Targeted Alpha Therapy for Glioblastoma: Review on In Vitro, In Vivo and Clinical Trials

Glioblastoma (GB), a prevalent and highly malignant primary brain tumour with a very high mortality rate due to its resistance to conventional therapies and invasive nature, resulting in 5-year survival rates of only 4-17%. Despite recent advancements in cancer management, the survival rates for GB patients have not significantly improved over the last 10-20 years. Consequently, there exists a critical unmet need for innovative therapies. One promising approach for GB is Targeted Alpha Therapy (TAT), which aims to selectively deliver potentially therapeutic radiation doses to malignant cells and the tumour microenvironment while minimising radiation exposure to surrounding normal tissue with or without conventional external beam radiation. This approach has shown promise in both pre-clinical and clinical settings. A review was conducted following PRISMA 2020 guidelines across Medline, SCOPUS, and Embase, identifying 34 relevant studies out of 526 initially found. In pre-clinical studies, TAT demonstrated high binding specificity to targeted GB cells, with affinity rates between 60.0% and 84.2%, and minimal binding to non-targeted cells (4.0-5.6%). This specificity significantly enhanced cytotoxic effects and improved biodistribution when delivered intratumorally. Mice treated with TAT showed markedly higher median survival rates compared to control groups. In clinical trials, TAT applied to recurrent GB (rGB) displayed varying success rates in extending overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival. Particularly effective when integrated into treatment regimens for both newly diagnosed and recurrent cases, TAT increased the median OS by 16.1% in newly diagnosed GB and by 36.4% in rGB, compared to current standard therapies. Furthermore, it was generally well tolerated with minimal adverse effects. These findings underscore the potential of TAT as a viable therapeutic option in the management of GB.

Astatine-211 based radionuclide therapy: Current clinical trial landscape

Astatine-211 (²¹¹At) has physical properties that make it one of the top candidates for use as a radiation source for alpha particle-based radionuclide therapy, also referred to as targeted alpha therapy (TAT). Here, we summarize the main results of the completed clinical trials, further describe ongoing trials, and discuss future prospects.

Targeted and Nontargeted α-Particle Therapies

α-Particle irradiation of cancerous tissue is increasingly recognized as a potent therapeutic option. We briefly review the physics, radiobiology, and dosimetry of α-particle emitters, as well as the distinguishing features that make them unique for radiopharmaceutical therapy. We also review the emerging clinical role of α-particle therapy in managing cancer and recent studies on in vitro and preclinical α-particle therapy delivered by antibodies, other small molecules, and nanometer-sized particles. In addition to their unique radiopharmaceutical characteristics, the increased availability and improved radiochemistry of α-particle radionuclides have contributed to the growing recent interest in α-particle radiotherapy. Targeted therapy strategies have presented novel possibilities for the use of α-particles in the treatment of cancer. Clinical experience has already demonstrated the safe and effective use of α-particle emitters as potent tumor-selective drugs for the treatment of leukemia and metastatic disease.

211At labeled substance P (5-11) as potential radiopharmaceutical for glioma treatment

INTRODUCTION

The purposes of the present work were to label substance P (5-11) with ²¹¹At using a rhodium(III) complex with a bifunctional ligand-2-(1,5,9,13-tetrathiacyclohexadecan-3-yloxy)acetic acid ([16aneS₄]-COOH) and to assess the in vitro stability and toxicity of the obtained radiobioconjugate.

METHODS

Two approaches were evaluated to obtain ¹³¹I/²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-SP_5-11 radiobioconjugates, based on 2-step and 1-step syntheses. In the first method ¹³¹I/²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-COOH complexes were obtained that required further coupling to a biomolecule. In the second approach, the bioconjugate [16aneS₄]-SP_5-11 was synthesized and further labeled with ¹³¹I and ²¹¹At through the utilization of a Rh(III) metal cation bridge. The synthesized compounds were analyzed by HPLC, TLC and paper electrophoresis.

RESULTS

The ¹³¹I/²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-COOH complexes were obtained in high yield and possessed good stability in PBS and CSF. Preliminary studies on coupling of ¹³¹I-Rh[16aneS₄]-COOH to substance P (5-11) in 2-step synthesis showed that this procedure was too long with respect to ²¹¹At half-life, prompting us to improve it by finally using a 1-step synthesis. This strategy not only shortened the labeling time, but also increased final yield of ¹³¹I/²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-SP_5-11 radiobioconjugates. The stability of both compounds in PBS and CSF was high. Toxicity studies with the ²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-SP_5-11 demonstrated that radiobioconjugate significantly reduced T98G cell viability in a dose dependent manner reaching 20% of survival at the highest radioactivity 1200kBq/mL.

CONCLUSIONS

The radiobioconjugate ²¹¹At-Rh[16aneS₄]-SP_5-11 revealed its potential in killing glioma T98G cells during in vitro studies; therefore further animal studies to are required to determine its in vivo stability and treatment potential in normal and xenografted mice.

Microarray Studies on 211At Administration in BALB/c Nude Mice Indicate Systemic Effects on Transcriptional Regulation in Nonthyroid Tissues

Targeted α-therapy is a promising treatment option for various types of malignant tumors. Radiolabeled cancer-seeking agents, however, undergo degradation, resulting in a certain percentage of free radionuclide in the body. The radiohalogen ²¹¹At accumulates in various tissues, with specifically high uptake in the thyroid. When normal thyroid function is disturbed because of ionizing radiation (IR) exposure, deleterious effects can occur in tissues that depend on thyroid hormone (TH) regulation for normal physiologic function. However, knowledge of systemic effects is still rudimentary. We previously reported similarities in transcriptomic regulation between the thyroid and other tissues despite large differences in absorbed dose from ²¹¹At. Here, we present supportive evidence on systemic effects after ²¹¹At administration.

METHODS

Expression microarray data from the kidney cortex and medulla, liver, lungs, and spleen were used from previous studies in which mice were intravenously injected with 0.064-42 kBq of ²¹¹At and killed after 24 h or injected with 1.7 kBq of ²¹¹At and killed after 1, 6, or 168 h. Controls were mock-treated and killed after 24 h. Literature-based gene signatures were used to evaluate the relative impact from IR- or TH-induced regulation. Thyroid- and TH-associated upstream regulators as well as thyroid-related diseases and functions were generated using functional analysis software.

RESULTS

Responses in IR- or TH-associated gene signatures were tissue-specific and varied over time, and the relative impact of each gene signature differed between the investigated tissues. The liver showed a clear dominance of TH-responding genes. In the kidney cortex, kidney medulla, and lungs, the TH-associated signature was detected to at least an extent similar to the IR-associated signature. The spleen was the single tissue showing regulation of only IR-associated signature genes. Various thyroid-associated diseases and functions were inferred from the data: L-triiodothyronine, TH, TH receptor, and triiodothyronine (reverse) were inferred as upstream regulators with differences in incidence and strength of regulation depending on tissue type.

CONCLUSION

These findings indicate that transcriptional regulation in various nonthyroid tissues was-in part-induced by thyroid (hormone)-dependent signaling. Consideration of the systemic context between tissues could contribute to normal tissue risk assessment and planning of remedial measures.

Transcriptional response in normal mouse tissues after i.v. (211)At administration - response related to absorbed dose, dose rate, and time

Background

In cancer radiotherapy, knowledge of normal tissue responses and toxicity risks is essential in order to deliver the highest possible absorbed dose to the tumor while maintaining normal tissue exposure at non-critical levels. However, few studies have investigated normal tissue responses in vivo after ²¹¹At administration. In order to identify molecular biomarkers of ionizing radiation exposure, we investigated genome-wide transcriptional responses to (very) low mean absorbed doses from ²¹¹At in normal mouse tissues.

Methods

Female BALB/c nude mice were intravenously injected with 1.7 kBq ²¹¹At and killed after 1 h, 6 h, or 7 days or injected with 105 or 7.5 kBq and killed after 1 and 6 h, respectively. Controls were mock-treated. Total RNA was extracted from tissue samples of kidney cortex and medulla, liver, lungs, and spleen and subjected to microarray analysis. Enriched biological processes were categorized after cellular function based on Gene Ontology terms.

Results

Responses were tissue-specific with regard to the number of significantly regulated transcripts and associated cellular function. Dose rate effects on transcript regulation were observed with both direct and inverse trends. In several tissues, Angptl4, Per1 and Per2, and Tsc22d3 showed consistent transcript regulation at all exposure conditions.

Conclusions

This study demonstrated tissue-specific transcriptional responses and distinct dose rate effects after ²¹¹At administration. Transcript regulation of individual genes, as well as cellular responses inferred from enriched transcript data, may serve as biomarkers in vivo. These findings expand the knowledge base on normal tissue responses and may help to evaluate and limit side effects of radionuclide therapy.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13550-014-0078-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Comparative analysis of transcriptional gene regulation indicates similar physiologic response in mouse tissues at low absorbed doses from intravenously administered 211At

(211)At is a promising therapeutic radionuclide because of the nearly optimal biological effectiveness of emitted α-particles. Unbound (211)At accumulates in the thyroid gland and in other vital normal tissues. However, few studies have been performed that assess the (211)At-induced normal-tissue damage in vivo. Knowledge about the extent and quality of resulting responses in various organs offers a new venue for reducing risks and side effects and increasing the overall well-being of the patient during and after therapy.

METHODS

Female BALB/c nude mice were injected intravenously with 0.064-42 kBq of (211)At or mock-treated, and the kidneys, liver, lungs, and spleen were excised 24 h after injection. A transcriptional gene expression analysis was performed in triplicate using RNA microarray technology. Biological processes associated with regulated transcripts were grouped into 8 main categories with 31 subcategories according to gene ontology terms for comparison of regulatory profiles.

RESULTS

A substantial decrease in the total number of regulated transcripts was observed between 0.64 and 1.8 kBq of (211)At for all investigated tissues. Few genes were differentially regulated in each tissue at all absorbed doses. In all tissues, most of these genes showed a nonmonotonous dependence on absorbed dose. However, the direction of regulation generally remained uniform for a given gene. Few known radiation-associated genes were regulated on the transcriptional level, and their expression profile generally appeared to be dose-independent and tissue-specific. The regulatory profiles of categorized biological processes were tissue-specific and reflected the shift in regulatory intensity between 0.64 and 1.8 kBq of (211)At. The profiles revealed strongly regulated and nonregulated subcategories.

CONCLUSION

The strong regulatory change observed between 0.64 and 1.8 kBq is hypothesized to result not only from low-dose effects in each tissue but also from physiologic responses to ionizing radiation-induced damage to, for example, the (211)At-accumulating thyroid gland. The presented results demonstrate the complexity of responses to radionuclides in vivo and highlight the need for further research to also consider physiology in ionizing radiation-induced responses.

Production of [(211)At]-astatinated radiopharmaceuticals and applications in targeted α-particle therapy

(211)At is a promising radionuclide for α-particle therapy of cancers. Its physical characteristics make this radionuclide particularly interesting to consider when bound to cancer-targeting biomolecules for the treatment of microscopic tumors. (211)At is produced by cyclotron irradiation of (209)Bi with α-particles accelerated at ~28 MeV and can be obtained in high radionuclidic purity after isolation from the target. Its chemistry resembles iodine, but there is also a tendency to behave as a metalloid. However, the chemical behavior of astatine has not yet been clearly established, primarily due to the lack of any stable isotopes of this element, which precludes the use of conventional analytical techniques for its characterization. There are also only a limited number of research centers that have been able to produce this element in sufficient amounts to carry out extensive investigations. Despite these difficulties, chemical reactions typically used with iodine can be performed, and a number of biomolecules of interest have been labeled with (211)At. However, most of these compounds exhibit unacceptable instability in vivo due to the weakness of the astatine-biomolecule bond. Nonetheless, several compounds have shown high potential for the treatment of cancers in vitro and in several animal models, thus providing a promising basis that has allowed initiation of the first two clinical studies.

Preclinical evaluation of 227Th-labeled and 177Lu-labeled trastuzumab in mice with HER-2-positive ovarian cancer xenografts

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the present study was to compare the biodistribution, normal tissue toxicity, and therapeutic effect of two low-dose rate radioimmunoconjugates (RICs) in mice with HER2-expressing ovarian cancer xenografts: the α-particle-emitting (227)Th-trastuzumab and the β-particle-emitting (177)Lu-trastuzumab.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Trastuzumab (Herceptin), conjugated to DOTA and radiolabeled with (227)Th or (177)Lu, was injected intravenously into mice bearing SKOV-3 xenografts. The biodistribution was determined at different time points after injection. The organs were collected and measured for radioactivity content using a gamma spectrometer. Inhibition of tumor growth was measured after a single injection of (227)Th-trastuzumab, (227)Th-rituximab, (177)Lu-trastuzumab, trastuzumab alone, and NaCl. The toxicity of (227)Th-trastuzumab and (177)Lu-trastuzumab was evaluated by measurement of body weight, determination of blood cell counts, analysis of clinical chemistry parameters, and histological examination of tissue specimens.

RESULTS

The absorbed radiation dose to the tumor was 4 Gy after administration of 400 kBq/kg (227)Th-trastuzumab and 72 MBq/kg (177)Lu-trastuzumab. A significantly better antitumor effect of (227)Th-trastuzumab (8 and 30 days' growth delay for 400 and 600 kBq/kg, respectively) was observed as compared with untreated control, trastuzumab alone, 600 kBq/kg (227)Th-rituximab (nonspecific targeting), and 72 MBq/kg (177)Lu-trastuzumab. Mean survival of mice after treatment with (227)Th-trastuzumab (107 ± 9 and 129 ± 12 days for 400 and 600 kBq/kg (227)Th-trastuzumab, respectively) was significantly improved compared with control (88 ± 11 days) and other RICs (85 ± 8 and 66 ± 6 days for 72 MBq/kg (177)Lu-trastuzumab and 600 kBq/kg (227)Th-rituximab, respectively) (P<0.05, Kaplan-Meier). Treatment-related toxicity was not observed in any group except for a transient decrease in white blood cells between 3 and 9 weeks after treatment with 400 and 600 kBq/kg (227)Th-trastuzumab.

CONCLUSION

The α-particle-emitting RIC (227)Th-trastuzumab effectively delayed tumor growth and prolonged survival of mice compared with β-emitting (177)Lu-trastuzumab administered at the same absorbed radiation dose to tumor. This new therapeutic approach warrants further studies aiming at clinical testing in patients with micrometastatic ovarian cancer.

Analysis of patient survival in a Phase I trial of systemic targeted α-therapy for metastatic melanoma

Targeted α-therapy is an experimental approach to the management of cancer. Short range α-particle radiation from a radioisotope attached to a targeting monoclonal antibody kills targeted cancer cells. Survival results are analyzed from a previously reported Phase I study of systemic targeted α-therapy for patients with stage IV metastatic melanoma or in-transit metastases. Following intravenous administration of 46-925 MBq of the α-immunoconjugate, (213)Bi-cDTPA-9.2.27, 38 patients were followed to observe response and toxicity. Responses were measured by physical examination, computed tomography at 8 weeks and blood sampling. Toxicity was monitored by blood pathology, urine analysis, glomerular filtration rate and human antimouse antibody response. The maximum tolerance dose was not achieved as there were no adverse events of any type or level. However, an objective partial response rate of 10% was observed, with 40% stable disease at 8 weeks and a median survival of 8.9 months. These results were unexpected because of the short half-life of the (213)Bi and short range of the α-radiation. Survival analysis demonstrated melanoma-inhibitory activity, disease stage, lactate dehydrogenase and treatment effects to be significant prognostic indicators for survival.

Evidence of extranuclear cell sensitivity to alpha-particle radiation using a microdosimetric model. I. Presentation and validation of a microdosimetric model

A microdosimetric model that makes it possible to consider the numerous biological and physical parameters of cellular alpha-particle irradiation by radiolabeled mAbs was developed. It allows for the calculation of single-hit and multi-hit distributions of specific energy within a cell nucleus or a whole cell in any irradiation configuration. Cells are considered either to be isolated or to be packed in a monolayer or a spheroid. The method of calculating energy deposits is analytical and is based on the continuous-slowing-down approximation. A model of cell survival, calculated from the microdosimetric spectra and the microdosimetric radiosensitivity, z(0), was also developed. The algorithm of calculations was validated by comparison with two general Monte Carlo codes: MCNPX and Geant4. Microdosimetric spectra determined by these three codes showed good agreement for numerous geometrical configurations. The analytical method was far more efficient in terms of calculation time: A gain of more than 1000 was observed when using our model compared with Monte Carlo calculations. Good agreements were also observed with previously published results.

Evidence of extranuclear cell sensitivity to alpha-particle radiation using a microdosimetric model. II. Application of the microdosimetric model to experimental results

A microdosimetric model was used to analyze the results of experimental studies on cells of two lymphoid cell lines (T2 and Ada) irradiated with (213)Bi-radiolabeled antibodies. These antibodies targeted MHC/peptide complexes. The density of target antigen could be modulated by varying the concentration of the peptide loaded onto the cells. This offered the possibility of changing the ratio of specific (from cell-bound antibody) to non-specific (from antibody present in the supernatant) irradiation. For both cell lines, survival plotted as a function of the mean absorbed dose was a decreasing exponential. For the T2 cells, the microdosimetric sensitivity calculated for the whole cell was equal whether the irradiation was non-specific (z(0) = 0.12 +/- 0.02 Gy) or specific (z(0) = 0.12 +/- 0.09 Gy). Similar results were obtained for Ada cells. These results constitute a biological validation of the microdosimetric model. For both cells, the measured cell mortality was greater than the percentage of hit cells calculated with the model at low mean absorbed doses. This observation thus suggests bystander effects. It poses the question of the relevance of the mean absorbed dose to the cell nuclei. A new concept in cellular dosimetry taking into account cytoplasm or membrane irradiation and bystander modeling appears to be needed.

Engineered modular recombinant transporters: application of new platform for targeted radiotherapeutic agents to alpha-particle emitting 211 At

PURPOSE

To generate and evaluate a modular recombinant transporter (MRT) for targeting 211 At to cancer cells overexpressing the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The MRT was produced with four functional modules: (1) human epidermal growth factor as the internalizable ligand, (2) the optimized nuclear localization sequence of simian vacuolating virus 40 (SV40) large T-antigen, (3) a translocation domain of diphtheria toxin as an endosomolytic module, and (4) the Escherichia coli hemoglobin-like protein (HMP) as a carrier module. MRT was labeled using N-succinimidyl 3-[211 At]astato-5-guanidinomethylbenzoate (SAGMB), its 125 I analogue SGMIB, or with 131 I using Iodogen. Binding, internalization, and clonogenic assays were performed with EGFR-expressing A431, D247 MG, and U87MG.wtEGFR human cancer cell lines.

RESULTS

The affinity of SGMIB-MRT binding to A431 cells, determined by Scatchard analysis, was 22 nM, comparable to that measured before labeling. The binding of SGMIB-MRT and its internalization by A431 cancer cells was 96% and 99% EGFR specific, respectively. Paired label assays demonstrated that compared with Iodogen-labeled MRT, SGMIB-MRT and SAGMB-MRT exhibited more than threefold greater peak levels and durations of intracellular retention of activity. SAGMB-MRT was 10-20 times more cytotoxic than [211 At]astatide for all three cell lines.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study have demonstrated the initial proof of principle for the MRT approach for designing targeted alpha-particle emitting radiotherapeutic agents. The high cytotoxicity of SAGMB-MRT for cancer cells overexpressing EGFR suggests that this 211 At-labeled conjugate has promise for the treatment of malignancies, such as glioma, which overexpress this receptor.

Peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy for melanoma

Melanocortin-1 receptor (MC1-R) and melanin are two attractive melanoma-specific targets for peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy for melanoma. Radiolabeled peptides targeting MC1-R/melanin can selectively and specifically target cytotoxic radiation generated from therapeutic radionuclides to melanoma cells for cell killing, while sparing the normal tissues and organs. This review highlights the recent advances of peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy of melanoma targeting MC1-R and melanin. The promising therapeutic efficacies of 188Re-(Arg(11))CCMSH (188Re-[Cys(3,4,10), D-Phe(7),Arg(11)]-alpha-MSH(3-13)), 177Lu- and 212Pb-labeled DOTA-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH (1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid-[ReO-(Cys(3,4,10), D-Phe(7), Arg(11))]-alpha-MSH(3-13)) and 188Re-HYNIC-4B4 (188Re-hydrazinonicotinamide-Tyr-Glu-Arg-Lys-Phe-Trp-His-Gly-Arg-His) in preclinical melanoma-bearing models demonstrate an optimistic outlook for peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy for melanoma. Peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy for melanoma will likely contribute in an adjuvant setting, once the primary tumor has been surgically removed, to treat metastatic deposits and for treatment of end-stage disease. The lack of effective treatments for metastatic melanoma and end-stage disease underscores the necessity to develop and implement new treatment strategies, such as peptide-targeted radionuclide therapy.

Clinical experience with alpha-particle emitting 211At: treatment of recurrent brain tumor patients with 211At-labeled chimeric antitenascin monoclonal antibody 81C6

alpha-Particle-emitting radionuclides, such as (211)At, with a 7.2-h half-life, may be optimally suited for the molecularly targeted radiotherapy of strategically sensitive tumor sites, such as those in the central nervous system. Because of the much shorter range and more potent cytotoxicity of alpha-particles than of beta-particles, (211)At-labeled agents may be ideal for the eradication of tumor cells remaining after surgical debulking of malignant brain tumors. The main goal of this study was to investigate the feasibility and safety of this approach in patients with recurrent malignant brain tumors.

METHODS

Chimeric antitenascin monoclonal antibody 81C6 (ch81C6) (10 mg) was labeled with 71-347 MBq of (211)At by use of N-succinimidyl 3-[(211)At]astatobenzoate. Eighteen patients were treated with (211)At-labeled ch81C6 ((211)At-ch81C6) administered into a surgically created resection cavity (SCRC) and then with salvage chemotherapy. Serial gamma-camera imaging and blood sampling over 24 h were performed.

RESULTS

A total of 96.7% +/- 3.6% (mean +/- SD) of (211)At decays occurred in the SCRC, and the mean blood-pool percentage injected dose was < or = 0.3. No patient experienced dose-limiting toxicity, and the maximum tolerated dose was not identified. Six patients experienced grade 2 neurotoxicity within 6 wk of (211)At-ch81C6 administration; this neurotoxicity resolved fully in all but 1 patient. No toxicities of grade 3 or higher were attributable to the treatment. No patient required repeat surgery for radionecrosis. The median survival times for all patients, those with glioblastoma multiforme, and those with anaplastic astrocytoma or oligodendroglioma were 54, 52, and 116 wk, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study provides proof of concept for regional targeted radiotherapy with (211)At-labeled molecules in oncology. Specifically, the regional administration of (211)At-ch81C6 is feasible, safe, and associated with a promising antitumor benefit in patients with malignant central nervous system tumors.

Treatment of solid tumors by interstitial release of recoiling short-lived alpha emitters

A new method utilizing alpha particles to treat solid tumors is presented. Tumors are treated with interstitial radioactive sources which continually release short-lived alpha emitting atoms from their surface. The atoms disperse inside the tumor, delivering a high dose through their alpha decays. We implement this scheme using thin wire sources impregnated with (224)Ra, which release by recoil (220)Rn, (216)Po and (212)Pb atoms. This work aims to demonstrate the feasibility of our method by measuring the activity patterns of the released radionuclides in experimental tumors. Sources carrying (224)Ra activities in the range 10-130 kBq were used in experiments on murine squamous cell carcinoma tumors. These included gamma spectroscopy of the dissected tumors and major organs, Fuji-plate autoradiography of histological tumor sections and tissue damage detection by Hematoxylin-Eosin staining. The measurements focused on (212)Pb and (212)Bi. The (220)Rn/(216)Po distribution was treated theoretically using a simple diffusion model. A simplified scheme was used to convert measured (212)Pb activities to absorbed dose estimates. Both physical and histological measurements confirmed the formation of a 5-7 mm diameter necrotic region receiving a therapeutic alpha-particle dose around the source. The necrotic regions shape closely corresponded to the measured activity patterns. (212)Pb was found to leave the tumor through the blood at a rate which decreased with tumor mass. Our results suggest that the proposed method, termed DART (diffusing alpha-emitters radiation therapy), may potentially be useful for the treatment of human patients.

Implementation of a microdosimetric model for radioimmunotherapeutic alpha emitters

A microdosimetric model for alpha-particle-emitting radiolabeled antibodies, based on an analytic method, was developed to be used for in vitro studies. The model took into consideration cell radii distributions or distributions of activity bound to cells, and calculated the single- and multihit distributions of specific energy within the target. The mean absorbed dose could then be derived from the specific energy spectra. The mean number of hits, the probability that no particle crossed the target, and the average lineal energy transfer at which the energy is deposited were also calculated. Many in vitro geometric configurations of cells (single cell, cellular monolayer, and cellular clusters) and many different distributions of radioactive sources observed in experiments (distribution on the cell surface or within the extracellular volume) could be modeled. To verify the implementation of our algorithm, a comparison was carried out for different sources and target configurations between our model and a general Monte Carlo code (MCNPX). A positive agreement was observed between the two approaches. By using the proposed model, computation speed was greatly improved, as compared with the Monte-Carlo approach. An example of the impact of some parameters (cell radii and activity distributions) on the dosimetric results is also given in this paper.

Melanoma therapy via peptide-targeted {alpha}-radiation

PURPOSE

The therapeutic efficacy of a unique melanoma-targeting peptide conjugated with an in vivo generated alpha-particle-emitting radionuclide was evaluated in the B16/F1 mouse melanoma animal model. alpha-Radiation is densely ionizing, resulting in high concentrations of destructive radicals and irreparable DNA double-strand breaks. This high linear energy transfer overcomes radiation-resistant tumor cells and oxygen effects resulting in potentially high therapeutic indices in tumors such as melanoma.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

The melanoma targeting peptide, 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclodecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid (DOTA)-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH, was radiolabeled with (212)Pb, the parent of (212)Bi, which decays via alpha and beta decay. Biodistribution and therapy studies were done in the B16/F1 melanoma-bearing C57 mouse flank tumor model.

RESULTS

(212)Pb[DOTA]-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH exhibited rapid tumor uptake and extended retention coupled with rapid whole body disappearance. Radiation dose delivered to the tumor was estimated to be 61 cGy/muCi (212)Pb administered. Treatment of melanoma-bearing mice with 50, 100, and 200 muCi of (212)Pb[DOTA]-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH extended their mean survival to 22, 28, and 49.8 days, respectively, compared with the 14.6-day mean survival of the placebo control group. Forty-five percent of the mice receiving 200 muCi doses survived the study disease-free.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment of B16/F1 murine melanoma-bearing mice with (212)Pb[DOTA]-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH significantly decreased tumor growth rates resulting in extended mean survival times, and in many cases, complete remission of disease. (212)Pb-DOTA-Re(Arg(11))CCMSH seems to be a very promising radiopharmaceutical for targeted radionuclide therapy of melanoma.

Cancer radioimmunotherapy with alpha-emitting nuclides

In lymphoid malignancies and in certain solid cancers such as medullary thyroid carcinoma, somewhat mixed success has been achieved when applying radioimmunotherapy (RIT) with beta-emitters for the treatment of refractory cases. The development of novel RIT with alpha-emitters has created new opportunities and theoretical advantages due to the high linear energy transfer (LET) and the short path length in biological tissue of alpha-particles. These physical properties offer the prospect of achieving selective tumoural cell killing. Thus, RIT with alpha-emitters appears particularly suited for the elimination of circulating single cells or cell clusters or for the treatment of micrometastases at an early stage. However, to avoid non-specific irradiation of healthy tissues, it is necessary to identify accessible tumoural targets easily and rapidly. For this purpose, a small number of alpha-emitters have been investigated, among which only a few have been used for in vivo preclinical studies. Another problem is the availability and cost of these radionuclides; for instance, the low cost and the development of a reliable actinium-225/bismuth-213 generator were probably determining elements in the choice of bismuth-213 in the only human trial of RIT with an alpha-emitter. This article reviews the literature concerning monoclonal antibodies radiolabelled with alpha-emitters that have been developed for possible RIT in cancer patients. The principal radio-immunoconjugates are considered, starting with physical and chemical properties of alpha-emitters, their mode of production, the possibilities and difficulties of labelling, in vitro studies and finally, when available, in vivo preclinical and clinical studies.

Simulation of binary methods for the microdosimetric analysis of cell survival after alpha-particle irradiation: ability to distinguish between different models

Analysis of cell survival after alpha-particle irradiation must account for the distribution in the amounts of energy deposited in each cell nucleus. Microdosimetric computations are usually used to determine these distributions. Irradiation with microbeams and other modern techniques has made these computations unnecessary for certain cell geometries. These techniques allow the survival of individual cells to be correlated with the amount of radiation delivered to individual cell nuclei. However, to maintain the individuality of data generated for each cell, new methods of analysis are required. In this study, we propose the use of binary methods. Each cell is regarded as a Bernoulli trial with a different probability for success (colony formation). Parameter values of the survival model are chosen to maximize the likelihood of the observed outcome. To evaluate this method, simulated data for 500, 5000 and 50,000 cells irradiated by alpha particles are analyzed along with the associated outcome for four different cell survival models. Each survival model has a different dependence on the radius of the cell nucleus. These results indicate that the model that was simulated has the highest likelihood value in all cases. However, the ability to distinguish between competing models is present only for a larger numbers of cells.

Dead cells in melanoma tumors provide abundant antigen for targeted delivery of ionizing radiation by a mAb to melanin

Melanoma is a cancer with a rising incidence, and metastatic disease is almost always lethal. We investigated the feasibility of targeting melanin, an intracellular melanocyte pigment, to deliver cytotoxic radiation to human melanoma cells in vivo by using a melanin-binding mAb (6D2). Nude mice bearing MNT1 pigmented human melanoma tumors were treated with mAb 6D2 labeled with 1.5 mCi (1 Ci = 37 GBq) of the beta-emitter 188-Rhenium (188Re) and manifested inhibition of tumor growth and prolonged survival. mAb 6D2 bound tumor melanin and demonstrated no crossreactivity with normal melanized tissues in black mice. The mechanism of melanin targeting involved Ab binding to extracellular melanin released during tumor cell turnover or to dying cells with permeable membranes. In this approach, the cytotoxic radiation emanating from labeled Ab bound to melanin is presumably delivered by "crossfire" effect to the adjacent viable tumor cells. Our results establish the feasibility of targeting melanin released from dead melanoma cells in tumors with radiolabeled Abs to achieve a therapeutic effect. In contrast to conventional tumor antigens, melanin is insoluble, resistant to degradation, and can be expected to accumulate in targeted tissues, suggesting that the efficacy of therapy could increase with each subsequent treatment cycle.

Microdosimetry of astatine-211 single-cell irradiation: role of daughter polonium-211 diffusion

A microdosimetric analysis of previously published data on 211At-albumin, free 211At, and 211At-C215 irradiation of Colo-205 cells in a slowly rotating single-cell suspension is presented. A custom-built computer program based on the Monte Carlo method was used to simulate the irradiation and the energy deposition in individual cell nuclei. Separate simulations were made for the assumption that the 211Po atom stays in the position where it is created, and that it diffuses away. The mean event number at which 37% of all cells survived, n37, and the frequency mean specific energy per event, zF, were estimated. The Poisson distribution of events and simulated single and multievent distributions of specific energy were used to find the single-cell specific energy at which the probability of survival is reduced to 37%, z37. The calculated single-cell radiosensitivity values show that 211Po atoms, created on a cell surface by the decay of 211At atoms, will diffuse from the cell during its life-span. The increasing distance to the cell nucleus will drastically decrease the probability of the emitted alpha particle to hit the nucleus. This will result in fewer alpha-particle events in the cell nucleus. For dispersed cells, the diffusion of 211Po atoms will reduce the total dose from cell-bound 211At by a factor of 2.

Sterically stabilized liposomes as a carrier for alpha-emitting radium and actinium radionuclides

The alpha-particle emitting radionuclides (223)Ra (t(1/2) = 11.4 d), (224)Ra (t(1/2) = 3.6 d), and (225)Ac(t(1/2) = 10.0 d) may have a broad application in targeted radiotherapy provided that they could be linked to vehicles with tumor affinity. The potential usefulness of liposomes as carriers was studied in the present work. Radium and actinium radionuclides could be loaded in good yields into sterically stabilized liposomes. Subsequent coating of the liposomes with a folate-F(ab')(2) construct yielded a product with affinity towards tumor cells expressing folate receptors. Radionuclide loaded liposomes showed excellent stability in serum in vitro.

In vitro and preclinical targeted alpha therapy of human prostate cancer with Bi-213 labeled J591 antibody against the prostate specific membrane antigen

Limited options for the treatment of prostate cancer have spurred the search for new therapies. One innovative approach is the use of targeted alpha therapy (TAT) to inhibit cancer growth, using an alpha particle emitting radioisotope such as (213)Bi. Because of its short range and high linear energy transfer (LET), alpha-particles may be particularly effective in the treatment of cancer, especially in inhibiting the development of metastatic tumors from micro-metastases. Prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSMA) is expressed in prostate cancer cells and the neovasculature of a wide variety of malignant neoplasms including lung, colon, breast and others, but not in normal vascular endothelium. The expression is further increased in higher-grade cancers, metastatic disease and hormone-refractory prostate cancer (PCA). J591 is one of several monoclonal antibodies (mabs) to the extracellular domain of PSMA. Chelation of J591 mab with (213)Bi forms the alpha-radioimmunoconjugate (AIC). The objective of this preclinical study was to design an injectable AIC to treat human prostate tumors growing subcutaneously in mice. The anti-proliferative effects of AIC against prostate cancer were tested in vitro using the MTS assay and in vivo with the nude mice model. Apoptosis was documented using terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase [TdT]-mediated deoxyuridinetriphosphate [dUTP] nick end-labeling (TUNEL) assay, while proliferative index was assessed using the Ki-67 marker. We show that a very high density of PSMA is expressed in an androgen-dependent human PCA cell line (LNCaP-LN3) and in tumor xenografts from nude mice. We also demonstrate that the AIC extensively inhibits the growth of LN3 cells in vitro in a concentration-dependent fashion, causing the cells to undergo apoptosis. Our in vivo studies showed that a local AIC injection of 50 microCi at 2 days post-cell inoculation gave complete inhibition of tumor growth, whereas results for a non-specific AIC were similar to those for untreated mice. Further, after 1 and 3 weeks post-tumor appearance, a single (100 microCi/100 microl) intra-lesional injection of AIC can inhibit the growth of LN3 tumor xenografts (volume<100 mm(3)) in nude mice. Tumors treated with AIC decreased in volume from a mean 46+/-14 mm(3) in the first week or 71+/-15 mm(3) in the third week to non-palpable, while in control mice treated with a non-specific AIC using the same dose, tumor volume increased from 42 to 590 mm(3). There were no observed side effects of the treatment. Because of its in vitro cytotoxicity and these anti-proliferative properties in vivo, the (213)Bi-J591 conjugate has considerable potential as a new therapeutic agent for the treatment of prostate cancer.

Characterization of an alpha-particle irradiator for individual cell dosimetry measurements

A computer-controlled, alpha-particle irradiator is described that allows for the measurement of the number and location of alpha-particle hits to individual cell nuclei, and subsequent scoring of cell survival. Cells are grown on a track-etch material (LR 115) and images are obtained of the cells prior to irradiation. The cells are then irradiated from below by a planar, collimated Am-241 source. The exposure time is varied so that the average number of hits to cell nuclei ranges from 0 to 3. After cell survival has been scored, images of the etched material are obtained and spatially registered to the original cell images. The etched images and cellular images are superimposed allowing for the determination of the number and position of hits to individual cell nuclei. This paper characterizes the irradiator including the energy and fluence of the incident alpha particles. Additionally, we describe the sources of uncertainty associated with this experiment, including the cell dish repositioning and cell migration during scanning and irradiation.

Preclinical studies of targeted alpha therapy for breast cancer using 213Bi-labelled-plasminogen activator inhibitor type 2

The control of micrometastatic breast cancer remains problematic. To this end, we are developing a new adjuvant therapy based on (213)Bi-PAI2, in which an alpha-emitting nuclide ((213)Bi) is chelated to the plasminogen activator inhibitor-2 (PAI2). PAI2 targets the cell-surface receptor bound urokinase plasminogen activator (uPA), which is involved with the metastatic spread of cancer cells. We have successfully labelled and tested recombinant human PAI2 with the alpha radioisotope (213)Bi to produce (213)Bi-PAI2, which is highly cytotoxic towards breast cancer cell lines. In this study, the 2-day postinoculation model, using MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells, was shown to be representative of micrometastatic disease. Our in vivo efficacy experiments show that a single local injection of (213)Bi-PAI2 can completely inhibit the growth of tumour at 2 days postcell inoculation, and a single systemic (i.p.) administration at 2 days causes tumour growth inhibition in a dose-dependent manner. The specific role of uPA as the target for (213)Bi-PAI2 therapy was determined by PAI2 pretreatment blocking studies. In vivo toxicity studies in nude mice indicate that up to 100 microCi of (213)Bi-PAI2 is well tolerated. Thus, (213)Bi-PAI2 is successful in targeting isolated breast cancer cells and preangiogenic cell clusters. These results indicate the promising potential of (213)Bi-PAI2 as a novel therapeutic agent for micrometastatic breast cancer.

Progress in immunoconjugate cancer therapeutics

Advances in immunoconjugate technology have revitalized the "magic bullet" concept of immunotherapeutics for the treatment of cancer. The growing availability of "human" antibodies, the increased epitope repertoire due to genomics and proteomics efforts, and advances in the means of identification and production of tumor-specific antibodies have greatly increased the potential for cancer therapeutic opportunities. Furthermore, the realization that effector molecule potency must be sufficiently high to be effective at concentrations that might realistically be delivered to the tumor site on an antibody carrier has greatly spurred the fields of medicinal chemistry and radionuclide chelate chemistry to produce such molecules.

Proteoglycans and tumor progression: Janus-faced molecules with contradictory functions in cancer

Understanding the details of the molecular mechanism of tumor dissemination revealed that several proteoglycan species are involved in the process but their role can be described as Janus-faced. One level of proteoglycan alterations is at the expression of their genes coding for the core protein. Characteristically, in progressing tumors two patterns emerged: loss or neoexpression of surface proteoglycans (PG) depending on the initial expression pattern of the cell type of origin. The situation is similarly complex concerning the changes of glycosaminoglycan (GAG) of the PG during tumor progression. This is due to the fact that the majority of PGs involved is hybrid molecule meaning that their core protein can be glycanated both with chondroitin and heparan sulfate. However, such an alteration in glycanation of PG may fundamentally change the function of the molecule, especially the one operating at the cell surface. Among the extracellular PGs, decorin emerged as inhibitor of progression while perlecan as a promoter of the process. Analysis of the available data indicate that during metastatization tumor cells must express at least one cell surface HSPG species from the syndecan-glypican-CD44v3 group. Furthermore, the HS-chain of these proteoglycan(s) carry important molecular signatures (suphution or epimerization patterns). Experimental data suggest that tumor cell surface heparan sulfate (PG) may provide a target for specific anti-metastatic interventions.

In vitro testing of the leukaemia monoclonal antibody WM-53 labeled with alpha and beta emitting radioisotopes

We report the preparation and testing of a new alpha emitting radio-immunoconjugate (RIC) against acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) using CD33 positive monoclonal antibody WM-53 (specific for HL-60 cell line). Using cyclic anhydride of diethylenetriaminepentacetic acid (cDTPAa) as chelator, antibody was labeled with 213Bi (alpha), 149Tb (alpha), 153Sm (beta) and 152Tb (positron). In vitro testing showed high labeling efficiency (90-95%) and stability (11-19% leaching) with immunoreactivity virtually the same before and after labeling. DNA synthesis data and MTS cell survival were compared for all RICs. Only the alpha emitter was found to be capable of inhibiting DNA synthesis and had selective cell kill with activity as low as 2-3 microCi. The high stability and outstanding cytotoxicity of the 213Bi conjugate provides the basis for targeted alpha therapy for the control of metastatic and disseminated cancer such as AML.

In vitro cytotoxicity of bismuth-213 (213Bi)-labeled-plasminogen activator inhibitor type 2 (alpha-PAI-2) on human breast cancer cells

Metastasis is the principal cause of death in breast cancer patients. New and improved treatments for eradicating micrometastases are needed. To this end, a novel alpha-emitting protein construct, 213Bi-labelled plasminogen activator inhibitor type-2 (PAI-2) (alpha-PAI-2), was evaluated in vitro. This construct exploits: (a) the overexpression of the cell-surface receptor bound urokinase plasminogen activator (uPA) in the metastatic spread of breast cancer cells; (b) the binding and inhibition of receptor-bound uPA by PAI-2; and (c) the high cytotoxicity of alpha radiation. High labeling efficiencies and stability of 213Bi bound to human recombinant PAI-2 conjugated with cyclic diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid anhydride were achieved (greater than 90%). The uPA inhibitory activity of the chelated PAI-2 was maintained as determined by complex formation with uPA and by inhibition of uPA activity. Furthermore, the reactivity of alpha-PAI-2 was confirmed in a cell assay as this construct was highly cytotoxic to breast cancer cell lines that express active, receptor bound uPA. The specificity of alpha-PAI-2 targeting was shown using several controls. Firstly, an active uPA blocking agent that limits PAI-2 binding significantly improved cell survival by a factor greater than three. Secondly, a non-specific alpha-BSA construct had minimal cytotoxic effect. Moreover, alpha-PAI-2 was not cytotoxic to freshly isolated normal human leukocytes, confirming that cells which do not contain active, receptor bound uPA cannot be targeted by alpha-PAI-2. In conclusion, we have validated, in vitro, the potential of alpha-PAI-2 as a novel therapeutic agent for breast cancer.

In vitro and preclinical studies of targeted alpha therapy (TAT) for colorectal cancer

INTRODUCTION

Effective targeted cancer therapy requires high selectivity and cytotoxicity of the labelled product. We report the preparation and testing of anticolorectal cancer monoclonal antibody c30.6 radioimmunoconjugates (RIC) labelled with alpha-emitting Bismuth-213 and positron emitting Terbium-152 using two chelators, viz. Cyclic dianhydride of diethylenetriaminepentacetic acid (DTPA) and CHX-A" (a DTPA derivative).

METHODS

Selectivity and stability of the RIC were tested in vitro (flow cytometry) and in vivo (biodistribution, organ/tumour uptake and retention). Cytotoxicity assays were carried out using tritiated thymidine uptake (inhibition of DNA synthesis) and MTS assay.

RESULTS

High labelling efficiency (ranging between 89 and 91%) and stability over 2-5 half-lives of the isotopes were seen. Kidney retention was not seen in contrast to high uptake and retention of both conjugates in tumours. Flow cytometry studies showed high specificity of the antibody before and after labelling and this unchanged targeting behaviour was reflected in cytotoxicity assays. These assays showed that only alpha-labelled antibody could selectively kill the cancer cells for activities as low as 2-3 microCi. The study also revealed that free isotopes or isotopes bound to nonspecific antibodies did not kill cancer cells.

CONCLUSION

The stability of the RICs and outstanding cytotoxicity of the alpha emitter, together with no kidney retention and high tumour uptake and retention of the radiolabel, offers a new approach for the potential control of colorectal cancer.

In vitro and preclinical targeted alpha therapy for melanoma, breast, prostate and colorectal cancers

Targeted alpha therapy (TAT) can inhibit the growth of micrometastases by selectively killing isolated and preangiogenic clusters of cancer cells. The alpha emitting radioisotopes Tb-149 and Bi-213 were chelated to cancer specific monoclonal antibodies to form alpha-immunoconjugates (AIC) against melanoma, leukaemia, prostate and colorectal cancer, and to the plasminogen activator inhibitor type-2 (PAI2) to form alpha-PAI2 (API) against breast and prostate cancer. These conjugates were found to be highly stable, specific and cytotoxic in vitro. Melanoma and breast cancer tumour growth was observed in nude mouse models for untreated controls and non-specific AIC/API at 2 days post-subcutaneous inoculation of cancer cells. Complete inhibition of melanoma and breast cancer growth was found for local injections of AIC and API, respectively. Intra-lesional TAT of established melanoma showed that all melanomas regressed with 100 microCi injections of AIC. These results point to the potential application of local and systemic TAT in the management of metastatic cancer.

Similarities and differences between free 211At and 125I- transport in porcine thyroid epithelial cells cultured in bicameral chambers

The transport and accumulation of free 211At and 125I- were investigated in thyrocytes cultured as monolayers in bicameral chambers under the influence of thyroid-stimulating hormone, stable iodide, ouabain and perchlorate. The results indicate that there are similarities and differences in the transport mechanisms of free 211At and 125I-. These results will be valuable in the development of radiation protection when handling and using 211At-labeled radiopharmaceuticals, and for the potential use of free 211At in radiation therapy of poorly differentiated thyroid cancer.

Tumor control probability model for alpha-particle-emitting radionuclides

Alpha-particle emitters are currently being evaluated for the treatment of metastatic disease. The dosimetry of alpha-particle emitters is a challenge, however, because the stochastic patterns of energy deposition within cellular targets must be taken into account. We propose a model for the tumor control probability of alpha-particle emitters which takes into account these stochastic effects. An expression for cell survival, which is a function of the microdosimetric single-event specific-energy distribution, is multiplied by the number of cells within the tumor cluster. Poisson statistics is used to model the probability of zero surviving cells within the cluster. Based on this analysis, a number of observations have been made: (1) The dose required to eradicate a tumor is nearly a linear function of the cell survival parameter z(0). (2) Cells with smaller nuclei will require more dose to achieve the same level of tumor control probability, relative to cells with larger nuclei, for an identical source-target configuration and cell sensitivity. (3) As the targeting of alpha-particle emitters becomes more specific, the dose required to achieve a given level of tumor control decreases. (4) Additional secondary effects include cell shape and the initial alpha-particle energy.

Radiotoxicity of systemically administered 211At-labeled human/mouse chimeric monoclonal antibody: a long-term survival study with histologic analysis

PURPOSE

The antitenascin human/mouse chimeric monoclonal antibody labeled with the alpha-particle-emitting radionuclide 211At is of interest as an endoradiotherapeutic agent for the treatment of brain tumors. To facilitate the investigation of 211At-labeled chimeric 81C6 in patients, the long-term radiotoxicity of this radiopharmaceutical has been evaluated.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Antibody labeling was performed using N-succinimidyl 3-[211At]astato-benzoate. After an initial dose-finding experiment, a second toxicity study was carried out at 4 dose levels in groups of 30 nonthyroid blocked B6C3F1 mice per group (15 males, 15 females). Male mice received either saline or 15-81 kBq/g and females received either saline or 16-83 kBq/g of 211At-labeled antibody. Ten animals (5 males, 5 females) were followed for 6 months and the remainder for 1 year.

RESULTS

The lethal dose in 10% of animals (LD10) for 211At-labeled chimeric 81C6 was 46 kBq/g in females and 102 kBq/g in males. Toxic effects--perivascular fibrosis of the intraventricular septum of the heart, bone marrow suppression, splenic white pulp atrophy, and spermatic maturational delay--generally were confined to a few animals receiving the highest doses of labeled antibody.

CONCLUSIONS

The LD10 of 211At-labeled chimeric 81C6 in this mouse strain was about half that of [211At]astatide. These results establish the preclinical maximum tolerated dose of 211At-labeled chimeric 81C6 and define in the mouse the target organs for toxicity. These studies will be useful for determining starting doses for clinical studies with 211At-labeled chimeric 81C6.