Evidence for cooperation between murine leukemia virus Env molecules in mixed oligomers

Unique Structure and Distinctive Properties of the Ancient and Ubiquitous Gamma-Type Envelope Glycoprotein

After the onset of the AIDS pandemic, HIV-1 (genus Lentivirus) became the predominant model for studying retrovirus Env glycoproteins and their role in entry. However, HIV Env is an inadequate model for understanding entry of viruses in the Alpharetrovirus, Gammaretrovirus and Deltaretrovirus genera. For example, oncogenic model system viruses such as Rous sarcoma virus (RSV, Alpharetrovirus), murine leukemia virus (MLV, Gammaretrovirus) and human T-cell leukemia viruses (HTLV-I and HTLV-II, Deltaretrovirus) encode Envs that are structurally and functionally distinct from HIV Env. We refer to these as Gamma-type Envs. Gamma-type Envs are probably the most widespread retroviral Envs in nature. They are found in exogenous and endogenous retroviruses representing a broad spectrum of vertebrate hosts including amphibians, birds, reptiles, mammals and fish. In endogenous form, gamma-type Envs have been evolutionarily coopted numerous times, most notably as placental syncytins (e.g., human SYNC1 and SYNC2). Remarkably, gamma-type Envs are also found outside of the Retroviridae. Gp2 proteins of filoviruses (e.g., Ebolavirus) and snake arenaviruses in the genus Reptarenavirus are gamma-type Env homologs, products of ancient recombination events involving viruses of different Baltimore classes. Distinctive hallmarks of gamma-type Envs include a labile disulfide bond linking the surface and transmembrane subunits, a multi-stage attachment and fusion mechanism, a highly conserved (but poorly understood) "immunosuppressive domain", and activation by the viral protease during virion maturation. Here, we synthesize work from diverse retrovirus model systems to illustrate these distinctive properties and to highlight avenues for further exploration of gamma-type Env structure and function.

Across the Hall from Pioneers

I was fortunate to be associated with the lab of Stephen Oroszlan at the US National Cancer Institute from ~1982 until his conversion to Emeritus status in 1995. His lab made groundbreaking discoveries on retroviral proteins during that time, including many features that could not have been inferred or anticipated from straightforward sequence information. Building on the Oroszlan lab results, my colleagues and I demonstrated that the zinc fingers in nucleocapsid proteins play a crucial role in genomic RNA encapsidation; that the N-terminal myristylation of the Gag proteins of many retroviruses is important for their association with the plasma membrane before particle assembly is completed; and that gammaretroviruses initially synthesize their Env protein as an inactive precursor and then truncate the cytoplasmic tail of the transmembrane protein, activating Env fusogenicity, during virus maturation. We also elucidated several aspects of the mechanism of translational suppression in pol gene expression in gammaretroviruses; amazingly, this is a fundamentally different mechanism of suppression from that in most other retroviral genera.

Cooperative cleavage of the R peptide in the Env trimer of Moloney murine leukemia virus facilitates its maturation for fusion competence

The spike protein of murine leukemia virus, MLV, is made as a trimer of the Env precursor. This is primed for receptor-induced activation of its membrane fusion function first by cellular furin cleavage in the ectodomain and then by viral protease cleavage in the endodomain. The first cleavage separates the peripheral surface (SU) subunit from the transmembrane (TM) subunit, and the latter releases a 16-residue-long peptide (R) from the TM endodomain. Here, we have studied the distribution of R peptide cleavages in the spike TM subunits of Moloney MLV preparations with partially R-peptide-processed spikes. The spikes were solubilized as trimers and separated with an R peptide antibody. This showed that the spikes were either uncleaved or cleaved in all of its TM subunits. Further studies showed that R peptide cleavage-inhibited Env mutants, L(649)V and L(649)I, were rescued by wild-type (wt) Env in heterotrimeric spikes. These findings suggested that the R peptide cleavages in the spike are facilitated through positive allosteric cooperativity; i.e., the cleavage of the TM subunit in one Env promoted the cleavages of the TMs in the other Envs. The mechanism ensures that protease cleavage in newly released virus will generate R-peptide-cleaved homotrimers rather than heterotrimeric intermediates. However, using a cleavage site Env mutant, L(649)R, which was not rescued by wt Env, it was possible to produce virus with heterotrimers. These were shown to be less fusion active than the R-peptide-cleaved homotrimers. Therefore, the cooperative cleavage will speed up the maturation of released virus for fusion competence.

Amphotropic retrovirus transduction is inhibited by high doses of particle-associated envelope proteins

Using a panel of amphotropic murine leukemia virus packaging cell lines that differed only in their levels of envelope protein (gp70) expression, we examined the relationship between transduction and the number of envelope proteins per virus. We generated virus stocks that contained different levels of virus-associated envelope proteins, purified them from gp70 that was not associated with the viruses, quantified their titers, and measured the efficiency with which they transduced NIH 3T3, TE671, and HeLa cells. As expected, titers increased monotonically with viral envelope protein number. Titers are measured using highly dilute virus, however, and are often not predictive of gene transfer when high doses of virus are used, as is done in gene therapy protocols. Interestingly, when we used high doses of virus, we observed significantly different trends: gene transfer increased, reached a maximum, and then declined sharply as the number of envelope proteins per virus increased. The highest levels of gene transfer occurred when cells were transduced with a moderate dose of virus that contained low levels of envelope protein. Our results indicate that transduction is inhibited when viruses that contain large numbers of envelope proteins are used. This is most likely because each virus, when it binds to a cell, delivers a large payload of envelope proteins that occupy or inactivate multiple virus receptors, reducing or eliminating the susceptibility of the cell to being transduced by additional viruses. The implications of our findings for the design of improved retroviral vectors for human gene therapy are discussed.

Characterization of R peptide of murine leukemia virus envelope glycoproteins in syncytium formation and entry

The C-terminal R peptide of ecotropic murine leukemia virus (MLV) envelope protein (Env) negatively controls membrane fusion activity. The R peptide cleavage during virion maturation activates its fusogenicity and is required for viral entry. We analyzed fusogenicity and transduction efficiency of mutant Env proteins of ecotropic, amphotropic, polytropic, and xenotropic MLVs. As the result, we found that the hydrophobic amino acid residues around the R peptide cleavage site are important for membrane fusion inhibition by the R peptide. In addition, we found that Env complexes with R peptide-truncated and -containing Env proteins have lower fusogenicity and transduction efficiency than those with the R-peptide-truncated Env alone, suggesting that efficient R peptide cleavage is required for efficient MLV vector transduction. The role of R peptide cleavage in amphotropic, polytropic, and xenotropic MLV infection has not been investigated. We found in this study that the R peptide cleavage is required for amphotropic, xenotropic, and polytropic MLV vector transduction, like with ecotropic MLV. The R-peptide-truncated Env proteins of the xenotropic and polytropic MLVs, however, had much lower fusogenicity than those of the ecotropic and amphotropic MLVs. These results provide valuable information for construction of efficient MLV vectors and for understanding the retroviral entry mechanism.

TR1.3 viral pathogenesis and syncytium formation are linked to Env-Gag cooperation

Infection with murine leukemia virus (MLV) TR1.3 or the related molecular construct W102G causes severe neuropathology in vivo. Infection is causally linked to the development of extensive syncytia in brain capillary endothelial cells (BCEC). These viruses also induce cell fusion of murine cell lines, such as SC-1 and NIH 3T3, which are otherwise resistant to MLV-induced syncytium formation. Although the virulence of these viruses maps within the env gene, the mechanism of fusion enhancement is not fully determined. To this end, we examined the capacity of the syncytium-inducing (SI) TR1.3 and W102G MLVs to overcome the fusion inhibitory activity inherent in the full-length Env cytoplasmic tail. These studies showed that the TR1.3 and W102G Envs did not induce premature cleavage of p2E, nor did they override p2E fusion inhibition. Indeed, in the presence of mutations that disrupt p2E function, the TR1.3 and W102G Envs significantly increased the extent of cell fusion compared to that with the non-syncytium-inducing MLV FB29. Surprisingly, we also observed that TR1.3 and W102G Envs failed to elicit syncytium formation in these in vitro assays. Coexpression of gag-pol with env restored syncytium formation, and accordingly, mutations within gag-pol were used to examine the minimal functional requirements for the SI phenotype. The results indicate that both gag-dependent particle budding and cleavage of p2E are required to activate the SI phenotype of TR1.3 and W102G viruses. Collectively, these data suggest that the TR1.3 and W102G viruses induce cell fusion by the fusion-from-without pathway.

Complete genome sequences of the two viral variants of the Graffi MuLV: Phylogenetic relationship with other murine leukemia retroviruses

A detailed phylogenetic analysis of two variants of the Graffi murine retrovirus, GV-1.2 and GV-1.4, showed that they are closely related to SRS 19-6 and Moloney MuLVs. Two stretches of sequence testify to the divergence between Graffi and SRS 19-6 MuLVs, one corresponding to a recombination event of Graffi MuLV with a xenotropic virus. Moloney MuLV was found more distant, particularly in the GAG region. Our study encompasses every class of MuLVs (ecotropic, amphotropic, xenotropic, polytropic) with some focus on exogenous ecotropic viruses and further adds to previous phylogenetic studies. Graffi, SRS 19-6, Moloney, Friend and Rauscher MuLVs form a cluster that appears to share a common ancestor with the Casitas-amphotropic and -ecotropic MuLVs but are more distant to the Akv-type and xenotropic MuLVs. The analysis also revealed that the ENV region of HEMV, the prototype of the MuLV ancestor, was closely related to the corresponding region of Cas-Br-E.

Stoichiometry of murine leukemia virus envelope protein-mediated fusion and its neutralization

Envelope glycoproteins (Envs) of retroviruses form trimers that mediate fusion between viral and cellular membranes and are the targets for neutralizing antibodies. Understanding in detail how Env trimers mediate membrane fusion, and how antibodies interfere with this process, is a fundamental problem in biology with practical implications for the development of antiviral drugs and vaccines. We investigated the stoichiometry of Env-mediated fusion and its inhibition by antibody by inserting an epitope from human immunodeficiency virus for a neutralizing antibody (2F5) into the surface (SU) or transmembrane (TM) protein of murine leukemia virus Env, along with point mutations that abrogate SU and TM function but complement one another. We transfected various combinations of these Env genes and investigated Env-mediated cell fusion and its inhibition by 2F5 antibody. Our results showed that heterotrimers with one functional SU molecule were fusion competent in complementation experiments and that one antibody molecule was sufficient to inactivate the fusion function of a trimer when its epitope was in functional SU or TM. 2F5 antibody could also neutralize trimers with the 2F5 epitope in nonfunctional SU or TM, but less efficiently.

Selection of feline leukemia virus envelope proteins from a library by functional association with a murine leukemia virus envelope

Libraries of feline leukemia virus subgroup A (FeLV-A)-derived envelope (Env) proteins with random peptides incorporated into the cell-targeting region were screened for productive gene delivery to the PC-3 human prostate cell line. In order to increase the efficiency of recovering and testing functional clones, the screen was performed in the presence of a replication-competent 4070A Env-expressing virus under conditions of viral interference. The Env proteins resulting from this library screen were able to mediate gene delivery to 4070A-infected human PC-3, DU145 prostate and TE671 rhabdomyosarcoma cells in the presence, but not absence, of 4070A helper virus. FeLV-A, FeLV-B and Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MuLV) Env proteins were unable to substitute for 4070A Env. Flow cytometry and Western blot analyses indicated increased cell-surface expression and virion incorporation of library-derived Env proteins in the presence of 4070A Env. Interference assays on cells infected with both 4070A and FeLV-B are consistent with the combination of library-derived and 4070A Env proteins utilizing the Pit1 receptor.

Relationship between retroviral vector membrane and vector stability

The present work studies the physico-chemical properties of retroviral vector membrane, in order to provide some explanation for the inactivation kinetics of these vectors and to devise new ways of improving transduction efficiency. For this purpose, vectors with an amphotropic envelope produced by TE Fly A7 cells at two culture temperatures (37 and 32 °C) were characterized by different techniques. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) results showed that vectors produced at 32 °C are more rigid than those produced at 37 °C. Further characterization of vector membrane composition allowed us to conclude that the vector inactivation rate increases with elevated cholesterol to phospholipid ratio. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) showed that production temperature also affects the conformation of the membrane proteins. Transduction studies using HCT116 cells and tri-dimensional organ cultures of mouse skin showed that vectors produced at 37 °C have higher stability and thus higher transduction efficiency in gene therapy relevant cells as compared with vectors produced at 32 °C. Overall, vectors produced at 37 °C show an increased stability at temperatures below 4 °C. Since vector membrane physico-chemical properties are affected in response to changes in culture temperature, such changes, along with alterations in medium composition, can be used prospectively to improve the stability and the transduction efficiency of retroviral vectors for therapeutic purposes.

Amino acid residues in the cytoplasmic domain of the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus glycoprotein critical for its incorporation into virions

Assembly of an infectious retrovirus requires the incorporation of the envelope glycoprotein complex during the process of particle budding. We have recently demonstrated that amino acid substitutions of a tyrosine residue in the cytoplasmic domain block glycoprotein incorporation into budding Mason-Pfizer monkey virus (M-PMV) particles and abrogate infectivity (C. Song, S. R. Dubay, and E. Hunter, J. Virol. 77:5192-5200, 2003). To investigate the contribution of other amino acids in the cytoplasmic domain to the process of glycoprotein incorporation, we introduced alanine-scanning mutations into this region of the transmembrane protein. The effects of the mutations on glycoprotein biosynthesis and function, as well as on virus infectivity, have been examined. Mutation of two cytoplasmic residues, valine 20 and histidine 21, inhibits viral protease-mediated cleavage of the cytoplasmic domain that is observed during virion maturation, but the mutant virions show only moderately reduced infectivity. We also demonstrate that the cytoplasmic domain of the M-PMV contains three amino acid residues that are absolutely essential for incorporation of glycoprotein into virions. In addition to the previously identified tyrosine at residue 22, an isoleucine at position 18 and a leucine at position 25 each mediate the process of incorporation and efficient release of virions. While isoleucine 18 may be involved in direct interactions with immature capsids, antibody uptake studies showed that leucine 25 and tyrosine 22 are part of an efficient internalization signal in the cytoplasmic domain of the M-PMV glycoprotein. These results demonstrate that the cytoplasmic domain of M-PMV Env, in part through its YXXL-mediated endocytosis and intracellular trafficking signals, plays a critical role in the incorporation of glycoprotein into virions.

Cell surface receptors for gammaretroviruses

Evidence obtained during the last few years has greatly extended our understanding of the cell surface receptors that mediate infections of retroviruses and has provided many surprising insights. In contrast to other cell surface components such as lectins or proteoglycans that influence infections indirectly by enhancing virus adsorption onto specific cells, the true receptors induce conformational changes in the viral envelope glycoproteins that are essential for infection. One surprise is that all of the cell surface receptors for gamma-retroviruses are proteins that have multiple transmembrane (TM) sequences, compatible with their identification in known instances as transporters for important solutes. In striking contrast, almost all other animal viruses use receptors that exclusively have single TM sequences, with the sole proven exception we know of being the coreceptors used by lentiviruses. This evidence strongly suggests that virus genera have been prevented because of their previous evolutionary adaptations from switching their specificities between single-TM and multi-TM receptors. This evidence also implies that gamma-retroviruses formed by divergent evolution from a common origin millions of years ago and that individual viruses have occasionally jumped between species (zoonoses) while retaining their commitment to using the orthologous receptor of the new host. Another surprise is that many gamma-retroviruses use not just one receptor but pairs of closely related receptors as alternatives. This appears to have enhanced viral survival by severely limiting the likelihood of host escape mutations. All of the receptors used by gamma-retroviruses contain hypervariable regions that are often heavily glycosylated and that control the viral host range properties, consistent with the idea that these sequences are battlegrounds of virus-host coevolution. However, in contrast to previous assumptions, we propose that gamma-retroviruses have become adapted to recognize conserved sites that are important for the receptor's natural function and that the hypervariable sequences have been elaborated by the hosts as defense bulwarks that surround the conserved viral attachment sites. Previously, it was believed that binding to receptors directly triggers a series of conformational changes in the viral envelope glycoproteins that culminate in fusion of the viral and cellular membranes. However, new evidence suggests that gamma-retroviral association with receptors triggers an obligatory interaction or cross-talk between envelope glycoproteins on the viral surface. If this intermediate step is prevented, infection fails. Conversely, in several circumstances this cross-talk can be induced in the absence of a cell surface receptor for the virus, in which case infection can proceed efficiently. This new evidence strongly implies that the role of cell surface receptors in infections of gamma-retroviruses (and perhaps of other enveloped animal viruses) is more complex and interesting than was previously imagined. Recently, another gammaretroviral receptor with multiple transmembrane sequences was cloned. See Prassolov, Y., Zhang, D., Ivanov, D., Lohler, J., Ross, S.R., and Stocking, C. Sodium-dependent myo-inositol transporter 1 is a receptor for Mus cervicolor M813 murine leukemia virus.

Cytoplasmic tail of Moloney murine leukemia virus envelope protein influences the conformation of the extracellular domain: implications for mechanism of action of the R Peptide

The envelope (Env) protein of Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoMuLV) is a homotrimeric complex whose monomers consist of linked surface (SU) and transmembrane (TM) proteins cleaved from a precursor protein by a cellular protease. In addition, a significant fraction of virion-associated TM is further processed by the viral protease to remove the C-terminal 16 amino acids of the cytoplasmic domain, the R peptide. This cleavage greatly enhances the fusogenicity of the protein and is necessary for the formation of a fully functional Env protein complex. We have previously proposed that R peptide cleavage enhances fusogenicity by altering the conformation of the ectodomain of the protein (Y. Zhao et al., J. Virol. 72:5392-5398, 1998). Using a series of truncation and point mutants of MoMuLV Env, we now provide direct biochemical and immunological evidence that the cytoplasmic tail and the membrane-spanning region of Env can influence the overall structure of the ectodomain of the protein and alter the strength of the SU-TM interaction. The R-peptide-truncated form of the protein, in particular, exhibits a markedly different conformation than the full-length protein.

The insertion of an anti-MHC I ScFv into the N-terminus of an ecotropic MLV glycoprotein does not alter its fusiogenic potential on murine cells

It is known that targeted infection requires the modification of the viral envelope, in order to render it capable of recognizing and specifically binding to a marker protein of the target cell. We have previously described such a recombinant envelope, which is able to extend the tropism of an ecotropic murine leukemia viruses (MLV) envelope to MHC I-expressing human cells. Although, this envelope was very efficient in binding human cells, it yielded very low infection titers. Our attempts to improve these yields by the additional cloning of a variety of spacers in the proximity of the single-chain variable fragment (ScFv) moiety did not significantly influenced human titers, although some alterations on murine titers were observed. To examine whether these low yields represent a decreased fusion capacity of the recombinant envelopes, we performed an assay which allowed the direct comparison between the fusiogenicity of the wild-type (w/t) and the chimeric envelopes. No fusiogenicity of the chimeric envelopes was observed when chimera-expressing cells were co-cultured with human cells. The inability of the chimeras to induce fusion after binding of the ScFv moiety to its ligand may explain, in part, the low infection titers on human cells. However, the several-fold differences observed between the titers of the w/t envelope and the various chimeras on murine cells were not reflected on their fusiogenic potentials, which were all in the same order of magnitude. Our results demonstrate that the binding of the ScFv moiety to its ligand induces no fusion, albeit its insertion into the envelope does not alter the intrinsic fusiogenic ability of the latter. Induction of fusion results from the binding of the envelope to the ecotropic receptor, without being directly proportional to its binding affinity. Chimeras with different infection titers on murine cells yielded similar syncytia counts after their binding to the ecotropic receptor.

Sequences in the cytoplasmic tail of the gibbon ape leukemia virus envelope protein that prevent its incorporation into lentivirus vectors

Pseudotyping retrovirus and lentivirus vectors with different viral fusion proteins is a useful strategy to alter the host range of the vectors. Although lentivirus vectors are efficiently pseudotyped by Env proteins from several different subtypes of murine leukemia virus (MuLV), the related protein from gibbon ape leukemia virus (GaLV) does not form functional pseudotypes. We have determined that this arises because of an inability of GaLV Env to be incorporated into lentivirus vector particles. By exploiting the homology between the GaLV and MuLV Env proteins, we have mapped the determinants of incompatibility in the GaLV Env. Three modifications that allowed GaLV Env to pseudotype human immunodeficiency virus type 1 particles were identified: removal of the R peptide (C-terminal half of the cytoplasmic domain), replacement of the whole cytoplasmic tail with the corresponding MuLV region, and mutation of two residues upstream of the R peptide cleavage site. In addition, we have previously proposed that removal of the R peptide from MuLV Env proteins enhances their fusogenicity by transmitting a conformational change to the ectodomain of the protein (Y. Zhao et al., J. Virol. 72:5392-5398, 1998). Our analysis of chimeric MuLV/GaLV Env proteins provides further evidence in support of this model and suggests that proper Env function involves both interactions within the cytoplasmic tail and more long-range interactions between the cytoplasmic tail, the membrane-spanning region, and the ectodomain of the protein.

Two point mutations increase targeted transduction and stabilize vector association of a modified retroviral envelope protein

The current strategy of targeting retroviral vector transduction by inserting a peptide ligand into the envelope protein has met with several obstacles. These modified proteins redirected vector binding to a new cognate receptor on a specific cell type but gave little or no gene transfer because they did not fuse the vector and target cell membranes. They dissociated readily from vectors and often required coassembly of wild-type envelope protein. Here we report a novel strategy to overcome the fusion and stability defects of modified retroviral envelope proteins. We inserted a prototypic ligand, the receptor binding domain of amphotropic murine leukemia virus, into an ecotropic murine leukemia virus envelope protein mutant containing glutamine 227-to-arginine plus aspartate 243-to-tyrosine substitutions. This modified protein increased transduction redirected to human cells expressing the amphotropic receptor to a level within 10-fold that of wild-type amphotropic virus, an increase of as great as 2000-fold over transduction by modified protein lacking the mutations. In addition to suppressing the fusion defect, these mutations unexpectedly stabilized the association of the modified protein with vector particles. Insertion of clinically relevant ligands into this envelope mutant should improve the efficiency and reliability of retroviral transduction of specific cell types for gene therapy applications.

Cooperative subunit interactions within the oligomeric envelope glycoprotein of HIV-1: functional complementation of specific defects in gp120 and gp41

The envelope glycoprotein (Env) of HIV-1 is displayed on the surface of the virion or infected cell as an oligomer of multiple gp120/gp41 complexes. We sought to unravel the relationships between this oligomeric structure and the requirements for sequential interactions with CD4 and coreceptor (CCR5 or CXCR4). We used a quantitative cell fusion assay to examine the effects of coexpressing pairs of Envs, each nonfunctional because of a specific defect in one of the essential properties. We observed efficient fusion activity upon coexpression of two Env variants, one containing a gp41 subunit with a mutated fusion peptide and the other containing a gp120 subunit with a mutated CD4 binding site or a mismatched coreceptor specificity. We also observed fusion upon coexpression of two Env variants with distinct gp120 defects, i.e., a CD4 binding site mutation and the incorrect coreceptor specificity determinants. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments verified the efficient formation of mixed oligomers, suggesting that the observed fusion reflected subunit complementation within the oligomeric complex. These results support a model in which cooperative subunit interactions within the Env oligomer result in concerted conformational changes upon receptor binding, resulting in activation for fusion. The implications of these findings for Env function and virus neutralization are discussed.

A lentiviral vector expressing a fusogenic glycoprotein for cancer gene therapy

The gibbon ape leukaemia virus envelope fusogenic membrane glycoprotein (GALV FMG) is a highly potent cytotoxic gene with great potential for use in cancer gene therapy. Here, we show that production of a VSV-G pseudotyped lentiviral vector expressing GALV FMG reconciles the requirements of viral production with the cytotoxic effects of GALV in human cells and has high titres on both dividing and quiescent tumour cells. Direct intratumoral injection of these stocks eradicated progressively growing human tumour xenografts. The potent bystander effect of the FMG transgene is a major contributor to the success of this approach but immunological activation may also be a factor. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration in vivo of the potential both of FMG and lentiviral vectors for cancer gene therapy and highlights the importance of exploring different vector systems to complement the biological properties of the therapeutic transgene.

Efficient cell infection by Moloney murine leukemia virus-derived particles requires minimal amounts of envelope glycoprotein

Retrovirus entry into cells is mediated by specific interactions between the retrovirally encoded Env envelope glycoprotein and a host cell surface receptor. Though a number of peptide motifs responsible for the structure as well as for the binding and fusion activities of Env have been identified, only a few quantitative data concerning the infection process are available. Using an inducible expression system, we have expressed various amounts of ecotropic and amphotropic Env at the surfaces of Moloney murine leukemia virus-derived vectors and assayed for the infectivity of viral particles. Contrary to the current view that numerous noncooperative Env-viral receptor interactions are required for cell infection, we report here that very small amounts of Env are sufficient for optimal infection. However, increasing Env density clearly accelerates the rate at which infectious attachment to cells occurs. Moreover, our data also show that a surprisingly small number of Env molecules are sufficient to drive infection, albeit at a reduced efficiency, and that, under conditions of low expression, Env molecules act cooperatively. These observations have important consequences for our understanding of natural retroviral infection as well as for the design of cell-targeted infection techniques involving retroviral vectors.

Coreceptor-dependent inhibition of the cell fusion activity of simian immunodeficiency virus Env proteins

The cytoplasmic tail (R peptide) sequence is able to regulate the fusion activity of the murine leukemia virus (MuLV) envelope (Env) protein. We have previously shown that this sequence exerts a profound inhibitory effect on the fusion activity of simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV)-MuLV chimeric Env proteins which contain the extracellular and transmembrane domains of the SIV Env protein. Recent studies have shown that SIV can utilize several alternative cellular coreceptors for its fusion and entry into the cell. We have investigated the fusion activity of SIV and SIV-MuLV chimeric Env proteins using cells that express different coreceptors. HeLa cells were transfected with plasmid constructs that carry the SIV or SIV-MuLV chimeric Env protein genes and were overlaid with either CEMx174 cells or Ghost Gpr15 cells, which express the Gpr15 coreceptor for SIV, or Ghost CCR5 cells, which express CCR5, an alternate coreceptor for SIV. The R-peptide sequence in the SIV-MuLV chimeric proteins was found to inhibit the fusion with CEMx174 cells or Ghost Gpr15 cells. However, a significant level of fusion was still observed when HeLa cells expressing the chimeric Env proteins were cocultivated with Ghost CCR5 cells. These results show that the R-peptide sequence exerts differential effects on the fusion activity of SIV Env proteins using target cells that express alternative coreceptors.

Expanded host cell tropism and cytopathic properties of feline immunodeficiency virus strain PPR subsequent to passage through interleukin-2-independent T cells

A cytopathic variant of feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) strain PPR emerged after passage of wild-type virus on an interleukin-2-independent cell line. The virus, termed FIV-PPRglial, displayed a phenotype markedly different from the parental virus, including the ability to productively infect previously refractory cell lines, induction of large syncytia, and accelerated kinetic properties. A chimeric molecular clone, FIV-PPRchim42, containing the FIV-PPRglial envelope within the backbone of FIV-PPR, exhibited all the characteristics of the FIV-PPRglial phenotype, demonstrating that the viral envelope was responsible for the acquired traits. Subsequent molecular characterization revealed that the FIV-PPRglial envelope contained five amino acid substitutions relative to wild-type FIV-PPR. Mutagenic analyses further demonstrated that the acquired phenotype was minimally attributable to a combination of three mutations, specifically, a glutamine-to-proline change within the second constant domain of the surface protein (SU); a threonine-to-proline change within the V4 loop, also in the SU; and a premature stop codon in the cytoplasmic tail of the transmembrane protein. All three changes were required to produce the FIV-PPRglial phenotype. Cotransfection studies with mutant viruses in combination with each other and with FIV-PPR indicated that the truncated cytoplasmic tail was responsible for the induction of syncytium formation. Receptor usage analyses were pursued, and distinctions were observed between FIV-PPR and FIV-PPRglial. In vitro infections with FIV-PPR, FIV-PPRglial, and FIV-34TF10 on two adherent cell lines were ablated in the presence of SDF1alpha, the natural ligand for CXCR4. In contrast, viral infection of T cells was not limited to CXCR4 usage, and inhibition studies indicate the potential involvement of a CC chemokine receptor.

Activation of a cell entry pathway common to type C mammalian retroviruses by soluble envelope fragments

Mutations that negatively or positively affect the fusion properties of murine leukemia viruses (MLVs) have been found within all subdomains of their SU (surface) and TM (transmembrane) envelope units. Yet, the interrelations between these different regions of the envelope complex during the cell entry process are still elusive. Deletion of the histidine residue of the conserved PHQV motif at the amino terminus of the amphotropic or the ecotropic MLV SU resulted in the AdelH or the MOdelH fusion-defective mutant envelope, respectively. These delH mutant envelopes are incorporated on retroviral particles at normal densities and normally mediate virion binding to cells expressing the retroviral receptors. However, both their cell-cell and virus-cell fusogenicities were fully prevented at an early postbinding stage. We show here that the fusion defect of AdelH or MOdelH envelopes was also almost completely reverted by providing either soluble SU or a polypeptide encompassing the receptor-binding domain (RBD) to the target cells, provided that the integrity of the amino-terminal end of either polypeptide was preserved. Restoration of delH envelope fusogenicity was caused by activation of the target cells via specific interaction of the latter polypeptides with the retrovirus receptor rather than by their association with the delH envelope complexes. Moreover crossactivation of the target cells, leading to fusion activation of AdelH or MOdelH envelopes, was achieved by polypeptides containing various type C mammalian retrovirus RBDs, irrespective of the type of entry-defective glycoprotein that was used for infection. Our results indicate that although they recognize different receptors for binding to the cell surface, type C mammalian retroviruses use a common entry pathway which is activated by a conserved feature of their envelope glycoproteins.

Stoichiometry of monoclonal antibody neutralization of T-cell line-adapted human immunodeficiency virus type 1

In order to study the stoichiometry of monoclonal antibody (MAb) neutralization of T-cell line-adapted human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in antibody excess and under equilibrium conditions, we exploited the ability of HIV-1 to generate mixed oligomers when different env genes are coexpressed. By the coexpression of Env glycoproteins that either can or cannot bind a neutralizing MAb in an env transcomplementation assay, virions were generated in which the proportion of MAb binding sites could be regulated. As the proportion of MAb binding sites in Env chimeric virus increased, MAb neutralization gradually increased. Virus neutralization by virion aggregation was minimal, as MAb binding to HIV-1 Env did not interfere with an AMLV Env-mediated infection by HIV-1(AMLV/HIV-1) pseudotypes of CD4(-) HEK293 cells. MAb neutralization of chimeric virions could be described as a third-order function of the proportion of Env antigen refractory to MAb binding. This scenario is consistent with the Env oligomer constituting the minimal functional unit and neutralization occurring incrementally as each Env oligomer binds MAb. Alternatively, the data could be fit to a sigmoid function. Thus, these data could not exclude the existence of a threshold for neutralization. However, results from MAb neutralization of chimeric virus containing wild-type Env and Env defective in CD4 binding was readily explained by a model of incremental MAb neutralization. In summary, the data indicate that MAb neutralization of T-cell line-adapted HIV-1 is incremental rather than all or none and that each MAb binding an Env oligomer reduces the likelihood of infection.

Failure To cleave murine leukemia virus envelope protein does not preclude its incorporation in virions and productive virus-receptor interaction

It is thought that complete cleavage of retroviral envelope protein into mature surface protein (SU) and transmembrane protein (TM) is critical for its assembly into virions and the formation of infectious virus particles. Here we report the identification of highly infectious, cleavage-deficient envelope mutant proteins. Substitution of aspartate for lysine 104, arginines 124 and 126, or arginines 223 and 225 strongly suppressed cleavage of the envelope precursor and yet allowed efficient incorporation of precursor molecules as the predominant species in virions that were almost as infectious as the wild-type virus. These results indicate that cleavage of the envelope precursor into mature SU and TM is not necessary for assembly into virions. Moreover, they call into question how many mature envelope protein subunits are required to complete virus entry, suggesting that a very few molecules suffice. The failure of host cell proteases to cleave these mutant proteins, whose substitutions are distal to the actual site of cleavage, suggests that the envelope precursor is misfolded, sequestering the cleavage site. In agreement with this, all cleavage mutant proteins exhibited significant losses of receptor binding, suggesting that these residues play roles in proper envelope protein folding. We also identified a charged residue, arginine 102, whose substitution suppressed envelope cleavage and allowed precursor incorporation but resulted in virions that were virtually noninfectious and that exhibited the greatest reduction in receptor binding. Placement of these cleavage mutations into envelope proteins of targeted retroviral vectors for human gene therapy may prevent loss of the modified surface proteins from virions, improving their infectivity and storage hardiness.

Suppression of a fusion defect by second site mutations in the ecotropic murine leukemia virus surface protein

Entry of ecotropic murine leukemia virus initiates when the envelope surface protein recognizes and binds to the virus receptor on host cells. The envelope transmembrane protein then mediates fusion of viral and host cell membranes and penetration into the cytoplasm. Using a genetic selection, we isolated an infectious retrovirus variant containing three changes in the surface protein-histidine 8 to arginine, glutamine 227 to arginine, and aspartate 243 to tyrosine. Single replacement of histidine 8 with arginine (H8R) resulted in almost complete loss of infectivity, even though the mutant envelope proteins were stable and efficiently incorporated into virions. Virions carrying H8R envelope were proficient at binding cells expressing receptor but failed to induce cell-cell fusion of XC cells, indicating that the histidine at position 8 plays an essential role in fusion during penetration of the host cell membrane. Thus, there is at least one domain in SU that is involved in fusion; the fusion functions do not reside exclusively in TM. In contrast, envelope with all three changes induced cell-cell fusion of XC cells and produced virions that were 10,000-fold more infectious than those containing only the H8R substitution, indicating that changes at positions 227 and 243 can suppress a fusion defect caused by loss of histidine 8 function. Moreover, the other two changes acted synergistically, indicating that both compensate for the loss of the same essential function of histidine 8. The ability of these changes to suppress this fusion defect might provide a means for overcoming postbinding defects found in targeted retroviral vectors for use in human gene therapy.

Identification of the block in targeted retroviral-mediated gene transfer

A chimeric retroviral vector (33E67) containing a CD33-specific single-chain antibody was generated in an attempt to target cells displaying the CD33 surface antigen. The chimeric envelope protein was translated, processed, and incorporated into viral particles as efficiently as wild-type envelope protein. The viral particles carrying the 33E67 envelope protein could bind efficiently to the CD33 receptor on target cells and were internalized, but no gene transfer occurred. A unique experimental approach was used to examine the basis for this postbinding block. Our data indicate that the chimeric envelope protein itself cannot participate in the fusion process, the most reasonable explanation being that this chimeric protein cannot undergo the appropriate conformational change that is thought to be triggered by receptor binding, a suggested prerequisite to subsequent fusion and core entry. These results indicate that the block to gene transfer in this system, and probably in most of the current chimeric retroviral vectors to date, is the inability of the chimeric envelope protein to undergo this obligatory conformational change.

Role of variable regions A and B in receptor binding domain of amphotropic murine leukemia virus envelope protein

For the amphotropic murine leukemia virus (MuLV), a 208-amino-acid amino-terminal fragment of the surface unit (SU) of the envelope glycoprotein is sufficient to bind to its receptor, Pit2. Within this binding domain, two hypervariable regions, VRA and VRB, have been proposed to be important for receptor recognition. In order to specifically locate residues that are important for the interaction with Pit2, we generated a number of site-specific mutations in both VRA and VRB and analyzed the resulting envelope proteins when expressed on retroviral vectors. Concurrently, we substituted portions of the amphotropic SU with homologous regions from the polytropic MuLV envelope protein. The amphotropic SU was unaffected by most of the point mutations we introduced. In addition, the deletion of eight residues in a region of VRA that was previously suggested to be essential for Pit2 utilization only decreased titer on NIH 3T3 cells by 1 order of magnitude. Although the replacement of the amino-terminal two-thirds of VRA with the polytropic sequence abolished receptor binding, smaller nonoverlapping substitutions did not affect the function of the protein. We were not able to identify a single critical receptor contact point within VRA, and we suggest that the amphotropic receptor binding domain probably makes multiple contacts with the receptor and that the loss of some of these contacts can be tolerated.

Fusion between uninfected cells in retrovirus-induced fusion-from-within

We previously examined Moloney murine leukemia virus-induced fusion-from-within (FFWI) and fusion-from-without (FFWO) of SC-1 mouse cells. FFWI and FFWO can be distinguished by their stimulation by ionophores and polycations, respectively. FFWI is caused by infected cells. Normally, fusion between an infected cell and uninfected cells (heterofusions) is described, but we have surprisingly found that the infected cells also caused homofusion between uninfected cells in their vicinity (named neighbor homofusions). It was shown that neighbor homofusions were not induced by free virus particles (by FFWO). Transfectants expressing envelope proteins only induced heterofusions, indicating that virus production is necessary for the formation of neighbor homofusions. Both plasma membrane fragments and easily removable material from the surface of infected cells were able to induce fusion with the same stimulation pattern as FFWI and neighbor homofusion. These materials, especially the latter, have properties in common with virions, and it is discussed whether immature virions are involved in the formation of the neighbor homofusions.