New strategies for early diagnosis of heart allograft rejection

Heart Transplantation

Although the number of available donor hearts severely limits the epidemiologic impact of heart transplantation on patients with heart failure, patients with end-stage heart failure unresponsive to medical management currently have no other viable alternatives. Destination therapy with a ventricular assist device is the closest toward approaching clinical reality but has been plagued with problems of infection and stroke. The purpose of this review is to summarize recent developments in the field that may broaden the clinical impact of heart transplantation. For example, novel methods of cardiac preservation are being designed to safely evaluate and utilize “extended criteria” donors. Surgical techniques and medical management have reduced the incidence of postoperative right heart failure, and immunosuppressive regimens promise to limit chronic graft vascular disease.

T-Cell Surface Antigens and sCD30 as Biomarkers of the Risk of Rejection in Solid Organ Transplantation

T-cell activation is a characteristic of organ rejection. T cells, located in the draining lymph nodes of the transplant recipient, are faced with non-self-molecules presented by antigen presenting cells and become activated. Activated T cells are characterized by up-regulated surface antigens, such as costimulatory molecules, adhesion molecules, chemokine receptors, and major histocompatibility complex class II molecules. Surface antigen expression can be followed by flow cytometry using monoclonal antibodies in either cell function assays using donor-specific or nonspecific stimulation of isolated cells or whole blood and without stimulation on circulating lymphocytes. Molecules such as CD30 can be proteolytically cleaved off the surface of activated cells in vivo, and the determination of the soluble protein (sCD30) in serum or plasma is performed by immunoassays. As promising biomarkers for rejection and long-term transplant outcome, CD28 (costimulatory receptor for CD80 and CD86), CD154 (CD40 ligand), and sCD30 (tumor necrosis factor receptor superfamily, member 8) have been identified. Whereas cell function assays are time-consuming laboratory-developed tests which are difficult to standardize, commercial assays are frequently available for soluble proteins. Therefore, more data from clinical trials have been published for sCD30 compared with the surface antigens on activated T cells. This short review summarizes the association between selected surface antigens and immunosuppression, and rejection in solid organ transplantation.

Lymphocyte surface molecules as immune activation biomarkers

Immunosuppression is mandatory after solid organ transplantation between HLA mismatched individuals. It is a lifelong therapy that needs to be closely monitored to avoid under- and over-immunosuppression. For many drugs, pharmacokinetic monitoring has been proven to be beneficial. However, the therapeutic ranges are statistically derived surrogate markers for the effects that cannot predict the individual response of single patients. Better tailored immunosuppression biomarkers are needed that indicate immune activation. T cells are critically involved in organ rejection, and the means to assess their activation state may be promising to individualize immunosuppressive therapies. Activated T cells can be monitored with flow cytometry based on surface molecules that are typically up regulated or with molecules that are cleaved off the cell surface. Among these molecules are the interleukin-2 receptor (CD25); transferrin receptor (CD71); the T cell co-stimulatory molecules CD28, CD69, and CD154 and sCD30, which is a member of the TNF-alpha family. The effect of immunosuppressive drugs on T cell activation can be recorded with indirect cell function assays or by directly monitoring activated T cells in whole blood. Soluble proteins can be measured with immunoassays. This review provides a summary of the experimental and clinical studies investigating the potential of surface molecules as a tool for immune monitoring. It critically discusses the obstacles and shortcomings from an analytical and diagnostic perspective that are currently preventing their use in multicenter trials and clinical routine monitoring of transplant patients.

Pathways of major histocompatibility complex allorecognition

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Here, we review the pathways of allorecognition and their potential relevance to the balance between regulatory and effector responses following transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Transplantation between nonidentical members of the same species elicits an immune response that manifests as graft rejection or persistence. Presentation of foreign antigen to recipient T cells can occur via three nonmutually exclusive routes, the direct, indirect and semi-direct pathways. Allospecific T cells can have effector or regulatory functions, and the relative proportions of the two populations activated following alloantigen presentation are two of the factors that determine the clinical outcome. Regulatory T cells have been the subject of significant research, and there is now greater understanding of their recruitment and function in the context of allorecognition.

SUMMARY

A greater understanding of the mechanisms underlying allorecognition may be fundamental to appreciating how these different populations are recruited and could in turn inform novel strategies for immunomodulation.

Pathways of major histocompatibility complex allorecognition

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Here, we review the pathways of allorecognition and their potential relevance to the balance between regulatory and effector responses following transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Transplantation between nonidentical members of the same species elicits an immune response that manifests as graft rejection or persistence. Presentation of foreign antigen to recipient T cells can occur via three nonmutually exclusive routes, the direct, indirect and semi-direct pathways. Allospecific T cells can have effector or regulatory functions, and the relative proportions of the two populations activated following alloantigen presentation are two of the factors that determine the clinical outcome. Regulatory T cells have been the subject of significant research, and there is now greater understanding of their recruitment and function in the context of allorecognition.

SUMMARY

A greater understanding of the mechanisms underlying allorecognition may be fundamental to appreciating how these different populations are recruited and could in turn inform novel strategies for immunomodulation.

Monitoring of indirect allorecognition: wishful thinking or solid data?

Monitoring of T cells involved in the alloimmune response after transplantation requires the availability of reliable in vitro assays for the detection of T cells with both direct and indirect allospecificity. While generally accepted assays exist to measure helper and cytotoxic T cells involved in direct allorecognition, consensus about an assay for monitoring indirect T-cell allorecognition in clinical transplantation is lacking. Many studies claim a relationship between the reactivity of T cells with indirect allospecificity and graft rejection, but different protocols are used and essential controls are often lacking. In this review, the disadvantages and pitfalls of the current approaches are discussed, in some cases supported by the results of our own in vitro experiments. We conclude that an international workshop is necessary to establish and validate a uniform, robust and reliable assay for the monitoring of transplant recipients and to study the actual role of indirect allorecognition in acute and chronic rejection.

Expression of HLA Molecules on Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes: A Useful Monitoring Parameter in Cardiac Transplantation

During the rejection process of cardiac allografts, the expression of HLA antigens increases on various graft tissues, ie, the myocardium and the interstitial structures. However, in this type of transplant there is a paucity of knowledge about HLA expression on recipient cells, such as peripheral blood mononuclear cells. In the present study expression of HLA class I and class II antigens was monitored on peripheral blood lymphocytes prior to and during a 12-month follow-up, using flow cytometry. In our series, the frequency of acute rejection episodes was greater from the fourth to the ninth month after transplantation, coinciding with a reduction in cyclosporine blood levels. At the same time, expression of HLA class I and class II antigens significantly increased among recipients suffering from more severe acute rejection episodes compared with those showing acceptance of their grafts (P < .01). In conclusion, acute rejection episodes in cardiac transplantation were associated with up-regulation of HLA molecules on recipient peripheral blood cells. Monitoring the expression of HLA molecules on peripheral blood lymphocytes may represent an easy, noninvasive practice to individualize immunosuppressive therapy.

Differential White Cell Count Relationships With Human Cardiac Allograft Rejection

The focus of research in allograft rejection has targeted the lymphocyte, with little attention given to the neutrophil. Recent data indicate that a perioperative neutrophil influx into the cardiac allograft influences early rejection. Factors that influence neutrophil transendothelial migration might offer predictive markers of rejection. We explored the relationship between the number of circulating neutrophils in heart transplant recipients and the development of rejection. Differential white cell counts were obtained prior to transplantation and concurrently with subsequent endomyocardial rejection surveillance biopsies for 53 heart transplant recipients undergoing 410 biopsies. Preoperative differential white cell counts had no relationship with rejection. In the first 3 months after transplantation, no relationship was found between contemporary differential white cell counts and rejection. However, more than 3 months following surgery, rejection grade positively correlated on univariate analysis with neutrophil counts and the usage of cyclosporine, prednisolone, and mycophenolate. There was no relationship with eosinophils or lymphocytes. Multivariate analysis demonstrated a persistent relationship among rejection severity, neutrophil count, and prednisolone usage. A significant positive association of higher steroid usage with higher rejection grades must reflect efforts to treat patients with rejection. The significant association of higher neutrophil counts with higher rejection severity might suggest a pathological contribution to rejection. However, given the neutrophilia response to acute steroid administration, we must conclude that the neutrophil association was related to steroid administration. The absence of a relationship between white cell counts and rejection suggests that functional rather than antiproliferative strategies may offer the greatest therapeutic potential.

A novel flow assay for the detection of cytokine secreting alloreactive T cells: application to immune monitoring

The direct and indirect allorecognition pathways play an important role in graft rejection. We hypothesized that the presence of alloreactive memory T cells in the recipient's circulation increases the risk of rejection after transplantation. The objective of this study was to develop a noninvasive, immune monitoring tool that simultaneously measures donor-specific responses via both the direct and indirect recognition pathways. Our laboratory developed a whole blood flow cytometric cytokine secretion assay to identify interferon (IFN)-gamma secreting memory T cells in whole blood of renal transplant patients. The assay readily detected IFN-gamma producing CD3+ T cells in response to recall antigens tetanus toxoid, purified protein derivative, and alloantigens in whole blood from healthy controls. Analysis of sequential posttransplant blood samples from 19 renal allograft recipients showed that alloimmune responses were higher in transplant recipients who had undergone acute rejection than in those without acute rejection episodes. In addition, patients showing increased creatinine levels 3 months after transplantation were more likely to exhibit alloimmune responses than recipients with stable graft function. The flow cytokine secretion assay provides a reliable and simple method for identification of patients at risk of acute rejection and early graft dysfunction.

Immunoglobulin M-to-Immunoglobulin G Anti-Human Leukocyte Antigen Class II Antibody Switching in Cardiac Transplant Recipients Is Associated With an Increased Risk of Cellular Rejection and Coronary Artery Disease

Background— Activation of T cells induces immunoglobulin (Ig)M-to-IgG B-cell isotype switching via costimulatory regulatory pathways. Because rejection of transplanted organs is preceded by alloantigen-dependent T-cell activation, we investigated whether B-cell isotype switching could predict acute cellular rejection and the subsequent development of transplantation-related coronary artery disease (TCAD) in cardiac transplant recipients.

Methods and Results— Among 267 nonsensitized heart transplant recipients, switching from IgM to IgG anti-human leukocyte antigens (HLA) antibodies directed against class II but not against class I antigens was associated with a shorter duration to high-grade rejection, defined as International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation grade 3A or higher ( P <0.001), a higher cumulative rejection frequency ( P =0.002), accelerated development of TCAD ( P =0.04), and decreased late survival ( P =0.03). Conversely, the persistence of IgM anti-HLA antibodies against class II but not against class I antigens for >30 days and the lack of IgG isotype switching were associated with protection against both acute rejection ( P =0.02) and TCAD ( P =0.05). Alloisotype switching coincided with T-cell activation, as evidenced by increased serum levels of soluble CD40 ligand costimulatory molecules. Finally, a case-control study showed that reduction of cardiac allograft rejection by mycophenolic acid was accompanied by reduced CD40 ligand serum levels and the prevention of IgM-to-IgG anti-HLA class II antibody switching.

Conclusions— T-cell-dependent B-cell isotype switching and the consequent production of IgG anti-HLA class II antibodies are strongly correlated with acute cellular rejection, a high incidence of recurrent rejections, TCAD, and poor long-term survival. Detecting this isotype switch is a clinically useful surrogate marker for in vivo T-cell activation and may provide a noninvasive approach for monitoring the efficacy of T-cell targeted immunosuppressive therapy in heart transplant recipients.

Immunologic monitoring

The development of reliable in vitro assays that could allow the quantitation and characterization of anti-donor alloimmune responses has always been a goal in clinical transplantation, both to predict presensitization to the transplanted tissue and to be able to identify rejection without resorting to more invasive tests. With recent development in our understanding of transplantation biology and therapeutics, there is a real expectation that these tests may be used to identify tolerance as much as to predict rejection. The traditional limiting dilution assays still have a contribution to make and are being complemented by an array of tools, such as ELISpot, flow cytometry-based techniques, and microarray analysis. The assays that have been informative, to date, are discussed in this review. This information will lead, at least, to a better understanding of how and when the rejection process occurs. More interestingly, the objective is to apply this information to evaluate tolerance-inducing strategies or to identify patients that have become tolerant to their graft and can be weaned of immunosuppression. Of course sensitive, accurate and specific immunologic monitoring has applications well beyond the field of transplantation.

Use of rapamycin slows progression of cardiac transplantation vasculopathy

BACKGROUND

Cardiac transplantation vasculopathy is the leading cause of late death in heart transplantation recipients. Rapamycin is an immunosuppressant drug with potent antiproliferative and antimigratory effects. We investigated whether rapamycin could prevent progression of graft vasculopathy in 46 patients (age, 54+/-10 years; 4.3+/-2.3 years after transplantation) with severe disease.

METHODS AND RESULTS

At annual cardiac catheterization, patients were randomly assigned to treatment with rapamycin (n=22) versus continued current immunosuppression (n=24). Clinical characteristics including recipient age and sex, underlying cause of congestive heart failure, donor age and sex, and ischemic time were recorded. Cardiac catheterization was graded with the use of a semiquantitative scale and repeated annually. Clinically significant adverse events were defined as death, need for angioplasty or bypass surgery, myocardial infarction, and a >25% worsening of the catheterization score. These events were monitored as primary study end points. Anti-HLA class I and II antibody production and lymphocyte growth assays were measured with each biopsy. Patients selected for rapamycin had azathioprine or mycophenolate mofetil discontinued and were given rapamycin. Outcomes were compared by means of log-rank analysis. There were no significant differences in baseline characteristics. Duration of follow-up was comparable (rapamycin, 689+/-261; control, 630+/-207 days; NS). In the rapamycin group, 3 patients reached primary end points versus 14 patients in the control group (P<0.001). There was no difference in baseline or subsequent anti-HLA class I or II antibody production.

CONCLUSIONS

In this patient cohort with cardiac vasculopathy, treatment with rapamycin slowed disease progression probably by its antiproliferative and antimigratory effects.

Interactions between the recipient immune system and the left ventricular assist device surface: immunological and clinical implications

The unquestionable clinical success of left ventricular assist device (LVAD) implantation has, nevertheless, been accompanied by complications arising from interactions between the implanted biomaterial and the host immune system. The aberrant state of monocyte and T-cell activation resulting from these host/device interactions is accompanied by two parallel processes: (1) selective loss of Th1 cytokine producing CD4 T-cells through activation-induced cell death; and (2) unopposed activation of Th2 cytokine producing CD4 T-cells resulting in B-cell hyperreactivity and dysregulated immunoglobulin synthesis through Th2 cytokines and heightened CD40 ligand-CD40 interactions. The net results of these events is that, on the one hand, the LVAD recipient develops progressive defects in cellular immunity and is at increased risk of serious infection, and, on the other hand, is more likely to develop allosensitization, posing a significant risk to successful transplant outcome. Intravenous immunoglobulin therapy is an effective and safe modality for sensitized LVAD recipients awaiting cardiac transplantation, reducing serum anti-human lymphoicyte antigen (HLA) alloreactivity and shortening the duration to transplantation. The therapeutic and safety profile of intravenous immunoglobulin would appear to be superior to plasmapheresis. Immunosuppression incorporating intravenous cyclophosphamide before and after transplantation is safe and highly effective in sensitized LVAD recipients of cardiac transplantation. When used after transplantation as part of triple immunosuppressive regimens, cyclophosphamide is superior to mycophenolate mofetil in reducing episodes of allograft rejection in these patients. Because these immune dysfunctions appear to be related to the effects of excessive biomaterial-associated T-cell activation, future efforts will need to be directed at either altering the physical properties of the materials interacting with the host circulation or pharmacological intervention aimed more selectively at inhibiting T-cell activation.

Interleukin-2 receptor blockade in cardiac transplantation: influence of HLA-DR locus incompatibility on treatment efficacy

BACKGROUND

Because allograft rejection results from specific T-cell activation by donor human leukocyte antigens (HLA), new immunomodulatory therapies for organ-transplant recipients are used to selectively block T-cell activity without global immunosuppression. We investigated whether blockade of the high-affinity interleukin (IL)-2 receptor effectively prevented T-cell alloreactivity in cardiac transplantation.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A study of a humanized monoclonal antibody against the high-affinity IL-2 receptor (daclizumab) was performed in 70 adult, cardiac-transplant recipients. Patients were stratified based on the degree of donor-recipient HLA-DR matches. Primary and secondary endpoints were incidence and frequency of high-grade allograft rejections, IL-2-dependent, T-cell outgrowth from biopsy sites as measured by lymphocyte growth assay, and production of anti-HLA antibodies. Treatment with daclizumab significantly prevented development of high-grade acute rejection in recipients with at least one donor HLA-DR locus match during the first 3 months posttransplantation; in this group 0 of 13 (0%) treated with daclizumab experienced at least one high-grade rejection versus 3 of 13 (23%) controls (P=0.05). In addition, 1 of 12 (9%) daclizumab-treated patients experienced one or more episodes of IL-2-dependent, T-cell outgrowth versus 5 of 12 (42%) patients in the untreated group (P=0.05). In contrast, daclizumab used at the same dose and schedule was not as effective in fully HLA-DR-mismatched recipients. After cessation of daclizumab, allograft rejection increased to levels seen in controls.

CONCLUSIONS

IL-2-receptor blockade is effective for preventing alloreactivity and high-grade rejection in cardiac transplantation; however, its efficacy seemed to be influenced by the degree of donor-recipient, HLA-DR locus mismatching.

Immunobiologic consequences of assist devices

The aberrant state of monocyte and T-cell activation resulting from these host-device interaction is accompanied by two parallel processes: (1) selective loss of Th1 cytokine-producing CD4 T cells through activation-induced cell death, and (2) unopposed activation of Th2 cytokine-producing CD4 T cells resulting in B-cell hyperreactivity and dysregulated immunoglobulin synthesis via Th2 cytokines and heightened CD40 ligand-CD40 interactions. The net result of these events is that on one hand the VAD recipient develops progressive defects in cellular immunity and is at increased risk of serious infection, and on the other hand the VAD recipient is more likely to develop allosensitization, posing a significant risk to successful transplant outcome.

Regulatory functions of human CD4(+) T cells recognizing allopeptides in the context of self-HLA class II

Pretransplant blood transfusions sharing one human leukocyte antigen DR (HLA-DR) with the recipient have been shown to enhance graft survival, whereas HLA-DR mismatched blood transfusions will lead to immunization of the patient. The involvement of self HLA-DR suggests a role for CD4(+) regulatory T cells recognizing allopeptides in the context of self HLA class II molecules. Specific immunoregulation may be due to recognition of these allopeptides in the DR molecules of autologous T cells or dendritic cells. We tested this hypothesis on the basis of the reactivity of cell line ThoU6 which recognizes a peptide derived from an allo DR3 molecule, in the context of self DPB1*0301, and EL26, a CD4(+) T-cell clone recognizing HLA-A2 peptide in the presence of DRB1*1501. Addition of the line and clone to an assay in which the alloreactive cytotoxic T cell response (in a limiting dilution analysis) of PBLs sharing the restriction element was measured, resulted in a suppression of the anti-donor response but only when the proper peptide was added. These regulatory CD4(+) T cells were cytotoxic for targets presenting the proper peptide in the context of self MHC class II. Furthermore, these cells produced IL-10 after stimulation with the specific MHC/peptide combinations. Despite the similarity in function, EL26 and ThoU6 showed some differences in their phenotypic characteristics. Although both were CD25(+), EL26 expressed surface TGF-beta and CTLA-4, while ThoU6 did not. Similar regulatory T cells may explain the enhanced graft survival after HLA-DR shared blood transfusions either by their interaction with autologous alloreactive T cells or by modulation of autologous dendritic cells presenting the peptide involved.

Oligoclonal CD4(+) T cell expansions in lung transplant recipients with obliterative bronchiolitis

Obliterative bronchiolitis (OB) is a dreaded and frequent complication of lung transplantation with a poorly understood immunopathogenesis. To further evaluate disease mechanisms, we used T cell antigen receptor (TCR) beta-chain variable region RNase protection assays, after polymerase chain reaction amplification of TCR cDNA, to quantitate circulating CD4(+) and CD8(+) repertoires of transplant recipients with OB or no evidence of rejection (NER). All six recipients with OB had markedly abnormal CD4 expansions (2.5 +/- 0.5 expansions/recipient) attributable to oligoclonal proliferations. Only two of six recipients with NER had a single, much lesser, CD4(+) abnormality each (p < 0.01). Moreover, one of these patients developed OB shortly thereafter, and the other NER abnormality may have predated transplantation. In contrast, CD8(+) expansions were common in both recipient populations. Findings of CD4(+) expansions had 100% sensitivity and 80% specificity for the presence or imminent development of OB. These data suggest proliferations of CD4(+) T cells are important in OB pathogenesis, and these are most likely part of a major histocompatibility complex Class II-dependent process of indirect alloantigen presentation. These CD4(+) clones are likely to have facultative helper functions for the multiple and diverse immune processes that have been implicated in OB. Furthermore, the close association of CD4(+) expansions with OB raises possibilities of development of novel diagnostic and therapeutic approaches.

Propagation of activated T lymphocytes from endomyocardial biopsy samples of cardiac allografts: influence of the addition of recombinant interleukin-4 to the culture environment

In vivo, activated T cells can be propagated from endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) samples of cardiac allografts in cultures containing recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). However, T cells are sometimes not propagated in such cultures, even when rejection is present, and at other times the yield of lymphocytes is too small to allow further studies of these graft-infiltrating cells. The current study investigated the effects of the addition of recombinant interleukin-4 (rIL-4) to the culture environment. Cultures were performed on 532 consecutive EMB samples from 120 adult and pediatric heart transplant recipients. Each sample was divided into multiple fragments. Half of the fragments were cultured in media containing 30 U/mL of rIL-2 and the remaining half were cultured under identical conditions but with the addition of 200 U/mL of rIL-4. After 14 days, cell counts were performed, the cell phenotypes were assessed by flow cytometry, and donor specificity and cytotoxicity were assessed using the primed lymphocyte test (PLT) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assay, respectively. Lymphocyte growth occurred in 18% of grade 0-1a EMB in the presence of rIL-2 and in 29% of grade 0-1a EMB in the presence of rIL-2/rIL-4 (p = 0.02). For higher-grade EMB (equivalent to grade >or=1b), the proportion of positive cultures (approximately 39%) was similar in both conditions. For positive cultures, there was a 5-fold increase in the number of cells in the rIL-2/4 cultures compared to rIL-2 alone (1.6 x 10(6) versus 3.4 x 10(5)). Flow cytometry revealed an increase in the proportion of CD8+ cells in the rIL-2/4 cultures (42% versus 23%, p = 0.004). Proliferative responses to donor antigens (as assessed by using the PLT) were comparable between the two groups, but donor-specific cell-mediated cytotoxicity was enhanced on addition of rIL-4. Hence, addition of rIL-4 enhances the propagation of donor-specific T cells from heart biopsy samples, especially in the presence of minimal rejection. This will provide a greater quantity of material for further studies of graft-infiltrating cells.

Cellular methods used to evaluate the immune response in transplantation

Cellular assays have been developed to test for various effector, cytotoxic, and regulatory functions of T cells and have been used throughout the history of clinical transplantation to assess the immune profile of solid organ and marrow recipients. One goal of these cellular studies has been to determine if posttransplant changes in the donor antigen-specific cellular response could predict good and poor graft outcome, thereby allowing for individualization of immunosuppression. This review outlines the use of established and newly developed cellular assays to assess the dynamic processes of the posttransplant immune response and to provide insights into the mechanisms involved and potential points for intervention.

Synthetic HLA-A2 derived peptides are recognized and presented in renal graft recipients

Indirect presentation of allogeneic MHC antigen is an important pathway by which allografts are rejected and tolerance maintained by regulatory CD4(+) T cells. In this study HLA-A2 derived synthetic peptides were used to determine whether T cells of non-HLA-A2 renal graft recipients, which had been HLA-A2 mismatched to their organ donors, recognize some of the HLA-A2-derived peptides. Among the HLA-A2 mismatched patients, 60% recognized residues 56--69, 65--79, and 75--89. Peripheral blood lymphocytes derived from healthy individuals showed low reactivity towards allopeptides, indicating that sensitization towards HLA-A2 induced response towards HLA-A2 derived peptides. The response to the peptides was blocked by antibodies to HLA-DR, -DQ, and CD4. Depletion of antigen presenting cells abrogated response towards the allopeptides, confirming that the observed proliferation was mediated by the indirect pathway. Interestingly, although none of the HLA-A2 mismatched patients had any signs for either acute or chronic rejection, considerable response to allo-derived HLA-A2 was observed.

Immunobiology of left ventricular assist devices

The increasing use of implanted biomaterial devices has made it evident that no material is biologically inert. As a result of direct contact with elements of the blood circulation, such as during hemodialysis or after left ventricular assist device (LVAD) implantation, significant changes in systemic immunologic and thrombostatic functions occur. The clinical success of LVAD implantation has, nevertheless, been accompanied by complications arising from an aberrant state of monocyte and T-cell activation, leading to heightened susceptibility of circulating CD4 T cells to undergo activation-induced cell death; this results in progressive defects in cellular immunity and an increased risk of serious infection. Because of the increased state of T-cell activation and the selective loss of Th1 cytokine producing CD4 T cells, LVAD recipients also develop B-cell hyperreactivity and dysregulated immunoglobulin syntheses by unopposed production of Th2 cytokines and increased CD40 Ligand-CD40 interactions. LVADs are currently being evaluated as a permanent therapy for end-stage heart failure. Because these immune dysfunctions appear to be related to the effects of excessive biomaterial associated T-cell activation, future efforts will need to be directed at either altering the physical properties of the materials interacting with the host circulation or pharmacological intervention aimed at inhibiting T-cell activation.

Prevention of rejection in cardiac transplantation by blockade of the interleukin-2 receptor with a monoclonal antibody

BACKGROUND

Alloantigen-activated T cells express the high-affinity interleukin-2 receptor. Specific blockade of this receptor with the human IgG1 monoclonal antibody daclizumab may prevent rejection of allografts after cardiac transplantation without inducing global immunosuppression.

METHODS

We randomly assigned 55 nonsensitized patients undergoing a first cardiac transplantation to receive either induction therapy with daclizumab (1.0 mg per kilogram of body weight), given intravenously within 24 hours after cardiac-transplantation surgery and every two weeks thereafter, for a total of five doses, or generalized immunosuppressive therapy. Concomitant immunosuppression was achieved in both groups with cyclosporine, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisone. The primary end points were the incidence and severity of acute rejection, and the length of time to a first episode of biopsy-confirmed rejection.

RESULTS

Of the 55 patients in the study, 28 were randomly assigned to receive daclizumab and 27 served as the control group. During induction therapy, the mean frequency of acute rejection episodes (defined as a histologic grade of 2 or higher according to the classification of the International Society of Heart and Lung Transplants) was 0.64 per patient in the control group and 0.19 per patient in the daclizumab group (P=0.02). Acute rejection developed in 17 of 27 patients in the control group (63 percent), as compared with 5 of 28 patients in the daclizumab group (18 percent; relative risk, 2.8; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.1 to 7.4; P=0.04). Throughout follow-up, there were nine patients with episodes of acute rejection of histologic grade 3 in the control group, as compared with two in the daclizumab group (P= 0.03), and the time to a first episode of rejection was significantly longer in the daclizumab group (P=0.04). There were no adverse reactions to daclizumab and no significant differences between the groups in the incidence of infection or cancer during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Induction therapy with daclizumab safely reduces the frequency and severity of cardiac-allograft rejection during the induction period.

The use and misuse of immunologic monitoring after transplantation: approaches that have proved useful

Current practice in the monitoring of cardiac transplants revolves around the use of the endomyocardial biopsy. While this is effective for the identification of an ongoing immune response in the graft, for years investigators have explored less invasive approaches in the hope of achieving the same goal by examining the patient's immune response. For a number of years, lymphocytes, their subsets, and their level of activation in the periphery were investigated. To a large degree, it was a lack of specificity in these approaches that led to their falling out of favor. Examination of donor-specific reactivity by means of lymphocyte proliferation assays has also been used; however, these approaches have been impeded by the time and effort required to accomplish them. During the last few years, flow cytometric cross-matching during the posttransplant period has been used at our institution. While this cross-matching focuses on the humoral immune responses, we have found it to be of value in identifying patients at risk of rejection and in allowing the assessment of treatment modalities used to treat ongoing rejection. While the perfect approach remains to be found, the potential advantages of immunologic monitoring would seem to justify continued study.

New method for detection of heart allograft rejection: validation of sensitivity and reliability in a rat heterotopic allograft model

BACKGROUND

Patients with inflammatory heart muscle diseases would benefit from a safe, convenient, rapidly performed diagnostic technique with real-time results not involving tissue removal. We have performed a detailed evaluation of detection of heart allograft rejection by autofluorescence in a heterotopic abdominal rat heart allograft model ex vivo.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Recipient rats with allograft (Lewis to Fisher 344; n=71) and isograft (Lewis to Lewis; n=33) hearts, treated with cyclosporine or untreated, were killed at days 2, 4, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 56 after transplant. Nontransplant controls with (n=24) or without (n=24) immunosuppressive therapy were also studied. When the rats were killed, autofluorescence spectra were acquired under blue-light excitation from midtransverse ventricular sections of native and transplanted hearts. Corresponding sections were then evaluated pathologically by a modified International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation (ISHLT) grading schema. The spectral differences between rejecting and nonrejecting hearts were quantified by linear discriminant functions, producing scores that decreased progressively with increasing severity of tissue rejection. Mean+/-SD discriminant function scores were 2.9+/-1.6, 1.8+/-2.2, -0.1+/-2.8, -1.2+/-2.3, and -2.3+/-3.0 for isografts and allograft ISHLT grades 0, I, II, and III, respectively (Spearman rank-order correlation -0.6; P<0.001, test for trend). Cyclosporine had no detectable effect on the spectra.

CONCLUSIONS

The correlation between changes in autofluorescence spectra and ISHLT rejection grade strongly supports the possibility of catheter-based, fluorescence-guided surveillance of rejection.

Donor cell induced CD69 expression and intracellular IL-2 and IL-4 production by peripheral blood lymphocytes isolated from kidney transplant recipients

Flow cytometry assays, which measure CD69 activation and intracellular cytokine production, have been used to measure peripheral blood lymphocyte (PBL) responses to in vitro antigen exposure. In the present study, we show that, in healthy individuals and immunosuppressed kidney transplant recipients, CD69 expression and intracellular cytokine production by peripheral blood T cells compare favorably to thymidine uptake as a measure of PBL response to alloantigen in mixed leukocyte culture (MLC). Heparinized whole blood from 23 healthy individuals was incubated for 24-48 h with 3rd party allogeneic monocytes; blood from twelve kidney transplant recipients was incubated with monocytes from their kidney donor and with monocytes from unrelated individuals. The percentage of T cells expressing surface CD69 or intracellular IL-2 or IL-4 was determined by 3-color flow cytometry. We identified 5 donor-specific response patterns in our kidney transplant group. One transplant recipient was hyporesponsive; his cells did not express CD69 or produce IL-2 in response to either donor or 3rd party allogeneic cells. All other transplant recipients expressed CD69 and IL-2 in response to 3rd party allogeneic cells. Two had no response to donor cells (donor-specific hyporesponsiveness), three had donor-specific anergy (CD69 expression without cytokine production in response to donor cells), five had a donor-specific Thl response (CD69 expression and IL-2 production in response to donor cells), and one had a donor-specific Th2 response (CD69 expression and IL-4 but not IL-2 production in response to donor cells). Rapid measures of donor-specific hyporesponsiveness such as CD69 activation antigen expression and intracellular cytokine production may prove valuable in monitoring lymphocyte function and aid in the long-term management of kidney transplant recipients.

Preformed IgG antibodies against major histocompatibility complex class II antigens are major risk factors for high-grade cellular rejection in recipients of heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Preformed anti-HLA antibodies reacting specifically with donor lymphocytes have been associated with acute vascular rejection and early cardiac allograft failure. However, the effect of preformed anti-HLA antibodies directed against allogeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I or II antigens of a donor panel on heart transplantation outcome has not been extensively studied.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The study group consisted of 68 patients who received cardiac transplants between 1989 and 1996 and who were at high risk for developing anti-HLA antibodies before transplantation. The effect of preformed antibodies against allogeneic MHC class I or class II antigens on the development of early high-grade cellular rejection and on cumulative annual rejection frequency was determined. Both patients with left ventricular assist devices and retransplantation candidates had a similar increase in the frequency of IgG anti-MHC class II antibodies (IgG anti-II) compared with control subjects (P<0.0001), whereas the frequency of IgG anti-MHC class I antibodies (IgG anti-I) was elevated only in patients with left ventricular assist devices. Pretransplantation IgG anti-II predicted early development of high-grade cellular rejection (P=0.006) and higher cumulative annual rejection frequency (P<0.001) in both of these sensitized patient groups. Among retransplantation recipients, a match between donors 1 and 2 at HLA-A additionally predicted an earlier time to a high-grade cellular rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

These results emphasize the importance of specifically screening heart transplantation candidates for the presence of IgG antibodies directed against MHC class II molecules and suggest that strategies aimed at their reduction may have an impact on the onset and frequency of high-grade cellular rejections after transplantation.

Intramolecular and intermolecular spreading during the course of organ allograft rejection

There are two distinct pathways by which T cells may recognize MHC alloantigens. The direct pathway involves T-cell recognition of intact MHC molecules expressed by donor antigen-presenting cells (APCs). The second, or indirect, pathway describes T-cell recognition of peptides derived from the processing and presentation of allogeneic MHC molecules on self APCs. Recent data demonstrates that indirect recognition plays a central role in both acute and chronic rejection of human organ allografts. Our studies have shown that, at the onset of primary acute rejection, recipient T-cell responses to donor HLA-DR alloantigens are limited to a single dominant determinant present on one of the disparate alloantigens and restricted by one of the responder's HLA-DR molecules. In allograft recipients with recurring episodes of rejection, and/or at the onset of chronic rejection, recipient T-cell reactivity may spread to other epitopes within the allogeneic MHC molecule as well as to other alloantigens expressed by graft tissue. Both quantitative and qualitative alterations in T-cell allopeptide reactivity are associated with increased risk of cellular and/or humoral rejection. These studies provide a basis for the design of new therapeutic strategies and for immunologic monitoring of transplant recipients.

An immunological algorithm to predict risk of high-grade rejection in cardiac transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Transplant-related coronary-artery disease (TCAD) develops frequently in cardiac-allograft recipients, and limits long-term survival. We examined the relation between this disorder and cumulative frequency of high-grade rejection, and investigated whether concomitant use of three immunological factors at the time of a low-grade endomyocardial biopsy can predict progression to high-grade rejection.

METHODS

We investigated the relation between the cumulative annual frequency of high-grade rejection and TCAD in 198 recipients of cardiac transplantation between 1992 and 1996 by means of Kaplan-Meier actuarial life-tables. Endomyocardial biopsy, lymphocyte-growth assays, and anti-HLA antibody measurements were compiled over 12 months in 102 patients during their first post-transplant year. We calculated predictive values for high-grade rejection within 90 days by chi2, Kaplan Meier survival curves, and by multivariable logistic regression analyses.

FINDINGS

We found a direct correlation between cumulative annual frequency of rejection and TCAD onset with highest risk in those with more than 0.75 rejections per year (p=0.0002). After a low-grade endomyocardial biopsy (0 or 1A), one or more donor-recipient HLA-DR matches protected against high-grade rejections (p<0.001). Among individuals with one or two DR matches, the negative predictive value for progression from a low-grade biopsy to a high-grade rejection was 87% in the presence of a negative lymphocyte-growth assay. Among individuals with no DR matches, the presence of either a positive lymphocyte-growth assay or IgG anti-major-histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antibodies was independently associated with high probability of progression to rejection (64% and 66%, respectively, p<0.0005). When both assays were positive, concomitantly with a low-grade endomyocardial biopsy, the positive predictive value for progression to a high-grade rejection was 86% (p<0.0001). For endomyocardial-biopsy grades 1B or 2, a positive lymphocyte-growth assay alone was associated with high-grade rejection in 100% of cases.

INTERPRETATION

Use of an algorithm combining three immunological factors at the time of a low-grade endomyocardial biopsy enables prospective stratification of cardiac transplant recipients into risk categories for progression to high-grade rejection. Low-risk individuals require fewer biopsies, moderate-risk individuals require an ongoing schedule of surveillance biopsies, and high-risk individuals require rational organisation of interventional strategies aimed at preventing rejection. Additional predictive factors are needed to identify moderate-risk individuals who will progress to rejection. Ultimately, successful intervention may have an impact on the subsequent complication of TCAD.

Persistent allopeptide reactivity and epitope spreading in chronic rejection of organ allografts

The role of the indirect allorecognition pathway in acute allograft rejection has been documented both in organ recipients and in experimental models. However, it is unknown whether self-restricted recognition of donor alloantigens also contributes to chronic allograft rejection. The aim of this study was to determine the relationship between allopeptide reactivity, epitope spreading, and chronic rejection. Using synthetic peptides corresponding to the hypervariable region of 32 HLA-DR alleles, we have followed the specificity of self-restricted T cell alloresponses to the donor in a population of 34 heart allograft recipients. T cells from sequential samples of blood collected from the patients up to 36 mo after transplantation were studied in limiting dilution analysis for allopeptide reactivity. The incidence of coronary artery vasculopathy (CAV) was significantly higher in patients who displayed persistent alloreactivity late after transplantation than in patients who showed no alloreactivity after the first 6 mo after transplantation. Both intra- and intermolecular spreading of epitopes was observed with an increased frequency in patients developing CAV in less than 2 yr, compared with patients without CAV; this suggests that diversification of the immune response against the graft contributes to chronic rejection. These data provide a strategy for identifying patients at risk of developing CAV and a rationale for therapeutic intervention aimed to prevent the progression of the rejection process.