Glioblastoma multiforme: a controlled trial to assess the value of specific active immunotherapy in patients treated by radical surgery and radiotherapy

Personalised therapeutic approaches to glioblastoma: A systematic review

Introduction

Glioblastoma is the most common and malignant primary brain tumour with median survival of 14.6 months. Personalised medicine aims to improve survival by targeting individualised patient characteristics. However, a major limitation has been application of targeted therapies in a non-personalised manner without biomarker enrichment. This has risked therapies being discounted without fair and rigorous evaluation. The objective was therefore to synthesise the current evidence on survival efficacy of personalised therapies in glioblastoma.

Methods

Studies reporting a survival outcome in human adults with supratentorial glioblastoma were eligible. PRISMA guidelines were followed. MEDLINE, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science and the Cochrane Library were searched to 5th May 2022. Clinicaltrials.gov was searched to 25th May 2022. Reference lists were hand-searched. Duplicate title/abstract screening, data extraction and risk of bias assessments were conducted. A quantitative synthesis is presented.

Results

A total of 102 trials were included: 16 were randomised and 41 studied newly diagnosed patients. Of 5,527 included patients, 59.4% were male and mean age was 53.7 years. More than 20 types of personalised therapy were included: targeted molecular therapies were the most studied (33.3%, 34/102), followed by autologous dendritic cell vaccines (32.4%, 33/102) and autologous tumour vaccines (10.8%, 11/102). There was no consistent evidence for survival efficacy of any personalised therapy.

Conclusion

Personalised glioblastoma therapies remain of unproven survival benefit. Evidence is inconsistent with high risk of bias. Nonetheless, encouraging results in some trials provide reason for optimism. Future focus should address target-enriched trials, combination therapies, longitudinal biomarker monitoring and standardised reporting.

NK Cell-Based Glioblastoma Immunotherapy

Glioblastoma (GB) is the most aggressive and most common malignant primary brain tumor diagnosed in adults. GB shows a poor prognosis and, unfortunately, current therapies are unable to improve its clinical outcome, imposing the need for innovative therapeutic approaches. The main reason for the poor prognosis is the great cell heterogeneity of the tumor mass and its high capacity for invading healthy tissues. Moreover, the glioblastoma microenvironment is capable of suppressing the action of the immune system through several mechanisms such as recruitment of cell modulators. Development of new therapies that avoid this immune evasion could improve the response to the current treatments for this pathology. Natural Killer (NK) cells are cellular components of the immune system more difficult to deceive by tumor cells and with greater cytotoxic activity. Their use in immunotherapy gains strength because they are a less toxic alternative to existing therapy, but the current research focuses on mimicking the NK attack strategy. Here, we summarize the most recent studies regarding molecular mechanisms involved in the GB and immune cells interaction and highlight the relevance of NK cells in the new therapeutic challenges.

Therapeutic efficacy of specific immunotherapy for glioma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Although different immunotherapeutic approaches have been developed for the treatment of glioma, there is a discrepancy between clinical trials limiting their approval as common treatment. So, the current systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted to assess survival and clinical response of specific immunotherapy in patients with glioma. Generally, seven databases were searched to find eligible studies. Controlled clinical trials investigating the efficacy of specific immunotherapy in glioma were found eligible. After data extraction and risk of bias assessment, the data were analyzed based on the level of heterogeneity. Overall, 25 articles with 2964 patients were included. Generally, mean overall survival did not statistically improve in immunotherapy [median difference=1.51; 95% confidence interval (CI)=-0.16-3.17; p=0.08]; however, it was 11.16 months higher in passive immunotherapy (95% CI=5.69-16.64; p<0.0001). One-year overall survival was significantly higher in immunotherapy groups [hazard ratio (HR)=0.69; 95% CI=0.52-0.92; p=0.01]. As the hazard rate in the immunotherapy approach was 0.83 of the control group, 2-year overall survival was significantly higher in immunotherapy (HR=0.83; 95% CI=0.69-0.99; p=0.04). Three-year overall survival was significantly higher in immunotherapy as well (HR=0.67; 95% CI=0.48-0.92; p=0.01). Overall, median progression-free survival was significantly higher in immunotherapy (standard median difference=0.323; 95% CI=0.110-0.536; p=0.003). However, 1-year progression-free survival was not remarkably different between immunotherapy and control groups (HR=0.94; 95% CI=0.74-1.18; p=0.59). Specific immunotherapy demonstrated remarkable improvement in survival of patients with glioma and could be a considerable choice of treatment in the future. Despite the current promising results, further high-quality randomized controlled trials are required to approve immunotherapeutic approaches as the standard of care and the front-line treatment for glioma.

History and current state of immunotherapy in glioma and brain metastasis

Malignant brain tumors such as glioblastoma (GBM) and brain metastasis have poor prognosis despite conventional therapies. Successful use of vaccines and checkpoint inhibitors in systemic malignancy has increased the hope that immune therapies could improve survival in patients with brain tumors. Manipulating the immune system to fight malignancy has a long history of both modest breakthroughs and pitfalls that should be considered when applying the current immunotherapy approaches to patients with brain tumors. Therapeutic vaccine trials for GBM date back to the mid 1900s and have taken many forms; from irradiated tumor lysate to cell transfer therapies and peptide vaccines. These therapies were generally well tolerated without significant autoimmune toxicity, however also did not demonstrate significant clinical benefit. In contrast, the newer checkpoint inhibitors have demonstrated durable benefit in some metastatic malignancies, accompanied by significant autoimmune toxicity. While this toxicity was not unexpected, it exceeded what was predicted from pre-clinical studies and in many ways was similar to the prior trials of immunostimulants. This review will discuss the history of these studies and demonstrate that the future use of immune therapy for brain tumors will likely need a personalized approach that balances autoimmune toxicity with the opportunity for significant survival benefit.

An integrative view on sex differences in brain tumors

Sex differences in human health and disease can range from undetectable to profound. Differences in brain tumor rates and outcome are evident in males and females throughout the world and regardless of age. These observations indicate that fundamental aspects of sex determination can impact the biology of brain tumors. It is likely that optimal personalized approaches to the treatment of male and female brain tumor patients will require recognizing and understanding the ways in which the biology of their tumors can differ. It is our view that sex-specific approaches to brain tumor screening and care will be enhanced by rigorously documenting differences in brain tumor rates and outcomes in males and females, and understanding the developmental and evolutionary origins of sex differences. Here we offer such an integrative perspective on brain tumors. It is our intent to encourage the consideration of sex differences in clinical and basic scientific investigations.

Heat shock protein-peptide complex in the treatment of glioblastoma

Vaccination immunotherapies offer the promise of long-term tumor control, and preclinical trials have found promising results. Active immunotherapy uses the adaptive immune response to specifically kill tumor cells. Tumor-specific antigens are processed by antigen-presenting cells and recognized by specific effector lymphocytes. However, basic vaccination strategies with tumor lysates have been unsuccessful in inducing antiglioma immunity in clinical trials. Gliomas are known to modulate the activity of antigen-presenting cells to reduce antitumor immune activity. Recently, tumor-derived heat shock proteins have been found to more effectively activate the immune response. Widely expressed, heat shock proteins are thought to present protein peptide fragments in a format conducive to processing by antigen-presenting cells. As a part of the protein synthesis machinery, peptides complexed with heat shock proteins are effectively representative of antigens expressed by the cell; these peptides convey the specificity of this vaccination strategy. The heat shock protein-peptide vaccine is one of many promising immunotherapeutic strategies being evaluated in clinical trials. These can be broadly classified as active, passive and adoptive, each with advantages and disadvantages. Here, we compare and contrast heat shock protein-peptide vaccines with other immunotherapies and describe the outcomes of clinical trials to date.

The PEPvIII-KLH (CDX-110) vaccine in glioblastoma multiforme patients

Conventional therapies for glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) fail to target tumor cells exclusively, resulting in non-specific toxicity. Immune targeting of tumor-specific mutations may allow for more precise eradication of neoplastic cells. EGFR variant III (EGFRvIII) is a tumor-specific mutation that is widely expressed in GBM and other neoplasms and its expression enhances tumorigenicity. This in-frame deletion mutation splits a codon, resulting in a novel glycine at the fusion junction producing a tumor-specific epitope target for cellular or humoral immunotherapy. We have previously shown that vaccination with a peptide that spans the EGFRvIII fusion junction (PEPvIII-KLH/CDX-110) is an efficacious immunotherapy in syngeneic murine models. In this review, we summarize our results in GBM patients targeting this mutation in multiple, multi-institutional Phase II immunotherapy trials. These trials demonstrated that a selected population of GBM patients who received vaccines targeting EGFRvIII had an unexpectedly long survival time. Further therapeutic strategies and potential pitfalls of using this approach are discussed.

Tumor-specific immunotherapy targeting the EGFRvIII mutation in patients with malignant glioma

Conventional therapies for malignant gliomas (MGs) fail to target tumor cells exclusively, such that their efficacy is ultimately limited by non-specific toxicity. Immunologic targeting of tumor-specific gene mutations, however, may allow more precise eradication of neoplastic cells. The epidermal growth factor receptor variant III (EGFRvIII) is a consistent tumor-specific mutation that is widely expressed in MGs and other neoplasms. This mutation encodes a constitutively active tyrosine kinase that enhances tumorgenicity and migration and confers radiation and chemotherapeutic resistance. This in-frame deletion mutation splits a codon resulting in the creation of a novel glycine at the fusion junction between normally distant parts of the molecule and producing a sequence re-arrangement which creates a tumor-specific epitope for cellular or humoral immunotherapy in patients with MGs. We have previously shown that vaccination with a peptide that spans the EGFRvIII fusion junction is an efficacious immunotherapy in syngeneic murine models, but patients with MGs have a profound immunosuppression that may inhibit the ability of antigen presenting cells (APCs), even those generated ex vivo, to induce EGFRvIII-specific immune responses. In this report, we summarize our results in humans targeting this mutation in two consecutive and one multi-institutional Phase II immunotherapy trials. These trials demonstrated that vaccines targeting EGFRvIII are capable of inducing potent T- and B-cell immunity in these patients, and lead to an unexpectedly long survival time. Most importantly, vaccines targeting EGFRvIII were universally successful at eliminating tumor cells expressing the targeted antigen without any evidence of symptomatic collateral toxicity. These studies establish the tumor-specific EGFRvIII mutation as a novel target for humoral- and cell-mediated immunotherapy in a variety of cancers. The recurrence of EGFRvIII-negative tumors in our patients, however, highlights the need for targeting a broader repertoire of tumor-specific antigens.

Dendritic cell vaccination in patients with malignant gliomas: current status and future directions

OBJECTIVE

Despite recent advances in neurosurgical resection techniques, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy, malignant gliomas continue to have a dismal prognosis because relapses are unavoidable.

METHODS

Dendritic cell vaccination has recently emerged as a promising type of active immunotherapy that aims to induce rather than transfer specific antitumor immune responses in patients. Active immunotherapy is the only type of immunotherapy able to induce immunological memory.

RESULTS

Although an increasing number of small clinical trials show safety, feasibility, and immunological and clinical responses, this technology requires further clarification of some critical basic and clinical issues before its presumed place in the treatment of malignant gliomas can be specified. This article addresses the basic and clinical pitfalls that, more than with conventional therapies, may interfere with the potential benefits of this approach.

CONCLUSION

Considering the particular mechanisms involved in the immune modulation of tumor biology using dendritic cell-based vaccinations, the authors summarize the arguments in favor of a further, appropriate assessment of this technology.

Dendritic cells are essential for priming but inefficient for boosting antitumour immune response in an orthotopic murine glioma model

The prognosis of malignant gliomas remains dismal and alternative therapeutic strategies are required. Immunotherapy with dendritic cells (DCs) pulsed with tumour antigens emerges as a promising approach. Many parameters influence the efficacy of DC-based vaccines and need to be optimised in preclinical models. The present study compares different vaccine schedules using DCs loaded with tumour cell lysate (DC-Lysate) for increasing long-term survival in the GL26 orthotopic murine glioma model, focusing on the number of injections and an optimal way to recall antitumour immune response. Double vaccination with DC-Lysate strongly prolonged median survival compared to unvaccinated animals (mean survival 87.5 days vs. 25 days; p < 0.0001). In vitro data showed specific cytotoxic activity against GL26. However, late tumour relapses frequently occurred after 3 months and only 20% of mice were finally cured at 7 months. While one, two or three DC injections gave identical survival, a boost using only tumour lysate after initial DC-Lysate priming dramatically improved long-term survival in vaccinated mice, compared to the double DC-Lysate group, with 67.5% of animals cured at 7 months (p < 0.0001). In vitro data showed better specific CTL response and also the induction of specific anti-GL26 antibodies in the DC-Lysate/Lysate group, which mediated Complement Dependent Cytotoxicity. These experimental data may be of importance for the design of clinical trials that currently use multiple DC injections.

Immunotherapy for human glioma: innovative approaches and recent results

The outcome for malignant glioma patients remains dismal despite treatment with surgical resection, radiation and chemotherapy. The goal of immunotherapy is to eradicate or suppress the residual infiltrative component of these tumors. Although there is clinical evidence for cell-mediated antiglioma activity, there are special considerations that need to be accounted for in the design of immunotherapeutics for CNS tumors, such as possible differences in antigen-presenting cells, trafficking of effector T-cells and immunosuppression. Previously characterized immunosuppression in glioma patients has included low peripheral blood lymphocyte counts, reduced delayed type hypersensitivity reactions to recall antigens, impaired mitogen-induced blastogenic responses by peripheral blood mononuclear cells, increased CD8+ suppressor T-cells, decreased CD4+ T-cell activity in vitro, diminished immunoglobulin synthesis by B-cells and impaired transmembrane signaling through the T-cell receptor/CD3 complex. Recent impairments that are being identified include anergy, failure of costimulation, lack of sufficient numbers of functional effector T-cells and the presence of T-suppressor cells within the tumor microenvironment. It is proposed that these inherent problems will need to be overcome in order for immunotherapies to realize their potential. Paradoxically, the efficacy of recent clinical immunotherapies for glioma patients appears equivalent to that seen in other cancer immunotherapeutic approaches. This review will provide an overview of the juxtaposition of the immune system and CNS, and will discuss the most recent and ongoing immunotherapeutic clinical trials that are demonstrating promising results.

Immunotherapy of prolactinoma with a T helper 1 activator adjuvant and autoantigens: a case report

OBJECTIVE

To date, efforts to reliably manipulate the immune system to promote tumor regression in the brain have been disappointing. We report a unique experience of successful immunotherapy to treat a pituitary macroprolactinoma.

METHODS

A 31-year-old woman with an established history of pituitary macroprolactinoma who had undergone tumor resection followed by radiation was admitted to our clinic. The diagnosis had been made due to the patient's symptoms, a serum prolactin (PRL) level of 29,600 mIU/l, a brain MRI revealing a 23 x 19 x 18 mm pituitary mass and a positive PRL immunohistochemistry of the mass. Six months following surgery, she reexperienced headache, excessive sweating and a serum PRL concentration of 2,960 mIU/l despite receiving 30 mg/day bromocriptine. Brain MRI revealed a pituitary mass (3 x 6 x 8 mm) compatible with a pituitary adenoma. Twenty micrograms per milliliter of G2 (as a T helper 1 activator adjuvant) was inoculated intradermally once per week for 24 consecutive weeks (each injection contained 10 mug of G2). The autoantigens were inoculated at the same time with G2.

RESULTS

After immunotherapy, serum PRL concentration decreased to 82 mIU/l, the patient's symptoms disappeared, skin thickness increased to normal and bromocriptine dosage was tapered to 20 mg per week. A follow-up brain MRI revealed almost complete disappearance of the tumor. The patient does not complain of any problems at 1-year follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Activation of both nonspecific (natural killer cells) and specific (cytotoxic T lymphocytes) immunity in relation to the T helper 1 cytokine network is a promising strategy for the treatment of tumors of the central nervous system in humans, especially pituitary macroprolactinomas.

Immunotherapy for malignant gliomas: emphasis on strategies of active specific immunotherapy using autologous dendritic cells

REVIEW

In this review, we discuss immunotherapy for malignant gliomas.

EMPHASIS

The emphasis is on the novel strategy of active specific immunotherapy using dendritic cells as antigen-presenting cells, especially its theoretical concepts and advantages, specific requirements, critical issues, pre-clinical and early clinical experience. Dendritic cell vaccination is situated in the diversity of other immunotherapeutical approaches.

FURTHER DISCUSSION

Future directions, challenges, and drawbacks will be discussed.

Cell-mediated immunotherapy: a new approach to the treatment of malignant glioma

BACKGROUND

The dismal prognosis for patients harboring intracranial gliomas has prompted an intensive search for effective treatment alternatives such as immunotherapy. Our increased knowledge in basic immunology, glioma immunobiology, and molecular biology may lead to the development of effective, rational immunotherapy approaches.

METHODS

The authors reviewed the literature on glioma immunology, the status of tumor vaccine therapy and on novel techniques to monitor the tumor-specific immune response.

RESULTS

Experimental conditions currently exist whereby potent antitumor cell-mediated immune responses can be generated. However, clinically, no therapeutic regimen has proven effective. Obstacles to establishing an effective immunotherapy regimen are the lack of a well-defined glioma-specific antigen, the heterogeneity of tumor cells in gliomas, and the modulating effect of the glioma itself on the immune system. Unique strategies to overcome these barriers are being developed.

CONCLUSIONS

Novel strategies to generate an anti-glioma immune response through use of dendritic cell vaccination, directed cytokine delivery, gene-based immunotherapy, and reversal of tumor-induced immunosuppression are promising. These strategies carry the potential of overcoming the resistance of gliomas to immunotherapeutic manipulation and, undoubtedly, will become a part of our future therapeutic armamentarium.

Preliminary results of active specific immunization with modified tumor cell vaccine in glioblastoma multiforme

OBJECT

Treatment for glioblastoma multiforme has failed to show any progress for decades. While specific immunization with tumor cells modified with Newcastle-Disease-Virus (NDV) has been reported successful in some extracerebral tumors, its effect on glioblastoma is unknown. We report on 11 patients, in whom this approach was analyzed.

METHODS

A vaccine was produced from autologous tumor cell cultures of 11 patients with glioblastoma. After completed surgery and radiotherapy an intracutaneous vaccination was performed 4 times with a 2 week interval and finally after 3 months. Local reactions, general side effects and survival were monitored closely.

RESULTS

The local reaction of the skin after injection of vaccine increased from 1.67 to 4.05 cm2 in 8 weeks. The skin reaction after parallel injection of inactivated, untreated tumor cells increased from 0.11 to 1.09 cm2. The median survival was 46 weeks (mean 60 weeks). No side effects were noted.

CONCLUSION

Active specific immunization with NDV-modified glioblastoma cells produced a noticeable peripheral immune response. In this preliminary series survival of patients was not significantly longer after active specific immunization than after combined treatment of surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. As there were no side effects, however, active specific immunization may be considered an alternative in the management of glioblastoma.

Progress in active-specific immunotherapy of brain malignancies

Despite the significant advances in neurosurgical techniques and oncology treatment regimens, the prognosis of patients with brain malignancies remains dismal. Brain tumours remain as lethal in the beginning of this new millennium as they were 30 years ago. Among the promising treatment modalities being tested are various immunotherapeutic approaches. Development of cancer vaccines, also known as active-specific immunotherapy, for malignant brain tumours is summarised in this review. Understanding the mechanisms behind vaccinations and the initiation of immune response have helped the design and improvement of the efficacy of clinical vaccines. The emergence of the antigen-presenting properties of dendritic cells brings the cancer vaccine field into a new generation. Preclinical work on the use of dendritic cell-based vaccine for malignant brain tumours are encouraging. The move from these preliminary studies to the clinic is anticipated with high hope.

Unarmed, tumor-specific monoclonal antibody effectively treats brain tumors

The epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) is often amplified and rearranged structurally in tumors of the brain, breast, lung, and ovary. The most common mutation, EGFRvIII, is characterized by an in-frame deletion of 801 base pairs, resulting in the generation of a novel tumor-specific epitope at the fusion junction. A murine homologue of the human EGFRvIII mutation was created, and an IgG2a murine mAb, Y10, was generated that recognizes the human and murine equivalents of this tumor-specific antigen. In vitro, Y10 was found to inhibit DNA synthesis and cellular proliferation and to induce autonomous, complement-mediated, and antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Systemic treatment with i.p. Y10 of s.c. B16 melanomas transfected to express stably the murine EGFRvIII led to long-term survival in all mice treated (n = 20; P < 0.001). Similar therapy with i.p. Y10 failed to increase median survival of mice with EGFRvIII-expressing B16 melanomas in the brain; however, treatment with a single intratumoral injection of Y10 increased median survival by an average 286%, with 26% long-term survivors (n = 117; P < 0.001). The mechanism of action of Y10 in vivo was shown to be independent of complement, granulocytes, natural killer cells, and T lymphocytes through in vivo complement and cell subset depletions. Treatment with Y10 in Fc receptor knockout mice demonstrated the mechanism of Y10 to be Fc receptor-dependent. These data indicate that an unarmed, tumor-specific mAb may be an effective immunotherapy against human tumors and potentially other pathologic processes in the "immunologically privileged" central nervous system.

Glioma immunology and immunotherapy

OBJECTIVE

Despite advances in conventional therapy, the prognosis for most glioma patients remains dismal. This has prompted an intensive search for effective treatment alternatives. Immunotherapy, one such alternative, has long been recognized as a potentially potent cancer treatment but has been limited by an inadequate understanding of the immune system. Now, increased insight into immunology is suggesting more rational approaches to immunotherapy. In this article, we explore key aspects of modern immunology and discuss their implications for glioma therapy.

METHODS

A thorough literature review of glioma immunology and immunotherapy was undertaken to inquire into the basic immunology, central nervous system immunology, glioma immunobiology, standard glioma immunotherapy, and recent immunotherapeutic advances in glioma treatment.

RESULTS

Although gliomas express tumor-associated antigens and appear potentially sensitive to immune responses, many factors work together to inhibit antiglioma immunity. Not surprisingly, most clinical attempts at glioma immunotherapy have met with little success to date. However, novel immunostimulatory strategies, such as immunogene therapy, directed cytokine delivery, and dendritic cell manipulation, have recently yielded dramatic preclinical results in glioma models. This suggests that glioma-derived immunosuppression can be overcome.

CONCLUSION

Modern molecular biology and immunology techniques have yielded a wealth of new data about glioma immunobiology. Armed with this information, many investigators have proposed novel means to stimulate antiglioma immune responses. Although definitive clinical results remain to be seen, the current renaissance in glioma immunology and immunotherapy shows great promise for the future.

Bone marrow-derived dendritic cells pulsed with a tumor-specific peptide elicit effective anti-tumor immunity against intracranial neoplasms

Although the central nervous system (CNS) is often regarded as an immunologically privileged site, it is well established that specific CNS immunoreactivity can be generated through peripheral vaccination with CNS antigens. Dendritic cells (DC) are potent antigen presenting cells of hematopoietic origin that have emerged as a promising tool for cancer immunotherapy capable of evoking significant anti-tumor immunity when pulsed with tumor-associated peptides. To explore a role for DC-based immunization strategies for the treatment of CNS tumors, we developed a brain tumor model using the C3 sarcoma cell line which expresses the tumor-specific, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted peptide epitope E7(49-57). Syngeneic C57Bl/6 mice receiving intravenous (i.v.) injections of bone marrow-derived DCs pulsed with E7 peptide were effectively protected against a subsequent intracerebral challenge with C3 tumor cells. More importantly, this systemic immunization strategy was effective in a therapy model as 67% of animals (10 of 15) with established (day 7) intracerebral C3 tumors treated with 3 weekly injections of E7 peptide-pulsed DCs achieved a long-term survival (>90 days) while no control animals survived beyond day 41. In vivo depletion of CD8+ cells, but not CD4+ or asialo-GM1+ cells, abrogated the efficacy of E7 peptide-pulsed DC therapy of established tumors, indicating a pivotal role of specific CD8+ T-cell responses in mediating the anti-tumor effect. Our findings support the hypothesis that effective CNS anti-tumor immunoreactivity can be generated with DC-based tumor vaccines.

Efficient retrovirus-mediated cytokine-gene transduction of primary-cultured human glioma cells for tumor vaccination therapy

In order to realize a novel vaccination treatment for malignant gliomas using tumor cells genetically modified to express certain cytokines, it is essential to achieve an efficient gene transduction into primary cultured cells. We investigated the feasibility of preparing a glioma vaccine through retrovirus-mediated gene transduction. Glioma cells were cultured primarily from surgically resected tumor tissues of six patients. We obtained more than 1000-fold proliferation of cultures within eight weeks in all six cases. In vitro infection with a recombinant retrovirus GKlacZ carrying an Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase marker gene resulted in over 65% gene transfer to the primary cultured glioma cells. Further enrichment (approximately 90%) of transduced cells was possible by employing repeated infections or using vectors with neo' marker gene. Two cytokine genes, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and interleukin-4, were introduced into glioma cells by sequential transduction with two single-expression GK vectors. The transduced glioma cells produced high levels of both cytokines. We also evaluated simultaneous introduction of two genes with double-expression GK vectors containing internal ribosomal entry site (IRES) or internal promoter (PGK). Although the cells transduced with double-expression vectors secreted both cytokines, the level of the gene product following IRES or PGK was 10 times lower than that of the upstream gene product. The transduced cells retained cytokine secretion in vitro for 14 days after 100 Gy irradiation. Our data indicate the feasibility of retrovirus-mediated preparation of gene-modified tumor vaccines from clinical glioma materials, which could be useful for potentiating antitumor immunity in glioma patients.

Monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) gene transduction: an effective tumor vaccine strategy for non-intracranial tumors

Recently, there has been renewed interest in the concept of tumor vaccines using genetically engineered tumor cells expressing a variety of cytokines to increase their immunogenicity. Human MCP-1 (JE) is a potent chemoattractant and activator of monocytes and T lymphocytes and thus a good candidate gene for a tumor vaccine. We therefore evaluated the efficacy of vaccines consisting of irradiated tumor cells transduced with the murine MCP-1 gene in the syngeneic 9L gliosarcoma brain tumor model. 9L cell lines stably expressing murine MCP-1 (9L-JE) and control cell lines expressing neomycin 3' phosphotransferase (9L-Neo) were generated by infection with a Moloney murine leukemia retroviral vector. Fisher 344 rats were immunized with intradermal injections of 5 x 10(5) or 2 x 10(6) irradiated (5000 cGy) 9L-JE, 9L-Neo, and wild-type 9L (9L-WT) cells. Two weeks later immunized and non-immunized animals were challenged with various doses of intradermal (5 x 10(6)-5 x 10(7) or intracerebral (2 x 10(4)-5 x 10(5) 9L-WT cells. Intradermal tumors grew in all non-immunized animals. No tumors grew in animals immunized with irradiated 9L-JE or 9L-Neo cells and challenged with inocula of fewer than 5 x 10(5) 9L-WT cells. With higher inocula up to 10(7) cells, tumors appeared in all the animals, but subsequently regressed in the immunized animals. Tumors in animals immunized with 9L-JE were always smaller than tumors in the other groups. In addition, only the 9L-JE vaccine protected against tumor inocula of 5 x 10(7) cells. Thus vaccination with MCP-1-expressing cells was able to protect animals against at least a 100-fold larger number of challenge tumor cells than vaccination with control cells. In contrast to studies with intradermal tumors, immunization with 9L-JE and 9L-Neo produced only minimal protection against intracerebral tumors. There was no significant difference between the 9L-JE and 9L-Neo vaccines in intracerebral challenge. This study suggests that tumor vaccines expressing cytokine genes such as MCP-1 can increase the antitumor response. However, the protective effect of these vaccines appears to be largely limited to intradermal tumors rather than intracerebral tumors.

Immunization with mutagen-treated (tum-) cells causes rejection of nonimmunogenic rat glioma isografts

The ethyl-N-nitrosourea-induced rat glioma N32 was treated with the mutagenic compound N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine and the surviving cells cloned by limited dilution. Out of 20 clones tested 8 did not produce tumors subcutaneously even after challenge doses 3 log units above the minimal tumor dose for N32. All of 5 clones grew in a retarded manner intracerebrally but produced tumors in some animals. Preimmunizations with three of the rejected clones (tum-) gave protection against subcutaneous and intracerebral isografts of the unmutated N32. This effect could be enhanced if the cells used for immunizations were pretreated with interferon gamma (IFN gamma) for 48 h. If immunizations were started subsequent to challenge, only immunization with one of two tested tum- clones pretreated with IFN gamma induced significant rejection against intracerebral N32 isografts. Both N32 and its tum- clones were MHC class I positive and MHC class II negative. IFN gamma treatment enhanced the MHC class I expression with 20%-90% on the tum- clones and with 40% on N32. MHC class II expression could be induced on N32 cells after 7 days of IFN gamma treatment but not on any of the tum- clones tested. We conclude that the enhancing effect of IFN gamma treatment on tumor isograft rejection may depend on up-regulation of MHC class I but not of MHC class II. This investigation demonstrates that it is possible to induce rejection of weakly immunogenic intracerebral brain tumors by immunization with selected highly immunogenic tumor cell mutants. In conjunction with relevant cytokines, the cross-protective effect of these tum- variants might be further enhanced and serve as a model for immunotherapy against malignant human brain tumors.

Immunotherapy of glioblastoma with intratumoural administration of autologous lymphocytes and human lymphoblastoid interferon. A further clinical study

A clinical trial of an immunotherapy which consisted of intratumoural injections of autologous lymphocytes with human lymphoblastoid interferon was evaluated in 31 patients with intracranial glioblastoma. Immunotherapy was performed after stereotactic biopsy or surgical resection. The treatment was tolerated well by all patients. Three patients showed positive response to immunotherapy as documented by transient regression or stabilization of the tumour size on computed tomography. Nevertheless, there is no significant difference in the survival time of the patients treated with immunotherapy and those not treated. We conclude that this immunotherapeutic regimen is not beneficial in patients with glioblastoma when used as single treatment after tumoural biopsy or resection.

Hypofractionated radiation therapy and concurrent cisplatin in malignant cerebral gliomas. Rapid palliation in low performance status patients

Twenty-eight patients with high-grade cerebral gliomas (16 biopsy-proven and 12 diagnosed clinically and by computed tomography scan) were treated with altered fraction radiation and concomitant cisplatin (C-DDP). Twenty cases (Groups IA and IB) whose Karnofsky performance status (KPS) was 60% or less received hypofractionation and C-DDP. All these patients had received high-dose Decadron (Merck Sharp & Dohme, West Point, PA), and their conditions were not improving or progressively deteriorating. The first 11 patients (Group IA) received from 600 cGy twice weekly to 3600 cGy over 3 weeks combined with C-DDP IV at 40 mg/M2 every 2 weeks for two courses. The nine subsequent patients (Group IB) received from 600 cGy weekly to 3600 cGy over 5 to 6 weeks with C-DDP IV at 40 mg/M2 every 1 to 2 weeks for four courses. The target volume in all cases was confined to the tumor as defined on computed tomography (CT) scan with a 2 cm to 3 cm margin. The C-DDP at 40 mg/M2 was administered immediately (within 5 minutes after radiation). Eight cases (Group II) with a KPS of more than 60% were treated with hyperfractionation, i.e., from 200 cGy twice daily to 4800 cGy in just under 3 weeks. The C-DDP was administered every 2 weeks for a total of two courses, as for Group IA. In Group I, 15 of 20 (75%) patients experienced rapid improvement in their performance status, which usually becoming evident within 1 to 2 weeks from the initiation of treatment, and progressed over time. Four patients with a KPS of 10% improved their KPS to over 60%. This regimen was both well tolerated and logistically very convenient both for the patients and attending staff. Follow-up CT scans in three of 16 evaluable patients in the hypofractionated group showed complete tumor resolution. Median survival for Group IA was 7 months, for Group IB was 12 months, and overall was eight months. The Group II median survival was 9 months. This experience suggests that hypofractionated radiation in combination with C-DDP may offer rapid palliation with improvement in functional status in severely compromised patients with malignant glioma.

Intratumoral LAK cell and interleukin-2 therapy of human gliomas

Adoptive immunotherapy using lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells and interleukin-2 (IL-2) offers the possibility of a new treatment for patients with malignant glial tumors. In a clinical trial, the effectiveness of a 5-day treatment cycle of direct intratumoral administration of both LAK cells and IL-2 via a reservoir/catheter system in patients with recurrent malignant gliomas was studied. Ten patients were entered into the study, nine of whom were treated with 15 cycles of LAK cells (0.9 to 21.0 x 10(9) cells) and IL-2 (49 to 450 x 10(3) U/kg). The 10th patient in the study was not treated because of the onset of severe neurological deficits prior to beginning immunotherapy. Of the nine patients treated, one had a partial tumor response to immunotherapy as documented by computerized tomography. Neurological side effects occurred in all patients undergoing treatment and were related to increases in cerebral edema that appeared to be mediated by the immunotherapy. This report demonstrates the present limitations of regional adoptive immunotherapy with LAK cells and IL-2 in the treatment of human glial tumors.

Radiation therapy for brain tumors

Results of radiation therapy obtained at the University of California, San Francisco over the last 25 years for various adult types of brain tumors are presented. Included are astrocytomas, ependymomas, pineal and suprasellar tumors, meningiomas, and malignant gliomas. For each tumor type considered, the disease-free survival rate appeared to be improved when subtotal resection was followed by irradiation. The lack of improvement in survival with malignant gliomas has prompted investigation into more aggressive multimodality therapies. These are discussed along with a new program using high-activity iodine 125 sources to deliver high-dose radiotherapy to malignant gliomas. It is possible that this new approach will lead to improved survival rates and be applicable to many tumors within the central nervous system.

Levamisole in the treatment of glioblastoma multiforme

Twenty-five patients with malignant glioma were randomized to receive radiation therapy only or radiation therapy and oral Levamisole. There were no differences in survival between the two groups and therefore no advantage in the use of Levamisole in glioblastoma could be demonstrated.

In vivo immunization against autologous glioblastoma-associated antigens

A glioblastoma patient was immunized in vivo with a mixture of autologous and homologous glioblastoma cells coupled to adjuvant peptide and cord-factor analog. Immune activity of peripheral blood lymphocytes was measured in a short-term 51chromium-release assay against autologous tumor target cells. The patient developed direct cell-mediated cytotoxicity against tumor-associated antigens, which appeared to be T-cell mediated.

Specific adoptive immunotherapy of malignant glioma with long-term cytotoxic T lymphocyte line expanded in T-cell growth factor. Experimental study and future prospects

The purposes of the current study were: (1) to investigate the immunoregulatory effects of T-cell growth factor (TCGF) on the activation and differentiation of syngeneic cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) populations generated against a 20-methylcholanthrene-induced ependymoblastoma, 203-glioma, in C57BL/6 mice; and (2) to determine whether the glioma-specific CTL clone (G-CTLL) could be established by TCGF, and whether the in vivo efficacy of the cloned cells could be rendered more effective in adoptive therapy. It was found that TCGF largely allows the CTL populations to proliferate and thus can activate the depressed cytotoxic activity in tumour-bearing mice. Two lines of G-CTLL were successfully obtained by the limiting dilution technique. The G-CTLL retained a TCGF-dependent proliferative growth and a marked cytotoxic activity with target specificity for over 18 months, characterized by a surface phenotype of Lyt-1-.2.3+, Lyt-2 antibody blocking of cytotoxicity and the production of immune interferon in response to mitogen and tumour antigen. In the Winn assay and the adoptive transfer assay, the therapeutic effects were detected in intracranially inoculated tumours in mice. The in vivo efficacy was dependent on the dose of G-CTLL and on the time of the intravenous administration, although the transfer was inversely ineffective in conditions of increased intracranial pressure. The mechanism responsible for the in vivo effect was probably due to the adoptive immunity and/or the tumour-specific interferon production of G-CTLL.

Comparison of postoperative radiotherapy and combined postoperative radiotherapy and chemotherapy in the multidisciplinary management of malignant gliomas. A joint Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group study

Recently, the RTOG and ECOG concluded a joint randomized study on malignant gliomas that was in progress for the past five years. A total of 626 patients entered this protocol. Sixty-seven percent of the 535 evaluable patients have died and thus this represents a preliminary report of a major joint clinical trial. The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy after neurosurgery of three new treatment options as compared with control treatment of radiotherapy alone. The four options were: (1) control radiation; 6000 rad/6-7 weeks to whole brain; (2) a higher radiation dose; Control dose plus a booster dose of 1000 rad/1-2 weeks to the tumor; (3) control radiation dose plus BCNU (80 mg/m2/day IV X 3 and repeat BCNU every 8 weeks); (4) Control radiation dose plus combination methyl-CCNU (125 mg/m2/day orally X 1 and repeat methyl-CCNU every 8 weeks), and DTIC (150 mg/m2/day IV X 5 and repeat DTIC every 4 weeks). All pertinent patient characteristics were studied and several important prognostic factors have been identified. Notably, age, histologic type (Astrocytoma with anaplastic foci, versus glioblastoma multiforme), initial performance status, time since first symptoms and presence or absence of seizure. At this time, it appeared that there was no treatment option which was significantly better than the control. The study identified that age was the most important prognostic factor. Patients who were younger than age 40 years had an 18-month survival of 64%, patients who were age 40-60 years had an 18-month survival of 20%, and patients who were older than age 60 had an 18-month survival of 8%. The study also demonstrated that a modified histologic classification of anaplastic astrocytoma versus glioblastoma provided better prognostic information than the astrocytoma grading system of Kernohan. Patients with anaplastic astrocytoma had a median survival of 27 months as compared to 8 months for patients with glioblastoma. In further evaluation of any beneficial effect of chemotherapy, it was identified that only among the 40-60-year-old groups, BCNU treated patients appeared to have significantly increased survival than patients in the control groups (P = 0.01, one-sided). Similarly, methyl-CCNU + DTIC was suggestively better than the control (P = 0.08, one-sided). The higher radiation dose, 7000 rad/8-9 weeks appeared to give no significantly better survival over the control dose option. Both BCNU and methyl-CCNU + DTIC produced some toxicity. The combination of methyl-CCNU + DTIC was more toxic than BCNU, producing severe or worse thrombocytopenia in 23% of the patients as compared to 6% on BCNU.

Immunobiology of primary intracranial tumors. Part 7: Active immunization of patients with anaplastic human glioma cells: a pilot study

Twenty patients with malignant gliomas were selected for active immunization within 4 weeks following surgery. Each patient had a Karnofsky Functional Rating equal to or greater than 70, a peripheral blood lymphocyte count equal to or greater than 1000 cells/cu mm, skin test responses to one or more of four recall antigens, peripheral blood T-cells equal to or greater than half that of control, and was not receiving steroid therapy at the time of entry into the study. Each patient received subcutaneous inoculations with one of two human glioma tissue culture cell lines (D-54MG or U-251MG) monthly, with 500 micrograms of bacillus Calmette-Guérin cell wall (BCG-CW) being included with the first inoculation. Each patient also received levamisole, 2.5 mg/kg 3 days per week every other week. Radiotherapy and chemotherapy with BCNU were begun after the first month of immunization. Follow-up evaluations included computerized tomography brain scans, neurological examinations, Karnofsky Functional Ratings, and studies of general immune competence. No evidence of allergic encephalomyelitis was noted clinically, nor was any gross or microscopic evidence of such pathology obtained upon autopsy of three of these patients. Serial studies of general immune competence showed no alterations from those previously described with non-immunized patients. Patients who were inoculated with the U-251MG cell line have had a longer survival time compared to those inoculated with the D-54MG cell line (p less than 0.0590) or compared to 58 historical cases of glioma patients treated with levamisole, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy alone (p less than 0.02).

Immunobiology of primary intracranial tumors. Part 8: Serological responses to active immunization of patients with anaplastic gliomas

Serial serological studies were carried out on 19 of 20 patients with malignant gliomas who were actively immunized with one of two human glioma tissue culture cell lines (D-54MG or U-251MG). Most patients mounted a significant serum reaction to histocompatibility antigens (HLA's), as well as an antibody response to fetal bovine serum (FBS) which was added to the glioma-cell inoculum. These two sources of antibody accounted for greater than 90% of the antibody induced by these inoculations. Two patients continued to have significant amounts of binding antibody to the original immunizing cell line following exhaustive absorptions of FBS and these two had all remaining significant antibody removed by further absorption of the serum against the 2-T osteogenic sarcoma tissue culture cell line known to possess antigens cross-reactive with human gliomas. One single patient continued to show significant antibody binding to the original glioma cell line following absorption against FBS, human platelets, and the 2-T cell line, and therefore seems to have produced glioma-distinctive antibodies in response to immunization. The antibody preparation from this patient was also cytotoxic against the original glioma cell line, as well as another recently cultured human glioblastoma cell line. The significance of these serological studies is discussed as it relates to immunological responses patients with gliomas may make to active immunization.

Mechanisms by which human gliomas may escape cellular immune attack

Whereas substantial evidence indicates that the majority of glioma patients make humoral immune responses to their own tumours, the evidence that glioma patients make significant cellular immune responses is more tenuous and controversial. In order to study those properties of human gliomas that might contribute to their ability to escape cell-mediated immune attack, we have examined the ability of cultured human glioma cells to elicit allogeneic cytolytic lymphocyte responses in vitro. Five of ten glioma lines were unable to elicit allogeneic cytolytic lymphocyte responses in mixed lymphocyte-tumour cultures, despite the presence of serologically detectable alloantigens on the surface of the glioma cells. Analysis of the reasons why certain glioma lines failed to stimulate cytolytic lymphocyte responses revealed three distinct mechanisms by which human gliomas may escape cellular immune attack: 1. a defect in immunogenicity which can be overcome by "help" from an allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction, 2. the secretion of a protective mucopolysaccharide coat, and 3. the production of macromolecular immunosuppressive substance(s). The implications of these findings for the immunotherapy of human gliomas are discussed.

Reoperation for glioblastoma

The results of a second operation for tumor removal in 24 adult patients with supratentorial glioblastoma multiforme or anaplastic astrocytoma were analyzed. The median survival time after reoperation was 14 weeks. Five of the 24 patients lived 6 months or longer after reoperation. Only three of these patients maintained a Karnofsky rating (KR) of at least 60 for 6 months or longer after reoperation. Preoperative neurological status (KR) is the most significant determinant of survival after reoperation (p = 0.02). When the KR is at least 60, median survival after reoperation is 22 weeks. When the KR prior to reoperation is less than 60, median survival is 9 weeks. Only one of 13 patients with a KR of less than 60 prior to reoperation survived longer than 6 months after the second operation. The interval between first and second operation is significantly related to survival (p = 0.03), but when adjustment is made for the KR the interoperative interval is no longer significantly related to survival after the second operation (p = 0.39). Age, sex, and location of tumor were not significantly related to duration of survival. This study suggests that reoperation is most likely to produce the best result when the KR is at least 60 and the interval between operations is longer than 6 months. Using these criteria, one-third of the patients could be expected to survive with a KR of at least 60 for 6 months. The study indicates that reoperation should not be carried out when the KR is less than 60.

Immunological aspects of intrinsic glial tumors

✓ Fundamental concepts of general tumor immunology and modes of immunotherapy are presented. Significant work dealing with the relationship of the immune system to intrinsic glial neoplasms is reviewed in relation to therapeutic applications and future investigative efforts.

Immunobiology of primary intracranial tumors. Part 4: levamisole as an immune stimulant in patients and in the ASV glioma model

Levamisole was evaluated as an immune stimulant in a randomized controlled study of patients with anaplastic gliomas, who had undergone surgical resection and who were also treated with radiotherapy and BCNU chemotherapy. Of 102 patients placed into the study, 85 were determined to comprise the adequately treated group (ATG): a full course of radiotherapy and two cycles of BCNU chemotherapy. Within the ATG, those patients who received levamisole did not demonstrate significantly different serial delayed hypersensitivity reactions, peripheral blood lymphocyte and T-cell counts, or serum IgM levels, compared to those patients not receiving levamisole. There was no significant difference in survival times of the two groups. Studies utilizing the avian sarcoma virus-induced glioma in rats also showed no improvement in survival with levamisole stimulation as the only immune agent, but the combination of active immunization and adjuvant stimulation with bacillus Calmette-Guerin plus levamisole was found to be therapeutically effective in this model and will be used in future pilot studies of active immunization in patients.

Tumoural antigens on experimental and human glioblastoma

The fact that glioblastoma multiforme possesses antigens differing from those of normal brain has been stressed in early papers from Scheimberg, Mahaley, Eggers, and Brooks. In our work the presence of specific cytoplasmic and nuclear antigens in neoplastic cells has been demonstrated. These specific antigens are present not only in experimental tumours from the rat, but also in human glioblastoma, and are easily demonstrated by immunodiffusion and immunofluorescence techniques. From our work differences between intracellular and membrane antigens are clear, as the latter do not react with IgG immunoglobulin. On the other hand, tumoural antigens in glioblastoma have similar antigenic qualities to those of histocompatible antigens in normal brain. Experimental and human glioblastomas have weak antigens, as demonstrated by frequent tumour recurrence following amputation and the positive cross-reaction of antibody with normal brain in experimental models. Glioblastoma multiforme may have a common antigen as its antibodies easily cross-react positively with different human tumours with similar, histological features. As tumoural membranes did not react as cytoplasm and nuclei, we cannot say that membrane antigens resemble those of intracellular contents. The fact that viral-induced tumours may have common antigens should point to aetiological possibilities in this group of tumours. Delayed cellular response is very useful during the follow-up of these patients. Positive DNCB and intradermal reactions could be elicited in those patients in whom the antigenic overload has been reduced as a consequence of a surgical procedure. On the other hand, patients with extensive and infiltrating tumoural masses exhibited weak or negative delayed cellular responses. Humoral responses from the patient's sera may not have the prognostic value of cellular responses.

Glioblastoma multiforme

Glioblastoma multiforme is the most common primary brain tumor of adults, as well as the most malignant. Its etiology is unknown, but the tumor is thought to arise through dedifferentiation of adult astrocytes. It occurs most frequently between the ages of 40 and 60, in men more often than in women (1.5:1). Important early symptoms include subtle personality change, headache, weakness, and intellectual impairment; specific complaints and physical findings depend on the location of the lesion. The initial diagnostic test should be a CT-scan; it will detect more than 90% of malignant astrocytomas. Surgery remains the cornerstone of treatment; patients receiving radical debulking have a median survival of 8 months compared to the 3 month survival of unoperated cases. Modern neurosurgical technique, neuroanesthesia, mannitol, and corticosteroids have reduced the surgical mortality to 3%. Most patients also receive 4500 rads of whole-brain irradiation and 1800 rads to the operative site; radiotherapy increases the median survival of operated patients by 2 to 3 months. An additional small increment in survival time and some improvement in quality of survival can be achieved by nitrosourea chemotherapy; the latter is usually given as 100 mg/m2/day x 3 days of BCNU every eight to ten weeks. Experimental treatments under study include the use of radiosensitizers, the role of immunotherapy and the application of microwave-induced hyperthermia. Two-year survival remains 10% to 20%, and there are virtually no five-year survivors. An optimal combined modality treatment plan, one in which each cellular compartment of this truly multiforme tumor is effectively addressed, remains to be designated.