The NOD mouse: recessive diabetogenic gene in the major histocompatibility complex

Local expression of transgene encoded TNF alpha in islets prevents autoimmune diabetes in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice by preventing the development of auto-reactive islet-specific T cells

Lately, TNF alpha has been the focus of studies of autoimmunity; its role in the progression of autoimmune diabetes is, however, still unclear. To analyze the effects of TNF alpha in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), we have generated nonobese diabetic (NOD) transgenic mice expressing TNF alpha under the control of the rat insulin II promoter (RIP). In transgenic mice, TNF alpha expression on the islets resulted in massive insulitis, composed of CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells, and B cells. Despite infiltration of considerable number of lymphoid cells in islets, expression of TNF alpha protected NOD mice from IDDM. To determine the mechanism of TNF alpha action, splenic cells from control NOD and RIP-TNF alpha mice were adoptively transferred to NOD-SCID recipients. In contrast to the induction of diabetes by splenic cells from control NOD mice, splenic cells from RIP-TNF alpha transgenic mice did not induce diabetes in NOD-SCID recipients. Diabetes was induced however, in the RIP-TNF alpha transgenic mice when CD8+ diabetogenic cloned T cells or splenic cells from diabetic NOD mice were adoptively transferred to these mice. Furthermore, expression of TNF alpha in islets also downregulated splenic cell responses to autoantigens. These data establish a mechanism of TNF alpha action and provide evidence that local expression of TNF alpha protects NOD mice from autoimmune diabetes by preventing the development of autoreactive islet-specific T cells.

Non-obese diabetic mice hemizygous at the T cell receptor alpha locus are susceptible to diabetes and sialitis

To test the hypothesis that T cells carrying two T cell receptor (TCR) alpha chains play a role in autoimmunity, we backcrossed the non-obese diabetic (NOD) strain with one carrying a TCR alpha gene disrupted by homologous recombination. Mice carrying one copy of the disrupted gene are incapable of generating T cells carrying two cell surface TCR alpha chains. Our early results suggested that either dual TCR alpha T cells play a role in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) induction in NOD mice or that a locus co-segregating with the disrupted TCR alpha locus protected mice from diabetes induction. From the analysis both of mice in which the region co-segregating with the disrupted TCR alpha locus is minimized and of the F1 offspring of NOD mice with the 129 strain (TCR alpha hemizygous mice), the apparent protective effect of the absence of dual TCR alpha T cells is lost; thus, such cells do not appear to play a critical role in autoimmune disease in NOD mice.

Monoclonal T cells identified in early NOD islet infiltrates

To examine the hypothesis that a single initiating antigen was recognized by a monoclonal T cell population leading to subsequent inflammatory insulitis in non-obese (NOD) mouse islets, we examined the T cell receptor TCR V beta repertoire of islet-infiltrating T cells in very young (2-week-old) NOD mice. In independent experiments, we repeatedly identified one monoclonal TCR V-beta 8.2 gene product expressed by T lymphocytes infiltrating the islets of NOD mice at 2 weeks of age. The resultant inflammatory response quickly obscures the monoclonal nature of the initiating event. These data suggest that autoimmune diabetes in NOD mice may be initiated by recognition of a single autoantigen.

Different contribution of HLA-DR and -DQ genes in susceptibility and resistance to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM)

Previous studies have indicated that certain alleles of HLA-DR and -DQ genes were strongly associated with susceptibility and resistance to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), and the role of DQ molecule in IDDM has been suggested. To further clarify the association of DQ alleles with IDDM, we determined the nucleotide sequences of full-length cDNA from 13 DQA1 alleles and 14 DQB1 alleles. The sequencing analysis revealed sequence polymorphisms outside the hypervariable region of DQ genes. We then analyzed the DQA1 and DQB1 polymorphisms along with that of DRB genes in 86 B-lymphoblastoid cell lines (B-LCLs) from various ethnic groups and in healthy unrelated Japanese and Norwegian individuals. The allelic and haplotypic distributions in each population revealed the characteristic haplotypic formation in the HLA class II region. HLA genes in 139 Japanese and 100 Norwegian IDDM patients were analyzed. DQB1*0301 was negatively associated with IDDM in both ethnic groups, irrespective of associated DRB1 and DQA1 alleles. In DQB1*0302 positive populations, which represented a positive association with IDDM in both ethnic groups, DRB1*0401, *0404, *0802 haplotypes increased in the patients, whereas DRB1*0406 haplotype decreased. Considering about the hierarchy in DRB1 alleles with IDDM susceptibility (DRB1*0401>*0404>*0403 in Norwegian and DRB1*0802>*0403>*0406 in Japanese), the genetic predisposition to IDDM is suggested to be defined by the combination of DR-associated susceptibility and DQ-associated susceptibility and by the DQ-associated resistance which is a dominant genetic trait.

The contribution of insulitis to diabetes development in tumor necrosis factor transgenic mice

The inflammatory response mediated by cytokines such as TNF can promote recruitment of lymphocytes to a tissue. Moreover, if other conditions are met, this can provide a predisposing role to autoimmune disease. TNFs induce the appearance of adhesion molecules (and presumably, therefore, extravasation of lymphocytes into tissue from the vasculature) and increase the levels of MHC class I on tissue. However, it is not clear which of these effects plays the key role in induction of disease. This should be the subject of further study. The data substantiate the hypothesis that chronic inflammation might play a precipitating role in autoimmunity and could be one of the environmental factors of importance in the development of so many autoimmune diseases.

Development of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in [(NOD + BALB/c) --> NOD] mixed allogeneic bone marrow chimeras

To examine the possibility that the bone marrow cells of BALB/c genotype interfere with the development of insulitis and diabetes in NOD mice, we transplanted BALB/c bone marrow cells mixed with NOD bone marrow cells into NOD mice. The [(NOD + BALB/c) --> NOD] chimeras developed insulitis and diabetes, indicating that BALB/c bone marrow cells do not interfere with the development of the disease in NOD mice. Surprisingly, these mice have been reconstituted with only NOD hematolymphoid cells. When the pancreatic tissues from newborn NOD and BALB/c mice were grafted into [(NOD + BALB/c) --> NOD] chimeras, the BALB/c pancreatic tissues were rejected, whereas the NOD graft showed insulitis. Furthermore, the spleen cells of the chimeras showed responsiveness to BALB/c spleen cells in mixed lymphocyte reaction and generated cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for the H-2d and third party targets. These findings indicate that the hematolymphoid cells (including hemopoietic stem cells) of NOD mice are more resilient than those of normal BALB/c mice, and that insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus will recur after bone marrow transplantation unless the hematolymphoid cells of NOD mice are completely destroyed by irradiation.

Exacerbated autoimmunity associated with a T helper-1 cytokine profile shift in H-2E-transgenic mice

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II genes are the strongest susceptibility markers for many human autoimmune diseases. A perplexing aspect of this is that HLA alleles can confer either susceptibility or dominant protection. In nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, the strongest known diabetes susceptibility locus is within the MHC and is presumed to be the H-2Ag7 product. When NOD mice carry a transgenic E alpha d molecule allowing expression of an H-2E heterodimer, diabetes is prevented. We investigated whether, as in human autoimmunity, a single class II heterodimer might protect from some autoimmune diseases while predisposing to others. NOD mice are susceptible to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) induced by the proteolipoprotein (PLP) epitope 56-70. Susceptibility to EAE was analyzed in NOD mice which either have or lack transgenic H-2E expression. We found that H-2E expression in NOD mice has converse effects on diabetes and EAE: while diabetes is prevented, EAE is greatly exacerbated and leads to demyelination. Although PLP 56-70 could be presented both in the context of H-2A and H-2E, increased disease severity in H-2E transgenic mice could not be attributed either to an enhanced T cell proliferative response to PLP or to differences in determinant spread. However, cytokine analysis of the response revealed important differences between NOD mice and their H-2E transgenic counterparts: H-2E expression was associated with reduced interleukin-4 secretion and enhanced interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) secretion by lymph node cells, while the response of central nervous system infiltrating T cells displayed a markedly enhanced IFN-gamma response. Thus, whether a particular class II molecule confers resistance or susceptibility to an autoimmune disease may depend on differential cytokine profiles elicited by particular class II/autoantigen complexes.

Genetic polymorphism of the human tumor necrosis factor region in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Linkage disequilibrium of TNFab microsatellite alleles with HLA haplotypes

The TNF region within the MHC includes a number of immunologically important genes. Microsatellites TNFa and TNFb adjacent to TNF exhibit extensive polymorphism. Employing a PCR-based technique, we identified TNFab haplotypes and defined their distribution in 97 controls and 48 diabetics of Caucasoid origin in a search for other genes within the MHC potentially associated with IDDM. Twenty-five different TNFab haplotypes were identified. A significant difference (p < 0.0005) in frequency between patients and controls was found for TNFa1b5 (relative risk 53). However, no other TNFab microsatellites demonstrated significantly different frequencies. Among diabetics TNFa1b5 was found to be in linkage disequilibrium with HLA-DR3-B18, a haplotype known to be associated with IDDM. Thus the increased frequency of TNFa1b5 among diabetics could reflect a linkage disequilibrium with a gene within the TNF region or with other genes, including the HLAs, which characterize this haplotype. In both controls and diabetics TNFa2b3 and TNFa7b4 were in linkage disequilibrium with DR3-B8 and DR7, respectively. Among diabetics, TNFa2b1 and TNFa6b5 were in linkage disequilibrium with DR4-B62 and DR4-B44, respectively. It is intriguing that TNFab haplotypes, represented by a short piece of about 200 nucleotides in the untranslated region upstream of TNF beta gene, maintain strong linkage disequilibria with different HLA haplotypes extending over 1 million base pairs. The identification of TNFab microsatellites exhibiting a high polymorphic index in a region lacking known polymorphic markers may provide potentially important information regarding the association of HLA haplotypes with autoimmune diseases, as they are in close proximity to other genes of immunologic importance.

Identification of a new susceptibility locus for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus by ancestral haplotype congenic mapping

The number and exact locations of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-linked diabetogenic genes (Idd-1) are unknown because of strong linkage disequilibrium within the MHC. By using a congenic NOD mouse strain that possesses a recombinant MHC from a diabetes-resistant sister strain, we have now shown that Idd-1 consists of at least two components, one in and one outside the class II A and E regions. A new susceptibility gene (Idd-16) was mapped to the < 11-centiMorgan segment of chromosome 17 adjacent to, but distinct from, previously known Idd-1 candidates, class II A, E, and Tap genes. The coding sequences and splicing donor and acceptor sequences of the Tnfa gene, a candidate gene for Idd-16, were identical in the NOD, CTS, and BALB/c alleles, ruling out amino acid changes in the TNF molecule as a determinant of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus susceptibility. Our results not only map a new MHC-linked diabetogenic gene(s) but also suggest a new way to fine map disease susceptibility genes within a region where strong linkage disequilibrium exists.

A major histocompatibility complex class II restriction for BioBreeding/Worcester diabetes-inducing T cells

Inbred diabetes-prone (DP) BioBreeding/Worcester (BB/Wor) (RT1u) rats develop spontaneous autoimmune diabetes, which, like human insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, is mediated by autoreactive T lymphocytes. Breeding studies have shown an absolute requirement for at least one copy of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) RT1u haplotype for spontaneous diabetes expression. Concanavalin A-activated spleen cells from acutely diabetic DP rats adoptively transfer diabetes only to recipients that express at least one RT1u haplotype. To investigate the basis for the MHC requirement in BB/Wor autoimmunity, diabetes-inducing T cell lines were derived from the spleens of acutely diabetic DP rats. Upon activation in vitro with islet cells, the T cell lines adoptively transfer insulitis and diabetes into young DP recipients and non-diabetes-prone RT1 congenic rat strains that are class IIu. Recipients that are RT1u at only the class I A or C locus, but not at the class II B/D loci, do not develop diabetes after T cell transfer. The adoptive transfer of diabetes by Concanavalin A-activated diabetic DP spleen cells also requires that donor and recipient share class II B/Du gene products. Furthermore, the adoptive transfer of diabetes into MHC class IIu congenic rats is independent of the class I haplotype; i.e., it occurs in the presence of class I Aa Cu or Au Ca gene products. BB/Wor T cells can be activated in vitro for the transfer of diabetes with islet cell antigens and class II-positive but not class IIu-negative antigen-presenting cells. The inductive phase of BB diabetes is therefore MHC class II restricted, and this appears to operate at the level of interaction between inducing T cells and class IIu antigen-presenting cells. These results may explain the well-documented, but not yet understood, MHC class II genetic contribution to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus pathogenesis, and they may facilitate the development of protocols designed to prevent diabetes onset in susceptible individuals.

Mapping the diabetes polygene Idd3 on mouse chromosome 3 by use of novel congenic strains

Development of novel congenic mouse strains has allowed us to better define the location of the diabetogenic locus, Idd3, on Chromosome (Chr) 3. Congenic strains were identified by use of published and newly developed microsatellite markers, their genomes fingerprinted by a rapid, fluorescence-based approach, and their susceptibility to type 1 diabetes evaluated. The maximum interval containing Idd3 is now approximately 4 cM.

No evidence for TCR V beta repertoire changes influencing disease protection in E-transgenic NOD mice

In order to study whether positive selection of T cells plays any role in the MHC-dependent protection from diabetes in the non-obese-diabetic (NOD) mouse, the T cell V beta repertoire has been studied in NOD mice and in NOD mice either transgenic for the wildtype MHC class II E alpha gene, or for delta Y, a promotor-mutagenized E alpha gene with a restricted tissue expression. The E alpha transgenic line is protected from both insulitis and diabetes. The delta Y transgenic line is neither protected from insulitis nor from diabetes, although it can perform both positive and negative E-mediated selection in the thymus. The V beta repertoire was studied in the pancreatic lymph nodes as these drain the area which is the target for the autoimmune attack. We see no evidence for E alpha TCR V beta repertoire differing from both nontransgenic NOD mice and delta Y mice despite its striking difference in susceptibility to autoimmunity. We conclude that none of the differences in the TCR V beta repertoire of E alpha-transgenic NOD mice hitherto observed are likely to explain the protective effect of E molecule expression in NOD mice.

Molecular genetics of diabetes mellitus

As a result of advances in technology, genome searches have been carried out for susceptibility genes for type 1 diabetes in humans and in the NOD mouse. These have shown that, in the NOD mouse, diabetes susceptibility is under the control of at least ten separate chromosomal loci. In the human, in addition to HLA and INS, two new susceptibility genes have been localized, IDDM4 on chromosome 11q and IDDM5 on 6q, demonstrating the polygenic nature of type 1 diabetes and the role of HLA as the major locus. Candidate genes at these loci are the subject of current investigation. Genetic and immunological markers of disease may be of value in screening the general population for individuals at risk of developing type 1 diabetes. The predictive power of different screening strategies should be tested in order to work out the potential value to the general population of preventive therapies that are now undergoing clinical trials in high risk 'pre-diabetics'. Type 2 diabetes is genetically heterogeneous, and, since 1992, two distinct genetic subtypes have been identified. The first is defined by mutations in the GCK gene, which cause up to 60% of cases of MODY. The second, designated MIDD (maternally inherited diabetes and deafness), is defined by mutation in the mitochondrial gene for tRNA(Leu(UUR)). MIDD patients are less obese than is usual for typical type 2 diabetes, may present in early adult life or occasionally in childhood and may have been diagnosed as having autoimmune type 1 diabetes, type 2 diabetes or MODY. Typically, patients with MIDD require insulin earlier than do type 2 diabetics without mitochondrial mutations. Genetically complex diseases, such as diabetes, hypertension, cancer and coronary heart disease, are common in most populations. The approaches to the genetic analysis of diabetes outlined in this review are likely to be useful to the genetic analysis of many of these disorders. Progress in this area will have important implications for public health strategies in the next decade and beyond.

T helper cell subsets in insulin-dependent diabetes

It has been proposed that the development of insulin-dependent diabetes is controlled by the T helper 1 (TH1) versus TH2 phenotype of autoreactive TH cells: TH1 cells would promote diabetes, whereas TH2 cells would actually protect from disease. This proposition was tested by establishing cultures of TH1 and TH2 cells that express an identical diabetogenic T cell receptor and comparing their ability to initiate disease in neonatal nonobese diabetic mice. TH1-like cells actively promoted diabetes; TH2-like cells invaded the islets but did not provoke disease--neither did they provide substantial protection.

Behavioral evidence of thermal hyperalgesia in non-obese diabetic mice with and without insulin-dependent diabetes

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse, a model of Type 1 diabetes in humans, has proven useful for the study of genetic, immunologic and epidemiologic aspects of inherited diabetes. Behavioral evidence of hyperalgesia may also be present in the NOD mouse but has not been described. This study examined NOD mice with (NOD+) and without (NOD-) insulin-dependent diabetes, and control strain (ILI) mice for evidence of hyperalgesia to a noxious thermal stimulus. Interestingly, both NOD+ and NOD- mice showed reduced mean hindpaw withdrawal latencies when compared with non-diabetic ILI mice. NOD+ and NOD- mice were also abnormal in their general appearance, activity level, posture, gait and muscle bulk when compared with ILI mice. These findings raise the possibility that hyperalgesia in insulin-dependent NOD mice, or insulin-dependent humans with Type 1 diabetes, may be independent of diabetes and due to a primary disturbance within sensory pathways.

Tolerance induction as a therapeutic strategy for the control of autoimmune endocrine disease in mouse models

This chapter aims to describe ways in which autoimmunity can be prevented or reversed and 'self-tolerance' re-established. To this end we have largely restricted our overview to the two main autoimmune disease models with which we are involved, i.e. IDDM in NOD mice and EAT in H-2k mice although, where appropriate and to demonstrate a particular point, other models are mentioned. The chapter has been divided into sections covering protection afforded by 1) transgenes, 2) autoantigen and 3) by reagents targetting T-cell surface molecules. Where established, the mechanism by which protection or tolerance is achieved is described but where, as in most cases, it is unknown the possibilities are discussed. Investigations using T-cell lines and clones and on islet regeneration which are currently being followed as part of a comprehensive approach to the study of autoimmunity are included as separate sections and their relevance discussed.

A diabetes-associated T-cell autoantigen maps to a telomeric locus on mouse chromosome 6

Identification of diabetes-associated T-cell autoantigens is important for understanding the immunopathology of diabetes and developing improved therapeutic strategies. We have used a genetic approach to move toward identifying the autoantigen recognized by a diabetogenic islet-specific T-cell clone from a nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse. The unique antigen recognition pattern of this clone was utilized to map the gene encoding the antigen (or its expression) by genetic linkage analysis. In vitro analysis of T-cell proliferation by this clone showed that the capacity of the islets to stimulate T cells segregates as a single codominant gene in BALB/cByJ x (BALB/cByJ x NOD/Bdc) backcross mice. This phenotype was tightly linked to two microsatellites in the telomeric region of mouse chromosome 6.

Genetic and pathogenic basis of autoimmune diabetes in NOD mice

Non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice are an excellent model of T-cell mediated autoimmune insulin-dependent diabetes in humans. Recent studies in NOD mice have shown that this disease is a result of epistatic interactions between multiple genes, both inside and outside the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), generating T cells reactive against an expanding repertoire of autoantigens.

Resistance alleles at two non-major histocompatibility complex-linked insulin-dependent diabetes loci on chromosome 3, Idd3 and Idd10, protect nonobese diabetic mice from diabetes

Development of diabetes in NOD mice is polygenic and dependent on both major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-linked and non-MHC-linked insulin-dependent diabetes (Idd) genes. In (F1 x NOD) backcross analyses using the B10.H-2g7 or B6.PL-Thy1a strains as the outcross partner, we previously identified several non-MHC Idd loci, including two located on chromosome 3 (Idd3 and Idd10). In the current study, we report that protection from diabetes is observed in NOD congenic strains having B6.PL-Thy1a- or B10-derived alleles at Idd3 or Idd10. It is important to note that only partial protection is provided by two doses of the resistance allele at either Idd3 or Idd10. However, nearly complete protection from diabetes is achieved when resistance alleles are expressed at both loci. Development of these congenic strains has allowed Idd3 to be localized between Glut2 and D3Mit6, close to the Il2 locus.

Production of interleukin 10 by islet cells accelerates immune-mediated destruction of beta cells in nonobese diabetic mice

The T helper type 2 (Th2) cell product interleukin 10 (IL-10) inhibits the proliferation and function of Th1 lymphocytes and macrophages (M phi). The nonobese diabetic mouse strain (NOD/Shi) develops a M phi and T cell-dependent autoimmune diabetes that closely resembles human insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). The objective of the present study was to explore the consequences of localized production of IL-10 on diabetes development in NOD/Shi mice. Surprisingly, local production of IL-10 accelerated the onset and increased the prevalence of diabetes, since diabetes developed at 5-10 wk of age in 92% of IL-10 positive I-A beta g7/g7, I-E- mice in first (N2) and second (N3) generation backcrosses between IL-10 transgenic BALB/c mice and (NOD/Shi) mice. None of the IL-10 negative major histocompatibility complex-identical littermates were diabetic at this age. Furthermore, diabetes developed in 33% of I-A beta g7/d, I-E+ N3 mice in the presence of IL-10 before the mice were 10 wk old. Our findings support the notion that IL-10 should not simply be regarded as an immunoinhibitory cytokine, since it possesses powerful, immunostimulatory properties as well. Furthermore, our observations suggest that beta cell destruction in NOD mice may be a Th2-mediated event.

The complex interplay of the DQB1 and DQA1 loci in the generation of the susceptible and protective phenotype for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

IDDM patients of North East Italian region were molecularly typed for their HLA-DQB1 and DQA1 loci by using allele specific oligonucleotide probes and PCR amplified genomic DNA. IDDM status strongly correlated with DQB1 alleles carrying a non-aspartic acid residue in position 57 of DQ beta chain and DQA1 alleles with an arginine residue in position 52 of DQ alpha chain. Genotype analysis revealed that individuals with two DQB1 alleles having a non-aspartic residue in position 57 and two DQA1 alleles with an arginine residue in position 52 had the highest relative risk of disease: they constituted 41% of IDDM patients as compared to 0% of controls. Heterozygosity either at residue 57 of DQB1 or residue 52 of DQA1 was sufficient to abrogate statistical significance for disease association, although 43.6% of IDDM patients were included in these two groups as compared to 21.6% of normal controls. On the other hand the presence of two DQB1 alleles with aspartic acid in position 57 was sufficient to confer resistance to disease irrespective of the DQA1 genotype. Based on the number of possible susceptible heterodimers an individual can form, it was found that 85% of IDDM cases could form two or more heterodimers (two in cis and two in trans), but no IDDM case was found to form one susceptible heterodimer in cis. These results demonstrate that the complete HLA-DQ genotype, more than single DQB1 or DQA1 alleles or DQB1-DQA1 haplotypes, is associated with the highest risk of disease. Screening of the population for preventive purposes and/or early signs of IDDM should then take advantage of this result and "susceptible homozygous" individuals should be followed very closely and considered the first group of choice for possible new therapeutical trials.

A role for non-MHC genetic polymorphism in susceptibility to spontaneous autoimmunity

Peripheral immunological tolerance is traditionally explained by mechanisms for deletion or inactivation of autoreactive T cell clones. Using an autoimmune disease model combining transgenic mice expressing a well-defined antigen, influenza hemagglutinin (HA), on islet beta cells (Ins-HA), and a T cell receptor transgene (TCR-HNT) specific for a class II-restricted HA peptide, we demonstrate that the conventional assumptions do not apply to this in vivo situation. Double transgenic mice displayed either resistance or susceptibility to spontaneous autoimmune disease, depending on genetic contributions from either of two common inbred mouse strains, BALB/c or B10.D2. Functional studies on autoreactive CD4+ T cells from resistant mice showed that, contrary to expectations, neither clonal anergy, clonal deletion, nor receptor desensitization was induced; rather, there was a non-MHC-encoded predisposition toward differentiation to a nonpathogenic effector (Th2 versus Th1) phenotype. T cells from resistant double transgenic mice showed evidence for prior activation by antigen, suggesting that disease may be actively suppressed by autoreactive Th2 cells. These findings shed light on functional aspects of genetically determined susceptibility to autoimmunity, and should lead to new therapeutic approaches aimed at controlling the differentiation of autoreactive CD4+ effector T cells in vivo.

Polygenic trait analysis by neural network learning

AI techniques have been applied to the domain of DNA sequence analysis in predicting or identifying certain specialized regions, in recognizing genes, and in understanding the evolutionary relationships between sequences. This paper focuses on a kind of genetic pattern recognition, namely, the problem of identifying the gene combinations (patterns) causally related to a given trait determined by multiple genes (a so-called polygenic trait). A novel approach is presented which combines neural-network and knowledge-based techniques. The neural network is trained to predict the trait and then the knowledge embedded in the network is decoded into symbolic patterns. This hybrid approach is evaluated in the domain of identifying genes of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus. The consistency between the results with this approach and those reported in genetic literature supports the viability of this approach.

Genetic analysis of immune dysfunction in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice: mapping of a susceptibility locus close to the Bcl-2 gene correlates with increased resistance of NOD T cells to apoptosis induction

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse strain provides a remarkable model for investigating the mechanisms of autoimmunity. Independent genetic analyses of this model have previously shown that chromosome 1-linked loci were involved in the control of periinsulitis and sialitis on the one hand and of insulitis and diabetes on the other hand. In the present work, analysis of a [NOD x (NOD x C57BL/6)F1] backcross progeny allowed us to clearly dissociate two genetic regions: one was associated with periinsulitis and mapped to the middle region of chromosome 1, in the vicinity of the Bcl-2 gene; the other was associated with insulitis and mapped to the proximal part of the chromosome. Three intermediate markers D1Mit18, D1Mit5 and D1Mit19 covering at least 25 centiMorgans between these two regions, were associated with neither periinsulitis nor insulitis. The role of the Bcl-2-linked region in the immune anomalies of NOD mice was further investigated in a (NOD x C57BL/6)F2 cross where the Bcl-2nod haplotype was linked to elevated serum levels of IgG (p < 0.0005). The middle region of chromosome 1 is, therefore, involved in the control of three phenotypes, including periinsulitis, sialitis and hyperIgG, pointing to Bcl-2 as a good candidate for a cause of the NOD mouse disease. Consistent with the anti-apoptotic function of the Bcl-2 gene product, activated T lymphocytes from NOD mice showed a markedly increased resistance to induction of apoptosis following deprivation of interleukin-2 when compared to those from non-autoimmune strains. After the recent observation of the Fas gene alterations in the lpr and lprcg mutations, these findings indicate that deregulation of lymphoid cell apoptosis may be a general pathogenetic mechanism in autoimmune diseases.

Absence of association of TAP and LMP genes with type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus

Although one of the major genes which cause type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus is located in the class II HLA region in humans, its precise location is still unknown. In order to investigate whether TAP (Transporter associated with Antigen Processing) and LMP (Low Molecular Weight Polypeptide) genes, which are located in the class II HLA region, are HLA-linked diabetogenic genes, the association of TAP1, TAP2 and LMP2 genes with type 1 diabetes was analyzed in the Japanese population. No difference in allele frequencies of these genes was detected between diabetic patients and control subjects. On the other hand, DQA1 and DQB1 genes showed significant association with type 1 diabetes. These data suggest that the diabetogenic gene in the class II HLA region may be located near the DQA1 and DQB1 loci, rather than the TAP and LMP loci.

Resistance to cyclophosphamide-induced diabetes in transgenic NOD mice expressing I-Ak

Transgenic expression of the MHC (major histocompatibility complex) class II I-Ak molecule was previously shown to effectively reduce the incidence of insulitis in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice at the age of 20 weeks. We have further characterized the expression and function of the I-Ak molecule and examined its effects on the incidence of diabetes in NOD mice. The newly expressed I-Ak molecule was recognized as an alloantigen by the T lymphocytes of normal NOD mice as shown by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). The levels of endogenous I-Ag7 expression on peripheral blood lymphocytes were not affected by the transgene expression. Transgenic NOD mice were completely resistant to spontaneous diabetes, but the treatment by cyclophosphamide, which effectively induces diabetes in normal NOD mice, caused diabetes, although at a much lower incidence than that of normal NOD mice. On the basis of these findings, we discuss the role of I-Ak in the prevention of diabetes in NOD mice.

An Abd transgene prevents diabetes in nonobese diabetic mice by inducing regulatory T cells

Susceptibility to the human autoimmune disease insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus is strongly associated with particular haplotypes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Similarly, in a spontaneous animal model of this disease, the nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse, the genes of the MHC play an important role in the development of diabetes. We have produced transgenic NOD mice that express the class II MHC molecule I-Ad in addition to the endogenous I-Ag7 molecules in order to study the role of these molecules in the disease process. Although the inflammatory lesions within the islets of Langerhans in the pancreas appear similar in transgenic and nontransgenic animals, transgenic mice develop diabetes with greatly diminished frequency compared to their nontransgenic littermates (10% of transgenic females by 30 weeks of age compared to 45% of nontransgenic females). Furthermore, adoptive transfer experiments show that T cells present in the transgenic mice are able to interfere with the diabetogenic process caused by T cells from nontransgenic mice. Thus, the mechanism by which I-Ad molecules protect mice from diabetes includes selecting in the thymus and/or inducing in the periphery T cells capable of inhibiting diabetes development.

Characterizations of candidate genes for IDD susceptibility from the diabetes-prone NOD mouse strain

The nucleotide sequences of the NOD and C57BL/6J alleles of Glut-2, Sod-2, and Il-2 were determined by RT-PCR sequencing. Each of these loci is located in intervals that strongly correlated with susceptibility to diabetes in an (NOD/Uf x C57BL/6J)F1 x NOD/Uf backcross. No significant variations in the alleles of Glut-2 at 16 cM on Chromosome (Chr) 3 or Sod-2 at 8 cM on Chr 17 were detected. However, the Il-2 allele in NOD at 20 cM on Chr 3 was found to differ from that in C57BL/6J by a complex mutation involving the contraction of a simple sequence repeat (SSR). Il-2 in NOD differs from the allele in C57BL/6J via a complex mutation involving a deletion of four CAG codons from the SSR together with a length-compensatory four-codon duplication of a segment 5' from the SSR. Two nonsynonymous mutations in the coding region 5' to the SSR were also detected. Only these two allelic forms of Il-2 were detected in a survey of 13 standard inbred lines and 4 wild mouse strains. We propose to designate these alleles as Il-2a (for alleles such as C57BL/6J that contain 12 CAG repeats) and Il-2b (for alleles such as NOD), which occurred in a variety of standard inbred strains and in all four wild Mus musculus domesticus tested. The distribution of these Il-2 alleles among inbred strains correlated with the detection of Chr 3 as an interval effecting diabetes susceptibility in three separate genetic crosses.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Following a diabetogenic T cell from genesis through pathogenesis

Nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice spontaneously develop a disease very similar to type 1 diabetes in humans. We have generated a transgenic mouse strain carrying the rearranged T cell receptor genes from a diabetogenic T cell clone derived from a NOD mouse. Self-reactive T cells expressing the transgene-encoded specificity are not tolerized in these animals, resulting in rampant insulitis and eventually diabetes. Features of the disease process emphasize two so-called check-points, recognized previously in the NOD and human diseases but easily misinterpreted. Although NOD mice are protected from insulitis and diabetes by expression of the E molecule encoded in the major histocompatibility complex, the transgenics are not, permitting us to exclude some possible mechanisms of protection.

I-E+ nonobese diabetic mice develop insulitis and diabetes

The development of type I diabetes in the nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse is under the control of multiple genes, one or more of which is linked to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). The MHC class II region has been implicated in disease development, with expression of an I-E transgene in NOD mice shown to provide protection from insulitis and diabetes. To examine the effect of expressing an I-E+ or I-E- non-NOD MHC on the NOD background, three I-E+ and three I-E- NOD MHC congenic strains (NOD.H-2i5, NOD.H-2k, and NOD.H-2h2, and NOD.H-2h4, NOD.H-2i7, and NOD.H-2b, respectively) were developed. Of these strains, both I-E+ NOD.H-2h2 and I-E- NOD.H-2h4 mice developed insulitis, but not diabetes. The remaining four congenic strains were free of insulitis and diabetes. These results indicate that in the absence of the NOD MHC, diabetes fails to develop. Each NOD MHC congenic strain was crossed with the NOD strain to produce I-E+ and I-E- F1 mice; these mice thus expressed one dose of the NOD MHC and one dose of a non-NOD MHC on the NOD background. While a single dose of a non-NOD MHC provided a large degree of disease protection to all of the F1 strains, a proportion of I-E+ and I-E- F1 mice aged 5-12 mo developed insulitis and cyclophosphamide-induced diabetes. When I-E+ F1 mice were aged 9-17 mo, spontaneous diabetes developed as well. These data are the first to demonstrate that I-E+ NOD mice develop diabetes, indicating that expression of I-E in NOD mice is not in itself sufficient to prevent insulitis or diabetes. In fact, I-E- F1 strains were no more protected from diabetes than I-E+ F1 strains, suggesting that other non-NOD MHC-linked genes are important in protection from disease. Finally, transfer of NOD bone marrow into irradiated I-E+ F1 recipients resulted in high incidences of diabetes, indicating that expression of non-NOD MHC products in the thymus, in the absence of expression in bone marrow-derived cells, is not sufficient to provide protection from diabetes.

RFLP analysis of the MHC class III region defines unique haplotypes for the non-obese diabetic, cataract Shionogi and the non-obese non-diabetic mouse strains

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse strain which spontaneously develops diabetes is a model for human Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus. At least one of several genes controlling diabetes in the NOD mouse has been mapped to the MHC. Although previous experiments have implicated the MHC class II genes in the development of the disease, the existence of other MHC linked susceptibility genes has not been ruled out. In order to identify these susceptibility genes we have further characterized the MHC haplotype of the NOD mouse and two non-diabetic sister strains, the non-obese non-diabetic (NON) and cataract Shionogi (CTS). We have examined the mouse MHC class III region for the presence of homologous genes to 17 newly isolated human MHC class III region genes (G1, G2, G4, G6, G7a/valyl-tRNA synthetase, HSP70, G8, G9, G10, G12, G13, G14, G15, G16, G17 and G18). We detect unique hybridizing DNA fragments for 16 of the 17 genes in six inbred mouse strains (NOD, NON, CTS, B10, BALB/c and CBA/J) indicating that this part of the H-2 region is similar to the human MHC class III region. Using a panel of restriction enzymes we have defined RFLPs for 6 (G2, G6, HSP70, G12, G16, G18) of the 16 cross-hybridizing probes. The RFLPs demonstrate that NOD, NON and CTS mouse strains each have a distinct MHC haplotype in the MHC class III region.

Pancreatic beta-cell destruction in non-obese diabetic mice

We determined the natural history of the widespread pancreatic islet beta-cell destruction that precedes the onset of spontaneous putative autoimmune diabetes mellitus in NOD mice. For this purpose, we performed both histological and immunocytochemical examinations of pancreata retrieved from mice at 2 through 30 weeks of age. An overexpression of la antigens was identified on islet beta cells at 4 weeks of age, without evidence of mononuclear cell infiltration. The abnormal expression of la antigens was age-related and was associated with hyperexpression of class I antigens and progressive islet cell histologic damage after 17 weeks of age. Immunocytochemical examination of islet cell infiltrate showed that the number of macrophages did not increase during the early phase of islet cell damage in these mice. The L3T4/Lyt-2 ratio increased after 7 weeks of age, but was 1:1 in the late stage of insulitis. These findings suggest that widespread islet beta-cell destruction is a process that begins primarily with derangements of the pancreatic beta-cell immune pattern, which may trigger a mononuclear cell reaction.

Prevention of autoimmune diabetes in non-obese diabetic mice by treatment with a class II major histocompatibility complex-blocking peptide

The role of antigen presentation as a possible mechanism underlying major histocompatibility complex (MHC) association of autoimmune disease has been studied in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice. By screening for inhibition of antigen presentation to NOD T cell hybridoma, we have selected a synthetic peptide, yTYTVHAAHAYTYt (small letters denote D amino acids), that efficiently blocks antigen presentation by the NOD class II MHC molecule A alpha g7A beta g7 (Ag7) in vitro. The inhibition is MHC selective, in that it does not affect antigen presentation by the E(d) and E(k) molecules, and has only a marginal effect on presentation by the A(d) molecule. This peptide also inhibits the priming for Ag7-restricted T cell responses in vivo, and prevents the spontaneous development of diabetes in female NOD mice, when administered chronically from 3 wk of age on. Chronic treatment with a control peptide, KMKMVHAAHAKMKM, that fails to bind to Ag7 has no effect on the disease. These data indicate that antigen presentation by the Ag7 molecule plays a pivotal role in the induction of autoimmune diabetes. Furthermore, the results demonstrate that interference with antigen presentation by a class II molecule can prevent the onset of spontaneous autoimmune disease associated with the same molecule.

A multiplicity of protein antigens in subcellular fractions of rat insulinoma tissue are able to stimulate T cells obtained from non-obese diabetic mice

Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus is a T-cell mediated autoimmune disease with a number of different proteins being implicated as target autoantigens. A 38 kDa protein residing in the insulin secretory granule of insulinoma tissue is recognized by T-cell clones from a newly-diagnosed Type 1 diabetic patient. We have investigated the capacity of normal rat pancreatic beta-cell extracts and various subcellular fractions of transplantable RIN tissue to induce proliferation of T cells from non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice and H-2 identical NON.NOD-H-2g7 control mice. Normal rat islet beta-cell protein fractions induced intense, dose-dependent proliferation of NOD splenic T cells, but only marginal proliferative responses of NON.NOD-H-2g7 splenic T cells. To further localize the target antigens, four different subcellular fractions from RIN tissue were used as a source of antigen; here in particular the cytosolic proteins showed dose-dependent activation capacity with splenic T cells in NOD animals. These activities were absent in control mice. There was no proliferation after incubation with microsome preparations from other rat endocrine tissues. Purified carboxypeptidase H did not have any stimulatory activity on NOD T cells. Fractionation of the RIN cytosolic proteins showed a large number of different fractions eliciting proliferative activity. These results demonstrate that NOD T cells respond to a large number of potential islet beta-cell target antigens and it will be necessary to utilize NOD T-cell clones to identify the number and nature of these antigens.

Linkage on chromosome 3 of autoimmune diabetes and defective Fc receptor for IgG in NOD mice

A congenic, non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse strain that contains a segment of chromosome 3 from the diabetes-resistant mouse strain B6.PL-Thy-1a was less susceptible to diabetes than NOD mice. A fully penetrant immunological defect also mapped to this segment, which encodes the high-affinity Fc receptor for immunoglobulin G (IgG), Fc gamma RI. The NOD Fcgr1 allele, which results in a deletion of the cytoplasmic tail, caused a 73 percent reduction in the turnover of cell surface receptor-antibody complexes. The development of congenic strains and the characterization of Mendelian traits that are specific to the disease phenotype demonstrate the feasibility of dissecting the pathophysiology of complex, non-Mendelian diseases.

Molecular basis of genetic polymorphism in major histocompatibility complex-linked proteasome gene (Lmp-2)

Four genes, closely linked to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II genes, have been identified in humans, mice, and rats and are thought to be involved in the generation and transport of endogenous immunogenic peptides for the MHC class I antigen-processing pathway. The Tap-1 and Tap-2 genes presumably encode a heterodimeric protein complex responsible for transporting endogenous immunogenic peptides to the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum. The Lmp-2 and Lmp-7 gene products are two subunits of the large cytosolic proteasome complex possibly involved in generation of endogenous peptides. To study the genetic polymorphism of the Lmp-2 gene, we used a published cDNA sequence as a consensus sequence and PCR-amplified, cloned, and sequenced the Lmp-2 gene from 12 inbred mouse strains. We found three amino acid variants, LMP-2d, LMP-2b, and LMP-2q, which partially correlated with restriction fragment length polymorphism variants identified with Southern blots. Allelic polymorphism of the Lmp-2 gene may be involved in peptide selection, leading to autoimmune disease susceptibility.

Genetic analysis of diabetes and insulitis in an interspecific cross of the nonobese diabetic mouse with Mus spretus

The nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse is a widely used model for genetic studies of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus due to the similarities between the murine and human diseases. To aid in the localization and identification of diabetes-related susceptibility genes, we have constructed an interspecific backcross between NOD and Mus spretus (SEG/Pas) mice. Although no diabetic animals were observed in the first backcross generation of (SEG/Pas x NOD) x NOD (BC1), the incidence of insulitis (lymphocyte infiltration of the islets of Langerhans) exceeded 20% after injections of cyclophosphamide, a treatment that provokes an acute form of diabetes in NOD mice. Insulitis, a prediabetic condition, is a useful phenotype in studies of diabetes susceptibility. In the second backcross (BC2) generation, 8% of the animals became diabetic and 76% were found to have insulitis. Genetic mapping studies in the BC2 families confirmed the importance of the major histocompatibility complex region on the severity of insulitis and suggested that additional susceptibility loci were linked to markers on mouse chromosomes 3, 6, and 15. Mus spretus crosses have been an important tool in recent advances in murine genetics, and our results extend their usefulness to the study of a multifactorial disease.

Short-term administration of anti-L3T4 MoAb prevents diabetes in NOD mice

We treated 2-week-old and 8-week-old non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice with 1 mg of anti-L3T4 MoAb weekly for 4 weeks. This short-term treatment of anti-L3T4 MoAb prevented the development of overt diabetes in NOD mice, in both groups, even after cessation of the therapy. However, there were overt mononuclear cell infiltrations in the majority of islets, and no appreciable differences in the degree of insulitis between treated and control mice. There were also no significant differences in the percentage of L3T4+ T cells expressing V beta 5, V beta 8 and V beta 11 antigens between the treated and the control group. In contrast, most of the male NOD mice injected with 200 mg/kg of cyclophosphamide did not become diabetic when the spleen cells from the MoAb-treated female NOD mice were transferred to these animals 48 h before the cyclophosphamide injection. Thus, the tolerance induced by the short-term administration of anti-L3T4 MoAb to NOD mice may not be due to clonal deletion, but rather to newly generated suppressor cells in the animals.

Mixed haplotypes and autoimmunity

Why do (NZB x NZW)F1 mice develop an autoimmune lupus-like syndrome? The second exons of the class II genes of NZB and NZW are identical to their counterparts of H-2d and H-2u haplotypes. Several lines of evidence suggest that this allows the production of a mixed haplotype molecule, I-E alpha dE beta z, and that this molecule plays a key role in the development of autoimmunity.

MHC class I and autoimmune diabetes

The cause of failed self tolerance, resulting in autoimmunity is unknown, although genetic linkage to genes within the MHC class II region have been well described. We present evidence that failed self tolerance in autoimmune diabetes appears to be secondary to an antigen presenting cell defect; the diabetic antigen presenting cells fail to deliver fragments of endogenous antigens to the cell surface in the groove of MHC class I. In the diabetic NOD mouse model, this correlates with a rare allele at the Tap-1 locus, a gene that controls proper MHC class I assembly by providing fragments of endogenous peptides into the endoplasmic reticulum. We propose that MHC class I presentation of self peptides may represent a normal pathway for tolerance induction and interruption of this important class I function from any cause, including the MHC class II-linked Tap-1 and Tap-2 genes, which may result in autoreactivity.

Insulin-dependent diabetes in the NOD mouse model. I. Detection and characterization of autoantibody bound to the surface of pancreatic beta cells prior to development of the insulitis lesion in prediabetic NOD mice

Type I, insulin-dependent diabetes (IDD) results from an autoimmune response against the insulin producing pancreatic beta cells. This autoimmune reaction involves both humoral and cell-mediated factors; nevertheless, the relative role of each remains unresolved. Furthermore, while adoptive transfer experiments have provided evidence for the role of T cells in beta cell destruction, the specific events which initiate leukocyte migration into the islets (insulitis) are unknown. Earlier studies indicated that NOD pancreatic beta cells may bind small amounts of autoantibody. Because of the possible importance of an early humoral response to the initiation of insulitis and subsequent disease, we have investigated a number of aspects of this phenomenon to determine the nature and specificity of the early autoantibodies as well as the time at which autoantibody binds to beta cells. Results of this study demonstrate that NOD/Uf mice are sensitized to islet-cell associated antigens, including GAD, prior to the first appearance of insulitis; that a small percentage of the beta cells of NOD/Uf mice have autoantibody bound to their surface prior to insulitis; that sera collected from preinsulitis NOD/Uf mice contain autoantibodies which will bind to beta cells of both IDD-prone and IDD-resistant mice; and that the autoantibodies which bind pancreatic beta cells are predominantly IgM with lesser amounts of IgG and IgA. These findings suggest that, in the natural course of IDD, insulitis may develop in response to an initial autoantibody-mediated injury of beta cells.

Analysis of VH gene utilisation in the non-obese diabetic mouse

The immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy chain variable (VH) gene complexity and the VH gene utilisation pattern of the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse were investigated. We found that the NOD mouse displays a VH gene complexity which appears to be identical to that of the C57BL/6 mouse. Thus, Southern hybridisation using probes specific for 9 of the murine VH gene families revealed identical restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) patterns in both mouse strains. As indicated by immunofluorescence analysis using allotype specific monoclonal antibodies the NOD mice were also found to carry the IgCH-1b allele. Collectively, these data suggest that the NOD mice carry an IgVH locus identical to that carried by C57BL/6. In contrast to the apparent identity at the level of germline VH gene repertoires, the pattern of VH gene utilisation differed considerably between these two mouse strains. Thus, in NOD mice the neonatal preference of D-proximal VH genes was found to be more pronounced than in C57BL/6 mice. Moreover, in contrast to adult C57BL/6 mice a D-proximal bias was evident also in adult NOD mice. On the basis of these findings we discuss the possibility that the distorted development of B cell repertoires in the NOD mouse could be directly or indirectly related to the T cell mediated, autoimmune process in the NOD mouse.