Reductive materials for remediation of hexavalent chromium contaminated soil - A review

Elimination of the interference of sulfides by zinc ions on the determination of hexavalent chromium in soil by Method 3060a & Method 7196a

The sulfides are recognized as the most promising reducing agents for remediation of chromium-contaminated soils due to their strong reducing ability and low cost. However, the residual sulfides and elemental sulfur (S0) from the oxidation of sulfides significantly interfere with the determination of hexavalent chromium (Cr(Ⅵ)) in soil, seriously hindering the engineering application and experimental researches. The effectiveness of the Cu2+-EDTA method in removing S0 interference is unsatisfactory due to the inability to maintain sufficient Cu2+ concentrations during alkaline digestion. The toluene-mercury method, utilizing hot toxic toluene for pre-extraction of S0, makes the operation complex and require higher personal safety protection. This paper proposes a simple method for eliminating sulfides and S0 interference using Zn2+, only involving the addition of Zn2+ before alkaline digestion without extra operation. Experimental results indicate that at pH > 12.5, S0 begins to produce a large amount polysulfides (Sn2-) during the alkaline digestion, which in turn reduces Cr(Ⅵ). At the same pH, Zn2+ predominantly exists as aqueous Zn(OH)42- and instantly eliminates the S0-generated Sn2- by the formation of ZnS precipitates. Experiments also indicate that the addition of Zn2+ exerts no significant influence on the method detection limits of the USEPA Method 3060a & Method 7196a.

Comparing Cr(III) oxidation intermediated by different manganese oxidizing bacteria: Efficiencies, kinetic and key structure characteristics of biogenic manganese oxides

The oxidation of Cr(III) to Cr(VI) plays a critical role in the biogeochemical cycling of chromium, particularly in soils. This study investigated Cr(III) oxidation mediated by three strains of manganese-oxidizing bacteria: Pseudomonas putida MnB1, Brevundimonas diminuta MnO-2, and Pannonibacter phragmitetus MnO-3 through generating biogenic manganese oxides (BioMnOx). The MnB1-generated BioMnOx exhibited superior Cr(III) oxidation efficiency (82.00 %) compared with the BioMnOx generated by MnO-2 (2.50 %) and MnO-3 (3.26 %). Structural characterization (XRD, SEM, TEM, XPS) demonstrated that MnB1-derived BioMnOx possessed three distinctive structural features: a disordered layered structure, abundant oxygen vacancies, and elevated Mn(III/IV) ratios, which synergistically enhanced active site availability for Cr(III) oxidation. Notably, only the MnB1 system effectively oxidized slightly soluble Cr(III) forms (e.g., Cr(OH)3, CrxFe1-x(OH)3), with these structural advantages directly accounting for its superior efficiency (82.00 %). Kinetic analysis showed that the Cr(III) oxidation followed a zero-order kinetics during the rapid oxidation phase and MnB1 achieved the highest oxidation rate with different Cr(III) forms. In the leaching experiment, both of the robust manganese oxidizing bacteria MnB1 and the indigenous microorganisms significantly enhanced Cr(III) oxidation in soil. These findings highlight the critical role of BioMnOx structure in driving Cr(III) oxidation and offer deeper insights into the biogeochemical cycling of chromium in the natural and contaminated environments.

Insights into biostimulation-enhanced microbial detoxification of chromium ore processing residue-contaminated soil: The critical role of Cr(VI) key host-phase transformation and soil microbiota shifts

The continuous and slow release of Cr(VI) from chromium ore processing residue contaminated soil (COPR-soil) poses a substantial threat to soil and groundwater. Despite microbial reduction is considered as an effective approach for the remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil, the efficiency and rate of Cr(VI) reduction in COPR-soil, especially Cr(VI) embedded in minerals (e.g., vaterite, Ca/Al-Cr layered double hydroxide (Ca/Al-Cr LDH)) remain low. Here, a biostimulation-enhanced microbial detoxification strategy was developed, utilizing the strong electron transfer properties of FeSx. The removal efficiency of Cr(VI) from COPR-soil reached 99.9 %, with a 9-fold increase in the reduction rate of dissolved Cr(VI) compared to microbial remediation. FeSx semiconductor nanoparticles adhered tightly to the surface of the electroactive bacterium Pannonibacter phragmitetus BB (BB), facilitating mineral-microbial interactions that increased protein concentration by 35.8 % and Cr(VI) tolerance by 23.0 %. Biostimulation with FeSx significantly enhanced the biochemical dissolution capacity and electron shuttle potential of BB, accelerating the transformation of Cr(VI) host-phases. Vaterite was completely converted to calcite with a 22 % increase in transformation degree, while the interlayer nanoconfined Ca-Cr coordination in Ca/Al-Cr LDH shifted to a more accessible outer nonconfined structure. This transformation reduced the Cr(VI) binding capacity by 68.6 % and 79.4 %, respectively, effectively releasing Cr(VI) from mineral. Soluble Fe(III) emerged as a critical electron shuttle, enabling indirect electron transfer from BB to Cr(VI) via the Fe(III)/Fe(II) redox cycle. Additionally, biostimulation enhanced soil fertility and stability, fostering microbial consortia with improved resistance to environmental stresses through Cr(VI) efflux and intracellular translocation of Fe-Fe carrier complexes. This study provides a promising strategy to promote effective microbial remediation of COPR-soil.

Chromium dynamics in soil and detoxification of chromite belts using rhizospheric soil-plant interface

The chromium-contaminated soil expresses its severe eco-toxicity on living organisms of the locality and adjoining regions. This review has focused on the chemical interactions of chromium variants in soil and the sequestration of chromium using the soil-plant interface in the rhizosphere. The application of plant hyper-accumulators on chromium-contaminated soil for chromium sequestration is an attempt to minimize chromium toxicity of mining and industrial belts. This review utilized the PRISMA 2009 systematic review methodology. The literature screening was conducted by searching databases such as Scopus, Google Scholar, and Web of Science up to 2025 using specific keywords. In countries like Kazakhstan, South Africa, and India, more than 90% of world shipping-grade mine reserves of chromium are present. The mining and metallurgy of chromium can threaten the environmental quality and the region's public health. The Sukinda chromite mines in India are globally known for their rich chromite mining, metallurgy, and eco-toxicity. The present article analyzes the ecological challenges and searches for possible interactions of chromium variants in soil. The solution to mitigate chromium toxicity is possible using the rhizospheric soil-plant interface. This article's findings and discussion section help solve ecological challenges and strive for healthy soil at chromium-polluted sites. This review article can contribute to sustainable soil quality improvement at mining and industrial belts. Further research on the isotopic tracer technique is recommended to enhance the understanding of chromium dynamics in soil.

Nanoscale Fe(0)-zeolite composite derived from coal bottom ash for efficient treatment of Cr(VI)-contaminated groundwater: Unveiling the importance of locations for surface-bound Fe(II) and Fe(0) passivation products

The synthesis of coal bottom ash-induced zeolite (Si-Al material) has been widely reported; however, the selective recovery of the three main elements, viz., Si, Al, and Fe, from coal bottom ash for the synthesis of reactive adsorbents has not yet been reported. In this study, we separated the magnetic and non-magnetic fractions of coal bottom ash to selectively recover Fe and Si-Al for synthesizing nanoscale zero-valent iron@zeolite (NZVI@ZBA) composites with uniform formation of Fe(0) nanoparticles on the ZBA surface. NZVI@ZBA exhibited a higher removal capacity for Cr(VI) (153.9 mg gNZVI-1) than bare NZVI (3.6 times), NZVI@Al2O3 (4.1 times), and NZVI@SiO2 (3.5 times). The enhanced Cr(VI) removal was primarily attributed to well-distributed NZVI particles and the formation of surface-bound Fe(II) on the large surface area of ZBA. A significant portion of NZVI passivation products (i.e., CrxFe1-x(OH)3) was formed on the ZBA surface rather than on the NZVI surface, whereas bare NZVI signified that the entire NZVI surface was covered by passivation products, blocking electron transfer from the core NZVI. Finally, an adverse effect of Ca²⁺ was observed during the groundwater test, because Ca2+ occupied the adsorption sites of ZBA that were available for the released Fe²⁺ from NZVI. The novel findings in this study can provide insights into the complete recycling of coal bottom ash to produce value-added materials and highlight the importance of the formation location of surface-bound Fe(II) and Fe(0) passivation products when the NZVI@support composite is applied for the reductive removal of contaminants.

Photochemical oxidation of Cr(III) to Cr(VI) in the presence of Fe(III): Influence of Fe(III) concentration and UV wavelength

The reduction of Cr(VI) to Cr(III) is key to lowering environmental toxicity and mobility, but the reverse process remains less understood. We investigated Cr(III) oxidation mechanisms across various pH levels and light wavelengths (185, 254, and 358 nm) in the presence of Fe(III). At pH 3.0 under 358 nm light, Cr(VI) production peaked at 11.65 μM, driven by photo-reactive Fe(OH)²⁺ producing •OH radicals. While Fe(III) generally promotes Cr(III) oxidation, concentrations above 0.5 mM inhibited the process. Oxidation was most intense under 185 nm light, generating up to 217 μM of Cr(VI), due to Fe(III) and water photolysis. At 254 and 358 nm, •OH was solely produced by Fe(III) photolysis, where •OH oxidized Fe(II), which then reduced Cr(VI), slowing Cr(III) oxidation. Short-wavelength, high-energy light significantly enhances Cr(III) oxidation. Under such UV exposure in the atmosphere, Cr(III)-containing aerosols and particles may undergo harmful transformations, potentially entering ecosystems via acidic deposition and posing health risks.

Boron-dependent autoinducer-2-mediated quorum sensing stimulates the Cr(VI) reduction of Leucobacter chromiireducens CD49

Traditionally, abiotic factors such as pH, temperature, and initial Cr(VI) concentration have been undoubtedly recognized as the external driving forces that dramatically affect the microbial-mediated remediation of Cr(VI) pollutants. However, concentrating on whether and how the biological behaviors and metabolic activities drive the microbial-mediated Cr(VI) detoxification is a study-worthy but little-known issue. In this study, Leucobacter chromiireducens CD49 isolated from heavy-metal-contaminated soil was identified to tolerate 8000.0 mg/L Cr(VI), and reduce 92.7% of 100.0 mg/L Cr(VI) within 66 h. Kinetic models were developed to determine the arithmetic relationships between Cr(VI) concentration and reaction time, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy exhibited the co-occurrence of Cr(III) and Cr(VI) on the bacterial cell surface. Furthermore, an integrated genomic-transcriptomic study was employed to explore the genetic-level response of strain CD49 to Cr(VI) stress, and most differentially expressed genes in the Cr(VI)-treatment group were enriched in biological process-related pathways, especially in quorum sensing (QS). Under the optimal conditions based on Box-Behnken Design experiments, intriguingly, boron-dependent autoinducer-2 (AI-2)-mediated QS was stimulated after H3BO3 introduction to further improve the biofilm production, biomass, and Cr(VI) reduction efficiency of strain CD49. Additionally, significantly up-regulated expression of genes chrR, chrA, and luxS further indicated the positive effect of AI-2-mediated QS on Cr(VI) reduction. Collectively, the findings pioneeringly present a chain of evidence for QS-stimulated Cr(VI) reduction, which may provide a theoretical basis for future improvement of microbial-mediated Cr(VI) remediation.

Efficient remediation of different concentrations of Cr-contaminated soils by nano zero-valent iron modified with carboxymethyl cellulose and biochar

Nano zero-valent iron (nZVI) is widely used in soil remediation due to its high reactivity. However, the easy agglomeration, poor antioxidant ability and passivation layer of Fe-Cr coprecipitates of nZVI have limited its application scale in Cr-contaminated soil remediation, especially in high concentration of Cr-contaminated soil. Herein, we found that the carboxymethyl cellulose on nZVI particles could increase the zeta potential value of soil and change the phase of nZVI. Along with the presence of biochar, 97.0% and 96.6% Cr immobilization efficiency through CMC-nZVI/BC were respectively achieved in high and low concentrations of Cr-contaminated soils after 90-days remediation. In addition, the immobilization efficiency of Cr(VI) only decreased by 5.1% through CMC-nZVI/BC treatment after 10 weeks aging in air, attributing to the strong antioxidation ability. As for the surrounding Cr-contaminated groundwater, the Cr(VI) removal capacity of CMC-nZVI/BC was evaluated under different reaction conditions through column experiments and COMSOL Multiphysics. CMC-nZVI/BC could efficiently remove 85% of Cr(VI) in about 400 hr when the initial Cr(VI) concentration was 40 mg/L and the flow rate was 0.5 mL/min. This study demonstrates that uniformly dispersed CMC-nZVI/BC has an excellent remediation effect on different concentrations of Cr-contaminated soils.

3D-Printed Fluorescent Hydrogel Consisting of Conjugated Polymer and Biomacromolecule for Fast and Sensitive Detection of Cr(VI) in Vegetables

Portable fluorescent film sensors offer a solution to the contamination issue in homogeneous sensor detection systems. However, their special structure leads to low sensitivity and a long response time, resulting in a significant scientific challenge limiting their development and application. In this work, we propose a dual design strategy to prepare highly sensitive film sensors for rapidly detecting Cr2O72-. Specifically, P(Fmoc-Osu)-SA hydrogel films were developed by integrating the biological macromolecule sodium alginate (SA) with the conjugated polymer poly(N-(9-Fluorenylmethoxycarbonyloxy)succinimide) (P(Fmoc-Osu)), using both mold and inkjet 3D printing methods. The "molecular wire effect" of the sensing unit P(Fmoc-Osu) and the water channel within the film substrate are responsible for the improved sensitivity and the reduced response time of this thin film sensor. P(Fmoc-Osu)-SA hydrogel films prepared by these two methods can rapidly detect Cr2O72- with limits of detection of 1.18 and 0.078 nM, respectively. Considering that 3D-printed hydrogel films can be tailored to different shapes according to detection needs, the P(Fmoc-Osu)-SA hydrogel films produced from this method were effectively applied in vegetable samples. This study provides an innovative and effective strategy for the development of biocompatible hydrogel sensors that offer the potential for determining trace amounts of Cr2O72- in agriculture.

Reduction of hexavalent chromium by compost-derived dissolved organic matter

Compost-derived dissolved organic matter (DOMC) is a heterogeneous assemblage of different redox-active organic molecules. We hypothesize that DOMC can interact with Cr(VI) and reduce it to Cr(III), thereby influencing the dynamics of Cr(VI) in soil and aquatic environments. Here, DOMC, along with soil humic substances isolated from red soil and black soil, were fractionated into humic acid fractions (i.e., HAC, HAB, and HAR) and fulvic acid fractions (i.e., FAC, FAB, and FAR), respectively. The reduction and interaction between Cr(VI) and the six organic matter fractions were investigated. The results showed that the total Cr(VI) reduction capacity (TRC) of the six organic matter fractions was 26.77-49.34 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM. The TRC of HA fractions was 35.54-49.34 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM, which exceeded that of FA fractions (26.77-31.29 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM). DOMC had a HA/FA ratio of 0.64, which was higher than that of black soil humic substance (0.59) and red soil humic substance (0.20). The sum of the TRC of DOMC was 35.57 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM, which was larger than that of black soil humic substance (32.87 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM) and red soil humic substance (33.01 μM Cr(VI) per mg OM). The TRC was positively correlated with TOC, TN, phenol C, alkyl C, and aromatic C contents and negatively correlated with E2/E3, O-alkyl C, and carboxyl C contents. The reduction of Cr(VI) at pH 6 was negligible, whereas 32-67% Cr(VI) was reduced at pH 2. The Cr(VI) reduction capacities (RC2, RC2, and RC6) at pH 2-6 were positively correlated (R2 > 0.71) with phenol C. Spectral analysis showed that there was no obvious complexation between Cr(VI) and the six organic matter fractions at pH 6, and thus the reduction of Cr(VI) was negligible, but solution pH could affect the accessibility of organic molecules to Cr(VI) and thus influence Cr(VI) reduction.

Synergistic Effects of Unmodified Tea Leaves and Tea Biochar Application on Remediation of Cr-Contaminated Soil

Hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) contamination in soil presents significant risks due to its high toxicity to both the environment and human health. Renewable, low-cost natural materials offer promising solutions for Cr(VI) reduction and soil remediation. However, the effects of unmodified tea leaves and tea-derived biochar on chromium-contaminated soils remain inadequately understood. In this study, tea tree pruning waste was converted into biochar at various temperatures, and the impacts of both unmodified tea leaves and tea biochar on soil Cr(VI) content, chromium fractionation, and soil biochemical properties were assessed using a soil incubation experiment. The results showed that the combined treatment of tea and tea biochar produced at 500 °C reduced Cr(VI) content by up to 49.30% compared to the control. Chromium fractionation analysis revealed a significant increase in the residual chromium fraction, accounting for 32.97% of total chromium, substantially reducing its bioavailability and mobility. Soil properties were markedly improved, with notable increases in pH (14.89%), cation exchange capacity (CEC; up to 100.24%), and organic matter content (up to 167.12%) under the combined treatments. Correlation analysis confirmed that Cr(VI) content reductions were positively correlated with increases in pH, nutrient retention, and enzyme activities, highlighting their role in chromium stabilization. This study underscores the synergistic potential of unmodified tea leaves and tea biochar as an innovative, eco-friendly strategy for Cr(VI) remediation, enhancing both soil quality and heavy metal stabilization.

A novel sequential extraction method for the measurement of Cr(VI) and Cr(III) species distribution in soil: New insights into the chromium speciation

The distribution characteristics of Cr(VI) species in contaminated soil is crucial for soil remediation; however, there is currently a lack of methods for analysing anionic Cr(VI) species in soil. This study has developed a novel sequential extraction method for speciation of Cr(VI) and Cr(III). Besides extraction experiments, simulated chromium species were prepared to verify the presence of proposed chromium species. The results show that Cr(VI) species in soil can be categorized into water-soluble Cr(VI), electrostatically adsorbed Cr(VI), Cr(VI) specifically adsorbed by minerals containing exchangeable Ca2+, Cr(VI) specifically adsorbed by hydrous metal oxides, calcium chromate Cr(VI) and stable complexed adsorption Cr(VI). These Cr(VI) species can be selectively extracted by specific solutions through ion exchange or weak acid dissolution. The most stable Cr(VI) species is Cr(VI) complexed by hydrous iron oxides through bidentate ligand binding; only by dissolution of hydrous iron oxides can this Cr(VI) species be leached. The distribution of Cr(VI) species is closely linked to particular soil compositions including exchangeable Ca2+ and hydrous iron oxides which determinate the Cr(VI) adsorption in soil. Cr(III) species comprise Fe-Cr coprecipitate hydroxides Cr(III), Fe-Mn oxide-bound Cr(III), organic matter-bound Cr(III) and residual Cr(III). Their distribution depends on the types of reductants present in the soil.

Microbial electrochemical Cr(VI) reduction in a soil continuous flow system

Microbial electrochemical technologies represent innovative approaches to contaminated soil and groundwater remediation and provide a flexible framework for removing organic and inorganic contaminants by integrating electrochemical and biological techniques. To simulate in situ microbial electrochemical treatment of groundwater plumes, this study investigates Cr(VI) reduction within a bioelectrochemical continuous flow (BECF) system equipped with soil-buried electrodes, comparing it to abiotic and open-circuit controls. Continuous-flow systems were tested with two chromium-contaminated solutions (20-50 mg Cr(VI)/L). Additional nutrients, buffers, or organic substrates were introduced during the tests in the systems. With an initial Cr(VI) concentration of 20 mg/L, 1.00 mg Cr(VI)/(L day) bioelectrochemical removal rate in the BECF system was observed, corresponding to 99.5% removal within nine days. At the end of the test with 50 mg Cr(VI)/L (156 days), the residual Cr(VI) dissolved concentration was two orders of magnitude lower than that in the open circuit control, achieving 99.9% bioelectrochemical removal in the BECF. Bacteria belonging to the orders Solirubrobacteriales, Gaiellales, Bacillales, Gemmatimonadales, and Propionibacteriales characterized the bacterial communities identified in soil samples; differently, Burkholderiales, Mycobacteriales, Cytophagales, Rhizobiales, and Caulobacterales characterized the planktonic bacterial communities. The complexity of the microbial community structure suggests the involvement of different microorganisms and strategies in the bioelectrochemical removal of chromium. In the absence of organic carbon, microbial electrochemical removal of hexavalent chromium was found to be the most efficient way to remove Cr(VI), and it may represent an innovative and sustainable approach for soil and groundwater remediation. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2024;20:2033-2049. © 2024 The Author(s). Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC).

Simultaneous natural attenuation of Cr(VI) and nitrate in the hyporheic zone sediments from an upstream tributary of the Jinsha River in the Sichuan Basin

The coexistence of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) and nitrate (NO3-) in groundwater and surface water presents a considerable challenge for the natural attenuation of these two contaminants because their interactions in nature remain contentious. This study investigated the interplay between Cr(VI) and NO3- in hyporheic zone (HZ) sediments by integrating Cr(VI) reduction kinetics, NO3- transformation, microbial community structure, and a three-rate model. The concurrent natural attenuation of Cr(VI) and NO3- in the sediments was significantly influenced by their initial concentrations and redox conditions. The reduction of low concentrations of Cr(VI) (37.1 and 96.2 μM) was slightly enhanced by NO3-, while inhibitory effects were observed at high concentrations of Cr(VI) (200.0 μM). However, except for an initial low concentration of Cr(VI) (37.1 μM) and NO3- (450 μM), the reduction of NO3- was adversely affected by Cr(VI). The reduction rates and efficiencies of Cr(VI) and NO3- were noticeably lower under aerobic conditions than under anaerobic conditions. This phenomenon can be attributed to the presence of O2, which decreased the selectivity of sediments-associated Fe(II) towards Cr(VI) and NO3- and induced alterations in the microbial community structure, leading to subsequent changes in NO3- transformation. Furthermore, the three-rate model represents a robust approach for elucidating the reduction of Cr(VI) in the presence of co-contaminants, such as NO3- contamination under diverse redox conditions. This study provides further insights into the interaction mechanism between Cr(VI) and NO3- within the HZ, necessitating the consideration of the microbial toxicity of Cr(VI) and electron competition among Cr(VI), NO3-, and O2.

Mechanisms and influential factors of soil chromium long-term stability by an accelerated aging system after chemical stabilization

Chemical stabilization is one of the most widely used remediation strategies for chromium (Cr)-contaminated soils by reducing Cr(VI) to Cr(III), and its performance is affected by human and natural processes in a prolonged period, challenging long-term Cr stability. In this work, we established a method for evaluating the long-term effectiveness of remediation of Cr-contaminated soils, and developed an accelerated aging system to simultaneously simulate acid rain leaching and freeze-thaw cycles. The mechanisms and influencing factors of long-term (50-year) change in soil Cr speciation were unravelled after stabilization with Metafix®. Chemical stabilization remarkably decreased the contents of Cr(VI)soil, Crtotal-leach and Cr(VI)leach, among which the removal rate of Cr(VI) in soil was up to 89.70 %, but it also aggravated soil Cr instability. During the accelerated aging process, Crtotal-leach change rates in chemically stabilized soil samples were 0.0462-0.0587 mg/(L·a), and soil Cr became instable after 20-year accelerated aging. The proportion of Cr bound to organic matter and residual Cr increased in soil, and exchangeable Cr decreased. Linear combination fitting results of XANES also showed that Cr(VI) and Cr3+ were transformed into OM-Cr(III), Fh-Cr(III) and CrFeO3 after restoration. During the accelerated aging process, acid rain leaching activated Cr(III) and dissolved Cr(VI), whereas freeze-thaw cycle mainly affected OM-Cr. Chemical stabilization, acid rain leaching and aging time were the major factors influencing the stability of soil Cr, and the freeze-thaw cycle promoted the influence of acid rain leaching. This study provided a new way to explore the long-term effectiveness and instability mechanisms at Cr-contaminated site after chemical stabilization.

Effects of nZVI on the migration and availability of Cr(VI) in soils under simulated acid rain leaching conditions

Hexavalent chromium, Cr(VI), is a ubiquitous toxic metal that can be reduced to Cr(III) by nano-zero-valent iron (nZVI). Finding out effects of continuous rainfall leaching on the Cr(VI) release and availability remains a problem, needing to be addressed. Whether the Cr(VI) reduction by nZVI and continuous rainfall leaching lead to localized heterogeneity in soil is unclear. Therefore, two in situ high-resolution (HR) techniques of the diffusive gradients in thin-films (DGT) and planar optode were combined with ex situ sampling experiments here. Results demonstrate that nZVI decreased Cr(VI) leaching by 5.60-8.50 % compared to control soils. DGT-measured concentrations of Cr(VI), CDGT-Cr(VI), ranged from 7.31 to 19.4 μg L-1 in the control soils, increasing with depth while CDGT-Cr(VI) in nZVI-treated soils (2.41-6.18 μg L-1) decreased or remained stable with depth. However, simulated acid-rain leaching increases CDGT-Cr(VI) by 1.61-fold in nZVI-treated soils, negatively affecting the remediation. DGT measurements in bulk soils using disc devices are better at capturing the change of Cr(VI) availability at different conditions, whereas 2D-HR DGT mappings did not characterize significant mobilization of Cr(VI) at the micro-scale. These findings emphasize the importance of monitoring Cr(VI) release and availability in remediated soil under acid-rain leaching conditions for effective environment management.

Remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil by CS/PPy coupling with Microbacterium sp. YL3

In this research, a new material, chitosan/polypyrrole (CS/PPy), was synthesized and linked with the Cr(VI)-reducing bacterial strain YL3 to treat Cr(VI)-polluted soil. The findings demonstrated that the synergistic application of strain YL3 and CS/PPy achieved the greatest reduction (99.6 %). During the remediation process, CS/PPy served as a mass-storage and sustained release agent in the soil, which initially decreased the toxic effects of high concentrations of Cr(VI) on strain YL3, thereby enhancing the Cr(VI) reduction efficiency of strain YL3. These combined effects significantly mitigated Cr(VI) stress in the soil and restored enzyme activities. Furthermore, wheat growth in the treated soil also significantly improved. High-throughput sequencing of the microorganisms in the treated soil revealed that CS/PPy was not only effective at removing Cr(VI) but also at preserving the original microbial diversity of the soil. This suggests that the combined treatment using strain YL3 and CS/PPy could rehabilitate Cr(VI)-contaminated soil, positioning CS/PPy as a promising composite material for future bioremediation efforts in Cr(VI)-contaminated soils.

A META analysis on the efficacy of functional materials for soil chromium remediation

Metallic chromium pollution in soil is widespread, which aroused intensive research in recent decades. In mainstream research, most studies use materials with a reducing ability to adsorb and reduce hexavalent chromium. However, comprehensive analyses and systematic verifications of these different materials are scarce. Therefore, this study conducted a meta-analysis of relevant papers published from 2013 to October 2024 to compare and analyze the performance and usage conditions of some common materials, such as iron-based materials, mineral inorganic materials, organic materials, and layered double hydroxide materials. We synthesized 31 papers for 186 pairwise comparisons and selected the Standardized Mean Difference (SMD) as the appropriate effect size for mean-to-mean comparisons. Fe-based materials had the most stable performance based on its numerous data support, while organic materials had the worst performance. The difference in performance between inorganic mineral materials was the greatest, which was closely related to the selection of components. The difference in the effectiveness of inorganic materials was the greatest, which was closely related to the selection of components and there was room for further improvement. Through further analysis of the impact of environmental factors on material performance, it can be concluded that the effect of the material was better under alkaline, non-sandy, low organic matter, and high CEC soil conditions.

Optimizing Typha biochar with phosphoric acid modification and ferric chloride impregnation for hexavalent chromium remediation in water and soil

Considering the persistent and covert nature of heavy metal soil contamination, the sustainable development of ecological environments and food safety is at significant risk. Our study focuses on remediating soils contaminated with chromium (Cr); we introduce an advanced remediation material, iron oxide phosphoric acid-loaded activated biochar (HFBC), synthesized through pyrolysis. This HFBC displays greater microporosity, fewer impurities, and enhanced efficiency for the remediation process. Our research utilized a comprehensive set of analytical techniques, including Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR), and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS), alongside adsorption studies to elucidate the Cr removal mechanism. The effectiveness of HFBC in remediation was influenced by several factors: the pH level, dosage of HFBC, the initial concentration of Cr, and the ambient temperature. Our results indicated an optimal chromium (VI) adsorption capacity of 55.5 mg/g by HFBC at a pH of 6.0 and a temperature of 25 °C, with the process adhering to the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and the Langmuir adsorption isotherm, thus suggesting spontaneity in the uptake method. Moreover, this mechanism encompasses both adsorption and reduction reactions. Using HFBC in pot experiments with cabbage indicated not only an increase in soil pH and cation exchange capacity (CEC), but also a surge in bacterial community abundance. Significant reductions in bioavailable chromium were also recorded. Interestingly, HFBC addition bolstered the growth of cabbage, while concurrently diminishing chromium accumulation within the plant, particularly notable as the HFBC application rate increased. In summation, the HFBC produced in our study has demonstrated convincing efficacy in removing chromium from aqueous solutions and soil. Moreover, the positive agronomic implications of its use, such as enhanced plant growth and reduced heavy metal uptake by plants, indicate its high potential for operational value in the domain of environmental remediation of heavy metals.

Influence of elevated temperature on the species and mobility of chromium in ferrous sulfate-amended contaminated soil

Ferrous sulfate (FeSO4) combined with acid pretreatment is usually employed to remediate contaminated soils containing Cr(VI). However, the long-term efficiency of this stabilization method is important for its sustainability. In this study, a gradient temperature-elevating exposure test was employed to investigate the stability of Cr in FeSO4-remediated soil when exposed to elevated temperatures (40 °C, 120 °C, and 500 °C), possibly caused by hot weather and/or wildfires. The results of chemical extraction and X-ray absorption near edge structure spectroscopy (XANES) showed that the Cr(VI) in contaminated soil was successfully transformed to Cr(III) after stabilization, resulting in the dramatic decrease of water-leachable Cr(VI). The stabilization efficiency was further improved under 40 °C treatment after 30 days. Subsequently, the 120 °C treatment (7 days) had relatively little effect on the Cr speciation and mobility in soils. However, even one day of 500 °C calcination resulted in the deterioration of stabilization efficiency, and the water-leachable Cr(VI) re-increased and became higher than the Chinese environmental standards (total Cr 15 mg/L, Cr(VI) 5 mg/L) for the classification of hazardous solid wastes. XANES results reflected that heating at 500 °C facilitate the formation of Cr2O3, which was mainly caused by thermal decomposition and dehydration of Cr(OH)3 in the soil. Besides, the transformation of Cr species resulted in the enhanced association of Cr with the most stable residual fraction (88.3%-91.6%) in soil. Based on chemical extraction results, it was suggested that the oxidation of Cr(III) to Cr(VI) contributed to the re-increased mobility of Cr(VI) in soil. However, the XANES results showed that almost no significant re-oxidization of Cr(III) to Cr(VI) happened after heating at 500 °C, which was probably caused by XANES linear combination fits (LCF) uncertainties. Moreover, the changes in soil properties, including a rise in pH to a slightly alkaline range and/or the decomposition of organic matter, possibly contributed to the enhanced mobility of Cr(VI) in soil. This study contributes to clarifying the mobility and transformation of Cr in contaminated soils and provides a support for the sustainable management of remediated soils.

Improving the practicality of recombinant Escherichia coli biosensor in detecting trace Cr(VI) by modifying the cryogenic storage conditions of biosensors and applying simple pretreatment

Hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) is a global environmental pollutant. To reduce the risk caused by Cr(VI), a simple, accurate, reproducible, and inexpensive method for quantifying Cr(VI) in water and soil should be developed. In this study, three types of recombinant Escherichia coli biosensors (namely T7-lux-E. coli, T3-lux-E. coli, and SP6-lux-E. coli biosensor) containing promoters (T7, T3, and SP6), chromate-sensing regulator chrB, and the reporter gene luxAB were constructed. This study investigated the effects of cryogenic freezing temperature and time on trace Cr(VI) measurement by using recombinant E. coli biosensors. The results indicated that the activity of thawed frozen SP6-lux-E. coli cells stored at -20 °C for 270 days did not differ from that of freshly prepared cells. Turbidity and conductivity in water samples and organic matter in soil interfered with Cr(VI) measurement using the biosensor. The SP6-lux-E. coli biosensor exhibited a wide measurement range and a low deviation of <5% for measuring Cr(VI) in various Cr(VI)-contaminated water and soil samples and required only a simple pretreatment or extraction process even after 270-day storage at -20 °C. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to report the use of recombinant biosensors for accurately measuring Cr(VI) in both water and soil.

Minor chromium passivation of S-ZVI enhanced the long-term dechlorination performance of trichlorethylene: Effects of corrosion and passivation on the reactivity and selectivity

The corrosion and surface passivation of sulfidized zero-valent iron (S-ZVI) by common groundwater ions and contaminants are considered to be the most challenging aspects in the application of S-ZVI for remediation of chlorinated contaminants. This study investigated the impacts of corrosive chloride (Cl-) and passivation of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) on the long-term reactivity, selectivity, corrosion behavior, and physicochemical properties during the 60-day aging process of S-ZVI. Although the co-existing of Cl- promoted the initial reactivity of S-ZVI, the rapid consumption of Fe° content shortened the reactive lifetime owing to the insufficient electron capacity. Severe passivation by Cr(VI) (30 mg L-1) preserved the Fe° content but significantly interfered with the reductive sulfur species, resulting in an increase in electron transfer resistance. In comparison, minor passivated S-ZVI (5.0 mg L-1 Cr(VI)) inhibited the hydrogen evolution while concurrently mitigating the further oxidation of the reductive iron and sulfur species, which significantly enhanced the long-term reactivity and selectivity of S-ZVI. Furthermore, the enhancement effect of minor passivation could be detected in the aging processes of one-step, two-step, and mechanochemically synthesized S-ZVI particles with different S/Fe ratios and precursors, which further verified the advantages of minor passivation. This observation is inspirable for the development of innovative strategies for environmental remediation by S-ZVI-based materials.

Phase transformation of Cr(VI) host-mineral driven by citric acid-aided mechanochemical approach for advanced remediation of chromium ore processing residue-contaminated soil

The slow release of Cr(VI) from chromium ore processing residue-contaminated soil (COPR-soil) poses a significant environmental and health risk, yet advanced remediation techniques are still insufficient. Here, the slow-release behavior of Cr(VI) in COPR-soil is observed and attributed to the embedded Cr(VI) in the lattice of vaterite due to the isomeric substitution of CrO42- for CO32-. A citric acid-aided mechanochemical approach with FeS2/ZVI as reductive material was developed and found to be highly effective in remediating COPR-soil. Almost all Cr(VI) in COPR-soil, including Cr(VI) embedded in the minerals, are reduced with a reduction efficiency of 99.94%. Cr(VI) reduction kinetics indicate that the Cr(VI) reduction rate constant in the presence of citric acid was 4.8 times higher compared to its absence. According to the Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction (XRD), and Electron Probe X-ray Micro-Analyzer (EPMA) analysis, the reduction of Cr(VI) embedded in vaterite was mainly attributed to the citric acid-induced protonation effect. That is, under the protonation effect, the embedded Cr(VI) could be released from vaterite through its phase transformation to calcite, whose affinity to Cr(VI) is low. While the reduction of released Cr(VI) could be promoted due to the complexation of citric acid with disulfide groups on FeS2/ZVI. The results of long-term stability tests demonstrated that the remediated COPR-soil exhibited excellent long-term stability, which may also be associated with improved utilization of available carbon and electron donors by the Cr(VI) reducing bacteria (Proteobacteria)-dominated microbial community in the presence of citric acid, thereby promoting to establish a stable reducing microenvironment. Collectively, these findings will further our understanding of the reduction remediation of COPR-soil, especially in the case of Cr(VI) embedded in minerals.

Enhanced remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil by modified zero-valent iron with oxalic acid on biochar

Hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) is carcinogenic and widely presented in soil. In this study, modified zero-valent iron (ZVI) with oxalic acid on biochar (OA-ZVI/BC) was prepared using wet ball milling method for the remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil. Microscopic characterizations showed that ZVI were distributed on the biochar uniformly and confirmed the enhanced interface interaction between biochar and ZVI by wet ball milling. Electrochemical analysis indicated the strong electron transfer ability and enhanced corrosion behavior of OA-ZVI/BC. Moreover, inhibitory efficiencies of Cr(VI) removal with the addition of 1,10-phenanthroline suggested abundant Fe2+ generation in OA-ZVI/BC, which might facilitate the reduction of Cr(VI) to Cr(III). Theory calculation further demonstrated the ZVI modified by oxalic acid was more susceptible to solid-solid interfacial reactions with Cr(VI), and more electrons were transferred to Cr(VI). When applied to Cr(VI)-contaminated soil, OA-ZVI/BC could passivate 96.7 % total Cr(VI) and maintained for 90 days. The toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) and simple based extraction test (SBET) were used to evaluate the leaching toxicity and bioaccessibility of Cr(VI), respectively. The TCLP-Cr(VI) decreased to 0.11 mg·L-1 after OA-ZVI/BC treatment, much lower than that of soils with ZVI/BC and OA-ZVI remediation (1.5 mg·L-1 and 4.1 mg·L-1). The bioaccessibility of Cr(VI) reduced by 93.5 % after 3-month remediation. Sequential extraction showed that Cr fractions in the soil after OA-ZVI/BC remediation was converted from acetic acid-extractable (HOAc-extractable) to more stable forms (e.g., residual and oxidizable forms). Benefiting from the synergies of oxalic acid, biochar and wet ball milling, OA-ZVI/BC exhibited an excellent performance on the remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil, whose mechanisms involved adsorption, reduction (Fe0/Fe2+, Fe2+/Fe3+) and co-precipitation. This study herein develops a promising ZVI technology in the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soil.

Remediation materials for the immobilization of hexavalent chromium in contaminated soil: Preparation, applications, and mechanisms

Hexavalent chromium is a toxic metal that can induce severe chromium contamination of soil, posing a potential risk to human health and ecosystems. In recent years, the immobilization of Cr(VI) using remediation materials including inorganic materials, organic materials, microbial agents, and composites has exhibited great potential in remediating Cr(VI)-contaminated soil owing to the environmental-friendliness, short period, simple operation, low cost, applicability on an industrial scale, and high efficiency of these materials. Therefore, a systematical summary of the current progress on various remediation materials is essential. This work introduces the production (sources) of remediation materials and examines their characteristics in detail. Additionally, a critical summary of recent research on the utilization of remediation materials for the stabilization of Cr(VI) in the soil is provided, together with an evaluation of their remediation efficiencies toward Cr(VI). The influences of remediation material applications on soil physicochemical properties, microbial community structure, and plant growth are summarized. The immobilization mechanisms of remediation materials toward Cr(VI) in the soil are illuminated. Importantly, this study evaluates the feasibility of each remediation material application for Cr(VI) remediation. The latest knowledge on the development of remediation materials for the immobilization of Cr(VI) in the soil is also presented. Overall, this review will provide a reference for the development of remediation materials and their application in remediating Cr(VI)-contaminated soil.

Addressing the issue of surface mechanisms and competitive effects in Cr(VI) reductive-adsorption on tin-hydroxyapatite in the presence of co-ions

Our group recently proposed an innovative sustainable reductant-adsorbent material, tin(II)-hydroxyapatite (Sn/HAP, ca. 10 wt% Sn) for the interfacial Cr(VI) reductive adsorption process. In this study, Cr(VI) removal capacity was evaluated in multi-component solutions containing representative background ions (i.e., CaCl2, Ca(NO3)2, MgSO4, Na2SO4, Fe(NO3)3, AlCl3, Zn(NO3)2, or Mn(NO3)2). Sn/HAP was able to reduce Cr(VI) with complete Cr3+ adsorption on HAP surface, except in the presence of Fe3+ and Al3+ ions. Some metal ions co-existing in solution, such as Fe3+, Al3+, Zn2+, and Mn2+, were also adsorbed on HAP surface. Reuse experiments of the Sn/HAP sample, up to 7 runs, resulted in a total amount of reduced Cr(VI) of ca. 15-18 mg g-1. Fast kinetics of Cr(VI) reductive adsorption at 25 °C in a multi-metal component solution was observed. The pseudo-second order model was in excellent agreement with the experimental kinetic data, leading to a rate constant (k25°C) value of ca. 30 M-1 s-1. The collection of adsorption isotherms of Cr3+ and Fe3+, together with TEM-EDX analysis permitted the unveiling of competitive adsorption phenomena between metal ions. The obtained results demonstrate that Sn/HAP could be an efficient material for the removal of hexavalent chromium in aqueous solutions containing high concentrations of inorganic impurities.

Effective Cr(VI) reduction and immobilization in chromite ore processing residue (COPR) contaminated soils by ferrous sulfate and digestate: A comparative investigation with typical reducing agents

Chemical reduction combined with microbial stabilization is a green and efficient method for the remediation of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) contaminated soil. In this study, the combination of ferrous sulfate with kitchen waste digestate was applied to reduce and immobilize Cr(VI) in chromite ore processing residue (COPR) contaminated soils, and systematically evaluated the remediation performance of Cr(VI) compared with several typical reducing agents (i.e., ferrous sulfate, zero valent iron, sodium thiosulfate, ferrous sulfide, and calcium polysulfide). The results showed that the combination of ferrous sulfate and digestate had superior advantages of a lower dosage of reducing agent and a long-term remediation effect compared to other single chemical reductants. Under an Fe(II):Cr(VI) molar ratio of 3:1% and 4% digestate (wt), the content of Cr(VI) in the soil decreased to 5.07 mg/kg after 60 days of remediation. Meanwhile, the leaching concentrations of Cr(VI) were below detection limit, which can meet the hazardous waste toxicity leaching standard. The risk level of Cr pollution was decreased from very high risk to low risk. The X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) results further demonstrated that the combined treatments were beneficial to Cr(VI) reduction and stabilization. The abundance of bacteria with Cr(VI) reducing ability was higher than other treatments. Moreover, the high abundance of carbon and nitrogen metabolism in the combined treatments demonstrated that the addition of digestate was beneficial to the recovery and flourishing of Cr(VI)-reducing related microorganisms in COPR contaminated soils. This work provided an alternative way on Cr(VI) remediation in COPR contaminated soils.

Cr(VI) Reduction and Fe(II) Regeneration by Penicillium oxalicum SL2-Enhanced Nanoscale Zero-Valent Iron

Nanoscale zero-valent iron (nZVI) faces significant challenges in Cr(VI) remediation through aggregation and passivation. This study identified a Cr(VI)-resistant filamentous fungus (Penicillium oxalicum SL2) for nZVI activation and elucidated the synergistic mechanism in chromium remediation. P. oxalicum SL2 and nZVI synergistically and effectively removed Cr(VI), mainly by extracellular nonenzymatic reduction (89.1%). P. oxalicum SL2 exhibited marked iron precipitate solubilization and Fe(II) regeneration capabilities. The existence of the Fe(II)-Cr(V)-oxalate complex (HCrFeC₄O₉) indicated that in addition to directly reducing Cr(VI), iron ions generated by nZVI stimulated Cr(VI) reduction by organic acids secreted by P. oxalicum SL2. RNA sequencing and bioinformatics analysis revealed that P. oxalicum SL2 inhibited phosphate transport channels to suppress Cr(VI) transport, facilitated iron and siderophore transport to store Fe, activated the glyoxylate cycle to survive harsh environments, and enhanced organic acid and riboflavin secretion to reduce Cr(VI). Cr(VI) exposure also stimulated the antioxidative system, promoting catalase activity and maintaining the intracellular thiol/disulfide balance. Cr(VI)/Fe(III) reductases played crucial roles in the intracellular reduction of chromium and iron, while nZVI decreased cellular oxidative stress and alleviated Cr(VI) toxicity to P. oxalicum SL2. Overall, the P. oxalicum SL2-nZVI synergistic system is a promising approach for regenerating Fe(II) while reducing Cr(VI).

The occurrence of "yellowing" phenomenon and its main driving factors after the remediation of chromium (Cr)-contaminated soils: A literature review

Chromium (Cr) is a highly toxic element, which is widely present in environment due to industrial activities. One of most applicable technique to clean up Cr pollution is chemical reduction. However, the Cr(VI) concentration in soil increases again after remediation, and meanwhile the yellow soil would appear, which is commonly called as "yellowing" phenomenon. To date, the reason behind the phenomenon has been disputed for decades. This study aimed to introduce the possible "yellowing" mechanism and the influencing factors based on the extensive literature review. In this work, the concept of "yellowing" phenomenon was explained, and the most potential reasons include the reoxidation of manganese (Mn) oxides and mass transfer were summarized. Based on the reported finding and results, the large area of "yellowing" is likely to be caused by the re-migration of Cr(VI), since it could not sufficiently contact with the reductant under the effects of the mass transfer. In addition, other driving factors also control the occurrence of "yellowing" phenomenon. This review provides valuable reference for the academic peers participating in the Cr-contaminated sites remediation.

Chromium (III) and chromium (VI) removal and organic matter interaction with nanofiltration

Chromium (Cr) is a toxic inorganic contaminant for drinking water, in which the concentration has to be controlled for human health and safety. Cr retention was investigated with stirred cell experiments using sulphonated polyethersulfone nanofiltration (NF) membranes of different molecular weight cut-off (MWCO). Cr(III) and Cr(VI) retention follow the order of the MWCO of the studied NF membranes; HY70-720 Da > HY50-1000 Da > HY10-3000 Da with a pH dependency, especially for Cr(III). The importance of the charge exclusion was highlighted when Cr(OH)₄^- (for Cr(III)) and CrO₄^2- (for Cr(VI)) was the predominant species in the feed solution. In presence of organic matter, namely humic acid (HA), Cr(III) retention increased by 60 %, while no influence of HA was observed for Cr(VI). HA did not induce major modifications on the membrane surface charge for these membranes. Solute-solute interaction, in particular Cr(III)-HA complexation, was the responsible mechanism for the increase in Cr(III) retention. This was confirmed by asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation, coupled with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (FFFF-ICP-MS) analysis. Cr(III)-HA complexation was significant at HA concentrations as low as 1 mgC/L. The chosen NF membranes were able to achieve the EU guideline (25 μg/L) for Cr in drinking water for a feed concentration of 250 μg/L.

Reductive transformation of Cr(VI) in contaminated soil by polyphenols: The role of gallic and tannic acid

Polyphenols, as an important category of natural organics, are ubiquitous in plants and structurally diverse. Batch experiments were conducted to investigate the role of natural polyphenol, such as gallic acid (GA) and tannic acid (TA), in the biochemical behavior of Cr(VI) in soil media. GA and TA can effectively convert Cr(VI) to Cr(III) under neutral conditions (pH 7.0). However, there are significant differences in the transport, leaching toxicity, and bioavailability of reduced Cr(III) between the two systems. UV-vis spectra, chromium (Cr) mass balance, speciation distribution, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy were used to explore the intrinsic mechanisms of Cr(VI) reduction and (im)mobilization in the presence of GA or TA. Results showed that the reduction of Cr(VI) by GA was accompanied by poor immobilization of reduced Cr(III), especially at high GA concentrations (4-10 g/L), which was associated with the formation of soluble Cr(III) complexes. After treatment with 4 g/L GA, 51.49 ± 3.04% of the Cr in GA system was mobilized as complexes into aqueous phase. In contrast, the reduction of Cr(VI) and the subsequent precipitation of reduced Cr(III) was dominant in the TA system. After treatment with 4 g/L TA, 97.24 ± 0.31% of the total Cr in the TA system was immobilized into soil phase and transformed into more stable fractions. Our findings provide new insights into how natural organics shape the fate and transport of Cr in soils, which also have substantial implications for the development of Cr sequestration technology.

Stabilization and strengthening of chromium(VI)-contaminated soil via magnesium ascorbyl phosphate (MAP) and phytase addition

Cr(VI) contamination of soil threatens the environment and reduces soil strength. Therefore, both Cr(VI) stabilization and soil reinforcement should be considered in site remediation for future construction. This study investigated a biochemical treatment process using magnesium ascorbyl phosphate (MAP) and phytase. MAP was hydrolyzed via phytase catalysis to produce ascorbic acid (AA) and MgHPO₄·3H₂O precipitation. The AA reduced Cr(VI) into low-toxic Cr(III), which precipitated as Cr(OH)₃ and CrPO₄. More than 90% of the 500 mg/kg Cr(VI) in soil was reduced by 5% MAP (wt% of soil) and 1% phytase (vol/vol of soil water) doses at the geotechnically optimal soil moisture content of 16.8%. The MgHPO₄·3H₂O precipitates filled soil pores and enhanced the unconfined compression strength of treated soil by more than two times. This research reports a novel and practical enzymatically induced phosphate precipitation process for the remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil.

Synergistic effect of sulfidated nano zerovalent iron and proton-buffering montmorillonite in reductive immobilization of alkaline Cr(VI)-contaminated soil

Effective remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil with strong alkalinity and high Cr(VI) concentration is a severe challenge. Herein, a proton-buffering montmorillonite-supported sulfidated nano zerovalent iron (nFeS/Fe⁰@H-Mt) was developed for remediation of alkaline Cr(VI)-contaminated soil. The reductive efficiencies of water-soluble Cr(VI) reached 99.7%, 99.3% and 99.8% in three tested soils with initial concentrations of 439.6, 3307.5 and 4626.7 mg kg^-1, respectively, after 15 d of nFeS/Fe⁰@H-Mt treatment. Further speciation analyses demonstrated most available Cr species (exchangeable and carbonate-bound Cr) were transformed into more stable Cr species. The leachable Cr(VI) and total Cr obtained by toxicity leaching procedures decreased to extremely low levels and maintained long-term stability for 120 d. Such superior reductive immobilization performance of FeS/Fe⁰@H-Mt was attributed to the synergistic effect of sulfidated nano zerovalent iron and proton-buffering montmorillonite, which induced the coordination of proton donation and electron transfer. The proton-buffering montmorillonite (H-Mt) could prevent the aggregation of nanoparticles and provide protons to accelerate the corrosion of Fe⁰. In addition, the FeS component improved electron selectivity and facilitated electron transfer of Fe⁰ to Cr(VI). Our study demonstrated that the coordination of proton donation and electron transfer significantly enhanced the Cr(VI) reduction under the alkaline condition thus leading to effective remediation of alkaline Cr(VI)-contaminated soil.

Remediation and its biological responses to Cd(II)-Cr(VI)-Pb(II) multi-contaminated soil by supported nano zero-valent iron composites

Multi-metal contaminated soil has received extensive attention. The biochar and bentonite-supported nano zero-valent iron (nZVI) (BC-BE-nZVI) composite was synthesized in this study by the liquid-phase reduction method. Subsequently, the BC-BE-nZVI composite was applied to immobilize cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), and lead (Pb) in simulated contaminated soil. The simultaneous immobilization efficiencies of Cd, Cr(VI), Cr_total, and Pb were achieved at 70.95 %, 100 %, 86.21 %, and 100 %, respectively. In addition, mobility and bioavailabilities of Cd, Cr, and Pb were significantly decreased and the risk of iron toxicity was reduced. Stabilized metal species in the contaminated soil (e.g., Cd(OH)₂, Cd-Fe-(OH)₂, Cr_xFe_1-xOOH, Cr_xFe_1-x(OH)₃, PbO, PbCrO₄, and Pb(OH)₂) were formed after the BC-BE-nZVI treatment. Thus, the immobilization mechanisms of Cd, Cr, and Pb, including adsorption, reduction, co-precipitation, and complexation co-exist with the metals. More importantly, bacterial richness, bacterial diversity, soil enzyme activities (dehydrogenase, urease, and fluorescein diacetate hydrolase), and microbial activity were enhanced by applying the BC-BE-nZVI composite, thus increasing the soil metabolic function. Over all, this work applied a promising procedure for remediating multi- metal contaminated soil by using the BC-BE-nZVI composite.

Heavy metal stabilization remediation in polluted soils with stabilizing materials: a review

The remediation of soil contaminated by heavy metals has long been a concern of academics. This is due to the fact that heavy metals discharged into the environment as a result of natural and anthropogenic activities may have detrimental consequences for human health, the ecological environment, the economy, and society. Metal stabilization has received considerable attention and has shown to be a promising soil remediation option among the several techniques for the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soils. This review discusses various stabilizing materials, including inorganic materials like clay minerals, phosphorus-containing materials, calcium silicon materials, metals, and metal oxides, as well as organic materials like manure, municipal solid waste, and biochar, for the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soils. Through diverse remediation processes such as adsorption, complexation, precipitation, and redox reactions, these additives efficiently limit the biological effectiveness of heavy metals in soils. It should also be emphasized that the effectiveness of metal stabilization is influenced by soil pH, organic matter content, amendment type and dosage, heavy metal species and contamination level, and plant variety. Furthermore, a comprehensive overview of the methods for evaluating the effectiveness of heavy metal stabilization based on soil physicochemical properties, heavy metal morphology, and bioactivity has also been provided. At the same time, it is critical to assess the stability and timeliness of the heavy metals' long-term remedial effect. Finally, the priority should be on developing novel, efficient, environmentally friendly, and economically feasible stabilizing agents, as well as establishing a systematic assessment method and criteria for analyzing their long-term effects.

Preparation of a novel iron oxychloride (FeOCl) auxiliary electrode in promoting electrokinetic remediation of Cr(VI) contaminated soil: An experimental and DFT calculation analysis

The utilization of auxiliary electrode can improve substantially the electrokinetic remediation efficiency of heavy metal contaminated soil. The increase in the auxiliary electrode performance is the key to further promote the electrokinetic remediation efficiency. In this study, two kinds of auxiliary electrodes, pure FeOCl and doped FeOCl with W and S, were prepared and used in the electrokinetic remediation of Cr(VI) contaminated soil. The system equipped with the auxiliary electrode doped FeOCl brought more stable system current (202 mA) and more uniform electric field than blank group (130 mA). The reduction rate of Cr(VI) was increased by 50% due to the presence of Fe²⁺ and S^2-. The accelerating migration of ions by auxiliary electrode was responsible for the improvement in electrokinetic remediation efficiency. Density functional theory (DFT) calculation showed that Cl vacancy formation energies of pure FeOCl, S-doped FeOCl (S/FeOCl) and W-doped FeOCl (W/FeOCl) were 1.29, 1.15 and 1.49 eV respectively, and the ion diffusion barriers were 0.093, 0.099 and 0.148 eV respectively. Calculation results indicated that the doping of S was conducive to the diffusion of Cl ions, and the bonding of W-Cl was stronger than Fe-Cl. The charging and discharging process of auxiliary electrode became easier due to the formation of lower vacancy in S-doped FeOCl, which could bring a higher current for the electrokinetic remediation system. The electrochemical performance of FeOCl doped with W and S was improved obviously. This study provided a further explanation for the positive role of auxiliary electrode in electrokinetic remediation system.

External sodium acetate improved Cr(VI) stabilization in a Cr-spiked soil during chemical-microbial reduction processes: Insights into Cr(VI) reduction performance, microbial community and metabolic functions

Interest combined chemical and microbial reduction for Cr(VI) remediation in contaminated sites has greatly increased. However, the effect of external carbon sources on Cr(VI) reduction during chemical-microbial reduction processes has not been studied. Therefore, in this study, the role of external sodium acetate (SA) in improving Cr(VI) reduction and stabilization in a representative Cr(VI)-spiked soils was systemically investigated. The results of batch experiments suggested that the soil Cr(VI) content declined from 1000 mg/kg to 2.6-5.1 mg/kg at 1-5 g C/kg SA supplemented within 15 days of reaction. The external addition of SA resulted in a significant increase in the relative abundances of Cr(VI)-reducing microorganisms, such as Tissierella, Proteiniclasticum and Proteiniclasticum. The relative abundance of Tissierella increased from 9.1% to 29.8% with the SA treatment at 5 g C/kg soil, which was the main contributors to microbial Cr(VI) reduction. Redundancy analysis indicated that pH and SA were the predominant factors affecting the microbial community in the SA treatments at 2 g C/kg soil and 5 g C/kg soil. Functional prediction suggested that the addition of SA had a positive effect on the metabolism of key substances involved in Cr(VI) microbial reduction. This work provides new insightful guidance on Cr(VI) remediation in contaminated soils.

Enhanced elimination of Cr(VI) from aqueous media by polyethyleneimine modified corn straw biochar supported sulfide nanoscale zero valent iron: Performance and mechanism

A novel polyethyleneimine modified corn straw biochar supported sulfide nanoscale zero-valent iron (S-nZVI@PBC) was developed to enhance Cr(VI) removal from aqueous media. The characteristics of morphology, chemical composition, and functional groups of S-nZVI@PBC, as well as its kinetics and mechanism for Cr(VI) removal were explored. Characterization verified S-nZVI was successfully loaded onto PEI modified biochar. The adsorption process was well represented pseudo-second-order model (R² = 0.990) and Langmuir isotherm model (R² = 0.962), indicating it was a monolayer chemical adsorption process. The Cr(VI) removal was affected by pH and achieved the maximum when pH = 3.0, which may be ascribed to the better corrosion of nZVI and release of Fe(II) from the S-nZVI@PBC in acidic condition. The primary mechanisms were adsorption, reduction, and co-precipitation. S-nZVI@PBC exhibited higher stability and reusability than nZVI, which makes it more promising in environmental application. Overall, S-nZVI@PBC is of great potential for treating Cr(VI)-containing wastewater.

Insights into the evolution of Cr(VI) species in long-term hexavalent chromium contaminated soil

Compare to the content of Cr(VI), the distribution of specific Cr(VI) species in soil is rarely paid attention to, which may lead to an inaccurate environmental risk assessment of Cr(VI) contaminated soil or inability to meet stringent requirement for soil remediation. Herein, to reveal the primary mechanisms and factors controlling the evolution of Cr(VI) species in soil, the distribution of Cr(VI) and Cr(III) species in soils with different particle sizes and textures was systematically investigated by using a modified sequential extraction procedure and spectroscopy characterizations (e.g., SEM-EDS mapping). The results show that a significant proportion of Cr(VI) can be captured by minerals containing exchangeable calcium ions and metal oxide hydrates in the soil, forming a relatively stable adsorbed Cr(VI). Also, a small fraction of Cr(VI) can precipitate as calcium chromate with free calcium ion which is the most stable Cr(VI) species in the soil. The majority of Cr(VI) discharged into soil tends to be reduced by ferrous ions or minerals containing ferrous ions with a product of Fe(III)-Cr(III) coprecipitate. Therefore, the speciation of Cr in the soil is closely correlated to Fe and Ca. After the equilibrium of adsorption, precipitation, and reduction reactions of Cr(VI), the rest of Cr(VI) retains as the form of its original water-soluble state in soil. The evolution of Cr(VI) species and the content of specific Cr species in soil are mainly determined by the contents of iron, exchangeable calcium ions and metal oxide hydrates, which effect the Cr(VI) reduction, precipitation and adsorption, respectively.

Multifunctional interfaces for multiple uses: Tin(II)-hydroxyapatite for reductive adsorption of Cr(VI) and its upcycling into catalyst for air protection reactions

Evidence collected to date by our group has demonstrated that tin(II)-functionalized hydroxyapatites (Sn/HAP) are a newly discovered class of ecofriendly reductive adsorbents for Cr(VI) removal from wastewaters. In this work an upgraded series of Sn/HAP materials assured a maximum removal capacity of ≈ 20 mgCr/g, doubling the previously reported value for Sn/HAP materials, thanks to higher Sn-dispersion as proved by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and electron microscopy. Insights on kinetics and thermodynamics of the reductive adsorption process are provided and the influence of pH, dosage, and nature of Cr(VI) precursors on chromium removal performances have been investigated. Pseudo-second-order kinetics described the interfacial reductive adsorption process on Sn/HAP, characterized by low activation energy (21 kJ mol-1), when measured in the 278-318 K range. Tests performed in the 2-6 pH interval showed similar efficiency in terms of Cr(VI) removal. Conventional procedures of recycling and regeneration resulted ineffective in restoring the pristine performances of the samples due to surface presence of both Sn(IV) and Cr(III). To overcome these weaknesses, the used samples (Sn + Cr/HAP) were upcycled into catalysts in a circular economy perspective. Used samples were tested as catalysts in gas-phase catalytic processes for air pollution remediation: selective catalytic reduction of NOx (NH3-SCR), NH3 selective catalytic Oxidation (NH3-SCO), and selective catalytic oxidation of methane to CO2. Catalytic tests enlightened the interesting activity of the upcycled Sn + Cr/HAP samples in catalytic oxidation processes, being able to selectively oxidize methane to CO2 at relatively low temperature.

Treatment of distiller grain with wet-process phosphoric acid leads to biochar for the sustained release of nutrients and adsorption of Cr(VI)

Soil amendment products, such as biochar, with both sustained nutrient release and heavy metal retention properties are of great need in agricultural and environmental industries. Herein, we successfully prepared a new biochar material with multinutrient sustained-release characteristics and chromium removal potential derived from distiller grain by wet-process phosphoric acid (WPPA) modification without washing. SEM, TEM TG-IR, in situ DRIFTS and XRD characterization indicated that biochar and polyphosphate formed simultaneously and were tightly intertwined by one-step pyrolysis. The optimal product (PKBC-400) had the most stable carbon structure and an adequate P-O-P structure with less P loss. Batch experiments illustrated that 92.83% P (ortho-P), 85.94% K, 41.49% Fe, 78.42% Al and 65.60% Mg were continuously released in water from PKBC-400 within 63 days, and the maximum Cr removal rate reached 83.57% (50 mg/L K₂Cr₂O₇, pH=3.0) with an increased BET surface area (304.0557 m²/g) after nutrient release. SEM, IC and ³¹P NMR analyses revealed that the dissolution and hydrolysis of polyphosphates not only realized the sustained release of multiple nutrients but also significantly improved the sustained release performance. The proposed resource utilization strategy provided new ideas for Cr hazard control, biomass waste utilization and fertilizer development.

Effect of Ginkgo biloba leaves on the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) in soil and its underlying mechanism

Cr(VI) is a toxic, teratogenic, and carcinogenic heavy metal element in soil that poses major ecological and human health risks. In this study, microcosm tests combined with X-ray absorption near-edge spectra (XANES) and 16Sr DNA amplification techniques were used to explore the effect of Ginkgo biloba leaves on the removal efficiency of Cr(VI) in soil and its underlying mechanism. Ginkgo biloba leaves had a favorable remediation effect on soil varying in Cr(VI) contamination levels, and the optimal effect was observed when 5% Ginkgo biloba leaves were added. The occurrence state of Cr(VI) in soil before and after the addition of Ginkgo biloba leaves was analyzed by XANES, which revealed that Cr(VI) was fully converted to the more biologically innocuous Cr(III), and the hydroxyl-containing quercetin in Ginkgo biloba leaves was one of the primary components mediating this reduction reaction. The Cr(VI) content was significantly lower in non-sterilized soil than in sterilized soil, suggesting that soil microorganisms play a key role in the remediation process. The addition of Ginkgo biloba leaves decreased the α-diversity and altered the β-diversity of the soil bacterial community. Actinobacteria was the dominant phylum in the soil remediated by Ginkgo biloba leaves; four genera of Cr(VI)-reducing bacteria were also enriched, including Agrococcus, Klebsiella, Streptomyces, and Microbacterium. Functional gene abundances predicted by PICRUST indicated that the expression of glutathione synthesis genes was substantially up-regulated, which might be the main metabolic pathway underlying the mitigation of Cr(VI) toxicity in soil by Cr(VI)-reducing bacteria. In sum, Ginkgo biloba leaves can effectively remove soil Cr(VI) and reduce Cr(VI) to Cr(III) via quercetin in soil, which also functions as a carbon source to drive the production of glutathione via Cr(VI)-reducing bacteria and mitigate Cr(VI) toxicity. The findings of this study elucidate the chemical and microbial mechanisms of Cr(VI) removal in soil by Ginkgo biloba leaves and provide insights that could be used to enhance the remediation of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil.

Assessment of spatial variations in pollution load of agricultural soil samples of Ludhiana district, Punjab

Surveying, mapping, and characterizing soil properties are the critical steps in designating soil quality. Continuous use of inorganic fertilizers, pesticides, wastewater discharge, and leachates cause soil degradation and contamination of potable water and food ultimately leading to soil pollution and ill effects on human health. This study was undertaken to monitor the soil quality of agricultural soil samples collected from ten different agricultural fields in Ludhiana, Punjab (India), near Buddha Nullah, a Sutlej River tributary. Physico-chemical characteristics and heavy metal contents of soil samples were estimated during the study. The obtained results showed that all the agricultural soil samples were slightly alkaline in nature. Soil nutrients such as nitrates, phosphates, and potassium ranged from 0.06 to 0.11 mg/g, 0.03 to 0.08 mg/g, and 0.04 to 0.15 mg/g respectively. The contents (mg/kg) of heavy metals such as cadmium, chromium, cobalt, copper, and lead were observed to be above the permissible limits in most of the soil samples. Allium cepa root chromosomal aberration assay was used for genotoxicity studies which has shown that Hambran (HBN), a site approx. 12.9 km of the Buddha Nullah, induced maximum genotoxic effects, i.e., 46.7% aberrant cells in root tip cells of Allium cepa. The statistical analysis revealed the positive correlation of heavy metals like Cr, Cu, and Ni (at p ≤ 0.05 and p ≤ 0.01) with the total chromosomal aberrations induced in Allium cepa.

Study on combined technology of glutathione reduction and alkali solidification of chromium-containing sludge

Chromium-containing sludge (CCS) is a solid hazardous waste containing various heavy metals, threatening the human body and the environment. In this study, CCS was solidified/stabilized by a combined method of glutathione (GSH) prereduction of Cr(VI) and alkali-excited blast furnace slag (BFS) preparation of geopolymer/gel. To explore the prospect of glutathione treatment of solid waste and combination with solidification/stabilization technology. The appropriate dosage and initial pH value of GSH were obtained through experiments (the dosage of GSH was 0.5%, and the initial pH value was 1). The preparation parameters (content of alkali activator 13%, modulus of alkali activator 1.7, initial curing temperature 25 ℃, liquid-solid ratio 0.26) and mechanism of geopolymer/gel were studied. GSH pre-reduction technology significantly increases the maximum dosage of CCS in the solidified body, and increases the proportion of heavy metals in the residual state. The solidified product meets landfill requirements and holds promise as a building material. According to XRD, FTIR, SEM-EDS, Geopolymers/gels solidify heavy metals utilizing physical encapsulation, chemical encapsulation, charge balance, and bonding.

Remediation of Cr(VI)-Contaminated Soil by Biochar-Supported Nanoscale Zero-Valent Iron and the Consequences for Indigenous Microbial Communities

Biochar/nano-zero-valent iron (BC-nZVI) composites are currently of great interest as an efficient remediation material for contaminated soil, but their potential to remediate Cr-contaminated soils and effect on soil microecology is unclear. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of BC-nZVI composites on the removal of Cr(VI) from soil, and indigenous microbial diversity and community composition. The results showed that after 15 days of remediation with 10 g/kg of BC-nZVI, 86.55% of Cr(VI) was removed from the soil. The remediation of the Cr-contaminated soil with BC-nZVI resulted in a significant increase in OTUs and α-diversity index, and even a significant increase in the abundance and diversity of indigenous bacteria and unique bacterial species in the community by reducing the toxic concentration of Cr, changing soil properties, and providing habitat for survival. These results confirm that BC-nZVI is effective in removing Cr(VI) and stabilizing Cr in soil with no significant adverse effects on soil quality or soil microorganisms.

Immobilization of hexavalent chromium in soil-plant environment using calcium silicate hydrate synthesized from coal gangue

The presence of excessive hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) in the contaminated soils and plants has become a global environmental issue due to its toxicity and carcinogenicity. This work investigated the feasibility of immobilizing Cr(VI) in the soil-plant environment using calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H) synthesized from coal gangue. The results revealed that the C-S-H amendment increased soil pH and organic matter (OM), which further promoted Cr(VI) immobilization. Results also revealed that exchangeable and carbonate bound fractions of Cr were either converted into Fe/Mn oxide and OM bound fractions of Cr or hardly released residual fraction of Cr due to C-S-H treatment. The C-S-H accelerated conversion of Cr(VI) into Cr(III) promoting plant growth and alleviating the toxic effect of Cr(VI). Cr(VI) was mainly immobilized and accumulated in the plant roots which resulted in comparatively lower Cr(VI) content in the edible part of plants. The exchangeable fraction of Cr in soil could be used as a bioavailability evaluation index of Cr(VI) in plants. In short, C-S-H was proved to be a practical and environmentally friendly amendment for in-situ immobilization of Cr(VI) contaminated soil.

Fate and mechanistic insights into nanoscale zerovalent iron (nZVI) activation of sludge derived biochar reacted with Cr(VI)

While nanoscale zero-valent iron modified biochar (nZVI-BC) have been widely investigated for the removal of heavy metals, the corrosion products of nZVI and their interaction with heavy metals have not been revealed yet. In this paper, nZVI-BC was synthesized and applied for the removal of Cr(VI). Batch experiments indicated that the adsorption of Cr(VI) fit Langmuir isotherm, with the maximum removal capacity at 172.4 mg/g at pH 2.0. SEM-EDS, BET, XRD, FT-IR, Raman and XPS investigation suggested that reduction of Cr(VI) to Cr(III) was the major removal mechanism. pH played an important role on the corrosion of nZVI-BC, at pH 4.5 and 2.0, FeOOH and Fe₃O₄ were detected as the major iron oxide, respectively. Therefore, FeOOH-BC and Fe₃O₄-BC were further prepared and their interaction with Cr were studied. Combining with DFT calculations, it revealed that Fe₃O₄ has higher adsorption capacity and was responsible for the effective removal of Cr(VI) through electrostatic attraction and reduction under acidic conditions. However, Fe₃O₄ will continue to convert to the more stable FeOOH, which is the key to for the subsequent stabilization of the reduced Cr(III). The results showed that the oxide corrosion products of nZVI-BC were subjected to the environment, which will eventually affect the fate and transport of the adsorbed heavy metal.

Recovery of chromium (VI) from hazardous APV wastewater using a novel synergistic extraction system

As a well-known hazardous material, chromium (VI) in industrial wastewater has always attracted extensive attention. Many studies have focused on the recovery of Cr (VI) which is still challenging and received considerable interest. In this study, a novel synergistic extraction system using amide as extractant and Cyanex 272 as synergistic extractant was built to recover chromium (VI) from the APV wastewater. After optimizing the process parameters of extractant concentration, initial pH, extraction temperature, extraction time, extraction phase ratio, ammonia concentration and stripping phase ratio, the final extraction and stripping efficiency reached more than 99% and 98%, respectively. The Cr₂O₃ product with a purity of 99.52 was prepared and the organic phase could be effectively regenerated for recycling. The extraction mechanism of chromium (VI) in the synergistic extraction system was investigated in-depth with slope method, ESI-MS analysis and FT-IR analysis. In addition, molecular electrostatic potentials analysis was used to display visually the formation process of the extract complex. This paper offered a unique approach to guide sustainable chromium (VI) recovery from hazardous wastewater with great industrial and theoretical significance.

Coexistence of Cr and Ni in anthropogenic soils and their chemistry: implication to proper management and remediation

In anthropogenic soils, there have been relatively limited studies focusing on Cr and Ni contaminants because they exhibit less toxic effects to overall ecosystem and human health than other metal contaminants. In recent years, however, soil contamination with Cr and Ni has become a serious concern in several parts of the world because of the continuously increasing concentrations of these metals due to accelerated industrialization and urbanization. To investigate the status of soil contamination with Cr and Ni by anthropogenic activities, relevant global data sets in different land-use types reported by several studies were reviewed. This review presents the significant work done on Cr and Ni concentrations in roadside, central business district (CBD), and industrial soils in 46 global cities and evaluated their correlation by global data in the past few years. The highest concentrations of Cr and Ni were observed in industrial soils. Furthermore, a significant relationship was found between Cr and Ni concentrations in the soils, which might be because both metals are released from the same sources or anthropogenic activity processes. We also discuss the state of knowledge about the chemistry and distribution of Cr and Ni in the soil environment to understand how their processes such as redox reaction, precipitation-dissolution, and sorption-desorption affect the remediation of Cr- and Ni-contaminated soils using in situ immobilization technology. Application of organic and inorganic immobilizing agents (e.g., lime, compost, and sulfur) for the clean-up of Cr- and Ni-contaminated soils has received increasing interest from several researchers worldwide. Several immobilizing agents have been suggested and experimentally tested with varying degrees of achievement in Cr- and Ni-contaminated soils. Overall, the use of sulfur-containing amendments and pH-increasing materials could be considered the best options for the remediation of co-contamination of Cr and Ni in soil.