine. Its highest dose was only able to significantly protect mice against acute toxicity of soman and increase the efficacy of antidotal treatment (atropine in combination with the oxime HI-6) of soman-poisoned mice. In addition, the highest dose of 6-chlorotacrine was significantly more effective to protect mice from soman poisoning than its lowest dose.

CONCLUSION

These findings demonstrate the important influence of the dose of 6-chlorotacine on its prophylactic efficacy in the case of pharmacological pretreatment of soman poisoning in mice.