Cyclosporine inhibition of leukocyte calcineurin is much less in whole blood than in culture medium

Effects of cyclosporine and dexamethasone on canine T cell expression of interleukin-2 and interferon-gamma

Cyclosporine and glucocorticoids are powerful immunosuppressive agents used to treat many inflammatory diseases in dogs. Cyclosporine inhibits calcineurin-dependent pathways of T cell activation and resultant T cell cytokine production, and glucocorticoids directly inhibit genes coding for cytokines. Little work has been done comparing the effects of these agents on T cell cytokine production in dogs. Our study measured T cell interleukin-2 (IL-2) and interferon-gamma (IFN-γ) production using flow cytometry and T cell IL-2 and IFN-γ gene expression using quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) in activated canine T cells incubated with cyclosporine and dexamethasone in vitro. For flow cytometric assays, diluted whole blood was cultured for 7 h in the presence of cyclosporine (10, 100, 500, and 1000 ng/mL) or dexamethasone (10 ng/mL, 100 ng/mL, 1 μg/mL, and 10 μg/mL). For qRT-PCR, whole blood was cultured for 5 h with the same drugs at the same concentrations, and RNA was then extracted from leukocytes. Flow cytometry and qRT-PCR both demonstrated inhibition of IL-2 and IFN-γ that was concentration-dependent in response to cyclosporine, and was more variable for dexamethasone. Quantitative RT-PCR but not flow cytometry documented significant reduction of IL-2 expression after dexamethasone treatment, while both methods showed concentration-dependent suppression of IFN-γ. Quantitative RT-PCR also revealed additional cytokine suppression at higher cyclosporine concentrations, an effect not found using flow cytometry, and may therefore be the preferred method for cytokine determination in dogs. Suppression of IL-2 and IFN-γ in activated T cells may have potential as an indicator of the efficacy of cyclosporine and glucocorticoids in suppressing canine T cell function in vivo, and may therefore be of value for characterizing the immunosuppression induced by these drugs in clinical patients.

Post-transplant dyslipidemia: Mechanisms, diagnosis and management

Post-transplant dyslipidemia is highly prevalent and presents unique management challenges to the clinician. The two major outcomes to consider with post-transplant therapies for dyslipidemia are preserving or improving allograft function, and reducing cardiovascular risk. Although there are other cardiovascular risk factors such as graft dysfunction, hypertension, and diabetes, attention to dyslipidemia is warranted because interventions for dyslipidemia have an impact on reducing cardiac events in clinical trials specific to the transplant population. Dyslipidemia is not synonymous with hyperlipidemia. Numerous mechanisms exist for the occurrence of post-transplant dyslipidemia, including those mediated by immunosuppressive drug therapy. Statin therapy has received the most attention in all solid organ transplant recipient populations, although the effect of proper dietary advice and adjuvant pharmacological and non-pharmacological agents should not be dismissed. At all stages of treatment appropriate monitoring strategies for side effects should be implemented so that the benefits from these therapies can be achieved. Clinicians have a choice when there is a conflict between various transplant society and lipid society guidelines for therapy and targets.

Toward managing chronic rejection after lung transplant: the fate and effects of inhaled cyclosporine in a complex environment

The fate and effects of inhaled cyclosporine A (CsA) are considered after deposition on the lung surface. Special emphasis is given to a post-lung transplant environment and to the potential effects of the drug on the various cell types it is expected to encounter. The known stability, metabolism, pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of the drug have been reviewed and discussed in the context of the lung microenvironment. Arguments support the contention that the immuno-inhibitory and anti-inflammatory effects of CsA are not restricted to T-cells. It is likely that pharmacologically effective concentrations of CsA can be sustained in the lungs but due to the complexity of uptake and action, the elucidation of effective posology must ultimately rely on clinical evidence.

Pharmacodynamic monitoring of calcineurin inhibition therapy: principles, performance, and perspectives

The calcineurin inhibitors (CNIs) cyclosporin A and tacrolimus are immunosuppressive drugs used extensively in allograft recipients. These drugs show large interindividual pharmacokinetic variation and are associated with severe adverse affects, including nephrotoxicity and cardiovascular disease. In current practice, CNIs are combined with other immunosuppressive drugs such as steroids and mycophenolate mofetil. Dosage is titrated based on blood concentration measurement. For further optimization of calcineurin (CN) inhibition therapy, new monitoring strategies are required. Pharmacodynamic-monitoring strategies constitute novel approaches for optimization of CNIs therapy. This review focuses on the general aspects of immunosuppressive drug pharmacodynamic monitoring and describes the methodologies used for monitoring CN inhibition therapy. Two different types of pharmacodynamic-monitoring strategies can be distinguished: (1) enzymatic strategies, which monitor inhibition of drug-target enzyme activity, and (2) immunologic strategies, which measure cellular responsiveness after in vitro simulated immunologic responses. Enzymatic tests are drug type-specific markers in which CN activity is directly determined. Immunologic strategies measure immune responsiveness at several levels, such as mRNA transcripts (intracellular) concentrations/excretion of cytokines, expression of surface activation markers, and cell proliferation. This review also discusses analytical issues and clinical experience with these techniques. The call for new methodologies to evaluate immunosuppressive therapy has led to the development of a large variety of pharmacodynamic-monitoring strategies. The first reports of their clinical relevance are available, but further understanding of the analytical and clinical variables involved are required for the development of accurate, reproducible, and clinically relevant markers.

Calcineurin activity and inhibition in skin and (epi)dermal cell cultures

Calcineurin (Cn) is the target of the immunosuppressive drugs cyclosporine A (CsA), tacrolimus (Trl), and pimecrolimus (Prl). Trl and Prl are often used topically for treatment of various skin diseases. The Cn inhibitors CsA and Trl are mostly used for maintenance therapy of transplant patients. Their long-term use, however, causes a dramatic increase in skin cancer risk. By using a newly developed assay for Cn measurement in blood, we were able to demonstrate Cn activity in total skin homogenates. A significantly higher activity was found in epidermis compared to dermis. In skin cell cultures, fibroblasts showed the highest activity as compared to keratinocytes and melanocytes. Of the Cn inhibitors, Trl showed stronger inhibition than CsA and Prl (57 and 55% in fibroblast and keratinocyte cultures, respectively). Also, the lowest IC(50) (the half maximal inhibitory concentration) values were found for Trl (0.5 and 1.3 nM in two different fibroblast cultures). Cn activity and its inhibition can thus be studied in dermatological samples. The effects of Cn inhibition in fibroblasts and keratinocytes may be of influence on the overall functioning of the skin immune system.

Low-Dose Cyclosporine with Mycophenolate Mofetil Induces Similar Calcineurin Activity and Cytokine Inhibition as does Standard-Dose Cyclosporine in Stable Renal Allografts

One strategy to minimize nephrotoxicity in maintenance immunosuppression in renal transplantation is reduction of cyclosporine (CsA) with addition of mycophenolate mofetil (MMF). This approach seems safe, but concern exists about whether it yields adequate immunosuppression in the long term. Thus, we investigated the pharmacodynamic response to CsA in stable renal allografts treated with standard CsA (n = 17, CsA-C0h > or = 125 ng/mL) and low CsA plus MMF (n = 18 CsA-C0h <100 ng/mL). Patients treated with MMF without CsA (n = 13) and healthy subjects (n = 7) were used as controls. We observed that inhibition of calcineurin (CN) activity in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), as well as interleukin (IL)-2 and interferon (IFN)-gamma production were similar in Standard-CsA and Low-CsA+MMF groups. Moreover, addition of MMF to a low CsA dose regime improved the correlation between CsA-C2h and both CN activity and IL-2 production. Thus, our results suggest that MMF could be synergistic with the pharmacodynamic effect of low CsA in maintenance immunosuppression.

Monitoring of NFAT-regulated gene expression in the peripheral blood of allograft recipients: a novel perspective toward individually optimized drug doses of cyclosporine A

BACKGROUND

With the introduction of cyclosporine A (CsA), long-term allograft function has significantly improved. Problems related to limited therapeutic margins and CsA toxicity remain unsolved. Until now there have been no reliable, practical markers to measure the biologic activity of CsA in vivo.

METHODS

Expression of NFAT (nuclear factor of activated T cells)-regulated genes (interleukin 2, interferon-gamma, and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor) in phorbol myristate acetate/ionomycin-stimulated peripheral blood from healthy volunteers (n=34) and from stable renal (n=25), cardiac (n=26), and liver (n=14) transplant recipients receiving CsA therapy was measured by quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction before and 2 hr after drug intake. Gene expression and CsA plasma levels were correlated.

RESULTS

Two hours after oral CsA ingestion, the mean suppression of induced interleukin 2, interferon-gamma, and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor gene expression was 85%. The individual decline of NFAT-regulated gene expression and the total drug exposure at this time point were closely related. Six hours after oral CsA uptake, gene expression levels reached predose values and subsequently increased further in some patients (rebound effect).

CONCLUSION

Quantitative measurement of the inhibition of NFAT-regulated gene expression 2 hr after CsA intake represents a novel approach to assess the biologic effectiveness of CsA therapy and has the potential to enable individualized immunosuppressive regimens.

Whole-blood cultures from renal-transplant patients stimulated ex vivo show that the effects of cyclosporine on lymphocyte proliferation are related to P-glycoprotein expression

BACKGROUND

Cyclosporine (CsA) is a substrate for the MDR-1 gene product P-glycoprotein (P-gp). CsA efficacy may be modulated by lymphocyte P-gp expression levels. In this study, CsA inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation in whole-blood cultures ex vivo has been related to (1) lymphocyte P-gp expression and (2) the C3435T polymorphism in the MDR-1 gene, which has been reported to alter P-gp function.

METHODS

In 30 renal-transplant recipients taking CsA monotherapy, P-gp expression was measured by flow cytometry. Whole-blood samples were stimulated with purified protein derivative (PPD) and phytohemagglutinin (PHA). CsA resistance ex vivo was defined as less than 10% reduction in proliferation with either PPD or PHA at 2 hours compared with 0 hours.

RESULTS

CsA resistance was associated with greater P-gp expression using either PPD (median expression, resistant 1.89 vs. sensitive 0.96, P =0.02) or PHA (1.66 vs. 0.96, respectively, P =0.02). Whole-blood CsA levels in resistant and sensitive patients were similar. The C3435T polymorphism did not affect inhibition of proliferation by CsA (P >0.05 for all between genotype group comparisons).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that lymphocyte P-gp expression determines the degree of inhibition of proliferation by CsA ex vivo; whether this also affects CsA effectiveness in vivo and therefore graft survival requires further study.

Conversion from cyclosporine A to tacrolimus in pediatric kidney transplant recipients with chronic rejection: Changes in the immune responses

BACKGROUND

Tacrolimus (Tac) has immunosuppressant properties similar to those of cyclosporine A (CsA), but it is more potent. At present, however, its immunosuppressive activity in renal transplant recipients with ongoing chronic rejection has not been clarified.

METHODS

We studied changes in kidney function, mixed lymphocyte culture, cell-mediated lympholysis, cytotoxic antibodies, lymphocyte population, and cytokine response before and after the conversion from CsA to Tac in 14 pediatric renal transplant recipients with chronic rejection. CsA (5.9+/-0.2 mg/kg/d) was replaced by Tac (0.1+/-0.004 mg/kg/d).

RESULTS

Serum creatinine decreased (2.3+/-0.2-1.9+/-0.2 mg/dL, P <0.005), creatinine clearance increased (36.8+/-2.5-46.1+/-4.4 mL/min/1.73 m, P <0.005), and urinary protein excretion decreased (0.4+/-0.01-0.2+/-0.04 g/24 hr, P <0.03) after 6 months, and these values were maintained after 2 years with Tac treatment. During Tac therapy, anti-donor and anti-control mixed lymphocyte culture decreased 38% and 31% (P <0.05), respectively. Cell-mediated lympholysis did not change. CD3 decreased from 87%+/-2% to 80%+/-2% (P <0.005), and CD8 decreased from 34%+/-3% to 27%+/-2% (P <0.005). The switch to Tac decreased the interferon-gamma production in vitro (P <0.05) and increased tumor necrosis factor-alpha levels (P <0.05). The release of interleukin-10 was strikingly augmented with CsA or Tac therapy (P <0.01), but transforming growth factor-beta secretion was similar.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data indicate that conversion from CsA to Tac therapy leads to an improvement in renal function without altering key elements of the immunosuppression in children with ongoing chronic rejection.

Mycophenolic acid is a potent inhibitor of the expression of tumour necrosis factor- and tumour necrosis factor-receptor superfamily costimulatory molecules

The tumour necrosis factor (TNF) ligands CD154, CD70 and TNF receptors CD134 and CD137 are all involved in allograft rejection. Because these molecules are not present on resting T cells, we investigated whether immunosuppressive drugs could inhibit their induction. Expression was induced in vitro on T cells by phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate and ionomycin or by allogeneic dendritic cells in the presence or absence of cyclosporin A (CsA), tacrolimus (TAC), rapamycin derivative (SDZ RAD), or mycophenolic acid (MPA), and determined by flow cytometry. To study the effect of in vivo exposure to immunosuppressive drugs on these molecules, immunohistochemistry was performed on human lymph nodes from patients treated with TAC or TAC and MMF. The calcineurin inhibitors (CI) CsA and TAC strongly suppressed the induction of CD70, CD137 and CD154, but not of CD134, upon pharmacological stimulation of T cells in vitro. In allogeneic stimulations only CD137 and CD154 were inhibited by CI. SDZ RAD did not inhibit pharmacological induction, but in allogeneic stimulations all the investigated molecules were partially suppressed. Both in pharmacological and in allogeneic stimulations, MPA inhibited induction of all tested molecules on T cells nearly completely at 4 micro g/ml. However, in lymph nodes obtained from patients chronically treated with MMF and TAC no reduction of the expression of these molecules was observed. This was possibly caused by trough levels which were in vivo lower (mean: 2.3 micro g/ml) than the concentration giving complete inhibition in vitro. In conclusion, in contrast to CsA, TAC and SDZ RAD, MPA is a potent inhibitor of the induction of TNF- and TNF-receptor superfamily molecules on T cells. To obtain long-term suppression of these molecules in vivo, a plasma trough level of 4 micro g/ml is indicated.

Individual variability in cyclosporin A sensitivity: the assessment of functional measures on CD28-mediated costimulation of human whole blood T lymphocytes

The quantitative analysis of cyclosporin A (CsA) effects might be helpful for optimizing immunosuppressive treatment after allogeneic organ transplantation in individual patients, as rejection can occur despite the existence of CsA blood levels within therapeutic ranges. Previous investigations found that costimulation of the CD28 pathway generally mediates CsA-resistant proliferation of T cell receptor (TCR)-activated T lymphocytes. However, here we describe considerable interindividual variation regarding the immunosuppressive effects of CsA (1000 microg/L) on anti-CD3/CD28 T cell costimulation in a human whole blood assay. In the in vitro study, we found a significant reduction of T cell proliferation, activation marker expression (CD25, CD69) on the T cell surface, and interleukin-2 (IL-2) protein expression in whole blood samples of all healthy subjects (n = 11). However, the investigation of cytokine mRNA profiles revealed variable results of in vitro CsA sensitivity. Whole blood samples of 3 of 11 healthy individuals demonstrated a marked suppression of IL-2 mRNA expression (>50%) and a partial inhibition of IL-4, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) mRNA expression on addition of CsA. In contrast, the remaining 8 healthy individuals had cytokine mRNA expression levels that were unaffected or even increased when CsA was administered in vitro. In patients undergoing CsA monotherapy (ex vivo study, n = 9), we found a significant suppression of IL-2 mRNA levels in 4 of 9 patients ex vivo. Thus, we cannot confirm a universal CsA resistance of T cells on anti-CD3/CD28 costimulation. Instead, our results suggest an individual degree of CsA sensitivity that might be more consistent with clinical experience. Prospective studies are necessary to determine if individual degrees of CsA sensitivity correlate with clinical events and are associated with a low or high risk of transplant rejection.

Cytokine gene expression by alloactivated cells in SCID mice

OBJECTIVES

The severe combined immune deficient (SCID) mouse provides a neutral environment to study human immune responses. We therefore tested human gene expression of Interleukin (IL) 2, 4 and 10, interferon gamma (IFNgamma); transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGFbeta1); and CD40 ligand (CD40L) in splenic extracts of SCID mice after engraftment of PBLs from two persons (direct MLR) or one person plus allopeptides (indirect MLR) in the presence or absence of cyclosporin A (CsA) or FK506.

METHODS

Cytokine gene expression was detected by RT and quantitative (for IFN-gamma, TGFbeta1 and CD40L) PCR. All cells, allopeptides, CsA (25 mg/kg/day for 7 days) or FK 506 (0.5 mg/kg/day for 7 days) were administered intraperitoneally (IP).

RESULTS

In both direct and indirect MLR the numbers of SCID mice expressing the human cytokine genes varied between 33% for IL4 and 100% for IL10, IFN-gamma, TGFbeta1, and CD40L. There was significant interpersonal variation in levels of gene expression. Concomitant CsA or FK506 administration for 7 days did not abrogate early or late (1 week after discontinuation of CsA or FK506) cytokine gene expression in either the direct or indirect MLR, but paradoxically enhanced levels of IFN-gamma, TGFbeta1 and CD40L gene expression in some experiments.

CONCLUSIONS

The results explain late rejection after rapid calcineurin inhibitor withdrawal or reduction, and illustrate the potential use of SCID mice as a surrogate model to study graft outcome by determination levels of gene expression and sensitivity to immunosuppressive agents in the in vivo alloresponse.

CD154 is expressed during treatment with calcineurin inhibitors after organ transplantation

BACKGROUND

CD154 (CD40 ligand) monoclonal antibody prevents allograft rejection in rodents and monkeys. Inasmuch as calcineurin inhibitors (CI) inhibit CD154 expression by pharmacologic agents in vitro, we investigated whether CD154 is also inhibited by CI in vivo and in vitro during allogeneic stimulation.

METHODS

CD154 expression was determined by immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry in human lymph nodes and spleen sections from rhesus monkeys with or without CI treatment. The effect of CI on induction of CD154 expression was studied by stimulating lymphocytes with phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) and ionomycin or with allogeneic monocyte-derived mature dendritic cells.

RESULTS

Lymph nodes from patients with or without CI cyclosporine (CsA) or FK506 (FK) treatment showed comparable CD154 expression, which was present on the cell surface of T cells. CD154-expressing cells were also present in spleens from monkeys treated with CsA in comparable numbers to those in the nontreated group. Moreover, in several liver transplant rejection biopsies taken during CI therapy CD154-expressing cells were observed. In vitro, CsA and FK strongly inhibited induction of CD154 expression on peripheral blood mononuclear cells by pharmacologic stimuli. Maximum inhibition was found at 50 ng/ml CsA and 20 ng/ml FK. CD154 expression induced by dendritic cells in peripheral blood mononuclear cells or spleen cells was also almost completely inhibited by CsA.

CONCLUSION

Although CI strongly suppressed pharmacologic and allogeneic induction of CD154 expression on T cells in vitro at concentrations at approximately clinical trough levels, CD154 is prominently expressed during CI therapy in lymphoid tissue and (sporadically) in liver allografts. This suggests that the CD154-CD40 pathway remains functional during CI therapy, which may contribute to allograft rejections in the clinical setting.

Tissue distribution of calcineurin and its sensitivity to inhibition by cyclosporine

The immunosuppressive activity of cyclosporine is mediated by inhibiting calcineurin phosphatase. However, calcineurin is widely distributed in other tissues. We examined the degree of calcineurin inhibition by cyclosporine in various tissues. In vitro, the cyclosporine concentration inhibiting 50% (IC50) of calcineurin was to approximately 10 ng/mL in human and mouse leukocytes suspensions. In vitro and in vivo IC50s of cyclosporine in homogenates of mouse kidney, heart, liver, testis, and spleen were also comparable (9-48 ng/mL). The maximum calcineurin inhibition by cyclosporine varied, from 83 to 95% of calcineurin activity in spleen, kidney, liver, and testis to 60% in heart and only 10% in brain. Maximum calcineurin inhibition was increased by the addition of cyclophilin A, indicating that cyclophilin concentrations were limiting in some tissues, at least in this assay. Western analysis of mouse tissues showed significantly less cyclophilin in heart than other tissues. cyclosporine concentrations per weight of tissue protein were highest in kidney and liver and lowest in brain and testis after oral dosing, with intermediate levels in spleen, heart, and whole blood. Thus each cyclosporine dose produces rapid and wide-spread inhibition of calcineurin in tissues, with differences in total susceptibility of each tissue.

Whole-Blood Calcineurin Activity Is Not Predicted by Cyclosporine Blood Concentration in Renal Transplant Recipients

Background: In transplant patients, current cyclosporine (CsA) dose monitoring with classic pharmacokinetics has demonstrated limitations. Evaluation of the activity of calcineurin (CN), the serine-threonine phosphatase enzyme target of CsA, has been proposed as a reliable way to optimize CsA dosing.

Methods: CN activity was measured in whole blood in an attempt to overcome the high variability of results obtained previously with peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). We also explored, in vitro, a possible relationship between the CsA concentration and CN inhibition in whole blood. Finally, we assessed whether the CsA blood trough concentration correlates with whole-blood CN activity in kidney transplant recipients (n = 15) on maintenance immunosuppression with CsA.

Results: In 14 healthy individuals, less scattered CN activity values were documented in whole blood than in the PBMC fraction. Whole-blood CN activity was higher than the sum of the enzyme activity in each cell blood fraction. After ex vivo incubation of whole blood from healthy subjects (n = 5) with increasing concentrations of CsA (50–1000 μg/L for 1 h), a concentration-dependent inhibition of CN activity was found comparable to that in the PBMC fraction. Moreover, in 15 kidney transplant recipients, no relationship was found between CsA pharmacokinetic parameters and CN activity at time 0. However, a highly significant correlation was found between CN area under the CN activity-time curve, which represents the extent of the CN daily inhibition, and CN activity at time 0 (r = 0.79; P &lt;0.01) and at 12 h postdosing (r = 0.96; P &lt;0.01).

Conclusions: Measuring CN activity in whole-blood samples is a reproducible method. In kidney transplant recipients, CsA trough concentrations do not predict baseline CN activity. Moreover, a single CN activity monitoring at baseline or at time 12 h post-CsA dosing may be a useful surrogate for the inhibition of this enzyme by CsA during 12 h.

Measurement of mycophenolate mofetil effect in transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Immunosuppression involves the nature of the immunosuppressive agents and individual differences in patient factors. We investigated whether the effect of mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) is measurable using an in vitro measure of immunocompetence and related its effects to cyclosporine (CsA) in vitro.

METHODS

Liver or kidney transplant recipients receiving prednisone; CsA or tacrolimus; and MMF, azathioprine (AZA), or neither, were studied. Immunocompetence was assessed by one-way mixed lymphocyte culture using patients' peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) and three validated stimulators. The effect of immunosuppressive agents added in vitro on normal PBL stimulation by Staphylococcus enterotoxin B was determined by the carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester measurement of division.

RESULTS

Patients receiving MMF had an average immunocompetence level of 12+/-23, compared with 39.7+/-65 and 25.5+/-42 for those receiving AZA or neither AZA nor MMF, respectively. Thus, there was an approximately 80% suppression of the response in the MMF group. Assessment of normal cell division revealed that CsA allowed multiple cell generations but suppressed the numbers of cells in each, whereas MMF blocked proliferation into subsequent generations. Addition of clinically relevant levels of mycophenolic acid, the active agent for MMF, added to more moderate levels of CsA, was required to achieve greater than 80% suppression, consistent with the degree of immunocompetence depression measured in patients.

CONCLUSIONS

These data provide the novel finding that the effect of MMF treatment on patients is measurable in their PBL as decreased immunocompetence in vitro. The effect of MMF on normal PBL approximates the 80% inhibition that we found in patients. Moreover, the effect of MMF on cell division provides a rationale for the superior effectiveness of regimens including MMF.

The effects of lipid-lowering agents on acute renal allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

Preliminary results from clinical trials suggest that 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl co-enzyme A reductase inhibitors may help prevent acute renal allograft rejection. However, the mechanism for this putative effect of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl co-enzyme A reductase inhibitors, and whether it is independent of lipid-lowering per SE are unknown.

METHODS

Immediately after renal transplantation we randomly allocated (proportioned 2:1:2) patients to: 1) simvastatin (10 mg/day, n=53), 2) simvastatin placebo plus gemfibrozil (dose adjusted for renal function, n=36), and 3) simvastatin placebo (n=52).

RESULTS

Simvastatin, but not gemfibrozil, reduced total and low density lipoprotein cholesterol during the first 90 days posttransplant. There were no major adverse effects of therapy. However, there were no effects of treatment on acute rejection. Indeed, survival free of acute rejection at 90 days was 72% in the simvastatin group, 72% in the gemfibrozil group, and 77% in the placebo control group (P=0.771). A post hoc power analysis suggested that there was only a 7.5% chance that a true effect of simvastatin on acute rejection (versus placebo) was not detected, and a 2.5% chance that an effect of gemfibrozil on acute rejection (versus placebo) was not detected in this study.

CONCLUSION

Lipid-lowering agents may not reduce the incidence of acute renal allograft rejection. However, additional studies are needed to confirm this observation. In the mean time, many if not most renal transplant recipients should be treated with HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors starting early posttransplant to prevent cardiovascular disease complications. The results of this study suggest that starting lipid-lowering therapy immediately after renal transplantation is both safe and effective in lowering total and low density lipoprotein cholesterol.

Monitoring the duration of antigen-receptor occupancy by calcineurin/glycogen-synthase-kinase-3 control of NF-AT nuclear shuttling

Recent structural studies have supported a kinetic model of TCR activation, raising the question of how the duration of receptor occupancy is translated into activation of immune response genes. We summarize evidence that the cytoplasmic-to-nuclear shuttling of NF-ATc family members monitors the duration of receptor occupancy.

Pharmacodynamics of immunosuppressive drugs

The inability to measure the effects of immunosuppressive drugs on immune cells in vivo has always severely limited preclinical drug development, the design and interpretation of clinical trials and the optimal clinical use of this drug class in transplantation. Now, new technologies using microliter samples of whole blood and exploiting the specificity, sensitivity and versatility of flow cytometry have been developed. These novel techniques not only are illuminating the 'black box' that has obscured the pharmacodynamic effects of immunosuppressants but also are uncovering new mechanisms of action of these drugs. Pharmacodynamic assays measure biologically relevant events in vivo, since changes in lymphocyte functions in blood collected from immunosuppressed graft recipients faithfully reflect histopathologic events within allograft tissue.

Human T cell responses to human and porcine endothelial cells are highly sensitive to cyclosporin A and FK506 in vitro

BACKGROUND

Human T cells proliferate in response to both human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) and porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC) via the second signals LFA-3/CD2 and B7-2 (CD86), respectively. Previous studies have shown that stimulation of T cells via CD28 or phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) activation is highly resistant to inhibition by cyclosporine A (CsA) and tacrolimus (FK506), as is the response of T cells to phytohemmaglutinin in the presence of endothelial cells. We have investigated the inhibitory effects of CsA and FK506 on the direct response of human CD4+ T cells to HUVEC and PAEC and the effect of adding B7-1 transfectants.

METHODS

T cell proliferation, interleukin-2 release bioassays and a multiple cytokine bioassay employing the TF-1 cell line were used as indicators of T cell responses to HUVEC and PAEC either in the presence or absence of CsA and FK506. In some experiments, B7-1 transfectants were also added.

RESULTS

Proliferative responses and interleukin-2 release were highly sensitive to CsA, the ID50 being significantly less for HUVEC (6.5 ng/ml) than PAEC (15 ng/ml). The ID50 of CsA for the mixed lymphocyte response (MLR) was similar to PAEC (18.6 ng/ml), all these values being significantly less than the T cell activation by phytohemmaglutinin (PHA) (227 ng/ml). Addition of B7-1 transfectants significantly increased interleukin-2 production by T cells/HUVEC and resistance to CsA was greatly increased to an ID50 of > 1000 ng/ml. In contrast, addition of B7-1 transfectants to T cells/PAEC had no effect either on T cell proliferation, IL-2 production, or CsA resistance. Similar results were obtained with FK506. Using the TF-1 cell line, it was determined that cytokines other than IL-2 are released during CD4+ T cell/EC interactions, with similar sensitivity to CsA and FK506.

CONCLUSIONS

It is concluded that both allogeneic and xenogeneic T cell/endothelial responses should be inhibited by therapeutic levels of CsA in vivo, assuming the absence of trans-stimulation by B7 molecules.

The temporal profile of calcineurin inhibition by cyclosporine in vivo

BACKGROUND

Cyclosporine (CsA) acts by inhibiting the phosphatase calcineurin (CN), but the time course and extent of inhibition in vivo are unknown. We examined the effect of single oral CsA doses on CN activity in humans and mice in vivo.

METHODS

In humans, blood CsA levels were determined and CN activity was measured in whole blood and in blood leukocytes of patients up to 12 hr after CsA dosing (just before the second dose). Samples were collected from patients receiving a first single dose (2.5 mg/kg), and up to 14 days later after repeated dosing. In mice, after CsA dosing (12.5-200 mg/kg) by oral gavage, CsA levels in blood and tissue (spleen, kidney) were determined and CN activity was measured in spleen and kidney.

RESULTS

In humans, peak CsA levels of 800-2285 microg/L at 1-2 hr produced 70-96% CN inhibition. Inhibition correlated closely with the rise and fall of CsA levels with no observable lag at the times sampled. Repeated doses showed similar CN inhibition to first dose, with no significant adaptation. In mice, CsA peaked at 1 hr in blood, spleen, and kidney, with higher concentrations in spleen and kidney than in blood. CN inhibition closely followed CsA concentrations/doses, and was greater in kidney than spleen.

CONCLUSION

Thus CsA induces partial CN inhibition that varies directly with the blood and tissue levels, and may be greater in some tissues due to higher drug accumulation. The high CsA concentrations and CN inhibition in kidney may be relevant to nephrotoxicity.

Regulation of antigen-induced human T-lymphocyte responses by calcineurin antagonists

BACKGROUND

Cyclosporin A (CS) and tacrolimus (FK506, FK) are calcineurin antagonists used widely as T-cell immunosuppressants; however, their relative efficacy on antigen-stimulated T-cell subsets remains undefined.

OBJECTIVE

We have examined the effects of CS and FK on antigen-driven proliferation and cytokine generation from human PBMCs and T-cell clones.

METHODS

Proliferation was assessed by tritiated thymidine incorporation. Cytokine generation was assessed by reverse transcription-PCR and ELISA.

RESULTS

Ragweed- and tetanus toxoid-driven proliferation of PBMCs was down-regulated equally by CS or FK. Gene expression for proinflammatory cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, and IFN-gamma) assessed by reverse transcription-PCR was down-regulated in a concentration-dependent manner by either drug. Antigen-induced proliferation of ragweed-specific Th0, Th1, or Th2 clones was inhibited by either CS or FK. Cytokine gene expression and protein secretion into culture supernatants (IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, and IFN-gamma) were down-regulated in a concentration-dependent manner by either CS or FK in all relevant T-cell subsets. Interestingly, down-regulation of IL-5 protein generation from Th0 and Th2 clones was consistently less sensitive to either drug than was the effect on either IL-4 or IL-13 protein generation.

CONCLUSION

CS and FK promote equivalent down-regulation of Th0, Th1, and Th2 responses; however, IL-5 generation is relatively insensitive to the immunomodulatory effects of calcineurin antagonists.

Pressure overload induces severe hypertrophy in mice treated with cyclosporine, an inhibitor of calcineurin

Cardiac hypertrophy is the fundamental adaptation of the adult heart to mechanical load. Recent work has shown that inhibition of calcineurin activity with cyclosporine suppresses the development of hypertrophy in calcineurin transgenic mice and in in vitro systems of neonatal rat cardiocytes stimulated with peptide growth factors. To test the hypothesis that the calcineurin signaling pathway is critical for load-induced hypertrophy in vivo, we examined the effects of cyclosporine treatment on left ventricular hypertrophy induced by experimental ascending aortic stenosis for 4 weeks in mice. Left ventricular systolic pressure was elevated to a similar level in aortic stenosis mice that were treated with cyclosporine versus no drug. Left ventricular mass and myocyte size were similar in treated and untreated aortic stenosis animals and significantly greater than control animals, showing that cyclosporine treatment does not suppress hypertrophic growth. Both treated and untreated animals showed increased left ventricular expression of the load-sensitive gene atrial natriuretic factor. Calcineurin activity was measured in the left ventricle and the spleen from control mice and aortic stenosis mice treated with cyclosporine versus no drug. Levels of calcineurin activity were similar in the spleens of control and untreated aortic stenosis mice. However, calcineurin activity was severely depressed in left ventricular tissue of untreated aortic stenosis mice compared with control mice and was further reduced by cyclosporine treatment. Thus, pathological hypertrophy and cardiac-restricted gene expression induced by pressure overload in vivo are not suppressed by treatment with cyclosporine and do not appear to depend on the elevation of left ventricular calcineurin activity.

Transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta mimics and anti-TGF-beta antibody abrogates the in vivo effects of cyclosporine: demonstration of a direct role of TGF-beta in immunosuppression and nephrotoxicity of cyclosporine

BACKGROUND

Cyclosporine (CsA) has been shown to induce the expression of transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta both in vitro and in vivo. It is hypothesized that the efficacy as well as the side effects of CsA are mediated by TGF-beta. This study was planned to investigate whether anti-TGF-beta mitigated and TGF-beta reproduced the in vivo effects of CsA to directly prove this hypothesis.

METHODS

B6AF1 (H2b/k.d) mice were divided into groups and received the following: CsA, vehicle (olive oil), CsA + anti-TGF-beta1 antibody, TGF-beta1, or vehicle phosphate-buffered saline/bovine serum albumin. All studies were carried out at 10 and 28 days after the last day of CsA administration with the exception of the exogenous TGF-beta experiments, which were performed 5 days after exogenous TGF-beta administration. The efficacy was studied by the anti-CD3-induced ex vivo proliferation of splenocytes measured by [3H]thymidine uptake; TGF-beta protein levels were quantified by ELISA. TGF-beta, collagen, and fibronectin gene expression was studied using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction, and histopathological analysis was made on periodic acid-Schiff- and trichrome C-stained thin kidney sections.

RESULTS

CsA treatment resulted in decreased ex vivo proliferation of splenocytes, an increase in TGF-beta protein in the sera, and renal histopathological changes including tubular swelling, vacuolization, thrombotic microangiopathy, and increased expression of TGF-beta, collagen and fibronectin genes. All of these findings were blocked by anti-TGF-beta antibody.

CONCLUSION

The study demonstrates the in vivo modulation of the effects of CsA by manipulating TGF-beta levels and suggests that TGF-beta at least in part mediates CsA's beneficial and detrimental effects.

Cyclosporine A-induced hyperactivity in rats: is it mediated by immunosuppression, neurotrophism, or both?

Cyclosporine A (CsA) immunosuppressive treatment has become an adjunctive therapy in neural transplantation of dopamine-secreting cells for treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD). Recently, CsA and its analogues have been shown to promote trophic effects against neurodegenerative disorders, and therefore CsA may have direct beneficial effects on dopaminergic neurons and dopamine-mediated behaviors. The present study examined the interaction between the reported CsA-induced hyperactivity and the possible alterations in nigral tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)-immunoreactive neurons in rats with damaged blood-brain barrier. CsA was administered at a therapeutic dose (10 mg/kg/day, IP, for 9 days) used in neural transplantation protocol for PD animal models. CsA-treated animals displayed significantly higher general spontaneous locomotor activity than control animals at drug injection days 7 and 9. Histological assays at day 9 revealed that there was a significant increase in TH-immunoreactive neurons in the nigra of CsA-treated rats compared to that of the vehicle-treated rats. The nigral TH elevation was accompanied by suppressed calcium-phosphotase calcineurin activity, indicating an inhibition of host immune response. This is the first report of CsA exerting simultaneous immunosuppressive and neurotrophic effects, as well as increasing general spontaneous locomotor behavior. These results support the utility of CsA as a therapeutic agent for PD and other movement disorders.

Ex vivo assessment of immunosuppression in undiluted whole blood from pigs dosed with tacrolimus (FK506)

To assess the duration of immunosuppression in FK506-dosed pigs, an undiluted whole blood assay was established to measure reactivities of T cells in their physiological milieu. PMA and ionomycin were shown to induce IL-2 production in swine blood. The IC50 of FK506 in inhibiting IL-2 production in whole blood and isolated PBMC stimulated with PMA and ionomycin measured 1.2 and 0.04 nM, respectively. These data underscore the influence of red blood cells and plasma proteins on drug potency. IL-2 levels were determined in blood drawn immediately before and 1, 24, 48, and 72 h after iv dosing. For pigs dosed with 0.05 mg/kg, 50% recovery of IL-2 production was observed at 16 h and 100% at 35 h after dosing. For pigs dosed with 0.15 mg/kg, 50% recovery was observed at 38 h and 100% at 72 h. Blood concentrations of FK506 at 50 and 100% recovery of IL-2 production measured 10.8 and 2.2 nM for pigs dosed with 0.05 mg/kg and 6.1 and 1.1 nM for pigs dosed with 0.15 mg/kg, respectively. These concentrations are severalfold higher than predicted from the IC50 of FK506 for inhibiting IL-2 production in the whole blood assay. These data suggest that the true potency of FK506 in blood after dosing is influenced by additional factors, which could include plasma protein binding, the presence of active or interfering metabolites, serum interfering factors, and sequestration of drug in blood cells. Our results demonstrate the utility of an undiluted whole blood assay for assessing the duration of immunosuppression in drug-dosed animals and emphasize the importance of assessing drug potency in the whole blood environment ex vivo.

Chronic cyclosporine-A injection in rats with damaged blood-brain barrier does not impair retention of passive avoidance

Recently, we demonstrated that chronic administration of immunosuppressant drug, cyclosporine-A (CsA), does not produce impairment in memory retention of a passive avoidance task in normal adult rats. Since CsA has been used as an adjunctive therapy to avoid xenograft rejection inherent in neural transplantation therapy for neurodegenerative disorders, we replicated our previous study in animals with damaged blood-brain barrier (BBB) simulating that of the neural transplantation protocol. Adult rats with damaged BBB that received either chronic CsA (5, 10, and 20 mg/kg) or vehicle injection did not differ significantly in their memory retention of the passive avoidance task that rewarded 'less mobile activity', in that animals avoided electric shock when they restrained their movements within the safe compartment. General spontaneous locomotor activity also was not altered by CsA, except in animals that received 20 mg/kg, which displayed significant hypoactivity at later post-injection periods of CsA. The absence of potentiation of retention of the passive avoidance task in all CsA-treated animals, including the hypoactive ones, suggests that locomotor activity did not interfere with cognitive behavior. The present results confirm our previous findings that the therapeutic dosage (10 mg/kg) of CsA used for neural transplantation does not produce visible deleterious effects on the performance of memory retention task in immunosuppressed rats with damaged BBB.

Monitoring of cyclosporin and azathioprine in organ transplantation

Cyclosporin A (CsA) is a cyclic undecapeptide that was first isolated from the fungus Tricoderma polysporum. The introduction of this potent immunosuppressive compound significantly improved the outcome of solid organ and bone marrow allograft transplantation. There is now a large body of accumulated experience in the monitoring of this drug, and several consensus conferences have addressed this issue /1-3/. Azathioprine in CsA-based triple therapy with steroids is still widely used in organ transplantation even though it is known to carry the risk of severe myelosuppression. Measurement of white blood cell (WBC) and platelet counts is generally used to recognize azathioprine toxicity. However, recent reports /4-6/ have indicated that patients with a genetically determined deficiency in thiopurine methyltransferase (TPMT), an important enzyme in azathioprine metabolism, are at high risk for myelosuppression. Monitoring of active azathioprine metabolites, which are responsible both for the immunosuppressive action and for the toxicity of azathioprine, may be necessary in such cases. It should also be noted that the incidence of posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD) is a function of the intensity of immunosuppression /7,8/. Thus the combination of CsA, azathioprine and steroids is associated with an approximately three-fold higher incidence of PTLD than low dose CsA guided by therapeutic drug monitoring /8/.

Late blockade of T cell costimulation interrupts progression of experimental chronic allograft rejection

Early blockade of T cell-costimulatory activation pathways prevents development of experimental chronic allograft rejection. Ongoing T cell recognition of alloantigen and activation may also play an important role in progression of chronic rejection, but definitive evidence is lacking. We used the fusion protein CTLA4Ig to block CD28-B7 T cell costimulation late after the onset of initial graft injury. Using the F334 into LEW rat model of chronic renal allograft rejection, transplant recipients were treated with a 10-d course of cyclosporine, and a subgroup received a single injection of CTLA4Ig at 8 wk after transplant. Functionally, CTLA4Ig administration prevented development of progressive proteinuria (14.3+/-4.1 mg/24 h versus 41.0+/-12.0 mg/24 h at 24 wk after transplant, P < 0.05). Histologically, graft mononuclear cell infiltration, glomerular hypertrophy, focal and segmental glomerulosclerosis, and intimal vascular hyperplasia were all attenuated in CTLA4Ig-treated animals. Lastly, reverse transcriptase-PCR and immunohistologic studies showed a significant reduction in the intragraft expression of key products of T cell and macrophage activation, and upregulation of what have recently been termed as "protective" genes, including the bcl family members, Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL, and hemoxygenase. Our data are the first to demonstrate that blocking T cell-costimulatory activation late after transplantation, after initial graft injury, prevents progression of chronic allograft rejection supporting the hypothesis that ongoing T cell recognition of alloantigen and activation are key mediators of ongoing chronic allograft rejection.

Enhancing the effect of secreted cyclophilin B on immunosuppressive activity of cyclosporine

BACKGROUND

Cyclophilin B (CyPB) is a cyclosporine (CsA)-binding protein, located within intracellular vesicles and secreted in biological fluids. In previous works, we reported that CyPB specifically interacts with the T-cell membrane and potentiates the ability of CsA to inhibit CD3-induced proliferation of T lymphocytes.

METHODS

CyPB levels were measured in plasma from healthy donors and transplant patients. The role of extracellular CyPB on the distribution and activity of CsA was investigated first by studies on the uptake of free and CyPB-complexed drug by blood cells, and second by studies on the inhibitory effects of these two compounds on the CD3-induced proliferation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells.

RESULTS

A significant increase in plasma CyPB level was observed for CsA-treated patients (13+/-6.4 nM, n=42) in comparison with untreated donors (4.3+/-2.1 nM, n=34). In vitro, extracellular CyPB dose dependently modified CsA distribution between plasma, erythrocyte, and lymphocyte contents, by both retaining the complexed drug extracellularly and promoting its specific accumulation within peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Moreover, the enhanced ability of CyPB-complexed CsA to suppress CD3-induced T-cell proliferation was preserved in the presence of other blood cells, implying specific targeting of the drug to sensitive cells. Furthermore, although a large interindividual variability of sensitivity to the drug was confirmed for 18 individuals, we found that CyPB potentiated the activity of CsA in restoring a high sensitivity to the immunosuppressant.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that plasma CyPB may contribute to the acceptance and the good maintenance of organ transplantation by enhancing the immunosuppressive activity of CsA through a receptor-mediated incorporation of CyPB-complexed CsA within peripheral blood lymphocytes.

Evidence that calcineurin is rate-limiting for primary human lymphocyte activation

Cyclosporine (CsA) is both a clinical immunosuppressive drug and a probe to dissect intracellular signaling pathways. In vitro, CsA inhibits lymphocyte gene activation by inhibiting the phosphatase activity of calcineurin (CN). In clinical use, CsA treatment inhibits 50-75% of CN activity in circulating leukocytes. We modeled this degree of CN inhibition in primary human leukocytes in vitro in order to study the effect of partial CN inhibition on the downstream signaling events that lead to gene activation. In CsA-treated leukocytes stimulated by calcium ionophore, the degree of reduction in CN activity was accompanied by a similar degree of inhibition of each event tested: dephosphorylation of nuclear factor of activated T cell proteins, nuclear DNA binding, activation of a transfected reporter gene construct, IFN-gamma and IL-2 mRNA accumulation, and IFN-gamma production. Furthermore, the degree of CN inhibition was reflected by a similar degree of reduction in lymphocyte proliferation and IFN-gamma production in the allogeneic mixed lymphocyte cultures. These data support the conclusion that CN activity is rate-limiting for the activation of primary human T lymphocytes. Thus, the reduction of CN activity observed in CsA-treated patients is accompanied by a similar degree of reduction in lymphocyte gene activation, and accounts for the immunosuppression observed.

Quantitating immunosuppression. Estimating the 50% inhibitory concentration for in vivo cyclosporine in mice

Cyclosporine (CsA) blocks T cell responses in vitro by inhibiting the phosphatase activity of calcineurin (CN) and thus preventing the activation of cytokine transcription. In the study presented here, we measured the extent of inhibition of these functions in the tissues of CsA-fed mice. Mice fed increasing doses of CsA were assessed for CsA blood and tissue levels, spleen cell CN activity, ex vivo spleen cell cytokine induction by A23187, and in vivo interferon-gamma induction during an allogeneic response. The CN activity of spleen homogenates and cell suspensions and the ex vivo cytokine responses of spleen cells from CsA-treated mice were inhibited with a 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) greater than 300 microg/L. The in vivo interferon-gamma response to an allogeneic ascites tumor was also inhibited by CsA treatment, with IC50s between 517 and 886 microg/L. The true IC50 for CsA in vivo may be even higher, as CsA levels in spleen and kidney were 4-fold higher than concomitant blood levels. We conclude that inhibition of CN activity by systemically administered CsA leads to a parallel reduction in cytokine gene induction in response to an allogeneic stimulus. In light of our previous clinical findings that therapeutic levels of CsA in renal transplant patients were associated with only partial inhibition of CN activity, these current results support the concept that partial CN inhibition can account for both the immunosuppression and the immunocompetence of CsA-treated patients.

The functional consequences of partial calcineurin inhibition in human peripheral blood mononuclear leucocytes

Calcium-dependent signal transduction is essential to the induction of cytokine expression by stimuli acting through the T cell receptor. In vitro, the immunosuppressant cyclosporine (CyA) blocks this pathway by inhibition of calcineurin (CN) phosphatase activity. But in vivo, patients on CyA have only 50% inhibition of CN and can mount cytokine responses. To simulate this state of partial inhibition, we studied the responses of human peripheral blood mononuclear leucocytes (PBL) in vitro at low CyA concentrations. PBL were challenged in vitro with calcium ionophores or anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody. The induction of IFN-gamma (interferon-gamma) and IL-2 (interleukin 2) steady-state mRNA was studied by Northern blotting and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. IFN-gamma was assessed in a radiolabelled antibody binding assay or by ELISA (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay). CN was assessed by dephosphorylation of a 32P-serine labelled 19 amino acid substrate. CyA inhibited CN with an IC50 (concentration giving 50% inhibition) of 10 ng/ml (95% confidence interval, CI = 8-13 ng/ml). Likewise, the induction of IFN-gamma and IL-2 mRNA by calcium ionophore A23187 was inhibited with IC50 of 14 ng/ml (95% CI = 8-27 ng/ml) and 32 ng/ml (95% CI = 5-178 ng/ml), respectively, while the IC50 for inhibition of IFN-gamma protein secretion was 8 ng/ml (95% CI = 9-18 ng/ml). Partial inhibition of CN also altered the threshold for IFN-gamma induction. CyA 10 ng/ml inhibited IFN-gamma induction by anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody OKT3 significantly more at low OKT3 concentrations (10 ng/ml, mean +/- SEM = 72 +/- 9% inhibition) compared to high OKT3 concentrations (1000 ng/ml, 47 +/- 6%, p < 0.01). Similar results were seen using high and low concentrations of A23187. Finally, cells pretreated with CyA recovered the ability to respond to high concentrations of A23187 (5 microM) faster than low concentrations (0.5 microM). We conclude that the principal defect in lymphocytes with partial CN inhibition is a reduction in maximum cytokine output which is closely related to the degree of CN inhibition. In addition, there is significantly greater inhibition of weak stimuli compared to maximal stimuli. These defects may explain why patients on CyA can have a reduction in immune responsiveness but still retain protection from infection.