Binding of the adenovirus VAI RNA to the interferon-induced 68-kDa protein kinase correlates with function

Shaping the host cell environment with viral noncoding RNAs

Just like the cells they infect viruses express different classes of noncoding RNAs (ncRNAs). Viral ncRNAs come in all shapes and forms, and they usually associate with cellular proteins that are important for their functions. Viral ncRNAs have diverse functions, but they all contribute to the viral control of the cellular environment. Viruses utilize ncRNAs to regulate viral replication, to decide whether they should remain latent or reactivate, to evade the host immune responses, or to promote cellular transformation. In this review we describe the diverse functions played by different classes of ncRNAs expressed by adenoviruses and herpesviruses, how they contribute to the viral infection, and how their study led to insights into RNA-based mechanisms at play in host cells.

Ribosomal protein RACK1 enhances translation of poliovirus and other viral IRESs

Viruses have evolved strategies to ensure efficient translation using host cell ribosomes and translation factors. In addition to cleaving translation initiation factors required for host cell translation, poliovirus (PV) uses an internal ribosome entry site (IRES). Recent studies suggest that viruses exploit specific ribosomal proteins to enhance translation of their viral proteins. The ribosomal protein receptor for activated C kinase 1 (RACK1), a protein of the 40S ribosomal subunit, was previously shown to mediate translation from the 5' cricket paralysis virus and hepatitis C virus IRESs. Here we found that translation of a PV dual-luciferase reporter shows a moderate dependence on RACK1. However, in the context of a viral infection we observed significantly reduced poliovirus plaque size and titers and delayed host cell translational shut-off. Our findings further illustrate the involvement of the cellular translational machinery during PV infection and how viruses usurp the function of specific ribosomal proteins.

Battling for Ribosomes: Translational Control at the Forefront of the Antiviral Response

In the early stages of infection, gaining control of the cellular protein synthesis machinery including its ribosomes is the ultimate combat objective for a virus. To successfully replicate, viruses unequivocally need to usurp and redeploy this machinery for translation of their own mRNA. In response, the host triggers global shutdown of translation while paradoxically allowing swift synthesis of antiviral proteins as a strategy to limit collateral damage. This fundamental conflict at the level of translational control defines the outcome of infection. As part of this special issue on molecular mechanisms of early virus-host cell interactions, we review the current state of knowledge regarding translational control during viral infection with specific emphasis on protein kinase RNA-activated and mammalian target of rapamycin-mediated mechanisms. We also describe recent technological advances that will allow unprecedented insight into how viruses and host cells battle for ribosomes.

Dissection of the adenoviral VA RNAI central domain structure reveals minimum requirements for RNA-mediated inhibition of PKR

Virus-associated RNA I (VA RNAI) is a short (∼160-nucleotide) non-coding RNA transcript employed by adenoviruses to subvert the innate immune system protein double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase (PKR). The central domain of VA RNAI is proposed to contain a complex tertiary structure that contributes to its optimal inhibitory activity against PKR. Here we use a combination of VA RNAI mutagenesis, structural analyses, as well as PKR activity and binding assays to dissect this tertiary structure and assess its functional role. Our results support the existence of a pH- and Mg(2+)-dependent tertiary structure involving pseudoknot formation within the central domain. Unexpectedly, this structure appears to play no direct role in PKR inhibition. Deletion of central domain sequences within a minimal but fully active construct lacking the tertiary structure reveals a crucial role in PKR binding and inhibition for nucleotides in the 5' half of the central domain. Deletion of the central domain 3' half also significantly impacts activity but appears to arise indirectly by reducing its capacity to assist in optimally presenting the 5' half sequence. Collectively, our results identify regions of VA RNAI critical for PKR inhibition and reveal that the requirements for an effective RNA inhibitor of PKR are simpler than appreciated previously.

Identification of adenovirus-encoded small RNAs by deep RNA sequencing

Using deep RNA sequencing, we have studied the expression of adenovirus-encoded small RNAs at different times after infection. Nineteen small RNAs which comprised more than 1% of the total pool of small RNAs at least one time point were identified. These small RNAs were between 25 and 35 nucleotides long and mapped in the region of the VA RNAI and RNAII genes. However, the overlap was incomplete and some contained a few extra nucleotides at the 3' end. This finding together with the observation that some of the small RNAs were detected before VA RNA expression had started might indicate that they are derived from other precursors than VA RNAI and II. Interestingly, the small RNAs displayed different expression profiles during the course of the infection suggesting that they have different functions. An effort was made to identify their mRNA targets by using computer prediction and deep cDNA sequencing. The most significant targets for the earliest small RNAs were genes involved in signaling pathways.

Adenovirus Vector-Derived VA-RNA-Mediated Innate Immune Responses

The major limitation of the clinical use of replication-incompetent adenovirus (Ad) vectors is the interference by innate immune responses, including induction of inflammatory cytokines and interferons (IFN), following in vivo application of Ad vectors. Ad vector-induced production of inflammatory cytokines and IFNs also results in severe organ damage and efficient induction of acquired immune responses against Ad proteins and transgene products. Ad vector-induced innate immune responses are triggered by the recognition of Ad components by pattern recognition receptors (PRRs). In order to reduce the side effects by Ad vector-induced innate immune responses and to develop safer Ad vectors, it is crucial to clarify which PRRs and which Ad components are involved in Ad vector-induced innate immune responses. Our group previously demonstrated that myeloid differentiating factor 88 (MyD88) and toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9) play crucial roles in the Ad vector-induced inflammatory cytokine production in mouse bone marrow-derived dendritic cells. Furthermore, our group recently found that virus associated-RNAs (VA-RNAs), which are about 160 nucleotide-long non-coding small RNAs encoded in the Ad genome, are involved in IFN production through the IFN-β promoter stimulator-1 (IPS-1)-mediated signaling pathway following Ad vector transduction. The aim of this review is to highlight the Ad vector-induced innate immune responses following transduction, especially VA-RNA-mediated innate immune responses. Our findings on the mechanism of Ad vector-induced innate immune responses should make an important contribution to the development of safer Ad vectors, such as an Ad vector lacking expression of VA-RNAs.

Adenovirus and miRNAs

Adenovirus infection has a tremendous impact on the cellular silencing machinery. Adenoviruses express high amounts of non-coding virus associated (VA) RNAs able to saturate key factors of the RNA interference (RNAi) processing pathway, such as Exportin 5 and Dicer. Furthermore, a proportion of VA RNAs is cleaved by Dicer into viral microRNAs (mivaRNAs) that can saturate Argonaute, an essential protein for miRNA function. Thus, processing and function of cellular miRNAs is blocked in adenoviral-infected cells. However, viral miRNAs actively target the expression of cellular genes involved in relevant functions such as cell proliferation, DNA repair or RNA regulation. Interestingly, the cellular silencing machinery is active at early times post-infection and can be used to control the adenovirus cell cycle. This is relevant for therapeutic purposes against adenoviral infections or when recombinant adenoviruses are used as vectors for gene therapy. Manipulation of the viral genome allows the use of adenoviral vectors to express therapeutic miRNAs or to be silenced by the RNAi machinery leading to safer vectors with a specific tropism. This article is part of a "Special Issue entitled:MicroRNAs in viral gene regulation".

The PKR-binding domain of adenovirus VA RNAI exists as a mixture of two functionally non-equivalent structures

VA RNA_I is a non-coding adenoviral transcript that counteracts the host cell anti-viral defenses such as immune responses mediated via PKR. We investigated potential alternate secondary structure conformations within the PKR-binding domain of VA RNA_I using site-directed mutagenesis, RNA UV-melting analysis and enzymatic RNA secondary structure probing. The latter data clearly indicated that the wild-type VA RNA_I apical stem can adopt two different conformations and that it exists as a mixed population of these two structures. In contrast, in two sequence variants we designed to eliminate one of the possible structures, while leaving the other intact, each formed a unique secondary structure. This clarification of the apical stem pairing also suggests a small alteration to the apical stem–loop secondary structure. The relative ability of the two apical stem conformations to bind PKR and inhibit kinase activity was measured by isothermal titration calorimetry and PKR autophosphorylation inhibition assay. We found that the two sequence variants displayed markedly different activities, with one being a significantly poorer binder and inhibitor of PKR. Whether the presence of the VA RNA_I conformation with reduced PKR inhibitory activity is directly beneficial to the virus in the cell for some other function requires further investigation.

Systematic deletion of the adenovirus-associated RNAI terminal stem reveals a surprisingly active RNA inhibitor of double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase

Adenoviruses use the short noncoding RNA transcript virus-associated (VA) RNA(I) to counteract two critical elements of the host cell defense system, innate cellular immunity and RNA interference, mediated by the double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase (PKR) and Dicer/RNA-induced silencing complex, respectively. We progressively shortened the VA RNA(I) terminal stem to examine its necessity for inhibition of PKR. Each deletion, up to 15 bp into the terminal stem, resulted in a cumulative decrease in PKR inhibitory activity. Remarkably, however, despite significant apparent destabilization of the RNA structure, the final RNA mutant that lacked the entire terminal stem (TSDelta21 RNA) efficiently bound PKR and exhibited wild-type inhibitory activity. TSDelta21 RNA stability was strongly influenced by solution pH, indicating the involvement of a protonated base within the VA RNA(I) central domain tertiary structure. Gel filtration chromatography and isothermal titration calorimetry analysis indicated that wild-type VA RNA(I) and TSDelta21 RNA form similar 1:1 complexes with PKR but that the latter lacks secondary binding site(s) that might be provided by the terminal stem. Although TSDelta21 RNA bound PKR with wild-type K(d), and overall change in free energy (DeltaG), the thermodynamics of binding (DeltaH and DeltaS) were significantly altered. These results demonstrate that the VA RNA(I) terminal stem is entirely dispensable for inhibition of PKR. Potentially, VA RNA(I) is therefore a truly bi-functional RNA; Dicer processing of the VA RNA(I) terminal stem saturates the RNA interference system while generating a "mini-VA RNA(I)" molecule that remains fully active against PKR.

Analysis of adenovirus VA RNAI structure and stability using compensatory base pair modifications

Adenovirus VA RNAs are short non-coding transcripts that assist in maintaining viral protein expression in infected cells. Six sets of mismatch and compensatory base pair mutants of VA RNA(I) were examined by gel mobility and RNA UV melting to assess the contribution of each structural domain to its overall structure and stability. Each domain of VA RNA(I) was first assigned to one of two apparent unfolding transitions in the wild-type melting profile. The Terminal Stem and Central Domain unfold in a single cooperative apparent transition with an apparent T(m) of approximately 60 degrees C. In contrast, the Apical Stem unfolds independently and with much higher apparent T(m) of approximately 83 degrees C. Remarkably, this domain appears to behave as an almost entirely autonomous unit within the RNA, mirroring the functional division within the RNA between PKR binding and inhibition. The effects of mismatch and compensatory mutations at five of the six sites on the RNA melting profile are consistent with proposed base pairing and provide further validation of the current secondary structure model. Mutations in the Central Domain were tested in PKR inhibition assays and a component of the VA RNA(I) Central Domain structure essential for PKR inhibitory activity was identified.

Deletion of VAI and VAII RNA genes in the design of oncolytic adenoviruses

Deletion of viral functions that can be complemented by the specific phenotype of tumor cells is a common strategy to design oncolytic viruses. For example, enhanced mRNA cytoplasmic export in tumor cells phenocopies the adenovirus E1B-55K function and renders mutants of this protein tumor selective. Also, an activated RB pathway complements specific E1A functions that can be deleted to produce oncolytic viruses. In this paper we demonstrate that an adenoviral mutant deleted in virus-associated I (VAI) and VAII RNAs (Ad-VAdel) has oncotropism characterized by 100-fold replication deficiency compared with wild-type adenovirus in normal cells and an unaffected ability to replicate and kill different types of tumor cells. This mutant also displays active antitumoral activity in vivo. In contrast, this oncotropism is less evident in a mutant expressing an inactive form of VAI (Adsub719) because VAII RNA expression is upregulated. The mRNA translation promoted by VA RNA genes can be phenocopied in tumor cells with the activation of signal transduction pathways, such as the Ras pathway.

Uncoupling of RNA binding and PKR kinase activation by viral inhibitor RNAs

Protein kinase RNA-activated (PKR) is a serine/threonine kinase that contains an N-terminal RNA-binding domain and a C-terminal kinase domain. Upon binding double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), PKR can become activated and phosphorylate cellular targets, such as eukaryotic translation initiation factor 2alpha (eIF-2alpha). Phosphorylation of eIF-2alpha results in attenuation of protein translation by the ribosome in either a general or an mRNA-specific manner. Therefore, the interaction between PKR and dsRNAs represents a crucial host cell defense mechanism against viral infection. Viruses can circumvent PKR function by transcription of virus-encoded dsRNA inhibitors that bind to and inactivate PKR. We present here a biophysical characterization of the interactions between human PKR and two viral inhibitor RNAs, EBER(I) (from Epstein-Barr virus) and VA(I) (from human adenovirus). Autophosphorylation assays confirmed that both EBER(I) and VA(I) are inhibitors of PKR activation, and profiled the kinetics of the inhibition. Binding affinities of dsRNAs to PKR double-stranded RNA-binding domains (dsRBDs) were determined by isothermal titration calorimetry and gel electrophoresis. A single stem-loop domain from each inhibitory RNA mediates the interaction with both dsRBDs of PKR. The binding sites on inhibitor RNAs and the dsRBDs of PKR have been mapped by NMR chemical shift perturbation experiments, which indicate that inhibitors of PKR employ similar surfaces of interaction as activators. Finally, we show that dsRNA binding and inactivation are non-equivalent; regions other than the dsRBD stem-loops of inhibitory RNA are required for inhibition.

Sequence-specific interference by small RNAs derived from adenovirus VAI RNA

A virus-associated RNA (VAI) of adenoviruses is a cytoplasmic non-coding RNA and it plays an important role for viral replication in infected cells. VAI RNA transcripts, produced by RNA polymerase III (pol III), form tightly structured stems, which confer resistance to cellular defense systems. We demonstrate here that small RNAs of approximately 22 nucleotides are produced from a terminal stem region but not from an apical stem of VAI RNA. We determined the processing sites of VAI RNA by S1 nuclease mapping and further confirmed that the processed small RNA can act as small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) or as microRNAs (miRNAs) in transient transfection assays and during viral infection. Our data demonstrate that non-coding RNAs synthesized by pol III can be substrates for Dicer, and diced small RNAs might regulate cellular phenomena as siRNAs and miRNAs.

Targeting a KH-domain protein with RNA decoys

RNA-binding proteins are involved in the regulation of many aspects of eukaryotic gene expression. Targeted interference with RNA-protein interactions could offer novel approaches to modulation of expression profiles, alteration of developmental pathways, and reversal of certain disease processes. Here we investigate a decoy strategy for the study of the alphaCP subgroup of KH-domain RNA-binding proteins. These poly(C)-binding proteins have been implicated in a wide spectrum of posttranscriptional controls. Three categories of RNA decoys to alphaCPs were studied: poly(C) homopolymers, native mRNA-binding sites, and a high-affinity structure selected from a combinatorial library. Native chemistry was found to be essential for alphaCP decoy action. Because alphaCP proteins are found in both the nucleus and cytoplasm, decoy cassettes were incorporated within both nuclear (U1 snRNA) and cytoplasmic (VA1 RNA) RNA frameworks. Several sequences demonstrated optimal decoy properties when assayed for protein-binding and decoy bioactivity in vitro. A subset of these transcripts was shown to mediate targeted inhibition of alphaCP-dependent translation when expressed in either the nucleus or cytoplasm of transfected cells. Significantly, these studies establish the feasibility of developing RNA decoys that can selectively target biologic functions of abundant and widely expressed RNA binding proteins.

Inhibition of internal ribosomal entry site-directed translation of HCV by recombinant IFN-alpha correlates with a reduced La protein

Translation of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) polyprotein is mediated by an internal ribosome entry site (IRES) that is located within the 5'-nontranslated region (5'NTR). We investigated the effect of interferon alfa (IFN-alpha) on the IRES-directed translation of HCV, using two stably transformed cell lines, RCF-1 and RCF-26, of Huh7 cells derived from human hepatocellular carcinoma that express dicistronic reporter proteins, Renilla luciferase (RL) and firefly luciferase (FL), separated by HCV-IRES. After the administration of IFN-alpha or poly(I)-poly(C), HCV-IRES-directed translation was inhibited in a dose-dependent manner. The relative HCV-IRES activity (F/L) decreased to 60% at 5,000 IU/mL of IFN-alpha and 45% at 40 microg/mL of poly(I)-poly(C). Thus, IFN-alpha or poly(I)-poly(C) inhibited HCV-IRES-directed translation more efficiently than a cellular cap-dependent translation. 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase (2',5'AS) protein level in cells analyzed significantly increased after the administration of IFN-alpha, but not upon poly(I)-poly(C). Overexpression of double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase (PKR) gene did not mimic the selective inhibition of HCV-IRES-directed translation in the transformant cells, suggesting that neither the 2',5'AS nor the PKR system are involved in this selective inhibition. Interestingly, the expression of the autoantigen, La, which has been reported to enhance HCV-IRES-directed translation, was significantly reduced after the administration of IFN-alpha and poly(I)-poly(C) in a dose-dependent manner. Transient expression of La protein completely restored the selective inhibition of HCV-IRES-directed translation by IFN-alpha and poly(I)-poly(C). These findings suggested a new antiviral mechanism induced by IFN-alpha in that IFN-alpha or poly(I)-poly(C) selectively inhibited HCV-IRES-directed translation compared with the eukaryotic cap-dependent translation through the reduction of La protein.

Efficacy of adenoviral TNF alpha antisense is enhanced by a macrophage specific promoter

Macrophage-derived TNF alpha is a critical mediator of inflammation and destruction in diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and Crohn's disease. These studies were undertaken to develop an effective adenovirus-based strategy to specifically suppress TNF alpha in primary human macrophages. A variety of promoters and LTRs were evaluated for effective expression in the macrophage cell line RAW 264.7. The CMV promoter and the Visna LTR were the most strongly expressed and were therefore used to drive the expression of TNF alpha antisense fragments. In transient transfection assays, the antisense fragment terminating at the 3' end of the first exon (216 bp) was superior to the others (70 and 750 bp), when expressed under the control of either the CMV promoter or the Visna LTR. Adenoviral vectors expressing the 216 bp TNF alpha antisense fragment, controlled by the CMV promoter or the Visna LTR, were both effective at suppressing LPS-induced TNF alpha secretion by primary human macrophages. However, the Visna LTR was more effective not only at suppressing LPS-induced TNF alpha secretion, but also IL-6, which is highly sensitive to TNF alpha secretion. These results demonstrate that effective, specific, suppression of TNF alpha in macrophages is possible, employing a directed antisense approach and a promoter system that is highly efficient in human macrophages.

Regulation of TNF-alpha expression in normal macrophages: the role of C/EBPbeta

C/EBPbeta is present in monocytes and macrophages, binds to the proximal region of the TNF-alpha promoter, and contributes to its regulation. This study was performed to characterize the ability of C/EBPbeta to regulate the TNF-alpha gene in myelomonocytic cells and primary macrophages. In transient transfection assays, overexpression of wild type C/EBPbeta resulted in a 3-4-fold activation of a 120 base pair TNF-alpha promoter-reporter construct, while overexpression of a dominant negative (DN) C/EBPbeta inhibited LPS-induced activation. In vitro monocyte-differentiated macrophages, infected with an adenoviral vector expressing the DN C/EBPbeta (AdDNC/EBPbeta) or the control Adbetagal, expressed their transgenes weakly, however expression was greatly enhanced in the presence of PMA. Infection with AdDNC/EBPbeta resulted in 60% suppression of LPS induced TNFalpha secretion compared to Adbetagal infection (P<0.001) in PMA-treated macrophages. Northern blot analysis demonstrated approximately a 40% reduction of the TNF-alpha mRNA in the presence of the DN C/EBPbeta, suggesting that the effect of the DN C/EBPbeta was at the transcriptional level. In contrast, AdDNC/EBPbeta infection did not result in inhibition of LPS-induced TNF-alpha secretion in the absence of PMA. Further, DN versions of both C/EBPbeta and c-Jun, but not NF-kappaB p65, suppressed PMA-induced TNF-alpha secretion in macrophages. These observations demonstrate that, C/EBPbeta and c-Jun contribute to the regulation of the TNF-alpha gene in normal macrophages following treatment with PMA.

Downregulation of the CCR5 beta-chemokine receptor and inhibition of HIV-1 infection by stable VA1-ribozyme chimeric transcripts

The CCR5 beta-chemokine receptor is the coreceptor for macrophage-tropic (M-tropic) strains of HIV-1 and appears to be the principal coreceptor during early stages of human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) infection. Approximately 1%-2% of the Western European Caucasian population is homozygous for a 32-bp deletion in the coding region of the CCR5 gene, rendering them less susceptible to HIV infection. These individuals still harbor a normal immune response, thereby making CCR5 an attractive cellular target for anti-HIV therapies. Based on the natural population studies, reduction in CCR5 expression should not affect the physiologic function of the modified cells but should interfere with their susceptibility to HIV-1 infection. To downregulate this receptor, we have designed a hammerhead ribozyme (RZ) that specifically targets the CCR5 mRNA and lacks complementarity to other members of the chemokine receptor gene family. For expression of this highly specific ribozyme, we have taken advantage of the stable transcripts afforded by transcription from the RNA polymerase III (pol III)-based adenoviral VA1 gene. Importantly, the VA1-chimeric ribozyme is stably expressed with a half-life of almost 6 hours. Using this expression system, we show up to 70% downregulation of the elevated levels of CCR5 receptor in the HOS-CD4.CCR5 cell line. The monocytic cell line PM1 was stably transduced with the chimeric VA1 ribozyme constructs. In these cells, substantial resistance to challenge with an M-tropic but not a T-tropic HIV viral strain was observed, demonstrating specificity in downregulating the CCR5 coreceptor. The VA1-CCR5 ribozyme chimeras described in this study should prove useful in both studies of CCR5 receptor function and therapeutic intervention of monocytotropic HIV-1 infection. The VA1 vector described in this study is well suited for the stable cytoplasmic expression of other ribozyme constructs as well.

TNF-alpha gene expression in macrophages: regulation by NF-kappa B is independent of c-Jun or C/EBP beta

The interaction of transcription factors is critical in the regulation of gene expression. This study characterized the mechanism by which NF-kappa B family members interact to regulate the human TNF-alpha gene. A 120-bp TNF-alpha promoter-reporter, possessing binding sites for NF-kappa B (kappa B3), C/EBP beta (CCAAT/enhancer binding protein beta), and c-Jun, was activated by cotransfection of plasmids expressing the wild-type version of each of these transcription factors. Employing adenoviral vectors, dominant-negative versions of NF-kappa B p65, and c-Jun, but not C/EBP beta, suppressed (p < 0.05-0.001) LPS-induced TNF-alpha secretion in primary human macrophages. Following LPS stimulation, NF-kappa B p50/p65 heterodimers bound to the kappa B3 site and c-Jun to the -103 AP-1 site of the TNF-alpha promoter. By transient transfection, NF-kappa B p65 and p50 synergistically activated the TNF-alpha promoter. In contrast, no synergy was observed between NF-kappa B p65, with or without NF-kappa B p50, and c-Jun or C/EBP beta, even in the presence of the coactivator p300. The contribution of the upstream kappa B binding sites was also examined. Following LPS stimulation, the kappa B1 site bound both NF-kappa B p50/p65 heterodimers and p50 homodimers. The binding by NF-kappa B p50 homodimers to the kappa B1, but not to the kappa 3, site contributed to the inability of macrophages to respond to a second LPS challenge. In summary, adjacent kappa B3 and AP-1 sites in the human TNF-alpha promoter contribute independently to LPS-induced activation. Although both the kappa B1 and kappa B3 sites bound transcriptionally active NF-kappa B p50/p65 heterodimers, only the kappa B1 site contributed to down-regulation by NF-kappa B p50 homodimers.

Subversion of cytokine networks by viruses

Viruses and the immune system have been competitors throughout their co-evolution. It is therefore not surprising that the viruses in circulation today possess a variety of strategies to counteract those aspects of the immune system that are involved in virus clearance. Examination of these virus encoded functions provides an important view of immune function and an appreciation of the complexity of the virus-host interaction. It is clear that viruses, seeking to subvert the immune system, have become adept in blocking the communication channels of the immune system. There are numerous examples of viral proteins that target the cytokine networks, disrupting the processes by which the delicately balanced immune system is regulated. This review focuses on the gene products of poxviruses, adenoviruses and herpesviruses that function primarily as immune-modulators.

Molecular mechanisms of interferon resistance mediated by viral-directed inhibition of PKR, the interferon-induced protein kinase

The interferon (IFN)-induced cellular antiviral response is the first line of defense against viral infection within an animal host. In order to establish a productive infection, eukaryotic viruses must first overcome the IFN-induced blocks imposed on viral replication. The double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase (PKR) is a key component mediating the antiviral actions of IFN. This IFN-induced protein kinase can restrict viral replication through its ability to phosphorylate the protein synthesis initiation factor eukaryotic initiation factor-2 alpha-subunit and reduce levels of viral protein synthesis. Viruses, therefore, must block the function of PKR in order to avoid these deleterious antiviral effects associated with PKR activity. Indeed, many viruses have developed effective measures to repress PKR activity during infection. This review will focus primarily on an overview of the different molecular mechanisms employed by these viruses to meet a common goal: the inhibition of PKR function, uncompromised viral protein synthesis, and unrestricted virus replication. The past few years have seen exciting new advances in this area. Rather unexpectedly, this area of research has benefited from the use of the yeast system to study PKR. Other recent advances include studies on PKR regulation by the herpes simplex viruses and data from our laboratory on the medically important hepatitis C viruses. We speculate that IFN is ineffective as a therapeutic agent against hepatitis C virus because the virus can effectively repress PKR function. Finally, we will discuss briefly the future directions of this PKR field.

Molecular basis of immune evasion strategies by adenoviruses

Human adenoviruses have provided valuable insights into virus-host interactions at the clinical and experimental levels. In addition to the medical importance of adenoviruses in acute infections and the ability of the virus to persist in the host, adenovirus-based recombinants are being developed as potential vaccine vectors. It is now clear that adenoviruses employ various strategies to modulate the innate and the adaptive host immune defences. Adenovirus genome-coded products that interact with the immune response of the host have been identified, and to a large extent the molecular mechanisms of their functions have been revealed. Such knowledge will no doubt influence our approach to the areas of viral pathogenesis, vaccine development and immune modulation for disease management.

The 58-kDa cellular inhibitor of the double stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase requires the tetratricopeptide repeat 6 and DnaJ motifs to stimulate protein synthesis in vivo

Double stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) is a double stranded RNA-activated, interferon-induced serine-threonine kinase that participates in both the antiviral and antiproliferative properties of interferon. We previously found that influenza virus inhibited PKR function by recruiting or activating a cellular inhibitor termed P58(IPK). The present study was undertaken to complement our earlier analyses, which demonstrated that P58(IPK) efficiently inhibited PKR autophosphorylation and activity in vitro. We now report that P58(IPK) down-regulates PKR and, in turn, stimulates protein synthetic rates inside the cell. Using transfection analysis, we show that P58(IPK) stimulates translation of secreted embryonic alkaline phosphatase reporter gene mRNA. Furthermore, we found that at least two regions of the P58(IPK) molecule were required for PKR inhibitory activity in COS-1 cells: (i) the DnaJ similarity region at the carboxyl terminus (amino acids 391-504); and (ii) the tetratricopeptide repeat 6 (TPR6) domain (amino acids 222-255) located in the middle of the P58(IPK) protein and within the eukaryotic protein synthesis initiation factor 2alpha homology region. P58(IPK) variants lacking either one of these regions were unable to stimulate secreted embryonic alkaline phosphatase protein synthetic rates. Consistent with this data is the observation that the DeltaTPR6 mutant (the P58(IPK) variant lacking the TPR6 motif) failed to block PKR activity in vitro. Based on these data and our earlier in vitro functional and PKR-P58(IPK) binding analyses, a revised model of PKR regulation by P58(IPK) is presented.

Structure, function, and evolution of adenovirus-associated RNA: a phylogenetic approach

To explore the structure and function of a small regulatory RNA, we examined the virus-associated (VA) RNA species of all 47 known human adenovirus serotypes and of one simian virus, SA7. The VA RNA gene regions of 43 human adenoviruses were amplified and sequenced, and the structures of 10 representative VA RNAs were probed by nuclease sensitivity analysis. Most human viruses have two VA RNA species, VA RNA, and VA RNAII, but nine viruses (19%) have a single VA RNA gene. Sequence alignments classified the RNAs into eight families, corresponding broadly to the known virus groups, and three superfamilies. One superfamily contains the single VA RNAs of groups A and F and the VA RNAI species of group C; the second contains the VA RNAI species of groups B1, D, and E and the unclassified viruses (adenovirus types 42 to 47), as well as the single VA RNAs of group B2; and the third contains all VA RNAII species. Fourteen regions of homology occur throughout the molecule. The longest of these correspond to transcription signals; most of the others participate in RNA secondary structure. The previously identified tetranucleotide pair, GGGU:ACCC, is nearly invariant, diverging slightly (to GGGU:ACCU) only in the two group F viruses and forming a stem in the central domain that is critical for VA RNA structure and function. Secondary structure models which accommodate the nuclease sensitivity data and sequence variations within each family were generated. The major structural features-the terminal stem, apical stem-loop, and central domain-are conserved in all VA RNAs, but differences exist in the apical stem and central domains, especially of the VA RNAII species. Sequence analysis suggests that an ancestral VA RNA gene underwent duplication during the evolution of viruses containing two VA RNA genes. Although the VA RNAII gene seems to have been lost or inactivated by secondary deletion events in some viruses, the high degree of homology among the VA RNAII species implies that this RNA may play an undiscovered role in virus survival. We speculate that the VA RNA genes originated from cellular sequences containing multiple tRNA genes.

In vitro activation of the interferon-induced, double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase PKR by RNA from the 3' untranslated regions of human alpha-tropomyosin

The cellular kinase known as PKR (protein kinase RNA-activated) is induced by interferon and activated by RNA. PKR is known to have antiviral properties due to its role in translational control. Active PKR phosphorylates eukaryotic initiation factor 2 alpha and leads to inhibition of translation, including viral translation. PKR is also known to function as a tumor suppressor, presumably by limiting the rate of tumor-cell translation and growth. Recent research has shown that RNA from the 3' untranslated region (3'UTR) of human alpha-tropomyosin has tumor-suppressor properties in vivo [Rastinejad, F., Conboy, M. J., Rando, T. A. & Blau, H. M. (1993) Cell 75, 1107-1117]. Here we report that purified RNA from the 3'UTR of human alpha-tropomyosin can inhibit in vitro translation in a manner consistent with activation of PKR. Inhibition of translation by tropomyosin 3'UTR RNA was observed in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate system, which is known to contain endogenous PKR but was not seen in wheat germ lysate, which is not responsive to a known activator of PKR. A control RNA purified in the same manner as the 3'UTR RNA did not inhibit translation in either system. The inhibition of translation observed in reticulocyte lysates was prevented by the addition of adenovirus virus-associated RNA1 (VA RNAI), an inhibitor of PKR activation. Tropomyosin 3'UTR RNA was bound by immunoprecipitated PKR and activated the enzyme in an in vitro kinase assay. These data suggest that activation of PKR could be the mechanism by which tropomyosin 3'UTR RNA exerts its tumor-suppression activity in vivo.

Effect of single-base substitutions in the central domain of virus-associated RNA I on its function

Adenoviruses use virus-associated RNA I (VAI RNA) to counteract the cellular antiviral response mediated by the interferon-induced, double-stranded-RNA-activated protein kinase PKR. VAI RNA is a highly structured small RNA which consists of two long duplex regions connected at the center by a complex, short stem-loop. This short stem-loop and the adjacent base-paired regions, referred to as the central domain, bind to PKR and inactivate it. Currently it is not known whether binding of VAI RNA to PKR is dependent solely on the secondary (and tertiary) structure of the central domain or whether nucleotide sequences in the central domain are also critical for this interaction. To address this question, 54 VAI mutants with single-base substitution mutations in the central domain of the RNA were constructed, and their capacities to inhibit the autophosphoryation of PKR in vitro were determined. It was found that although about half of the mutants inhibited PKR activity as efficiently as the wild type, a significant number of mutants lost the inhibitory activity substantially, without a perceptible change in their secondary structures. These results indicate that, in addition to secondary structure, at least some nucleotides in the central domain may be critical for the efficient function of VAI RNA.

Activation of interferon-inducible 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthetase by adenoviral VAI RNA

2'-5' oligoadenylate (2-5(A)) synthetase and protein kinase, RNA activated (PKR) are the only two known enzymes that bind double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and get activated by it. We have previously identified their dsRNA binding domains, which do not have any sequence homology. Here, we report a profound difference between the two enzymes with respect to the structural features of the dsRNA that are required for their activation. The adenoviral virus-associated type I (VAI) RNA cannot activate PKR, although it binds to the protein and thereby prevents its activation by authentic dsRNA. In contrast, we observed that VAI RNA can both bind and activate 2-5(A) synthetase. Mutations in VAI RNA, which removed occasional mismatches present in its double-stranded stems, markedly enhanced its 2-5(A) synthetase-activating capacity. These mutants, however, are incapable of activating PKR. Other mutations, which disrupted the structure of the central stem-loop region of the VAI RNA, reduced its ability to activate 2-5(A) synthetase. These debilitated mutants could bind to the synthetase protein, although they fail to bind to PKR.

A novel translational regulation function for the simian virus 40 large-T antigen gene

Cells use the interferon-induced, double-stranded-RNA-dependent protein kinase PKR as a defense against virus infections. Upon activation, PKR phosphorylates and thereby inactivates the protein synthesis initiation factor eIF-2, resulting in the cessation of protein synthesis. Viruses have evolved various strategies to counteract this cellular defense. In this paper, we show that simian virus 40 (SV40) large-T antigen can antagonize the translational inhibitory effect resulting from the activation of PKR in virus-infected cells. Unlike the situation with other virus-host cell interactions, SV40 large-T antigen does not block the activation of PKR, suggesting that SV40 counteracts the cellular antiviral response mediated by PKR at a step downstream of PKR activation. Mutational analysis of large-T antigen indicates that a domain located between amino acids 400 and 600 of large-T antigen is responsible for this function. These results define a novel translational regulatory function for the SV40 large-T antigen.

Structural features of adenovirus 2 virus-associated RNA required for binding to the protein kinase DAI

The double-stranded RNA activated protein kinase DAI contains an RNA binding domain consisting of two copies of a double-stranded RNA binding motif. We have investigated the role of RNA structure in the interaction between DAI and the structured single-stranded RNA, adenovirus VA RNAI, which inhibits DAI activation. Mutations in the apical stem, terminal stem, and central domain of the RNA were tested to assess the contribution of these elements to DAI binding in vitro. The data demonstrate that over half a turn of intact apical stem is required for the interaction and that there is a correlation between the binding of apical stem mutants and their ability to function both in vivo and in vitro. There was also evidence of preference for GC-rich sequence in the proximal region of the apical stem. In the central domain the correlation between binding and function of mutant RNAs was poor, suggesting that at least some of this region plays no direct role in binding to DAI, despite its functional importance. Exceptionally, central domain mutations that encroached on the phylogenetically conserved stem 4 of VA RNA disrupted binding, and complementary mutations in this sequence partially restored binding. Measurement of the binding of wild-type VA RNAI to DAI and p20, a truncated form of the protein containing the RNA binding domains alone, under various ionic conditions imply that the major interactions are electrostatic and occur via the protein's RNA binding domain. However, differences between full-length DAI and p20 in their binding to mutants in the conserved stem suggest that regions outside the RNA binding domain also participate in the binding. The additional interactions are likely to be non-ionic, and may be important for preventing DAI activation during virus infection.

In vitro analysis of virus-associated RNA I (VAI RNA): inhibition of the double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase PKR by VAI RNA mutants correlates with the in vivo phenotype and the structural integrity of the central domain

Adenoviruses use the virus-encoded virus-associated RNA (VAI RNA) as a defense against cellular antiviral response by blocking the activation of the interferon-induced, double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase PKR. The structure of VAI RNA consists of two long, imperfectly base-paired duplex regions connected by a complex short stem-loop at the center, referred to as the central domain. By using a series of adenovirus mutants with linker-scan mutations in the VAI RNA gene, we recently showed that the critical elements required for function in the VAI RNA molecule are in the central domain and that these same elements of the central domain are also involved in binding to PKR. In virus-infected cells, VAI RNA interacts with latent kinase, which is bound to ribosomes; this interaction takes place in a complex milieu. To more fully understand the relationship between structure and function and to determine whether the in vivo phenotype of these mutants can be reproduced in vitro, we have now analyzed these mutant VAI alleles for their ability to block the activation of a partially purified PKR from HeLa cells. We have also derived the structure of these mutants experimentally and correlated the structure with function. Without exception, when the structure of the short stem-loop of the central domain was perturbed, the mutants failed to inhibit PKR. Structural disruptions elsewhere in the central domain or in the long duplex regions of the molecule were not deleterious for in vitro function. Thus, these results support our previous findings and underscore the importance of the elements present in the central domain of the VAI RNA for its function. Our results also suggest that the interaction between PKR and VAI RNA involves a precise secondary (and tertiary) structure in the central domain. It has been suggested that VAI RNA does not activate PKR in virus-infected cells because of mismatches in the imperfectly base-paired long duplex regions. We constructed mutant VAI genes in which the imperfectly base-paired duplex regions were converted to perfectly base-paired regions and assayed in vitro for the activation of PKR. As with the wild-type VAI RNA, these mutants failed to activate PKR in vitro, while they were able to block the activation of PKR better than did the wild type. These results suggest that the failure of VAI RNA to activate PKR is not the result of mismatches in the long duplex regions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Comparative analysis of the structure and function of adenovirus virus-associated RNAs

The protein kinase DAI is an important component of the interferon-induced cellular defense mechanism. In cells infected by adenovirus type 2 (Ad2), activation of the kinase is prevented by the synthesis of a small, highly ordered virus-associated (VA) RNA, VA RNAI. The inhibitory function of this RNA depends on its structure, which has been partially elucidated by a combination of mutagenesis and RNase sensitivity analysis. To gain further insight into the structure and function of this regulatory RNA, we have compared the primary sequences, secondary structures, and functions of seven VA RNA species from five human and animal adenoviruses. The sequences exhibit variable degrees of homology, with a particularly close relationship between the VA RNAII species of Ad2 and Ad7 and notably divergent sequence for the avian (CELO) virus VA RNA. Apart from two pairs of mutually complementary tetranucleotides which are highly conserved, homologies are limited to transcription signals located within the RNA sequence and at its termini. Secondary structure analysis indicated that all seven RNAs conform to the model in which VA RNA possesses three main structural regions, a terminal stem, an apical stem-loop, and a central domain, although these elements vary in size and other details. The apical stem is implicated in binding to DAI, and the central domain is essential for inhibition of DAI activation. One of the pairs of conserved tetranucleotides (CCGG:C/UCGG) provides further evidence for the existence of the apical stem, but the other conserved pair (GGGU:ACCC) strongly suggests a revised structure for the central domain. In two functional assays conducted in vivo, the VA RNAI species of Ad2 and Ad7 were the most active, their corresponding VA RNAII species displayed little activity, and the single VA RNAs of Ad12 and simian adenovirus type 7 exhibited intermediate activity. Correlation of the structural and functional data suggests that the VA RNAII species adopt a structure different from those of the other VA RNA species and may play a different role in the life cycle of the virus.

Organization of the double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase DAI and virus-associated VA RNAI in adenovirus-2-infected HeLa cells

We have examined the cellular distribution of the double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase DAI in adenovirus 2 (Ad2)-infected and uninfected HeLa cells. In uninfected cells DAI was found to be concentrated in the cytoplasm. In addition, DAI was localized in the nucleoli and diffusely distributed throughout the nucleoplasm. Cells treated with alpha-interferon displayed a similar pattern of distribution for DAI. When RNA polymerase I activity was inhibited by the drug actinomycin D, nucleoli segregated and DAI was found to colocalize with the dense fibrillar region of the nucleoli. During mitosis, the distribution of DAI paralleled that of rRNA. In adenovirus-infected cells the localization of DAI was similar to that in uninfected interphase cells. VA RNAI was detected in Ad2-infected cells by 10–14 hours post-infection as fine dots in the nucleoplasm. By 18–24 hours post-infection, VA RNAI appeared in bigger and more abundant dots in the nucleoplasm and the cytoplasm was intensively labeled. Transient expression of the VA RNAI gene in uninfected cells resulted in a similar localization of the RNA. Our results are consistent with a role for DAI and VA RNAI in protein synthesis and suggest that DAI may play an early role in ribosome biogenesis in the nucleolus in addition to its cytoplasmic role in translation.

Mutational analysis of the central domain of adenovirus virus-associated RNA mandates a revision of the proposed secondary structure

Protein synthesis in adenovirus-infected cells is regulated during the late phase of infection. The rate of initiation is maintained by a small viral RNA, virus-associated (VA) RNAI, which prevents the phosphorylation of eukaryotic initiation factor eIF-2 by a double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase, DAI. On the basis of nuclease sensitivity analysis, a secondary-structure model was proposed for VA RNA. The model predicts a complex stem-loop structure in the central part of the molecule, the central domain, joining two duplexed stems. The central domain is required for the inhibition of DAI activation and participates in the binding of VA RNA to DAI. To assess the significance of the postulated stem-loop structure in the central domain, we generated compensating, deletion, and substitution mutations. A substitution mutation which disrupts the structure in the central domain abolishes VA RNA function in vitro and in vivo. Base-compensating mutations failed to restore the function or structure of the mutant, implying that the stem-loop structure may not exist. To confirm this observation, we tested mutants with alterations in the hypothetical loop and short stem that constitute the main features of the wild-type model structure. The upper part of the hypothetical loop could be deleted without abolishing the ability of the RNA to block DAI activation in vitro, whereas other loop mutations were deleterious for function and caused major rearrangements in the molecule. Base-compensating mutations in the stem did not restore the expected base pairing, even though the mutant RNAs were still functional in vitro. Surprisingly, a mutant with a noncompensating substitution mutation in the stem was more effective than wild-type VA RNAI in DAI inhibition assays but was ineffective in vivo. The structural and functional consequences of these mutations do not support the proposed model structure for the central domain, and we therefore suggest an alternative structure in which tertiary interactions may play a significant role in shaping the specificity of VA RNA function in the infected cell. Discrepancies between the functionality of mutant forms of VA RNA in vivo and in vitro are consistent with the existence of additional roles for VA RNA in the cell.

Degradation of the interferon-induced 68,000-M(r) protein kinase by poliovirus requires RNA

Control of the interferon-induced double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) activated protein kinase (referred to as P68 because of its M(r) of 68,000 in human cells) by animal viruses is essential to avoid decreases in protein synthetic rates during infection. We have previously demonstrated that poliovirus establishes a unique way of regulating the protein kinase, namely by inducing the specific degradation of P68 during infection (T. L. Black, B. Safer, A. Hovanessian, and M. G. Katze, J. Virol. 63:2244-2251, 1989). In the present study we investigated the mechanisms by which P68 degradation occurred. To do this we used an in vitro degradation assay which faithfully reproduced the in vivo events. Although viral gene expression was required for P68 degradation, the major poliovirus proteases, 2A and 3C, were found not to be directly involved with P68 proteolysis. However, the protease responsible for P68 degradation required divalent cations for maximal activity and probably has both an RNA and a protein component since trypsin and ribonuclease abrogated the activity. Despite this requirement for divalent cations and RNA, activation of the kinase was not required for proteolysis since a catalytically inactive P68 was still degraded. Mapping of P68 protease-sensitive sites by using in vitro translated truncation and deletion mutants revealed that sites required for degradation resided in the amino terminus and colocalized to dsRNA-binding domains. Finally, we found that preincubation of cell extracts with the synthetic dsRNA poly(I-C) largely prevented P68 proteolysis, providing additional evidence for the critical role of RNA. On the basis of these data, we present a hypothetical model depicting possible mechanisms of P68 degradation in poliovirus-infected cells.

Role of the apical stem in maintaining the structure and function of adenovirus virus-associated RNA

Adenovirus virus-associated (VA) RNAI maintains efficient protein synthesis during the late phase of infection by preventing the activation of the double-stranded-RNA-dependent protein kinase, DAI. A secondary structure model for VA RNAI predicts the existence of two stems joined by a complex stem-loop structure, the central domain. The structural consequences of mutations and compensating mutations introduced into the apical stem lend support to this model. In transient expression assays for VA RNA function, foreign sequences inserted into the apical stem were fully tolerated provided that the stem remained intact. Mutants in which the base of the apical stem was disrupted retained partial activity, but truncation of the apical stem abolished the ability of the RNA to block DAI activation in vitro, suggesting that the length and position of the stem are both important for VA RNA function. These results imply that VA RNAI activity depends on secondary structure at the top of the apical stem as well as in the central domain and are consistent with a two-step mechanism involving DAI interactions with both the apical stem and the central domain.