Risk of diphtheria among schoolchildren in the Russian Federation in relation to time since last vaccination

BACKGROUND

Between 1990 and 1996, more than 110,000 cases and 2900 deaths from diphtheria were reported in the Russian Federation. In 1994, because disease rates were high among children aged 7-10 years, the age of administration of the second booster dose of diphtheria vaccine was lowered from 9 years to 6 years, the age of school entry. To assess the impact of this policy change, we did a matched case-control study in three Russian cities.

METHODS

Children aged 6-8 years who had diphtheria between September, 1994, and December, 1996, were each matched with five to seven children acting as controls who were within 3 months of age of the case and were from the same class at school. We did a matched analysis using conditional logistic regression.

FINDINGS

We analysed the immunisation records of 58 cases and 306 controls. All but one case and all controls had received at least three doses of diphtheria-toxoid vaccine. 19 (33%) cases and 144 (47%) controls had received a booster dose of diphtheria toxoid within the previous 2 years. Cases were more likely than were controls to have received only four doses rather than five (odds ratio 2.8 [95% CI 1.2-6.5]) and to have a time since the last dose of diphtheria toxoid of 3-4 years (3.1 [1.1-9.1]) or 5-7 years (15.0 [2.5-89.0]), compared with children for whom it was 2 years or less. On multivariate analysis only a time since the last dose of 5-7 years remained significantly associated with disease (matched odds ratio adjusted for total number of doses 10.9 [1.6-75.1]).

CONCLUSION

A booster dose of diphtheria-toxoid vaccine given to children in the Russian Federation at 6-8 years of age reduced the interval since the last dose of diphtheria toxoid and improved protection against diphtheria.

Measles epidemiology and outbreak response immunization in a rural community in Peru

Only limited data are available on the impact of measles outbreak response immunization (ORI) in developing countries. We conducted a community survey in Espindola, a rural border community in northern Peru, following a measles outbreak and subsequent ORI to study the epidemiology and impact of the outbreak and to evaluate the costs and benefits of measles ORI. During the outbreak, 150 of the 553 Espindola residents developed clinical cases of measles. Adults accounted for 44.0% of cases, and were frequently identified as primary cases. The attack rate among all susceptible people was 45.5% and was highest (61.2%) for the 16-20 year age group. Among adults, significant risk factors for developing measles included being aged 16-20 years (relative risk [RR] = 3.06, 95% CI = 2.08, 4.49) and being male (RR = 1.73, 95% CI = 1.11, 2.71). Among serologically confirmed cases, 60.7% developed diarrhoea and 32.1% pneumonia. The overall case-fatality rate was 3.3%, but reached 19.1% in the 0-23-month age group. Failure to reach children through either routine immunization or national campaigns made this community vulnerable to the severe and extensive impact of measles virus importation. The ORI campaign targeted non-measles case children aged 6 months to 15 years, regardless of their previous immunization status, and was effective in terminating this measles outbreak and in preventing morbidity, loss of livelihood and death despite the involvement of large numbers of adults in measles transmission. The last measles case occurred within 3 weeks of completing ORI. The ORI campaign, which would have cost approximately US$ 3000 in 1998, saved as many as 1155 person-days of work among 77 adults, prevented an estimated 87 cases of diarrhoea and 46 cases of pneumonia, and averted 5 deaths.

Comparison of AIK-C measles vaccine in infants at 6 months with Schwarz vaccine at 9 months: a randomized controlled trial in Ghana

In a randomized controlled trial in a measles endemic area, standard-dose (4.0 log10pfu) AIK-C measles vaccine administered at 6 months of age was compared to standard-dose Schwarz vaccine (3.7log10pfu) given at 9 months. Seroconversion rates at 3 and 6 months after immunization in the two groups were comparable and similar. The geometric mean titres achieved were, however, significantly higher in the Schwarz group (P < 0.05). No immediate serious side-effects were observed with either vaccine. We conclude that standard-dose AIK-C measles vaccine can be recommended for measles immunization in children below 9 months of age, especially in highly endemic and high-risk areas in developing countries.

Safety and immunogenicity of oral killed whole cell recombinant B subunit cholera vaccine in Barranquilla, Colombia

In January and February 1992, an assessment was conducted of the safety and immunogenicity of two doses of a new oral cholera vaccine prepared from the recombinant B subunit of the toxin and from killed whole cells (rBS/WC) in 1,165 individuals between the ages of 12 months and 64 years in Barranquilla, Colombia. This was a randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled study. Participants received two doses of either the vaccine or a placebo (killed Escherichia coli K12) over a two-week interval. Few symptoms were detected during the three days following administration of the initial dose and even fewer following the second. Sera obtained upon administration of the first dose and two weeks after administration of the second were tested for Vibrio cholerae 01 Inaba vibriocidal antibodies and antitoxins. Geometric mean titers (GMT) of vibriocidal antibodies were found to increase two-fold in subjects receiving the vaccine. In the paired samples taken from vaccinated subjects, two-fold or greater increases were observed in 44% and four-fold or greater increases were observed in 34%, as compared to similar increases in 9.2% and 2.2% of the sera taken from those receiving the placebo (P < 0.05). The GMTs of IgG and IgA antitoxins, as determined by ELISA, increased by factors of 4 and 3.2, respectively, in those receiving the vaccine, as compared to factors of 1.1 and 1.1 in those given the placebo (P < 0.001 for IgG, P < 0.01 for IgA). Approximately 80% of the paired samples from the vaccinated group showed an increase of both IgG and IgA antitoxins > or = 1.5, as compared to only about 20% of those in the placebo group (P < 0.000001). Belonging to the O blood group did not significantly affect the immune response. Children under age four tended to show a weaker vibriocidal antibody response and a stronger antitoxin response than older subjects. The two doses of oral vaccine were found to be safe and without attributable side-effects. The vibriocidal antibody and antitoxin responses were similar to those obtained previously with the conventional oral killed whole cell B subunit cholera vaccine.

Reduced doses of hepatitis B vaccines: is it a good idea?

Hepatitis B vaccines are not generic products and it cannot be assumed that all such vaccines can be used in reduced doses in order to save costs. Any use of vaccines in an unlicensed manner should only be performed in the context of a study that is approved by the national control authority and appropriate ethical review committees.

Intradermal administration of measles vaccines

The aim of the study reported here was to determine if bifurcated needles or multiple puncture cylinders would prove suitable for administration of measles vaccines. Children 9 to 11 months old in São Paulo, Brazil, were assigned to receive either Biken-Cam 70 (5,000 TCID50/0.5 ml) or Edmonston-Zagreb (7,000 TCID50/0.5 ml) measles vaccines intradermally with a bifurcated needle or a multiple puncture cylinder. These devices are usually used to administer smallpox or BCG vaccine. The volume of vaccine inoculated was approximately 0.003 ml. Measles IgG antibodies were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) at the time of vaccination and 8 weeks later. The study participants were examined 14 days after inoculation for possible adverse reactions. Overall, the children's average age was 9.5 +/- 0.66 months at vaccination. None of the 45 recipients of Biken-Cam vaccine responded serologically. The 49 Edmonston-Zagreb vaccine recipients immunized with the multiple puncture cylinder had a somewhat higher serologic response rate (35%) and mean concentration of measles antibodies (323 mIU/ml) than those 51 who received the same vaccine administered with the bifurcated needle (26% and 291 mIU/ml, respectively). The rates of reported symptoms after vaccination did not differ significantly among the groups. Overall, the low serologic response rates following intradermal immunization with for devices tested in this study indicate that this route of administration is not suitable for routine administration of standard-titer vaccines.

The immunogenicity and safety of Haemophilus influenzae type b-tetanus toxoid conjugate vaccine in Gambian infants

In developing countries, Haemophilus influenzae type b is a major cause of meningitis and pneumonia in the 1st year of life. The safety and immunogenicity of a Haemophilus influenzae type b polysaccharide-tetanus toxoid conjugate vaccine (PRP-T) were evaluated in two studies of Gambian infants. In the first study, 131 infants were recruited and randomized into three groups to receive PRP-T at 1 and 3 months (group A), PRP-T at 2 and 4 months (group B) or no PRP-T (group C). The liquid form of PRP-T was used. The geometric mean titre (GMT) of anti-PRP antibody 1 month after the second dose was 0.26 microgram/ml in group A and 0.41 microgram/ml in group B. In the second study, 66 infants were given PRP-T in the lyophilized form at 2, 3 and 4 months of age. The GMT 1 month after the first dose was 0.09 microgram/ml, after the second 0.74 microgram/ml and after the third 2.32 micrograms/ml. After the third dose, 72% of children had antibody levels greater than 1.0 microgram/ml and 93% greater than 0.15 microgram/ml. No serious side-effects were observed and the rate of adverse reactions was consistent with the concurrent administration of diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DPT) vaccine.

Lessons from Cuba: mass campaign administration of trivalent oral poliovirus vaccine and seroprevalence of poliovirus neutralizing antibodies

The immunogenicity of trivalent oral poliovirus vaccine (TOPV), which is less effective in tropical than in temperate areas, may potentially be improved in several ways, including increasing the number of doses. Little information is available on TOPV when more than 6 doses are given. The situation in Cuba provides a unique opportunity to relate the seroprevalence of neutralizing antibodies to the dose of TOPV because Cuba has not reported culture-confirmed poliomyelitis since 1973 and TOPV is only administered in twice yearly 1-week mass immunization campaigns. Sera from 2000 children nationwide were studied for neutralizing antibody among children who received 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 doses of TOPV. These doses were administered in the period 1989-91, when TOPV (from the USSR) was being used with 500,000, 200,000, and 300,000 median tissue-culture-infecting doses (TCID50) for types 1, 2 and 3, respectively--the 5:2:3 formulation. Seroprevalence of neutralizing antibody after two TOPV doses was 91.5% for type 1, 90.8% for type 2, and 45.9% for type 3. Seroprevalence of type-3 neutralizing antibody after 6 doses remained low (73.4%), but increased to 83.5% after 8 doses (P < 0.05). Although 16.5% of the children remained unprotected for type-3 infection even after 8 doses, mass campaign immunization strategies were sufficient to eradicate the transmission of wild poliovirus in Cuba. Because the seroprevalence of type-1 neutralizing antibody was high (91.5%) after two campaign doses, additional studies using different formulations are needed to determine whether simultaneous improvement in the type-3 response to two campaign doses can be achieved.

Immunogenicity of a supplemental dose of oral versus inactivated poliovirus vaccine

In many developing countries, the immunogenicity of three doses of live, attenuated, oral poliovirus vaccine (OPV) is lower than that in industrialised countries. We evaluated serum neutralising antibody responses in 368 children aged 6 months and 346 children aged 9 months in Côte d'Ivoire who had previously received three doses of OPV at 2, 3, and 4 months of age, and who were then randomised to receive a supplemental dose of OPV or enhanced-potency inactivated poliovirus vaccine (IPV) at the time of measles vaccination. Although both vaccines increased seroconversion to all three poliovirus types, antibody responses were greater in the IPV group. Among children with no detectable antibody at baseline, IPV was 2 to 14 times more likely than OPV to induce seroconversion (type 1, 80% vs 40% at 6 months [p < 0.001] and 81% vs 14% at 9 months [p < 0.001]; type 3, 76% vs 22% at 6 months [p < 0.001], and 67% vs 5% at 9 months [p < 0.001]. Among children with detectable antibody at baseline, IPV was 1.4 to 7 times more likely than OPV to elicit 4-fold or more rises in antibody titre (p < 0.01). Geometric mean titres (GMTs) to all three poliovirus types were also consistently higher among IPV recipients than in OPV recipients when measured 4-6 weeks and 13-17 months after vaccination. Administration of a supplemental dose of IPV or OPV, which requires no additional visits or changes in the existing immunisation schedule, might improve protection against paralytic poliomyelitis in communities with suboptimum seroconversion rates after three doses of OPV.

Intravasal application of BCG (Bacille Calmette Guerin) is not an effective method for control of fertility in the male: a preliminary report

Bacille Calmette Guerin (BCG) was applied intravasally in male rats with the hope of developing a method for control of fertility in the male. Our results, however, suggest that this approach is not feasible for control of male fertility.

Clinical efficacy of trivalent oral poliomyelitis vaccine: a case-control study

A case-control study was carried out between May 1988 and May 1989 to assess the effectiveness of three doses of trivalent oral poliomyelitis vaccine (TOPV3) in children aged 6-35 months in Madras city. All the cases were patients with acute paralytic poliomyelitis who were residing in Madras city and were hospitalized in the Institute of Child Health; they represented 95% of such cases in the city. The diagnosis was based on clinical grounds and confirmed by stool culture which was positive in 60%. Age- and sex-matched controls, all residing in the city of Madras, were recruited concurrently from the Institute's outpatient department. There were 78 cases and 315 controls. Vaccine efficacy observed for TOPV3 was 81% (95% CI, 58-91%) for the 6-35-month age group and 86% (95% CI, 67-94%) for the 6-23-month age group. Vaccine efficacy, after controlling for age using the Mantel-Haenszel method, was 83% (95% CI, 67-91%). An unimmunized child was at 5 times greater risk of developing acute paralytic poliomyelitis than a fully immunized child.

Expanded programme on immunization (EPI). Safety of high titre measles vaccines

Unexpected results suggesting decreased survival when compared with standard titre vaccine administered at 9 months of age have been found in some field studies evaluating the performance of high titre measles vaccine. Analytical difficulties have arisen because the studies were not specifically designed to measure survival. Nonetheless, careful analysis of the results from all of the high titre vaccine trials showed decreased survival of high titre vaccine recipients, in areas with high background mortality rates, compared with recipients of standard measles vaccines at 9 months. No systematic biases could be found in the studies to explain these differences. Statistical analysis of these data suggested that the findings were unlikely to be attributable to chance alone. The panel recommended that high titre measles vaccine derived from the original Edmonston measles vaccine isolate should no longer be recommended for use in immunization programmes. Further post-licensure field studies of new measles vaccines should take into account the results of these studies. Additional detailed epidemiological studies in populations that have received high titre vaccines and their controls were encouraged.

Epidemic poliomyelitis in The Gambia following the control of poliomyelitis as an endemic disease. II. Clinical efficacy of trivalent oral polio vaccine

An epidemic of poliomyelitis caused by poliovirus type 1 occurred in The Gambia from May to November 1986. Descriptive findings and vaccination coverage levels are reported in part I. This article (part II) describes a case-control study to estimate the clinical efficacy of three or more doses of trivalent oral polio vaccine compared with zero doses. "Cases" were 1- to 7-year-old children paralyzed during the epidemic who were diagnosed as having poliomyelitis by designated referral physicians. They were identified by reports from referral physicians during the epidemic and by a nationwide village-to-village search after the epidemic. Up to five controls were randomly selected for each case from among children of the same age and sex living in neighboring households. In a matched analysis of 195 cases and 839 controls, the efficacy of three or more doses of trivalent oral polio vaccine was 72% (95% confidence interval 57-82) when children without vaccination cards were considered unvaccinated. The efficacy of three or more doses in 1- to 2-year-old children, in whom the determination of vaccination status was considered to be more accurate than in older children, was 81% (95% confidence interval 66-90). Vaccine failure was not associated with short intervals between doses. Higher levels of vaccination coverage and efficacy than those achieved in The Gambia may be needed in African countries to prevent the return of poliomyelitis as an epidemic disease after it has been controlled as an endemic disease.

Comparison of the immune response of four different dosages of a yeast-recombinant hepatitis B vaccine in Singapore children: a four-year follow-up study

The immunogenicity of four different dosages of yeast-derived hepatitis B vaccine (Merck, Sharp & Dohme: 0.6 micrograms, 1.25 micrograms, 2.5 micrograms and 5.0 micrograms), administered at 0, 1 and 6 months (0-1-6 schedule) intramuscularly, was evaluated in 122 seronegative healthy children 1-12 years of age. Three months after the first dose, 83.9-100% of the vaccinees seroconverted. Peak geometric mean titres (GMT) of between 1088 mlU/ml and 1699 mlU/ml were attained 3 months after completion of the vaccination schedule. After 24 months, anti-HBs (antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen) was detected in 93.1-100% of the vaccinees, but the GMT dropped to between 214.3 mlU/ml and 303.5 mlU/ml. After 48 months, 88.8-100% of the vaccinees continued to possess anti-HBs and 70.3-87% had titres above 10 mlU/ml. As expected, the GMT declined further to between 72.6 mlU/ml and 118.8 mlU/ml. There were no significant differences in seroconversion rates and GMT among the different dosage groups. All the vaccinees remained asymptomatic and free from hepatitis B virus infection. The study showed that reduced dosages of the vaccine (0.6 micrograms, 1.25 micrograms and 2.5 micrograms) were as immunogenic as the standard dose (5 micrograms); the 2.5-micrograms dose was recommended for the national childhood immunization programme in Singapore. No booster is necessary for at least four years after vaccination.

Oral immunisation against typhoid fever in Indonesia with Ty21a vaccine

When tested under conditions of moderate transmission of typhoid fever, a liquid formulation of the oral typhoid fever vaccine Ty21a had a protective efficacy of 96% in Egypt, and an enteric coated capsule formulation had an efficacy of 67% in Chile. We compared the two formulations under conditions of intense transmission of typhoid fever in Indonesia in a randomised, double-blind trial. 20,543 subjects (age range 3-44 years) received either three doses of enteric coated capsules containing placebo or live Ty21a, or three doses of lyophilised placebo or live Ty21a reconstituted with phosphate buffer. During 30 months of follow-up, the rate of blood-culture-positive typhoid fever among controls was 810/100,000 per year. Rates of typhoid fever were 379/100,000 per year for subjects who received the liquid formulation of vaccine and 468/100,000 per year for subjects who received enteric coated capsules. The protective efficacies of the liquid and enteric coated formulations were 53% and 42%, respectively. Neither formulation protected against infection with Salmonella paratyphi A. No major side-effects were noted, but the overall incidence of side-effects was greater in the vaccine groups. Under conditions of intense transmission, Ty21a protected against typhoid fever; however, because Ty21a will not protect all individuals, there is a need for additional approaches to prevent the disease.

Child mortality after high-titre measles vaccines: prospective study in Senegal

The use of Edmonston-Zagreb high-titre (EZ-HT) vaccine at age 6 months has been recommended for countries in which measles before the age of 9 months is a substantial cause of death, but little is known about the long-term effects of high-titre live measles vaccines given early in life. In a randomised vaccine trial in a rural area of Senegal, children were randomly assigned at birth to three vaccine groups: EZ-HT at 5 months (n = 336); Schwarz high-titre (SW-HT) at 5 months (n = 321); and placebo at 5 months followed by standard low-titre Schwarz vaccine at 10 months (standard: n = 358). All children were prospectively followed for 24-39 months in a well-established demographic surveillance system. Child mortality after immunisation was significantly higher in the two groups which received high-titre vaccines than in the group given the standard vaccine. The relative risk of death was 1.80 (95% confidence interval [CI] 1.18-2.74; p = 0.007) in the EZ-HT group and 1.51 (0.97-2.34; p = 0.07) in the SW-HT group compared with the standard group. The three vaccine groups were comparable as regards various social, family, and health characteristics, and there was no difference in mortality between children who received the standard vaccine and those who were eligible for the trial but did not take part for various reasons. The higher risk of death in the two high-titre vaccine groups remained significant in multivariate analyses. These findings suggest a need to reconsider the use of high-titre measles vaccines early in life in less developed countries.

Use of hCG stimulation test in women immunized with beta-hCG vaccine

Eleven normally menstruating women, who had earlier been immunized with NII beta-hCG vaccine but had no detectable anti-hCG antibody titres, were selected as controls for the hCG challenge test using 1000/2000 I.U. The test was repeated in five of them after a booster immunization, which raised antibody titres to 18-450 ng/ml. Stimulation of serum progesterone secretion was used as an index of corpus luteum (CL) response to the I.V. hCG. In the control group, the progesterone (P) secretory response following hCG stimulus showed peak levels which were significantly higher than basal levels in all except 2 subjects. The non-responsiveness in 2 subjects cannot be easily explained but may be dose-related. No significant difference was noted between the two dose levels. Length of luteal phase was increased by 4-5 days in 6 out of 20 cycles studied. The results of this test in 5 women before and after the vaccine boosters were encouraging as peak P levels appeared higher than basal levels in controls, but not so in the immunized group. However, these results could not be confirmed statistically. Nonetheless, this study is suggestive that the antibodies generated by this vaccine were capable of intercepting the effect of exogenous hCG in the human female. Further studies with more subjects and higher dosage of hCG are called for.

[Vaccines and developing countries]

Infectious diseases are the main cause of mortality and morbidity in developing countries. The Expanded Programme on Immunization, initiated by WHO in 1974, now reaches 60 mill. a year at a cost of less than 2 US $ per immunized child, and saves 2.2 mill. lives annually. The present vaccines, however, have significant shortcomings. Measles vaccine is given too late to prevent the large number of deaths occurring in the first year of life. Attenuated polio vaccine has to be given three times and inherits the risk of "vaccine palsy" and revertion to virulence. Tetanus vaccine given to children does not prevent neonatal tetanus, the main cause of tetanus casualties. BCG does not control spread of tuberculosis. Vaccines given parenterally involve some risk of spread of HIV, and some potentially useful vaccines are too expensive for developing countries. By only modest investments modern gene technology could give improved and new vaccines which would potentially save 20 mill. lives a year. Particularly promising is the recent development of multi-vaccine-vectors. However, poor prospects for profit in developing countries and patent "swapping" by commercial producers severely hamper development in the vaccine field.