Intrinsic B-cell hyporesponsiveness accounts for self-tolerance in lysozyme/anti-lysozyme double-transgenic mice

NR4A nuclear receptors in T and B lymphocytes: Gatekeepers of immune tolerance. Immunol Rev 2022;307:116-133. [PMID: 35174510 DOI: 10.1111/imr.13072]

Random VDJ recombination early in T and B cell development enables the adaptive immune system to recognize a vast array of evolving pathogens via antigen receptors. However, the potential of such randomly generated TCRs and BCRs to recognize and respond to self-antigens requires layers of tolerance mechanisms to mitigate the risk of life-threatening autoimmunity. Since they were originally cloned more than three decades ago, the NR4A family of nuclear hormone receptors have been implicated in many critical aspects of immune tolerance, including negative selection of thymocytes, peripheral T cell tolerance, regulatory T cells (Treg), and most recently in peripheral B cell tolerance. In this review, we discuss important insights from many laboratories as well as our own group into the function and mechanisms by which this small class of primary response genes promotes self-tolerance and immune homeostasis to balance the need for host defense against the inherent risks posed by the adaptive immune system.

Histone H2A-Reactive B Cells Are Functionally Anergic in Healthy Mice With Potential to Provide Humoral Protection Against HIV-1

Peripheral tolerance is essential for silencing weakly autoreactive B cells that have escaped central tolerance, but it is unclear why these potentially pathogenic B cells are retained rather than being eliminated entirely. Release from peripheral tolerance restraint can occur under certain circumstances (i.e., strong TLR stimulus), that are present during infection. In this regard, we hypothesized that autoreactive B cells could function as a reserve population that can be activated to contribute to the humoral immune response, particularly with pathogens, such as HIV-1, that exploit immune tolerance to avoid host defense. In this study, we identify a population of autoreactive B cells with the potential to neutralize HIV-1 and experimentally release them from the functional restrictions of peripheral tolerance. We have previously identified murine monoclonal antibodies that displayed autoreactivity against histone H2A and neutralized HIV-1 in vitro. Here, we identify additional H2A-reactive IgM monoclonal antibodies and demonstrate that they are both autoreactive and polyreactive with self and foreign antigens and are able to neutralize multiple clades of tier 2 HIV-1. Flow cytometric analysis of H2A-reactive B cells in naïve wildtype mice revealed that these B cells are present in peripheral B cell populations and we further document that murine H2A-reactive B cells are restrained by peripheral tolerance mechanisms. Specifically, we show endogenous H2A-reactive B cells display increased expression of the inhibitory mediators CD5 and phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) phosphatase and fail to mobilize calcium upon immunoreceptor stimulation; all characterized markers of anergy. Moreover, we show that toll-like receptor stimulation or provision of CD4 T cell help induces the in vitro production of H2A-reactive antibodies, breaking tolerance. Thus, we have identified a novel poly/autoreactive B cell population that has the potential to neutralize HIV-1 but is silenced by immune tolerance.

Conditional antibody expression to avoid central B cell deletion in humanized HIV-1 vaccine mouse models

HIV-1 vaccine development aims to elicit broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs) against diverse viral strains. In some HIV-1-infected individuals, bnAbs evolved from precursor antibodies through affinity maturation. To induce bnAbs, a vaccine must mediate a similar antibody maturation process. One way to test a vaccine is to immunize mouse models that express human bnAb precursors and assess whether the vaccine can convert precursor antibodies into bnAbs. A major problem with such mouse models is that bnAb expression often hinders B cell development. Such developmental blocks may be attributed to the unusual properties of bnAb variable regions, such as poly-reactivity and long antigen-binding loops, which are usually under negative selection during primary B cell development. To address this problem, we devised a method to circumvent such B cell developmental blocks by expressing bnAbs conditionally in mature B cells. We validated this method by expressing the unmutated common ancestor (UCA) of the human VRC26 bnAb in transgenic mice. Constitutive expression of the VRC26UCA led to developmental arrest of B cell progenitors in bone marrow; poly-reactivity of the VRC26UCA and poor pairing of the VRC26UCA heavy chain with the mouse surrogate light chain may contribute to this phenotype. The conditional expression strategy bypassed the impediment to VRC26UCA B cell development, enabling the expression of VRC26UCA in mature B cells. This approach should be generally applicable for expressing other bnAbs that are under negative selection during B cell development.

Nur77 Links Chronic Antigen Stimulation to B Cell Tolerance by Restricting the Survival of Self-Reactive B Cells in the Periphery

Nur77 (Nr4a1) belongs to a small family of orphan nuclear receptors that are rapidly induced by BCR stimulation, yet little is known about its function in B cells. We have previously characterized a reporter of Nr4a1 transcription, Nur77-eGFP, in which GFP expression faithfully detects Ag encounter by B cells in vitro and in vivo. In this study, we report that Nur77 expression correlates with the degree of self-reactivity, counterselection, and anergy among individual B cell clones from two distinct BCR transgenic mouse models but is dispensable for all of these tolerance mechanisms. However, we identify a role for Nur77 in restraining survival of self-reactive B cells in the periphery under conditions of competition for a limited supply of the survival factor BAFF. We find that Nur77 deficiency results in the progressive accumulation of self-reactive B cells in the mature repertoire with age and is sufficient to break B cell tolerance in V_H3H9 H chain transgenic mice. We thus propose that Nur77 is upregulated in self-reactive B cells in response to chronic Ag stimulation and selectively restricts the survival of these cells, gradually pruning self-reactivity from the mature repertoire to impose a novel layer of peripheral B cell tolerance.

Innate B-1 B Cells Are Not Enriched in Red Blood Cell Autoimmune Mice: Importance of B Cell Receptor Transgenic Selection

Autoimmune hemolytic anemia (AIHA) results from breakdown of humoral tolerance to RBC antigens. Past analyses of B-cell receptor transgenic (BCR-Tg) mice that recognize RBC autoantigens led to a paradigm in which autoreactive conventional B-2 B cells are deleted whereas extramedullary B-1 B cells escape deletion due to lack of exposure to RBCs. However, BCR-Tg mice utilized to shape the current paradigm were unable to undergo receptor editing or class-switching. Given the importance of receptor editing as mechanism to tolerize autoreactive B cells during central tolerance, we hypothesized that expansion of autoreactive B-1 B cells is a consequence of the inability of the autoreactive BCR to receptor edit. To test this hypothesis, we crossed two separate strains of BCR-Tg mice with transgenic mice expressing the BCR target on RBCs. Both BCR-Tg mice express the same immunoglobulin and, thus, secrete antibodies with identical specificity, but one strain (SwHEL) has normal receptor editing, whereas the other (IgHEL) does not. Similar to other AIHA models, the autoreactive IgHEL strain showed decreased B-2 B cells, an enrichment of B-1 B cells, and detectable anti-RBC autoantibodies and decreased RBC hematocrit and hemoglobin values. However, autoreactive SwHEL mice had induction of tolerance in both B-2 and B-1 B cells with anti-RBC autoantibody production without anemia. These data generate new understanding and challenge the existing paradigm of B cell tolerance to RBC autoantigens. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate that immune responses vary when BCR-Tg do not retain BCR editing and class-switching functions.

B cell receptor signaling-based index as a biomarker for the loss of peripheral immune tolerance in autoreactive B cells in rheumatoid arthritis

This study examines the loss of peripherally induced B cell immune tolerance in Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and establishes a novel signaling-based measure of activation in a subset of autoreactive B cells - the Induced tolerance status index (ITSI). Naturally occurring naïve autoreactive B cells can escape the “classical” tolerogenic mechanisms of clonal deletion and receptor editing, but remain peripherally tolerized through B cell receptor (BCR) signaling inhibition (postdevelopmental “receptor tuning” or anergy). ITSI is a statistical index that numerically determines the level of homology between activation patterns of BCR signaling intermediaries in B cells that are either tolerized or activated by auto antigen exposure, and thus quantifies the level of peripheral immune tolerance. The index is based on the logistic regression analysis of phosphorylation levels in a panel of BCR signaling proteins. Our results demonstrate a new approach to identifying autoreactive B cells based on their BCR signaling features.

Enhanced antibody responses to an HIV-1 membrane-proximal external region antigen in mice reconstituted with cultured lymphocytes

We have shown that the protective HIV-1 Ab, 2F5, avidly reacts with a conserved mammalian self-Ag, kynureninase, and that the development of B cells specific for the 2F5 epitope is constrained by immunological tolerance. These observations suggest that the capacity to mount Ab responses to the 2F5 epitope is mitigated by tolerance, but such capacity may be latent in the pretolerance and/or anergic B cell pools. In this study, we use B cell tetramer reagents to track the frequencies of B cells that recognize the HIV-1 2F5 epitope (SP62): in C57BL/6 mice, SP62-binding transitional B cells are readily identified in bone marrow but are lost during subsequent development. Unsurprisingly then, immunization with SP62 immunogen does not elicit significant humoral responses in normal C57BL/6 mice. Reconstitution of Rag1(null) mice with normal congenic B cells that have matured in vitro restores the capacity to mount significant serum Ab and germinal center responses to this HIV-1 epitope. These B cell cultures are permissive for the development of autoreactive B cells and support the development of SP62-specific B cell compartments normally lost in 2F5 Ab knockin mice. The recovery of humoral responses to the 2F5/SP62 epitope of HIV-1 by reconstitution with B cells containing forbidden, autoreactive clones provides direct evidence that normal C57BL/6 mice latently possess the capacity to generate humoral responses to a conserved, neutralizing HIV-1 epitope.

Functionally responsive self-reactive B cells of low affinity express reduced levels of surface IgM

Somatic gene rearrangement generates a diverse repertoire of B cells, many which have receptors possessing a range of affinities for self-Ag. Newly generated B cells express high and relatively uniform amounts of surface IgM (sIgM), while follicular (FO) B cells express sIgM at widely varying levels. It is plausible, therefore, that downmodulation of sIgM serves as a mechanism to maintain weakly self-reactive B cells in a responsive state by decreasing their avidity for self-Ag. We tested this hypothesis by performing comparative functional tests with FO IgM(hi) and IgM(lo) B cells from the unrestricted repertoire of WT C57BL/6 mice. We found that FO IgM(lo) B cells mobilized Ca(2+) equivalently to IgM(hi) B cells when the same number of sIgM molecules was engaged. In agreement, FO IgM(lo) B cells were functionally competent to produce an antibody response following adoptive transfer. The FO IgM(lo) cell population had elevated levels of Nur77 transcript, and was enriched with nuclear-reactive specificities. Hybridoma sampling revealed that these B-cell receptors were of low affinity. Collectively, these results suggest that sIgM downmodulation by low-affinity, self-reactive B cells preserves their immunocompetence and circumvents classical peripheral tolerance mechanisms that would otherwise reduce diversity within the B cell compartment.

Identification of autoantigens recognized by the 2F5 and 4E10 broadly neutralizing HIV-1 antibodies

Many human monoclonal antibodies that neutralize multiple clades of HIV-1 are polyreactive and bind avidly to mammalian autoantigens. Indeed, the generation of neutralizing antibodies to the 2F5 and 4E10 epitopes of HIV-1 gp41 in man may be proscribed by immune tolerance because mice expressing the V(H) and V(L) regions of 2F5 have a block in B cell development that is characteristic of central tolerance. This developmental blockade implies the presence of tolerizing autoantigens that are mimicked by the membrane-proximal external region of HIV-1 gp41. We identify human kynureninase (KYNU) and splicing factor 3b subunit 3 (SF3B3) as the primary conserved, vertebrate self-antigens recognized by the 2F5 and 4E10 antibodies, respectively. 2F5 binds the H4 domain of KYNU which contains the complete 2F5 linear epitope (ELDKWA). 4E10 recognizes an epitope of SF3B3 that is strongly dependent on hydrophobic interactions. Opossums carry a rare KYNU H4 domain that abolishes 2F5 binding, but they retain the SF3B3 4E10 epitope. Immunization of opossums with HIV-1 gp140 induced extraordinary titers of serum antibody to the 2F5 ELDKWA epitope but little or nothing to the 4E10 determinant. Identification of structural motifs shared by vertebrates and HIV-1 provides direct evidence that immunological tolerance can impair humoral responses to HIV-1.

Antigen-specific suppression of humoral immunity by anergic Ars/A1 B cells

Autoreactive anergic B lymphocytes are considered to be dangerous because of their potential for activation and recruitment into autoimmune responses. However, they persist for days and constitute ∼5% of the B cell pool. We assessed their functional potential in the Ars/A1 transgene model, where anergic B cells express a dual-reactive Ag receptor that binds, in addition to a self-Ag, the hapten p-azophenylarsonate (Ars). When Ars/A1 B cells were transferred into adoptive recipients that were immunized with foreign proteins covalently conjugated with Ars, endogenous IgG immune responses to both were selectively and severely diminished, and the development of T helper cells was impaired. Approximately 95% inhibition of the anti-Ars response was attained with ∼4000 transferred Ars/A1 B cells through redundant mechanisms, one of which depended on their expression of MHC class II but not upon secretion of IL-10 or IgM. This Ag-specific suppressive activity implicates the autoreactive anergic B cell as an enforcer of immunological tolerance to self-Ags.

Role of molecular mimicry and polyclonal cell activation in the induction of pathogenic β2-glycoprotein I-directed immune response in Balb/c mice upon hyperimmunization with tetanus toxoid

It is known that tetanus toxoid (TTd)-hyperimmunization induces increased titer of sera β2-glycoprotein I (β2GPI)-specific antibodies (Abs) in Balb/c mice. The concentrations of such induced anti-β2GPI Abs as well as their pathogenic potential are strongly influenced by the context of TTd application. β2GPI-specific immune response is established as a part of TTd-specific immune response by molecular mimicry mechanism due to structural homology between TTd and β2GPI. This finding is supported by the following facts: (1) cross-reactive Abs that recognize both TTd and β2GPI epitopes are present in Balb/c mice sera; (2) anti-TTd Abs secretion in splenic cultures is induced after β2GPI stimulation and vice versa. However, analyses of (1) IL-10 production following in vitro stimulation of immunized Balb/c mice splenocytes by TTd, β2GPI or glutaraldehyde-treated β2GPI and (2) specific impact of ConA and agonists of TLR2, TLR4, and TLR9 on anti-TTd and autoreactive Abs secretion strongly imply that these two branches of the TTd-induced immune response do not use identical cell populations and are regulated in a different way. Results presented in this paper describe that structural homology between foreign and self-antigens could focus mounted autoreactive immune response toward specific self-structure, but the context of antigen application, including a history of previous immune stimulations and adjuvants applied together with the antigen, are the main factors which determine the outcome of the induced immune response.

B-cell-lineage immunogen design in vaccine development with HIV-1 as a case study

Failure of immunization with the HIV-1 envelope to induce broadly neutralizing antibodies against conserved epitopes is a major barrier to producing a preventive HIV-1 vaccine. Broadly neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (BnAbs) from those subjects who do produce them after years of chronic HIV-1 infection have one or more unusual characteristics, including polyreactivity for host antigens, extensive somatic hypermutation and long, variable heavy-chain third complementarity-determining regions, factors that may limit their expression by host immunoregulatory mechanisms. The isolation of BnAbs from HIV-1-infected subjects and the use of computationally derived clonal lineages as templates provide a new path for HIV-1 vaccine immunogen design. This approach, which should be applicable to many infectious agents, holds promise for the construction of vaccines that can drive B cells along rare but desirable maturation pathways.

Anergic responses characterize a large fraction of human autoreactive naive B cells expressing low levels of surface IgM

B cell anergy represents an important mechanism of peripheral immunological tolerance for mature autoreactive B cells that escape central tolerance enforced by receptor editing and clonal deletion. Although well documented in mice, the extent of its participation in human B cell tolerance remains to be fully established. In this study, we characterize the functional behavior of strictly defined human naive B cells separated on the basis of their surface IgM (sIgM) expression levels. We demonstrate that cells with lower sIgM levels (IgM(lo)) are impaired in their ability to flux calcium in response to either anti-IgM or anti-IgD cross-linking and contain a significantly increased frequency of autoreactive cells compared with naive B cells with higher levels of sIgM. Phenotypically, in healthy subjects, IgM(lo) cells are characterized by the absence of activation markers, reduction of costimulatory molecules (CD19 and CD21), and increased levels of inhibitory CD22. Functionally, IgM(lo) cells display significantly weaker proliferation, impaired differentiation, and poor Ab production. In aggregate, the data indicate that hyporesponsiveness to BCR cross-linking associated with sIgM downregulation is present in a much larger fraction of all human naive B cells than previously reported and is likely to reflect a state of anergy induced by chronic autoantigen stimulation. Finally, our results indicate that in systemic lupus erythematosus patients, naive IgM(lo) cells display increased levels of CD95 and decreased levels of CD22, a phenotype consistent with enhanced activation of autoreactive naive B cells in this autoimmune disease.

Tolerance: an overview and perspectives

Self tolerance is dependent on mechanisms that operate on T cells and B cells from the earliest stages, that is, from when they first express anti-self-receptors in the primary lymphoid organs of the thymus and bone marrow, all the way through to when they engage with self antigens in the peripheral immune system and within tissues themselves. This continuum of checkpoints and fail-safes ensures that the risk of developing harmful autoimmune diseases remains very small. Certain tissues have a degree of privilege that allows them to mute the immune response against them by mechanisms that are also well represented in cancers. An understanding of the underlying mechanisms of self tolerance is hoped to spawn a new range of therapeutics designed to both reprogram the immune system to avoid long-term intense immunosuppression, and to override the immune system to achieve more effective immunity against cancers and persistent viral infections.

Stromal cell independent B cell development in vitro: generation and recovery of autoreactive clones

We describe and characterize a stromal cell independent culture system that efficiently supports pro-B cell to IgM+ B cell development with near normal levels of IgH and Igkappa diversity. Pro-B cells present in non-adherent bone marrow cells proliferate in the presence of IL-7 and subsequent to the removal of IL-7 and addition of BAFF, differentiate normally into IgM+ B cells. B cell development in vitro closely follows the patterns of development in vivo with culture-derived (CD) B cells demonstrating characteristic patterns of surface antigen expression and gene activation. IgM+ CD B cells respond to TLR stimulation by proliferation and differentiation into antibody-secreting cells. Self-reactive IgM+ B cell development is blocked in 3H9 IgH knockin mice; however, cultures of 3H9 IgH knockin pro-B cells yields high frequencies of "forbidden", autoreactive IgM+ B cells. Furthermore, serum IgG autoantibody exceeded that present in autoimmune, C4(-/-) animals following the reconstitution of RAG1(-/-) mice with IgM+ CD cells derived from BL/6 mice.

Decoration of T-independent antigen with ligands for CD22 and Siglec-G can suppress immunity and induce B cell tolerance in vivo

Autoreactive B lymphocytes first encountering self-antigens in peripheral tissues are normally regulated by induction of anergy or apoptosis. According to the “two-signal” model, antigen recognition alone should render B cells tolerant unless T cell help or inflammatory signals such as lipopolysaccharide are provided. However, no such signals seem necessary for responses to T-independent type 2 (TI-2) antigens, which are multimeric antigens lacking T cell epitopes and Toll-like receptor ligands. How then do mature B cells avoid making a TI-2–like response to multimeric self-antigens? We present evidence that TI-2 antigens decorated with ligands of inhibitory sialic acid–binding Ig-like lectins (siglecs) are poorly immunogenic and can induce tolerance to subsequent challenge with immunogenic antigen. Two siglecs, CD22 and Siglec-G, contributed to tolerance induction, preventing plasma cell differentiation or survival. Although mutations in CD22 and its signaling machinery have been associated with dysregulated B cell development and autoantibody production, previous analyses failed to identify a tolerance defect in antigen-specific mutant B cells. Our results support a role for siglecs in B cell self-/nonself-discrimination, namely suppressing responses to self-associated antigens while permitting rapid “missing self”–responses to unsialylated multimeric antigens. The results suggest use of siglec ligand antigen constructs as an approach for inducing tolerance.

Identification of Anergic B Cells within a Wild-Type Repertoire

The contribution of anergy to silencing of autoreactive B cells in physiologic settings is unknown. By comparing anergic and nonanergic immunoglobulin-transgenic mouse strains, we defined a set of surface markers that were used for presumptive identification of an anergic B cell cohort within a normal repertoire. Like anergic transgenic B cells, these physiologic anergic cells exhibited high basal intracellular free calcium and did not mobilize calcium, initiate tyrosine phosphorylation, proliferate, upregulate activation markers, or mount an immune response upon antigen-receptor stimulation. Autoreactive B cells were overrepresented in this cohort. On the basis of the frequency and lifespan of these cells, it appears that as many as 50% of newly produced B cells are destined to become anergic. In conclusion, our findings indicate that anergy is probably the primary mechanism by which autoreactive B cells are silenced. Thus maintenance of the unresponsiveness of anergic cells is critical for prevention of autoimmunity.

Effect of cell:cell competition and BAFF expression on peripheral B cell tolerance and B-1 cell survival in transgenic mice expressing a low level of Igkappa-reactive macroself antigen

In mice carrying a synthetic Igkappa-reactive superantigen ("kappa macroself antigen"), low level expression induced split peripheral B cell tolerance in the sIgkappa+ compartment, with striking reductions in follicular and marginal zone (MZ) B cells and the retention of significant numbers of sIgkappa+ B-1a but not B-1b cells in the peritoneum. Here, we characterize the transgenic line pKkappa with this split tolerance phenotype and assess the effects of B cell competition and the survival cytokine BAFF (B cell activating factor belonging to the TNF family) on peripheral tolerance. In pKkappa mice the surviving peritoneal and splenic kappa+ B cells were largely lost in mice carrying one copy of the human Ckappa exon in place of the mouse version, a maneuver that generates additional antigen non-reactive competitor B cells in this model. Furthermore, overexpression of BAFF suppressed kappa-macroself antigen-induced deletion and promoted production of both IgM,kappa and IgA,kappa antibodies in mice with normal Igkappa alleles but not in mice carrying one copy of the human Ckappa allele. These findings suggest that BAFF overexpression has minimal effects on the survival of autoreactive B cells in a polyclonal immune system and that B cell:B cell competition plays a potent role in suppressing the survival of B-1 and splenic B cells with excessive autoreactivity.

Increasing the foreignness of an antigen, by coupling a second and foreign antigen to it, increases the T helper type 2 component of the immune response to the first antigen

It has been proposed that the degree of an antigen's foreignness is important in determining the Th1/Th2 phenotype of the immune response it generates. We test this hypothesis here and partially dissect the underlying mechanism. Immunization of C57BL/6 and hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-transgenic mice, tolerant to HEL at the T-cell level, with low doses of sheep red blood cells (SRBC), generated a predominant T helper type 1 (Th1) response in both mouse strains. However, substantial numbers of SRBC-specific Th2 cells were generated when normal, but not HEL-transgenic, mice were immunized with a low dose of the conjugate HEL-SRBC. The generation of these anti-SRBC Th2 cells in normal mice required that HEL be coupled to SRBC, since HEL was ineffective in deviating the response to SRBC when present but coupled to another, non-cross-reacting, xenogeneic RBC. This Th2 deviation of the anti-SRBC response by HEL thus requires the operational recognition of HEL epitopes linked to SRBC. Thus increasing the foreignness of an antigen increases its ability to generate Th2 cells. Our findings, in the context of previous observations in related systems, support the proposal that more CD4(+) T-cell/CD4(+) T-cell interactions, mediated by the operational recognition of linked epitopes, are required to generate Th2 cells than Th1 cells.

B Cells from Mice Prematurely Expressing Human Complement Receptor Type 2 Are Unresponsive to T-Dependent Antigens

Complement receptor type 2 (CR2/CD21), in association with CD19, plays an important role in enhancing mature B cell responses to opsonized Ags. We have shown that mice expressing a human CR2/CD21 (hCR2/CD21) transgene during the CD43(+)/CD25(-) late pro-B cell stage of B cell development demonstrate marked changes in subsequent B cell ontogeny. In the present study, we show that the humoral immune response to the T cell-dependent Ag, sheep RBC, is muted severely in a manner inversely proportional to B cell expression level of hCR2. Individual Ag-specific IgG isotypes vary in the degree to which they are affected but all are reduced while IgM titers are normal. A substantial reduction in germinal centers, both in size and frequency, in the spleens of immunized hCR2 transgenic mice demonstrates a failure to maintain germinal center reaction. However, both IgM expression levels and LPS-proliferative responses appear fully intact in B cells from hCR2-positive mice, suggesting that this alteration in B cell phenotype is different qualitatively from that of specific Ag-defined anergy models. These data suggest that the unresponsiveness to T-dependent Ags displayed by hCR2-positive B cells is linked to an increase in the level of stimulus required to propel the B cell into a fully activated state and thus a normal humoral immune response to Ags. We conclude that this phenotype and these mice may offer an additional means to dissect mechanisms underlying B cell tolerance and Ag responsiveness both in bone marrow and periphery.

Antinuclear antigen B cells that down-regulate surface B cell receptor during development to mature, follicular phenotype do not display features of anergy in vitro

We previously demonstrated that B cells expressing a transgenic BCR with "dual reactivity" for the hapten arsonate and nuclear autoantigens efficiently complete development to follicular phenotype and stably reside in follicles in vivo. These B cells express very low levels of surface IgM and IgD, suggesting that they avoid central deletion and peripheral anergy by reducing their avidity for autoantigen via surface BCR (sBCR) down-regulation. Since a variety of states of B cell anergy have been previously described, a thorough examination of the functional capabilities of these B cells was required to test this hypothesis. In this study, we show that surface Ig cross-linking induces amounts of proximal BCR signaling in these B cells commensurate with their reduced sBCR levels. Functionally, however, they are comparable to nonautoreactive B cells in cell cycle progression, up-regulation of activation and costimulatory molecules, and Ab-forming cell differentiation when treated with a variety of stimuli in vitro. In addition, these B cells can efficiently process and present Ag and are capable of undergoing cognate interaction with naive TCR-transgenic T cells, resulting in robust IL-2 production. Together, these data reveal a lack of intrinsic anergy involving any known mechanism, supporting the idea that this type of antinuclear Ag B cell becomes indifferent to cognate autoantigen by down-regulating sBCR.

Rapid induction of splenic and peritoneal B-1a cells in adult mice by thymus-independent type-2 antigen

We have produced a transgenic mouse (PV1TgL) that can only generate B lymphocytes with an Ig receptor specific for the synthetic polymer polyvinyl pyrrolidinone. Before immunization, bone marrow B cell numbers are very low, and peripheral lymphoid organs are almost devoid of B cells, confirming the role of positive selection by Ag in the development of mature B cell populations. The predominant population of B cells in the spleens of naive adult PV1TgL mice have most of the characteristics of marginal zone B cells, including anatomical location in the peripheral areas of the splenic white pulp. After immunization, a new population of B cells appears in the spleen with the characteristics of B-1 cells. Similar cells also appear somewhat later in the peritoneal cavity. Our findings suggest that immunization with a thymus-independent Ag can lead to the appearance and expansion of Ag-reactive B-1 cells in an adult mouse.

B Cell Positive Selection: Road Map to the Primary Repertoire?

Accumulating evidence indicates that positive selection events mediate differentiation, lineage commitment, and longevity of B lymphocytes. The BCR plays a central role, dictating the likelihood that newly formed cells will complete maturation, as well as whether cells persist within mature pools. Competition among B cells for limited, life span-promoting resources, which include self-ligands, lineage-specific cytokines, and innate receptor ligands, underlie these selective processes. Together, these observations suggest that positive selection is a critical feature in the establishment and maintenance of all lymphocyte pools, prompting re-evaluation of the underlying biological rationale for this process.

Defective B-cell-negative selection and terminal differentiation in the ICF syndrome

Immunodeficiency, centromeric region instability, and facial anomalies (ICF) syndrome is a rare autosomal recessive disease. Mutations in the DNA methyltransferase 3B (DNMT3B) gene are responsible for most ICF cases reported. We investigated the B-cell defects associated with agammaglobulinemia in this syndrome by analyzing primary B cells from 4 ICF patients. ICF peripheral blood (PB) contains only naive B cells; memory and gut plasma cells are absent. Naive ICF B cells bear potentially autoreactive long heavy chain variable regions complementarity determining region 3's (V(H)CDR3's) enriched with positively charged residues, in contrast to normal PB transitional and mature B cells, indicating that negative selection is impaired in patients. Like anergic B cells in transgenic models, newly generated and immature B cells accumulate in PB. Moreover, these cells secrete immunoglobulins and exhibit increased apoptosis following in vitro activation. However, they are able to up-regulate CD86, indicating that mechanisms other than anergy participate in silencing of ICF B cells. One patient without DNMT3B mutations shows differences in immunoglobulin E (IgE) switch induction, suggesting that immunodeficiency could vary with the genetic origin of the syndrome. In this study, we determined that negative selection breakdown and peripheral B-cell maturation blockage contribute to agammaglobulinemia in the ICF syndrome.

IL-4 promotes Stat6-dependent survival of autoreactive B cells in vivo without inducing autoantibody production

Persistent cross-linking of hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-specific B cell membrane Ig (mIg) in double transgenic mice that express soluble HEL as a self Ag (HEL-Ig mice) decreases B cell mIgM expression, responsiveness, and life span. Because in vitro treatment with IL-4 inhibits T cell apoptosis through a Stat6-independent mechanism, increases mIg expression, and suppresses activation-induced B cell death, we studied IL-4 effects on B cell mIg expression, survival, and Ab secretion in Stat6-sufficient and deficient HEL-Ig mice. IL-4 treatment nearly normalized B cell number and greatly increased the percentage of mature B cells in HEL-Ig mice, but failed to normalize mIgM expression or spontaneous LPS-induced IgM secretion. IL-4 effects on B cell survival and maturation were CD4(+) T cell independent, but Stat6 dependent, and did not involve receptor editing. IL-4 had to be present while B cells were generated to have a detectable effect on autoreactive B cell survival; however, the survival of B cells generated in the presence of IL-4 was substantially increased even after IL-4 was withdrawn. These observations suggest that: 1) activation-induced B cell death and anergy are independent processes; 2) B cells that survive to maturity develop increased resistance to Ag-induced deletion; and 3) IL-4 promotes B and T cell survival through different mechanisms.

Negligible class II MHC presentation of B cell receptor-derived peptides by high density resting B cells

Resting B lymphocytes have been credited with inducing T cell tolerance to Ig-derived and monovalent self-Ags that are internalized via the B cell receptor (BCR). These conclusions are predicated upon the assumptions that resting B cells display BCR-associated peptides in class II MHC and that the cells remain quiescent during the course of experimental manipulation. To determine whether resting B cells display BCR-associated epitopes in class II MHC, we devised a sensitive assay that averted potential activation of B cells by Ag and minimized activation by prolonged culture. Ex vivo, Percoll-fractionated B cells expressing a kappa transgene encoding a T cell epitope were cultured with a reactive T cell hybridoma for 12 h. Whereas low density, LPS-activated, and BCR-activated B cells elicited significant IL-2 from the T cell hybridoma, resting high density B cells did not. Parallel results were obtained with normal B cells expressing a second epitope encoded by an endogenous V(H) gene. Anergic B cells, which are uniformly low density, also significantly stimulated the T cell hybridoma. Finally, longer culture periods with normal B cells resulted in a higher degree of B cell activation and significant stimulation of reactive T cell hybridomas. Our results provide evidence that activation of B cells profoundly enhances the processing and presentation of BCR-associated Ags.

Regulation of inherently autoreactive VH4-34 B cells in the maintenance of human B cell tolerance

The study of human B cell tolerance has been hampered by difficulties in identifying a sizable population of autoreactive B lymphocytes whose fate could be readily determined. Hypothesizing that B cells expressing intrinsically autoreactive antibodies encoded by the VH4-34 heavy chain gene (VH4-34 cells) represent such a population, we tracked VH4-34 cells in healthy individuals. Here, we show that naive VH4-34 cells are positively selected and mostly restricted to the follicular mantle zone. Subsequently, these cells are largely excluded from the germinal centers and underrepresented in the memory compartment. In healthy donors but not in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), these cells are prevented from differentiating into antibody-producing plasma cells. This blockade can be overcome ex vivo using cultures of naive and memory VH4-34 cells in the presence of CD70, IL-2, and IL-10. VH4-34 cells may therefore represent an experimentally useful surrogate for autoantibody transgenes and should prove valuable in studying human B cell tolerance in a physiological, polyclonal environment. Our initial results suggest that both positive and negative selection processes participate in the maintenance of tolerance in autoreactive human B cells at multiple checkpoints throughout B cell differentiation and that at least some censoring mechanisms are faulty in SLE.

Lupus-specific antiribonucleoprotein B cell tolerance in nonautoimmune mice is maintained by differentiation to B-1 and governed by B cell receptor signaling thresholds

Systemic lupus erythematosus is an autoimmune disease characterized by the presence of autoantibodies. One of the unique targets of the immune system in systemic lupus erythematosus is Sm, a ribonucleoprotein present in all cells. To understand the regulation of B cells specific to the Sm Ag in normal mice, we have generated an Ig H chain transgenic mouse (2-12H Tg). 2-12H Tg mice produce B cells specific for the Sm that remain tolerant due to ignorance. We demonstrate here that anti-Sm B cells of 2-12H Tg mice can differentiate into Sm-specific peritoneal B-1 cells that remain tolerant. Differentiation to B-1 and tolerance are governed by the strength of B cell receptor signaling, since manipulations of the B cell receptor coreceptors CD19 and CD22 affect anti-Sm B cell differentiation and autoantibody production. These results suggest a differentiation scheme in which peripheral ignorance to Sm is maintained in mice by the differentiation of anti-Sm B cells to B-1 cells that have increased activation thresholds.

B cell clonal elimination induced by membrane-bound self-antigen may require repeated antigen encounter or cell competition

Transgenic mouse experiments indicate that autoreactive B cells are eliminated upon encounter with membrane self-antigen. In this study we tested how B cell tolerance to MHC class I antigens is affected by altering the frequency of antigen-carrying cells in mixed bone marrow (BM) chimeras. When antigen-bearing cells are present at low frequency, the reactive B cells and their antigens may coexist in the peripheral lymphoid organs, but under these conditions the B cells are functionally anergic and have a shortened lifespan. Such putative anergic cells are strongly deleted in the presence of additional, non-antigen-bearing, non-transgenic B cells. Since the antigen concentration on the surface of each antigen-bearing cell should be high, these results suggest that for efficient deletion of autoreactive B cells multiple antigen encounters may be required, particularly when cellular competition is weak. These results have implications for the therapeutic use of BM chimerism to induce B cell tolerance to grafts.

T Cell Autoimmunity in Ig Transgenic Mice

Autoantibodies directed at a diverse group of proteins of the U1/Sm ribonucleoprotein (snRNP) are characteristic of systemic lupus erythematosus and are found in the MRL murine model of this disease. This study examines the role of transgenic B lymphocytes in the regulation of autoreactive T cells to the snRNP autoantigen. Transgenic mice were developed bearing an Ig heavy chain gene specific for the D protein component of murine snRNP. B lymphocytes in these mice are neither deleted nor anergic and are of an immature (heat-stable Aghigh) phenotype. T lymphocytes from anti-snRNP transgenic mice were examined using a recombinant form of the D protein of the murine snRNP complex. Our results revealed that transgenic anti-snRNP B cell APCs stimulated CD4 T cells from wild-type C57BL/6 and MRL lpr/lpr mice, while nonspecific APCs failed to stimulate CD4 T cells. This study demonstrates that autoreactive T cells are not deleted from wild-type mice, although their activation is facilitated by autoantigen-specific APCs. The snRNP-reactive T cells in C57BL/6 transgenic mice are tolerized, in contrast to those T cells from MRL lpr/lpr transgenic mice. These studies implicate a role for autoreactive B lymphocytes in the in vivo activation and/or diversification of autoreactive T cells.

B lymphocytes producing demyelinating autoantibodies: development and function in gene-targeted transgenic mice

We studied the cellular basis of self tolerance of B cells specific for brain autoantigens using transgenic mice engineered to produce high titers of autoantibodies against the myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG), a surface component of central nervous system myelin. We generated "knock-in" mice by replacing the germline JH locus with the rearranged immunoglobulin (Ig) H chain variable (V) gene of a pathogenic MOG-specific monoclonal antibody. In the transgenic mice, conventional B cells reach normal numbers in bone marrow and periphery and express exclusively transgenic H chains, resulting in high titers of MOG-specific serum Igs. Additionally, about one third of transgenic B cells bind MOG, thus demonstrating the absence of active tolerization. Furthermore, peritoneal B-1 lymphocytes are strongly depleted. Upon immunization with MOG, the mature transgenic B cell population undergoes normal differentiation to plasma cells secreting MOG-specific IgG antibodies, during which both Ig isotype switching and somatic mutation occur. In naive transgenic mice, the presence of this substantial autoreactive B cell population is benign, and the mice fail to develop either spontaneous neurological disease or pathological evidence of demyelination. However, the presence of the transgene both accelerates and exacerbates experimental autoimmune encephalitis, irrespective of the identity of the initial autoimmune insult.

Autoreactive B cell regulation: peripheral induction of developmental arrest by lupus-associated autoantigens

Anti-Sm and anti-ssDNA transgenic (Tg) mice were generated using the VH-D-JH rearrangement of an anti-Sm hybridoma of MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr origin. B cells of each specificity account for 15%-35% of the splenic repertoire, but no circulating anti-Sm or anti-ssDNA antibodies are detected. Most autoreactive cells exhibit an immature B cell phenotype and have short half-lives equivalent to those of non-Tg immature B cells. However, at least some anti-Sm B cells are functional, because immunization with murine snRNPs induces anti-Sm secretion. We propose that anti-Sm and anti-ssDNA are eliminated during the transition to mature B cells and that this late stage of tolerance induction is consequential to their spontaneous activation in murine lupus.

Negative signaling in B cells by surface immunoglobulins

Cross-linking of surface immunoglobulins generates negative signals that cause B-cell death unless appropriate rescue signals are provided. Surface IgM is the main transducer of the negative signaling, but surface IgD and IgG may also transduce negative signaling when cross-linked intensively. In the surface IgM+, IgD+ human malignant B lymphoma cell lines B104 and DND-39, cross-linking of surface IgM by anti-IgM antibodies induced cell death. Anti-IgM antibody-induced B104 cell death was inhibited by stimulation with alpha- and beta-interferons but not stimulation with anti-CD40 antibody or IL-4, whereas anti-IgM antibody-induced DND-39 cell death was inhibited by stimulation with anti-CD40 antibody but not stimulation with alpha- and beta-interferons. Anti-IgM antibody-stimulated B104 cells had morphologic features compatible with necrosis, whereas anti-IgM antibody-stimulated DND-39 cells showed morphologic features of apoptosis. CD11a/CD54-dependent cell adhesion induced by stimulation with anti-CD40 antibody was involved in anti-CD40 antibody-mediated inhibition of anti-IgM antibody-induced DND-39 cells. In normal human mature B cells, cross-linking of surface IgM induced different signaling consequences, including DNA synthesis or cell division (positive signaling) or cell cycle arrest or death (negative signaling). In this system, too, CD40-transduced signal inhibited anti-IgM antibody-induced negative signaling, and CD11a/CD54-dependent cell adhesion played a role in the rescue process. It is suggested that quantitatively different intensities of surface IgM cross-linking induce qualitatively different signaling consequences; relatively weak cross-linking may induce DNA synthesis; moderate cross-linking may induce DNA synthesis with cell cycle arrest at the G2/M interphase; and intense cross-linking may induce apoptotic cell death. The reasons for this difference are not yet known. Further elucidation of the molecular mechanisms responsible for surface IgM-mediated negative signaling and its rescue signaling may contribute toward development of therapy for allergic disorders by artificial modulation of specific immunoglobulin production.

Lipopolysaccharide prevents apoptosis and induces responsiveness to antigen receptor cross-linking in immature B cells

Unlike mature B cells, immature B cells are not activated in response to antigen receptor cross-linking. To examine the mechanisms underlying this unresponsiveness, we have studied the effects of reagents that have been shown to alter the responses of immature B cells to antigen receptor stimulation. Bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) is a polyclonal B-cell activator, and has been shown to interfere with B-cell tolerance induction in vivo and in vitro. Here we show that LPS can also overcome the unresponsiveness of immature B cells to stimulation with anti-receptor (anti-mu) antibodies. LPS synergizes with anti-mu to induce a proliferative response that exceeds the response of immature B cells to LPS alone. Moreover, pretreatment of immature cells with LPS allows them to proliferate in response to subsequent stimulation with anti-mu antibodies. This induction of responsiveness to anti-mu requires exposure to LPS for at least 8 hr. Although the mechanisms of induction are not fully understood, one component of the LPS effect appears to involve enhancement of immature B-cell survival in culture. Neonatal splenic B cells undergo spontaneous apoptosis at a much higher rate than mature B cells, but we have found that LPS causes a dramatic inhibition of apoptosis, even when it is present for only the first 8 hr of culture. The ability of LPS to promote survival of immature B cells and allow them to proliferate in response to antigen receptor stimulation provides a system for investigation of the biochemical mechanisms of unresponsiveness and tolerance susceptibility.

Human immunoglobulin (IgG) induced deletion of IgM rheumatoid factor B cells in transgenic mice

The singular ability of immunoglobulin genes to hypermutate their variable regions, while permitting the generation of high-affinity antibodies against foreign antigens, poses a problem in terms of maintenance of immunological self-tolerance. Immunoglobulin gene hypermutation driven by a foreign antigen has the potential to generate antibodies that cross-react with self-components. Consequently, there must exist a mechanism in the periphery for inactivation of mature autoreactive B cell clones. The classical experimental system used to address this problem is the induction of tolerance to soluble, deaggregated human IgG. We have analyzed the mechanism of induction of tolerance to human IgG using transgenic mice that express a human IgM rheumatoid factor (IgM RF) on a large proportion of their B cells. Injection of deaggregated human IgG caused a specific deletion of those B cells that express an intact IgM RF on their cell surface. The degree of RF B cell deletion was proportional to the reduction in the proliferative response of splenocytes to antigen (aggregated human IgG), or to F(ab')2 fragments of anti-human IgM antibodies. Control experiments showed that IgG administration had little effect on the numbers of mouse Ig-bearing cells or their ability to proliferate to a nonspecific mitogen. Thus, the effects of IgG on the human IgM RF B cell are antigen specific and are not due to nonspecific toxic effects of the human IgG preparation. These experiments demonstrate that peripheral exposure to IgG induces deletion of reactive B cells, without any evidence for anergy, and differ from data obtained by other investigators studying tolerance to soluble protein antigens. The results imply that human Igs have distinct properties as soluble antigens, and that peripheral nonresponsiveness to IgG may be due to lymphocyte deletion.

T helper cell unresponsiveness: rapid induction in antigen-transgenic and reversion in non-transgenic mice

T cell tolerance is usually established by clonal deletion of self-specific T cells in the thymus, or some times, in the periphery. Alternatively, tolerance may also be achieved by induction of clonal T cell unresponsiveness by a poorly understood mechanism called "anergy". We found that transgenic mice expressing a soluble form of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) glycoprotein (G) predominantly in liver and kidney exhibited normal B cell responses. VSV-G-specific T help-independent neutralizing IgM responses were within normal ranges, but no T help-dependent neutralizing IgG antibodies were generated upon immunization with recombinant VSV-G protein and recombinant vaccinia virus expressing VSV-G. This demonstrated absence of B cell tolerance but presence of T helper cell unresponsiveness. After adoptive transfer of transgenic spleen cells into thymectomized immuno-incompetent hosts, the unresponsive T helper cells regained function and switched the neutralizing IgM response to IgG, comparably to control T helper cells, within 7 days. Conversely, when naive non-transgenic spleen cells were transferred into transgenic mice, VSV-G-specific T helper cells became unresponsive within 3-4 days. These results suggest that VSV-G-specific T helper cells are rendered unresponsive within a few days in the VSV-G transgenic host also outside of the thymus and that this unresponsiveness was reversed by transfer into antigen-free recipients.

Anergic self-reactive B cells present self antigen and respond normally to CD40-dependent T-cell signals but are defective in antigen-receptor-mediated functions

B-cell tolerance to soluble protein self antigens such as hen egg lysozyme (HEL) is mediated by clonal anergy. Anergic B cells fail to mount antibody responses even in the presence of carrier-primed T cells, suggesting an inability to activate or respond to T helper cells. To investigate the nature of this defect, B cells from tolerant HEL/anti-HEL double-transgenic mice were incubated with a membrane preparation from activated T-cell clones expressing the CD40 ligand. These membranes, together with interleukin 4 and 5 deliver the downstream antigen-independent CD40-dependent B-cell-activating signals required for productive T-B collaboration. Anergic B cells responded to this stimulus by proliferating and secreting antibody at levels comparable to or better than control B cells. Furthermore, anergic B cells presented HEL acquired in vivo and could present the unrelated antigen, conalbumin, targeted for processing via surface IgD. In contrast, the low immunoglobulin receptor levels on anergic B cells were associated with reduced de novo presentation of HEL and a failure to upregulate costimulatory ligands for CD28. These defects in immunoglobulin-receptor-mediated functions could be overcome in vivo, suggesting a number of mechanisms for induction of autoantibody responses.

Anergic B cells constitutively present self antigen: enhanced immunoglobulin receptor-mediated presentation of antigenic determinants by B cells is hierarchical

Presentation of hen egg lysozyme (HEL) by HEL-specific B cells was studied in transgenic mice expressing anti-HEL immunoglobulin (Ig-transgenic). In T hybridoma assays, presentation of the HEL46-61 determinant by B cells from Ig-transgenic mice required 10(3)-10(4)-fold lower concentrations of HEL than were required for presentation by B cells from non-transgenic mice. In contrast, presentation of the HEL determinants 112-129 and 25-43 by HEL-specific B cells was either not significantly enhanced, or enhanced only 10-fold compared with B cells from non-transgenic mice. Enhanced presentation of HEL determinants by B cells from Ig-transgenic donors was specific for HEL, since keyhole limpet hemocyanin or synthetic HEL46-61 peptide were presented comparably by B cells from Ig-transgenic mice and non-transgenic littermates. A minimum of 1-4% Ig-transgenic B cells was required to detect enhanced presentation of HEL46-61 in vitro. Constitutive presentation of the HEL46-61 determinant, but not the HEL25-43 or HEL112-129 determinants, was detectable on anergic HEL-specific B cells from double (HEL/Ig)-transgenic mice. In the presence of exogenously added HEL, anergic B cells presented all three HEL determinants. Constitutively presented HEL46-61 was not due to endogenous synthesis of HEL antigen by anergic B cells from double-transgenic mice, as comparable levels of the HEL46-61 determinant were constitutively presented by B cells from Ig-Tg-->HEL-Tg irradiation bone marrow chimeric mice. Firstly, these results indicate that the enhanced antigen presentation mediated by Ig receptors on B cells is not equivalent for all antigenic determinants. Secondly, the data demonstrate that anergic, autoreactive B cells efficiently process and present nominal antigens in addition to constitutively presenting specific self antigen in vivo.

Immunoglobulin signal transduction guides the specificity of B cell-T cell interactions and is blocked in tolerant self-reactive B cells

The specificity of antibody (Ab) responses depends on focusing helper T (Th) lymphocyte signals to suitable B lymphocytes capable of binding foreign antigens (Ags), and away from nonspecific or self-reactive B cells. To investigate the molecular mechanisms that prevent the activation of self-reactive B lymphocytes, the activation requirements of B cells specific for the Ag hen egg lysozyme (HEL) obtained from immunoglobulin (Ig)-transgenic mice were compared with those of functionally tolerant B cells isolated from Ig-transgenic mice which also express soluble HEL. To eliminate the need for surface (s)Ig-mediated Ag uptake and presentation and allow the effects of sIg signaling to be studied in isolation, we assessed the ability of allogeneic T cells from bm12 strain mice to provide in vivo help to C57BL/6 strain-transgenic B cells. Interestingly, non-tolerant Ig-transgenic B cells required both allogeneic Th cells and binding of soluble HEL for efficient activation and Ab production. By contrast, tolerant self-reactive B cells from Ig/HEL double transgenic mice responded poorly to the same combination of allogeneic T cells and soluble HEL. The tolerant B cells were nevertheless normally responsive to stimulation with interleukin 4 and anti-CD40 Abs in vitro, suggesting that they retained the capacity to respond to mediators of T cell help. However, the tolerant B cells exhibited a proximal block in the sIg signaling pathway which prevented activation of receptor-associated tyrosine kinases in response to the binding of soluble HEL. The functional significance of this sIg signaling defect was confirmed by using a more potent membrane-bound form of HEL capable of triggering sIg signaling in tolerant B cells, which markedly restored their ability to collaborate with allogeneic Th cells and produce Ab. These findings indicate that Ag-specific B cells require two signals for mounting a T cell-dependent Ab response and identify regulation of sIg signaling as a mechanism for controlling self-reactive B cells.

The influence of antigen organization on B cell responsiveness

The influence of antigen epitope density and order on B cell induction and antibody production was assessed with the glycoprotein of vesicular stomatitis virus serotype Indiana [VSV-G (IND)]. VSV-G (IND) can be found in a highly repetitive form the envelope of VSV-IND and in a poorly organized form on the surface of infected cells. In VSV-G (IND) transgenic mice, B cells were unresponsive to the poorly organized VSV-G (IND) present as self antigen but responded promptly to the same antigen presented in the highly organized form. Thus, antigen organization influences B cell tolerance.

B cells are anergic in transgenic mice that express IgM anti-DNA antibodies

B lymphocytes in individuals with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) secrete pathogenic autoantibodies to DNA which cause clinical nephritis. (NZB X NZW) F1 (BW) female mice also secrete pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies, and therefore are considered to be an animal model of SLE. The rearranged immunoglobulin (Ig) genes that encode an anti-DNA antibody from a diseased BW mouse have been cloned, and transgenic (Tg) mice have been created by microinjection of these constructs into fertilized eggs from normal mice. As we reported previously, when the construct contains the C gamma 2a heavy chain constant (CH) region, the mice spontaneously secrete anti-DNA IgG and they develop mild nephritis. This demonstrated that the Ig encoded by the transgene is pathogenic. In contrast, here we report that when the construct contains the same anti-DNA Ig variable (V) regions used previously, along with the C mu region, the autoreactive B cells are rendered tolerant. Most B cells in the Tg mice express the mu transgene product on their surface, and rearrangement of endogenous light chain genes is partially suppressed. Furthermore, most hybridomas made from Tg B cells secrete IgM anti-DNA. Despite this, the Tg mice have reduced levels of total serum Ig and they do not secrete anti-DNA IgM either spontaneously or following immunization with DNA. We conclude that most B cells in the Tg mice have been rendered anergic. Anergy is however reversible in vitro; lipopolysaccharide stimulation of Tg B cells leads to the production of a significant amount of IgM anti-DNA antibody. The studies demonstrate that in this line of Tg mice on a normal mouse genetic background potentially pathogenic B cells that express a high-affinity Ig specific for a natural autoantigen are subject to tolerance by induction of anergy.