Pathological CNS autoimmune disease triggered by traumatic spinal cord injury: implications for autoimmune vaccine therapy

Spinal cord injury triggers systemic autoimmunity: evidence for chronic B lymphocyte activation and lupus-like autoantibody synthesis

Clinical and experimental data indicate that spinal cord injury (SCI) elicits pathological T-cell responses. Implicit in these data, but poorly understood, is that B lymphocytes (B cells) also contribute to the delayed pathophysiology of spinal trauma. Here, for the first time, we show that experimental spinal contusion injury elicits chronic systemic and intraspinal B cell activation with the emergence of a B cell-dependent organ-specific and systemic autoimmune response. Specifically, using sera from spinal cord injured mice, immunoblots reveal oligoclonal IgG reactivity against multiple CNS proteins. We also show SCI-induced synthesis of autoantibodies that bind nuclear antigens including DNA and RNA. Elevated levels of anti-DNA antibodies are a distinguishing feature of systemic lupus erythematosus and, via their ability to cross-react with neuronal antigens, can cause neuropathology. We show a similar pathologic potential for the autoantibodies produced after SCI. Thus, mammalian SCI produces marked dysregulation of B cell function (i.e. autoimmunity) with pathological potential.

Inflammation and Spinal Cord Injury: Infiltrating Leukocytes as Determinants of Injury and Repair Processes

The immune response that accompanies spinal cord injury contributes to both injury and reparative processes. It is this duality that is the focus of this review. Here we consider the complex cellular and molecular immune responses that lead to the infiltration of leukocytes and glial activation, promote oxidative stress and tissue damage, influence wound healing, and subsequently modulate locomotor recovery. Immunomodulatory strategies to improve outcomes are gaining momentum as ongoing research carefully dissects those pathways, which likely mediate cell injury from those, which favor recovery processes. Current therapeutic strategies address divergent approaches including early immunoblockade and vaccination with immune cells to prevent early tissue damage and support a wound-healing environment that favors plasticity. Despite these advances, there remain basic questions regarding how inflammatory cells interact in the injured spinal cord. Such questions likely arise as a result of our limited understanding of immune cell/neural interactions in a dynamic environment that culminates in progressive cell injury, demyelination, and regenerative failure.

Tolerogenic effect of fiber tract injury: reduced EAE severity following entorhinal cortex lesion

Despite transient, myelin-directed adaptive immune responses in regions of fiber tract degeneration, none of the current models of fiber tract injuries evokes disseminated demyelination, implying effective mechanisms maintaining or re-establishing immune tolerance. In fact, we have recently detected CD95L upregulation accompanied by apoptosis of leukocytes in zones of axonal degeneration induced by entorhinal cortex lesion (ECL), a model of layer-specific axonal degeneration. Moreover, infiltrating monocytes readily transformed into ramified microglia exhibiting a phenotype of immature (CD86+/CD80-) antigen-presenting cells. We now report the appearance of the axonal antigen neurofilament-light along with increased T cell apoptosis and enhanced expression of the pro-apoptotic gene Bad in cervical lymph nodes after ECL. In order to test the functional significance of such local and systemic depletory/regulatory mechanisms on subsequent immunity to central nervous system antigens, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis was induced by proteolipid protein immunization 30 days after ECL. In three independent experiments, we found significantly diminished disease scores and infiltrates in lesioned compared to sham-operated SJL mice. This is consistent with a previous meta-statistical analysis (Goodin et al. in Neurology 52:1737-1745, 1999) rejecting the O-hypothesis that brain trauma causes or exacerbates multiple sclerosis. Conversely, brain injuries may involve long-term tolerogenic effects towards brain antigens.

Influence of the intensity, level and phase of spinal cord injury on the proliferation of T cells and T-cell-dependent antibody reactions in rats

STUDY DESIGN

Three independent experiments in a rat model of contusive spinal cord (SC) injury were performed. Two studied the alterations induced by SC injury on some immunological aspects of the T-cell response. The third one evaluated the motor recovery of rats with low-thoracic injuries.

OBJECTIVE

To examine the effect of level, intensity and phase of SC injury on T-cell proliferation and T-cell-dependent antibody response.

SETTING

Neuroimmunology Department, UIMEN, IMSS-CAMINA Research Center.

METHODS

Lymphocyte proliferation and hemagglutination assays were performed. Animals were injured either moderately or severely at T1 or T12 SC segments. Analysis of peripheral T-cell proliferation in response to mitogens and to myelin basic protein (MBP), as well as of antibody production against a T-dependent antigen, was performed at acute, subacute and chronic phases.

RESULTS

A significant decrease of both response to mitogens and antibody production was found especially during the acute phase and in animals with severe and high (T1)-level injury. Animals with low (T12) and moderate contusions recovered to control levels at the chronic phase. An autoimmune reaction against MBP was observed only in animals with severe contusion at low level.

CONCLUSIONS

The intensity, level and phase of SC injury differentially alter the function of T cells. These results will allow a better interpretation of studies directed to elucidate the role of T lymphocytes in various processes developed after SC injury.

Immune-mediated neuroprotection of axotomized mouse facial motoneurons is dependent on the IL-4/STAT6 signaling pathway in CD4+ T cells

The CD4(+) T lymphocyte has recently been found to promote facial motoneuron (FMN) survival after nerve injury. Signal Transducer and Activator of Transcription (STAT)4 and STAT6 are key proteins involved in the CD4(+) T cell differentiation pathways leading to T helper type (Th)1 and Th2 cell development, respectively. To determine which CD4(+) T cell subset mediates FMN survival, the facial nerve axotomy paradigm was applied to STAT4-deficient (-/-) and STAT6-/- mice. A significant decrease in FMN survival 4 weeks after axotomy was observed in STAT6-/- mice compared to wild-type (WT) or STAT4-/- mice. Reconstituting STAT6-/- mice with CD4(+) T cells obtained from WT mice promoted WT levels of FMN survival after injury. Furthermore, rescue of FMN from axotomy-induced cell death in recombination activating gene (RAG)-2-/- mice (lacking T and B cells) could be achieved only by reconstitution with CD4(+) T cells expressing functional STAT6 protein. To determine if either the Th1 cytokine, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) or the Th2 cytokine IL-4 is involved in mediating FMN survival, facial nerve axotomy was applied to IFN-gamma-/- and IL-4-/- mice. A significant decrease in FMN survival after axotomy occurred in IL-4-/- but not in IFN-gamma-/- mice compared to WT mice, indicating that IL-4 but not IFN-gamma is important for FMN survival after nerve injury. In WT mice, intracellular IFN-gamma vs. IL-4 expression was examined in CD4(+) T cells from draining cervical lymph nodes 14 days after axotomy, and substantial increase in the production of both CD4(+) effector T cell subsets was found. Collectively, these data suggest that STAT6-mediated CD4(+) T cell differentiation into the Th2 subset is necessary for FMN survival. A hypothesis relevant to motoneuron disease progression is presented.

Basso Mouse Scale for locomotion detects differences in recovery after spinal cord injury in five common mouse strains

Genetically engineered mice are used extensively to examine molecular responses to spinal cord injury (SCI). Inherent strain differences may confound behavioral outcomes; therefore, behavioral characterization of several strains after SCI is warranted. The Basso, Beattie, Bresnahan Locomotor Rating Scale (BBB) for rats has been widely used for SCI mice, but may not accurately reflect their unique recovery pattern. This study's purpose was to develop a valid locomotor rating scale for mice and to identify strain differences in locomotor recovery after SCI. We examined C57BL/6, C57BL/10, B10.PL, BALB/c, and C57BL/6x129S6 F1 strains for 42 days after mild, moderate, and severe contusive SCI or transection of the mid thoracic spinal cord. Contusions were created using the Ohio State University electromagnetic SCI device which is a displacement-driven model, and the Infinite Horizon device, which is a force-driven model. Attributes and rankings for the Basso Mouse Scale for Locomotion (BMS) were determined from frequency analyses of seven locomotor categories. Mouse recovery differed from rats for coordination, paw position and trunk instability. Disagreement occurred across six expert raters using BBB (p < 0.05) but not BMS to assess the same mice. BMS detected significant differences in locomotor outcomes between severe contusion and transection (p < 0.05) and SCI severity gradations resulting from displacement variations of only 0.1 mm (p < 0.05). BMS demonstrated significant face, predictive and concurrent validity. Novice BMS raters with training scored within 0.5 points of experts and demonstrated high reliability (0.92-0.99). The BMS is a sensitive, valid and reliable locomotor measure in SCI mice. BMS revealed significantly higher recovery in C57BL/10, B10.PL and F1 than the C57BL/6 and BALB/c strains after moderate SCI (p < 0.05). The differing behavioral response to SCI suggests inherent genetic factors significantly impact locomotor recovery and must be considered in studies with inbred or genetically engineered mouse strains.

CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells and CD1-restricted NKT cells do not mediate facial motoneuron survival after axotomy

CD4+ T cells rescue facial motoneurons (FMN) from axotomy-induced cell death. The objective of this study is to determine if the CD4+ T regulatory subsets, CD4+CD25+ T or CD1d-restricted NKT cells are critical for FMN survival after facial nerve axotomy. Surviving FMN within facial motor nuclei from axotomized and control sides 4 weeks after axotomy were counted to determine percent FMN survival. Data generated by applying this paradigm to recombination activating gene-2-deficient mice reconstituted with CD4+ T cells depleted of CD4+CD25+ T cells and to CD1-/- mice, deficient in CD1d-restricted NKT cells, suggest that neither regulatory CD4+ T subset is critical for FMN survival.

Antigen presentation in autoimmunity and CNS inflammation: how T lymphocytes recognize the brain

The central nervous system (CNS) is traditionally viewed as an immune privileged site in which overzealous immune cells are prevented from doing irreparable damage. It was believed that immune responses occurring within the CNS could potentially do more damage than the initial pathogenic insult itself. However, virtually every aspect of CNS tissue damage, including degeneration, tumors, infection, and of course autoimmunity, involves a significant cellular inflammatory component. While the blood-brain barrier (BBB) inhibits diffusion of hydrophilic (immune) molecules across brain capillaries, activated lymphocytes readily pass the endothelial layer of postcapillary venules without difficulty. In classic neuro-immune diseases such as multiple sclerosis or acute disseminated encephalomyelitis, it is thought that neuroantigen-reactive lymphocytes, which have escaped immune tolerance, now invade the CNS and are responsible for tissue damage, demyelination, and axonal degeneration. The developed animal model for these disorders, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), reflects many aspects of the human conditions. Studies in EAE proved that auto-reactive encephalitogenic T helper (Th) cells are responsible for the onset of the disease. Th cells recognize their cognate antigen (Ag) only when presented by professional Ag-presenting cells in the context of major histocompatibility complex class II molecules. The apparent target structures of EAE immunity are myelinating oligodendrocytes, which are not capable of presenting Ag to invading encephalitogenic T cells. A compulsory third party is thus required to mediate between the attacking T cells and the myelin-expressing target. This review will discuss the recent advances in this field of research and we will discuss the journey of an auto-reactive T cell from its site of activation into perivascular spaces and further into the target tissue.

Minocycline neuroprotects, reduces microgliosis, and inhibits caspase protease expression early after spinal cord injury

Minocycline, a clinically used tetracycline for over 40 years, crosses the blood-brain barrier and prevents caspase up-regulation. It reduces apoptosis in mouse models of Huntington's disease and familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and is in clinical trial for sporadic ALS. Because apoptosis also occurs after brain and spinal cord (SCI) injury, its prevention may be useful in improving recovery. We analyzed minocycline's neuroprotective effects over 28 days following contusion SCI and found significant functional recovery compared to tetracycline. Histology, immunocytochemistry, and image analysis indicated statistically significant tissue sparing, reduced apoptosis and microgliosis, and less activated caspase-3 and substrate cleavage. Since our original report in abstract form, others have published both positive and negative effects of minocycline in various rodent models of SCI and with various routes of administration. We have since found decreased tumor necrosis factor-alpha, as well as caspase-3 mRNA expression, as possible mechanisms of action for minocycline's ameliorative action. These results support reports that modulating apoptosis, caspases, and microglia provide promising therapeutic targets for prevention and/or limiting the degree of functional loss after CNS trauma. Minocycline, and more potent chemically synthesized tetracyclines, may find a place in the therapeutic arsenal to promote recovery early after SCI in humans.

Comparative analysis of lesion development and intraspinal inflammation in four strains of mice following spinal contusion injury

Susceptibility to neuroinflammatory disease is influenced in part by genetics. Recent data indicate that survival of traumatized neurons is strain dependent and influenced by polygenic loci that control resistance/susceptibility to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), a model of CNS autoimmune disease. Here, we describe patterns of neurodegeneration and intraparenchymal inflammation after traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) in mice known to exhibit varying degrees of EAE susceptibility [EAE-resistant (r) or EAE-susceptible (s) mice]. Spinal cords from C57BL/6 (EAE-s), C57BL/10 (EAE-r), BALB/c (EAE-r), and B10.PL (EAE-s) mice were prepared for stereological and immunohistochemical analysis at 6 hours or 3, 7, 14, 28, or 42 days following midthoracic (T9) spinal contusion injury. In general, genetic predisposition to EAE predicted the magnitude of intraparenchymal inflammation but not lesion size/length or locomotor recovery. Specifically, microglia/macrophage activation, recruitment of neutrophils and lymphocytes, and de novo synthesis of MHC class II were greatest in C57BL/6 mice and least in BALB/c mice at all times examined. However, lesion volume and axial spread of neurodegeneration were similar in C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice and were significantly greater than in C57BL/10 or B10.PL mice. Strains with marked intraspinal inflammation also developed the most intense lesion fibrosis. Thus, strain-dependent neuroinflammation was observed after SCI, but without a consistent relationship to EAE susceptibility or lesion progression. Only in C57BL/6 mice was the magnitude of intraspinal inflammation predictive of secondary neurodegeneration, functional recovery, or fibrosis.

Experimental strategies to promote spinal cord regeneration--an integrative perspective

Detailed pathophysiological findings of secondary damage phenomena after spinal cord injury (SCI) as well as the identification of inhibitory and neurotrophic proteins have yielded a plethora of experimental therapeutic approaches. Main targets are (i) to minimize secondary damage progression (neuroprotection), (ii) to foster axon conduction (neurorestoration) and (iii) to supply a permissive environment to promote axonal sprouting (neuroregenerative therapies). Pre-clinical studies have raised hope in functional recovery through the antagonism of growth inhibitors, application of growth factors, cell transplantation, and vaccination strategies. To date, even though based on successful pre-clinical animal studies, results of clinical trials are characterized by dampened effects attributable to difficulties in the study design (patient heterogeneity) and species differences. A combination of complementary therapeutic strategies might be considered pre-requisite for future synergistic approaches. Here, we line out pre-clinical interventions resulting in improved functional neurological outcome after spinal cord injury and track them on their intended way to bedside.

Inflammation and neurodegeneration

Many CNS diseases of primarily noninflammatory origin, such as chronic neurodegenerative diseases, stroke and trauma, display inflammatory features. Conversely, damage to nerve cells and axons has emerged as a clinically important parameter of autoimmune neuroinflammatory conditions such as multiple sclerosis. Experimental data are conflicting as to whether neuroinflammatory reactions should be regarded as detrimental, or as an apt response serving to minimize nervous tissue damage. Despite this, modulation of inflammation is one of the most dynamic areas in the search for new therapeutic targets for a spectrum of CNS diseases. Recent developments in the field have unravelled an intricate regulation of neuroinflammation and disclosed several avenues that, with further exploration, may result in new ways of treating common and disabling CNS diseases.

Sensitization to brain antigens after stroke is augmented by lipopolysaccharide

After stroke, the blood-brain barrier is transiently disrupted, allowing leukocytes to enter the brain and brain antigens to enter the peripheral circulation. This encounter of normally sequestered brain antigens by the systemic immune system could therefore present an opportunity for an autoimmune response to brain to occur after stroke. In this study, we assessed the immune response to myelin basic protein (MBP) in animals subjected to middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO). Some animals received an intraperitoneal injection of lipopolysaccharide (LPS; 1 mg/kg) at reperfusion to stimulate a systemic inflammatory response. At 1 month after MCAO, animals exposed to LPS were more likely to be sensitized to MBP (66.7% versus 22.2%; P=0.007) and had more profound and persistent neurologic deficits than non-LPS-treated animals. Exposure to LPS was associated with increased expression of the costimulatory molecule B7.1 early after stroke onset (P=0.009) and increased brain atrophy 1 month after MCAO (P=0.03). These data suggest that animals subjected to a systemic inflammatory insult at the time of stroke are predisposed to develop an autoimmune response to brain, and that this response is associated with worse outcome. These data may partially explain why patients who become infected after stroke experience increased morbidity.

Immune regulatory mechanisms influence early pathology in spinal cord injury and in spontaneous autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Injuries to the central nervous system (CNS) trigger an inflammatory reaction with potentially devastating consequences. In this report we compared the characteristics of the inflammatory response on spinal cord injury (SCI) caused by a stab wound between the T7 and T9 vertebrae and spontaneous experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). SCI and EAE were compared in two types of myelin basic protein Ac1-11-specific T-cell receptor transgenic mice: T/R+ mice harbor regulatory T cells, and T/R- mice lack regulatory T cells. Our results show that 8 days after SCI, T/R- mice developed a strong T-cell infiltrate in the spinal cord, with remarkable down-modulation of CD4 expression that was accompanied by a local increase in Mac-3+ and F4/80+ reactivity and diffuse local and distal astrogliosis. In contrast, T/R+ mice exhibited a modest increase in CD4+ cells localized to the site of injury, without CD4 down-modulation; focal astrogliosis was restricted to the site of the lesion, although Mac-3+ and F4/80+ cells were also present. Similarly to T/R- mice that underwent SCI, T cells displaying down-modulated CD4 expression were found in the CNS of older T/R- mice afflicted by spontaneous EAE. Overall, our results suggest that common mechanisms regulate T-cell accumulation in CNS lesions of different causes, such as mechanic lesion or autoimmune-mediated damage.

Upregulation of complement inhibitors in association with vulnerable cells following contusion-induced spinal cord injury

We have previously described the activation of the classical, alternative, and terminal complement cascade pathways after acute contusion spinal cord injury using the New York University (NYU) weight-drop impactor. In the present study, we examined the induction of protein regulators of the complement cascade, factor H (FH), and clusterin, in the same experimental paradigm. The spinal cord of laminectomized adult rats was subjected to mild or severe injury using impactor weight-drop heights of 12.5 and 50 mm, respectively. The spinal cords of control and injured animals were evaluated at 1, 7, and 42 days after injury. Immunocytochemistry revealed a robust increase in the numbers and intensity of staining of FH, and clusterin-positive cells in the injured cord at all three time points, with the highest increases observed at 1 and 42 days after injury. FH and clusterin-positive cells were observed among neurons as well as oligodendrocytes. The increased expression was detected both rostrally and caudally from the injury site, in the latter case at distances up to 20 mm. The precise biological significance of injury-induced upregulation of these proteins remains to be determined. However, FH and clusterin are potent regulators of complement activity targeting upstream (FH) and downstream (clusterin) molecules of the pro-inflammatory cascade, which could be of vital importance in preventing a "runaway" inflammatory reaction in the injured spinal cord.

Immunoactivation and Altered Intercellular Communication Mediate the Pathophysiology of Spinal Cord Injury

Evidence and inferences from clinical research, clinical observation, and literature review support an etiologic paradigm for the pathophysiology of spinal cord injury (SCI). According to this paradigm, changes in immunoregulation and in the activation of cytokines or intercellular adhesion molecules (ICAMs) contribute to many of the comorbidities, metabolic changes, and pathophysiologic sequelae observed after traumatic SCI. Cytokines and ICAMs are endogenously secreted molecules that serve as intercellular signals and immunoregulators. They modulate the activity of cells and influence the organization and function of tissues or organs. These intercellular signals are posited as molecular links between the damaged, decentralized nervous system of SCI and the acquired autonomic failure, neuroendocrine-immunoregulatory dysfunction, diminished central nervous system (CNS) regenerative capacity, and broad spectrum of pathology, organ failure, and generalized impairment of homeostasis caused by trauma to the spinal cord. These highly bioactive molecules may also mediate or facilitate the intralesional CNS axonal damage and peripheral neurologic deficits sustained at time of acute CNS injury. Ultimately, it should be possible to develop treatments that will block or modulate the local and systemic expression of cytokine or ICAM bioactivity. Such treatments might aid victims of SCI by diminishing overall morbidity or mortality, helping restore sensorimotor function and homeostasis, and enhancing longevity and quality of life.

Human and murine lymphocyte neurotrophin expression is confined to B cells

Recent reports indicate that autoreactive T cells may produce neurotrophic factors capable of mediating repair and regeneration of damaged neurons. By using semiquantitative RT-PCR, we examined gene expression of nerve growth factor (NGF), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), and the trkB BDNF receptor in autoreactive T cells from SWXJ mice immunized with the p104-117 encephalitogen of myelin proteolipid protein (PLP 104-117). We observed antigen-inducible expression of NGF and BDNF, but not NT-3 and trkB, in lymph node cells activated with PLP 104-117. To determine which leukocyte subpopulation expressed neurotrophins, CD4(+), CD8(+), B220(+), CD11b(+), and NK1.1(+) cells were purified from activated primary cultures, and their mRNAs were analyzed. Neurotrophin expression was also measured in CD3(+) T cells purified from mouse CNS during acute onset of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis as well as in resting and activated human T cells and B cells purified from peripheral blood of normal subjects. In all cases, we found that neurotrophin expression was confined exclusively to B cells (B220(+)) in both mouse and human. CD3(+), CD4(+), and CD8(+) T cells as well as NK1.1(+) cells and CD11b(+) monocytes and macrophages did not express any detectable BDNF, NGF, NT-3, or trkB under any conditions. Our data indicate that B cells rather than T cells are the predominant if not the only source of leukocyte-derived neurotrophins and as such may provide "protective autoimmunity" in repair and regeneration of the injured nervous system.

A monoclonal antibody to CD11d reduces the inflammatory infiltrate into the injured spinal cord: a potential neuroprotective treatment

The accumulation of inflammatory cells in the lesion of a spinal cord injury (SCI) enhances secondary damage, resulting in further neurological impairment. High-dose methylprednisolone (MP) treatment is the only accepted treatment for inflammation secondary to human SCI but is minimally effective. Using a rat SCI model, we devised an anti-inflammatory treatment to block the infiltration of neutrophils and hematogenous monocyte/macrophages over the first 2 days postinjury by targeting the CD11dCD18 integrin. Anti-CD11d mAb administration following SCI effectively reduced neutrophil and macrophage infiltrate into lesions by 70% and 36%, respectively, over the first 72 h post-SCI. MP also reduced neutrophil and macrophage infiltrate by 60% and 28%, respectively, but by different mechanisms. The immunosuppression caused by anti-CD11d treatment was not sustained, as inflammatory cell numbers were not different from those observed in untreated SCI control animals at 7 days postinjury. In contrast, in MP-treated animals, the number of macrophages was still suppressed in the lesion while neutrophil numbers were significantly increased. These results suggest that anti-CD11d mAb treatment following SCI will minimize the destructive actions associated with early, uncontrolled leukocyte infiltration into the lesion while permitting the positive wound healing effects of macrophages at later time points.

Cellular transplantation strategies for spinal cord injury and translational neurobiology

Basic science advances in spinal cord injury and regeneration research have led to a variety of novel experimental therapeutics designed to promote functionally effective axonal regrowth and sprouting. Among these interventions are cell-based approaches involving transplantation of neural and non-neural tissue elements that have potential for restoring damaged neural pathways or reconstructing intraspinal synaptic circuitries by either regeneration or neuronal/glial replacement. Notably, some of these strategies (e.g., grafts of peripheral nerve tissue, olfactory ensheathing glia, activated macrophages, marrow stromal cells, myelin-forming oligodendrocyte precursors or stem cells, and fetal spinal cord tissue) have already been translated to the clinical arena, whereas others have imminent likelihood of bench-to-bedside application. Although this progress has generated considerable enthusiasm about treating what once was thought to be a totally incurable condition, there are many issues to be considered relative to treatment safety and efficacy. The following review reflects on different experimental applications of intraspinal transplantation with consideration of the underlying pathological, pathophysiological, functional, and neuroplastic responses to spinal trauma that such treatments may target along with related issues of procedural and biological safety. The discussion then moves to an overview of ongoing and completed clinical trials to date. The pros and cons of these endeavors are considered, as well as what has been learned from them. Attention is primarily directed at preclinical animal modeling and the importance of patterning clinical trials, as much as possible, according to laboratory experiences.

Inflammatory response after neurosurgery

Investigation into the inflammatory response in the central nervous system (CNS) is a rapidly growing field, and a vast amount of information on this topic has accumulated over the past two decades. Inflammation is a particularly interesting issue in the (traditionally non-regenerating) CNS, owing to its dual role in worsening or improving regeneration and functional outcome in certain circumstances. This paper reviews the current literature on the interactions between the immune system and the CNS in physiological and pathological states. The first part will provide an overview of the cellular and molecular components of CNS inflammation, this being followed by a discussion of the concept of systemic immunodepression after neurotrauma and neurosurgery. Finally, the delicate balance of immune responses in the CNS, with an emphasis on the beneficial effects of inflammation and possible therapeutic options, will be discussed.

Behavioral Testing After Spinal Cord Injury: Congruities, Complexities, and Controversies

Selection and implementation of behavioral tests in spinal cord injury research is an important process, and yet few papers have focused on these issues. The critical component of any behavioral experiment is the ability to produce reliable, reproducible, and worthwhile data. Unfortunately, the difference between worthwhile and worthless data is often subtle. This paper describes factors that must be considered in order to select the most sensitive behavioral tests to match the hypothesis of the experiment and apply any test in a standardized, consistent manner. Classifications of behavioral tests, their strengths and limitations, as well as methods to overcome these limitations are discussed. Recent work in translating behavioral tests from rats to mice is also provided. The purpose of this article is to provide a framework by which behavioral testing can be standardized within and across spinal cord injury labs.

Basic advances and new avenues in therapy of spinal cord injury

The prospects for successful clinical trials of neuroprotective and neurorestorative interventions for patients with acute and chronic myelopathies depend on preclinical animal models of injury and repair that reflect the human condition. Remarkable progress continues in the attempt to promote connections between the brain and the sensory and motor neurons below a spinal cord lesion. Recent experiments demonstrate the potential for biological therapies to regenerate or remyelinate axons and to incorporate new neural cells into the milieu of a traumatic spinal cord injury. The computational flexibility and plasticity of the sensorimotor systems of the brain, spinal cord, and motor unit make functional use of new circuitry feasible in patients. To incorporate residual and new pathways, neural repair strategies must be coupled to rehabilitation therapies that drive activity-dependent plasticity for walking, for reaching and grasping, and for bowel and bladder control. Prevention of pain and dysautonomia are also clinical targets. Research aims to define the temporal windows of opportunity for interventions, test the safety and efficacy of delivery systems of agents and cells, and provide a better understanding of the cascades of gene expression and cell interactions both acutely and chronically after injury. These bench-to-bedside studies are defining the neurobiology of spinal cord injury rehabilitation.

Self-tolerance in the immune privileged CNS: lessons from the entorhinal cortex lesion model

Upon peripheral immunization with myelin epitopes, susceptible rats and mice develop T cell-mediated demyelination similar to that observed in the human autoimmune disease multiple sclerosis (MS). In the same animals, brain injury does not induce autoimmune encephalomyelitis despite massive release of myelin antigens and early expansion of myelin specific T cells in local lymph nodes, indicating that the self-specific T cell clones are kept under control. Using entorhinal cortex lesion (ECL) to induce axonal degeneration in the hippocampus, we identified possible mechanisms of immune tolerance after brain trauma. Following ECL, astrocytes upregulate the death ligand CD95L, allowing apoptotic elimination of infiltrating activated T cells. Myelin-phagocytosing microglia express MHC-II and the costimulatory molecule CD86, but lack CD80, which is found only on activated antigen presenting cells (APCs). Restimulation of invading T cells by such immature APCs (e.g. CD80 negative microglia) may lead to T cell anergy and/or differentiation of regulatory/Th3-like cells due to insufficient costimulation and presence of high levels of TGF-beta and IL-10 in the CNS. Thus, T cell -apoptosis, -anergy, and -suppression apparently maintain immune tolerance after initial expansion of myelin-specific T lymphocytes following brain injury. This view is supported by a previous metastatistical analysis which rejected the hypothesis that brain trauma is causative of MS (Goddin et al., 1999). However, concomitant trauma-independent proinflammatory signals, e.g., those evoked by clinically quiescent infections, may trigger maturation of APCs, thus shifting a delicate balance from immune tolerance and protective immune responses to destructive autoimmunity.

Rapid induction of autoantibodies against Nogo-A and MOG in the absence of an encephalitogenic T cell response: implication for immunotherapeutic approaches in neurological diseases

Vaccinations against various antigens of the central nervous system (CNS) are gaining increasing interest as a therapeutic approach in a variety of neurological diseases such as spinal cord injury, ischemic stroke, Alzheimer disease, or spongiform encephalopathy. In the present work, the time window after spinal cord injury allowing potentially therapeutic antibody to penetrate the damaged blood-brain barrier (BBB) was measured by intravenous injection of a monoclonal anti-Nogo-A antibody. Although an influx of Nogo antibodies at the lesion site was detectable up to 2 wk after injury, a significant decrease in BBB permeability was noticed within the first week. Clearly, therefore, a vaccination protocol with a rapid antibody response is required for acute therapeutic interventions after CNS trauma. We designed a conjugate vaccine paradigm with particular focus on the safety and the kinetics of the antibody response. As antigen targets, we used Nogo-A and the strongly encephalitogenic myelin-oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG). Intrasplenic autoimmunization of rats with a Nogo-A-specific region fused to the Tetanus toxin C-fragment (TTC) resulted in a fast IgM response against Nogo-A. A specific switch to IgG was observed as soon as 4-7 days after intrasplenic immunization in TTC-primed animals. In spite of the induction of a specific IgG response after intrasplenic immunization, no signs of experimental autoimmune disease (EAE) or inflammatory infiltrates on histological examinations were observable. In contrast to subcutaneous immunization with MOG, in vitro cytokine secretion assays (IL-2, IL-10, and IFN-gamma) did not reveal activation of MOG-specific T cells after intrasplenic immunization. Our findings have critical implications for future strategies in the development of safe and efficient therapeutic vaccines for neurological diseases.

CNS regeneration: clinical possibility or basic science fantasy?

Following injury to the CNS, severed axons undergo a phase of abortive sprouting in the vicinity of the wound, but do not spontaneously re-grow or regenerate. From a long history of attempts to stimulate regeneraion, a major strategy that has been developed clinically is the implantation of tissue into denervated target regions. Unfortunately trials have so far not borne out the promise that this would prove a useful therapy for disorders such as Parkinson's disease. Many strategies have also been developed to stimulate the regeneration of axons across sites of injury, particularly in the spinal cord. Animal data have demonstrated that some of these approaches hold promise and that the spinal cord has a remarkable degree of intrinsic plasticity. Attempts are now being made to utilize experimental techniques in spinal patients.

Effects of cyclosporin-A on immune response, tissue protection and motor function of rats subjected to spinal cord injury

The aim of this work was to test the effect of cyclosporin-A (CsA) on some immunological, morphological and functional aspects developed after spinal cord injury. The specific cellular immune response against spinal cord constituents, the amount of spared tissue and myelination at the site of injury, and the motor function outcome were assessed in a first series of experiments. Rats were subjected to spinal cord compression and treated with cyclosporin-A before lesion and during the entire study. A specific lymphocyte response against spinal cord antigens was found in untreated spinal cord injured rats but not in cyclosporine-A treated injured rats. A significantly better myelination index was also found in injured cyclosporin-A-treated rats, as compared to untreated animals. The amount of spared spinal cord tissue at the epicenter was not significantly different comparing CsA-treated with vehicle-treated rats. Looking for a potential therapeutic use of CsA, in a second series of experiments, rats were subjected to spinal cord contusion and treated with cyclosporin-A from 1 to 72 h after lesion. Motor recovery and red nuclei neurons survival, were evaluated, and found to be significantly better in spinal cord injured rats treated with cyclosporin-A than in injured-untreated rats. This work confirms the existence of an autoimmune cellular reaction after injury that can be inhibited by cyclosporin-A treatment. Furthermore, cyclosporin-A promotes neuroprotection by diminishing both demyelination and neuronal cell death, resulting in a better motor outcome after spinal cord injury.

Rats and mice exhibit distinct inflammatory reactions after spinal cord injury

Spinal contusion pathology in rats and mice is distinct. Cystic cavities form at the impact site in rats while a dense connective tissue matrix occupies the injury site in mice. Because inflammatory cells coordinate mechanisms of tissue injury and repair, we evaluated whether the unique anatomical presentation in spinally injured rats and mice is associated with a species-specific inflammatory response. Immunohistochemistry was used to compare the leukocytic infiltrate between rats and mice. Microglia/macrophage reactions were similar between species; however, the onset and magnitude of lymphocyte and dendritic cell (DC) infiltration were markedly different. In rats, T-cell numbers were highest between 3 and 7 days postinjury and declined by 50% over the next 3 weeks. In mice, significant T-cell entry was not evident until 14 days postinjury, with T-cell numbers doubling between 2 and 6 weeks. Dendritic cell influx paralleled T-cell infiltration in rats but was absent in mouse spinal cord. De novo expression of major histocompatability class II molecules was increased in both species but to a greater extent in mice. Unique to mice were cells that resembled lymphocytes but did not express lymphocyte-specific markers. These cells extended from blood vessels within the fibrotic tissue matrix and expressed fibronectin, collagen I, CD11b, CD34, CD13, and CD45. This phenotype is characteristic of fibrocytes, specialized blood-borne cells involved in wound healing and immunity. Thus, species-specific neuroinflammation may contribute to the formation of distinct tissue environments at the site of spinal cord injury in mice and rats.

Neurotrophic cross-talk between the nervous and immune systems: implications for neurological diseases

Inflammatory reactions in the central nervous system usually are considered detrimental, but recent evidence suggests that they also can be beneficial and even have neuroprotective effects. Intriguingly, immune cells can produce various neurotrophic factors of various molecular families. The concept of "neuroprotective immunity" will have profound consequences for the pathogenesis and treatment of neuroinflammatory diseases such as multiple sclerosis. It also will prove important for neurodegenerative disorders, in which inflammatory reactions often occur. This review focuses on recent findings that immune cells produce brain-derived neurotrophic factor in multiple sclerosis lesions, whereas neurons and astrocytes express the appropriate tyrosine kinase receptor TrkB. Together with functional evidence for the neuroprotective effects of immune cells, these observations support the concept of "neuroprotective immunity." We next examine current and future therapeutic strategies for multiple sclerosis and experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in light of neuroprotective immunity and finally address the broader implications of this new concept for other neuroinflammatory and neurodegenerative diseases.

Autoimmunity as a special case of immunity: removing threats from within

The function of the adaptive immune response against exogenous (non-self) agents is to help the innate arm of the immune system (represented by phagocytic cells) to fight and eliminate these agents. We suggest that the body also protects itself against potentially harmful self components using mechanisms similar to those used for fighting and eliminating non-self agents, and that the protective immune activity against self-components competes with the activity of self-destructive compounds. Tolerance to self is thus not a lack of response to self, but the ability to tolerate an active defense response to self without developing an autoimmune disease.

Vaccination stimulates retinal ganglion cell regeneration in the adult optic nerve

We examined whether vaccination of adult rats with spinal cord homogenate (SCH) can promote regeneration of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) after microcrush lesion of the optic nerve. Injured animals vaccinated with SCH showed axon growth into the optic nerve and such regeneration was not observed in animals vaccinated with liver homogenate (LH). Regeneration was not a consequence of neuroprotection since our vaccine did not protect RGCs from axotomy-induced cell death. Sera of vaccinated animals were tested for antibodies against myelin-associated glycoprotein, NogoA, Nogo-66 receptor, or chondroitin sulphate proteoglycans (CSPG), but no significant levels were detected. Antibodies to myelin basic protein were present in the serum of some SCH-vaccinated animals. In culture, serum from SCH-vaccinated animals promoted RGC growth on myelin but not on CSPG. Our results show that the effect of the pro-regenerative vaccine is mediated by antibodies to SCH. However, we were not able to detect a significant immune reaction to growth inhibitory proteins, suggesting alternative mechanisms for the success of vaccination to promote regeneration.

Manipulating neuroinflammatory reactions in the injured spinal cord: back to basics

Recruitment of inflammatory leukocytes to the injured spinal cord is a physiological response that is associated with the production of cytokines and proteinases that are involved in host defense and wound repair. Cells in the spinal cord are mainly post-mitotic and tissue regeneration is poor; thus, these inflammatory mediators can exacerbate the damage to spared tissue and thereby impair spontaneous functional recovery. Although several aspects of immune function might benefit the CNS, experimental studies indicate that acute neuroinflammation aggravates tissue injury. Until the timing and nature of the molecular signals that govern leukocyte recruitment and activation after spinal injury are defined, clinical therapies designed to boost immune cell function should be avoided.

Therapeutic vaccination for spinal cord injury: helping the body to cure itself

Inflammation is thought to exacerbate the outcome of spinal cord injury. However, our findings have led us to view inflammation as a healing response that needs the help of a systemic immune response mediated by T helper 1 (Th1) cells that are specific to the abundant antigens residing in the lesion site. Strains differ in their ability to manifest, at the right time and intensity, a spontaneous T-cell response to antigens at the lesion site and therefore in their ability to generate a local inflammatory response whose outcome is beneficial (maintenance and repair). All strains, however, can benefit from immune intervention that boosts and regulates the inflammatory response. Because recovery comprises multi-step processes, pharmacological intervention will be less effective than well-synchronized, self-healing immune activity. Risk-free neuroprotective intervention might be achieved by post-traumatic vaccination with a weak, non-pathogenic, auto-antigen, causing autoimmune T cells to home to the lesion site where they become activated and therefore activate local phagocytic cells to remove hostile elements and provide growth factors.

Sexual dimorphism in the spontaneous recovery from spinal cord injury: a gender gap in beneficial autoimmunity?

Immune cells have been shown to contribute to spontaneous recovery from central nervous system (CNS) injury. Here we show that adult female rats and mice recover significantly better than their male littermates from incomplete spinal cord injury (ISCI). This sexual dimorphism is wiped out and recovery is worse in adult mice deprived of mature T cells. After spinal cord contusion in adult rats, functional recovery (measured by locomotor scores in an open field) was significantly worse in females treated with dihydrotestosterone prior to the injury than in placebo-treated controls, and significantly better in castrated males than in their noncastrated male littermates. Post-traumatic administration of the testosterone receptor antagonist flutamide promoted the functional recovery in adult male rats. These results, in line with the known inhibitory effect of testosterone on cell-mediated immunity, suggest that androgen-mediated immunosuppression plays a role in ISCI-related immune dysfunction and can therefore partly explain the worse outcome of ISCI in males than in female. We suggest that females, which are more prone to develop autoimmune response than males, benefit from this response in cases of CNS insults.