The differential dynamics of antibody subpopulation expression during affinity maturation in a teleost

Cold-blooded vertebrates evolved organized germinal center-like structures

Germinal centers (GCs) or analogous secondary lymphoid microstructures (SLMs) are thought to have evolved in endothermic species. However, living representatives of their ectothermic ancestors can mount potent secondary antibody responses upon infection or immunization, despite the apparent lack of SLMs in these cold-blooded vertebrates. How and where adaptive immune responses are induced in ectothermic species in the absence of GCs or analogous SLMs remain poorly understood. Here, we infected a teleost fish (trout) with the parasite Ichthyophthirius multifiliis (Ich) and identified the formation of large aggregates of highly proliferating IgM+ B cells and CD4+ T cells, contiguous to splenic melanomacrophage centers (MMCs). Most of these MMC-associated lymphoid aggregates (M-LAs) contained numerous antigen (Ag)-specific B cells. Analysis of the IgM heavy chain CDR3 repertoire of microdissected splenic M-LAs and non-M-LA areas revealed that the most frequent B cell clones induced after Ich infection were highly shared only within the M-LAs of infected animals. These M-LAs represented highly polyclonal SLMs in which Ag-specific B cell clonal expansion occurred. M-LA-associated B cells expressed high levels of activation-induced cytidine deaminase and underwent significant apoptosis, and somatic hypermutation of Igμ genes occurred prevalently in these cells. Our findings demonstrate that ectotherms evolved organized SLMs with GC-like roles. Moreover, our results also point to primordially conserved mechanisms by which M-LAs and mammalian polyclonal GCs develop and function.

Major histocompatibility complex class IIα and IIβ of pufferfish (Takifugu obscurus): Identification and functional characterization in response to bacterial challenge

Classical major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules play an essential role in immune system. In this study, MHC IIα (Pf-MHC IIα) and MHC IIβ (Pf-MHC IIβ) homology genes from pufferfish (Takifugu obscurus) were cloned and their functional characterization in response to bacterial challenge was identified. The nucleotide sequences of the open reading frames (ORFs) of pufferfish Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ were 708 bp and 750 bp, encoding 235 aa and 249 aa, respectively. The structure of Pf-MHC IIα or Pf-MHC IIβ contained a signal peptide, an α1/β1 domain, an α2/β2 domain, a transmembrane region and a cytoplasmic region. Multiple sequence alignment and phylogenetic analysis showed that Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ molecules had the highest similarity with Fugu rubripes (Takifugu rubripes). Cellular localization analysis indicated that the distribution of Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ was in the lymphocyte membrane and cytoplasm. qRT-PCR results showed that Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ expressed relatively high in skin, gills and gut. In addition, after stimulation challenge in vitro (lipopolysaccharide, or polyinosinic: polycytidylic acid) and in vivo (A. hydrophila), the mRNA expressions of Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ were significantly up-regulated in lymphocytes and in tissues of skin, gills, gut and head kidney. Moreover, Pf-MHC IIα or Pf-MHC IIβ neutralization reduced the ability of A. hydrophila to induce the expressions of lymphocyte cytokines (TNF-α, IL-1β and IL-10). Overall, it is speculated that Pf-MHC IIα and Pf-MHC IIβ may play an important role in the host response against A. hydrophila in pufferfish.

450 million years in the making: mapping the evolutionary foundations of germinal centers

Germinal centers (GCs) are distinct microanatomical structures that form in the secondary lymphoid organs of endothermic vertebrates (i.e., mammals and some birds). Within GCs, B cells undergo a Darwinian selection process to identify clones which can respond to pathogen insult as well as affinity mature the B cell repertoire. The GC response ultimately generates memory B cells and bone marrow plasma cells which facilitate humoral immunological memory, the basis for successful vaccination programs. GCs have not been observed in the secondary lymphoid organs of ectothermic jawed vertebrates (i.e., fishes, reptiles, and amphibians). However, abundant research over the past decades has indicated these organisms can produce antigen specific B cell responses and some degree of affinity maturation. This review examines data demonstrating that the fundamentals of B cell selection may be more conserved across vertebrate phylogeny than previously anticipated. Further, research in both conventional mammalian model systems and comparative models raises the question of what evolutionary benefit GCs provide endotherms if they are seemingly unnecessary for generating the basic functional components of jawed vertebrate humoral adaptive immune responses.

Characterization of T-cell receptors and immunoglobulin heavy chains loci and identification of T/B cell clusters in teleost

Bacterial disease is one of the important factors leading to economic losses in the turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) cultivation industry. T lymphocytes are major components of cellular immunity, whereas B lymphocytes produce immunoglobulins (Ig) that are key elements of humoral immune responses against infection. However, the genomic organization of genes encoding T-cell receptors (TCR) and immunoglobulin heavy chains (IgHs) in turbot remains largely unknown. In this study, abundant full-length transcripts of TCRs and IgHs were sequenced by Isoform-sequencing (Iso-seq), and we investigated and annotated the V, D, J and C gene loci of TCRα, TCRβ, IgT, IgM and IgD in turbot. Furthermore, through single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) of blood leukocytes, we confirmed that these identified TCRs and IgHs were highly expressed in T/B cell clusters, respectively. Meanwhile, we also identified the IgM⁺IgD⁺ B and IgT⁺ B cells with differential gene expression profiles and potential functions. Taken together, our results provide a comprehensive understanding of TCRs and IgHs loci in turbot, which will contribute to evolutionary and functional characterization of T and B lymphocytes in teleost.

Immunoglobulin VDJ repertoires reveal hallmarks of germinal centers in unique cell clusters isolated from zebrafish (Danio rerio) lymphoid tissues

DNA mutagenesis during antibody affinity maturation has potentially oncogenic or autoimmune outcomes if not tightly controlled as it is in mammalian germinal centers. Cold blooded vertebrates lack germinal centers, yet have a functional Ig gene mutator enzyme, Aicda. In fish there are clusters of Aicda⁺ cells encircled by pigmented 'melano-macrophages' and we test the hypothesis that these clusters are functionally analogous to germinal centers. Sequenced IgH VDJ repertoire libraries from individual isolated clusters showed evidence of B-cell clonal expansion and VDJ somatic hypermutation. Construction of Ig clonal lineage trees revealed that unlike surrounding lymphoid tissue, each cluster is dominated by a few B-cell VDJ clonotypes having hundreds of mutated variants. Recruitment of B-cells to the clusters appears to be ongoing, as there are additional Ig clones having smaller lineages. Finally, we show evidence for positive selection for replacement mutations in regions encoding the antigen contact loops, but not in the framework regions, consistent with functional antibody modification. Melano-macrophages appear to trap the Ag used for post-mutation B-cell selection, performing a role analogous to the follicular dendritic cells of mammalian germinal centers. These findings provide insights into the evolution of the affinity maturation process, the improvement of fish vaccines and possibly also the workings of atypical ectopic germinal centers generated in several human diseases.

A single-step, high throughput, and highly reproducible method for measuring IgM quantity and avidity directly from fish serum via biolayer interferometry (BLI)

Quantification of specific antibody responses is critical in determining activation of MHCII-dependent immune memory and is generally performed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Antibody avidity for a particular antigen is also informative of the quality of the adaptive immune response following vaccination. Avidity can be determined by chaotropic elution ELISA, pre-absorption ELISA, or surface plasmon resonance (SPR), although multimeric antibodies such as IgM are problematic for SPR. ELISA-based assays are very time consuming, require secondary antibody reagents, and are poorly repeatable. Here we demonstrate that biolayer interferometry (BLI) using an Octet HTX instrument can robustly and reproducibly quantify and determine avidity of specific IgM for an antigen directly from fish serum in a single step. We collected sera from giant grouper (Epinephelus lanceolatus) that had been vaccinated with the hapten 2,4-dinitrophenol conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH) and from control fish injected with phosphate buffered saline. The specific IgM in the serum and its avidity for DNP were quantified via ELISA and BLI. BLI was precise and highly repeatable for determination of the quantity and avidity of antibody in the serum compared to ELISA. The wet-lab preparation and machine running time for BLI was 3-5 times faster than ELISA to generate the same amount of data. The ELISA inter-plate variation significantly affected reproducibility while BLI was consistent and repeatable between samples and plates. Indeed, the consistency of BLI data indicated that technical triplicates were redundant. Biological replication alone was sufficient to elucidate the effect of treatments. However, BLI required a lower serum dilution than ELISA for similar sensitivity, and thus more serum was required to produce high resolution data. BLI is an extremely high-throughput assay, providing teleost serum IgM quantification and avidity data as a single-step, agile alternative to ELISA.

IgM-bearing B cell affinity subpopulations possess differential antigen sensitivity in rainbow trout

The need for accurate assessments of in vitro generated antibody prompted examination of the effect of antigen on secreted antibody concentrations and affinities. It was found that the antigen concentrations commonly employed for in vitro stimulation were able to significantly compromise IgM titer and affinity estimates in rainbow trout. Specifically, IgM titers were underestimated with the high affinity antibodies being specifically blocked. To remedy this, pulsed antigen cultures were employed, and it was found to reveal more accurate IgM antibody titers and affinity estimates. Additionally, pulsed dose responses provided evidence that high antigen concentrations specifically suppressed high affinity B cell induction. Optimal expression of high affinity antibodies required exposure to lower concentrations of antigen. Each affinity subpopulation appeared to possess a graded sensitivity to each dose of antigen, revealing the complex dynamic for differential IgM-bearing B cell induction that is possible during a response. These results reveal not only the need for antigen removal prior to in vitro antibody secretion, but also the possible role of high zone immunological tolerance on IgM affinity maturation in rainbow trout.

Immunological memory in teleost fish

Immunological memory can be regarded as the key aspect of adaptive immunity, i.e. a specific response to first contact with an antigen, which in mammals is determined by the properties of T, B and NK cells. Re-exposure to the same antigen results in a more rapid response of the activated specific cells, which have a unique property that is the immunological memory acquired upon first contact with the antigen. Such a state of immune activity is also to be understood as related to "altered behavior of the immune system" due to genetic alterations, presumably maintained independently of the antigen. It also indicates a possible alternative mechanism of maintaining the immune state at a low level of the immune response, "directed" by an antigen or dependent on an antigen, associated with repeated exposure to the same antigen from time to time, as well as the concept of innate immune memory, associated with epigenetic reprogramming of myeloid cells, i.e. macrophages and NK cells. Studies on Teleostei have provided evidence for the presence of immunological memory determined by T and B cells and a secondary response stronger than the primary response. Research has also demonstrated that in these animals macrophages and NK-like cells (similar to mammalian NK cells) are able to respond when re-exposed to the same antigen. Regardless of previous reports on immunological memory in teleost fish, many reactions and mechanisms related to this ability require further investigation. The very nature of immunological memory and the activity of cells involved in this process, in particular macrophages and NK-like cells, need to be explained. This paper presents problems associated with adaptive and innate immune memory in teleost fish and characteristics of cells associated with this ability.

Do ectothermic vertebrates have a home in which to affinity mature their antibody responses?

There has been a longstanding question of whether affinity maturation occurs in ectotherms, and if it does, where in tissues this happens. Although cold-blooded vertebrates (ectotherms) lack histologically discernible germinal centers, they have a fully functional Ig gene mutator enzyme (activation-induced cytidine deaminase: AID or Aicda). Protein and Ig cDNA transcript analyses provide evidence that ectotherms can, under certain conditions, demonstrate antibody affinity maturation, and somatic hypermutation of their Ig genes during secondary immune responses. Here, we review the evidence for antibody affinity maturation and somatic hypermutation of Ig V(D)J exons. We argue that past evidence of long-term intact antigen retention, and recent studies of in situ expression of AID transcripts, point to fish melanomacrophage clusters as sites functionally analogous to a germinal center. Recent work in zebrafish provides a way forward to test these predictions through V(D)J repertoire analyses on isolated, intact melanomacrophage clusters. This work has implications not only for vaccine use in aquaculture, but also for antibody affinity maturation processes in all ectothermic vertebrates.

Molecular cloning, characterization and expression analysis of major histocompatibility complex class I alpha gene of pufferfish (Takifugu obscurus)

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes play a key role in immune response in vertebrates. In this study, an MHC I alpha homolog gene (PfMHC Ⅰα) from pufferfish (Takifugu obscurus) was identified and its subcellular localization and expression patterns of PfMHC Ⅰα after challenge in vivo and in vitro were analysed. The open reading frame of PfMHC Ⅰα was 1,089 bp in length, encoding 362 aa. The immunofluorescence result revealed that PfMHC Ⅰα was presented on the membrane of lymphocytes. qRT-PCR analysis indicated that PfMHC Ⅰα was expressed in all examined tissues, with the highest expression in skin, followed by the expression in gills and whole blood. After challenge of Aeromonas hydrophila or polyinosinic: polycytidylic acid (Poly I:C) in vitro, the expression levels of PfMHC Ⅰα on pufferfish kidney lymphocytes were significantly up-regulated, with the highest expression level at 48 hr post-challenge. After infection with A. hydrophila or Poly I:C in vivo, the expression levels of PfMHC Ⅰα in the skin, whole blood and kidneys were significantly up-regulated. Taken together, it is speculated that PfMHC Ⅰα associates with resistance to both intracellular and extracellular antigens and plays an important role in the host response against pathogen infection in pufferfish.

The Analysis of Live-Attenuated Piscirickettsia salmonis Vaccine Reveals the Short-Term Upregulation of Innate and Adaptive Immune Genes in Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar): An In Situ Open-Sea Cages Study

Piscirickettsia salmonis, the etiological agent of the Salmon Rickettsial Septicemia (SRS), is one the most serious health problems for the Chilean salmon industry. Typical antimicrobial strategies used against P. salmonis include antibiotics and vaccines, but these applications have largely failed. A few years ago, the first attenuated-live vaccine against SRS (ALPHA JECT LiVac^® SRS vaccine) was released to the market. However, there is no data about the agents involved in the activation of the immune response induced under field conditions. Therefore, in this study we evaluated the expression profile of a set of gene markers related to innate and adaptive immunity in the context of a cellular response in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) reared under productive farm conditions and immunized with a live-attenuated vaccine against P. salmonis. We analyzed the expression at zero, 5-, 15- and 45-days post-vaccination (dpv). Our results reveal that the administration of the attenuated live SRS LiVac vaccine induces a short-term upregulation of the cellular-mediated immune response at 5 dpv modulated by the upregulation of ifnα, ifnγ, and the cd4 and cd8α T cell surface markers. In addition, we also registered the upregulation of il-10 and tgfβ. Altogether, the results suggest that a balanced activation of the immune response took place only at early times post-vaccination (5 dpv). The scope of this short-term upregulation of the cellular-mediated immune response against a natural outbreak in fish subjected to productive farm conditions deserves further research.

Epidermal Club Cells in Fishes: A Case for Ecoimmunological Analysis

Epidermal club cells (ECCs), along with mucus cells, are present in the skin of many fishes, particularly in the well-studied Ostariophysan family Cyprinidae. Most ECC-associated literature has focused on the potential role of ECCs as a component of chemical alarm cues released passively when a predator damages the skin of its prey, alerting nearby prey to the presence of an active predator. Because this warning system is maintained by receiver-side selection (senders are eaten), there is want of a mechanism to confer fitness benefits to the individual that invests in ECCs to explain their evolutionary origin and maintenance in this speciose group of fishes. In an attempt to understand the fitness benefits that accrue from investment in ECCs, we reviewed the phylogenetic distribution of ECCs and their histochemical properties. ECCs are found in various forms in all teleost superorders and in the chondrostei inferring either early or multiple independent origins over evolutionary time. We noted that ECCs respond to several environmental stressors/immunomodulators including parasites and pathogens, are suppressed by immunomodulators such as testosterone and cortisol, and their density covaries with food ration, demonstrating a dynamic metabolic cost to maintaining these cells. ECC density varies widely among and within fish populations, suggesting that ECCs may be a convenient tool with which to assay ecoimmunological tradeoffs between immune stress and foraging activity, reproductive state, and predator-prey interactions. Here, we review the case for ECC immune function, immune functions in fishes generally, and encourage future work describing the precise role of ECCs in the immune system and life history evolution in fishes.

Salmonid Antibacterial Immunity: An Aquaculture Perspective

The aquaculture industry is continuously threatened by infectious diseases, including those of bacterial origin. Regardless of the disease burden, aquaculture is already the main method for producing fish protein, having displaced capture fisheries. One attractive sector within this industry is the culture of salmonids, which are (a) uniquely under pressure due to overfishing and (b) the most valuable finfish per unit of weight. There are still knowledge gaps in the understanding of fish immunity, leading to vaccines that are not as effective as in terrestrial species, thus a common method to combat bacterial disease outbreaks is the use of antibiotics. Though effective, this method increases both the prevalence and risk of generating antibiotic-resistant bacteria. To facilitate vaccine design and/or alternative treatment efforts, a deeper understanding of the teleost immune system is essential. This review highlights the current state of teleost antibacterial immunity in the context of salmonid aquaculture. Additionally, the success of current techniques/methods used to combat bacterial diseases in salmonid aquaculture will be addressed. Filling the immunology knowledge gaps highlighted here will assist in reducing aquaculture losses in the future.

Recent Advances on Phagocytic B Cells in Teleost Fish

The momentous discovery of phagocytic activity in teleost B cells has caused a dramatic paradigm shift from the belief that phagocytosis is performed mainly by professional phagocytes derived from common myeloid progenitor cells, such as macrophages/monocytes, neutrophils, and dendritic cells. Recent advances on phagocytic B cells and their microbicidal ability in teleost fish position B cells at the crossroads, bridging innate with adaptive immunity. Most importantly, an increasing body of experimental evidence demonstrates that, in both teleosts and mammals, phagocytic B cells can recognize, take up, and destroy particulate antigens and then present those processed antigens to CD4⁺ T cells to elicit adaptive immune responses and that the phagocytosis is mediated by pattern recognition receptors and involves multiple cytokines. Thus, current findings collectively indicate that teleost phagocytic B cells, as well as their counterpart mammalian B1-B cells, can be considered one kind of professional phagocyte. The aim of this review is to summarize recent advances regarding teleost phagocytic B cells, with a particular focus on the recognizing receptors and modulating mechanisms of phagocytic B cells and the process of antigen presentation for T-cell activation. We also attempt to provide new insights into the adaptive evolution of the teleost fish phagocytic B cell on the basis of its innate and adaptive roles.

Zebrafish as an alternative animal model in human and animal vaccination research

Much of medical research relies on animal models to deepen knowledge of the causes of animal and human diseases, as well as to enable the development of innovative therapies. Despite rodents being the most widely used research model worldwide, in recent decades, the use of the zebrafish (Danio rerio) model has exponentially been adopted among the scientific community. This is because such a small tropical freshwater teleost fish has crucial genetic, anatomical and physiological homology with mammals. Therefore, zebrafish constitutes an excellent experimental model for behavioral, genetic and toxicological studies which unravels the mechanism of various human diseases. Furthermore, it serves well to test new therapeutic agents, such as the safety of new vaccines. The aim of this review was to provide a systematic literature review on the most recent studies carried out on the topic. It presents numerous advantages of this type of animal model in tests of efficacy and safety of both animal and human vaccines, thus highlighting gains in time and cost reduction of research and analyzes.

Long-Lived Plasma Cells Secrete High-Affinity Antibodies Responding to a T-Dependent Immunization in a Teleost Fish

The recent discovery of long-lived plasma cells (LLPCs) in mammals, which provide a constant expression of specific high-affinity antibodies that mediate humoral memory, has caused a dramatic paradigm shift in the study of immunity and vaccine development. In teleost fish, there are few studies regarding the association between LLPCs and antibody production, and the affinity of the antibodies secreted by the LLPCs is poorly understood. In the present study, channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) were immunized with trinitrophenylated-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (TNP-KLH) to examine TNP-specific antibody titers, affinities, antibody-secreting cell (ASC) dynamic changes, and especially the affinity of secreted antibodies by LLPCs post-immunization. We demonstrated that TNP-specific LLPCs were generated starting at week 4 post-immunization, achieved a maximal number at week 8, and maintained a comparable level throughout the 18-week post-immunization period, which was correlated with the dynamics of serum antibody titers and affinity maturation in the response. The LLPCs appeared to mostly reside within, or migrate to, the anterior kidney (bone marrow-like tissue in mammals), but a small portion was also located in the spleen and peripheral blood. The antibodies produced by the LLPCs possessed high affinities, indicating that the generation and development of LLPCs were driven by affinity selection in teleosts. Collectively, the results of this study provide insights toward the evolutionary understanding of the affinity-dependent mechanism of LLPC generation and development.

Comparative transcriptome analysis of the transcriptional heterogeneity in different IgM+ cell subsets from peripheral blood of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus)

In teleost fish, IgM⁺ B cells play important roles in innate and adaptive immunity. Different IgM⁺ B cells are detected in teleost, named IgM^lo and IgM^hi B cell subsets, according to the distinct expression levels of membrane IgM (mIgM). However, the study on the heterogeneity in IgM⁺ B cell subsets remains poorly understood. In this study, the comparative transcriptomic profiles of IgM^-, IgM^lo and IgM^hi from peripheral blood of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) were carried out by using RNA-sequencing technique. A total of 6045 and 5470 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were detected in IgM^lo and IgM^hi cells, respectively, as compared with IgM^- lymphocytes, whereas 3835 genes were differentially expressed when IgM^lo compared to IgM^hi cells. Analysis of the KEGG database indicated that the DEGs were enriched in immune system categories and signaling transduction and interaction in IgM^- vs IgM^hi, IgM^- vs IgM^lo and IgM^lo vs IgM^hi. Comparatively, in IgM^lo vs IgM^hi, GO enrichment analysis indicated that the DEGs enriched in nucleic acid binding transcription factor activity. Analysis of crucial transcription factors for B cell differentiation indicated that IgM^lo and IgM^hi cell clusters belonged to the different B cell subsets. The data generated in this study may provide insights into understanding the heterogeneity of IgM⁺ cells in teleost, and suggest that IgM⁺ B cells play a crucial role in innate immunity.

Acquired protective immune response in a fish-myxozoan model encompasses specific antibodies and inflammation resolution

The myxozoan parasite Enteromyxum leei causes chronic enteritis in gilthead sea bream (GSB, Sparus aurata) leading to intestinal dysfunction. Two trials were performed in which GSB that had survived a previous infection with E. leei (SUR), and naïve GSB (NAI), were exposed to water effluent containing parasite stages. Humoral factors (total IgM and IgT, specific anti-E. leei IgM, total serum peroxidases), histopathology and gene expression were analysed. Results showed that SUR maintained high levels of specific anti-E. leei IgM (up to 16 months), expressed high levels of immunoglobulins at the intestinal mucosa, particularly the soluble forms, and were resistant to re-infection. Their acquired-type response was complemented by other immune effectors locally and systemically, like cell cytotoxicity (high granzyme A expression), complement activity (high c3 and fucolectin expression), and serum peroxidases. In contrast to NAI, SUR displayed a post-inflammatory phenotype in the intestine and head kidney, characteristic of inflammation resolution (low il1β, high il10 and low hsp90α expression).

DNA vaccination for finfish aquaculture

In fish, DNA vaccines have been shown to give very high protection in experimental facilities against a number of viral diseases, particularly diseases caused by rhabdoviruses. However, their efficacy in generating protection against other families of fish viral pathogens is less clear. One DNA vaccine is currently in use commercially in fish farms in Canada and the commercialisation of another was authorised in Europe in 2017. The mechanism of action of DNA vaccines, including the role of the innate immune responses induced shortly after DNA vaccination in the activation of the adaptive immunity providing longer term specific protection, is still not fully understood. In Europe the procedure for the commercialisation of a veterinary DNA vaccine requires the resolution of certain concerns particularly about safety for the host vaccinated fish, the consumer and the environment. Relating to consumer acceptance and particularly environmental safety, a key question is whether a DNA vaccinated fish is considered a Genetically Modified Organism (GMO). In the present opinion paper these key aspects relating to the mechanisms of action, and to the development and the use of DNA vaccines in farmed fish are reviewed and discussed.

What could be the mechanisms of immunological memory in fish?

Vaccination is the most effective strategy to control infectious diseases in species with adaptive immunity. In human and in mouse, vaccination typically induces specific memory cells, which can mediate a fast anamnestic response upon infection by the targeted pathogen. In these species, successful vaccination induces a long-lasting protection, long after the titres of specific antibodies and the frequency of specific T cells have returned to steady state. Vaccination is also an important challenge in aquaculture, since alternative treatments are either too costly, or, in the case of antibiotics, are harmful for the environment or may result in dangerous resistances. However, the mechanisms of the long-term protection elicited by vaccines in fish remain poorly understood. Although fish possess typical B- and T-cells expressing diverse repertoires of immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors, many features of antigen specific responses are different from what is known in mouse and in human. Memory is one of the most elusive properties of fish adaptive immunity, and its basis is widely unknown. In this opinion article, we discuss the concept of immune memory in the context of the fish immunity. We illustrate the complexity of this question by discussing the results of experiments showing that protection can be passed through adoptive transfer of leukocytes from vaccinated donor fish to naive histocompatible recipients. Combined with tools developed in Targetfish and in previous projects, such as monoclonal antibodies against B- and T-cell markers, we propose that such models of protection transfer provide excellent systems to dissect the mechanisms of B- and T-cell memory in the future.

Affinity maturation occurs in channel catfish (Ictalurus punctaus) following immunization with a T-cell dependent antigen

Affinity maturation of the antibody response, a process of antibody affinity increasing over response, is one of the key features of the mammalian immune system. However, the process is incompletely understood in teleost, including channel catfish (Ictalurus punctaus). In this study, IgM affinity maturation in channel catfish was investigated by estimating the kinetics of antibody affinity using ELISA and ELISPOT assays. Fish were immunized with a T-cell dependent antigen (TNP-KLH), and individual serum IgM antibody titers and affinities, and IgM⁺ antibody-secreting cells (ASCs) in peripheral blood were analyzed over a period of 14 weeks. A detectable serum anti-TNP response developed by 2-weeks post-immunization, and the maximal antibody production was observed by 6-weeks post-immunization. The average affinity of anti-TNP serum antibody increased consistently and reached the maximum by 10-weeks post-immunization. The increase of antibody affinity beyond the point of optimal antibody titer revealed that the affinity maturation of IgM antibody response occurred in channel catfish. Dissection of dynamics of individual affinity subpopulations indicated that a significant proportion of low affinity subpopulations appeared at early response, and high affinity subpopulations appeared predominantly at later, resulting in a 100-fold increase in affinity over response. Additional, TNP⁺ IgM⁺ ASCs was detected by 2-weeks post-immunization and achieved the maximal number by 6-weeks post-immunization. Using an inhibition ELISPOT assay, the findings of a consistent increase in the average affinity of secreted IgM antibody by peripheral blood ASCs, as the immune response progressed, confirmed the occurrence of the affinity maturation. Taken together, the results of this study indicated that affinity maturation occurred in channel catfish following immunization with a TD antigen TNP-KLH.

Origin of Public Memory B Cell Clones in Fish After Antiviral Vaccination

Vaccination induces “public” antibody clonotypes common to all individuals of a species, that may mediate universal protection against pathogens. Only few studies tried to trace back the origin of these public B-cell clones. Here we used Illumina sequencing and computational modeling to unveil the mechanisms shaping the structure of the fish memory antibody response against an attenuated Viral Hemorrhagic Septicemia rhabdovirus. After vaccination, a persistent memory response with a public VH5JH5 IgM component was composed of dominant antibodies shared among all individuals. The rearrangement model showed that these public junctions occurred with high probability indicating that they were already favored before vaccination due to the recombination process, as shown in mammals. In addition, these clonotypes were in the naïve repertoire associated with larger similarity classes, composed of junctions differing only at one or two positions by amino acids with comparable properties. The model showed that this property was due to selective processes exerted between the recombination and the naive repertoire. Finally, our results showed that public clonotypes greatly expanded after vaccination displayed several VDJ junctions differing only by one or two amino acids with similar properties, highlighting a convergent response. The fish public memory antibody response to a virus is therefore shaped at three levels: by recombination biases, by selection acting on the formation of the pre-vaccination repertoire, and by convergent selection of functionally similar clonotypes during the response. We also show that naive repertoires of IgM and IgT have different structures and sharing between individuals, due to selection biases. In sum, our comparative approach identifies three conserved features of the antibody repertoire associated with public memory responses. These features were already present in the last common ancestors of fish and mammals, while other characteristics may represent species-specific solutions.

Ativação de células de memória na produção de anticorpos e na expressão de células IgM positivas no baço de tilápias-do-nilo

RESUMO O presente trabalho avaliou o papel do baço no armazenamento e na reativação das linhagens de células B, representadas por células IgM positivas imunomarcadas no tecido esplênico, bem como a funcionalidade dessas células, sobre a cinética dos linfócitos e na produção sistêmica de anticorpos em tilápias-do-nilo (Oreochromis niloticus). Foram separados dois grupos: grupo memória, constituído por peixes previamente imunizados com hemácia de carneiro a 2,5%, para a geração da memória imune, e o grupo naive, que recebeu o mesmo volume de solução salina a 0,65%. Após 32 dias, os dois grupos foram submetidos a uma nova dose do antígeno na mesma concentração, volume e via de inoculação. A reativação dos clones de memória foi evidenciada pelo aumento do número de células IgM positivas no baço do grupo memória no dia zero/pré-imune. Além disso, o mesmo grupo apresentou aumento dos títulos de anticorpos séricos no 14º dia e no número absoluto de linfócitos no 21º dia em relação ao grupo naive. Esses resultados sugerem que o baço não seja apenas um local de armazenamento, mas também de reativação de células B de memória em tilápia-do-nilo.

Fish Immunoglobulins

The B cell receptor and secreted antibody are at the nexus of humoral adaptive immunity. In this review, we summarize what is known of the immunoglobulin genes of jawed cartilaginous and bony fishes. We focus on what has been learned from genomic or cDNA sequence data, but where appropriate draw upon protein, immunization, affinity and structural studies. Work from major aquatic model organisms and less studied comparative species are both included to define what is the rule for an immunoglobulin isotype or taxonomic group and what exemplifies an exception.

Experimental Piscine orthoreovirus infection mediates protection against pancreas disease in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

Viral diseases are among the main challenges in farming of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). The most prevalent viral diseases in Norwegian salmon aquaculture are heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) caused by Piscine orthoreovirus (PRV), and pancreas disease (PD) caused by Salmonid alphavirus (SAV). Both PRV and SAV target heart and skeletal muscles, but SAV additionally targets exocrine pancreas. PRV and SAV are often present in the same locations and co-infections occur, but the effect of this crosstalk on disease development has not been investigated. In the present experiment, the effect of a primary PRV infection on subsequent SAV infection was studied. Atlantic salmon were infected with PRV by cohabitation, followed by addition of SAV shedder fish 4 or 10 weeks after the initial PRV infection. Histopathological evaluation, monitoring of viral RNA levels and host gene expression analysis were used to assess disease development. Significant reduction of SAV RNA levels and of PD specific histopathological changes were observed in the co-infected groups compared to fish infected by SAV only. A strong correlation was found between histopathological development and expression of disease related genes in heart. In conclusion, experimentally PRV infected salmon are less susceptible to secondary SAV infection and development of PD.

Mucosal Immunity and B Cells in Teleosts: Effect of Vaccination and Stress

Fish are subjected to several insults from the environment, which may endanger animal survival. Mucosal surfaces are the first line of defense against these threats, acting as a physical barrier to protect the animal but also functioning as an active immune tissue. Thus, four mucosal-associated lymphoid tissues (MALTs), which lead the immune responses in gut, skin, gills, and nose, have been described in fish. Humoral and cellular immunity, as well as their regulation and the factors that influence the response in these mucosal lymphoid tissues, are still not well known in most fish species. Mucosal B-lymphocytes and immunoglobulins (Igs) are key players in the immune response that takes place in those MALTs. The existence of IgT as a mucosal specialized Ig gives us the opportunity of measuring specific responses after infection or vaccination, a fact that was not possible until recently in most fish species. The vaccination process is influenced by several factors, being stress one of the main stimuli determining the success of the vaccine. Thus, one of the major goals in a vaccination process is to avoid possible situations of stress, which might interfere with fish immune performance. However, interaction between immune and neuroendocrine systems at mucosal tissues is still unknown. In this review, we will summarize the latest findings about B-lymphocytes and Igs in mucosal immunity and the effect of stress and vaccination on B-cell response at mucosal sites. It is important to point out that a limited number of studies have been published regarding stress in mucosa and very few about the influence of stress over mucosal B-lymphocytes.

Successive Oral Immunizations Against Piscirickettsia Salmonis and Infectious Salmon Anemia Virus are Required to Maintain a Long-Term Protection in Farmed Salmonids

Currently, there is a growing demand to determine the protective status of vaccinated fish in order to prevent diseases outbreaks. A set of different parameters that include the infectious and immunological status of vaccinated salmonids from 622 Chilean farms were analyzed during 2011-2014. The aim of this study was to optimize the vaccination program of these centers through the determination of the protective state of vaccinated fish using oral immunizations. This state was determined from the association of the concentration of the immunoglobulin M (IgM) in the serum and the mortality rate of vaccinated fish. Salmonids were vaccinated with different commercial mono- or polyvalent vaccines against salmonid rickettsial septicemia (SRS) and infectious salmon anemia (ISA), first by the intraperitoneal injection of oil-adjuvanted antigens and then by the stimulation of mucosal immunity using oral vaccines as a booster vaccination. The results showed that high levels of specific IgM antibodies were observed after injectable vaccination, reaching a maximum concentration at 600-800 degree-days. Similar levels of antibodies were observed when oral immunizations were administrated. The high concentration of antibodies [above 2750 ng/mL for ISA virus (ISAv) and 3500 ng/mL for SRS] was maintained for a period of 800 degree-days after each vaccination procedure. In this regard, oral immunizations maintained a long-term high concentration of anti-SRS and anti-ISAv specific IgM antibodies. When the concentration of antibodies decreased below 2000 pg/mL, a window of susceptibility to SRS infection was observed in the farm, suggesting a close association between antibody levels and fish protective status. These results demonstrated that, in the field, several oral immunizations are essential to uphold a high level of specific anti-pathogens antibodies and, therefore, the protective status during the whole productive cycle.

Unique Features of Fish Immune Repertoires: Particularities of Adaptive Immunity Within the Largest Group of Vertebrates

Fishes (i.e., teleost fishes) are the largest group of vertebrates. Although their immune system is based on the fundamental receptors, pathways, and cell types found in all groups of vertebrates, fishes show a diversity of particular features that challenge some classical concepts of immunology. In this chapter, we discuss the particularities of fish immune repertoires from a comparative perspective. We examine how allelic exclusion can be achieved when multiple Ig loci are present, how isotypic diversity and functional specificity impact clonal complexity, how loss of the MHC class II molecules affects the cooperation between T and B cells, and how deep sequencing technologies bring new insights about somatic hypermutation in the absence of germinal centers. The unique coexistence of two distinct B-cell lineages respectively specialized in systemic and mucosal responses is also discussed. Finally, we try to show that the diverse adaptations of immune repertoires in teleosts can help in understanding how somatic adaptive mechanisms of immunity evolved in parallel in different lineages across vertebrates.

The immunoglobulins of cold-blooded vertebrates

Although lymphocyte-like cells secreting somatically-recombining receptors have been identified in the jawless fishes (hagfish and lamprey), the cartilaginous fishes (sharks, skates, rays and chimaera) are the most phylogenetically distant group relative to mammals in which bona fide immunoglobulins (Igs) have been found. Studies of the antibodies and humoral immune responses of cartilaginous fishes and other cold-blooded vertebrates (bony fishes, amphibians and reptiles) are not only revealing information about the emergence and roles of the different Ig heavy and light chain isotypes, but also the evolution of specialised adaptive features such as isotype switching, somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation. It is becoming increasingly apparent that while the adaptive immune response in these vertebrate lineages arose a long time ago, it is most definitely not primitive and has evolved to become complex and sophisticated. This review will summarise what is currently known about the immunoglobulins of cold-blooded vertebrates and highlight the differences, and commonalities, between these and more “conventional” mammalian species.

Perspectives on antigen presenting cells in zebrafish

Antigen presentation is a critical step in the activation of naïve T lymphocytes. In mammals, dendritic cells (DCs), macrophages, and B lymphocytes can all function as antigen presenting cells (APCs). Although APCs have been identified in zebrafish, it is unclear if they fulfill similar roles in the initiation of adaptive immunity. Here we review the characterization of zebrafish macrophages, DCs, and B cells and evidence of their function as true APCs. Finally, we discuss the conservation of APC activity in vertebrates and the use of zebrafish to provide a new perspective on the evolution of these functions.

The teleost humoral immune response

Over the past 10 years our knowledge of cellular and molecular dynamics of teleost humoral immunity has increased enormously to now include: the existence of multiple isotypes, affinity-driven modulation of antibody structure and function, the unique trafficking patterns of each stage of B cell differentiation (including the plasma blast, short-lived and long-lived plasma cell, and the memory cell). Unfortunately the work which has generated the bulk of this information has generally employed defined antigens rather than vaccines. Thus, the focus of this review is to relate these aspects of immunity that are requisite for a mechanistic understanding of the generation of prophylactic immunity to the necessary analysis of responses to vaccines and vaccine candidates.

B cell memory following infection and challenge of channel catfish with Ichthyophthirius multifiliis

B cell responses in channel catfish to infection with the parasitic ciliate Ichthyophthirius multifiliis were followed for 3 years. High titers of serum IgM antibodies recognizing I. multifiliis immobilization antigens were present 5weeks after immunizing infection, but by 1 year titers were at low or undetectable levels. Two to three years after infection the numbers of antibody secreting cells recognizing immobilization antigens in skin and head kidney of immune fish had decreased to the level found in uninfected controls. Challenge of immune fish showed they remained immune and that the numbers of antibody secreting cells recognizing immobilization antigens increased in skin but not head kidney. This suggests that antigen-specific memory B cells persisted for 3 years after infection and upon challenge differentiated into antibody secreting cells that localized in skin. Our results suggest that humoral immunity in channel catfish is maintained through IgM(+) memory B cells.

The astonishing diversity of Ig classes and B cell repertoires in teleost fish

With lymphoid tissue anatomy different than mammals, and diverse adaptations to all aquatic environments, fish constitute a fascinating group of vertebrate to study the biology of B cell repertoires in a comparative perspective. Fish B lymphocytes express immunoglobulin (Ig) on their surface and secrete antigen-specific antibodies in response to immune challenges. Three antibody classes have been identified in fish, namely IgM, IgD, and IgT, while IgG, IgA, and IgE are absent. IgM and IgD have been found in all fish species analyzed, and thus seem to be primordial antibody classes. IgM and IgD are normally co-expressed from the same mRNA through alternative splicing, as in mammals. Tetrameric IgM is the main antibody class found in serum. Some species of fish also have IgT, which seems to exist only in fish and is specialized in mucosal immunity. IgM/IgD and IgT are expressed by two different sub-populations of B cells. The tools available to investigate B cell responses at the cellular level in fish are limited, but the progress of fish genomics has started to unravel a rich diversity of IgH and immunoglobulin light chain locus organization, which might be related to the succession of genome remodelings that occurred during fish evolution. Moreover, the development of deep sequencing techniques has allowed the investigation of the global features of the expressed fish B cell repertoires in zebrafish and rainbow trout, in steady state or after infection. This review provides a description of the organization of fish Ig loci, with a particular emphasis on their heterogeneity between species, and presents recent data on the structure of the expressed Ig repertoire in healthy and infected fish.

Teleost fish mount complex clonal IgM and IgT responses in spleen upon systemic viral infection

Upon infection, B-lymphocytes expressing antibodies specific for the intruding pathogen develop clonal responses triggered by pathogen recognition via the B-cell receptor. The constant region of antibodies produced by such responding clones dictates their functional properties. In teleost fish, the clonal structure of B-cell responses and the respective contribution of the three isotypes IgM, IgD and IgT remain unknown. The expression of IgM and IgT are mutually exclusive, leading to the existence of two B-cell subsets expressing either both IgM and IgD or only IgT. Here, we undertook a comprehensive analysis of the variable heavy chain (VH) domain repertoires of the IgM, IgD and IgT in spleen of homozygous isogenic rainbow trout (Onchorhynchus mykiss) before, and after challenge with a rhabdovirus, the Viral Hemorrhagic Septicemia Virus (VHSV), using CDR3-length spectratyping and pyrosequencing of immunoglobulin (Ig) transcripts. In healthy fish, we observed distinct repertoires for IgM, IgD and IgT, respectively, with a few amplified μ and τ junctions, suggesting the presence of IgM- and IgT-secreting cells in the spleen. In infected animals, we detected complex and highly diverse IgM responses involving all VH subgroups, and dominated by a few large public and private clones. A lower number of robust clonal responses involving only a few VH were detected for the mucosal IgT, indicating that both IgM(+) and IgT(+) spleen B cells responded to systemic infection but at different degrees. In contrast, the IgD response to the infection was faint. Although fish IgD and IgT present different structural features and evolutionary origin compared to mammalian IgD and IgA, respectively, their implication in the B-cell response evokes these mouse and human counterparts. Thus, it appears that the general properties of antibody responses were already in place in common ancestors of fish and mammals, and were globally conserved during evolution with possible functional convergences.

A holistic view of the dynamisms of teleost IgM: a case study of Streptococcus iniae vaccinated rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

To date, little is known about how trout IgM, the primary antibody of fish, varies in titer, specificity, disulfide cross-linking, and affinity following immunization with a pathogen. Work using defined antigens has demonstrated that the disulfide cross-linking structure of IgM becomes increasingly more polymerized during an immune response, coinciding with an increase in affinity, but it is unknown if this has relevance to aquatic pathogens. Understanding how IgM varies following vaccination with an aquatic pathogen is of considerable importance as effector functions allocated to multiple antibody isotypes in mammals are essentially relegated to this single molecule. To gain insights into the dynamism of IgM, rainbow trout were immunized with Streptococcus iniae and individual serum titers, their specificity and affinity to S. iniae, and the disulfide cross-linking pattern of both total-serum and specific Ig were analyzed over a period of 37 weeks. We found that in vaccinated animals titer increased by a factor of ≈100 from starting levels, affinity increased 10-fold, and diversity of S. iniae proteins recognized by trout antibody increased at least 5-fold. Most intriguing, though less cross-linked IgM predominated early in response, by week 5, the fully tetramerized antibody comprised 50% of total specific protein. We propose that this is a mechanism to optimize efficacy of carrying out effector functions and recognizing a wide array of epitopes with higher affinity.

Plasmablasts and plasma cells: reconsidering teleost immune system organization

Comparative immunologists have expended extensive efforts in the characterization of early fish B cell development; however, analysis of the post-antigen induction stages of antibody secreting cell (ASC) differentiation has been limited. In contrast, work with murine ASCs has resolved the physically and functionally distinct cells known as plasmablasts, the short-lived plasma cells and long-lived plasma cells. Teleost ASCs are now known to also possess comparable subpopulations, which can greatly differ in such basic functions as lifespan, antigen sensitivity, antibody secretion rate, differentiative potential, and distribution within the body. Understanding the mechanisms by which these subpopulations are produced and distributed is essential for both basic understanding in comparative immunology and practical vaccine engineering.