The role of host immune responses in determining the outcome of HIV infection

A comparison of elasticities of viral levels to specific immune response mechanisms in human immunodeficiency virus infection

BACKGROUND

The presence of an asymptomatic phase in an HIV infection indicates that the immune system can partially control the infection. Determining the immune mechanisms that contribute significantly to the partial control of the infection enhance the HIV infection intervention strategies and is important in vaccine development. Towards this goal, a discrete time HIV model, which incorporates the life cycle aspects of the virus, the antibody (humoral) response and the cell-mediated immune response is formulated to determine immune system components that are most efficient in controlling viral levels. Ecological relationships are used to model the interplay between the immune system components and the HIV pathogen. Model simulations and transient elasticity analysis of the viral levels to immune response parameters are used to compare the different immune mechanisms.

RESULTS

It is shown that cell-mediated immune response is more effective in controlling the viral levels than the antibody response. Killing of infected cells is shown to be crucial in controlling the viral levels. Our results show a negative correlation between the antibody response and the viral levels in the early stages of the infection, but we predicted this immune mechanism to be positively correlated with the viral levels in the late stage of the infection. A result that suggests lack of relevance of antibody response with infection progression. On the contrary, we predicted the cell-mediated immune response to be always negatively correlated with viral levels.

CONCLUSION

Neutralizing antibodies can only control the viral levels in the early days of the HIV infection whereas cell-mediated immune response is beneficial during all the stages of the infection. This study predicts that vaccine design efforts should also focus on stimulating killer T cells that target infected cells.

HIV immunopathogenesis and strategies for intervention

Therapeutic options aimed at tackling the HIV pandemic face many obstacles. The lack of readily accessible and affordable therapies means that most of those affected go untreated. The array of escape mechanisms used by HIV has undermined the efficiency of many antiviral products and continually represents a barrier to the development of an effective vaccine. Recent developments have seen a shift away from a cytopathic viral model of HIV pathogenesis towards the crucial role of immunopathogenic features--notably generalised immune activation--in the development of AIDS. As conventional vaccine strategies have sought to promote viral neutralisation and suppressive cellular responses, novel strategies that aim to address HIV immunopathogenesis should be sought. We review current opinion on HIV-induced pathogenic immune activation and strategies aimed at eliminating HIV, including a potential role for non-neutralising antibodies as part of a therapeutic vaccine option.

HLA homology within the C5 domain promotes peptide binding by HIV type 1 gp120

The mechanisms by which HIV-1 induces chronic pathogenic immune activation associated with disease progression remain unclear despite many years of AIDS research. One proposal suggests that sequence and structural mimicry between gp120 and HLA may endow HIV with the capacity to arouse alloreactive and autoimmune responses within the susceptible host, fueling disease progression in a manner similar to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Both gp120 and HLA share a common functional interaction with CD4 but also demonstrate peptide binding properties. Here we report the conserved nature of this feature across HIV-1 envelopes, the crucial role of the HLA homologous C5 region for peptide interactions, and the elimination of this property through specific antibody targeting. Given that the C5 domain mimics a HLA activation domain and the reported clinical benefits associated with nonneutralizing antibodies against this region, targeting the C5 domain may have use as a therapeutic vaccine to protect against disease progression.

Genetic analysis of the long terminal repeat (LTR) promoter region in HIV-1-infected individuals with different rates of disease progression

The long terminal repeat (LTR) region of HIV-1 promotes and modulates proviral transcription. LTR genetic variability might influence viral replication and disease progression. Proviral LTR sequences from 32 HIV-1-infected individuals showing different rates of disease progression were examined. Non-progressors (NP, n = 11) were individuals with high and stable CD4 counts and persistently low or undetectable plasma HIV-RNA. Slow progressors (SP, n = 6) were subjects with minimal CD4 decays over time and low plasma HIV-RNA. Typical progressors (TP, n = 15) were individuals with chronic infection showing CD4 counts repeatedly below 500 cells/mul. The mutation frequency within distinct LTR functional regions involved in HIV-1 transcription were compared in these three groups of patients. No significant differences were observed in the mutation frequency in most LTR regulatory sites when comparing the three groups. However, changes in USF regulatory binding sites were more frequent in TP than in SP/NP, while changes in Sp1 binding sites were less common in the former. This is the first study examining the genetic variability of the HIV-1 LTR region in long-term non-progressors showing further divergent outcomes.

HLA antigens as predictors of disease progression in HIV-infected haemophilia patients (a 22 years' follow up)

Our objective was to assess the influence of genetic factors such as HLA classes I and II antigens and other clinical and laboratory variables on the progression of HIV disease in a cohort of 118 HIV infected haemophilic subjects of Greek origin who had been typed for HLA antigens and were followed up prospectively for 22 years since seroconversion. At the end of the follow up we compared two groups of patients: 22 patients who had a fast progression to AIDS (median 6 years since seroconversion) vs. 33 patients who remained asymptomatic in stage A2 for up to 22 years (median 15 years). The results showed that the two groups did not differ significantly in age at seroconversion or baseline CD4+ T cell count. However there was a difference in the frequencies of certain HLA antigens in the two groups. The fast progressors had a higher frequency of HLA-A28, B21 and DR3, which was statistically significant (P = 0.02, 0.04, 0.05, respectively) compared to the slow progressors. These findings based on classical HLA typing techniques confirm other published observations and support the effect of genetic background in the progression of HIV infection in haemophilics.

Immunomodulatory effect of zidovudine (ZDV) on cytotoxic T lymphocytes previously exposed to ZDV

In a previous study, zidovudine (ZDV) was shown to cause a concentration-dependent inhibition of antigen-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clonal expansion (S. Francke, C. G. Orosz, K. A. Hayes, and L. E. Mathes, Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 44:1900-1905, 2000). However, this suppressive effect was lost if exposure to ZDV was delayed for 24 to 48 h during the antigen sensitization period, suggesting that antigen-primed CTL may be less susceptible than naive T lymphocytes to the suppressive effects of ZDV. The present study was undertaken to determine if naive T lymphocytes were more sensitive to the suppressive effects of ZDV than T lymphocytes previously exposed to antigen. The 50% inhibitory concentration (IC(50)) values of ZDV were determined on naive and antigen-primed T-cell responses in an alloantigen system. Lymphocyte cultures with continuous antigen exposure (double prime) were more resistant to ZDV suppression (IC(50) = 316 micro M) than were naive lymphocytes (IC(50) = 87.5 micro M). Interestingly, lymphocytes that were antigen primed but deprived of antigen during the final 7 days of culture (prime/hold) were exquisitely sensitive to ZDV suppression (IC(50) = 29.3 micro M). The addition of 80 micro M ZDV during the initial priming of the single-prime (prime/hold) and double-prime cultures did not select for a more drug-resistant cell population. The differences in ZDV sensitivities are likely a reflection of the physiological properties of the lymphocytes related to their activation state.

HLA and in vitro susceptibility to HIV infection

Since the beginning of the epidemic of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), evidence has accumulated that genetic factors are involved in the pathogenesis of the disease. Among the candidate molecules suspected to control susceptibility to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection and fast or slow progression of AIDS are the human leukocyte antigens (HLA). Investigating HLA-HIV correlation was mainly performed by investigating cohorts of patients with HIV/AIDS for a period of time and then statistically correlating certain features of AIDS with particular HLA alleles. This type of in vivo investigations resulted in the generation of an immense literature on the subject with so many HLA alleles being found to correlate with certain features of AIDS. Because of the complexity of AIDS pathogenesis and the involvement of many factors in the disease process, the different investigators failed to agree on the involvement of certain HLA molecules in AIDS pathogenesis. Some reports deny, or fail to confirm the existence of association between HLA and HIV progression to AIDS. This is probably due to the different ethnic backgrounds of the populations studied, the complexity of the HLA system, and to the ways these studies were conducted. This article briefly addresses our current knowledge on the HLA-HIV correlation in vivo and discusses alternative in vitro studies.

Influence of HLA-DR phenotype on the risk of hepatitis C virus-associated mixed cryoglobulinemia

OBJECTIVE

Circumstances predisposing hepatitis C virus (HCV)-infected patients to develop mixed cryoglobulinemia (MC), which may manifest as a small-vessel systemic vasculitis (MC vasculitis), remain unclear. Previous studies have failed to demonstrate a clear role of either viral factors (genotype, viral load) or host factors (lymphocytes or immunoglobulin subsets). This study was undertaken to examine a possible role of HLA class II alleles in HCV-associated MC.

METHODS

One hundred fifty-eight HCV-infected patients, of whom 76 had MC (56 with type II MC and 20 with type III MC) and 82 did not have MC, were studied prospectively. MC vasculitis was noted in 35 HCV-infected patients with type II IgMkappa-containing cryoglobulins. HLA-DRB1 and HLA-DQB1 polymorphism was analyzed by hybridization using allele-specific oligonucleotides, after gene amplification. The odds ratio (OR) was calculated with Woolf's method. Then, using multivariate analysis, demographic, biologic, immunologic, virologic, and liver histologic factors associated with the presence of MC and MC vasculitis were investigated.

RESULTS

HLA-DR11 was significantly more frequent in patients with type II MC than in those without MC (41.1% versus 17.1%; OR 3.4, corrected P [Pcorr] = 0.017), regardless of the presence of vasculitis accompanying the MC (37.1% of those with MC vasculitis, 34.1% of those with MC but no vasculitis). HLA-DR7 was less frequent in HCV-infected patients with MC than in those without MC (13.2% versus 30.5%; OR 0.34, P = 0.012, Pcorr not significant), with a particularly lower frequency in those with type II MC and those with MC vasculitis (12.5% and 8.6%, respectively). There was no significant difference in HLA-DQB1 distribution between the different patient groups. By univariate and multivariate analysis, HLA-DR11 was the only positive predictive factor, besides female sex and advanced age, for the presence of MC and HCV-associated MC vasculitis (OR 2.58).

CONCLUSION

Our results indicate that the presence of the DR11 phenotype is associated with a significantly increased risk for the development of type II MC in patients with chronic HCV infection. In contrast, HLA-DR7 appears to protect against the production of type II MC. These results suggest that the host's immune response genes may play a role in the pathogenesis of HCV-associated MC.

AIDS epidemic at the beginning of the third millennium: time for a new AIDS vaccine strategy

Current expansion of AIDS pandemic significantly accelerates AIDS vaccine research resulting in development and clinical testing of several AIDS vaccine candidates. At the same time, available experimental and clinical data demonstrate that current AIDS vaccine strategy is unsuccessful resulting in development of inefficient and harmful vaccines. This overview briefly summarizes reported results which point out the requirement for moratorium on the current clinical trials of HIV-1 gp120/160 vaccines and urgent need for development of a new, efficient and safe AIDS vaccine strategy.

Immune interventions

A better understanding of the immune response to HIV and the deleterious effect that HIV infection may have on the immune system in general, allows us to consider how best to restore protective immune responses to HIV and other opportunistic pathogens in the immunocompromised host. In this chapter, we summarise areas of current innovation and provide an update of the current state of knowledge concerning interventions which could result in the immunocompromised state being reversed. We describe the kinds of immune responses, which are thought to be useful in combating both the human immunodeficiency virus and other pathogenic organisms, and methods which are being considered to stimulate such responses. Lessons which may be learned from other disease states, which lead to immunodeficiency and methods for measuring successful outcome of treatment will be described.

Biological basis of the HLA-B8,DR3-associated progression of acquired immune deficiency syndrome

The factors influencing the evolution of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection are not fully known, but the host genotype undoubtedly plays a role in determining the outcome of the disease by affecting the immune response to HIV. The role of the host human leukocyte antigen (HLA) genotype in the regulation of susceptibility to HIV infection and expression has been studied extensively in different major risk groups. Certain HLA alleles and haplotypes, being associated with aberrant immune responses independently from HIV infection, have been reported to facilitate the rapid progression of disorders related to HIV infection. Particularly, the association of rapid acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) progression with genes from the HLA-B8,DR3 haplotype has been reported by different research groups. It is well known that this haplotype is associated in all Caucasian populations with a wide variety of diseases with autoimmune features and in healthy subjects with a number of immune system dysfunctions, as a reduced production of T helper (Th)1 type cytokine. HIV infection may act on this genetic background triggering immunopathogenetic mechanisms leading to AIDS with a dominant Th2 profile as a common feature.

HIV gp120 plus specific peptides are recognized in a similar manner to specific HLA plus peptide by HLA-restricted antigen-specific T-cell lines

HIV induces disease only following chronic activation of the immune system. Other retroviruses such as the mouse mammary tumour virus (MMTV) activate a large percentage of T cells by encoding a superantigen (SAg). To date there is no evidence that HIV encodes a SAg. An alternative way to induce pan-activation of the immune system is by allogeneic stimulation, which occurs following transplantation. Here we extend previous work which demonstrated that HIVpg120 could bind peptides in a similar manner to HLA, by demonstrating that human antigen presenting cells (APCs) expressing gp120 (but not DR1) can present a DR1-restricted peptide to induce proliferation of a DR1-restricted peptide-specific T-cell line in a similar manner to the same peptide presented by a DR1 expressing APC. Our data provide strong support for the hypothesis that the HLA-like regions of gp120 encode functional properties shared with HLA, and could explain the extraordinary clinical and immunological similarities between AIDS and chronic graft versus host disease.

Expression of the novel T cell activation molecule hpH4 in HIV-infected patients: correlation with disease status

We have described hpH4, a surface glycoprotein selectively expressed by activated T cells and mature thymocytes and displaying weak lateral association with CD4. The hpH4 expression pattern and biochemical features, together with analysis of its tryptic digest by peptide mass searching using MALDI-MS, suggested that it is a novel molecule. The aim of this work was to evaluate the peripheral blood T cell expression of hpH4 in HIV-infected patients and the interplay between HIV gp120 and hpH4, since both molecules interact with CD4. hpH4 expression during HIV-1 infection was evaluated by assessing 55 patients at various disease stages and following up 3 patients with primary infection and 3 patients with AIDS. hpH4 expression displayed a peak in the early phase of primary infection, dropped to control levels in the asymptomatic phase, and was newly expressed, at low levels, as AIDS developed. The expression kinetics were different than those shown by HLA-DR, CD25, and CD38. The most striking findings were the transient hpH4 expression peak displayed in the earliest stage, which was unique for hpH4. Incubation of T cells from normal donors with HIV gp120 induced transient hpH4 expression in resting CD4+ T cells and potentiated the hpH4 lateral association with CD4 in activated T cells. Moreover, hpH4 triggering inhibited gp120-induced death of CD4+ cells. Therefore, H4 expression may be a response to avoid apoptosis induced by HIV products.

nef/long terminal repeat quasispecies from HIV type 1-infected Mexican patients with different progression patterns and their pathogenesis in hu-PBL-SCID mice

To examine the genetic features of the long terminal repeat (LTR) derived from six HIV-1-infected individuals enrolled in the Mexico City Cohort, we cloned and sequenced a 505-bp fragment of the proviral LTR from their peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). All patients harbored HIV-1 LTR quasispecies corresponding to the B subtype. Three patients with high CD4+ T cell counts (>500/mm3) presented LTR sequences with point mutations in the TAR bulge. The LTR sequence from a patient classified as a long-term nonprogressor (LTNP) presented the most frequent naturally occurring length polymorphism (MFNLP) and two substitutions in the TAR region that were predicted to result in two alternative secondary RNA structures. A novel 18-bp deletion, which eliminates part of the putative binding site for the nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT-1), was identified in the overlapping nef/LTR sequence derived from a patient progressing to AIDS. This deletion coincides with the ability of this virus to consistently replicate at low levels in vivo (viral load <500 RNA copies/ml) and in vitro (unsuccessful virus isolation). On one occasion, when virus isolation was successful, the 18-bp deletion was no longer evident and LTR sequences with intact NFAT-1-binding sites were observed. Inoculation of hu-PBL-SCID mice with viruses from several Mexican patients resulted in differential CD4+ T cell depletion patterns 15 days postinfection, which agree with the in vivo CD4+ T cell count data from each patient.

Natural analogue peptides of an HIV-1 GP120 T-helper epitope antagonize response of GP120-specific human CD4 T-cell clones

Neutralizing antibodies and specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) may contribute to controlling viral spread, and ideally, to virus clearance in HIV infection. Both effector mechanisms depend on specific CD4 T-helper (Th) cells. Nevertheless, HIV hypervariability facilitates appearance of escape mutants for antibodies and for CTL responses. Here we also show that natural mutations (i.e., from sequences of different HIV strains) in an immunodominant Th epitope recognized by human CD4 clones specific for the envelope glycoprotein gp120 escape CD4 T-cell recognition. Furthermore, several natural analogue peptides exert an antagonistic function by inhibiting proliferative response of T cells specific to gp120 with a wild-type sequence. If similar events occur in vivo, they may represent an additional escape mechanism for HIV. In fact, antagonism for CD4 Th response may occur during superinfection with a different strain, or with the appearance of a variant carrying a mutated antagonistic sequence. In both cases, impaired Th cell function could lead to reduced immune control of HIV infection by interfering with CTL and antibody response.

The relationship between angiogenesis and the immune response in carcinogenesis and the progression of malignant disease

Recent studies have demonstrated that angiogenesis and suppressed cell-mediated immunity (CMI) play a central role in the pathogenesis of malignant disease facilitating tumour growth, invasion and metastasis. In the majority of tumours, the malignant process is preceded by a pathological condition or exposure to an irritant which itself is associated with the induction of angiogenesis and/or suppressed CMI. These include: cigarette smoking, chronic bronchitis and lung cancer; chronic oesophagitis and oesophageal cancer; chronic viral infections such as human papilloma virus and ano-genital cancers, chronic hepatitis B and C and hepatocellular carcinoma, and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and lymphomas; chronic inflammatory conditions such as Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis and colorectal cancer; asbestos exposure and mesothelioma and excessive sunlight exposure/sunburn and malignant melanoma. Chronic exposure to growth factors (insulin-like growth factor-I in acromegaly), mutations in tumour suppressor genes (TP53 in Li Fraumeni syndrome) and long-term exposure to immunosuppressive agents (cyclosporin A) may also give rise to similar environments and are associated with the development of a range of solid tumours. The increased blood supply would facilitate the development and proliferation of an abnormal clone or clones of cells arising as the result of: (a) an inherited genetic abnormality; and/or (b) acquired somatic mutations, the latter due to local production and/or enhanced delivery of carcinogens and mutagenic growth factors. With progressive detrimental mutations and growth-induced tumour hypoxia, the transformed cell, to a lesser or greater extent, may amplify the angiogenic process and CMI suppression, thereby facilitating further tumour growth and metastasis. There is accumulating evidence that long-term treatment with cyclo-oxygenase inhibitors (aspirin and indomethacin), cytokines such as interferon-alpha, anti-oestrogens (tamoxifen and raloxifene) and captopril significantly reduces the incidence of solid tumours such as breast and colorectal cancer. These agents are anti-angiogenic and, in the case of aspirin, indomethacin and interferon-alpha have proven immunomodulatory effects. Collectively these observations indicate that angiogenesis and suppressed CMI play a central role in the development and progression of malignant disease.

Pregnancy, HLA allogeneic challenge, and implications for AIDS etiology

Because of the large HLA genetic polymorphism, a human fetus usually has several paternal HLA antigens allogeneic to its mother. The maternal gamma-immunoglobulin (IgG) antibody response to fetal HLA alloantigens is noncytotoxic and associated with local suppression of maternal cell-mediated immunity (CMI) at the maternal-fetal interface. When mother and fetus are syngeneic for most HLA antigens, an increased risk exists for a maternal anti-placental cytotoxic CMI responses, compromising fetal survival. Local suppression of maternal CMI by an anti-HLA IgG response may have evolved to protect the fetoplacental unit from a maternal CMI cytotoxic reaction against expressed developmental neoantigens. A negative aspect of this adaptive response is that infectious organisms bearing HLA-homologous alloantigens (e.g. human immunodeficiency virus type 1, HIV-1) may generate a systemic IgG response suppressing CMI. Findings are reviewed suggesting this is an etiologic factor in the acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS).

New Class I and II HLA Alleles Strongly Associated with Opposite Patterns of Progression to AIDS

The genetics of resistance to infection by HIV-1 cohort consists of 200 slow and 75 rapid progressors to AIDS corresponding to the extremes of HIV disease outcome of 20,000 Caucasians of European descent. A comprehensive analysis of HLA class I and class II genes in this highly informative cohort has identified HLA alleles associated with fast or slow progression, including several not described previously. A quantitative analysis shows an overall HLA influence independent of and equal in magnitude (for the protective effect) to the effect of the CCR5-Δ32 mutation. Among HLA class I genes, A29 (p = 0.001) and B22 (p &lt; 0.0001) are significantly associated with rapid progression, whereas B14 (p = 0.001) and C8 (p = 0.004) are significantly associated with nonprogression. The class I alleles B27, B57, C14 (protective), and C16, as well as B35 (susceptible), are also influential, but their effects are less robust. Influence of class II alleles was only observed for DR11. These results confirm the influence of the immune system on disease progression and may have implications on peptide-based vaccine development.

Identification of multiple HIV-1 CTL epitopes presented by HLA-B*5101 molecules

We attempted to identify and characterize HIV-1 CTL epitopes presented by HLA-B51 which is associated with a slow progression to AIDS. HLA-B*5101 stabilization assay showed that 33 out of 172 HIV-1 peptides carrying HLA-B*5101 anchor residues bound to HLA-B*5101. Seven peptides were suggested as HIV-1 CTL epitopes presented by HLA-B*5101 because the specific CTL was induced for these peptides in PBMC from three HIV-1 seropositive individuals carrying HLA-B51 by stimulation with HLA-B*5101 binding peptides. Analysis of these epitopes using the specific CTL clones confirmed that six of seven HIV-1 peptides are epitopes presented by HLA-B*5101. Three epitopes presented by HLA-B*5101 are highly conserved among the clade B strain, suggesting that the specific CTL for these epitopes might play an important role in recognition of HIV-1 infected cells. These epitopes will be useful to analyze CTL responses in HIV-1 infected individuals.

Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity can protect PBMC from infection by cell-associated HIV-1

We have developed a novel in vitro assay system to study the role of antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) in protection against HIV-1 infection by cell-associated virus. HIV-1-infected NK-resistant cells are mixed with specific antibody and unstimulated PBMC and ADCC is allowed to occur over several hours. The PBMC are then activated and cultured to allow virus replication in newly infected T cells. To ensure that ADCC is the only mechanism by which protection could occur we have used haptenated (TNP) infected cells and anti-hapten antibody. Anti-hapten sera completely protected PBMC from infection by haptenated HIV-1-infected cells in ADCC protection assays. F(ab')2 fragments of anti-hapten IgG showed no protection, confirming that ADCC was responsible for protection by anti-hapten IgG. PCR analysis for HIV-1 DNA confirmed the elimination of infected cells. We believe this to be the first direct demonstration that ADCC alone can protect PBMC from infection by cell-associated HIV-1.

Virological and Immunological Features of Long-Term Human Immunodeficiency Virus–Infected Individuals Who Have Remained Asymptomatic Compared With Those Who Have Progressed to Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome

Infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) leads to a decrease in CD4+ T cells and disease progression within a decade of seroconversion. However, a small group of infected people, despite being infected by HIV for 10 or more years, remain clinically asymptomatic and have stable CD4+ cell counts without taking antiretroviral medication. To determine why these individuals, known as long-term survivors (LTS), remain healthy, the hematological profiles, viral load and properties, HIV coreceptor genotype, and anti-HIV immune responses of these people were compared with those of individuals who have progressed to disease (Progressors) over the same time period. Unlike Progressors, LTS have a low circulating viral load and a low number of HIV-infected cells. These differences in the levels of the viral load were not associated with a dominant biologic viral phenotype, varying growth kinetics of the virus, mutation in the cellular CCR5 gene, or the presence of neutralizing antibodies. Importantly, the difference in viral load could be explained by the enhanced ability of CD8+ cells from LTS to suppress HIV replication.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Virological and Immunological Features of Long-Term Human Immunodeficiency Virus–Infected Individuals Who Have Remained Asymptomatic Compared With Those Who Have Progressed to Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome

Infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) leads to a decrease in CD4+ T cells and disease progression within a decade of seroconversion. However, a small group of infected people, despite being infected by HIV for 10 or more years, remain clinically asymptomatic and have stable CD4+ cell counts without taking antiretroviral medication. To determine why these individuals, known as long-term survivors (LTS), remain healthy, the hematological profiles, viral load and properties, HIV coreceptor genotype, and anti-HIV immune responses of these people were compared with those of individuals who have progressed to disease (Progressors) over the same time period. Unlike Progressors, LTS have a low circulating viral load and a low number of HIV-infected cells. These differences in the levels of the viral load were not associated with a dominant biologic viral phenotype, varying growth kinetics of the virus, mutation in the cellular CCR5 gene, or the presence of neutralizing antibodies. Importantly, the difference in viral load could be explained by the enhanced ability of CD8+ cells from LTS to suppress HIV replication.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Low CD4 counts rather than superantigenic-like effects account for differences in expressed T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoires between HIV-1 seropositive long-term non-progressors and individuals with progressive disease

Analysis of HIV-infected individuals who have stable CD4 counts many years after seroconversion may provide an insight as to how the host's immune system can successfully control HIV infection. In this study we analysed the T-cell receptor (TCR) Vbeta repertoire in 13 HIV+ individuals, seven of whom were classed as long-term non-progressors (LTNP), using a technique which couples anchor PCR (AnPCR) amplification of beta-chain cDNA to differential probe hybridization with non-radioactively labelled Vbeta family specific oligonucleotide probes. There were no significant differences in the expressed TCR repertoires between the LTNP group and the other HIV-infected individuals. However, there was a statistically significant inverse correlation between CD4 count and the number of Vbeta family-specific perturbations in the recent seroconverters (SC) and those with progressive infection (PI), consistent with other shared features of clinical disease progression (Th1/Th2 switch and high frequency of viral isolation). We conclude that long-term clinical non-progression in HIV-1 infection is not associated with the loss or expansion of a particular Vbeta family; instead, low CD4 count in the PI and SC individuals was correlated with increased number of Vbeta family-specific perturbations relative to the LTNP group and that it is hence unlikely that HIV encodes a superantigen.

Influence of host genes on HIV-1 disease progression

The role of host genes in the course of HIV-1 infection has been examined in different populations and among all major risk groups. Two extended human lymphocyte antigen (HLA) haplotypes, HLA A1-Cw7-B8-DR3-DQ2 and HLA A11-Cw4-B35-DR1-DQ1, are found to be associated with a faster progression to AIDS. The complement C4 factor and tumor necrosis factor genes of the major histocompatibility complex, as well as the mannose binding protein gene, have also been suggested to influence the outcome of AIDS. The recent discovery that chemokine receptors could serve as cofactors for HIV-1 cell entry has prompted a search for polymorphisms in chemokine receptor genes. A 32 base pair inactivating deletion in the CCR5 gene and a point mutation within the CCR2b gene resulting in a conservative amino acid substitution have been examined and shown to be independently associated with delayed disease progression. Together, these observations strongly support a genetic component in AIDS pathogenesis. This article synthesizes the current state of knowledge about the influence of host genes on HIV-1 disease progression. It provides a summary of all significant association studies reported so far. The role of the allelic polymorphism in these genes is discussed with regard to the immunopathogenesis of AIDS.

Distinct HLA class II alleles determine antibody response to vaccination with hepatitis B surface antigen

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) determinants control antibody production in response to protein antigens. Vaccination with hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) frequently fails in hemodialyzed patients, but the genetic factors that modulate humoral responsiveness are poorly characterized. We studied the distribution of HLA class II alleles in 415 hemodialyzed Caucasian patients who received a full course of HBsAg vaccination, using class II oligotyping after genomic amplification of the DRB1 and DQB1 loci. Phenotype frequencies were compared in 114 non responders (anti-HBs antibodies < or = 10 SI units/liter), 301 responders (anti-HBs antibodies > 10 units/liter) and 471 healthy controls. DRB1*01 (DR1) and DRB1*15 (DR15) frequencies were lower in nonresponders than in responders and controls (DR1, 12.3% vs. 22.9% and 24.8%, respectively; DR15, 14% vs. 22.9% and 25.1%), while DRB1*03 (DR3) and DRB1*14 (DR14) frequencies were higher (DR3, 32.5% vs. 16.6% and 25.3%, respectively; DR14, 9.6% vs. 3% and 6.6%). Overall, 44.5% of DR3 or DR14 patients were nonresponders, compared to 18.1% of DR1 or DR15 patients (P = 0.0001). In conclusion the humoral response to HBsAg vaccine is influenced by class II allelic variants, which differ in their capacity to bind and present peptides to T lymphocytes.

Opiates as potential cofactors in progression of HIV-1 infections to AIDS

Because of the widely documented association of AIDS with opiate abuse, there is considerable interest in knowing whether opiates alter progression of HIV-1 infections to AIDS. The main reason for this interest is that opiates and opiate-abuse have been shown to have broad influence on immune processes as well as in vitro expressions of HIV-1. This article reviews literature defining the connection between opiate use and AIDS. Basic understanding of the effects of opiates on immune process and HIV-1 infection, especially as derived from study of a monkey model of AIDS, are discussed as well as epidemiological data regarding the connection between chronic injected drug abuse and AIDS, in the context of current knowledge about the HIV-1 infectious process and AIDS pathogenesis. Theoretically, there is ample reason to suspect that opiates are involved in progression of HIV-1 infections to AIDS. To date, however, epidemiological approaches have been unable to link decline in CD4 T-cell counts, as a marker of AIDS progression, with opiate use--although other indices of AIDS progression have yet to be thoroughly evaluated in this regard. Also, the impact of opiate use and abuse on opportunistic infections occurring prior to or concurrent with HIV-1 infection has not been closely scrutinized. Interestingly, despite considerable evidence delineating the potential of opiates to exacerbate HIV-1 infections, there is suggestive evidence from both clinical observations and basic studies that homeostatically balancing conditions of chronic, consistent opiate exposure have the potential to protect the host from progression of HIV-1 infections--a situation that may well differ from when opiate-naive subjects first experience exposure to opiates and when opiate dependency is not maintained in a consistent fashion. Taken together, therefore, information from basic studies, including most particularly studies with monkeys, and epidemiological studies, indicates that effects of opiates on progression to AIDS may be conditionally variable. There are many aspects of the drug abuse culture that have potentially offsetting consequences in terms of their potential to up- or down-regulate both HIV-1 expression and host protective responses thereto that could be relevant in this regard. In conclusion, many ambiguities are yet to be considered, and basic and epidemiological studies to be pursued before the opiate-AIDS connection is fully understood.

Enhancement of feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) infection after DNA vaccination with the FIV envelope

Despite intensive experimentation to develop effective and safe vaccines against the human immunodeficiency viruses and other pathogenic lentiviruses, it remains unclear whether an immune response that does not afford protection may, on the contrary, produce adverse effects. In the present study, the effect of genetic immunization with the env gene was examined in a natural animal model of lentivirus pathogenesis, infection of cats by the feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV). Three groups of seven cats were immunized by intramuscular transfer of plasmid DNAs expressing either the wild-type envelope or two envelopes bearing mutations in the principal immunodominant domain of the transmembrane glycoprotein. Upon homologous challenge, determination of plasma virus load showed that the acute phase of viral infection occurred earlier in the three groups of cats immunized with FIV envelopes than in the control cats. Genetic immunization, however, elicited low or undetectable levels of antibodies directed against envelope glycoproteins. These results suggest that immunization with the FIV env gene may result in enhancement of infection and that mechanisms unrelated to enhancing antibodies underlay the observed acceleration.

Lymphoproliferative immune function in the Sydney Blood Bank Cohort, infected with natural nef/long terminal repeat mutants, and in other long-term survivors of transfusion-acquired HIV-1 infection

OBJECTIVES

To assess T-helper cell immune function (proliferation) in members of the Sydney Blood Bank Cohort (SBBC) compared with other individuals with transfusion- and sexually acquired HIV-1 infection and with matched HIV-negative controls.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Decreasing CD4 counts and T-helper cell function are associated with disease progression. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from study subjects were assayed for in vitro proliferative responses to HIV-1-derived antigens, recall antigens and alloantigen. T-helper cell function and CD4 counts in members of the SBBC were followed longitudinally.

RESULTS

Proliferative responses and CD4 counts from members of the SBBC were similar to or better than those of other transfusion- or sexually-acquired HIV-1-positive long-term non-progressors (LTNP), including the HIV-negative matched SBBC control groups. However, individuals with disease progression had reduced or undetectable proliferative responses to recall antigens but a conserved response to alloantigen; they also had low CD4 counts and low CD4:CD8 ratios. In the SBBC, these immune parameters were usually stable over time.

CONCLUSIONS

The unique SBBC with natural nef/long terminal repeat deletions in the HIV-1 genome were genuine LTNP without showing signs of disease progression. They appeared to be a group distinct from the tail-end of the normal distribution of disease progression rates, and may remain asymptomatic indefinitely. The SBBC virus may form the basis of a live attenuated immunotherapeutic or immunoprophylactic HIV vaccine.

Influence of microbial infections on the progression of HIV disease

HIV infection is associated with immune activation, which in turn stimulates HIV replication. Certain other co-infections cause immune activation and may contribute to an increased viral load. The impact of co-infections by microorganisms such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis can be important for patient survival, particularly those at high risk of exposure to infection and with poor access to medical care.

HIV infection induces changes in CD4+ T-cell phenotype and depletions within the CD4+ T-cell repertoire that are not immediately restored by antiviral or immune-based therapies

Changes in CD4+ T-cell surface marker phenotype and antigen receptor (TCR) repertoire were examined during the course of HIV infection and following therapy. A preferential decline in naive CD4+ T cells was noted as disease progressed. Following protease inhibitor therapy, naive CD4+ T cells increased only if they were present before initiation of therapy. Disruptions of the CD4+ TCR repertoire were most prevalent in patients with the lowest CD4+ T-cell counts. Antiviral or IL-12 therapy-induced increases in CD4+ T-cell counts led to only minor changes in previously disrupted repertoires. Thus, CD4+ T-cell death mediated by HIV-1 infection may result in a preferential decline in the number of naive CD4+ T cells and disruptions of the CD4+ T-cell repertoire that are not immediately corrected by antiviral or immune-based therapies.

Low-affinity cytotoxic T-lymphocytes require IFN-gamma to clear an acute viral infection

The majority of the response of cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL) to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) in H-2d mice is directed toward one epitope located on the nucleoprotein (NP, aa 118-126), and usually no primary responses to other epitopes are detectable. Previous studies have shown that thymic expression of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus-nucleoprotein (LCMV-NP) in H-2d transgenic mice (Thy-NP mice) leads to deletion of high-affinity anti-LCMV-NP CTL by negative selection. Selection is incomplete, so that low-affinity NP-specific CTL pass through the thymus and are detectable in the periphery. To analyze the importance of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) in the ability of low-affinity antiviral CTL to clear an acute viral infection, double transgenic mice were generated that are IFN-gamma deficient and express the NP of LCMV in the thymus (Thy-NP x IFN-gamma -/- mice). When infected with LCMV, these bigenic mice were unable to clear the infection despite generating low-affinity primary antiviral CTL, and they became persistently infected. In contrast, IFN-gamma competent Thy-NP mice cleared LCMV within 7-8 days and IFN-gamma deficient mice that did not express NP in their thymus generated high-affinity CTL that terminated an acute LCMV infection within 10-12 days post-viral challenge. Persistently infected IFN-gamma deficient mice selectively depleted LCMV-specific CTL and displayed reduced levels of antigen-presenting cells in the spleen, and 60% of these mice died at 2-3 months postinfection. Thus, IFN-gamma is required for clearing an acute viral infection in the absence of a high-affinity CTL response. In the absence of IFN-gamma persistent viral infection results despite the presence of low-affinity CTL.

The presence of host-derived HLA-DR1 on human immunodeficiency virus type 1 increases viral infectivity

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) incorporates several host cell components when budding out of the infected cell. One of the most abundant host-derived molecules acquired by HIV-1 is the HLA-DR determinant of the major histocompatibility complex class II (MHC-II) molecules. The fact that CD4 is the natural ligand of MHC-II prompted us to determine if such virally embedded cellular components can affect the biology of the virus. Herein, we report for the first time that the incorporation of cellular HLA-DR1 within HIV-1 enhances its infectivity. This observation was made possible with virions bearing or not bearing on their surfaces host-derived HLA-DR1 glycoproteins. Such virus stocks were prepared by a transient-expression system based on transfection of 293T cells with a recombinant luciferase-encoding HIV-1 molecular clone along with plasmids encoding the alpha and beta chains of HLA-DR1. Cell-free virions recovered from transfected cells were shown to have efficiently incorporated host-derived HLA-DR1 glycoproteins. Infectivity was increased by a factor of 1.6 to 2.3 for virions bearing on their surfaces host-derived HLA-DR1. The observed enhancement of HIV-1 infectivity was independent of the virus stocks used and was seen in several T-lymphoid cell lines, in a premonocytoid cell line, and in primary peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Finally, we determined that the presence of virion-bound cellular HLA-DR1 is associated with faster kinetics of virus infection. Taken together, these results suggest that HLA-DR-1-bearing HIV-1 particles had a greater infectivity per picogram of viral p24 protein than HLA-DR1-free virions.

V beta activation by HIV Nef protein: detection by a simple amplification procedure

We previously reported that Nef protein from human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) has superantigen properties. However, we were unable to consistently demonstrate V beta-specific expansion by Nef using flow cytometry, possibly due to its lower mitogenic activity compared to prototypic superantigens. Therefore, we developed a simple amplification detection method using immobilized anti-V beta antibodies. Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells from adult donors were treated for 24 h with Nef and restimulated with immobilized anti-V beta antibodies for an additional 72 h. Significant expansion of V beta 5.3 and V beta 18 T-cells were detected in Nef-treated cultures, with expansion of V beta 18 occurring with all donors tested, and V beta 5.3 expansion occurring in 50% of the donors. Variable responses were obtained with V beta 2, V beta 3, and V beta 9. These results were confirmed using the more time-consuming method of reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Thus, this novel, reproducible, and relatively simple method can detect V beta-specific expansion by weak superantigens.