Structural intermediates in the putative pathway from the cellular prion protein to the pathogenic form

Structure of prion β-oligomers as determined by short-distance crosslinking constraint-guided discrete molecular dynamics simulations

The conversion of the native monomeric cellular prion protein (PrP^C ) into an aggregated pathological β-oligomeric form (PrP^β ) and an infectious form (PrP^Sc ) is the central element in the development of prion diseases. The structure of the aggregates and the molecular mechanisms of the conformational changes involved in the conversion are still unknown. We applied mass spectrometry combined with chemical crosslinking, hydrogen/deuterium exchange, limited proteolysis, and surface modification for the differential characterization of the native and the urea+acid-converted prion β-oligomer structures to obtain insights into the mechanisms of conversion and aggregation. For the determination of the structure of the monomer and the dimer unit of the β-oligomer, we applied a recently-developed approach for de novo protein structure determination which is based on the incorporation of zero-length and short-distance crosslinking data as intra- and inter-protein constraints in discrete molecular dynamics simulations (CL-DMD). Based on all of the structural-proteomics experimental data and the computationally predicted structures of the monomer units, we propose the potential mode of assembly of the β-oligomer. The proposed β-oligomer assembly provides a clue on the β-sheet nucleation site, and how template-based conversion of the native prion molecule occurs, growth of the prion aggregates, and maturation into fibrils may occur.

Unraveling the Histidine Tautomerism Effect on the Initial Stages of Prion Misfolding: New Insights from a Computational Perspective

The aggregation and structural conversion of normal prion peptide (PrP^C) into the pathogenic scrapie form (PrP^Sc), which can act as a seed to enhance prion amyloid fiber formation, is believed to be a crucial event in prionopathies. Previous research suggests that the prion monomer may play an important role in oligomer generation during disease pathogenesis. In the present study, extensive replica-exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) simulations were conducted to explore the conformational characteristics of the huPrP (125-160) monomer under the histidine tautomerism effect. Investigating the structural characteristics and fibrilization process is challenging because two histidine tautomers [N_ε2-H (ε) and N_δ1-H (δ)] can occur in the open neutral state. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation outcomes have shown that the toxic εδ and δδ isomer (containing several and broader local minima) had the highest α-helix structures, with contents of 21.11% and 21.01%, respectively, and may have a strong influence on the organizational behavior of a monomeric prion. The amino acids aspartate 20 (D20)-asparagine 29 (N29) and isoleucine 15 (I15)-histidine 16 (H16), D20-arginine 27 (R27) as well as N29 formed α-helix with the highest probabilities in the δδ and εδ isomer, accordingly. On the basis of our findings, we propose the histidine tautomerization hypothesis as a new prion accumulation mechanism, which may exist to induce the formation of prion accumulates. Overall, our tautomerism hypothesis constitutes a promising perspective for enhancing understanding of prion disease pathobiology and may help in the design of a good inhibitor.

The G127V variant of the prion protein interferes with dimer formation in vitro but not in cellulo

Scrapie prion, PrPSc, formation is the central event of all types of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs), while the pathway with possible intermediates and their mechanism of formation from the normal isoform of prion (PrP), remains not fully understood. Recently, the G127V variant of the human PrP is reported to render the protein refractory to transmission of TSEs, via a yet unknown mechanism. Molecular dynamics studies suggested that this mutation interferes with the formation of PrP dimers. Here we analyze the dimerization of 127G and 127VPrP, in both in vitro and a mammalian cell culture system. Our results show that while molecular dynamics may capture the features affecting dimerization in vitro, G127V inhibiting dimer formation of PrP, these are not evidenced in a more complex cellular system.

Interrogating the Dimerization Interface of the Prion Protein Via Site-Specific Mutations to p-Benzoyl-L-Phenylalanine

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are centered on the conformational transition of the prion protein from a mainly helical, monomeric structure to a β-sheet rich ordered aggregate. Experiments indicate that the main infectious and toxic species in this process are however shorter oligomers, formation of which from the monomers is yet enigmatic. Here, we created 25 variants of the mouse prion protein site-specifically containing one genetically-incorporated para-benzoyl-phenylalanine (pBpa), a cross-linkable non-natural amino acid, in order to interrogate the interface of a prion protein-dimer, which might lie on the pathway of oligomerization. Our results reveal that the N-terminal part of the prion protein, especially regions around position 127 and 107, is integral part of the dimer interface. These together with additional pBpa-containing variants of mPrP might also facilitate to gain more structural insights into oligomeric and fibrillar prion protein species including the pathological variants.

Substitutions of PrP N-terminal histidine residues modulate scrapie disease pathogenesis and incubation time in transgenic mice

Prion diseases have been linked to impaired copper homeostasis and copper induced-oxidative damage to the brain. Divalent metal ions, such as Cu2+ and Zn2+, bind to cellular prion protein (PrPC) at octapeptide repeat (OR) and non-OR sites within the N-terminal half of the protein but information on the impact of such binding on conversion to the misfolded isoform often derives from studies using either OR and non-OR peptides or bacterially-expressed recombinant PrP. Here we created new transgenic mouse lines expressing PrP with disrupted copper binding sites within all four histidine-containing OR's (sites 1-4, H60G, H68G, H76G, H84G, "TetraH>G" allele) or at site 5 (composed of residues His-95 and His-110; "H95G" allele) and monitored the formation of misfolded PrP in vivo. Novel transgenic mice expressing PrP(TetraH>G) at levels comparable to wild-type (wt) controls were susceptible to mouse-adapted scrapie strain RML but showed significantly prolonged incubation times. In contrast, amino acid replacement at residue 95 accelerated disease progression in corresponding PrP(H95G) mice. Neuropathological lesions in terminally ill transgenic mice were similar to scrapie-infected wt controls, but less severe. The pattern of PrPSc deposition, however, was not synaptic as seen in wt animals, but instead dense globular plaque-like accumulations of PrPSc in TgPrP(TetraH>G) mice and diffuse PrPSc deposition in (TgPrP(H95G) mice), were observed throughout all brain sections. We conclude that OR and site 5 histidine substitutions have divergent phenotypic impacts and that cis interactions between the OR region and the site 5 region modulate pathogenic outcomes by affecting the PrP globular domain.

Pathogenic mechanisms of prion protein, amyloid-β and α-synuclein misfolding: the prion concept and neurotoxicity of protein oligomers

Proteinopathies represent a group of diseases characterized by the unregulated misfolding and aggregation of proteins. Accumulation of misfolded protein in the central nervous system (CNS) is associated with neurodegenerative diseases, such as the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (or prion diseases), Alzheimer's disease, and the synucleinopathies (the most common of which is Parkinson's disease). Of these, the pathogenic mechanisms of prion diseases are particularly striking where the transmissible, causative agent of disease is the prion, or proteinaceous infectious particle. Prions are composed almost exclusively of PrP^Sc ; a misfolded isoform of the normal cellular protein, PrP^C , which is found accumulated in the CNS in disease. Today, mounting evidence suggests other aggregating proteins, such as amyloid-β (Aβ) and α-synuclein (α-syn), proteins associated with Alzheimer's disease and synucleinopathies, respectively, share similar biophysical and biochemical properties with PrP^Sc that influences how they misfold, aggregate, and propagate in disease. In this regard, the definition of a 'prion' may ultimately expand to include other pathogenic proteins. Unifying knowledge of folded proteins may also reveal common mechanisms associated with other features of disease that are less understood, such as neurotoxicity. This review discusses the common features Aβ and α-syn share with PrP and neurotoxic mechanisms associated with these misfolded proteins. Several proteins are known to misfold and accumulate in the central nervous system causing a range of neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, and the prion diseases. Prions are transmissible misfolded conformers of the prion protein, PrP, which seed further generation of infectious proteins. Similar effects have recently been observed in proteins associated with Alzheimer's disease and the synucleinopathies, leading to the proposition that the definition of a 'prion' may ultimately expand to include other pathogenic proteins. Unifying knowledge of misfolded proteins may also reveal common mechanisms associated with other features of disease that are less understood, such as neurotoxicity.

An Account of Amyloid Oligomers: Facts and Figures Obtained from Experiments and Simulations

The deposition of amyloid in brain tissue in the context of neurodegenerative diseases involves the formation of intermediate species-termed oligomers-of lower molecular mass and with structures that deviate from those of mature amyloid fibrils. Because these oligomers are thought to be primarily responsible for the subsequent disease pathogenesis, the elucidation of their structure is of enormous interest. Nevertheless, because of the high aggregation propensity and the polydispersity of oligomeric species formed by the proteins or peptides in question, the preparation of appropriate samples for high-resolution structural methods has proven to be rather difficult. This is why theoretical approaches have been of particular importance in gaining insights into possible oligomeric structures for some time. Only recently has it been possible to achieve some progress with regard to the experimentally based structural characterization of defined oligomeric species. Here we discuss how theory and experiment are used to determine oligomer structures and what can be done to improve the integration of the two disciplines.

Progress towards structural understanding of infectious sheep PrP-amyloid

The still elusive structural difference of non-infectious and infectious amyloid of the mammalian prion protein (PrP) is a major pending milestone in understanding protein-mediated infectivity in neurodegenerative diseases. Preparations of PrP-amyloid proven to be infectious have never been investigated with a high-resolution technique. All available models to date have been based on low-resolution data. Here, we establish protocols for the preparation of infectious samples of full-length recombinant (rec) PrP-amyloid in NMR-sufficient amounts by spontaneous fibrillation and seeded fibril growth from brain extract. We link biological and structural data of infectious recPrP-amyloid, derived from bioassays, atomic force microscopy, and solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Our data indicate a semi-mobile N-terminus, some residues with secondary chemical shifts typical of α-helical secondary structure in the middle part between ∼115 to ∼155, and a distinct β-sheet core C-terminal of residue ∼155. These findings are not in agreement with all current models for PrP-amyloid. We also provide evidence that samples seeded from brain extract may not differ in the overall arrangement of secondary structure elements, but rather in the flexibility of protein segments outside the β-core region. Taken together, our protocols provide an essential basis for the high-resolution characterization of non-infectious and infectious PrP-amyloid in the near future.

Regulation of PrP(C) signaling and processing by dimerization

The cellular prion protein (PrP^C) is a glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored protein present at the cell surface. PrP^C N-terminal moiety is intrinsically disordered and is able to interact with a variety of ligands. Physiological ligands have neurotrophic activity, whilst others, including protein toxic oligomers, have neurotoxic functions. These two opposite activities involve different interacting partners and result from different PrP^C-activated signaling pathways. Remarkably, PrP^C may be inactivated either by physiological endoproteolysis and release of the N-terminal domain, or by ectodomain shedding. Ligand-induced PrP^C dimerization or enforced dimerization of PrP^C indicate that PrP^C dimerization represents an important molecular switch for both intracellular signaling and inactivation by the release of PrP^C N-terminal domain or shedding. In this review, we summarize evidence that cell surface receptor activity of PrP^C is finely regulated by dimerization.

N-terminal domain of prion protein directs its oligomeric association

The self-association of prion protein (PrP) is a critical step in the pathology of prion diseases. It is increasingly recognized that small non-fibrillar β-sheet-rich oligomers of PrP may be of crucial importance in the prion disease process. Here, we characterize the structure of a well defined β-sheet-rich oligomer, containing ∼12 PrP molecules, and often enclosing a central cavity, formed using full-length recombinant PrP. The N-terminal region of prion protein (residues 23-90) is required for the formation of this distinct oligomer; a truncated form comprising residues 91-231 forms a broad distribution of aggregated species. No infectivity or toxicity was found using cell and animal model systems. This study demonstrates that examination of the full repertoire of conformers and assembly states that can be accessed by PrP under specific experimental conditions should ideally be done using the full-length protein.

Distinct synthetic Aβ prion strains producing different amyloid deposits in bigenic mice

An increasing number of studies continue to show that the amyloid β (Aβ) peptide adopts an alternative conformation and acquires transmissibility; hence, it becomes a prion. Here, we report on the attributes of two strains of Aβ prions formed from synthetic Aβ peptides composed of either 40 or 42 residues. Modifying the conditions for Aβ polymerization increased both the protease resistance and prion infectivity compared with an earlier study. Approximately 150 d after intracerebral inoculation, both synthetic Aβ40 and Aβ42 prions produced a sustained rise in the bioluminescence imaging signal in the brains of bigenic Tg(APP23:Gfap-luc) mice, indicative of astrocytic gliosis. Pathological investigations showed that synthetic Aβ40 prions produced amyloid plaques containing both Aβ40 and Aβ42 in the brains of inoculated bigenic mice, whereas synthetic Aβ42 prions stimulated the formation of smaller, more numerous plaques composed predominantly of Aβ42. Synthetic Aβ40 preparations consisted of long straight fibrils; in contrast, the Aβ42 fibrils were much shorter. Addition of 3.47 mM (0.1%) SDS to the polymerization reaction produced Aβ42 fibrils that were indistinguishable from Aβ40 fibrils produced in the absence or presence of SDS. Moreover, the Aβ amyloid plaques in the brains of bigenic mice inoculated with Aβ42 prions prepared in the presence of SDS were similar to those found in mice that received Aβ40 prions. From these results, we conclude that the composition of Aβ plaques depends on the conformation of the inoculated Aβ polymers, and thus, these inocula represent distinct synthetic Aβ prion strains.

Protease-sensitive prions with 144-bp insertion mutations

Insertion of 144-base pair (bp) containing six extra octapeptide repeats between residues 51 and 91 of prion protein (PrP) gene is associated with inherited prion diseases. Most cases linked to this insertion examined by Western blotting showed detectable proteinase K-resistant PrPSc (rPrPSc) resembling PrPSc type 1 and type 2 in sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD), or PrP7-8 in Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker disease. However, cases lacking detectable rPrPSc also have been reported. Which PrP conformer is associated with neuropathological changes in the cases without detectable rPrPSc remains to be determined. Here we report that while all six but one subjects with the 144-bp insertion mutations examined display the pathognomonic PrP patches in the cerebellum, one of them exhibits no detectable typical rPrPSc even in PrPSc-enriched preparations. Instead, a large amount of abnormal PrP is captured from this case by gene 5 protein and sodium phosphotungstate, reagents that have been proved to specifically capture abnormal PrP. All captured abnormal PrP from the cerebellum and other brain regions is virtually sensitive to PK-digestion (termed sPrPSc). The presence of the predominant sPrPSc but absence of rPrPSc in this 144-bp insertion-linked inherited CJD case suggests that mutant sPrPSc is the main component of the PrP deposit patches and sPrPSc is sufficient to cause neurotoxicity and prion disease.

2-Aminothiazoles with improved pharmacotherapeutic properties for treatment of prion disease

Recently, we described the aminothiazole lead (4-biphenyl-4-ylthiazol-2-yl)-(6-methylpyridin-2-yl)-amine (1), which exhibits many desirable properties, including excellent stability in liver microsomes, oral bioavailability of ∼40 %, and high exposure in the brains of mice. Despite its good pharmacokinetic properties, compound 1 exhibited only modest potency in mouse neuroblastoma cells overexpressing the disease-causing prion protein PrP(Sc) . Accordingly, we sought to identify analogues of 1 with improved antiprion potency in ScN2a-cl3 cells while retaining similar or superior properties. Herein we report the discovery of improved lead compounds such as (6-methylpyridin-2-yl)-[4-(4-pyridin-3-yl-phenyl)thiazol-2-yl]amine and cyclopropanecarboxylic acid (4-biphenylthiazol-2-yl)amide, which exhibit brain exposure/EC50 ratios at least tenfold greater than that of compound 1.

Homodimerization as a molecular switch between low and high efficiency PrP C cell surface delivery and neuroprotective activity

PrP (C) is associated with a variety of functions, and its ability to interact with a multitude of partners, including itself, may largely explain PrP multifunctionality and the lack of consensus on the genuine physiological function of the protein in vivo. In contrast, there is a consensus in the literature that alterations in PrP (C) trafficking and intracellular retention result in neuronal degeneration. In addition, a proteolytic modification in the late secretory pathway termed the α-cleavage induces the secretion of PrPN1, a PrP (C) -derived metabolite with fascinating neuroprotective activity against toxic oligomeric Aβ molecules implicated in Alzheimer disease. Thus, studies focusing on understanding the regulation of PrP (C) trafficking to the cell surface and the modulation of α-cleavage are essential. The objective of this commentary is to highlight recent evidences that PrP (C) homodimerization stimulates trafficking of the protein to the cell surface and results in high levels of PrPN1 secretion. We also discuss a hypothetical model for these results and comment on future challenges and opportunities.

Single-molecule approaches to prion protein misfolding

The structural conversion of the prion protein PrP into a transmissible, misfolded form is the central element of prion disease, yet there is little consensus as to how it occurs. Key aspects of conversion into the diseased state remain unsettled, from details about the earliest stages of misfolding such as the involvement of partially- or fully-unfolded intermediates to the structure of the infectious state. Part of the difficulty in understanding the structural conversion arises from the complexity of the underlying energy landscapes. Single molecule methods provide a powerful tool for probing complex folding pathways as in prion misfolding, because they allow rare and transient events to be observed directly. We discuss recent work applying single-molecule probes to study misfolding in prion proteins, and what it has revealed about the folding dynamics of PrP that may underlie its unique behavior. We also discuss single-molecule studies probing the interactions that stabilize non-native structures within aggregates, pointing the way to future work that may help identify the microscopic events triggering pathogenic conversion. Although single-molecule approaches to misfolding are relatively young, they have a promising future in prion science.

Highly neurotoxic monomeric α-helical prion protein

Prion diseases are infectious and belong to the group of protein misfolding neurodegenerative diseases. In these diseases, neuronal dysfunction and death are caused by the neuronal toxicity of a particular misfolded form of their cognate protein. The ability to specifically target the toxic protein conformer or the neuronal death pathway would provide powerful therapeutic approaches to these diseases. The neurotoxic forms of the prion protein (PrP) have yet to be defined but there is evidence suggesting that at least some of them differ from infectious PrP (PrP(Sc)). Herein, without making an assumption about size or conformation, we searched for toxic forms of recombinant PrP after dilution refolding, size fractionation, and systematic biological testing of all fractions. We found that the PrP species most neurotoxic in vitro and in vivo (toxic PrP, TPrP) is a monomeric, highly α-helical form of PrP. TPrP caused autophagy, apoptosis, and a molecular signature remarkably similar to that observed in the brains of prion-infected animals. Interestingly, highly α-helical intermediates have been described for other amyloidogenic proteins but their biological significance remains to be established. We provide unique experimental evidence that a monomeric α-helical form of an amyloidogenic protein represents a cytotoxic species. Although toxic PrP has yet to be purified from prion-infected brains, TPrP might be the equivalent of one highly neurotoxic PrP species generated during prion replication. Because TPrP is a misfolded, highly neurotoxic form of PrP reproducing several features of prion-induced neuronal death, it constitutes a useful model to study PrP-induced neurodegenerative mechanisms.

Prion protein aggregation and fibrillogenesis in vitro

This chapter focuses on the structural conversion of natural and recombinant prion proteins in vitro. They key event in prion diseases is the conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) into its disease causing isoform PrP(Sc). This conversion is represented by a conformational change from an β-helical dominated isoform into the mostly β-sheeted PrP(Sc). Represented is an overview of in vitro conversion systems that result in β-structured recombinant prion proteins including the current achievements in the generation of synthetic mammalian prions as proof of the protein-only hypothesis. In addition to the conversion of recombinant PrP the chapter features a summary of the protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) technique which has gained enormous popularity in prion research. Given is a general overview about the technique itself and the broad spectrum of utilization as detection method for prions. The spontaneous generation of prions by the protein misfolding amplification (PMCA) are also discussed.

In vitro conversion and seeded fibrillization of posttranslationally modified prion protein

The conversion of the cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP(C)) into the pathologic isoform (PrP(Sc)) is the key event in prion diseases. To study the conversion process, an in vitro system based on varying the concentration of low amounts of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) has been employed. In the present study, the conversion of full-length PrP(C) isolated from Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO-PrP(C)) was examined. CHO-PrP(C) harbors native, posttranslational modifications, including the GPI anchor and two N-linked glyco-sylation sites. The properties of CHO-PrP(C) were compared with those of full-length and N-terminally truncated recombinant PrP. As shown earlier with recombinant PrP (recPrP90-231), transition from a soluble α-helical state as known for native PrP(C) into an aggregated, β-sheet-rich PrP(Sc)-like state could be induced by dilution of SDS. The aggregated state is partially proteinase K (PK)-resistant, exhibiting a cleavage site similar to that found with PrP(Sc). Compared to recPrP (90-231), fibril formation with CHO-PrP(C) requires lower SDS concentrations (0.0075%), and can be drastically accelerated by seeding with PrP(Sc) purified from brain homogenates of terminally sick hamsters. Our results show that recPrP 90-231 and CHO-PrPC behave qualitatively similar but quantitatively different. The in vivo situation can be simulated closer with CHO-PrP(C) because the specific PK cleave site could be shown and the seed-assisted fibrillization was much more efficient.

Molecular interactions between prions as seeds and recombinant prion proteins as substrates resemble the biological interspecies barrier in vitro

Prion diseases like Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans, Scrapie in sheep or bovine spongiform encephalopathy are fatal neurodegenerative diseases, which can be of sporadic, genetic, or infectious origin. Prion diseases are transmissible between different species, however, with a variable species barrier. The key event of prion amplification is the conversion of the cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP^C) into the pathogenic isoform (PrP^Sc). We developed a sodiumdodecylsulfate-based PrP conversion system that induces amyloid fibril formation from soluble α-helical structured recombinant PrP (recPrP). This approach was extended applying pre-purified PrP^Sc as seeds which accelerate fibrillization of recPrP. In the present study we investigated the interspecies coherence of prion disease. Therefore we used PrP^Sc from different species like Syrian hamster, cattle, mouse and sheep and seeded fibrillization of recPrP from the same or other species to mimic in vitro the natural species barrier. We could show that the in vitro system of seeded fibrillization is in accordance with what is known from the naturally occurring species barriers.

Structural changes of membrane-anchored native PrP(C)

Misfolding and subsequent aggregation of endogenous proteins constitute essential steps in many human disorders, including Alzheimer and prion diseases. In most prion protein-folding studies, the posttranslational modifications, the lipid anchor in particular, were lacking. Here, we studied a fully posttranslationally modified cellular prion protein, carrying two N-glycosylations and the natural GPI anchor. We used time-resolved FTIR to study the prion protein secondary structure changes when binding to a raft-like lipid membrane via its GPI anchor. We observed that membrane anchoring above a threshold concentration induced refolding of the prion protein to intermolecular beta-sheets. Such transition is not observed in solution and is membrane specific. Excessive membrane anchoring, analyzed with molecular sensitivity, is thought to be a crucial event in the development of prion diseases.

Aggregation and amyloid fibril formation of the prion protein is accelerated in the presence of glycogen

Prion diseases like Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans or scrapie in sheep and goats are infectious neurodegenerative diseases. Their infectious agent, called prion, is composed mainly of aggregated and misfolded prion protein and non-proteinaceous components. An example of such a common non-proteinaceous secondary component of natural prions is the polysaccharide scaffold. We studied the influence of such a polysaccharide on the conformational transition of PrP applying an in vitro conversion system. Here we report that glycogen supports and accelerates PrP amorphous aggregation similar to seeded aggregation and leads to co-aggregates. Furthermore, PrP fibril formation was highly accelerated in the presence of glycogen.

Spontaneous and BSE-prion-seeded amyloid formation of full length recombinant bovine prion protein

The conversion of the cellular isoform of the prion protein into the pathogenic isoform PrP(Sc) is the key event in prion diseases. The disease can occur spontaneously genetically or by infection. In earlier studies we presented an in vitro conversion system which simulates the structural transition in recPrP by varying low concentrations of SDS at constant NaCl. In the present study we adopted the conversion system from experimental Scrapie in hamster to bovine recPrP and generated amyloid fibrils. The intermediate state which is optimal for fibril formation is a soluble, beta-rich state. The system was extended using BSE-prions as seeds and led to an acceleration of fibril formation by orders of magnitude. This seeded amyloid formation assay avoids any PK-treatment, is therefore able to detect even PK-sensitive PrP(Sc) and does not require cellular components.

Prion infection: seeded fibrillization or more?

The prion infection is a conversion of host encoded prion protein (PrP) from its cellular isoform PrP(C) into the pathological and infectious isoform PrP(Sc); the conversion process was investigated by in vitro studies using recombinant and cellular PrP and natural PrP(Sc). We present a brief summary of the results determined with our in vitro conversion system and the derived mechanistic models. We describe well characterized intermediates and precursor states during the conversion process, kinetic studies of spontaneous and seeded fibrillogenesis and the impact of the membrane environment.

Mechanisms of prion protein assembly into amyloid

The conversion of the alpha-helical, cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP(C)) to the insoluble, beta-sheet-rich, infectious, disease-causing isoform (PrP(Sc)) is the key event in prion diseases. In an earlier study, several forms of PrP were converted into a fibrillar state by using an in vitro conversion system consisting of low concentrations of SDS and 250 mM NaCl. Here, we characterize the structure of the fibril precursor state, that is, the soluble state under fibrillization conditions. CD spectroscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation, and chemical cross-linking indicate that the precursor state exists in a monomer-dimer equilibrium of partially denatured, alpha-helical PrP, with a well defined contact site of the subunits in the dimer. Using fluorescence with thioflavin T, we monitored and quantitatively described the kinetics of seeded fibril formation, including dependence of the reaction on substrate and seed concentrations. Exponential, seed-enhanced growth can be achieved in homogeneous solution, which can be enhanced by sonication. From these data, we propose a mechanistic model of fibrillization, including the presence of several intermediate structures. These studies also provide a simplified amplification system for prions.

Curcumin binds to the alpha-helical intermediate and to the amyloid form of prion protein - a new mechanism for the inhibition of PrP(Sc) accumulation

Conversion of the native, predominantly alpha-helical conformation of prion protein (PrP) into the beta-stranded conformation is characteristic for the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies such as Creutzfeld-Jakob disease. Curcumin, an extended planar molecule and a dietary polyphenol, inhibits in vitro conversion of PrP and formation of protease resistant PrP in neuroblastoma cell lines. Curcumin recognizes the converted beta-form of the PrP both as oligomers and fibrils but not the native form. Curcumin binds to the prion fibrils in the left-handed chiral arrangement as determined by circular dichroism. We show that curcumin labels the plaques of the brain sections of variant Creutzfeld-Jakob disease cases and stains the same structures as antibodies against the PrP. In contrast to thioflavin T, curcumin also binds to the alpha-helical intermediate of PrP present at acidic pH at stoichiometry of 1 : 1. Congo red competes with curcumin for binding to the alpha-intermediate as well as to the beta-form of PrP but is toxic and binds also to the native form of PrP. We therefore show that the partially unfolded structural intermediate of the PrP can be targeted by non-toxic compound of natural origin.

In vitro and in vivo neurotoxicity of prion protein oligomers

The mechanisms underlying prion-linked neurodegeneration remain to be elucidated, despite several recent advances in this field. Herein, we show that soluble, low molecular weight oligomers of the full-length prion protein (PrP), which possess characteristics of PrP to PrPsc conversion intermediates such as partial protease resistance, are neurotoxic in vitro on primary cultures of neurons and in vivo after subcortical stereotaxic injection. Monomeric PrP was not toxic. Insoluble, fibrillar forms of PrP exhibited no toxicity in vitro and were less toxic than their oligomeric counterparts in vivo. The toxicity was independent of PrP expression in the neurons both in vitro and in vivo for the PrP oligomers and in vivo for the PrP fibrils. Rescue experiments with antibodies showed that the exposure of the hydrophobic stretch of PrP at the oligomeric surface was necessary for toxicity. This study identifies toxic PrP species in vivo. It shows that PrP-induced neurodegeneration shares common mechanisms with other brain amyloidoses like Alzheimer disease and opens new avenues for neuroprotective intervention strategies of prion diseases targeting PrP oligomers.

Toxic effects of intracerebral PrP antibody administration during the course of BSE infection in mice

The absence of specific immune response is a hallmark of prion diseases. However, in vitro and in vivo experiments have provided evidence that an anti-PrP humoral response could have beneficial effects. Prophylactic passive immunization performed at the time of infection delayed or prevented disease. Nonetheless, the potential therapeutic effect of PrP antibodies administered shortly before the clinical signs has never been tested in vivo. Moreover, a recent study showed the potential toxicity of PrP antibodies administered intracerebrally. We aimed at evaluating the effect of a prolonged intracerebral anti-PrP antibody administration at the time of neuroinvasion in BSE infected Tg20 mice. Unexpectedly, despite a good penetration of the antibodies in the brain parenchyma, the treatment was not protective against the development of BSE. Instead, it led to an extensive neuronal loss, strong astrogliosis and microglial activation. Since this effect was observed after injection of anti-PrP antibodies as whole IgGs, F(ab')(2) or Fab fragments, the toxicity was directly related to the ability of the antibodies to recognize native PrP and to the intracerebral concentration achieved, and not to the Fc portion or the divalence of the antibodies. This experiment shows that a prolonged treatment with anti-PrP antibodies by the intracerebral route can induce severe side-effects and calls for caution with regard to the use of similar approaches for late therapeutic interventions in humans.

Regulation of prion protein expression by noncoding regions of the Prnp gene

Expression of the cellular prion protein is necessary for the transmission and propagation of prion diseases. Increasing the level of prion protein expression decreases the incubation period for these diseases. Therefore, understanding the regulation of prion protein expression could be critical for treating or preventing these diseases. We investigated the regulation of prion protein expression by the promoter and noncoding regions of the bovine and murine Prnp genes. We determined that expression is modulated by intron 1 and exon 1. In the absence of intron1, exon 1 inhibited activity of the promoter. However, intron 1 demonstrated promoter-like activity and possessed a TATA box. In addition, we identified an alternative transcript present in the brains of cattle and mice that lacks exon 1. Taken together, these results show that intron 1 and exon 1 play a critical role in the regulation of prion protein expression. Because switching off prion protein expression has been shown to arrest prion disease, these regions present novel targets for intervention in the disease process.

Interaction of the cellular prion protein with raft-like lipid membranes

Conversion of the cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP(C)) into the disease-associated isoform (PrP(Sc)) plays a key role in the development of prion diseases. Within its cellular pathway, PrP(C) undergoes several posttranslational modifications, i.e., the attachment of two N-linked glycans and a glycosyl phosphatidyl inositol (GPI) anchor, by which it is linked to the plasma membrane on the exterior cell surface. To study the interaction of PrP(C) with model membranes, we purified posttranslationally modified PrP(C) from transgenic Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The mono-, di- and oligomeric states of PrP(C) free in solution were analyzed by analytical ultracentrifugation. The interaction of PrP(C) with model membranes was studied using both lipid vesicles in solution and lipid bilayers bound to a chip surface. The equilibrium and mechanism of PrP(C) association with the model membranes were analyzed by surface plasmon resonance. Depending on the degree of saturation of binding sites, the concentration of PrP(C) released from the membrane into aqueous solution was estimated at between 10(-9) and 10(-7) M. This corresponds to a free energy of the insertion reaction of -48 kJ/mol. Consequences for the conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) are discussed.

Prions: protein only or something more? Overview of potential prion cofactors

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) in humans and animals are attributed to protein-only infectious agents, called prions. Prions have been proposed to arise from the conformational conversion of the cellular protein PrP(C) into a misfolded form (e.g., PrP(Sc) for scrapie), which precipitates into aggregates and fibrils. It has been proposed that the conversion process is triggered by the interaction of the infectious form (PrP(Sc)) with the cellular form (PrP(C)) or might result from a mutation in the gene for PrP(C). However, until recently, all efforts to reproduce this process in vitro had failed, suggesting that host factors are necessary for prion replication. In this review we discuss recent findings such as the cellular factors that might be involved in the conformational conversion of prion proteins and the potential mechanisms by which they could operate.

Photo-induced crosslinking of prion protein oligomers and prions

Prion diseases are caused by a unique type of infectious agent, which is thought to consist of a misfolded beta-sheeted form of the alpha-helical cellular prion protein (PrPC). This misfolded isoform (PrPSc) tends to form insoluble amyloid-like aggregates, impeding classical structural analysis by X-ray crystallography or NMR. Intermolecular crosslinking may provide a means of stabilizing notoriously elusive oligomers for further analysis and may be used for analyzing aggregate architecture by characterising intermolecular contact sites. Using a photo-induced crosslinking method (PICUP), aggregates of recombinant PrP (rPrP) and PrPSc were linked at interacting surfaces via amino acid side chains. The degree of crosslinking within PrP aggregates was adjustable using varying light intensities and could efficiently be monitored by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Specific intermolecular crosslinking of PrPSc molecules was achieved even in crude brain homogenate. Functional studies showed that stabilized aggregates of rPrP did not loose their capacity to induce further protein aggregation and crosslinking of PrPSc did not alter significantly the level of infectivity, indicating that photo-induced covalent linkage of PrPSc does not destruct surfaces important for prion propagation.

Rare Large Scale Subdomain Motions in Prion Protein can Initiate Aggregation

The prion protein is thought to induce prion diseases by changing its conformation from the cellular form, PrP(C), into the infectious Scrapie-form, PrP(Sc). Little is known about the structural and dynamical features of this conformational change. We here introduce a novel concept that involves rare large scale motions between the subdomains beta1-alpha1-beta2 and alpha2-alpha3 in the carboxy-terminal, globular part of PrP. The interface between these two subdomains carries most pathogenic mutations known to be associated with prion diseases. Based on computational simulations as well as experimental results we propose that such a large scale motion subsequently destabilizes large parts of the cellular conformer PrP(C), thus, rendering it prone to structural rearrangements, including aggregation of now partially unfolded parts of the PrP sequence. We hypothesize that such large scale motions occur as a rare event even under equilibrium conditions and that the interaction of such partially destabilized PrP(C)-conformers, which we named PrP(C*), contributes to the formation of pathogenic oligomeric species of the prion protein.

Acid inactivation of prions: efficient at elevated temperature or high acid concentration

Scrapie prion rods isolated from hamster and non-infectious aggregates of the corresponding recombinant protein rPrP(90–231) were incubated with hydrochloric acid. The amount of PrP and of infectivity that survived incubation in HCl at varying times, acid concentrations and temperatures was quantified by Western blot densitometry and bioassays, respectively. Prion rods and rPrP aggregates showed similar HCl hydrolysis kinetics of PrP, indicating structural homology. For 1 M HCl and 25 °C, the rate of PrP hydrolysis follows first-order kinetics at 0·014 h−1; the rate of infectivity inactivation is 0·54 h−1. Hydrolysis for 1 h at 25 °C was only slightly proportional to HCl concentration up to 5 M, but complete loss of infectivity and PrP reduction to <2 % was observed at 8 M HCl. The temperature dependence of unhydrolysed PrP, as well as infectivity at 1 M HCl for 1 h, showed a slight decrease up to 45 °C, but a sigmoidal decrease by several orders of magnitude at higher temperatures. The slow hydrolysis of PrP and inactivation of infectivity by acid treatment at room temperature are attributed to solvent inaccessibility of prion rods and rPrP aggregates, respectively. The more effective hydrolysis and inactivation at temperatures above 45 °C are interpreted as thermally induced disaggregation with an activation energy of 50–60 kJ mol−1. Most importantly, infectivity was always inactivated faster or to a higher extent than PrP was hydrolysed at several incubation times, HCl concentrations and temperatures.

Putative aggregation initiation sites in prion protein

Misfolded prion protein, PrPSc, is believed to be the pathogenic agens in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. Little is known about the autocatalytic misfolding process. Looking at the intrinsic properties of short sequence stretches, such as conformational flexibility and the tendency to populate extended conformers, we have examined the aggregation behaviour of various peptides within the region 106-157 of the sequence of human prion protein. We observed fast aggregation for the peptide containing residues I138-I-H-F141. This sequence, which is presented at the surface of cellular prion protein, PrPC, in an almost beta-sheet-like conformation, is therefore an ideal anchor-point for initial intermolecular contacts leading to oligomerization. We further report that the aggregation propensity of the neurotoxic peptide 106-126 appears to be centred in its termini and not in the central, alanine-rich sequence (A113-G-AAAA-G-A120).

Assembly of natural and recombinant prion protein into fibrils

The conversion of the alpha-helical, cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP C ) to the insoluble, beta-sheet-rich, infectious, disease-causing isoform (PrP Sc ) is the fundamental event in the prion diseases. The C-terminal fragment of PrP Sc (PrP 27-30) is formed by limited proteolysis and retains infectivity. Unlike full-length PrP Sc , PrP 27-30 polymerizes into rod-shaped structures with the ultra-structural and tinctorial properties of amyloid. To study the folding of PrP, both with respect to the formation of PrP Sc from PrP C and the assembly of rods from PrP 27-30, we solubilized Syrian hamster (sol SHa) PrP 27-30 in low concentrations (0.2%) of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) under conditions previously used to study the structural transitions of this protein. Sol SHaPrP 27-30 adopted a beta-sheet-rich structure at SDS concentrations between 0.02% and 0.04% and remained soluble. Here we report that NaCl stabilizes SHaPrP 27-30 in a soluble, beta-sheet-rich state that allows fibril assembly to proceed over several weeks. Under these conditions, fibril formation occurred not only with sol PrP 27-30, but also with native SHaPrP C . Addition of sphingolipids seems to increase fibril growth. When recombinant (rec) SHaPrP(90-231) was exposed to low concentrations of SDS, similar to those used to polymerize sol SHaPrP 27-30 in the presence of 250 mM NaCl, fibril formation occurred regularly. When fibrils formed from PrP 27-30 or PrP C were bioassayed in transgenic mice overexpressing full-length SHaPrP, no infectivity was obtained, whereas amyloid fibrils formed of rec mouse PrP(89-230) were infectious. At present, it cannot be determined whether the lack of infectivity is caused by a difference in the structure of the fibrils or in the bioassay conditions.

Single particle analysis of manganese-induced prion protein aggregates

Prion diseases are characterized by the conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) to a disease-specific aggregated isoform (PrP(Sc)). We have shown that Mn(2+) ions amplify aggregation, whereas Cu(2+) has an inhibitory effect. To characterize Mn(2+)-induced aggregates, we used cross-correlation analysis as well as scanning for intensely fluorescent targets in an SDS-dependent aggregation assay with fluorescently labeled PrP. We found that the effect of Mn(2+) was mainly due to the association of preformed PrP oligomers to larger aggregates, rapidly reversible by EDTA, and independent of the histidine-dependent copper-binding sites of PrP, suggesting that Mn(2+) induces reversible intermolecular binding. In contrast, the inhibitory effect of Cu(2+) required binding to histidine-containing binding sites, indicating that binding of copper affects the structure of PrP(C) which in turn modifies the susceptibility to manganese and the ability to aggregate. These findings suggest that copper and manganese may also affect prion propagation in vivo.

Polymorphisms at codons 108 and 189 in murine PrP play distinct roles in the control of scrapie incubation time

Susceptibility to transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) is associated strongly with PrP polymorphisms in humans, sheep and rodents. In mice, scrapie incubation time is controlled by polymorphisms at PrP codons 108 (leucine or phenylalanine) and 189 (threonine or valine), but the precise role of each polymorphism in the control of disease is unknown. The L108F and T189V polymorphisms are present in distinct structural regions of PrP and thus provide an excellent model with which to investigate the role of PrP structure and gene variation in TSEs. Two unique lines of transgenic mice, in which 108F and 189V have been targeted separately into the endogenous murine Prnp a gene, have been produced. TSE inoculation of inbred lines of mice expressing all allelic combinations at codons 108 and 189 has revealed a complex relationship between PrP allele and incubation time. It has been established that both codons 108 and 189 control TSE incubation time, and that each polymorphism plays a distinct role in the disease process. Comparison of ME7 incubation times in mouse lines that are heterozygous at both codons has also identified a previously unrecognized intramolecular interaction between PrP codons 108 and 189.

The structural transition of the prion protein into its pathogenic conformation is induced by unmasking hydrophobic sites

A series of structural intermediates in the putative pathway from the cellular prion protein PrP(C) to the pathogenic form PrP(Sc) was established by systematic variation of low concentrations (<0.1%) of the detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) or by the interaction with the bacterial chaperonin GroEL. Most extended studies were carried out with recombinant PrP (90-231) corresponding to the amino acid sequence of hamster prions PrP 27-30. Similar results were obtained with full-length recombinant PrP, hamster PrP 27-30 and PrP(C) isolated from transgenic, non-infected CHO cells. Varying the incubation conditions, i.e. the concentration of SDS, the GroEL and GroEL/ES, but always at neutral pH and room temperature, different conformations could be established. The conformations were characterized with respect to secondary structure as determined by CD spectroscopy and to molecular mass, as determined by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and analytical ultracentrifugation: alpha-helical monomers, soluble alpha-helical dimers, soluble but beta-structured oligomers of a minimal size of 12-14 PrP molecules, and insoluble multimers were observed. A high activation barrier was found between the alpha-helical dimers and beta-structured oligomers. The numbers of SDS-molecules bound to PrP in different conformations were determined: Partially denatured, alpha-helical monomers bind 31 SDS molecules per PrP molecule, alpha-helical dimers 21, beta-structured oligomers 19-20, and beta-structured multimers show very strong binding of five SDS molecules per PrP molecule. Binding of only five molecules of SDS per molecule of PrP leads to fast formation of beta-structures followed by irreversible aggregation. It is discussed that strongest binding of SDS has an effect identical with or similar to the interaction with GroEL thereby inducing identical or very similar transitions. The interaction with GroEL/ES stabilizes the soluble, alpha-helical conformation. The structure and their stabilities and particularly the induction of transitions by interaction of hydrophobic sites of PrP are discussed in respect to their biological relevance.

Effect of metal ions on de novo aggregation of full-length prion protein

It is well established that the prion protein (PrP) contains metal ion binding sites with specificity for copper. Changes in copper levels have been suggested to influence incubation time in experimental prion disease. Therefore, we studied the effect of heavy metal ions (Cu(2+), Mn(2+), Ni(2+), Co(2+), and Zn(2+)) in vitro in a model system that utilizes changes in the concentration of SDS to induce structural conversion and aggregation of recombinant PrP. To quantify and characterize PrP aggregates, we used fluorescently labelled PrP and cross-correlation analysis as well as scanning for intensely fluorescent targets in a confocal single molecule detection system. We found a specific strong pro-aggregatory effect of Mn(2+) at low micromolar concentrations that could be blocked by nanomolar concentration of Cu(2+). These findings suggest that metal ions such as copper and manganese may also affect PrP conversion in vivo.

The prion-like protein Doppel fails to interact with itself, the prion protein and the 37 kDa/67 kDa laminin receptor in the yeast two-hybrid system

The prion-like protein termed Doppel (Dpl) shows approx. 25% sequence identity with all known prion proteins (PrP). We recently showed that the cellular PrP is dimeric under native conditions, a finding which was confirmed by the investigation of its crystal structure. Human PrP further interacts with its cellular receptor, the 37 kDa/67 kDa laminin receptor (LRP/LR). Here we report that human Doppel fails to interact with (i). itself, (ii). the human 37 kDa/67 kDa LRP/LR, and (iii). the human cellular prion protein (huPrP) in the yeast two-hybrid system. Our findings suggest that Dpl and PrP are not related or are only marginally related with respect to their ligand binding behaviour.