Analysis of sequence transfers resembling gene conversion in a mouse antibody transgene

Clustered Mutations at the Murine and Human IgH Locus Exhibit Significant Linkage Consistent with Templated Mutagenesis

Somatic hypermutation generates a myriad of Ab mutants in Ag-specific B cells, from which high-affinity mutants are selected. Chickens, sheep, and rabbits use nontemplated point mutations and templated mutations via gene conversion to diversify their expressed Ig loci, whereas mice and humans rely solely on untemplated somatic point mutations. In this study, we demonstrate that, in addition to untemplated point mutations, templated mutagenesis readily occurs at the murine and human Ig loci. We provide two distinct lines of evidence that are not explained by the Neuberger model of somatic hypermutation: 1) across multiple data sets there is significant linkage disequilibrium between individual mutations, especially among close mutations, and 2) among those mutations, those <8 bp apart are significantly more likely to match microhomologous regions in the IgHV repertoire than predicted by the mutation profiles of somatic hypermutation. Together, this supports the role of templated mutagenesis during somatic diversification of Ag-activated B cells.

Gene Conversion-Like Events in the Diversification of Human Rearranged IGHV3-23*01 Gene Sequences

Gene conversion (GCV), a mechanism mediated by activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is well established as a mechanism of immunoglobulin diversification in a few species. However, definitive evidence of GCV-like events in human immunoglobulin genes is scarce. The lack of evidence of GCV in human rearranged immunoglobulin gene sequences is puzzling given the presence of highly similar germline donors and the presence of all the enzymatic machinery required for GCV. In this study, we undertook a computational analysis of rearranged IGHV3-23(*)01 gene sequences from common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) patients, AID-deficient patients, and healthy individuals to survey "GCV-like" activities. We analyzed rearranged IGHV3-23(*)01 gene sequences obtained from total PBMC RNA and single-cell polymerase chain reaction of individual B cell lysates. Our search identified strong evidence of GCV-like activity. We observed that GCV-like tracts are flanked by AID hotspot motifs. Structural modeling of IGHV3-23(*)01 gene sequence revealed that hypermutable bases flanking GCV-like tracts are in the single stranded DNA (ssDNA) of stable stem-loop structures (SLSs). ssDNA is inherently fragile and also an optimal target for AID. We speculate that GCV could have been initiated by the targeting of hypermutable bases in ssDNA state in stable SLSs, plausibly by AID. We have observed that the frequency of GCV-like events is significantly higher in rearranged IGHV3-23-(*)01 sequences from healthy individuals compared to that of CVID patients. We did not observe GCV-like events in rearranged IGHV3-23-(*)01 sequences from AID-deficient patients. GCV, unlike somatic hypermutation (SHM), can result in multiple base substitutions that can alter many amino acids. The extensive changes in antibody affinity by GCV-like events would be instrumental in protecting humans against pathogens that diversify their genome by antigenic shift.

Negative selection by IgM superantigen defines a B cell central tolerance compartment and reveals mutations allowing escape

To analyze B lymphocyte central tolerance in a polyclonal immune system, mice were engineered to express a superantigen reactive to IgM of allotype b (IgM(b)). IgM(b/b) mice carrying superantigen were severely B cell lymphopenic, but small numbers of B cells matured. Their sera contained low levels of IgG and occasionally high levels of IgA. In bone marrow, immature B cells were normal in number, but internalized IgM and had a unique gene expression profile, compared with those expressing high levels of surface IgM, including elevated recombinase activator gene expression. A comparable B cell population was defined in wild-type bone marrows, with an abundance suggesting that at steady state ∼20% of normal developing B cells are constantly encountering autoantigens in situ. In superantigen-expressing mice, as well as in mice carrying the 3H9 anti-DNA IgH transgene, or 3H9 H along with mutation in the murine κ-deleting element RS, IgM internalization was correlated with CD19 downmodulation. CD19(low) bone marrow cells from 3H9;RS(-/-) mice were enriched in L chains that promote DNA binding. Our results suggest that central tolerance and attendant L chain receptor editing affect a large fraction of normal developing B cells. IgH(a/b) mice carrying the superantigen had a ∼50% loss in follicular B cell numbers, suggesting that escape from central tolerance by receptor editing from one IgH allele to another was not a major mechanism. IgM(b) superantigen hosts reconstituted with experimental bone marrow were demonstrated to be useful in revealing pathways involved in central tolerance.

Translocation of an antibody transgene requires AID and occurs by interchromosomal switching to all switch regions except the mu switch region

Immunoglobulin (Ig) class switch recombination (CSR) occurs most often by intrachromosomal recombinations between switch (S) regions located on a single chromosome, but it can also occur by interchomosomal recombinations between Ig heavy chain (Igh) S regions located on chomosomal homologs. Interchromosomal recombinations have also been found between chromosomes that are not homologs; examples are Igh/c-myc and Igh/transgene translocations. Most, but not all, studies have indicated that activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is important in Igh/c-myc translocations. The role of AID has not been determined for Igh/transgene translocations. We now show that the majority of Igh/transgene translocations between non-homologs from an Ig transgenic mouse are dependent on AID, but we also find a small number of these translocations that can occur in the absence of AID. Surprisingly, our results also indicate that, although Sγ switch sequences in the endogenous Igh locus participate in chromosomal translocations with the non-homolog transgene-bearing chromosome, Sμ switch sequences do not. This contrasts with the fact that both endogenous Sμ and Sγ sequences participate in intrachromosomal CSR. Our findings suggest the operation of a regulatory mechanism that can differentially control the accessibility of Sμ and Sγ regions for non-homolog translocations even when both are accessible for intrachromosomal recombination.

Endogenous TCR recombination in TCR Tg single RAG-deficient mice uncovered by robust in vivo T cell activation and selection

Recombination activating gene (RAG)-deficient TCR (T Cell Receptor) Tg (transgenic) mice are routinely used as sources of monoclonal T cells. We found that after the transfer of T cells from a RAG-2-deficient 5CC7 TCR Tg mice into allogeneic hosts we recovered a population of T cells expressing diverse alphabeta-TCRs. In fact, in the thymus and spleen of the 5CC7 RAG-2-deficient donor mice, we detected rare T cells expressing non-Tg TCR chains. Similar observations were obtained using T cells from two other TCR transgenic strains, namely RAG-2-deficient aHY and RAG-1-deficient OT-1 mice. The sequences of the endogenous TCR transcripts suggested that gene recombination could occur, albeit quite inefficiently, in the RAG-deficient mice we used. In agreement, we evidenced rare TCR Valpha and Vbeta-chain transcripts in non-Tg RAG-2-deficient mice. Since in these non-Tg RAG-deficient mice no mature T cells could ever be found, our findings suggested a role for the TCR Tg in rescuing rare recombined endogenous chains. Robust T-cell activation by the allogeneic environment favored the selection and expansion of the rare cells expressing endogenous TCRs. Potential mechanisms involved in the recombination of the endogenous TCR chains in the different strains of RAG-deficient mice used, and in particular the possibility of RAG-1 hypomorphism due to an incomplete knocking out procedure, are discussed. Our findings have important experimental implications for studies using TCR-Tg RAG-deficient cells as monoclonal T cell populations.

Sequence transfers between variable regions in a mouse antibody transgene can occur by gene conversion

Different vertebrate species show widely differing usage of somatic hyperconversion (SHC) as a mechanism for diversifying expressed Ab V genes. The basis for the differing levels of SHC in different species is not known. Although no clear evidence for SHC has been found in normal mouse B cells, transgenic mice carrying high-copy numbers of a gene construct designed to optimize detection of SHC have previously been shown to exhibit sequence transfers that resemble gene conversion events. However, these transgene sequence transfers could reflect multistep or reciprocal DNA recombination events rather than gene conversions. We now find in low-copy number transgenic mice that transgene sequence transfers can exhibit the unidirectional sequence information movement that is a hallmark of gene conversion. This indicates that gene conversion between V region sequences can occur in mouse B cells; we propose that the lack of efficient SHC contributions to Ab diversification in normal mice may be due, at least in part, to the particular pattern of V gene recombinational accessibility that occurs in differentiating mouse B cells.

Antibody repertoire development in fetal and neonatal pigs. VII. Characterization of the preimmune kappa light chain repertoire

Combinatorial diversity is highly restricted in the preimmune porcine H chain repertoire compared with that in humans and mice. This raised the question of whether similar restriction characterized the preimmune L chain repertoire. In this study we present evidence that >90% of all expressed Vkappa genes in the porcine preimmune repertoire belong to three subfamilies of Vkappa genes that share 87% sequence similarity with human IGKV2. This porcine Vkappa family also shares sequence similarity with some, but not all, Vkappa genes from sheep. Hybridization with sperm DNA and sequence analyses of polynucleotides from overlapping bacterial artificial chromosome clones suggest swine possess approximately 60 IGVK2 genes. The latter method also revealed that certain IGKV2 subfamilies are not expressed in the preimmune repertoire. Six members of an IGVK1 family were also expressed as part of the preimmune repertoire, and these shared 87% sequence similarity with human IGVK1. Five Jkappa segments, complete with recombination signal sequences and separated by approximately 300 nt, were identified approximately 3 kb upstream of a single Ckappa. Surprisingly, Jkappa2 accounted for >90% of all framework region 4 sequences in the preimmune repertoire. These findings show that swine use approximately 10 IGVK2 genes from three of six subfamilies and preferentially one Jkappa segment to generate their preimmune kappa repertoire. These studies, like those of porcine Ig constant regions and MHC genes, also indicate unexpected high sequence similarity with their human counterparts despite differences in phylogeny and the mechanism of repertoire diversification.

Cis-acting regulatory sequences promote high-frequency gene conversion between repeated sequences in mammalian cells

In mammalian cells, little is known about the nature of recombination-prone regions of the genome. Previously, we reported that the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) mu locus behaved as a hotspot for mitotic, intrachromosomal gene conversion (GC) between repeated mu constant (Cmu) regions in mouse hybridoma cells. To investigate whether elements within the mu gene regulatory region were required for hotspot activity, gene targeting was used to delete a 9.1 kb segment encompassing the mu gene promoter (Pmu), enhancer (Emu) and switch region (Smu) from the locus. In these cell lines, GC between the Cmu repeats was significantly reduced, indicating that this 'recombination-enhancing sequence' (RES) is necessary for GC hotspot activity at the IgH locus. Importantly, the RES fragment stimulated GC when appended to the same Cmu repeats integrated at ectopic genomic sites. We also show that deletion of Emu and flanking matrix attachment regions (MARs) from the RES abolishes GC hotspot activity at the IgH locus. However, no stimulation of ectopic GC was observed with the Emu/MARs fragment alone. Finally, we provide evidence that no correlation exists between the level of transcription and GC promoted by the RES. We suggest a model whereby Emu/MARS enhances mitotic GC at the endogenous IgH mu locus by effecting chromatin modifications in adjacent DNA.

Gene conversion-like sequence transfers between transgenic antibody V genes are independent of RAD54

Homology-based Ig gene conversion is a major mechanism for Ab diversification in chickens and the Rad54 DNA repair protein plays an important role in this process. In mice, although gene conversion appears to be rare among endogenous Ig genes, Ab H chain transgenes undergo isotype switching and gene conversion-like sequence transfer processes that also appear to involve homologous recombination or gene conversion. Furthermore, homology-based DNA repair has been suggested to be important for somatic mutation of endogenous mouse Ig genes. To assess the role of Rad54 in these mouse B cell processes, we have analyzed H chain transgene isotype switching, sequence transfer, and somatic hypermutation in mice that lack RAD54. We find that Rad54 is not required for either transgene switching or transgene hypermutation. Furthermore, even transgene sequence transfers that are known to require homology-based recombinations are Rad54 independent. These results indicate that mouse B cells must use factors for promoting homologous recombination that are distinct from the Rad54 proteins important in homology-based chicken Ab gene recombinations. Our findings also suggest that mouse H chain transgene sequence transfers might be more closely related to an error-prone homology-based somatic hypermutational mechanism than to the hyperconversion mechanism that operates in chicken B cells.

Evidence for the murine IgH mu locus acting as a hot spot for intrachromosomal homologous recombination

Homologous recombination accomplishes the exchange of genetic information between two similar or identical DNA duplexes. It can occur either by gene conversion, a process of unidirectional genetic exchange, or by reciprocal crossing over. Homologous recombination is well known for its role in generating genetic diversity in meiosis and, in mitosis, as a DNA repair mechanism. In the immune system, the evidence suggests a role for homologous recombination in Ig gene evolution and in the diversification of Ab function. Previously, we reported the occurrence of homologous recombination between repeated, donor and recipient alleles of the Ig H chain mu gene C (Cmu) region residing at the Ig mu locus in mouse hybridoma cells. In this study, we constructed mouse hybridoma cell lines bearing Cmu region heteroalleles to learn more about the intrachromosomal homologous recombination process. A high frequency of homologous recombination (gene conversion) was observed for markers spanning the entire recipient Cmu region, suggesting that recombination might initiate at random sites within the Cmu region. The Cmu region heteroalleles were equally proficient as either conversion donors or recipients. Remarkably, when the same Cmu heteroalleles were tested for recombination in ectopic genomic positions, the mean frequency of gene conversion was reduced by at least 65-fold. These results are consistent with the murine IgH mu locus behaving as a hot spot for intrachromosomal homologous recombination.

Gene conversion-like sequence transfers in a mouse antibody transgene: antigen selection allows sensitive detection of V region interactions based on homology

Gene conversion is important for antibody diversification in chickens, rabbits and cows. In mice, however, conversion events appear to be infrequent among endogenous antibody genes. DNA sequence transfer events that resemble gene conversions have been reported for a mouse H chain transgene (VVC(mu)) that contains two closely spaced homologous VDJ segments. Surprisingly, these reported VVC(mu) sequence transfers were found frequently among mouse B cells responding to immunization. Transgene sequence transfers could be occurring at high frequency in responding VVC(mu) B cells or could be occurring at lower frequency with subsequent amplification by preferential antigen selection. To distinguish these possibilities, we have analyzed a second transgene (InVVC(mu)) that is identical to VVC(mu) except that the two VDJ regions have been exchanged in position. We find that transgene sequence transfers are much less frequent among responding B cells in InVVC(mu) mice, demonstrating the importance of selection in the frequent transgene conversions observed in VVC(mu) mice. These results suggest that mice, like other species, can use gene conversion to diversify antibodies. Such diversification events are apparently infrequent, however, and might only be detected among endogenous Ig genes with a favorable arrangement of V genes and an antigenic stimulation that selects cells with conversions. For both VVC(mu) and InVVC(mu) mice, conversion-like sequence transfers are strongly correlated with somatic hypermutation. Based on these results, we hypothesize that, in mice, gene conversions represent infrequent alternative reactions of a homology-based DNA repair process that is central in the somatic hypermutational mechanism.

Ablation of XRCC2/3 transforms immunoglobulin V gene conversion into somatic hypermutation

After gene rearrangement, immunoglobulin V genes are further diversified by either somatic hypermutation or gene conversion. Hypermutation (in man and mouse) occurs by the fixation of individual, non-templated nucleotide substitutions. Gene conversion (in chicken) is templated by a set of upstream V pseudogenes. Here we show that if the RAD51 paralogues XRCC2, XRCC3 or RAD51B are ablated the pattern of diversification of the immunoglobulin V gene in the chicken DT40 B-cell lymphoma line exhibits a marked shift from one of gene conversion to one of somatic hypermutation. Non-templated, single-nucleotide substitutions are incorporated at high frequency specifically into the V domain, largely at G/C and with a marked hotspot preference. These mutant DT40 cell lines provide a tractable model for the genetic dissection of immunoglobulin hypermutation and the results support the idea that gene conversion and somatic hypermutation constitute distinct pathways for processing a common lesion in the immunoglobulin V gene. The marked induction of somatic hypermutation that is achieved by ablating the RAD51 paralogues is probably a consequence of modifying the recombination-mediated repair of such initiating lesions.

The reverse transcriptase model of somatic hypermutation

The evidence supporting the reverse transcriptase model of somatic hypermutation is critically reviewed. The model provides a coherent explanation for many apparently unrelated findings. We also show that the somatic hypermutation pattern in the human BCL-6 gene can be interpreted in terms of the reverse transcriptase model and the notion of feedback of somatically mutated sequences to the germline over evolutionary time.

Antigen-Induced Somatic Diversification of Rabbit IgH Genes: Gene Conversion and Point Mutation

During T cell-dependent immune responses in mouse and human, Ig genes diversify by somatic hypermutation within germinal centers. Rabbits, in addition to using somatic hypermutation to diversify their IgH genes, use a somatic gene conversion-like mechanism, which involves homologous recombination between upstream VH gene segments and the rearranged VDJ genes. Somatic gene conversion and somatic hypermutation occur in young rabbit gut-associated lymphoid tissue and are thought to diversify a primary Ab repertoire that is otherwise limited by preferential VH gene segment utilization. Because somatic gene conversion is rarely found within Ig genes during immune responses in mouse and human, we investigated whether gene conversion in rabbit also occurs during specific immune responses, in a location other than gut-associated lymphoid tissue. We analyzed clonally related VDJ genes from popliteal lymph node B cells responding to primary, secondary, and tertiary immunization with the hapten FITC coupled to a protein carrier. Clonally related VDJ gene sequences were derived from FITC-specific hybridomas, as well as from Ag-induced germinal centers of the popliteal lymph node. By analyzing the nature of mutations within these clonally related VDJ gene sequences, we found evidence not only of ongoing somatic hypermutation, but also of ongoing somatic gene conversion. Thus in rabbit, both somatic gene conversion and somatic hypermutation occur during the course of an immune response.

Somatic hypermutation and the three R's: repair, replication and recombination

Somatic hypermutation introduces single base changes into the rearranged variable (V) regions of antigen activated B cells at a rate of approximately 1 mutation per kilobase per generation. This is nearly a million-fold higher than the typical mutation rate in a mammalian somatic cell. Rampant mutation at this level could have a devastating effect, but somatic hypermutation is accurately targeted and tightly regulated. Here, we provide an overview of immunoglobulin gene somatic hypermutation; discuss mechanisms of mutation in model organisms that may be relevant to the hypermutation mechanism; and review recent advances toward understanding the possible role(s) of DNA repair, replication, and recombination in this fascinating process.

Alternative Splicing and Hypermutation of a Nonproductively Rearranged TCR α-Chain in a T Cell Hybridoma

Like Ig genes, TCR genes are formed by somatic rearrangements of noncontiguous genomic V, J, and C regions. Unlike Ig genes, somatic hypermutation of TCR V regions is an infrequent event. We describe the occurrence of spontaneous hypermutation in a nonproductively rearranged TCR α-chain gene in a clonal T cell hybridoma that had lost its productively rearranged α-chain. The mutating hybridoma was eventually supplanted in culture by a nonmutating variant that had restored an open reading frame in the nonproductively rearranged TCR α-chain through the use of cryptic splice sites in the Vα region. Evidence is presented for the presence of cDNA reverse transcripts of the TCR α-chain within the hybridoma, suggesting a role for reverse transcriptase in the generation of mutations.

A λ 3′ Enhancer Drives Active and Untemplated Somatic Hypermutation of a λ1 Transgene

Somatic hypermutation is a highly regulated process that targets mutations to the rearranged Ig genes. Little is known about the cis-elements required for somatic hypermutation of the λ light chain gene. We have studied somatic hypermutation of a rearranged λ1 transgene under the control of either a λ2-4 or κ 3′ enhancer. The mutations in the transgenes were analyzed by sequencing DNA amplified from hypermutating Peyer’s patch B cells. The results indicate that the λ 3′ enhancer can drive active hypermutation of a λ1 transgene in Peyer’s patch cells. The λ1 transgene under analysis carried two marked Vλ2 genes immediately upstream that could serve as sequence donors in possible gene conversion events. There was no evidence of sequence transfer to the hypermutated λ1 gene, suggesting that gene conversion is not a major mechanism for somatic hypermutation in mice.

Hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes in memory B cells of DNA repair-deficient mice

To investigate the possible involvement of DNA repair in the process of somatic hypermutation of rearranged immunoglobulin variable (V) region genes, we have analyzed the occurrence, frequency, distribution, and pattern of mutations in rearranged Vlambda1 light chain genes from naive and memory B cells in DNA repair-deficient mutant mouse strains. Hypermutation was found unaffected in mice carrying mutations in either of the following DNA repair genes: xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group (XP)A and XPD, Cockayne syndrome complementation group B (CSB), mutS homologue 2 (MSH2), radiation sensitivity 54 (RAD54), poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP), and 3-alkyladenine DNA-glycosylase (AAG). These results indicate that both subpathways of nucleotide excision repair, global genome repair, and transcription-coupled repair are not required for somatic hypermutation. This appears also to be true for mismatch repair, RAD54-dependent double-strand-break repair, and AAG-mediated base excision repair.

A unifying hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of somatic mutation and gene conversion in rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes

We have reviewed available data concerning the mechanism of somatic hypermutation in rearranged variable genes of Ig in B lymphocytes of mice and the gene conversion process which generates diversity in these genes in the B lymphocytes of chickens. In our view, these data are consistent with a unifying hypothesis of diversity generating mechanisms involving reverse transcription to produce cDNA from RNA transcripts followed by homologous recombination into chromosomal DNA. Thus, seemingly different processes in the mouse and chicken may have a common molecular basis.

Somatic diversification of IgH genes in rabbit

Rabbits have helped elucidate one of the major immunologic puzzles, namely the genetic control of antibody diversity. The primary IgH antibody repertoire in rabbits is dominated by B cells that use the same germline VH-gene segment in VDJ gene rearrangements. The VDJ genes of essentially all B lymphocytes undergo somatic diversification within the first few weeks of the rabbit's life. Such diversification occurs both by a somatic gene conversion-like mechanism as well as by somatic hyperpointmutation. The diversification that occurs early in ontogeny takes place in gut-associated lymphoid tissues and potentially depends on external factors such as microbial antigens. Few, if any, new B lymphocytes develop in adult rabbits and we discuss how the antibody repertoire is maintained throughout life. Finally, we discuss the molecular mechanism of somatic gene conversion of Ig genes, including the possibility that this involves the use of RAD51, an enzyme required for gene conversion-mediated mating type switch in yeast.

Recombination-based mechanisms for somatic hypermutation

We review some experiments designed to test recombination-based mechanisms for somatic hypermutation in mice, particularly mechanisms involving templated mutation or gene conversion. As recombination and repair functions are highly conserved among prokaryotes and eukaryotes, pathways of mutation in microorganisms may prove relevant to the mechanism of somatic hypermutation. Escherichia coli initiates a recombination-based pathway of mutation in response to environmental stimuli, and this "adaptive" pathway of mutation has striking similarities with somatic hypermutation, as does a process of mutagenic repair that occurs at double-strand breaks in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We present a model for recombination-based hypermutation of the immunoglobulin loci which could result in either templated or non-templated mutation.

The signature of somatic hypermutation appears to be written into the germline IgV segment repertoire

We present here a unifying hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of somatic hypermutation and somatic gene conversion in IgV genes involving reverse transcription using RNA templates from the V-gene loci to produce cDNA which undergoes homologous recombination with chromosomal V(D)J DNA. Experimental evidence produced over the last 20 years is essentially consistent with this hypothesis. We also review evidence suggesting that somatically generated IgV sequences from B lymphocytes have been fed back to germline DNA over evolutionary time.

Mechanism of antigen-driven somatic hypermutation of rearranged immunoglobulin V(D)J genes in the mouse

Available data relevant to the mechanism of somatic hypermutation have been critically evaluated in the context of alternative models: (i) error-generating reverse transcription (RT) followed by homologous recombination; and (ii) error-prone DNA replication/repair. A set of basic principles concerning somatic hypermutation has also been formulated and a revised and expanded "RT-Mutatorsome" concept (analogous to telomerase) is presented which is consistent with these principles and all data on the distribution of somatic mutations in normal and Ig transgenic mice carrying particular V(D)J and flanking region constructs. It is predicted that in the mouse VH and Vk loci. the J-C intronic Enhancer-Nuclear Matrix Attachment Region (Ei/MAR) contains a unique sequence motif or secondary structure which ensures that only V(D)J sequences mutate whilst other regions of the genome are not mutated.

B cell development in mice

The development and establishment of the B Cell Repertoire is the net result of both genetic and environmental forces. The primary event at the genetic level is Ig gene rearrangement resulting in numerous possible combination of genes which can be further modified by somatic events such as N segment addition and somatic mutation. Environmental forces in the form of self and exogenous Ags also shape the repertoire by positively or negatively selecting B cells according to the specificity of their Ig receptors. These are dynamic processes beginning with the earliest expression of immunoglobulins in fetal life and continuing throughout life. In this review we discuss the genetic and selective mechanisms responsible for differences in the early immune system compared to that of the adult.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

The relationship between somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation in the mouse is delineated. Recent work on the anatomical and cellular site of this process is surveyed. The molecular characteristics of somatic hypermutation are described in terms of the region mutated and the distinctive patterns of nucleotide changes that are observed. The results of experiments utilizing transgenic mice to find out the minimum cis-acting sequences required to recruit hypermutation are summarized. The hypothesis that V gene sequences have evolved in order to target mutation to certain sites but not others is discussed. The use that different species make of somatic hypermutation to generate either the primary or secondary B cell repertoire is considered. Possible molecular mechanisms for the hypermutation process and future goals of research are outlined.

The molecular basis of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

Somatic hypermutation amplifies the variable region repertoire of immunoglobulin genes. Recent experimental evidence has thrown light on various molecular models of somatic hypermutation. A link between somatic hypermutation and transcription coupled DNA repair is shaping up.

Rearrangement/hypermutation/gene conversion: when, where and why?

Diversification strategies for immunoglobulins vary widely in different species. Here, Jean-Claude Weill and Claude-Agnès Reynaud argue that V(D)J recombination arose as a means for achieving allelic exclusion rather than diversity, and postulate that the choice of a diversification strategy is selected along with a specific site of B-cell differentiation. They propose that somatic mutation and gene conversion represent analogous molecular strategies occurring in specific chromatin accessibility contexts.

The effect of carrier and carrier priming on the kinetics and pattern of somatic mutation in the V chi Ox1 gene

Priming mice with a chicken gamma globulin (CGG) carrier protein significantly accelerated the onset of somatic mutation in the V chi Ox1 gene when the mice were subsequently immunized with 2-phenyl-5-oxazolone (phOx) coupled to CGG. The first mutations were already detected 7 days after immunization, while in the true primary response, they are not apparent until day 10. It was also found that comparing the mutation pattern of V chi Ox1 genes from hybridomas derived after immunization with phOx coupled to different carriers revealed quite distinct patterns of somatic mutation. Analysis of hybridoma sequences from the primary immune response to phOx-ovalbumin showed that the codons for Ser29, Ser31 and Lys45 were hot-spots for somatic mutation. Thus, the frequency and pattern of somatic mutations in the V chi Ox1 gene depends on the available T cell help as well as on the complex structure of the immunizing antigen.

Reciprocal homologous recombination in or near antibody VDJ genes

To determine if rearranged heavy chain variable (VDJ) genes can recombine with each other by crossing over of DNA strands, we constructed a transgene that contained a promoter, VDJ gene, reporter gene to detect crossover events, intron enhancer, matrix attachment region, and constant gene for IgM (C mu). Following immunization of transgenic mice, hybrid molecules were isolated from B cell DNA which contained the transgene recombined with the endogenous IgH locus. Reciprocal products of crossovers were detected by plasmid rescue and PCR amplification, and they were sequenced. Recombination occurred somewhere within 147 bp of homology that contained the JH4 gene segment and 3' flanking DNA. The recombined transgenes had a 20-fold increase in mutation in the VDJ region compared to nonrecombined transgenes, which indicates that DNA sequences 3' of the C mu gene in the endogenous IgH locus are necessary for full activity of the mutator mechanism. The recovery of recombinants between VDJ transgenes and endogenous VDJ genes raises the possibility that reciprocal recombination may somatically diversify rearranged genes between maternal and paternal alleles.

Immunoglobulin variable region hypermutation in hybrids derived from a pre-B- and a myeloma cell line

Somatic mutation of the variable (V) regions of immunoglobulin genes occurs in vivo at rates that have been estimated to be between 10(-3) and 10(-4) per bp per generation. To study this process in vitro, the 18.81 pre-B-cell line and hybrids derived by fusing 18.81 to the NSO myeloma fusion partner were transfected with a mu heavy-chain construct containing a nonsense mutation in the V region (Vn) or the constant region (Cn). Mutation was quantitated by reversion analysis using the ELISA spot assay to detect single cells secreting IgM. Fluctuation analysis revealed that V-region mutations spontaneously occurred in 18.81 cells at an average rate of 5.8 x 10(-6) per bp per cell generation and in selected 18.81-NSO hybrids at greatly increased rates of 1.6 x 10(-3) to 5.8 x 10(-4) per bp per generation. The Vn construct also reverted frequently in transgenic mice, indicating that it contained sufficient information to mutate at high rates both in vivo and in vitro. Sequence analysis of reverted genes revealed that reversion was due to point mutations. Since the rates and nature of the mutations that are occurring in these transfected genes are similar to those reported in vivo, it should be possible to use this system to identify the cis-acting sequences and trans-acting factors that are responsible for V-region somatic hypermutation.

Somatic hypermutation

For the generation of secondary response antibodies, immunoglobulin genes are subjected to hypermutation. Cells expressing antibodies with higher affinity are then selected by antigen. Recent clues to the mechanism of hypermutation come from experiments using transgenic mice enabling analysis of the controlling cis-acting elements and the intrinsic features of the hypermutation, dissociated from the effects of antigenic selection.