Novel Lethal Form of Congenital Hypopituitarism Associated With the First Recessive LHX4 Mutation

BACKGROUND

LHX4 encodes a member of the LIM-homeodomain family of transcription factors that is required for normal development of the pituitary gland. To date, only incompletely penetrant heterozygous mutations in LHX4 have been described in patients with variable combined pituitary hormone deficiencies.

OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS

To report a unique family with a novel recessive variant in LHX4 associated with a lethal form of congenital hypopituitarism that was identified through screening a total of 97 patients.

METHOD

We screened 97 unrelated patients with combined pituitary hormone deficiency, including 65% with an ectopic posterior pituitary, for variants in the LHX4 gene using Sanger sequencing. Control databases (1000 Genomes, dbSNP, Exome Variant Server, ExAC Browser) were consulted upon identification of variants.

RESULTS

We identified the first novel homozygous missense variant (c.377C>T, p.T126M) in two deceased male patients of Pakistani origin with severe panhypopituitarism associated with anterior pituitary aplasia and posterior pituitary ectopia. Both were born small for gestational age with a small phallus, undescended testes, and mid-facial hypoplasia. The parents' first-born child was a female with mid-facial hypoplasia (DNA was unavailable). Despite rapid commencement of hydrocortisone and T4 in the brothers, all three children died within the first week of life. The LHX4(p.T126M) variant is located within the LIM2 domain, in a highly conserved location. The absence of homozygosity for the variant in over 65 000 controls suggests that it is likely to be responsible for the phenotype.

CONCLUSION

We report, for the first time to our knowledge, a novel homozygous mutation in LHX4 associated with a lethal phenotype, implying that recessive mutations in LHX4 may be incompatible with life.

Clostridium difficile prevalence rates in a large healthcare system stratified according to patient population, age, gender, and specimen consistency

We evaluated Clostridium difficile prevalence rates in 2,807 clinically indicated stool specimens stratified by inpatient (IP), nursing home patient (NH), outpatient (OP), age, gender, and specimen consistency using bacterial culture, toxin detection, and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) ribotyping. Rates were determined based on the detection of toxigenic C. difficile isolates. We identified significant differences in the rates between patient populations and with age. Specimens from NH had a higher rate (46%) for toxigenic C. difficile than specimens from IP (18%) and OP (17%). There were no gender-related differences in the rates. Liquid specimens had a lower rate (15%) than partially formed and soft specimens (25%) and formed specimens (18%) for the isolation of toxigenic C. difficile. The nontoxigenic rate was lowest for NH (4%) and highest for patients<20 years of age (23%). We identified 31 different toxigenic ribotypes from a sampling of 190 isolates that showed the lowest diversity in NH. Fluoroquinolone resistance was observed in 93% of the 027 isolates, all of the 053 isolates, and in four other ribotypes. We observed different rates for toxigenic C. difficile in stratified patient populations, with the highest rate for NH, a low overall nontoxigenic rate, and fluoroquinolone resistance.

Molecular analysis of novel PROP1 mutations associated with combined pituitary hormone deficiency (CPHD)

OBJECTIVE

Homozygous mutations in the gene encoding the pituitary transcription factor PROP1 are associated with combined pituitary hormone deficiency (CPHD) in both mice and humans with a highly variable phenotype with respect to the severity and time of initiation of pituitary hormone deficiency. We have ascertained three pedigrees with PROP1 mutations from a large cohort of patients with variable degrees of CPHD who were screened for mutations in PROP1.

RESULTS

Affected individuals from all three pedigrees were found to harbour novel PROP1 mutations. We have identified two siblings in one family who were homozygous for an intronic mutation (c.343-11C > G) that disrupts correct splicing resulting in the loss of exon 3 from the PROP1 transcript. Two siblings from a second, unrelated family are compound heterozygotes for two point mutations in the coding region, a missense mutation (p.R125W) that leads to impaired transcriptional activation, and a deletion of a single nucleotide (c.310delC) resulting in a frameshift and nonfunctional mutant protein. Additionally, we identified a homozygous deletion of the PROP1 locus in two patients born to consanguineous parents.

CONCLUSION

Mutations in PROP1 are a frequent cause of familial CPHD. We have described four novel mutations in PROP1 in 3 pedigrees, all resulting in PROP1 deficiency by different mechanisms. The phenotypic variation observed in association with PROP1 mutations both within and between families, together with the evolving nature of hormone deficiencies and sometimes changing pituitary morphology indicates a need for continual monitoring of these patients.

Involvement of the nuclear matrix in the control of skeletal genes: the NMP1 (YY1), NMP2 (Cbfa1), and NMP4 (Nmp4/CIZ) transcription factors

The functional role of the osteoblast nuclear matrix has been a matter of supposition. Its presumed function as an architectural agent of transcription derives primarily from the low solubility of nuclear matrix proteins and their typical localization into discrete subnuclear domains. In addressing how the nuclear matrix regulates skeletal genes, the authors compare Nmp4, Cbfal, and YY1 for the purpose of profiling osteoblast nuclear matrix transcription factors. All three proteins contribute to the transcription of ECM genes and partition into the osteoblast nuclear matrix via a nuclear matrix targeting domain. The authors propose that osteoblast nuclear matrix transcription factors involved in ECM regulation generally have the capacity to alter DNA geometry and reciprocally respond to DNA as an allosteric ligand. This may allow these proteins to adapt to the local nuclear architecture and generate the pattern of regulation specified by that architecture via unmasking of the appropriate transactivation domains. Osteoblast nuclear matrix transcription factors may also act as transcriptional adaptor molecules by supporting the formation of higher order protein complexes along target gene promoters. The genes encoding all three proteins considered here have trinucleotide repeat domains, although the significance of this is unclear. There is no canonical nuclear matrix binding motif, but finger-like structures may be suited for anchoring proteins to discrete subnuclear domains. Finally, the ability to leave the osteoblast nuclear matrix may be as important to the function of some nuclear matrix transcription factors as their association with this subcompartment.

Osteoblast intracellular localization of Nmp4 proteins

Nmp4 proteins are transcription factors that contribute to the expression of type I collagen and many of the matrix metalloproteinase genes. Numerous Nmp4 isoforms have been identified. These proteins, all derived from a single gene, have from five to eight Cys(2)His(2) zinc fingers, the arrangement of which directs specific isoforms to nuclear matrix subdomains. Nmp4 isoforms also have an SH3 binding domain, typical of cytoplasmic docking proteins. Although recent evidence indicates that Nmp4 proteins also reside in the osteoblast cytoplasm, whether they localize to specific organelles or structures is not well defined. The intracellular localization of a protein is a determinant of its function and provides insights into its mechanism of action. As a first step toward determining the functional relationship between the cytoplasmic and nuclear Nmp4 compartments, we mapped their location in the osteoblast cytoplasm. Immunocytochemical analysis of osteoblasts demonstrated that Nmp4 antibodies labeled the mitochondria, colocalized with Golgi protein 58K, and lightly stained the cytoplasm. Western analysis using Nmp4 antibodies revealed a complex profile of protein bands in the nuclear, mitochondrial, and cytosolic fractions. Several of these proteins were specific to defined intracellular domains. Consistent with the western analyses, reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis detected previously uncharacterized Nmp4 isoforms. These data necessarily enlarge the known Nmp4 family from nuclear matrix transcription factors to a more widely extended class of intracellular proteins.

Identification of porcine Lhx3 and SF1 as candidate genes for QTL affecting growth and reproduction traits in swine

The distal portion of the long arm of porcine chromosome 1 has been shown to harbour several quantitative trait loci affecting growth and reproductive traits in swine. In order to identify potential candidate genes that might underlie these effects, a comparative mapping analysis was undertaken to define the extent of orthologous segments of human chromosome 9. A microsatellite associated with heat shock protein (HSP) A5 was used to define the proximal boundary of the quantitative trait loci (QTL) region, which suggests the human orthologue of the gene(s) responsible for the observed effects lies between HSPA5 and the q arm telomere of human chromosome 9. Examination of this region revealed two candidate genes with known roles in production of hormones essential to growth and reproductive function. The steroidogenic factor 1 and Lhx3 LIM homeodomain transcription factor genes were mapped to 123 and 155 cM, respectively, of the Sus scrofa chromosome 1 (SSC1) linkage group, placing both genes within the confidence interval for the observed QTL. To further evaluate Lhx3, we examined the expression profile during porcine embryonic development. Low levels were detected at early embryonic stages, when development of the nervous system is proceeding. A transient increase in expression level is observed during the time of pituitary organogenesis and again at the time of differentiation of anterior pituitary cells, with relatively high levels of expression persisting in the adult pituitary gland. This ontology is consistent with Lhx3 being a candidate gene for the QTL.

Role of the LIM domains in DNA recognition by the Lhx3 neuroendocrine transcription factor

LIM homeodomain transcription factors regulate many aspects of development in multicellular organisms. Such factors contain two LIM domains in their amino terminus and a DNA-binding homeodomain. To better understand the mechanism of gene regulation by these proteins, we studied the role of the LIM domains in DNA interaction by Lhx3, a protein that is essential for pituitary development and motor neuron specification in mammals. By site selection, we demonstrate that Lhx3 binds at high affinity to an AT-rich consensus DNA sequence that is similar to sequences located within the promoters of some pituitary hormone genes. The LIM domains reduce the affinity of DNA binding by Lhx3, but do not affect the specificity. Lhx3 preferentially binds to the consensus site as a monomer with minor groove contacts. The Lhx3 binding consensus site confers Lhx3-dependent transcriptional activation to heterologous promoters. Further, DNA molecules containing the consensus Lhx3 binding site are bent to similar angles in complexes containing either wild type Lhx3 or Lhx3 lacking LIM domains. These data are consistent with Lhx3 having the properties of an architectural transcription factor. We also propose that there are distinct classes of LIM homeodomain transcription factors in which the LIM domains play different roles in modulating interactions with DNA sites in target genes.

An isoform-specific inhibitory domain regulates the LHX3 LIM homeodomain factor holoprotein and the production of a functional alternate translation form

The LHX3 LIM homeodomain transcription factor is required for pituitary development and motor neuron specification. The Lhx3 gene encodes two isoforms, LHX3a and LHX3b, that differ in their amino-terminal sequences. Humans and mice with defective Lhx3 genes are deficient in gonadotrope, lactotrope, somatotrope, and thyrotrope pituitary cells. We show that, whereas Lhx3b is highly expressed in these Lhx3-dependent cell types, high levels of Lhx3a expression are restricted to alpha glycoprotein subunit-expressing thyrotropes and gonadotropes. Cross-species comparison reveals the LHX3b-specific domain is more conserved than the LHX3a-specific domain. We demonstrate that the LHX3b-specific domain is a transferable inhibitor that reduces gene activation and DNA binding by homeodomain proteins. In addition, we identify a novel LHX3 protein (M2-LHX3) and determine that this molecule is generated by an internal translation initiation codon. The LHX3a- and LHX3b-specific coding sequences regulate differential usage of this internal start codon. Further, we identify the major activation domain of LHX3 in the carboxyl terminus of the molecule. M2-LHX3 is active because it retains this domain and binds DNA better than LHX3a or LHX3b. Other LIM homeodomain genes, including Lhx4, generate similar truncated proteins. These studies describe how transcriptional regulatory genes can generate multiple functional proteins.

Characterization and imaging of A6 epithelial cell clones expressing fluorescently labeled ENaC subunits

A6 model renal epithelial cells were stably transfected with enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-tagged alpha- or beta-subunits of the epithelial Na(+) channel (ENaC). Transfected RNA and proteins were both expressed in low abundance, similar to the endogenous levels of ENaC in native cells. In living cells, laser scanning confocal microscopy revealed a predominantly subapical distribution of EGFP-labeled subunits, suggesting a readily accessible pool of subunits available to participate in Na(+) transport. The basal level of Na(+) transport in the clonal lines was enhanced two- to fourfold relative to the parent line. Natriferic responses to insulin or aldosterone were similar in magnitude to the parent line, while forskolin-stimulated Na(+) transport was 64% greater than control in both the alpha- and beta-transfected lines. In response to forskolin, EGFP-labeled channel subunits traffic to the apical membrane. These data suggest that channel regulators, not the channel per se, form the rate-limiting step in response to insulin or aldosterone stimulation, while the number of channel subunits is important for basal as well as cAMP-stimulated Na(+) transport.

LHX3 transcription factor mutations associated with combined pituitary hormone deficiency impair the activation of pituitary target genes

The Lhx3 LIM homeodomain transcription factor is critical for pituitary gland formation and specification of the anterior pituitary hormone-secreting cell types. Two mutations in LHX3, a missense mutation changing a tyrosine to a cysteine and an intragenic deletion that results in a truncated protein lacking the DNA-binding homeodomain, have been identified in humans. These mutations were identified in patients with retarded growth and combined pituitary hormone deficiency and also abnormal neck and cervical spine development. For both the LHX3a and LHX3b isoforms, we compared the ability of wild type and mutant LHX3 proteins to trans-activate pituitary genes, bind DNA recognition elements, and interact with partner proteins. The tyrosine missense mutation inhibits the ability of LHX3 to induce transcription from selected target genes but does not prevent DNA binding and interaction with partner proteins such as NLI and Pit-1. Mutant LHX3 proteins lacking a homeodomain do not bind DNA and do not induce transcription from pituitary genes. These studies demonstrate that mutations in the LHX3 isoforms impair their gene regulatory functions and support the hypothesis that defects in the LHX3 gene cause complex pituitary disease in humans.

Cloning and functional analysis of a family of nuclear matrix transcription factors (NP/NMP4) that regulate type I collagen expression in osteoblasts

Collagen expression is coupled to cell structure in connective tissue. We propose that nuclear matrix architectural transcription factors link cell shape with collagen promoter geometry and activity. We previously indicated that nuclear matrix proteins (NP/NMP4) interact with the rat type I collagen alpha1(I) polypeptide chain (COL1A1) promoter at two poly(dT) sequences (sites A and B) and bend the DNA. Here, our objective was to determine whether NP/NMP4-COL1A1 binding influences promoter activity and to clone NP/NMP4. Promoter-reporter constructs containing 3.5 kilobases (kb) of COL1A1 5' flanking sequence were fused to a reporter gene. Mutation of site A or site B increased promoter activity in rat UMR-106 osteoblast-like cells. Several full-length complementary DNAs (cDNAs) were isolated from an expression library using site B as a probe. These clones expressed proteins with molecular weights and COLIA1 binding activity similar to NP/NMP4. Antibodies to these proteins disrupted native NP/NMP4-COL1A1 binding activity. Overexpression of specific clones in UMR-106 cells repressed COL1A1 promoter activity. The isolated cDNAs encode isoforms of Cys2His2 zinc finger proteins that contain an AT-hook, a motif found in architectural transcription factors. Some of these isoforms recently have been identified as Cas-interacting zinc finger proteins (CIZ) that localize to fibroblast focal adhesions and enhance metalloproteinase gene expression. We observed NP/NMP4/CIZ expression in osteocytes, osteoblasts, and chondrocytes in rat bone. We conclude that NP/NMP4/CIZ is a novel family of nuclear matrix transcription factors that may be part of a general mechanical pathway that couples cell structure and function during extracellular matrix remodeling.

Biochemical and genetic characterization of the porcine Prophet of Pit-1 pituitary transcription factor

Prophet of Pit-1 (Prop-1) is a paired class homeodomain transcription factor that is specifically expressed in the pituitary gland. Mutations in the Prop-1 gene cause compound pituitary diseases in mouse models and human patients. We have cloned and analyzed the porcine ortholog of Prop-1. Analysis of cDNAs revealed that the porcine Prop-1 sequence is similar to the mouse and human proteins within the homeodomain and carboxyl terminus, but the amino terminus is poorly conserved. The Prop-1 gene consists of three exons and two introns and spans 3.8 kilobases of genomic DNA. In addition, we mapped Prop-1 to the q arm of pig chromosome two. During development, Prop-1 is expressed at the time of pituitary organogenesis. In the adult, expression was observed at low levels only in the pituitary gland. The porcine Prop-1 protein displays similar biochemical, DNA binding, and transcriptional activities to human PROP-1. We conclude that, although the structural divergence between the porcine and human PROP-1 molecules may indicate some distinct functions, the porcine Prop-1 gene encodes a pituitary transcription factor with similar overall activities to the human ortholog.

NP/NMP4 transcription factors have distinct osteoblast nuclear matrix subdomains

The mechanisms underlying the coupling of type I collagen and matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) expression to cell structure and adhesion are poorly understood. We propose that nuclear matrix architectural transcription factors link cell structure and transcription via their association with nuclear matrix subdomains and by their capacity for altering promoter geometry. NP/NMP4 are nuclear matrix proteins that contain from five to eight Cys(2)His(2) zinc fingers. Some NP/NMP4 isoforms bind to the rat type I collagen alpha1(I) polypeptide chain promoter in the manner of architectural transcription factors and alter basal transcription in osteoblast-like cells (Thunyakitpisal et al. in review). Certain isoforms of NP/NMP4 are identical to CIZ, Cas-interacting zinc finger protein, a nucleocytoplasmic shuttling protein that associates with focal adhesions and regulates MMP expression [Nakamoto et al. (2000): Mol Cell Biol 20:1649-1658]. To better understand the role of subnuclear architecture in collagen and MMP expression, we mapped the osteoblast nuclear distribution of NP/NMP4 proteins and identified the functional motifs necessary for nuclear localization and nuclear matrix targeting. Immunofluorescence microscopy was used to determine the cellular and subnuclear distribution of native NP/NMP4 proteins and green fluorescent protein (GFP)-NP/NMP4 fusion proteins in osteoblast-like cells. All GFP-NP/NMP4 fusion proteins localized to the nucleus, but accumulated in distinct nuclear matrix subdomains. The zinc finger domain was necessary and sufficient for nuclear import and matrix targeting. We conclude that the arrangement of the NP/NMP4 zinc fingers largely determines the subnuclear location of these isoforms.

The homeodomain coordinates nuclear entry of the Lhx3 neuroendocrine transcription factor and association with the nuclear matrix

LIM homeodomain transcription factors regulate development in complex organisms. To characterize the molecular signals required for the nuclear localization of these proteins, we examined the Lhx3 factor. Lhx3 is essential for pituitary organogenesis and motor neuron specification. By using functional fluorescent derivatives, we demonstrate that Lhx3 is found in both the nucleoplasm and nuclear matrix. Three nuclear localization signals were mapped within the homeodomain, and one was located in the carboxyl terminus. The homeodomain also serves as the nuclear matrix targeting sequence. No individual signal is alone required for nuclear localization of Lhx3; the signals work in combinatorial fashion. Specific combinations of these signals transferred nuclear localization to cytoplasmic proteins. Mutation of nuclear localization signals within the homeodomain inhibited Lhx3 transcriptional function. By contrast, mutation of the carboxyl-terminal signal activated Lhx3, indicating that this region is critical to transcriptional activity and may be a target of regulatory pathways. The pattern of conservation of the nuclear localization and nuclear matrix targeting signals suggests that the LIM homeodomain factors use similar mechanisms for subcellular localization. Furthermore, upon nuclear entry, association of Lhx3 with the nuclear matrix may contribute to LIM homeodomain factor interaction with other classes of transcription factors.

Molecular analysis of LHX3 and PROP-1 in pituitary hormone deficiency patients with posterior pituitary ectopia

The cause of posterior pituitary ectopia associated with anterior pituitary hormone deficiencies is unknown. We describe children with combined pituitary hormone deficiency (CPHD) or isolated GH deficiency. In all cases, magnetic resonance imaging examination revealed abnormal pituitary gland development featuring ectopic posterior lobe location and frequently hypoplastic anterior lobes. Embryonic development of the pituitary requires the coordinated expression of specific transcription factors. Mutations of the PIT-1 and PROP-1 transcription factors are responsible for CPHD in some patients with normally positioned posterior pituitaries. In mice, the Lhx3 LIM homeodomain transcription factor is required for both structural development and cellular differentiation of the pituitary gland. Thus, we hypothesized that mutations in one or both of the two human LHX3 isoforms are responsible for posterior pituitary ectopia associated with anterior pituitary hypopituitarism. Comprehensive molecular analysis of the LHX3 isoforms was performed to test this hypothesis. No loss of function mutations in the LHX3 gene were detected. In addition, analysis of PROP-1 did not reveal mutations that might cause this phenotype. These studies suggest that the abnormal processes leading to the development of CPHD or GH deficiency associated with posterior pituitary ectopia are not a result of aberrant LHX3 or PROP- 1 function, but may be caused by defects at other gene loci.

Applications of developmental biology to medicine and animal agriculture

With the complete sequence of the human genome expected by winter 2001, genomic-based drug discovery efforts of the pharmaceutical industry are focusing on finding the relatively few therapeutically useful genes from among the total gene set. Methods to rapidly elucidate gene function will have increasing value in these investigations. The use of model organisms in functional genomics has begun to be recognized and exploited and is one example of the emerging use of the tools of developmental biology in recent drug discovery efforts. The use of protein products expressed during embryo-genesis and the use of certain pluripotent cell populations (stem cells) as candidate therapeutics are other applications of developmental biology to the treatment of human diseases. These agents may be used to repair damaged or diseased tissues by inducing or directing developmental programs that recapitulate embryonic processes to replace specialized cells. The activation or silencing of embryonic genes in the disease state, particularly those encoding transcription factors, is another avenue of exploitation. Finally, the direct drug-induced manipulation of embryonic development is a unique application of developmental biology in animal agriculture.

Analysis of the human LHX3 neuroendocrine transcription factor gene and mapping to the subtelomeric region of chromosome 9

The Lhx3 LIM homeodomain transcription factor is critical to pituitary organogenesis and motor neuron development. We determined the genomic structure and chromosomal localization of human LHX3. The gene contains seven coding exons and six introns that span 8.7 kilobases in length. The LHX3 gene codes for two functionally distinct isoforms that differ in their amino termini but share common LIM domains and a homeodomain. The functional domains of the LHX3 proteins are encoded by distinct exons. The alternate amino termini and LIM domains lie within individual exons, and the homeodomain is coded by two exons interrupted by a small intron. Human LHX3 maps to the subtelomeric region of chromosome 9 at band 9q34.3, within a region noted for chromosomal translocation and insertion events. Characterization of the genomic organization and chromosomal localization of LHX3 will enable molecular evaluation and genetic diagnoses of pituitary diseases and central nervous system developmental disorders in humans.

Differential activation of pituitary hormone genes by human Lhx3 isoforms with distinct DNA binding properties

Lhx3 is a LIM homeodomain transcription factor essential for pituitary development and motor neuron specification in mice. We identified two isoforms of human Lhx3, hLhx3a and hLhx3b, which differ in their ability to trans-activate pituitary gene targets. These factors are identical within the LIM domains and the homeodomain, but differ in their amino-terminal sequences preceding the LIM motifs. Both isoforms are localized to the nucleus and are expressed in the adult human pituitary, but gene activation studies demonstrate characteristic functional differences. Human Lhx3a trans-activated the alpha-glycoprotein subunit promoter and a reporter construct containing a high-affinity Lhx3 binding site more effectively than the hLhx3b isoform. In addition, hLhx3a synergized with the pituitary POU domain factor, Pit-1, to strongly induce transcription of the TSHbeta-subunit gene, while hLhx3b did not. We demonstrate that the differences in gene activation properties between hLhx3a and hLhx3b correlate with their DNA binding to sites within these genes. The short hLhx3b-specific amino-terminal domain inhibits DNA binding and gene activation functions of the molecule. These data suggest that isoforms of Lhx3 may play distinct roles during development of the mammalian pituitary gland and other neuroendocrine systems.

Characterization of the porcine Lhx3/LIM-3/P-Lim LIM homeodomain transcription factor

Lhx3/LIM-3/P-Lim is a LIM homeodomain transcription factor which is essential in mice for the development of anterior and intermediate lobes of the pituitary gland. We report the cloning and characterization of porcine Lhx3. The porcine Lhx3 protein exhibits strong similarity to murine Lhx3 within the amino terminal LIM domains and the homeodomain, however, it is diverged in regions outside these motifs. Expression vectors for porcine Lhx3 activated murine and porcine alpha-glycoprotein reporter genes in transfection assays, and recombinant porcine Lhx3 protein specifically bound to a target site within the porcine alpha-glycoprotein gene upstream sequence. In addition, porcine Lhx3 synergistically induced transcription from prolactin enhancer/promoter reporter genes in cooperation with the Pit-1 pituitary transcription factor. Porcine Lhx3 protein interacted with Pit-1 protein in solution and also with the LIM domain-binding protein NLI/Lbd1/CLIM. Together, these data indicate that many aspects of Lhx3 function in the mammalian pituitary are conserved and that Lhx3 may be involved in the activation of trophic hormone genes during early and late stages of pituitary organogenesis. Divergence in the Lhx3 amino acid sequence between mammalian species may suggest distinct activities for this protein in some species and may help identify important functional domains of this key developmental transcription factor.

Hormone signaling pathways: planes, trains, and automobiles

Hormones and Signaling, Volume 1 Edited by Bert O'Malley. San Diego, Academic Press, 1998, $69.95 (xv+364 pages), ISBN 0-23-312411-5.

The Pit-1 gene is regulated by distinct early and late pituitary-specific enhancers

The differentiation of three anterior pituitary cell types is regulated by the tissue-specific POU domain factor Pit-1, which is initially expressed on Embryonic Day 13.5-14 in mice. The Pit-1 gene remains continuously, highly expressed in the somatotrope, thyrotrope, and lactotrope cells of the adult. Using the Pit-1-defective Snell dwarf as a genetic background, we demonstrate that the Pit-1 gene utilizes distinct enhancers for initial gene activation and for subsequent autoregulation (required for maintenance of expression) and that Pit-1-dependent activation of the distal enhancer can be mediated in the absence of the early enhancer. These two distinct enhancers provide the basis for temporally specific regulation by discrete pituitary-specific factors, events likely to be prototypic for regulation of other classes of genes encoding transcription factors controlling terminal differentiation.

Function of the conserved Pit-1 gene distal enhancer in progenitor and differentiated pituitary cells

Pit-1 is a homeodomain transcription factor that is required for the function and survival of the hormone-secreting somatotrope, lactotrope and thyrotrope cells of the anterior pituitary gland. Within the upstream region of the mouse Pit-1 gene at around -10 kb, a complex transcriptional enhancer confers autoregulation and response to hormones and morphogens upon the gene. We demonstrate that this enhancer is conserved in both sequence and function and that related sequences are present in other rodents. Enhancer sequences from mouse, rat and hamster Pit-1 genes activated transcription from Pit-1 promoter reporter genes in a pituitary progenitor cell line, in somatolactotrope cells and conferred pituitary cell-specific activation on heterologous promoters. Elements allowing regulation by vitamin D3, pituitary-specific factors and Pit-1-dependent response to retinoic acid are well conserved. Studies comparing distal enhancer activity with that of a second proposed enhancer sequence at -3 to -5 kb in the rat Pit-1 gene revealed that the distal enhancer has markedly higher activity than the -3 to -5 kb region in both progenitor and differentiated pituitary cell lines. The functional conservation of the distal enhancer element suggests that it is crucial to the maintenance and cell-specific regulation of the Pit-1 gene.

A novel family of Cys-Cys, His-Cys zinc finger transcription factors expressed in developing nervous system and pituitary gland

A screen designed to identify proteins that specifically bind to retinoic acid response elements resulted in the identification of a rat cDNA encoding a novel protein containing six Cys-Cys, His-Cys zinc fingers. This gene is expressed in a restricted fashion exhibiting distinct temporal and spatial patterns in the developing nervous system, primarily brain, spinal cord, sensory ganglia, retina, and nasal epithelia, as well as in the pituitary, and is referred to as neural zinc finger factor 1 (NZF-1). NZF-1 binds specifically to a cis-regulatory element of the beta-retinoic acid receptor (RAR beta) gene, as well as to other related DNA elements, including two in the upstream enhancer region of the mouse Pit-1 gene. In heterologous cells, NZF-1 activates transcription from promoters containing specific binding sequences and can synergize with other factors, such as Pit-1, to regulate gene expression. These results suggest that NZF-1 may exert regulatory roles in the developing and mature nervous system and in the pituitary gland. Identification of a second mouse gene highly homologous to NZF-1, encoded by a distinct genomic locus, reveals a dispersed gene family encoding proteins containing Cys-Cys, His-Cys motifs.

P-Lim, a LIM homeodomain factor, is expressed during pituitary organ and cell commitment and synergizes with Pit-1

A pituitary LIM homeodomain factor, P-Lim, is expressed as Rathke's pouch forms and as specific pituitary cell phenotypes are established, suggesting functional roles throughout pituitary development. While selectively expressed in both anterior and intermediate pituitary in mature mice, P-Lim is also transiently expressed in the developing ventral neural cord and brainstem. P-Lim binds to and activates the promoter of the alpha-glycoprotein subunit gene, a marker of early pituitary development, and synergizes with Pit-1 in transcriptional activation of genes encoding terminal differentiation markers. The LIM domain of P-Lim specifically interacts with the Pit-1 POU domain and is required for synergistic interactions with Pit-1, but not for basal transcriptional activation events.

Transcriptional mechanisms in anterior pituitary cell differentiation

Development of the anterior pituitary gland involves the establishment of five distinct cell lineages which are each characterized by the expression of specific trophic hormone genes. Recent studies of the thyrotrope, somatotrope, and lactotrope cell types have investigated the molecular decisions responsible for the commitment and differentiation of these cell types and have characterized the regulatory mechanisms that govern cell-specific expression of individual hormone genes. In particular, elucidation of the molecular basis of heritable dwarf phenotypes lacking particular pituitary cell lineages, such as the Snell, Jackson, and little dwarf mice, and studies of the regulation of trans-acting factors, including Pit-1, involved in pituitary cell restricted gene activation have begun to delineate the pathways responsible for development of this organ.

An alternative Pit-1 RNA splicing product reveals modular binding and nonmodular transcriptional activities of the POU-specific domain

We have identified a form of the pituitary-specific POU protein Pit-1 that results from deletion of the POU-specific (POUs) domain by alternative RNA splicing. This natural variant of Pit-1 (called delta 4Pit-1) has revealed several aspects of the function of the POUs domain. The delta 4Pit-1 protein was characterized using a delta 4Pit-1-specific antiserum. Further, selection assays of random oligonucleotide pools identified binding site preferences for both wild type and delta 4Pit-1. Methylation interference, copper phenanthrolene, and missing contact analyses were used to compare the binding characteristics of the two forms of Pit-1 on a selected site. DNA binding affinity assays on several DNA elements revealed that the POUs domain contains a modular DNA binding activity affecting the DNA binding affinity of the entire POU domain on some, but not on other, DNA sites. Functional analysis on such DNA elements has revealed that the POUs domain is an essential, but nonmodular, component of the Pit-1 trans-activation domain dependent on its natural context within the Pit-1 protein.

A tissue-specific enhancer confers Pit-1-dependent morphogen inducibility and autoregulation on the pit-1 gene

Pit-1 is a tissue-specific POU domain factor obligatory for the appearance of three cell phenotypes in the anterior pituitary gland. Expression of the pit-1 gene requires the actions of a cell-specific 390-bp enhancer, located 10 kb 5' of the pit-1 transcription initiation site, within sequence that proves essential for effective pituitary targeting of transgene expression during murine development. The enhancer requires the concerted actions of a cell-specific cis-active element, Pit-1 autoregulatory sites, and atypical morphogen response elements. Pituitary ontogeny in the Pit-1-defective Snell dwarf mouse reveals that pit-1 autoregulation is not required for initial activation or continued expression during critical phases of Pit-1 target gene activation but, subsequently, is necessary for maintenance of pit-1 gene expression following birth. A potent 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3-responsive enhancer element defines a physiological site in which a single nucleotide alteration in the sequence of core binding motifs modulates the spacing rules for nuclear receptor response elements. Unexpectedly, the major retinoic acid response element is absolutely dependent on Pit-1 for retinoic acid receptor function. On this DNA element, Pit-1 appears to function as a coregulator of the retinoic acid receptor, suggesting an intriguing linkage between a cell-specific transcription factor and the actions of morphogen receptors that is likely to be prototypic of mechanisms by which other cell-specific transcription factors might confer morphogen receptor responsivity during mammalian organogenesis.

A unique pattern of expression of the four muscle regulatory factor proteins distinguishes somitic from embryonic, fetal and newborn mouse myogenic cells

A unique pattern of expression of the four muscle regulatory factor (MRF) proteins was found to distinguish early somitic from embryonic, fetal and newborn limb myogenic cells in vitro. Expression of the myosin heavy chain (MHC), MyoD, myogenin, Myf-5, and MRF4 proteins was examined by immunocytochemistry in cultures of four distinct types of mouse myogenic cells: somitic (E8.5), embryonic (E11.5), fetal (E16.5) and newborn limb. In embryonic, fetal and newborn cultures, the MRF proteins were expressed in generally similar patterns: MyoD was the first MRF expressed; MyoD and myogenin were expressed by more cells than Myf-5 or MRF4; and each of the four MRFs was found both in cells that expressed MHC and in cells that did not express MHC. In cultures of somitic cells, in contrast, Myf-5 was expressed first and by more cells than MyoD or myogenin; MRF4 was not detected; and the MRFs were never found to be coexpressed with MHC in the same cell. Thus, some somitic cells had the unexpected ability to maintain MHC expression in the absence of detectable MRF protein expression. The different myogenic programs of embryonic, fetal and newborn myogenic cells are not, therefore, a simple result of qualitatively different MRF expression patterns, whereas myogenesis by somitic cells does include a unique pattern of MRF expression.

Isolation and structural analysis of the rat MyoD gene

We have cloned and determined the nucleotide (nt) sequence of a 6.5-kb genomic DNA fragment containing the rat MyoD gene (encoding a muscle regulatory factor, MyoD). Mouse fibroblasts transfected with this DNA display a high degree of conversion to a muscle phenotype, suggesting that this genomic clone contains sufficient sequence information to allow the production of the rat MyoD protein in these cells. The 6.5-kb genomic fragment contains the complete coding region of MyoD, distributed over three exons, plus 2.3 kb of 5'-noncoding sequence and 1.4 kb of 3'-noncoding sequence. Based on RNase protection assays, the major transcription start point of MyoD is located 210 nt 5' to a methionine start codon and 26 nt 3' to a TAAATA motif which bears similarity to a consensus recognition sequence (TATA) utilized by eukaryotic RNA polymerase II transcription complexes. The high degree of identity between the amino acid sequence of rat MyoD and the MyoD proteins isolated from other vertebrates indicates that this muscle regulatory protein has been evolutionarily conserved.

Expression of the muscle regulatory factor MRF4 during somite and skeletal myofiber development

The muscle regulatory factors MRF4, myogenin, myf-5, and MyoD constitute a family of proteins that can function as muscle-specific transcriptional activators. Although this gene family has been extensively studied, a specific role for each factor during myogenesis remains to be determined. Understanding how these factors function requires a detailed analysis of their expression patterns during development. Toward this goal, we examined the temporal pattern of expression of MRF4 and the other factors in the rat myogenic cell line L6J1-C, in newborn rat primary muscle cell cultures and in fetal and postnatal rat limb muscle. Our results demonstrate that MyoD, myogenin, and myf-5 transcripts accumulate maximally at various stages of myoblast differentiation and decline to low expression levels in adult muscle tissue. In contrast, MRF4 transcript accumulation is restricted to cell cultures containing multinucleate myofibers, and its expression in vivo increases sharply during late fetal muscle development. This level of MRF4 expression is maintained in the adult which, together with decreased expression of the other three muscle regulatory factors, makes MRF4 the predominant factor in adult muscle. In situ hybridization of mouse embryo tissue sections indicates that MRF4 transcripts accumulate in the limb beginning 13.5 days post coitum, which is 2 days later than the initial appearance of myogenin and MyoD transcripts. Hybridization to earlier stages of development reveals, however, that MRF4 mRNA initially is present in the myotomal compartment of the somites, just after myogenin but 2 days prior to MyoD expression. Unlike myogenin and MyoD, MRF4 expression declines in the myotomes at the time that multinucleate axial muscles begin to form in this region, although during later development MRF4 is expressed in the myofibers of axial muscles at levels comparable to those in the limb. Differences in the expression patterns for MRF4, myogenin, myf-5 and MyoD between myotomal and other skeletal muscle development suggest that the relative timing of expression for each muscle regulatory factor may control the distinct phenotypes associated with myotomal myocytes and multinucleate myofibers.

Differential trans activation associated with the muscle regulatory factors MyoD1, myogenin, and MRF4

Expression of the mammalian muscle regulatory factors MyoD1, myogenin, and MRF4 will convert C3H10T1/2 fibroblasts to stable muscle cell lineages. Recent studies have shown that MyoD1 and myogenin also trans-activate expression of a number of cotransfected contractile protein genes, suggesting that these muscle regulatory factors are involved in controlling terminal differentiation events. The extent and specificity of trans activation by the muscle regulatory factors, however, have not been compared directly. In this study, we found that MyoD1, myogenin, and MRF4 exhibited different trans-activation capacities. In contrast to MyoD1 and myogenin, MRF4 was inefficient in trans-activating most of the genes tested, although conversion of C3H10T1/2 fibroblasts to a myogenic lineage was observed at similar frequencies with all three factors. Addition of basic fibroblast growth factor to cells expressing exogenous muscle regulatory factors inhibited the transcriptional activation of cotransfected genes, demonstrating that MyoD1, myogenin, or MRF4 proteins alone are not sufficient to produce a terminally differentiated phenotype. In all cases, trans activation was dependent on signal transduction pathways that are regulated by fibroblast growth factor. Our observations, coupled with previous studies showing differences in the temporal expression and protein structure of MyoD1, myogenin, and MRF4, suggest that the individual members of the muscle regulatory factor family have distinct biological roles in controlling skeletal muscle development.

Identification of MRF4: a new member of the muscle regulatory factor gene family

We have identified a rat cDNA encoding MRF4, a new member of the muscle regulatory factor gene family that includes MyoD1, myogenin, and Myf-5. MRF4 encodes a predicted 27-kD protein that contains a conserved helix-loop-helix motif, which is a common feature of this gene family. Northern analyses indicate that MRF4 is expressed solely in skeletal muscle tissue but is not detected in most embryonic muscle cell lines. Transfection of MRF4 into C3H10T1/2 fibroblasts produces stable myogenic lineages at frequencies that are equal to or greater than those obtained when MyoD1 or myogenin are introduced into these cells. Expression of the MRF4 cDNA leads to expression of the endogenous MyoD1 and myogenin genes, although C3H10T1/2 cells expressing MyoD1 or myogenin cDNAs do not express MRF4. Interestingly, the endogenous MyoD1 and myogenin genes are negatively regulated by serum and by purified growth factors since MRF4-transfected C3H10T1/2 cells activate MyoD1 and myogenin expression only in mitogen-depleted, differentiation-induced muscle cultures. The myofiber-specific expression pattern of MyoD1 and myogenin in these cells suggests that the primary role for this muscle regulatory factor gene family may be in regulating specific terminal differentiation events that are crucial for normal skeletal muscle development.

Fibroblast growth factor and transforming growth factor beta repress transcription of the myogenic regulatory gene MyoD1

In this report, we demonstrate that myogenic cultures inhibited from differentiating by treatment with fibroblast growth factor or transforming growth factor beta show reduced levels of MyoD1 mRNA. Although this repression may contribute to the inhibition of myogenesis by growth factors, additional regulatory pathways must be affected, since inhibition still occurs in cultures engineered to constitutively express MyoD1 mRNA.