Identification of polyclonal serum specificities with phage-display libraries

Comparison of motif-based and whole-unique-sequence-based analyses of phage display library datasets generated by biopanning of anti-Borrelia burgdorferi immune sera

Detection of protection-associated epitopes via reverse vaccinology is the first step for development of subunit vaccines against microbial pathogens. Mapping subunit vaccine targets requires high throughput methods, which would allow delineation of epitopes recognized by protective antibodies on a large scale. Phage displayed random peptide library coupled to Next Generation Sequencing (PDRPL/NGS) is the universal platform that enables high-yield identification of peptides that mimic epitopes (mimotopes). Despite being unsurpassed as a tool for discovery of polyclonal serum mimotopes, the PDRPL/NGS is far inferior as a quantitative method of immune response. Difficult-to-control fluctuations in amounts of antibody-bound phages after rounds of selection and amplification diminish the quantitative capacity of the PDRPL/NGS. In an attempt to improve the accuracy of the PDRPL/NGS method, we compared the discriminating capacity of two approaches for PDRPL/NGS data analysis. The whole-unique-sequence-based analysis (WUSA) involved generation of 7-mer peptide profiles and comparison of the numbers of sequencing reads for unique peptide sequences between serum samples. The motif-based analysis (MA) included identification of 4-mer consensus motifs unifying unique 7-mer sequences and comparison of motifs between serum samples. The motif comparison was based not on the numbers of sequencing reads, but on the numbers of distinct 7-mers constituting the motifs. Our PDRPL/NGS datasets generated from biopanning of protective and non-protective anti-Borrelia burgdorferi sera of New Zealand rabbits were used to contrast the two approaches. As a result, the principle component analyses (PCA) showed that the discriminating powers of the WUSA and MA were similar. In contrast, the unsupervised hierarchical clustering obtained via the MA classified the preimmune, non-protective, and protective sera better than the WUSA-based clustering. Also, a total number of discriminating motifs was higher than that of discriminating 7-mers. In sum, our results indicate that MA approach improves the accuracy and quantitative capacity of the PDRPL/NGS method.

Phage display peptide libraries: deviations from randomness and correctives

Peptide-expressing phage display libraries are widely used for the interrogation of antibodies. Affinity selected peptides are then analyzed to discover epitope mimetics, or are subjected to computational algorithms for epitope prediction. A critical assumption for these applications is the random representation of amino acids in the initial naïve peptide library. In a previous study, we implemented next generation sequencing to evaluate a naïve library and discovered severe deviations from randomness in UAG codon over-representation as well as in high G phosphoramidite abundance causing amino acid distribution biases. In this study, we demonstrate that the UAG over-representation can be attributed to the burden imposed on the phage upon the assembly of the recombinant Protein 8 subunits. This was corrected by constructing the libraries using supE44-containing bacteria which suppress the UAG driven abortive termination. We also demonstrate that the overabundance of G stems from variant synthesis-efficiency and can be corrected using compensating oligonucleotide-mixtures calibrated by mass spectroscopy. Construction of libraries implementing these correctives results in markedly improved libraries that display random distribution of amino acids, thus ensuring that enriched peptides obtained in biopanning represent a genuine selection event, a fundamental assumption for phage display applications.

Purification of polyclonal anti-conformational antibodies for use in affinity selection from random peptide phage display libraries: a study using the hydatid vaccine EG95

The use of polyclonal antibodies to screen random peptide phage display libraries often results in the recognition of a large number of peptides that mimic linear epitopes on various proteins. There appears to be a bias in the use of this technology toward the selection of peptides that mimic linear epitopes. In many circumstances the correct folding of a protein immunogen is required for conferring protection. The use of random peptide phage display libraries to identify peptide mimics of conformational epitopes in these cases requires a strategy for overcoming this bias. Conformational epitopes on the hydatid vaccine EG95 have been shown to result in protective immunity in sheep, whereas linear epitopes are not protective. In this paper we describe a strategy that results in the purification of polyclonal antibodies directed against conformational epitopes while eliminating antibodies directed against linear epitopes. These affinity purified antibodies were then used to select a peptide from a random peptide phage display library that has the capacity to mimic conformational epitopes on EG95. This peptide was subsequently used to affinity purify monospecific antibodies against EG95.

Identification of peptides specific for antibodies in vitiligo using a phage library

Patients with vitiligo produce specific autoantibodies that can be detected in their sera. These antibodies are believed to play a role in the pathogenesis of this disease. A random peptide library displayed on phage is a technique that can be used to identify the epitopes that react with monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies. We used this technique to identify the epitopes that react specifically with the vitiligo autoantibodies. By screening the random peptide phage library and using ELISA, two clones that showed a higher frequency of reactivity with the antibodies in the sera of patients with vitiligo were identified. The peptides do not show any similarity with the autoantigens so far implicated in vitiligo, indicating that these epitopes may mimic conformational epitopes in proteins.

Cloning and characterization of a novel immunogenic protein 3 (NIP3) from Brugia malayi by immuno screening of a phage-display cDNA expression library

Iterative screening of a phage display cDNA expression library of the third-stage larvae (L3) of Brugia malayi with sera from putatively immune individuals (endemic normal, EN) identified a novel clone with insert showing significant homology to Onchocerca volvulus novel immunogenic protein-3 (Ov-NIP3) gene and Caenorhabditis elegans NIP3-like protein and hence the gene was designated Brugia malayi NIP3-like protein (BmNIP3). EST database analysis showed that ESTs from several gastrointestinal nematodes such as Ancylostoma caninum, Teladorsagia circumcincta, Haemonchus contortus and Strongyloides stercoralis has BmNIP3 homologues, but the gene has not been described from these parasites. Sequence analyses showed that BmNIP3 has three potential mucin-type O-glycosylation sites and several serine/threonine phosphorylation sites. As expected, BmNIP3 protein isolated from the parasite was serine/threonine phosphorylated. Further analyses showed that BmNIP3 is differentially transcribed, with highest level of expression present in the larval (L3 and L4) stages. Mice immunized with rBmNIP3 developed strong antibody responses predominantly of the IgG1 and IgG2a subtype. A similar analyses of the sera samples from EN individuals showed that they also carry high levels of IgG1 and IgG2 antibodies against BmNIP3, whereas, chronically infected patients carry largely IgG3 antibodies and MF individuals carry high levels of IgG1 antibodies against BmNIP3. This study thus describes a novel protein from B. malayi that appears to be highly immunogenic in both humans and mice.

Peptide inhibitor of pancreatic lipase selected by phage display using different elution strategies

Interference with fat hydrolysis results in the reduced use of ingested lipids. Inhibition of pancreatic lipase reduces the efficiency of fat absorption in the small intestine and thereby initiates modest long-term reduction in body weight. In an attempt to select peptides with affinity for the surface of pancreatic lipase and potential inhibitory activity, a random, cyclic heptapeptide phage-displayed library was used. Five independent selections, differing in elution step, were performed. In three selection protocols, a sequential elution strategy was applied in anticipation of improving the selection of high-affinity clones. Four heptapeptides with the highest affinity, seemingly for pancreatic lipase, were selected, synthesized, and characterized for their capacity to inhibit enzyme function. Although no clear consensus among the sequenced peptides was found, one of the selected peptides inhibited pancreatic lipase with an apparent inhibition constant of 16 muM.

Identification of epitopes in the nucleocapsid protein of Nipah virus using a linear phage-displayed random peptide library

A random peptide library of heptamers displayed on the surface of M13 bacteriophage was used to identify specific epitopes of antibodies in pooled sera of swine naturally infected by Nipah virus. The selected heptapeptides were aligned with protein sequences of Nipah virus and several putative epitopes were identified within the nucleocapsid protein. A total of 41 of 60 (68%) selected phage clones had inserts resembling a region with the sequence SNRTQGE, located at the C-terminal end (amino acids 503-509) of the nucleocapsid protein. The binding of antibodies in the swine and human antisera to the phage clone was inhibited by a synthetic peptide corresponding to this region. Epitopes identified by phage display are consistent with the predicted antigenic sites for the Nipah virus nucleocapsid protein. The selected phage clone used as a coating antigen discriminated swine and human Nipah virus sera-positive from sera-negative samples exhibiting characteristics, which might be attractive for diagnostic tests.

Novel phage display-based subtractive screening to identify vaccine candidates of Brugia malayi

This study describes a novel phage display method based on an iterative subtraction strategy to identify candidate vaccine antigens of Brugia malayi. A cDNA library of the infective larval stage of B. malayi expressed on the surface of T7 phage was sequentially screened with sera samples from human subjects showing different manifestations of the disease. Antigens that selectively and specifically bind to immune sera were then enriched using a multi-step panning procedure. This strategy identified five antigens, four of which were previously reported (ALT-2, TPX-2, VAH and COX-2) and the other one was a novel cuticular collagen (Col-4). Sera from immune individuals specifically recognized all the five antigens. However, ALT-2 appeared to be the most predominantly recognized antigen by the immune sera. Therefore, it was decided to evaluate the vaccine potential of recombinant ALT-2 (rALT-2) in a mouse and jird model. The results presented show that immunization with rALT-2 conferred over 73% protection against a challenge infection in the jird model and over 64% protection in the mouse model. The present study suggests that phage display-based cDNA screening may be a powerful tool to identify candidate vaccine antigens of infectious agents.

Isolation of foot-and-mouth disease virus specific bovine antibody fragments from phage display libraries

Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is an important veterinary pathogen which can cause widespread epidemics. Due to the high antigenic variability of FMDV, it is important to undertake mutation analysis under immunological pressure. To study the bovine antibody response at a molecular level, phage display technology was used to produce bovine anti-FMDV Fabs. CH1-VH chains with FMDV specific binding could be isolated after selection from a library made from vaccinated cattle. Though their involvement in the bovine immune response remains to be ascertained, it is planned to express the five different selected VH domains in bacterial or insect systems as sequence homologies with integrin beta6 chain could shed light on the basis of FMDV type receptor specificities.

Anti-HBs after hepatitis B immunization with plasma-derived and recombinant DNA-derived vaccines: binding to mutant HBsAg

The G145R mutant of the small S-protein is a major escape mutant of hepatitis B virus observed in natural infection, after immunization and HBIG therapy. In a previous study we found that plasma-derived and recombinant DNA-derived vaccine HBsAg reacted differently with monoclonal antibodies sensitive for the G145R change. In the present study we investigated the binding of polyclonal anti-HBs obtained after immunization with plasma vaccine and recombinant DNA vaccine to synthetic peptides (adw(2), adr) and rHBsAg (HepG2) (ayw(3); wild type and a 145R mutant). Anti-HBs binding to synthetic peptids (25-mers, 7aa overlap) from the "a"-loop was significantly reduced by the G145R substitution and by changing the amino acid sequence from adw(2) into adr. With mutant G145R rHBsAg the inhibitory activity of vaccine anti-HBs was decreased compared to rHBsAg wild type. In general only minor differences were observed between plasma vaccine and recombinant DNA vaccine related antibody responses. However, the individual heterogeneity in epitope specific reactivity with its possible consequences for protection (against escape mutants) is not reflected in an anti-HBs titer by standard anti-HBs assays. The presented differentiation in anti-HBs response after immunization may deliver new tools for evaluation of future vaccines.

Profiling the immune response in patients with breast cancer by phage-displayed cDNA libraries

Display on the surface of filamentous phages has been shown to be well suited for the enrichment of serum antibody-binding ligands. Here, we have taken the advantage of this technology to analyze the humoral immune response in patients with cancer. The cDNA repertoires from breast cancer cell lines T47D and MCF-7 were fused to the 3'-end of the filamentous phage M13 gene VI in all three reading frames. When the libraries were biopanned on rabbit polyclonal IgG against the human Bcl-x(L) protein, positive clones were selected, thus confirming the utility of the libraries. Using serum antibodies from patients with breast cancer, we specifically selected IgG-binding phage-encoded cDNA products. Sequence analysis of the selected clones identified important antigens including p53, centromere-F, int-2, pentraxin I, integrin beta5, cathepsin L2 and S3 ribosomal protein. The selected phage-displayed cDNA products were recognized by a significant number of breast cancer sera as compared to sera from normal individuals. Although the human pentraxin I mRNA was reported to be exclusively localized in the nervous system, we found it also expressed by breast cancer cell lines. Four out of 30 patients with breast cancer (13 %) showed reactivity with the recombinant pentraxin expressed in Escherichia coli, while no reactivity was found in normal sera. The obtained results demonstrate that phage display could be a valuable method for the identification of antigens recognized by the humoral immune system in patients with cancer.

Utilisation of bacteriophage display libraries to identify peptide sequences recognised by equine herpesvirus type 1 specific equine sera

Three filamentous phage random peptide display libraries were used in biopanning experiments with purified IgG from the serum of a gnotobiotic foal infected with equine herpesvirus-1 (EHV-1) to enrich for epitopes binding to anti-EHV-1 antibodies. The sequences of the amino acids displayed were aligned with protein sequences of EHV-1, thereby identifying a number of potential antibody binding regions. Presumptive epitopes were identified within the proteins encoded by genes 7 (DNA helicase/primase complex protein), 11 (tegument protein), 16 (glycoprotein C), 41 (integral membrane protein), 70 (glycoprotein G), 71 (envelope glycoprotein gp300), and 74 (glycoprotein E). Two groups of sequences, which aligned with either glycoprotein C (gC) or glycoprotein E (gE), identified type-specific epitopes which could be used to distinguish between sera from horses infected with either EHV-1 or EHV-4 in an ELISA using either the phage displaying the peptide or synthetic peptides as antigen. The gC epitope had been previously identified as an immunogenic region by conventional monoclonal antibody screening whereas the gE antibody binding region had not been previously identified. This demonstrates that screening of phage display peptide libraries with post-infection polyclonal sera is a suitable method for identifying diagnostic antigens for viral infections such as EHV-1.

Sequential determination of ligands binding to discrete components in heterogeneous mixtures by iterative panning and blocking (IPAB)

Biopanning has been used extensively in conjunction with purified components, but there are also examples in which mixtures of targets have been investigated. This study introduces a methodological innovation, termed iterative panning and blocking (IPAB), to extend the range of specific interactions that can be probed in mixtures. Here this procedure is used to probe a mixture of high molecular mass components of human cord blood with phage-peptide display libraries. The initial panning recovered phage that bore the consensus motif Gly-Pro-Arg-Pro, a known fibrinogen-binding motif. These phage bound specifically to purified fibrinogen. A series of peptides containing the Gly-Pro-Arg-Pro motif efficiently blocked the binding of phage having the same motif, presumably by binding to their common target. A second round of panning was performed against the same target mixture in the presence of this blocking peptide. Phage recovered from this second panning exhibited a motif (Ser-His-Tyr) that was subsequently shown to bind specifically to complement component C1q. A second peptide containing this motif specifically blocked the interaction of the phage with C1q. A third round of panning performed in the presence of both the fibrinogen- and the C1q- blocking peptides yielded phage with a new peptide motif (Asn-Pro-Phe) that also bound specifically to C1q, apparently at a new site. The three motifs isolated through this iterative process were distinct in that each was blocked only by its corresponding peptide. This IPAB strategy can be applied to many high diversity selection procedures that target complex mixtures.

Specificities of multiple sclerosis cerebrospinal fluid and serum antibodies against mimotopes

In order to characterize antigenic epitopes specifically targeted by the immune response of patients with multiple sclerosis (MS), the antibody specificities of cerebrospinal fluids (CSF) and sera from the same MS patients have been analyzed using a random pentadecapeptide library displayed on phage. The 3 peptides (mimotopes) selected with MS sera were not disease-specific. In contrast, the combination of 4 MS CSF selected mimotopes, allowed the detection of specific antibodies in 21 of 60 MS CSF whereas only 2 of 27 CSF from patients with other neurological diseases equally recognized the 4 mimotopes. Some amino acid similarities were found between two MS CSF selected mimotopes and two envelope regions (319-329 and 433-443, respectively) of MSRV (multiple-sclerosis-associated retrovirus) and the related endogenous retrovirus HERV-W.

Natural and iatrogenic variation in hepatitis B virus

The existence of HBV as quasispecies is thought to be favoured by the infidelity of HBV RT, which would account for the emergence of the many natural mutants with point substitutions. RT infidelity may also underlie the hypermutation phenomenon. Indeed, the oft-reported point mutation in the preC gene that leads to failure of HBeAg synthesis may be driven by a hypermutation-related mechanism. The presence of mutants with deletions and insertions involving single nucleotides and oligonucleotides at specific positions in the genome, and of mutants with deletions of even longer stretches particularly in the C gene, suggests that other mutagenic mechanisms operate. Candidates include slippage during mispairing between template and progeny DNA strand, the action of cellular topoisomerase I, and gene splicing using alternative donor and acceptor sites. Natural substitutions, deletions or insertions involving the Cp/ENII locus in the X gene can significantly alter the extent of viral replicative activity. Similar mutations occurring at other locations of Cp/ENII, and at B-cell epitope sites of the S gene are associated with failure to detect serological markers of HBV infection. HBV variation can also arise from recombination between coinfecting strains. S gene mutations that become evident following HBIG administration and HBV vaccination are all point substitutions, as are mutations in functional RT domains of the P gene after treatment with viral RT-inhibitory drugs. Widespread and long-term use of prophylactic and therapeutic agents may potentially generate serologically occult HBV variants that might become difficult to eradicate.

Two distinct segments of the hepatitis B virus surface antigen contribute synergistically to its association with the viral core particles

The long surface antigen polypeptide (L-HBsAg) of hepatitis B virus (HBV) is believed to mediate contact between the virus envelope and nucleocapsid protein (HBcAg). The N and C termini of L-HBsAg were shortened progressively in order to define the minimum contiguous sequence of amino acids that contains the residues necessary for association with HBcAg. The resulting mutants were expressed in rabbit reticulocyte lysates and their interaction with HBcAg was examined with an immunoprecipitation assay and an equilibrium binding assay in solution to give relative dissociation constants. Binding of HBcAg particles by L-HBsAg displayed two widely differing dissociation constants, indicating two distinct binding sites between the molecules. The two distinct sites, one located between residues 24 and 191 and the other between residues 191 and 322 of L-HBsAg, contribute synergistically to high-affinity binding to HBcAg, but disruption of either of these segments resulted in a much weaker interaction showing only one dissociation constant. Inhibition of the interaction by peptides that bind to the tips of the nucleocapsid spikes differentiated contacts in HBcAg for the two binding domains in L-HBsAg and implied that the amino-terminal binding domain contacts the tips of the HBcAg spikes. Analysis of specific single amino acid mutants of L-HBsAg showed that Arg92 played an important role in the interaction.

High Resolution Mapping of the B Cell Epitopes of Staphylokinase in Humans Using Negative Selection of a Phage-Displayed Antigen Library

Staphylokinase (Sak), a 16-kDa protein secreted by Staphylococcus aureus, induces fibrin-specific thrombolysis in patients with thrombotic disorders. However, Sak also elicits high titers of neutralizing Abs that persist for several months and preclude its repeated use in humans. To identify the antigenic determinants of Sak recognized by humans, a phage-displayed library of Sak variants was selected for mutants that escape binding to an affinity matrix derivatized with patient-specific polyclonal anti-Sak Abs. Fifty-six escape Sak variants were identified after three selection cycles using human polyclonal anti-Sak IgGs obtained from four different patients. DNA sequencing revealed 213 amino acid substitutions, of which 73% were found at 25 positions clustered in eight discontinuous Sak antigenic segments. Although each antigenic segment was recognized to a variable extent by each patient antiserum, the main epitopes of Sak in all patients were roughly targeted to two large discontinuous areas covering 35% of the solvent-accessible surface of Sak. The antigenic area I comprises three segments centered on residues 66, 73, and 135, while the antigenic area II consists of four segments centered on positions 20, 95, 102, and 121. These results suggest that a secondary immune response against Sak can occur in patients, and confirm an initial site-directed mutagenesis study wherein amino acid Lys74 was shown to play a prominent antigenic role. Comprehensive mapping of the most relevant sites of Sak that are antigenic for humans will guide efforts to modulate the immunogenicity of this therapeutically important molecule.

Use of the phage display technique for detection of epitopes recognized by polyclonal rabbit gliadin antibodies

A random phage heptapeptide library was screened with rabbit antibodies against wheat flour proteins comprising gliadins and a small amount of low molecular weight glutenins (gli/glu). Gli/glu antibodies isolated from the sera selected different consensus sequences (CS). All CS contained tri- to pentapeptide stretches homologous to gli/glu sequences (proposed epitopes). In alpha- and gamma-type gliadins, these sequences are clustered in the N-terminal region recently suspected to be toxic for humans with celiac disease. Peptides with CS were synthesized and checked for reactivity. Only immune and no control rabbit sera reacted with synthetic peptides. One of eight human sera containing gliadin antibodies was reactive as well (4/8 peptides) but control sera were negative. Thus the phage display technique is useful for epitope screening of polyclonal antibodies even in the case of a group of homologous but diverse antigens.

Screening of horse polyclonal antibodies with a random peptide library displayed on phage: identification of ligands used as antigens in an ELISA test to detect the presence of antibodies to equine arteritis virus

A random hexapeptide fusion-phage library was screened to isolate phages that bind to antibodies present in horse sera positive for equine arteritis virus (EAV). Analysis of the peptide sequences displayed by isolated phages identified seven groups. 25% of the isolated phages used as antigens in an ELISA test were specifically recognised by a pool of sera which was positive for EAV in virus neutralisation test (VN). Five of these, when used as antigen in ELISA, detected greater than 50% of sera (n = 30) containing antibodies to EAV as detected by VN. When these five phages were pooled together and used as antigen in ELISA, the detection was improved. The sensitivity and specificity of the ELISA were 99 and 71%, respectively, compared with the EAV neutralisation test (n = 200). This study has shown the potential that phage display libraries have for identifying peptide sequences which could be used as antigen in diagnostic ELISAs.

Cell-surface interactions of echovirus 22

Echovirus 22 (EV22) is a picornavirus forming a distinct molecular cluster together with echovirus 23. EV22 has an Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) peptide motif in its capsid protein VP1; similar motifs are known to mediate many cell-cell and microbe-host interactions. To identify peptide sequences that specifically bind to EV22 and potentially play a role in receptor recognition, we have used here peptide libraries displayed in filamentous phage. We isolated an EV22-binding motif CLRSG(R/F)GC. The synthetic CLRSGRGC peptide was able to inhibit EV22 infection. The infection was also inhibited by an RGD-containing peptide representing the C terminus of the EV22 capsid protein VP1 and CWDDGWLC (an RGD-binding peptide; Pasqualini, R., Koivunen, E., and Ruoslahti, E. (1995) J. Cell Biol. 130, 1189-1196). As the EV22-recognizing sequence LRSG is found in the integrin beta1 chain and the entire LRSGRG hexapeptide occurs in the matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9), we carried out blocking experiments with anti-integrin and anti-MMP-9 antibodies. EV22 infection could be blocked in cell cultures with anti-alphav, -beta1, and, to a lesser extent, with anti-MMP-9 antibodies. These results imply that EV22 recognizes preferentially alphavbeta1-integrin as a cellular receptor and MMP-9 may also play a role in the cell-surface interactions of the virus.