Comparison of nucleic acid and protein immunization for induction of antibodies specific for HIV-1 gp120

Modulation of HIV-1 immunity by adjuvants

Purpose of review

To summarize the role of adjuvants in eliciting desirable antibody responses against HIV-1 with particular emphasis on both historical context and recent developments.

Recent findings

Increased understanding of the role of pattern recognition receptors such as Toll-like receptors in recruiting and directing the immune system has increased the variety of adjuvant formulations being tested in animal models and humans. Across all vaccine platforms, adjuvant formulations have been shown to enhance desirable immune responses such as higher antibody titers and increased functional activity. Although no vaccine formulation has yet succeeded in eliciting broad neutralizing antibodies against HIV-1, the ability of adjuvants to direct the immune response to immunogens suggests they will be critically important in any successful HIV-1 vaccine.

Summary

The parallel development of adjuvants along with better HIV-1 immunogens will be needed for a successful AIDS vaccine. Additional comparative testing will be required to determine the optimal adjuvant and immunogen regimen that can elicit antibody responses capable of blocking HIV-1 transmission.

DNA/MVA Vaccines for HIV/AIDS

Since the initial proof-of-concept studies examining the ability of antigen-encoded plasmid DNA to serve as an immunogen, DNA vaccines have evolved as a clinically safe and effective platform for priming HIV-specific cellular and humoral responses in heterologous "prime-boost" vaccination regimens. Direct injection of plasmid DNA into the muscle induces T- and B-cell responses against foreign antigens. However, the insufficient magnitude of this response has led to the development of approaches for enhancing the immunogenicity of DNA vaccines. The last two decades have seen significant progress in the DNA-based vaccine platform with optimized plasmid constructs, improved delivery methods, such as electroporation, the use of molecular adjuvants and novel strategies combining DNA with viral vectors and subunit proteins. These innovations are paving the way for the clinical application of DNA-based HIV vaccines. Here, we review preclinical studies on the DNA-prime/modified vaccinia Ankara (MVA)-boost vaccine modality for HIV. There is a great deal of interest in enhancing the immunogenicity of DNA by engineering DNA vaccines to co-express immune modulatory adjuvants. Some of these adjuvants have demonstrated encouraging results in preclinical and clinical studies, and these data will be examined, as well.

FcalphaRI (CD89) alleles determine the proinflammatory potential of serum IgA

The human IgA FcR (FcalphaRI; CD89) mediates a variety of immune system functions including degranulation, endocytosis, phagocytosis, cytokine synthesis, and cytokine release. We have identified a common, nonsynonymous, single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in the coding region of CD89 (844A-->G) (rs16986050), which changes codon 248 from AGC (Ser(248)) to GGC (Gly(248)) in the cytoplasmic domain of the receptor. The two different alleles demonstrate significantly different FcalphaRI-mediated intracellular calcium mobilization and degranulation in rat basophilic leukemia cells and cytokine production (IL-6 and TNF-alpha) in murine macrophage P388D1 cells. In the absence of FcR gamma-chain association in P388D1 cells, the Ser(248)-FcalphaRI allele does not mediate cytokine production, but the Gly(248)-FcalphaRI allele retains the capacity to mediate a robust production of proinflammatory cytokine. This allele-dependent difference is also seen with FcalphaRI-mediated IL-6 cytokine release by human neutrophils ex vivo. These findings and the enrichment of the proinflammatory Gly(248)-FcalphaRI allele in systemic lupus erythematosus populations in two ethnic groups compared with their respective non-systemic lupus erythematosus controls suggest that FcalphaRI (CD89) alpha-chain alleles may affect receptor-mediated signaling and play an important role in the modulation of immune responses in inflammatory diseases.

Vaccines for viral and parasitic diseases produced with baculovirus vectors

The baculovirus-insect cell expression system is an approved system for the production of viral antigens with vaccine potential for humans and animals and has been used for production of subunit vaccines against parasitic diseases as well. Many candidate subunit vaccines have been expressed in this system and immunization commonly led to protective immunity against pathogen challenge. The first vaccines produced in insect cells for animal use are now on the market. This chapter deals with the tailoring of the baculovirus-insect cell expression system for vaccine production in terms of expression levels, integrity and immunogenicity of recombinant proteins, and baculovirus genome stability. Various expression strategies are discussed including chimeric, virus-like particles, baculovirus display of foreign antigens on budded virions or in occlusion bodies, and specialized baculovirus vectors with mammalian promoters that express the antigen in the immunized individual. A historical overview shows the wide variety of viral (glyco)proteins that have successfully been expressed in this system for vaccine purposes. The potential of this expression system for antiparasite vaccines is illustrated. The combination of subunit vaccines and marker tests, both based on antigens expressed in insect cells, provides a powerful tool to combat disease and to monitor infectious agents.

A DNA vaccine coding for the Brucella outer membrane protein 31 confers protection against B. melitensis and B. ovis infection by eliciting a specific cytotoxic response

The development of an effective subunit vaccine against brucellosis is a research area of intense interest. The outer membrane proteins (Omps) of Brucella spp. have been extensively characterized as potential immunogenic and protective antigens. This study was conducted to evaluate the immunogenicity and protective efficacy of the B. melitensis Omp31 gene cloned in the pCI plasmid (pCIOmp31). Immunization of BALB/c mice with pCIOmp31 conferred protection against B. ovis and B. melitensis infection. Mice vaccinated with pCIOmp31 developed a very weak humoral response, and in vitro stimulation of their splenocytes with recombinant Omp31 did not induced the secretion of gamma interferon. Splenocytes from Omp31-vaccinated animals induced a specific cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte activity, which leads to the in vitro lysis of Brucella-infected macrophages. pCIOmp31 immunization elicited mainly CD8(+) T cells, which mediate cytotoxicity via perforins, but also CD4(+) T cells, which mediate lysis via the Fas-FasL pathway. In vivo depletion of T-cell subsets showed that the pCIOmp31-induced protection against Brucella infection is mediated predominantly by CD8(+) T cells, although CD4(+)T cells also contribute. Our results demonstrate that the Omp31 DNA vaccine induces cytotoxic responses that have the potential to contribute to protection against Brucella infection. The protective response could be related to the induction of CD8(+) T cells that eliminate Brucella-infected cells via the perforin pathway.

DNA immunization of mice with a plasmid encoding Neisseria gonorrhea PorB protein by intramuscular injection and epidermal particle bombardment

Immunogenicity of a DNA vaccine encoding PorB from Neisseria gonorrhoeae strain FA1090 was analyzed in BALB/C mice immunized by intramuscular needle injection or epidermal gene gun bombardment. Both delivery routes generated measurable specific antibodies although the gene gun response was slower. Antibody isotypes were indicative of Th2 activation following gene gun immunization and of Th1 activation following intramuscular injection. In both immunization protocols, boosting with either renatured recombinant (rr) PorB protein or PorB expressed from Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus replicon particles (VRPs) significantly increased anti-PorB antibody levels. Boosting with rrPorB protein had little effect on antibody isotypes, while boosting with VRPs expressing PorB-enhanced a Th1 type response. Whole cell binding experiments showed that a portion of the antibodies recognized the surface of the homologous N. gonorrhoeae strain. Serum from groups with high antibody levels showed some opsonization of the homologous strain using human neutrophils. These results showed the potential of DNA vaccination for the purpose of priming an antibody response against PorB of N. gonorrhoeae. When combined with a protein or VRP boost, DNA priming resulted in high-titer and long-lasting responses. Based on different prime-boost protocols, we could polarize immune responses to predominantly Th1 or Th2, which should enable future studies of the types of immune responses that are protective in mouse models of gonorrhea.

Monoclonal antibodies for the structural analysis of the Na+/H+ antiporter NhaA from Escherichia coli

Since their advent some 25 years ago, monoclonal antibodies have developed into powerful tools for structural and functional analysis of their cognate antigens. Together with the respective antigen binding fragments, antibodies offer exclusive capacities in detection, characterization, purification and functional assays for every given ligand. Antibody-fragment mediated crystallization represents a major advance in determining the three-dimensional structure of membrane-bound protein complexes. In this review, we focus on the methods used to generate monoclonal antibodies against the NhaA antiporter from Escherichia coli as a paradigm of secondary transporters. We describe examples on how antibodies are helpful in understanding structure and function relationships for this important class of integral membrane proteins. The generated conformation-specific antibody fragments are highly valuable reagents for co-crystallization attempts and structure determination of the antiporter.

Comparative vaccine studies in HLA-A2.1-transgenic mice reveal a clustered organization of epitopes presented in hepatitis C virus natural infection

A polyepitopic CD8(+)-T-cell response is thought to be critical for control of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection. Using transgenic mice, we analyzed the immunogenicity and dominance of most known HLA-A2.1 epitopes presented during infection by using vaccines that carry the potential to enter clinical trials: peptides, DNA, and recombinant adenoviruses. The vaccines capacity to induce specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes and interferon gamma-producing cells revealed that immunogenic epitopes are clustered in specific antigens. For two key antigens, flanking regions were shown to greatly enhance the scope of epitope recognition, whereas a DNA-adenovirus prime-boost vaccination strategy augmented epitope immunogenicity, even that of subdominant ones. The present study reveals a clustered organization of HCV immunogenic HLA.A2.1 epitopes and strategies to modulate their dominance.

Characteristics of polymeric lambda-IgA binding to leukocytes in IgA nephropathy

IgA nephropathy (IgAN) is characterized by predominant mesangial polymeric IgA1 (pIgA1) deposits, with increased plasma IgA1 levels. Plasma IgA levels are determined by the rate of IgA production, uptake by leukocytes, and removal by hepatocytes. Fc(alpha) receptor 1 (Fc(alpha)R1) is a candidate molecule for the regulation of IgA levels, but reports of its expression in leukocytes in IgAN are conflicting. Increased binding of endogenous IgA to circulating granulocytes and monocytes in IgAN was demonstrated in this study. Fc(alpha)R1 expression on leukocytes was increased, independently of plasma IgA levels. Fc(alpha)R1 was not saturated in leukocytes, because of internalization of IgA after uptake. Further binding of exogenous IgA isolated from individual subjects was observed with leukocytes from the same subjects. Compared with cells from control subjects, granulocytes but not monocytes from patients with IgAN exhibited a greater binding capacity for exogenous IgA, predominantly pIgA. To circumvent the possibility that endogenous IgA might alter Fc(alpha)R1 expression, granulocytes or monocytes derived from the HL-60 or U937 cell lines were used to explore the nature of IgA binding. A higher affinity for pIgA was demonstrated. Inhibition studies using unlabeled IgA, other serum proteins, or a specific Fc(alpha)R1-blocking antibody suggested binding mechanisms other than Fc(alpha)R1 for pIgA uptake by leukocytes. This study also suggested the migration and/or sequestration of "activated" leukocytes with predominant lambda-IgA in the mononuclear phagocytic system or inflammatory tissues, after the initial binding of lambda-pIgA. These immunologic abnormalities might contribute to the glomerulointerstitial injury in IgAN, in the presence of leukocytic infiltration.

A DNA vaccine encoding lumazine synthase from Brucella abortus induces protective immunity in BALB/c mice

This study was conducted to evaluate the immunogenicity of the Brucella abortus lumazine synthase (BLS) gene cloned into the pcDNA3 plasmid, which is driven by the cytomegalovirus promoter. Injection of plasmid DNA carrying the BLS gene (pcDNA-BLS) into BALB/c mice elicited both humoral and cellular immune responses. Antibodies to the encoded BLS included immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) IgG2a, IgG2b, IgG3, and IgM isotypes. Animals injected with pcDNA-BLS exhibited a dominance of IgG2a over IgG1. In addition, spleen cells from vaccinated animals produced interleukin-2 and gamma interferon but not IL-10 or IL-4 after in vitro stimulation with recombinant BLS (rBLS), suggesting the induction of a Th1 response. Protection was evaluated by comparing the levels of infection in the spleens of vaccinated mice challenged with B. abortus 544. Immunization with pcDNA-BLS- reduced the bacterial burden relative to those in the control groups. Mice immunized with rBLS produced a significant humoral response but did not show a specific cellular response or any protection from challenge. Altogether, these data suggest that pcDNA-BLS is a good immunogen for the production of humoral and cell-mediated responses in mice and is a candidate for use in future studies of vaccination against brucellosis.

Immunogenicity of the Brucella melitensis recombinant ribosome recycling factor-homologous protein and its cDNA

A study was conducted to evaluate the immunogenicity of the Brucella melitensis ribosome recycling factor (RRF)-homologous protein (CP24). The CP24 gene was cloned, expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. The resulting purified recombinant protein (rCP24) produced delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions in B. melitensis-infected mice but not in naive controls. Thus, we decided to characterise the immune responses generated with DNA vaccination (pcDNACP24) or immunisation with the rCP24 in adjuvant. Animals injected with pcDNACP24 exhibited a dominance of IgG2a to IgG1 while mice injected with rCP24 developed a higher response of IgG1 than IgG2a. Both immunisation protocols were capable of eliciting CP24-specific gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) producing cells. Spleen cells from pcDNACP24-immunised mice did not produce interleukin (IL)-4, IL-10 or up-regulation of IL-2 mRNA. Cells from rCP24-immunised mice produced IL-10, up-regulated IL-2 mRNA but did not produce IL-4. Neither immunisation with purified CP24 nor injection of pcDNACP24 protected mice against challenge with live smooth B. melitensis. However, the potential of CP24 for a Brucella diagnostic test based on an in vitro antigen (Ag)-specific IFN-gamma production or DTH test would be worth testing.

The interaction of Fc alpha RI with IgA and its implications for ligand binding by immunoreceptors of the leukocyte receptor cluster

This study defines the molecular basis of the FcalphaRI (CD89):IgA interaction, which is distinct from that of the other leukocyte Fc receptors and their Ig ligands. A comprehensive analysis using both cell-free (biosensor) and cell-based assays was used to define and characterize the IgA binding region of FcalphaRI. Biosensor analysis of mutant FcalphaRI proteins showed that residues Y35, Y81, and R82 were essential for IgA binding, and R52 also contributed. The role of the essential residues (Y35 and R82) was confirmed by analysis of mutant receptors expressed on the surface of mammalian cells. These receptors failed to bind IgA, but were detected by the mAb MY43, which blocks IgA binding to FcalphaRI, indicating that its epitope does not coincide with these IgA binding residues. A homology model of the ectodomains of FcalphaRI was generated based on the structures of killer Ig-like receptors, which share 30-34% identity with FcalphaRI. Key structural features of killer Ig-like receptors are appropriately reproduced in the model, including the structural conservation of the interdomain linker and hydrophobic core (residues V17, V97, and W183). In this FcalphaRI model the residues forming the IgA binding site identified by mutagenesis form a single face near the N-terminus of the receptor, distinct from other leukocyte Fc receptors where ligand binding is in the second domain. This taken together with major differences in kinetics and affinity for IgA:FcalphaRI interaction that were observed depending on whether FcalphaRI was immobilized or in solution suggest a mode of interaction unique among the leukocyte receptors.

DNA vaccines: immunology, application, and optimization*

The development and widespread use of vaccines against infectious agents have been a great triumph of medical science. One reason for the success of currently available vaccines is that they are capable of inducing long-lived antibody responses, which are the principal agents of immune protection against most viruses and bacteria. Despite these successes, vaccination against intracellular organisms that require cell-mediated immunity, such as the agents of tuberculosis, malaria, leishmaniasis, and human immunodeficiency virus infection, are either not available or not uniformly effective. Owing to the substantial morbidity and mortality associated with these diseases worldwide, an understanding of the mechanisms involved in generating long-lived cellular immune responses has tremendous practical importance. For these reasons, a new form of vaccination, using DNA that contains the gene for the antigen of interest, is under intensive investigation, because it can engender both humoral and cellular immune responses. This review focuses on the mechanisms by which DNA vaccines elicit immune responses. In addition, a list of potential applications in a variety of preclinical models is provided.

DNA vaccination favours memory rather than effector B cell responses

Following priming and boosting of mice with a DNA vector pEE6DeltaS-hCGss expressing sequences encoding a transmembrane version of the beta-chain of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCGbeta), we failed to detect appreciable levels of specific antibody. However, subsequent challenge with hCG protein in Ribi adjuvant elicited a strong and rapid secondary immune response. This response was of comparable magnitude to that produced following priming, boosting and challenge with protein in adjuvant. Thus, DNA vaccination with this vector is as efficient in generating B cell memory as is conventional immunization, but the memory generation occurs in the absence of an overt effector response. Despite an overall similar level of specific antibody, the DNA-vaccinated mice produced hCG-specific antibodies biased towards IgG2a and IgG2b isotypes, whereas the protein-vaccinated mice produced higher levels of IgG1 antibodies. Both Th1 and Th2 cytokines (interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and IL-4) were lower in the spleens of the DNA-immunized animals compared with the protein-Ribi-immunized animals, possibly suggesting a different level of helper T cell response to the two different modes of immunization.

The effect of low-profile serine substitutions in the V3 loop of HIV-1 gp120 IIIB/LAI on the immunogenicity of the envelope protein

Many microbial antigens contain powerful hypervariable epitopes that fail to induce broadly protective immunity because they dominate the immune response at the expense of more conserved but weaker epitopes. If the undesired B cell epitopes are eliminated, the immune system could be focused on the conserved epitopes and produce a stronger antibody response to conserved parts of the protein and thus become a more efficacious immunogen for a vaccine. We examined this possibility using the human immunodeficiency virus envelope glycoprotein (gp)120 IIIB/LAI and selectively replaced the amino acids from the V3 region and analyzed the overall immunogenicity of the mutant proteins after nucleic acid immunization in mice. The most variable residues of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp120 V3 loop sequence were replaced with serine, which has a small uncharged hydrophilic side chain and therefore is likely to be less immunogenic than amino acids found in wildtype V3 sequences. The serine substitutions did not affect the ability of soluble CD4 to bind the mutant molecules compared with wildtype gp120 and monoclonal antibodies against both linear and discontinuous epitopes located in the V1/V2, C1, and C4 regions of the molecule. These data suggest that the V3 loop substitutions did not grossly affect the overall conformation of the envelope molecule. Immunization of CBA x BALB/c F1 mice with DNA expression plasmids for the wild-type gp120 sequence induced a predominantly IgGI antibody response with end point titers of 10(4)-5 x 10(4). The antibodies reacted only with conformationally intact gp120. Serine replacements targeted to both sides of the V3 loop had a major impact on gp120 immunogenicity, with a markedly reduced response in the majority of animals tested. Analysis of the epitope specificity of the responses suggests that N-terminal amino acids in the V3 loop contribute to the major immunodominant epitope and provides no evidence that their removal enhances immunogenicity of the conserved regions.

Development and application of PROVAX adjuvant formulation for subunit cancer vaccines

A major challenge facing the development of subunit vaccines comprised of well-defined recombinant antigens is their weak immunogenicity and inability to induce effective cytotoxic T cell (CTL) responses. Adjuvants aimed at increasing the immunogenicity of recombinant antigens remain a focus in vaccine development. The potency of an adjuvant is linked to specific stimulation of T cell responses, involving TH1 and TH2 subsets of CD4(+) T helper cells and CD8(+) CTL and B cell-mediated antibody responses. As a result of the existence of two distinct intra-cellular pathways for antigen processing, immunization with exogenous antigens often shows a greater propensity for T helper and antibody responses, but not CD8(+) CTL responses. However, existing experimental evidence suggests that CD8(+) CTLs, which are critical in the elimination of viral-infected and neoplastic cells, can be elicited with soluble antigens when delivered in appropriate formulations or adjuvants. This review focuses on the properties of PROVAX adjuvant in inducing antigen-specific CTL responses, antibody responses and tumor regression in experimental models and its potential application for the development of recombinant cancer vaccines.

Modulation of immune responses to hepatitis C virus envelope E2 protein following injection of plasmid DNA using single or combined delivery routes

Different delivery routes of plasmid DNA may result in the induction of differential humoral and cellular immunity. We have studied the influence of two main routes of plasmid injection, performed intramuscularly and intraepidermally using a gene gun, for the induction of immune responses specific to hepatitis C virus (HCV) envelope protein E2. Three plasmids expressing different immunogenic domains of E2 (amino acids [aa] 384443, aa 504-555, and aa 384-746) were injected into BALB/c mice according to five different protocols using various combinations of intramuscular (i.m.) or intraepidermal (i.e.) primary and booster injections. Seroconversion rates, antibody titers and isotypes, epitope recognition, and T-helper (Th) release cytokine profiles were analyzed. Antibody titers and epitope recognition were linked to either or both the nature of the immunogen expressed and the delivery route chosen. In all cases, the lowest antibody titers were obtained using single i.m.-based protocols. Independently of the antibody titers generated, only some specific i.e.-combined delivery routes induced antibodies able to recognize determinants located in the N-terminal of E2 (aa 384411 and aa 411437) and mimicked by synthetic peptides. By contrast, the antibody isotypes and the splenic cytokine production identified were independent of the plasmids used and the delivery route implemented. All conditions resulted in Th-1 like responses suggested by the exclusive detection of IgG2a and 2b antibodies and the production of interferon gamma (INF-gamma) but no interleukin-4 (IL-4). Overall, our results suggest that the combination of i.m. and i.e. delivery routes provides the most efficient way to induce a broad immune response against HCV-E2.

Immunoglobulin G subclass responses in mice immunized with plasmid DNA encoding the CFA/I fimbria of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli

Balb/c mice immunized either with a plasmid vector (pRECFA), encoding the CFA/I fimbrial adhesin of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC), or purified CFA/I fimbriae induced similar antibody responses in regard to the kinetics of serum total immunoglobulins and IgG. Nonetheless, the IgG subclass responses in mice vaccinated with DNA were composed predominantly by IgG2a (ranging from 39 to 74% of the total anti-CFA/I IgG) and, to a lesser extent, by IgG (ranging from 15 to 24% of the total anti-CFA/I IgG) during a 12 week observation period. On the other hand, mice immunized with purified CFA/I presented mainly an IgG1 antibody response (ranging from 39 to 67% of the total anti-CFA/I IgG). These results indicated that, irrespective of the immunogenic properties and-or origin of the encoded antigen, immunization with pRECFA elicited an specific IgG subclass response which may affect the ability of DNA vaccines to induce a protective immune response against CFA/I mediated colonization of ETEC bacterial cells.