Shaping the Repertoire of Cytotoxic T-Lymphocyte Responses: Explanation for the Immunodominance Effect Whereby Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes Specific for Immunodominant Antigens Prevent Recognition of Nondominant Antigens

Functional avidity-driven activation-induced cell death shapes CTL immunodominance

Immunodominance is a complex phenomenon that relies on a mere numerical concept, while being potentially influenced at every step of the immune response. We investigated the mechanisms leading to the establishment of CTL immunodominance in a retroviral model and found that the previously defined subdominant Env-specific CD8(+) T cells are endowed with an unexpectedly higher functional avidity than is the immunodominant Gag-recognizing counterpart. This high avidity, along with the Env Ag overload, results in a supraoptimal TCR engagement. The overstimulation makes Env-specific T lymphocytes more susceptible to apoptosis, thus hampering their expansion and leading to an unintentional "immune kamikazing." Therefore, Ag-dependent, hyperactivation-induced cell death can be regarded as a novel mechanism in the establishment of the immunodominance that restrains and opposes the expansion of high-avidity T cells in favor of lower-affinity populations.

Deletion of naïve T cells recognizing the minor histocompatibility antigen HY with toxin-coupled peptide-MHC class I tetramers inhibits cognate CTL responses and alters immunodominance

Alloreactive T-cell responses directed against minor histocompatibility (H) antigens, which arise from diverse genetic disparities between donor and recipient outside the MHC, are an important cause of rejection of MHC-matched grafts. Because clinically significant responses appear to be directed at only a few antigens, the selective deletion of naïve T cells recognizing donor-specific, immunodominant minor H antigens in recipients before transplantation may be a useful tolerogenic strategy. We have previously demonstrated that peptide-MHC class I tetramers coupled to a toxin can efficiently eliminate specific TCR-transgenic T cells in vivo. Here, using the minor histocompatibility antigen HY as a model, we investigated whether toxic tetramers could inhibit the subsequent priming of the two H2-D(b)-restricted, immunodominant T-cell responses by deleting precursor CTL. Immunization of female mice with male bone marrow elicited robust CTL activity against the Uty and Smcy epitopes, with Uty constituting the major response. As hypothesized, toxic tetramer administration prior to immunization increased survival of cognate peptide-pulsed cells in an in vivo CTL assay, and reduced the frequency of corresponding T cells. However, tetramer-mediated decreases in either T-cell population magnified CTL responses against the non-targeted epitope, suggesting that D(b)-Uty(+) and D(b)-Smcy(+) T cells compete for a limited common resource during priming. Toxic tetramers conceivably could be used in combination to dissect manipulate CD8(+) T-cell immunodominance hierarchies, and to prevent the induction of donor-specific, minor H antigen CTL responses in allotransplantation.

Rejection of leukemic cells requires antigen-specific T cells with high functional avidity

In a context where injection of antigen (Ag)-specific T cells probably represents the future of leukemia immunotherapy, identification of optimal target Ags is crucial. We therefore sought to discover a reliable marker for selection of the most potent Ags. To this end, (1) we immunized mice against 8 individual Ags: 4 minor histocompatibility Ags (miHAs) and 4 leukemia-associated Ags (LAAs) that were overexpressed on leukemic relative to normal thymocytes; (2) we assessed their ability to reject EL4 leukemic cells; and (3) we correlated the properties of our Ags (and their cognate T cells) with their ability to induce protective antileukemic responses. Overall, individual miHAs instigated more potent antileukemic responses than LAAs. Three features had no influence on the ability of primed T cells to reject leukemic cells: (1) MHC-peptide affinity; (2) the stability of MHC-peptide complexes; and (3) epitope density at the surface of leukemic cells, as assessed using mass spectrometry. The cardinal feature of successful Ags is that they were recognized by high-avidity CD8 T cells that proliferated extensively in vivo. Our work suggests that in vitro evaluation of functional avidity represents the best criterion for selection of Ags, which should be prioritized in clinical trials of leukemia immunotherapy.

Broadening of the T-cell repertoire to HIV-1 Gag p24 by vaccination of HLA-A2/DR transgenic mice with overlapping peptides in the CAF05 adjuvant

Induction of broad T-cell immune responses is regarded as critical for vaccines against the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) which exhibit high diversity and, therefore, focus has been on inducing cytotoxic CD8 T-cell responses against the more conserved parts of the virus, such as the Gag protein. Herein, we have used the p24 protein which contains a range of conserved T-cell epitopes. We demonstrate that a vaccine of HIV-1 subtype B consensus group-specific antigen (Gag) p24 protein with the CD8-inducing liposomal cationic adjuvant formulation (CAF) 05, induces both CD4 and CD8 T-cell responses in CB6F1 mice. The adjuvanted vaccine also induced functional antigen-specific cytotoxicity in vivo. Furthermore, we found that when fragmenting the Gag p24 protein into overlapping Gag p24 peptides, a broader T-cell epitope specificity was induced in the humanized human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A2/DR-transgenic mouse model. Thus, combining overlapping Gag p24 peptides with CAF05 appears to be a promising and simple strategy for inducing broader T-cell responses to multiple conserved epitopes which will be relevant for both prophylactic and therapeutic HIV-1 vaccines.

Increasing the efficacy of tumor cell vaccines by enhancing cross priming

Cancer immunotherapy has been attempted for more than a century, and investment has intensified in the last 20 years. The complexity of the immune system is exemplified by the myriad of immunotherapeutic approaches under investigation. While anti-tumor immunity has been achieved experimentally with multiple effector cells and molecules, particular promise is shown for harnessing the CD8 T cell response. Tumor cell-based vaccines have been employed in hundreds of clinical trials to date and offer several advantages over subunit and peptide vaccines. However, tumor cell-based vaccines, often aimed at cross priming tumor-reactive CD8 T cells, have shown modest success in clinical trials. Here we review the mechanisms of cross priming and discuss strategies to increase the efficacy of tumor cell-based vaccines. A synthesis of recent findings on tissue culture conditions, cell death, and dendritic cell activation reveals promising new avenues for clinical investigation.

HIV fragment gag vaccine induces broader T cell response in mice

Broad T-cell response is considered critical for HIV-1 vaccines to compensate viral diversity. Usually, a limited number of immunodominant epitopes are recognized in natural infections, as well as in vaccinations. Here, we seek to overcome immunofocusing of CD8 T Cell responses to HIV-1 CN54 gag DNA (delivered as a plasmid) in BalB/C mice by splitting it into fragments for reducing competition of recognition between dominant and sub-dominant epitopes. As expected, mice immunized with mixture of DNA fragments elicited significantly broader T cell responses than whole-length gag. We also further studied the effects when fragments and full-length DNA vaccines are combined for prime-boost vaccination. Interestingly, mice primed with full-length gag and boosted with DNA vaccine fragments induced similar T-cell response breadth as mice both primed and boosted by fragments DNA. In contrast, mice primed with DNA vaccine fragments and boosted with full-length gag failed to broaden T cell responses, once again, only the dominant epitopes were recognized. In summary, our study demonstrated that "fragmentation strategy" can indeed broaden T cell responses. This enhancement is more likely achieved in boosting stage. This study offers a promising way to design a vaccine with higher chance covering the highly diversified circulating strains.

Direct presentation regulates the magnitude of the CD8+ T cell response to cell-associated antigen through prolonged T cell proliferation

The magnitude and complexity of Ag-specific CD8(+) T cell responses is determined by intrinsic properties of the immune system and extrinsic factors, such as vaccination. We evaluated mechanisms that regulate the CD8(+) T cell response to two distinct determinants derived from the same protein Ag, SV40 T Ag (T Ag), following immunization of C57BL/6 mice with T Ag-transformed cells. The results show that direct presentation of T cell determinants by T Ag-transformed cells regulates the magnitude of the CD8(+) T cell response in vivo but not the immunodominance hierarchy. The immunodominance hierarchy was reversed in a dose-dependent manner by addition of excess naive T cells targeting the subdominant determinant. However, T cell competition played only a minor role in limiting T cell accumulation under physiological conditions. We found that the magnitude of the T cell response was regulated by the ability of T Ag-transformed cells to directly present the T Ag determinants. The hierarchy of the CD8(+) T cell response was maintained when Ag presentation in vivo was restricted to cross-presentation, but the presence of T Ag-transformed cells capable of direct presentation dramatically enhanced T cell accumulation at the peak of the response. This enhancement was due to a prolonged period of T cell proliferation, resulting in a delay in T cell contraction. Our findings reveal that direct presentation by nonprofessional APCs can dramatically enhance accumulation of CD8(+) T cells during the primary response, revealing a potential strategy to enhance vaccination approaches.

Enhanced protein expression by internal ribosomal entry site-driven mRNA translation as a novel approach for in vitro loading of dendritic cells with antigens

Transfection of dendritic cells (DCs) with messenger RNAs (mRNAs) of tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) is a promising strategy for cancer vaccines. TAA mRNA can be generated by in vitro transcription using DNA encoding the TAA gene as a template. A cap analog is usually added upon in vitro transcription to stabilize mRNA and enhance the efficiency of mRNA translation. However, the inclusion of the cap analog correlates with significantly lower-yield mRNA transcription, potentially leading to an expensive vaccine manufacturing process. To solve this problem, we present a novel approach in which DNA templates are modified with an internal ribosomal entry site (IRES) sequence inserted upstream of the gene of interest to replace the use of the cap analog. The presence of IRES greatly enhanced transcription for the mRNA in vitro compared with the cap analog. Also, higher transgene expression was achieved using luciferase (Luc) mRNA with IRES than using capped Luc mRNA to transfect DCs. Immunization of mice with DCs transfected with IRES-containing mRNA encoding chicken ovalbumin (OVA) induced significant levels of antigen-specific interferon gamma-producing CD8(+) T cells and in vivo killing of antigen-bearing cells. Consistently, mice immunized with IRES-containing OVA mRNA-transfected DCs were protected from pulmonary metastasis of melanoma cells injected intravenously. We suggest that IRES can be used for the production of larger quantities of mRNA and that such IRES-containing mRNAs may be useful for DC-based antitumor immunotherapy.

Portable flanking sequences modulate CTL epitope processing

Peptide presentation is critical for immune recognition of pathogen-infected cells by CD8+ T lymphocytes. Although a limited number of immunodominant peptide epitopes are consistently observed in diseases such as HIV-1 infection, the relationship between immunodominance and antigen processing in humans is largely unknown. Here, we have demonstrated that endogenous processing and presentation of a human immunodominant HIV-1 epitope is more efficient than that of a subdominant epitope. Furthermore, we have shown that the regions flanking the immunodominant epitope constitute a portable motif that increases the production and antigenicity of otherwise subdominant epitopes. We used a novel in vitro degradation assay involving cytosolic extracts as well as endogenous intracellular processing assays to examine 2 well-characterized HIV-1 Gag overlapping epitopes presented by the same HLA class I allele, one of which is consistently immunodominant and the other subdominant in infected persons. The kinetics and products of degradation of HIV-1 Gag favored the production of peptides encompassing the immunodominant epitope and destruction of the subdominant one. Notably, cytosolic digestion experiments revealed flanking residues proximal to the immunodominant epitope that increased the production and antigenicity of otherwise subdominant epitopes. Furthermore, specific point mutations in these portable flanking sequences modulated the production and antigenicity of epitopes. Such portable epitope processing determinants provide what we believe is a novel approach to optimizing CTL responses elicited by vaccine vectors.

Asynchronous differentiation of CD8 T cells that recognize dominant and cryptic antigens

Restriction of T cell responses to a few epitopes (immunodominance) is a central feature of immune responses. We analyzed the entire transcriptome of effector CD8 T cells specific for a dominant (H7(a)) and a cryptic (HY) mouse Ag and performed a longitudinal analysis of selected T cell differentiation markers. We found that Ag specificity had a relatively modest influence on the repertoire of genes that are transcriptionally modulated by the CD8 T cell differentiation program. Although the differentiation programs of anti-H7(a) and anti-HY T cells were similar, they did not progress simultaneously. The expansion peak of anti-H7(a) T cells was reached on day 10 while that of anti-HY T cells was attained on days 15-20. Between days 10 and 20, anti-H7(a) T cells were in the contraction phase and anti-HY T cells in the expansion phase. Furthermore, expansion and development of effector function were well-synchronized in anti-H7(a) T cells but were disconnected in anti-HY T cells. We propose that, by leading to selective expansion of the fittest CD8 T cells, immunodominance may be beneficial to the host. Inhibition of the T cell response to cryptic Ag would ensure that host resources (APC, cytokines) for which T cells compete are devoted to T cells with the best effector potential. One implication is that favoring expansion of the fittest effector T cells in general may be more important than increasing the diversity of the T cell repertoire.

Immunodominance and Immunodomination: Critical Factors in Developing Effective CD8+ T‐Cell–Based Cancer Vaccines

The focusing of cellular immunity toward one, or just a few, antigenic determinant, even during immune responses to complex microorganisms or antigens, is known as immunodominance. Although described in many systems, the mechanisms of determinant immunodominance are only just beginning to be appreciated, especially in relation to the interplay between T cells of differing specificities and the interactions between T cells and the antigen-presenting cells (APCs). The outcome of these cellular interactions can lead to a form of immune suppression of one specificity by another-described as "immunodomination". The specific and detailed mechanisms involved in this process are now partly defined. A full understanding of all the factors that control immunodominance and influence immunodomination will help us to develop better viral and cancer vaccines.

The structure and location of SIMP/STT3B account for its prominent imprint on the MHC I immunopeptidome

Proteins show drastic discrepancies in their contribution to the collection of self-peptides that shape the repertoire of CD8 T cells (MHC I self-immunopeptidome). To decipher why selected proteins are the foremost sources of MHC I-associated self-peptides, we chose to study SIMP/STT3B because this protein generates very high amounts of MHC I-associated peptides in mice and humans. We show that the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-associated degradation pathway and MHC I processing intersect at SIMP/STT3B. Relevant key features of SIMP/STT3B are its lysine-rich region, its propensity to misfold and its location in the ER membrane in close proximity to the immunoproteasome. Moreover, we show that coupling to SIMP/STT3B can be used to foster MHC I presentation of a selected peptide, here the ovalbumin peptide SIINFEKL. These data yield novel insights into relations between the cell proteome and the MHC I immunopeptidome. They suggest that the contribution of a given protein to the MHC I immunopeptidome results from the interplay of at least three factors: the presence of degrons (degradation signals), the tendency of the protein to misfold and its subcellular localization. Furthermore, they indicate that substrates of the ER-associated degradation pathway may have a prominent imprint on the MHC I self-immunopeptidome.

Immunodominance of HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses in acute HIV-1 infection: at the crossroads of viral and host genetics

The development of HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses during acute HIV-1 infection is associated with a dramatic decline in HIV-1 replication and the resolution of the acute retroviral syndrome. These HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T cells typically target a small number of viral epitopes in a distinct hierarchical order, and high-level viremia in chronic progressive infection leads to broadly diversified HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T-cell responses with a less clear immunodominance pattern. It is argued here that the specific hierarchical pattern of immune responses in acute HIV-1 infection is the result of a tightly regulated process that, among other factors, is critically impacted by the kinetics of viral protein expression, the HLA class I background of the infected individual and the autologous sequence of the infecting virus.

CD8 T-cell ability to exert immunodomination correlates with T-cell receptor: Epitope association rate

When presented alone, H7 a and HY antigens elicit CD8 T-cell responses of similar amplitude, but H7 a totally abrogates the response to HY when both antigens are presented on the same antigen-presenting cell. We found that H7a- and HY-specific T-cell precursors had similar frequencies in nonimmune mice and expressed similar levels of CD5. The H7a -specific CD8 T-cell repertoire harvested at the time of primary response showed highly restricted T-cell receptor (TCR) diversity. Furthermore, T cells specific for H7a and HY expressed equivalent levels of CD8 and TCR and displayed similar tetramer decay rates. The key difference was that anti-H7a T cells exhibited a much more rapid TCR:epitope on-rate than anti-HY T cells. Coupled with evidence that primed CD8 T cells limit the duration of antigen presentation by killing or inactivating antigen-presenting cells, our data support a novel and simple model for immunodomination: the main feature of T cells that exert immunodomination is that, compared with other T cells, they are functionally primed after a shorter duration of antigen presentation.

Transplantation tolerance induced by intranasal administration of HY peptides

Induction of antigen-specific tolerance to transplantation antigens is desirable to control host-versus-graft and graft-versus-host reactions. Following molecular identification of a set of minor histocompatibility (H) antigens, we have used selected HY peptide epitopes for this purpose. Intranasal administration of individual major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-restricted HY peptides induces indefinite survival of syngeneic male skin grafts and allows engraftment of male bone marrow. Tolerance involves linked suppression to additional HY epitopes on test grafts. Long-term tolerance also requires suppression of emerging thymic emigrants. It does not involve deletion. HY peptide-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells expand on re-exposure to male antigen; these expansions are smaller in tolerant than control mice and fewer HY-specific cells from tolerant females secrete interferon gamma and interleukin 10 (IL-10). Significantly, CD4(+) cells from peptide-pretreated females fail to make IL-2 responses to cognate peptide, limiting expansion of the HY-specific CD8(+) populations that can cause graft rejection. Consistent with this, tolerance induction by HY peptide is abrogated by coadministration of lipopolysaccharide. IL-10 does not appear to be critically involved because tolerance is inducible in IL-10-deficient mice. Adoptive transfer of tolerance into naive neonatal recipients by splenocytes from long-term tolerant donors provides evidence for involvement of regulatory cells.

Analysis of immunodominance among minor histocompatibility antigens in allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

In major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), donor responses are directed against multiple host minor histocompatibility antigens (mHAgs), producing graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and graft-versus-tumor (GVT) effects. We studied MHC-matched, mHAg-mismatched C3H.SW>C57BL/6 HSCT in which three mHAg are molecularly defined (B6dom1, H3, H13) to determine if there is a hierarchy of immunodominance among the mHAgs and to learn the contribution of each to GVHD. We found that B6dom1 was the immunodominant mHAg. B6dom1 did not block responses to the subdominant mHAgs H3 and H13. The mechanism of immunodominance was not mHAg avidity or affinity for class I. B6dom1 elicited a broader variety of Vbeta clonotypes than either H3 or H13. Severe GVHD could occur in the absence of a strong B6dom1 response. Alloreactivity to isolated B6dom1, H3 or H13 differences did not produce severe GVHD. We concluded that immunodominance is explained by both mHAg density on host cells and the repertoire of donor T cells capable of responding to the mHAgs. Clinically significant GVHD requires donor responses to multiple mHAgs. Modulation of responses to a single immunodominant mHAg is insufficient for the prevention of GVHD, while immunotherapies directed against isolated mHAgs may not provoke severe GVHD.

Genetically modified dendritic cells--a new, promising cancer treatment strategy?

Dendritic cells (DCs), the most potent antigen-presenting cells (APCs), were discovered almost 30 years ago. Due to the priming of antigen-specific immune responses mediated by CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes, DCs are crucial for the induction of adaptive immunity against cancer. Therefore, vaccination of cancer patients with DCs presenting tumour-associated antigens (TAAs) have been believed to be a promising anticancer strategy. Multiple clinical trials have been carried out in order to evaluate the safety and efficacy of cancer vaccines based on antigen-pulsed DCs. However, pulsing of DCs with particular peptides has several disadvantages: i) short-time duration of antigen-major histocompatability complex (MHC) complexes, ii) a requirement for matching defined peptides with MHC complexes and iii) exclusive presentation of single antigen epitopes. Application of gene transfer technologies in the field of DC-based vaccines made possible the development of novel, anticancer immunisation strategies. In several animal models, DCs modified with genes encoding TAA or immunostimulatory proteins have been shown to be effective in the induction of antitumour immune responses. Based on these encouraging results, a first clinical trial of prostate cancer patients vaccinated with gene modified DCs has recently been initiated. In this article, methods used for genetic modification of DCs and anticancer vaccination strategies based on genetically modified DCs are reviewed.

Cutting edge: competition for APC by CTLs of different specificities is not functionally important during induction of antiviral responses

The hypothesis that T cell competition for access to APC influences priming of CTL responses is a controversial issue. A recent study using OVA as a model Ag supports this hypothesis and received considerable attention. However, using a comparable approach, we reached a different conclusion. We analyzed whether TCR transgenic T cells specific for lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus gp33-41/D(b) could inhibit the priming of endogenous responses against gp33-41 and against two other lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein-derived CTL epitopes. After priming with different stimuli, gp33-41/D(b)-specific TCR transgenic T cells reduced the endogenous gp33-41/D(b) response in a dose-dependent way, but all other endogenous responses were unaffected. Even when >10(6) TCR transgenic cells were combined with weak priming, no reduction of responses other than of those specific for gp33-41/D(b) was observed. Thus, competition for APC by CTLs of different specificities is not of functional relevance in antiviral immune responses.

Anatomic location and T-cell stimulatory functions of mouse dendritic cell subsets defined by CD4 and CD8 expression

Mouse spleen contains CD4+, CD8alpha+, and CD4-/CD8alpha- dendritic cells (DCs) in a 2:1:1 ratio. An analysis of 70 surface and cytoplasmic antigens revealed several differences in antigen expression between the 3 subsets. Notably, the Birbeck granule-associated Langerin antigen, as well as CD103 (the mouse homologue of the rat DC marker OX62), were specifically expressed by the CD8alpha+ DC subset. All DC types were apparent in the T-cell areas as well as in the splenic marginal zones and showed similar migratory capacity in collagen lattices. The 3 DC subtypes stimulated allogeneic CD4+ T cells comparably. However, CD8alpha+ DCs were very weak stimulators of resting or activated allogeneic CD8+ T cells, even at high stimulator-to-responder ratios, although this defect could be overcome under optimal DC/T cell ratios and peptide concentrations using CD8+ F5 T-cell receptor (TCR)-transgenic T cells. CD8alpha- or CD8alpha+ DCs presented alloantigens with the same efficiency for lysis by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), and their turnover rate of class I-peptide complexes was similar, thus neither an inability to present, nor rapid loss of antigenic complexes from CD8alpha DCs was responsible for the low allostimulatory capacity of CD8alpha+ DCs in vitro. Surprisingly, both CD8alpha+ DCs and CD4-/CD8- DCs efficiently primed minor histocompatibility (H-Y male antigen) cytotoxicity following intravenous injection, whereas CD4+ DCs were weak inducers of CTLs. Thus, the inability of CD8alpha+ DCs to stimulate CD8+ T cells is limited to certain in vitro assays that must lack certain enhancing signals present during in vivo interaction between CD8alpha+ DCs and CD8+ T cells.

CD53, a thymocyte selection marker whose induction requires a lower affinity TCR-MHC interaction than CD69, but is up-regulated with slower kinetics

The molecular mechanisms that govern the survival, maturation and export of thymocytes are the subject of intense study, and candidates for involvement in these processes might be identified by their differential expression during thymocyte selection. One such molecule is the tetraspanin CD53, which is not expressed on most CD4(+)CD8(+) double-positive (DP) cells in the normal mouse. We have examined CD53 expression on DP from several class I- and class II-restricted TCR transgenic (Tg) mice, and have found a strong correlation between CD53 expression and positive selection. CD53 expression in DP was formally demonstrated to be dependent upon MHC recognition as evidenced by studying DP from MHC-deficient mice which totally lack expression of this molecule. This link between selection and CD53 expression was reminiscent of CD69, and indeed the majority of selected DP from normal mice that express CD53 also express CD69. We compared CD53 and CD69 induction in vitro using pre-selected thymocytes from TCR-Tg mice that were stimulated either with mAb against TCR or with antigen-presenting cells (APC) pulsed with peptides. The data shows that with either stimulus, CD69 is induced rapidly on the thymocyte surface with expression detected in as little as 2 h. CD53 induction is slower with maximal expression taking up to 20 h. We also stimulated pre-selected thymocytes from the OT-1 TCR-Tg strain with APC pulsed with peptides of varying affinities for the TCR. Here low-affinity peptides which induce CD69 expression poorly were able to induce significant levels of CD53 expression. These data demonstrate that the induction of CD53 and CD69 upon selection is not identical. Thus a combination of the CD69 and CD53 selection markers may be a powerful tool to isolate thymocytes that have either been very recently selected or have arisen from differing MHC--TCR affinity interactions during selection.

Influence of tumor vaccines on graft versus tumor activity and graft versus host disease in allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

Powerful immunologically-mediated antitumor efforts can be observed in allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. In the absence of specific immune interventions, this graft versus tumor effect is closely associated with graft versus host disease. In the work summarized here, the influence of cellular tumor vaccines on graft versus tumor activity and graft versus host disease is examined in a murine model of MHC-matched, minor histocompatibility antigen-mismatched bone marrow transplantation. The experiments have generated the following conclusions. First, complex cellular vaccines, which include recipient minor histocompatibility antigens, when administered to allogeneic donors generate powerful graft versus tumor effects but also induce unacceptable exacerbations of graft versus host disease. Second, cellular tumor vaccines, which contain recipient minor histocompatibility antigens, can be administered to transplant recipients after transplant without significant exacerbation of GVHD and with retention of clinically significant graft versus tumor effects. Third, immunization of donors with molecularly defined tumor-associated antigens, which are not recipient minor histocompatibility antigens, can be coupled with post-transplant immunization of recipients with cellular vaccines without exacerbation of GVHD.

Contribution of HLA class I allele expression to CD8+ T-cell responses against Epstein-Barr virus

Most immune responses to viral infections involve CD8+ T cells recognizing viral peptides of typically 9-10 amino acids in the groove of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I. Importantly, CD8+ T-cell responses appear to focus on few viral epitopes, a phenomenon termed immunodominance. While the understanding of this phenomenon has been based largely on experimental mice models, it is imperative to evaluate its contribution in humans, as the design of peptide-based vaccines may be influenced by immunodomination. Here, we present evidence that immunodominance can be detected among Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) epitopes associated with two of the most frequent class I alleles in Western Europe, human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-A2 and HLA-B7. CD8+ T-cell responses to HLA-A2-associated EBV epitopes were significantly reduced in individuals coexpressing HLA-B7. The impairment of HLA-A2-associated responses correlated with a dominant response to an HLA-B7 epitope. The data demonstrate a hierarchy in the human cellular immune response to immunodominant EBV epitopes presented by separate HLA class I alleles. This may have implications for EBV vaccine development as well as for the interpretation of isolated analysis of immunodominant responses to EBV.

mRNA-based electrotransfection of human dendritic cells and induction of cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses against the telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT)

Dendritic cells (DCs) are recognised as the most potent antigen-presenting cells for induction of cellular immune responses, and vaccination with DCs pulsed with antigens has emerged as a promising strategy for generating protective immunity in mammals. We have developed a transfection method that uses in vitro synthesised mRNA and square-wave electroporation for transient expression in DCs and other cell types. The method is highly efficient and produces almost complete transfection of cells in culture. When using mRNA encoding the enhanced green fluorescence protein (EGFP), highest expression in DCs occurred on the second day after transfection and produced a 76-fold increase in mean fluorescence above background. High levels of expression were maintained for at least 5 days post-transfection. In comparison, square-wave electroporation of DCs with EGFP plasmid DNA yielded 15% transfected cells and a 28-fold increase of mean fluorescence. DCs transfected with mRNA encoding the telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT) acquired strong telomerase activity and were capable of eliciting a hTERT-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response in vitro.

Examination of HY response: T cell expansion, immunodominance, and cross-priming revealed by HY tetramer analysis

We have applied MHC class I tetramers representing the two H2(b) MHC class I-restricted epitopes of the mouse male-specific minor transplantation Ag, HY, to directly determine the extent of expansion and immunodominance within the CD8+ T cell compartment following exposure to male tissue. Immunization with male bone marrow (BM), spleen, dendritic cells (DCs) and by skin graft led to rapid expansion of both specificities occupying up to >20% of the CD8+ T cell pool. At a high dose, whole BM or spleen were found to be more effective at stimulating the response than BM-derived DCs. In vivo, immunodominance within the responding cell population was only observed following chronic Ag stimulation, whereas epitope immunodominance was established rapidly following in vitro restimulation. Peptide affinity for the restricting MHC molecule was greater for the immunodominant epitope, suggesting that this might be a factor in the emergence of immunodominance. Using tetramers, we were able to directly visualize the cross-primed CD8+ HY response, but we did not find it to be the principal route for MHC class I presentation. Immunization with female spleen or DCs coated with the full complement of defined HY peptides, including the A(b)-restricted CD4+ Th cell determinant, failed to induce tetramer-reactive cells.

Immunodomination results from functional differences between competing CTL

The presence of dominant epitopes suppresses generation of CTL activity toward other non-dominant epitopes found on the same antigen-presenting cell (APC). This phenomenon, termed immunodomination, drastically restricts the diversity of the repertoire of CTL responses. Under various experimental conditions we assessed the in vivo expansion by tetramer staining and function by expression of O-glycans and intracellular perforin of CTL specific for a dominant (B6(dom1)) and a non-dominant (HY) H2D(b)-restricted epitope. Immunodomination abrogated expansion rather than differentiation of HY-specific CTL. When immunodomination was precluded because HY was presented alone or because high numbers of antigen-bearing APC were present, the numbers of HY-specific T cells detected after antigen priming were similar to those of B6(dom1)-specific T cells. The main difference between T cells that recognized B6(dom1) versus HY was functional rather than quantitative. The key feature of T cells specific for B6(dom1) is that they show striking up-regulation of molecules involved in CTL effector activity rather than accumulating to particularly high levels, as assessed by tetramer staining. These results support the emerging concept that following antigen priming, CTL populations of similar size can display important differences in effector function, and suggest that these functional differences are instrumental in shaping the repertoire of CTL responses.

Adoptive transfer of minor histocompatibility antigen-specific T lymphocytes eradicates leukemia cells without causing graft-versus-host disease

Adoptive transfer of T cells reactive to minor histocompatibility antigens has the unmatched ability to eradicate malignant hematopoietic cells. Unfortunately, its use is hampered by the associated graft-versus-host disease. The critical issue of a possible dissociation of the antileukemic effect and graft-versus-host disease by targeting specific minor histocompatibility antigens remains unresolved because of the unknown nature and number of minor histocompatibility antigens necessary or sufficient to elicit anti-leukemic activity and graft-versus-host disease. We found that injection of T lymphocytes primed against a single major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted immunodominant minor histocompatibility antigen (B6dom1) caused no graft-versus-host disease but produced a curative anti-leukemic response. Avoidance of graft-versus-host disease required that no other host-reactive T cells be co-injected with T cells primed with B6dom1. Here we show that effective and non-toxic immunotherapy of hematologic malignancies can be achieved by targeting a single immunodominant minor histocompatibility antigen.

Generation of helper and cytotoxic CD4+T cell clones specific for the minor histocompatibility antigen H-Y, after in vitro priming of human T cells by HLA-identical monocyte-derived dendritic cells

BACKGROUND

There is now convincing evidence that minor histocompatibility antigens (mHag) may play a significant role in the pathogenesis of graft-versus-host disease after HLA-identical bone marrow transplantation. Indeed, in this clinical situation, T cells specific for mHag have been isolated. Here, we addressed whether one can generate mHag-specific T cells in vitro, without any in vivo immunization, among healthy blood donors.

METHODS

We used monocyte-derived dendritic cells (Mo-DCs) as antigen presenting cells to induce primary responses between healthy HLA-identical siblings, in mixed lymphocyte dendritic cell reactions (MLDCRs).

RESULTS

We show that CD4+ T-cell clones, specific for the mHag H-Y, can be generated in vitro. These clones were derived from a gender-mismatched positive MLDCR pair of HLA-identical siblings and were restricted by the HLA DQB1*0502 molecule. In addition, these CD4+ T clones were also able to lyse allogeneic targets with the same pattern of restriction and specificity than helper function. Finally, acute myeloid leukemia (AML) blast cells were susceptible to lysis by these clones.

CONCLUSIONS

Altogether, these results predict that Mo-DCs could help to generate class II-associated, mHag-specific, T-cell lines or clones in vitro, between healthy blood donors, without any need of transplantation-mediated immunization.

Quantitative analysis of the immune response to mouse non-MHC transplantation antigens in vivo: the H60 histocompatibility antigen dominates over all others

Minor histocompatibility Ags (minor H Ags) are substantial impediments to MHC-matched solid tissue and bone marrow transplantation. From an antigenic standpoint, transplantation between MHC-matched individuals has the potential to be remarkably complex. To determine the extent to which the immune response is simplified by the phenomenon of immunodominance, we used peptide/MHC tetramers based on recently discovered minor H Ags (H60, H13, and HY) and monitored in vivo CD8 T cell responses of female C57BL/6 mice primed with MHC-matched, but background-disparate, male BALB.B cells. CD8 T cells against H60 overwhelmed responses to the H13 and HY throughout primary and secondary challenge. H60 immunodominance was an inherent quality, overcoming a lower memory precursor frequency compared with that of H13 and evoking a T cell response with diverse TCRV beta usage. IFN-gamma staining examining congenically defined minor H Ags extended H60 dominance over additional minor H Ags, H28, H4, and H7. These four minor H Ags accounted for up to 85% of the CD8 T cell response, but H60 stood out as the major contributor. These findings show that immunodominance applies to antigenically complex transplantation settings in vivo and that the responses to the H60 minor H Ag dominates in this model. We suggest that immunodominant minor H Ags are those that result from the absence of a self analog.

Immunization of allogeneic bone marrow transplant recipients with tumor cell vaccines enhances graft-versus-tumor activity without exacerbating graft-versus-host disease

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) induces 2 closely associated immune responses: graft-versus-tumor (GVT) activity and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). We have previously shown that pretransplant immunization of allogeneic BMT donors with a recipient-derived tumor cell vaccine increases both GVT activity and lethal GVHD because of the priming of donor T cells against putative minor histocompatibility antigens (mHAgs) on the tumor vaccine cells. The work reported here tested the hypothesis that tumor cell vaccination after BMT would produce an increase in GVT activity without exacerbating GVHD. C3H.SW donor bone marrow and splenocytes were transplanted into major histocompatibility complex-matched, mHAg-mismatched C57BL/6 recipients. One month after BMT, recipients were immunized against either a C57BL/6 myeloid leukemia (C1498) or fibrosarcoma (205). Immunized recipients had a significant increase in survival and protection against tumor growth in both tumor models, and significant tumor protection was seen even in recipients with preexisting micrometastatic cancer before immunization. Alloreactivity appeared to contribute to the in vitro anti-tumor cytolytic activity, but in vivo immunity was tumor specific, and no exacerbation of GVHD was observed. Although the immunodominant mHAg B6dom1 was shown to be expressed by all B6 tumors tested and was largely responsible for the alloreactivity resulting from tumor immunization of donors, the in vitro alloreactivity of immune recipients was more restricted and was not mediated by recognition of B6dom1. In conclusion, post-transplant tumor immunization of allogeneic BMT recipients against either a leukemia or a solid tumor can increase GVT activity and survival without exacerbating GVHD.

The human UTY gene encodes a novel HLA-B8-restricted H-Y antigen

The mammalian Y chromosome encodes male-specific minor histocompatibility (H-Y) Ags that are recognized by female T cells in an MHC-restricted manner. Two human H-Y epitopes presented by HLA-A2 and HLA-B7, respectively, have been identified previously and both are derived from the SMCY gene. We previously isolated CD8+ CTL clones that recognized a male-specific minor histocompatibility Ag presented by HLA-B8. In contrast to the SMCY-encoded H-Y epitopes, the B8/H-Y Ag was not presented by fibroblasts from male donors, suggesting that it was encoded by a novel gene. We now report that the HLA-B8-restricted H-Y epitope is defined by the octameric peptide LPHNHTDL corresponding to aa residues 566-573 of the human UTY protein. Transcription of the UTY gene is detected in a wide range of human tissues, but presentation of the UTY-derived H-Y epitope to CTL by cultured human cells shows significant cell-type specificity. Identification of this CTL-defined H-Y epitope should facilitate analysis of its contribution to graft/host interactions following sex-mismatched organ and bone marrow transplantation.

Biochemical and Immunogenetic Analysis of an Immunodominant Peptide (B6dom1) Encoded by the Classical H7 Minor Histocompatibility Locus

Of the many minor histocompatibility (H) Ags that have been detected in mice, the ability to induce graft vs host disease (GVHD) after bone marrow transplantation is restricted to a limited number of immunodominant Ags. One such murine Ag, B6dom1, is presented by the H2-Db MHC class I molecule. We present biochemical evidence that the natural B6dom1 peptide is indistinguishable from AAPDNRETF, and we show that this peptide can be isolated from a wide array of tissues, with highest levels from the lymphoid organs and lung. Moreover, we employ a novel, somatic cell selection technique involving CTL-mediated immunoselection coupled with classical genetics, to show that B6dom1 is encoded by the H7 minor H locus originally discovered ∼40 years ago. These studies provide a molecular genetic framework for understanding B6dom1, and exemplify the fact that mouse minor H loci that encode immunodominant CTL epitopes can correspond to classical H loci originally identified by their ability to confer strong resistance to tumor transplantation. Additionally, these studies demonstrate the utility of somatic cell selection approaches toward resolving H Ag immunogenetics.