Monoclonal antibody screening of a phage-displayed random peptide library reveals mimotopes of chemokine receptor CCR5: implications for the tertiary structure of the receptor and for an N-terminal binding site for HIV-1 gp120

Short Communication: HIV-1 Variants That Use Mouse CCR5 Reveal Critical Interactions of gp120's V3 Crown with CCR5 Extracellular Loop 1

The CCR5 coreceptor amino terminus and extracellular (ECL) loops 1 and 2 have been implicated in HIV-1 infections, with species differences in these regions inhibiting zoonoses. Interactions of gp120 with CD4 and CCR5 reduce constraints on metastable envelope subunit gp41, enabling gp41 conformational changes needed for infection. We previously selected HIV-1_JRCSF variants that efficiently use CCR5(Δ18) with a deleted amino terminus or CCR5(HHMH) with ECL2 from an NIH/Swiss mouse. Unexpectedly, the adaptive gp120 mutations were nearly identical, suggesting that they function by weakening gp120's grip on gp41 and/or by increasing interactions with ECL1. To analyze this and further wean HIV-1 from human CCR5, we selected variants using CCR5(HMMH) with murine ECL1 and 2 sequences. HIV-1_JRCSF mutations adaptive for CCR5(Δ18) and CCR5(HHMH) were generally maladaptive for CCR5(HMMH), whereas the converse was true for CCR5(HMMH) adaptations. The HIV-1_JRCSF variant adapted to CCR5(HMMH) also weakly used intact NIH/Swiss mouse CCR5. Our results strongly suggest that HIV-1_JRCSF makes functionally critical contacts with human ECL1 and that adaptation to murine ECL1 requires multiple mutations in the crown of gp120's V3 loop.

Phages and HIV-1: from display to interplay

The complex hide-and-seek game between HIV-1 and the host immune system has impaired the development of an efficient vaccine. In addition, the high variability of the virus impedes the long-term control of viral replication by small antiviral drugs. For more than 20 years, phage display technology has been intensively used in the field of HIV-1 to explore the epitope landscape recognized by monoclonal and polyclonal HIV-1-specific antibodies, thereby providing precious data about immunodominant and neutralizing epitopes. In parallel, biopanning experiments with various combinatorial or antibody fragment libraries were conducted on viral targets as well as host receptors to identify HIV-1 inhibitors. Besides these applications, phage display technology has been applied to characterize the enzymatic specificity of the HIV-1 protease. Phage particles also represent valuable alternative carriers displaying various HIV-1 antigens to the immune system and eliciting antiviral responses. This review presents and summarizes the different studies conducted with regard to the nature of phage libraries, target display mode and biopanning procedures.

Study on CCR5 analogs and affinity peptides

The G protein-coupled receptor of human chemokine receptor 5 (CCR5) is a key target in the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection process due to its major involvement in binding to the HIV type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein gp120 and facilitating virus entry into the cells. The identification of naturally occurring CCR5 mutations (especially CCR5 delta-32) has allowed us to address the CCR5 molecule as a promising target to prevent or resist HIV infection in vivo. To obtain high-affinity peptides that can be used to block CCR5, CCR5 analogs with high conformational similarity are required. In this study, two recombinant proteins named CCR5 N-Linker-E2 and CCR5 mN-E1-E2 containing the fragments of the CCR5 N-terminal, the first extracellular loop or the second extracellular loop are cloned from a full-length human CCR5 cDNA. The recombinant human CCR5 analogs with self-cleavage activity of the intein Mxe or Ssp in the vector pTwinI were then produced with a high-yield expression and purification system in Escherichia coli. Experiments of extracellular epitope-activity identification (such as immunoprecipitation and indirective/competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) confirmed the close similarity between the epitope activity of the CCR5 analogs and that of the natural CCR5, suggesting the applicability of the recombinant CCR5 analogs as antagonists of the chemokine ligands. Subsequent screening of high-affinity peptides from the phage random-peptides library acquired nine polypeptides, which could be used as CCR5 peptide antagonists. The CCR5 analogs and affinity peptides elucidated in this paper provide us with a basis for further study of the mechanism of inhibition of HIV-1 infection.

Circulating human CD4 and CD8 T cells do not have large intracellular pools of CCR5

CC Chemokine Receptor 5 (CCR5) is an important mediator of chemotaxis and the primary coreceptor for HIV-1. A recent report by other researchers suggested that primary T cells harbor pools of intracellular CCR5. With the use of a series of complementary techniques to measure CCR5 expression (antibody labeling, Western blot, quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction), we established that intracellular pools of CCR5 do not exist and that the results obtained by the other researchers were false-positives that arose because of the generation of irrelevant binding sites for anti-CCR5 antibodies during fixation and permeabilization of cells.

Peptide ligands selected with CD4-induced epitopes on native dualtropic HIV-1 envelope proteins mimic extracellular coreceptor domains and bind to HIV-1 gp120 independently of coreceptor usage

During HIV-1 entry, binding of the viral envelope glycoprotein gp120 to the cellular CD4 receptor triggers conformational changes resulting in exposure of new epitopes, the highly conserved CD4-induced (CD4i) epitopes that are essential for subsequent binding to chemokine receptor CCR5 or CXCR4. Due to their functional conservation, CD4i epitopes represent attractive viral targets for HIV-1 entry inhibition. The aim of the present study was to select peptide ligands for CD4i epitopes on native dualtropic (R5X4) HIV-1 envelope (Env) glycoproteins by phage display. Using CD4-activated retroviral particles carrying Env from the R5X4 HIV-1 89.6 strain as the target, we performed screenings of random peptide phage libraries under stringent selection conditions. Selected peptides showed partial identity with amino acids in the extracellular domains of CCR5/CXCR4, including motifs rich in tyrosines and aspartates at the N terminus known to be important for gp120 binding. A synthetic peptide derivative (XD3) corresponding to the most frequently selected phages was optimized for Env binding on peptide arrays. Interestingly, the optimized peptide could bind specifically to gp120 derived from HIV-1 strains with different coreceptor usage, competed with binding of CD4i-specific monoclonal antibody (MAb) 17b, and interfered with entry of both a CCR5 (R5)-tropic and a CXCR4 (X4)-tropic Env pseudotyped virus. This peptide ligand therefore points at unique properties of CD4i epitopes shared by gp120 with different coreceptor usage and could thus serve to provide new insight into the conserved structural details essential for coreceptor binding for further drug development.

Antibody reactivity of conformational peptide mimics of a conserved H5N1 neutralization site in different fusion proteins

Several peptide mimics of a conserved H5N1 avian influenza virus neutralization site recognized by 8H5 mAb have been reported previously. In this study, the secondary and possibly higher structural orders of the peptide mimics 122 and 125 were investigated and found to be closely related to the specific binding with 8H5 mAb. These two peptide mimics were fused to three different carrier proteins, and the antibody binding activities were recovered in 4 of the 11 fusion proteins. HEV structural protein p239 and HBc were more suitable than the outer membrane protein T47 of the Treponema pallidum particle for the recovery of reactivity. The increase in the copy number of peptide mimics was important for the recovery of antibody-binding activity and the interaction between peptide and carrier protein may affect the spatial structure of both the peptide and the carrier protein. These results are likely to be of relevance for conformational peptide mimics in diagnostic tests, vaccine and inhibitors.

Inducing cross-clade neutralizing antibodies against HIV-1 by immunofocusing

Background

Although vaccines are important in preventing viral infections by inducing neutralizing antibodies (nAbs), HIV-1 has proven to be a difficult target and escapes humoral immunity through various mechanisms. We sought to test whether HIV-1 Env mimics may serve as immunogens.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Using random peptide phage display libraries, we identified the epitopes recognized by polyclonal antibodies of a rhesus monkey that had developed high-titer, broadly reactive nAbs after infection with a simian-human immunodeficiency virus (SHIV) encoding env of a recently transmitted HIV-1 clade C (HIV-C). Phage peptide inserts were analyzed for conformational and linear homology using computational analysis; some peptides mimicked various domains of the original HIV-C Env, such as conformational V3 loop epitopes and the conserved linear region of the gp120 C-terminus. Next, we devised a novel prime/boost strategy to test the immunogenicity of such phage-displayed peptides and primed mice only once with HIV-C gp160 DNA followed by boosting with mixtures of recombinant phages.

Conclusions/Significance

This strategy, which was designed to focus the immune system on a few Env epitopes (immunofocusing), not only induced HIV-C gp160 binding antibodies and cross-clade nAbs, but also linked a conserved HIV Env region for the first time to the induction of nAbs: the C-terminus of gp120. The identification of conserved antigen mimics may lead to novel immunogens capable of inducing broadly reactive nAbs.

A novel strategy to mimic discontinuous protective epitopes using a synthetic scaffold

Although vaccines have been used for a long time and different types of vaccines have been developed, as yet no fully synthetic vaccines have been produced. The production of fully synthetic vaccines has probably not been realized so far due to the structural limitations of linear synthetic peptides to mimic the native shape of protein fragments which is often needed to induce protective antibodies. In this report we used the Bordetella pertussis protein pertactin as a model and show that a novel synthetic scaffold can be used to mimic structurally defined epitopes by confined presentation of several different peptide arms. Guided by modelling a construct was synthesized that induced protective antibodies directed towards a discontinuous epitope. This approach opens up the possibility to the design of new and fully synthetic vaccines that can induce protective antibodies.

Peptide mimotopes selected with HIV-1-blocking monoclonal antibodies against CCR5 represent motifs specific for HIV-1 entry

CCR5 is a chemokine receptor that mediates entry of human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1). Two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) that block HIV-1 entry, 3A9 and 5C7, were used to select peptide mimotopes of sequences on CCR5 from phage displayed peptide libraries. The selected mimotofpes comprised motifs at the N-terminus and on the first and third extracellular loops (ECL1 and ECL3) of CCR5. Amino acids in these motifs were exchanged for alanines by site-directed mutagenesis (sdm) in the cDNA for human CCR5. Ensuing effects on antibody binding to CCR5, cellular entry of HIV-1 and chemokine-induced signalling were analysed by transfection of mutant cDNAs into HEK293.CD4 cells. For both mAbs, fluorescence-activated cell sorting analysis was used to define overlapping conformational epitopes on CCR5 at the N-terminus, on ECL1 and ECL3. Mutation of the N-terminal motif 10YD11 prevented HIV-1 entry into transfected cells as judged by single round infection assays with R5 and R5X4 HIV-1 isolates, as did mutation of the motif 96FG97 in ECL1, whereas mutation of the motif 274RLD276 in ECL3 had only a minor effect. None of the motifs in CCR5 relevant to HIV-1 entry disrupted chemokine-induced signalling. Thus, peptide mimotopes of conformational contact sites of CCR5 with the paratope of mAbs 3A9 and 5C7 represent sites on CCR5 that are essential for HIV-1 entry. Structural knowledge of these mimotopes could help elucidate the nature of the interaction between CCR5 and HIV-1, and thus the derivation of specific inhibitors of entry of HIV-1 into susceptible cells without interference with chemokine signalling.

Characterisation of an autoreactive conformational epitope on GAD65 recognised by the human monoclonal antibody b78 using a combination of phage display, in vitro mutagenesis and molecular modelling

Autoantibodies to the diabetes autoantigen, the 65kDa isoform of glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65), react with conformational epitopes defined according to linear sequences but not according to structural information, or contact sites with the antibody paratope. To ascertain such information for an exemplary human monoclonal antibody (mAb) to GAD65, b78, we combined antibody screening of phage-displayed peptide libraries, alanine mutagenesis of selected motifs, homology modelling of the PLP and C-terminal regions of GAD65, and molecular dynamics to examine for structural effects of mutagenesis. By phage display, mAb b78 selected phagotopes containing acidic residues (D, E), hydrophobic residues (Y, F or W) and LRS that localised to a possible surface-exposed conformational epitope on the combined homology model. Alanine mutants of GAD65 based on deduced contact residues were examined for binding with b78 and control sera. Mutation of (524)SRL(526), (572)DF(573) and (498)KPQ(500) reduced reactivity of b78 with mutant GAD65 > 50%. Molecular dynamics indicated that mutation of (498)KPQ(500) caused structural changes that could account for effects of this mutation. Thus phage display in combination with molecular modelling identified contact residues within a highly conformational epitope for mAb b78 in the C-terminus of GAD65. These techniques should have broad applicability to definition of epitope structure.

Amino acids critical for binding of autoantibody to an immunodominant conformational epitope of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex subunit E2: Identification by phage display and site-directed mutagenesis

The E2 subunit of the mitochondrial multienzyme pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDC-E2) is the major autoantigen in the liver disease, primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC). An epitope region which has been localized to amino acids 91-227 is believed to include the residue K173 to which is attached the lipoyl cofactor. We investigated structural features of this epitope region by screening random peptide phage-displayed libraries and identified prevalent phagotopes that contained likely contact amino acids in separate regions of the linear sequence, H132M133, and F178, V180. These were confirmed by site-directed alanine mutagenesis singly or in combination of the HM and FV residues in wild-type (wt) PDC-E2, and by immunization of rabbits with phage that expressed peptides MHLNTPP or FVLPWRI. The lipoyl lysine K173 also was mutated. Reactivities of mutants and wild-type (wt) PDC-E2, compared by ELISA using 12 PBC sera, showed decremental reactivity of mutant versus wt PDC-E2 (normalized to 100%): wt PDC-E2 (100%)>>PDC-E2(F178A,V180A) (mean+/-S.D., 59+/-17%)>PDC-E2(M133A) (50+/-13%)>PDC-E2(H132A) (36+/-13%)>PDC-E2(H132A,M133A) (28+/-8%)>PDC-E2(H132A,M133A,F178V,M180A) (18+/-13%). Notably PDC-E2(K173A) retained full reactivity (93+/-21%). Rabbits immunized with phage peptides generated antibodies reactive with entire PDC-E2. Our data convincingly validate phage library technology for defining spatially disparate contact residues for conformational epitopes. Ensuing data could be generally applicable to search for occult extrinsic agents as initiators of autoimmunity.

Requirement of multiple phage displayed peptide libraries for optimal mapping of a conformational antibody epitope on CCR5

In the absence of information from crystallography, conformational epitopes can often be discerned by antibody screening of phage displayed random peptide libraries. However the context in which the peptide is displayed, and the number of copies displayed in the library, can influence results and interpretations. Here, the monoclonal antibodies 3A9 specific for the transmembrane chemokine receptor CCR5, and CII-C1 specific for type II collagen, were used to screen multiple phage-displayed peptide libraries in which peptides were displayed in either the pIII or pVIII coat proteins. ELISA was used to test for reactivity and cross-inhibitory activity of isolated phage clones. Based on sequences of reactive phage inserts, epitope motifs were initially inferred from a molecular model of CCR5 and subsequently confirmed experimentally using mutagenesis to alanine. For each mAb, phage sequences from pIII biopannings were more diverse than from pVIII biopannings. Notably, sequences from either biopanning were cross-inhibitory despite a lack of linear sequence homology. For CCR5, residues 88H and 94W in the first loop of CCR5 were identified by pIII biopannings, and 7S9IYD11 at the N-terminus by pVIII biopannings. Thus conformational epitopes can be identified using phage display, but optimal mapping of complex epitopes can require the use of multiple peptide libraries.

Protecting from R5-tropic HIV: individual and combined effectiveness of a hammerhead ribozyme and a single-chain Fv antibody that targets CCR5

The CCR5 chemokine receptor is important for most clinical strains of HIV to establish infection. Individuals with naturally occurring polymorphisms in the CCR5 gene who have reduced or absent CCR5 are apparently otherwise healthy, but are resistant to HIV infection. With the goal of reducing CCR5 and protecting CCR5+ cells from R5-tropic HIV, we used Tag-deleted SV40-derived vectors to deliver several anti-CCR5 transgenes: 2C7, a single-chain Fv (SFv) antibody; VCKA1, a hammerhead ribozyme; and two natural CCR5 ligands, MIP-1alpha and MIP-1beta, modified to direct these chemokines, and hence their receptor to the endoplasmic reticulum. These transgenes were delivered using recombinant, Tag-deleted SV40-derived vectors to human CCR5+ cell lines and primary cells: monocyte-derived macrophages and brain microglia. All transgenes except MIP-1alpha decreased CCR5, as assayed by immunostaining, Northern blotting, and cytofluorimetry (FACS). Individually, all transgenes except MIP-1alpha protected from low challenge doses of HIV. At higher dose HIV challenges, protection provided by all transgenes diminished, the SFv and the ribozyme being most potent. Vectors carrying these two transgenes were used sequentially to deliver combination anti-CCR5 genetic therapy. This approach gave approximately additive reduction in CCR5, as measured by FACS and protected from higher dose HIV challenges. Reducing cell membrane CCR5 using anti-CCR5 transgenes, alone or in combinations, may therefore provide a degree of protection from R5-tropic strains of HIV.

Induction of autoantibodies to CCR5 in macaques and subsequent effects upon challenge with an R5-tropic simian/human immunodeficiency virus

Antibodies against CCR5, the major coreceptor for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), may have antiviral potential as viral fusion inhibitors. In this study, we generated a virus-like particle (VLP)-based vaccine that effectively breaks B-cell tolerance and elicits autoantibodies against CCR5 in pig-tailed macaques. Initial studies in mice identified a polypeptide comprising the N-terminal domain of pig-tailed macaque CCR5 fused to streptavidin that, when conjugated at high density to bovine papillomavirus major capsid protein L1 VLPs, induced high-titer immunoglobulin G (IgG) that bound to a macaque CCR5-expressing cell line in vitro. In macaques, CCR5 peptide-conjugated VLP preparations induced high-avidity anti-CCR5 IgG autoantibody responses, and all five immunized macaques generated IgG that could block infection of CCR5-tropic simian/human immunodeficiency virus SHIV(SF162P3) in vitro. Although the anti-CCR5 IgG titers declined with time, autoantibody levels were boosted upon revaccination. Vaccinated macaques remained healthy for a period of over 3 years after the initial immunization, and no decline in the number of CCR5-expressing T cells was detected. To test the prophylactic efficacy of CCR5 autoantibodies, immunized macaques were challenged with SHIV(SF162P3). Although the plasma-associated virus in half of six control macaques declined to undetectable levels, viral loads were lower, declined more rapidly, and eventually became undetectable in all five macaques in which CCR5 autoantibodies had been elicited. In addition, in the four vaccinated macaques with higher autoantibody titers, viral loads and time to control of viremia were significantly decreased relative to controls, indicating the possibility that CCR5 autoantibodies contributed to the control of viral replication.

Phage display for epitope determination: a paradigm for identifying receptor-ligand interactions

Antibodies that react with many different molecular species of protein and non-protein nature are widely studied in biology and have particular utilities, but the precise epitopes recognized are seldom well defined. The definition of epitopes by X-ray crystallography of the antigen-antibody complex, the gold standard procedure, has shown that most antibody epitopes are conformational and specified by interactions with topographic determinants on the surface of the antigenic molecule. Techniques available for the definition of such epitopes are limited. Phage display using either gene-specific libraries, or random peptide libraries, provides a powerful technique for an approach to epitope identification. The technique can identify amino acids on protein antigens that are critical for antibody binding and, further, the isolation of peptide motifs that are both structural and functional mimotopes of both protein and non-protein antigens. This review discusses techniques used to isolate such mimotopes, to confirm their specificity, and to characterize peptide epitopes. Moreover there are direct practical applications to deriving epitopes or mimotopes by sequence, notably the development of new diagnostic reagents, or therapeutic agonist or antagonist molecules. The techniques developed for mapping of antibody epitopes are applicable to probing the origins of autoimmune diseases and certain cancers by identifying "immunofootprints" of unknown initiating agents, as we discuss herein, and are directly applicable to examination of a wider range of receptor-ligand interactions.

Phage-displayed Bet mim 1, a mimotope of the major birch pollen allergen Bet v 1, induces B cell responses to the natural antigen using bystander T cell help

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In previous studies we have generated mimotopes of Bet v 1, the major birch pollen allergen, by biopannings of phage-display random peptide libraries. In the present study, we analysed the humoral and cellular immune response to Bet v 1-mimotopes.

METHODS

The mimotope CFPYCYPSESA, designated Bet mim 1, was used for intraperitoneal immunizations of BALB/c mice in phage-displayed form. For examination of the humoral immune response, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) experiments were applied. Stimulation capacities were investigated in cultured mouse splenocytes and in humoral Bet v 1-specific T cell clones.

RESULTS

We demonstrated that the Bet mim 1-induced murine antibody response against Bet v 1 was predominated by the IgG1 isotype. In these mice only the phage-displayed mimotopes, but neither the allergen nor the synthetic Bet mim 1-mimotopes were able to stimulate proliferation of cultured splenocytes. Using Bet v 1-specific T cell clones of allergic patients, phage-displayed and synthetic mimotopes were unable to stimulate T cell proliferation. Moreover, tolerance induction to Bet v 1 in mice by intranasal administration of Bet mim 1-phages or Bet mim 1-peptide failed.

CONCLUSION

Taking these results together, our data indicate that Bet mim 1 mimics a Bet v 1-epitope on the B cell but not on the T cell level. We suggest that the phage itself is responsible for the recruitment of T cells providing bystander help in the formation of a mimotope-specific humoral response.

A novel grass pollen allergen mimotope identified by phage display peptide library inhibits allergen-human IgE antibody interaction

The aim of this study was to investigate the molecular basis of human IgE-allergen interaction by screening a phage-displayed peptide library with an allergen-specific human IgE-mimicking monoclonal antibody (mAb). A mAb that reacted with major grass pollen allergens was successfully identified and shown to inhibit human IgE-allergen interaction. Biopanning of a phage-displayed random peptide library with this mAb yielded a 12 amino acid long mimotope. A synthetic peptide based on this 12-mer mimotope inhibited mAb and human IgE binding to grass pollen extracts. Our results indicate that such synthetic peptide mimotopes of allergens have potential as novel therapeutic agents.

Characterization of epitopes for virus-neutralizing monoclonal antibodies to Ross River virus E2 using phage-displayed random peptide libraries

Ross River virus (RRV) is the predominant cause of epidemic polyarthritis in Australia, yet the antigenic determinants are not well defined. We aimed to characterize epitope(s) on RRV-E2 for a panel of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) that recognize overlapping conformational epitopes on the E2 envelope protein of RRV and that neutralize virus infection of cells in vitro. Phage-displayed random peptide libraries were probed with the MAbs T1E7, NB3C4, and T10C9 using solution-phase and solid-phase biopanning methods. The peptides VSIFPPA and KTAISPT were selected 15 and 6 times, respectively, by all three of the MAbs using solution-phase biopanning. The peptide LRLPPAP was selected 8 times by NB3C4 using solid-phase biopanning; this peptide shares a trio of amino acids with the peptide VSIFPPA. Phage that expressed the peptides VSIFPPA and LRLPPAP were reactive with T1E7 and/or NB3C4, and phage that expressed the peptides VSIFPPA, LRLPPAP, and KTAISPT partially inhibited the reactivity of T1E7 with RRV. The selected peptides resemble regions of RRV-E2 adjacent to sites mutated in neutralization escape variants of RRV derived by culture in the presence of these MAbs (E2 210-219 and 238-245) and an additional region of E2 172-182. Together these sites represent a conformational epitope of E2 that is informative of cellular contact sites on RRV.