Emergence of committed B lymphoid progenitors in the developing chicken embryo

Role of Physiology, Immunity, Microbiota, and Infectious Diseases in the Gut Health of Poultry

“Gut health” refers to the physical state and physiological function of the gastrointestinal tract and in the livestock system; this topic is often focused on the complex interacting components of the intestinal system that influence animal growth performance and host-microbial homeostasis. Regardless, there is an increasing need to better understand the complexity of the intestinal system and the various factors that influence gut health, since the intestine is the largest immune and neuroendocrine organ that interacts with the most complex microbiome population. As we face the post-antibiotic growth promoters (AGP) era in many countries of the world, livestock need more options to deal with food security, food safety, and antibiotic resilience to maintain agricultural sustainability to feed the increasing human population. Furthermore, developing novel antibiotic alternative strategies needs a comprehensive understanding of how this complex system maintains homeostasis as we face unpredictable changes in external factors like antibiotic-resistant microbes, farming practices, climate changes, and consumers’ preferences for food. In this review, we attempt to assemble and summarize all the relevant information on chicken gut health to provide deeper insights into various aspects of gut health. Due to the broad and complex nature of the concept of “gut health”, we have highlighted the most pertinent factors related to the field performance of broiler chickens.

Identification, tissue characterization, and innate immune role of Angiogenin-4 expression in young broiler chickens

Intestinal epithelial cells are major producers of antimicrobial proteins, which play an important role in innate immunity. In addition to defensins, the Ribonuclease A superfamily includes important antimicrobial proteins involved in host-defense mechanisms in vertebrates. Angiogenin-4 (Ang4), a member of this RNase superfamily, has been demonstrated to be secreted by Paneth cells in mice. We have successfully cloned and characterized a new chicken gene (chAng4), found for the first time in a nonmammalian species, from intestinal epithelial and lymphoid cells. Characterization of chAng4 revealed 99% nucleotide and 97% amino acid sequence homology to mouse Ang4. Similar functional regions were identified, suggesting a role in innate immunity and regulation of gut microbiota. Furthermore, the mRNA expression pattern of chAng4 was studied in broilers in the presence or absence of beneficial bacteria (probiotics) and organic acids. The results showed that one-day-old chickens expressed low levels of Ang4 in almost all the evaluated tissues (crop, proventriculus, duodenum, jejunum, ileum, and cecal tonsils), except in the bursa of Fabricius that presented the highest expression level. The addition of probiotics and organic acids for either 7 or 14 consecutive days demonstrated a direct effect of probiotics and organic acids on chAng4 expression; moreover, broilers receiving probiotics and organic acids for only 7 D showed higher levels of chAng4 expression compared with those treated for 14 D. Broilers without treatment had a constant high level of expression in cecal tonsils and bursa. In conclusion, we were able to identify and characterize a new antimicrobial gene in chickens (chAng4) throughout the gastrointestinal tract. chAng4 mRNA gene expression was associated with the presence of naturally occurring and supplemented (probiotic) bacteria. The encoded protein might have a potential bactericidal effect against intestinal nonpathogenic and pathogenic microbes, modulating the intestinal microbiota and the innate immunity, and thereby may help minimize the use of antibiotics in poultry feed.

Effect of methionine deficiency on duodenal and jejunal IgA+ B cell count and immunoglobulin level of broilers

Dietary methionine (met) is reported to enhance antibody production and boost cell-mediated immunity in chickens. Methionine deficiency has been shown to affect the development of the lymphoid organs and the generation of antibodies in chickens. This study is designed to investigate the effects of met deficiency on IgA⁺ B cells and immunoglobulins (sIgA, IgA, IgG and IgM) for a 6 week period in the duodenum and jejunum of Cobb broiler chicken using immunohistochemistry and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) techniques. The results of the study showed that the IgA⁺ B cell count reduced significantly in the met deficiency group compared to the control group (P<0.05 or P<0.01). The contents of sIgA, IgA, IgG and IgM in the met deficiency group were significantly decreased (P<0.05 or P<0.01), especially at 28 and 42 days of age. It can be concluded that met deficiency exerts significant effects on the humoral immune system of intestinal mucosa. This study has provided valuable experimental insight which could be useful for future studies on the function of met in the intestine of humans and other animals.

Nickel Chloride (NiCl2) Induces Histopathological Lesions via Oxidative Damage in the Broiler's Bursa of Fabricius

The purpose of this study was to investigate the histopathological lesions, oxidative damage, changes of immunoglobulin G (IgG), immunoglobulin M (IgM), and immunoglobulin A (IgA) contents in the bursa of Fabricius and serum immunoglobulins (IgG, IgM, IgA) induced by dietary nickel chloride (NiCl2). Two hundred and eighty-one-day-old broilers were randomly divided into four groups and fed on a control diet and three experimental diets supplemented with 300, 600, and 900 mg/kg of NiCl2 for 42 days. Lesions were observed in the NiCl2-treated groups. Histopathologically, lymphocytes were decreased in lymphoid follicles with thinner cortices and wider medullae. Concurrently, the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px), and the ability to inhibit hydroxyl radical and glutathione (GSH) contents were significantly (p < 0.05 or p < 0.01) decreased, while malondialdehyde (MDA) contents were increased in the NiCl2-treated groups. The serum IgG, IgM, and bursa IgG and IgM contents were significantly (p < 0.05 or p < 0.01) lower in the NiCl2-treated groups than those in the control group. The above-mentioned results show that dietary NiCl2 in excess of 300 mg/kg can cause histopathological lesions via oxidative damage, which finally impairs the function of the bursa of Fabricius and reduces IgG and IgM contents of the serum and the bursa of Fabricius. The study is aimed to provide helpful materials for studies on Ni- or Ni compounds-induced B cell toxicity in both human and other animals in the future.

Toxicological effects of nickel chloride on IgA+ B Cells and sIgA, IgA, IgG, IgM in the intestinal mucosal immunity in broilers

The objective of this study was to investigate the toxicological effects of dietary NiCl2 on IgA+ B cells and the immunoglobulins including sIgA, IgA, IgG and IgM in the small intestine and cecal tonsil of broilers by the methods of immunohistochemistry and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Two hundred and forty one-day-old avian broilers were randomly divided into four groups and fed on a control diet and three experimental diets supplemented with 300, 600, and 900 mg/kg NiCl2 for 42 days. Compared with the control group, the IgA+ B cell number and the sIgA, IgA, IgG, and IgM contents in the NiCl2-treated groups were significantly decreased (p < 0.05 or p < 0.01). It was concluded that dietary NiCl2 in the excess of 300 mg/kg had negative effects on the IgA+ B cell number and the above mentioned immunoglobulin contents in the small intestine and the cecal tonsil. NiCl2-reduced sIgA, IgA, IgG and IgM contents is due to decrease in the population and/or the activation of B cell. The results suggest that NiCl2 at high levels has intestinal mucosal humoral immunotoxicity in animals.

New insight into the structure, development, functions and popular disorders of bursa Fabricii

Humoral immune responses in birds, contrary to mammals, depend on the normal functioning of bursa Fabricii. Recent studies have delivered new information about the structure, development and origin of cells that compose the bursa environment. Several viral infections affect bursa, causing lymphocyte depletion or excessive proliferation. This review summarizes data on the development and histology of healthy bursa and introduces some common disorders that affect this organ.

The influence of antibiotics on B-cell number, percentage, and distribution in the bursa of Fabricius of newly hatched chicks

Antibiotics are commonly used to prevent and treat poultry microbial infections, but certain antibiotic families depress humoral immunity, such as antibody production. Poultry humoral immunity depends on the normal functioning of the bursa of Fabricius and the B lymphocytes that mature in that gland. In this study, recommended therapeutic doses of enrofloxacin, florfenicol, or ceftiofur were administered to 2-d-old chicks. On d 7 post-hatch, bursae were sampled for histological, immunohistochemical, and flow cytometric determination of Bu-1-positive (Bu-1+) cell number, percentage, and distribution. The bursa of Fabricius from all treatment and control groups had normal morphology. The administration of antibiotics significantly decreased the number of Bu-1+ cells in the bursal medulla, with a simultaneous increase of these cells in the cortex. Flow cytometry revealed a significant decrease in the percentage of bursal Bu-1+ cells from all of the studied antibiotics: enrofloxacin (93.91 ± 3.27), florfenicol (87.84 ± 7.14), and ceftiofur (89.16 ± 5.68) compared with that of the control (96.48 ± 2.60). The combination of reduced percentages of Bu-1+ cells and a decrease in these cells in the medullary region suggests lower B cell maturation.

The ontogeny of the porcine immune system

Cellular and humoral aspects of the immune response develop sequentially in the fetus. During the ontogeny, the pluripotent stem cells emerge and differentiate into all hematopoietic lineages. Basic questions including the identification of the first lympho-hematopoietic sites, the origin of T and B lymphocytes, the development of different subpopulations of alphabeta T, gammadelta T and B lymphocytes as well as development of innate immunity and the acquisition of full immunological capacities are discussed here for swine and compared with other species. The description of related topics such as fertilization, morphogenesis, maternal-fetal-neonatal physiology and early neonatal development are also discussed.

V(D)J recombination: of mice and sharks

The adaptive immune system of jawed vertebrates is based on a vast, anticipatory repertoire of specific antigen receptors, immunoglobulins (Ig) in B-lymphocytes and T-cell receptors (TCR) in T-lymphocytes. The Ig and TCRdiversity is generated by a process called V(D)J recombination, which is initiated by the RAG recombinase. Although RAG activity is very well conserved, the regulated accessibility of the antigen receptor genes to RAG has evolved with the species' organizational structure, which differs most significantly between fishes and tetrapods. V(D)J recombination was primarily characterized in developing lymphocytes of mice and human beings and is often described as an ordered, two-stage program. Studies in rabbit, chicken and shark show that this process does not have to be ordered, nor does it need to take place in two stages to generate a diverse repertoire and enable the expression of a single species of antigen receptor per cell, a restriction called allelic exclusion.

A unique role for the lambda5 nonimmunoglobulin tail in early B lymphocyte development

Precursor BCR (pre-BCR) signaling governs proliferation and differentiation of pre-B cells during B lymphocyte development. However, it is controversial as to which parts of the pre-BCR, which is composed of Igmu H chain, surrogate L chain (SLC), and Igalpha-Igbeta, are important for signal initiation. Here, we show in transgenic mice that the N-terminal non-Ig-like (unique) tail of the surrogate L chain component lambda5 is critical for enhancing pre-BCR-induced proliferation signals. Pre-BCRs with a mutated lambda5 unique tail are still transported to the cell surface, but they deliver only basal signals that trigger survival and differentiation of pre-B cells. Further, we demonstrate that the positively charged residues of the lambda5 unique tail, which are required for pre-BCR self-oligomerization, can also mediate binding to stroma cell-associated self-Ags, such as heparan sulfate. These findings establish the lambda5 unique tail as a pre-BCR-specific autoreactive signaling motif that could increase the size of the primary Ab repertoire by selectively expanding pre-B cells with functional Igmu H chains.

Antibodies, immunoglobulin genes and the bursa of Fabricius in chicken B cell development

The bursa of Fabricius is critical for the normal development of B lymphocytes in birds. It is productively colonized during embryonic life by a limited number of B cell precursors that have undergone the immunoglobulin gene rearrangements required for expression of cell surface immunoglobulin. Immunoglobulin gene rearrangement occurs in the absence of terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase and generates minimal antibody diversity. In addition, observations that immunoglobulin heavy and light chain variable gene rearrangement occur at the same time and that allelic exclusion of immunoglobulin expression is regulated at the level of variable region gene rearrangement provide a striking contrast to rodent and primate models of immunoglobulin gene assembly. Following productive colonization of the bursa, developing B cells undergo rapid proliferation and the immunoglobulin V region genes that generate the specificity of the B cell surface immunoglobulin receptor undergo diversification. Immunoglobulin diversity in birds is generated by somatic gene conversion events in which sequences derived from upstream families of pseudogenes replace homologous sequences in unique and functionally rearranged immunoglobulin heavy and light chain variable region genes. This mechanism is distinct from and much more efficient than mechanisms of antibody diversification seen in rodents and primates. While the bursal microenvironment is not required for immunoglobulin gene rearrangement and expression, it is essential for the generation of antibody diversity by gene conversion. Following hatch, gut derived antigens are taken up by the bursa. While bursal development prior to hatch occurs in the absence of exogenous antigen, chicken B cell development after hatch may therefore be influenced by the presence of environmental antigen. This review focuses on the differences between B cell development in the chicken as compared to rodent and primate models.

Antibody repertoire development in swine

Swine belong to the Order Artiodactyla and like mice and humans, express IgM, IgD, IgG, IgE and IgA antibodies but a larger number of IgG subclasses. Like rabbits and chickens, expressed V(H) genes belong to the ancestral V(H)3 family and only 5 comprise >80% of the pre-immune repertoire. Since they use primarily two D(H) segments and have a single J(H) like chickens, junctional diversity plays a relatively greater role in repertoire formation than in humans and mice. Proportional light chain usage surprisingly resembles that in humans and is therefore distinctly different from the predominant kappa chain usage (>90%) of lab rodents and predominant lambda chain usage in other ungulates (>90%). The pre-immune V(kappa) repertoire also appears restricted since >95% of V(kappa)J(kappa) rearrangements use only a few members of the IGKV2 family and only J(kappa)2. Two V(lambda) families (IGLV3 and IGLV8) are used in forming the pre-immune repertoire. Antibodies that do not utilize light chains as in camelids, or the lengthy CDR3 regions seen in cattle that use V(H)4 family genes, have not been reported in swine. B cell lymphogenesis first occurs in the yolk sac but early VDJ rearrangements differ from mice and humans in that nearly 100% are in-frame and N-region additions are already present. Swine possess ileal Peyers patches like sheep which may be important for antigen-independent B cell repertoire diversification. The presence of pro B-like cells in interlobular areas of thymus and mature B cells in the thymic medulla that have switched to especially IgA in early gestation, is so far unique among mammals. The offspring of swine are believed to receive no passive immunity in utero and are precosial. Thus, they are a useful model for studies on fetal-neonatal immunological development. The model has already shown that: (a) colonization of the gut is required for responsiveness to TD and TI-2 antigens, (b) responsiveness due to colonization depends on bacterial PAMPs and (c) some viral pathogens can interfere with the establishment of immune homeostasis in neonates. Studies on swine reinforce concerns that caution be used when paradigms arising from studies in one mammal are extrapolated to other mammals, even when similarities are predicted by taxonomy and phylogeny. Swine exemplify a situation in which evolutionary diversification of the immune system is not characteristic of an entire order or even of other related systems in the same species.

Developmentally programmed expression of AID in chicken B cells

In mice, activation induced deaminase, AID, is expressed only in germinal center B cells. It is required for the initiation of somatic hypermutation and class switch recombination. In chickens and most mammals immunoglobulin gene rearrangement generates limited diversity and the primary immunoglobulin repertoire depends on subsequent somatic hypermutation or gene conversion. Immunoglobulin gene conversion in chickens starts in the embryonic bursa, before antigen exposure. The demonstrated requirement for AID for gene conversion in the bursal lymphoma cell line, DT40, implies developmental regulation of AID expression. To test this prediction, we examined the timing and location of AID mRNA expression. An abrupt increase in AID mRNA coincided with the onset of extensive Ig gene conversion in the bursa. Expression was also detected at earlier stages, implying either that expression of AID is not the only controlling factor for gene conversion, or that gene conversion can precede the formation of bursal follicles.

Comparison ofin ovoand post‐hatch vaccination with particular reference to infectious bursal disease. A review

In ovo vaccination is an alternative approach to post-hatch vaccination of chickens, particularly in broilers. Vaccination at embryonation day 18 helps to 'close the window' of susceptibility i.e. the time between vaccination and early exposure to infectious agents compared with post-hatch vaccination. Attempts on embryonal vaccination as a mode of vaccine delivery were approached from the observation that chickens already develop certain immunologic functions before hatching. The immune system in birds begins to develop early during embryogenesis and various immune reactions have been induced in the late stage chicken embryos. Compared with post-hatch vaccination, in ovo vaccination stimulates both the innate and adaptive immune responses with the advantage that because of the prenatal immunization, in ovo vaccinated chicks have developed an appreciable degree of protection by the time of hatch. Effects of maternal antibodies on vaccines to be used for in ovo vaccination can be prevented by developing vaccines that are insensitive to maternal antibodies. It has been described that vaccination of chicken embryos at embryonation day 18 did not significantly affect the immune competence of hatched chickens. The apparent absence of tolerance in chicks hatched from embryos exposed to an antigen at the late stage of embryonation implies the feasibility of in ovo vaccination. Investigations on in ovo vaccination to produce safe and efficient vaccines are still in progress. Currently a large number of vaccines are under investigation for viral, bacterial and protozoal diseases.

The Cytoplasmic Domain of Igα Is Necessary and Sufficient to Support Efficient Early B Cell Development

The B cell receptor complex (BcR) is essential for normal B lymphocyte function, and surface BcR expression is a crucial checkpoint in B cell development. However, functional requirements for chains of the BcR during development remain controversial. We have used retroviral gene transfer to introduce components of the BcR into chicken B cell precursors during embryonic development. A chimeric heterodimer, in which the cytoplasmic domains of chicken Igalpha and Igbeta are expressed by fusion with the extracellular and transmembrane domains of murine CD8alpha and CD8beta, respectively, targeted the cytoplasmic domains of the BcR to the cell surface in the absence of extracellular BcR domains. Expression of this chimeric heterodimer supported all early stages of embryo B cell development: bursal colonization, clonal expansion, and induction of repertoire diversification by gene conversion. Expression of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha, in the absence of the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta, was not only necessary, but sufficient to support B cell development as efficiently as the endogenous BcR. In contrast, expression of the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta in the absence of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha failed to support B cell development. The ability of the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha to support early B cell development required a functional Igalpha immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif. These results support a model in which expression of surface IgM following productive V(D)J recombination in developing B cell precursors serves to chaperone the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha to the B cell surface, thereby initiating subsequent stages of development.

The avian B-cell receptor complex: distinct roles of Igalpha and Igbeta in B-cell development

The bursa of Fabricius has evolved in birds as a gut-associated site of B-cell lymphopoiesis that is segregated from the development of other hematopoietic lineages. Despite differences in the developmental progression of chicken as compared to murine B-cell lymphopoiesis, cell-surface immunoglobulin (sIg) expression has been conserved in birds as an essential checkpoint in B-cell development. B-cell precursors that express an sIg complex that includes the evolutionarily conserved Igalpha/beta heterodimer colonize lymphoid follicles in the bursa, whereas B-cell precursors that fail to express sIg due to non-productive V(D)J recombination are eliminated. Productive retroviral gene transfer has allowed us to introduce chimeric receptor constructs into developing B-cell precursors in vivo. Chimeric proteins comprising the extracellular and transmembrane regions of murine CD8alpha fused to the cytoplasmic domain of chicken Igalpha efficiently supported B-cell development in precursors that lacked endogenous sIg expression. By contrast, expression of an equivalent chimeric receptor containing the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta actively inhibited B-cell development. Consequently, the cytoplasmic domains of Igalpha and Igbeta play functionally distinct roles in chicken B-cell development.

Immunoglobulin gene conversion: Insights from bursal B cells and the DT40 cell line

Chicken B cells diversify their immunoglobulin (Ig) light and heavy chain genes by pseudogene templated gene conversion within the bursa of Fabricius. Although Ig gene conversion was initially believed to occur only in birds, it is now clear that most farm animals also use this elegant mechanism to develop an immunoglobulin gene repertoire. The best model to study Ig gene conversion remains the chicken Ig light chain locus due to its compact size and the fact that all the pseudogene donors are sequenced. Furthermore, gene conversion continues in the bursa-derived DT40 cell line whose genome can be easily modified by targeted integration of transfected constructs. Disruption of the AID gene, which had been shown to control somatic hypermutation and switch recombination in mammals leads to a complete block of gene conversion in DT40 indicating that all B-cell specific repertoire formation is controlled by the same gene. Here, we review the genetics and the molecular mechanism of Ig gene conversion based on sequence analysis of bursal B cells and gene disruption studies in the DT40 cell line.

Development of Peyer's patch and cecal tonsil in gut-associated lymphoid tissues in the chicken embryo

It is well known that chicken B cells develop in the bursa of Fabricius (BF), which is categorized as gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT). Chicken GALT also includes Peyer's patch (PP) and cecal tonsil (CT). The relationship between these tissues in GALT during B cell development is currently unknown. In this study, we conducted comparative examination of PP, CT and BF development during embryogenesis using immunohistochemical staining. On day 13 of embryogenesis (E13), accumulation of MHC class II(+) cells was observed in the intestine. Thereafter, Bu-1(+) cells and IgM(+) cells appeared, and their number continuously increased at the same sites where MHC class II(+) cells were present. Similar results were obtained in the CT. The locations of embryonic PP were limited to two sites; near the Meckel's diverticulum and the ileocecal junction. Anlage of bursal follicles first appeared at E13 and developed thereafter. Immigration of Bu-1(+) cells to bursal follicles began at E13, and the number of Bu-1(+) cell subsequently increased. When the follicle of BF was eliminated from the embryo by treatment with testosterone, development of PP and CT were observed. We concluded therefore that the development of PP and CT start during late embryogenesis at the same time as the follicle of BF, and that appearance of surface IgM(+) cells in PP and CT is independent form the development of the follicle of BF.

Antibody repertoire development in fetal and neonatal piglets. VI. B cell lymphogenesis occurs at multiple sites with differences in the frequency of in-frame rearrangements

B cell lymphogenesis in mammals occurs in various tissues during development but it is generally accepted that it operates by the same mechanism in all tissues. We show that in swine, the frequency of in-frame (IF) VDJ rearrangements differs among yolk sac, fetal liver, spleen, early thymus, bone marrow, and late thymus. All VDJ rearrangements recovered and analyzed on the 20th day of gestation (DG20) from the yolk sac were 100% IF. Those recovered at DG30 in the fetal liver were >90% IF, and this predominance of cells with apparently a single IF rearrangement continued in all organs until approximately DG45, which corresponds to the time when lymphopoiesis begins in the bone marrow. Thereafter, the proportion of IF rearrangements drops to approximately 71%, i.e., the value predicted whether VDJ rearrangement is random and both chromosomes were involved. Unlike other tissues, VDJs recovered from thymus after DG50 display a pattern suggesting no selection for IF rearrangements. Regardless of differences in the proportion of IF rearrangements, we observed no significant age- or tissue-dependent changes in CDR3 diversity, N region additions, or other characteristics of fetal VDJs during ontogeny. These findings indicate there are multiple sites of B cell lymphogenesis in fetal piglets and differences in the frequency of productive VDJ rearrangements at various sites. We propose the latter to result from differential selection or a developmentally dependent change in the intrinsic mechanism of VDJ rearrangement.

Comparative analyses of immunoglobulin genes: surprises and portents

The study of immunoglobulin genes in non-mouse and non-human models has shown that different vertebrate groups have evolved distinct methods of generating antibody diversity. By contrast, the development of T cells in the thymus is quite similar in all of the species that have been examined. The three mechanisms by which B cells uniquely modify their immunoglobulin genes -- somatic hypermutation, gene conversion and class switching -- are increasingly believed to share some fundamental mechanisms, which studies in different vertebrate groups have helped (and will continue to help) to resolve. When these mechanisms are better understood, we should be able to look to the constitutive pathways from which they have evolved and perhaps determine whether the rearrangement of variable, diversity and joining antibody gene segments -- V(D)J recombination -- was superimposed on an existing adaptive immune system.

Influence of antibody diversification on the mechanism of haplotype exclusion of immunoglobulin gene expression

Allelic, or haplotype, exclusion of immunoglobulin gene expression ensures that the products of a single allele or light chain isotype are expressed on the B cell surface. Evidence has accumulated in rodent and primate models to indicate that the products of successful rearrangement regulate this process. In contrast, haplotype exclusion of chicken immunoglobulin gene expression is regulated at the level of variable region gene rearrangement. We discuss here alternative models for ensuring haplotype exclusion that may operate in the chicken and extend the discussion to address the issue as to how two apparently distinct mechanisms may have evolved to yield the same outcome.

Role of bursin in the development of B lymphocytes in chicken embryonic Bursa of Fabricius

Localization and role of bursin during Bursa of Fabricius (BF) ontogeny were examined by immunohistochemical staining and by in ovo injection with anti-bursin antibody. Mouse monoclonal anti-bursin antibody HU2 was generated by immunization with synthetic bursin. It recognized reticular cells (REC), follicular associated epithelium (FAE), FAE-supporting cells, and the basal layer of interfollicular epithelium (IFE) in the mature BF. Bu-1(+) cells were first detectable in the mesenchyme area at 13 days of embryogenesis (E13) before bud formation, then lined up along the bud, and homed into the bud at around E15. IgM(+) cells were detected in the bud after E13. Bursin was first observed at the under edge of the bud. Injection of HU2 into embryonal vein at E13 suppressed the appearance of IgM(+) cells in the Bursa at E17. These results indicate that bursin exists beneath the bud and may act on the appearance of IgM(+) cells during BF ontogeny.

Notch signaling suppresses IgH gene expression in chicken B cells: implication in spatially restricted expression of Serrate2/Notch1 in the bursa of Fabricius

The bursa of Fabricius is a central organ for chicken B cell development and provides an essential microenvironment for expansion of the B cell pool and for generation of a diversified B cell repertoire. We report here that genes encoding the Notch family of transmembrane proteins, key regulators of cell fate determination in development, are differentially expressed in the bursa of Fabricius: Notch1 is expressed in medullary B cells located close to the basement membrane-associated epithelium (BMAE). In contrast, a Notch ligand, Serrate2, is expressed exclusively in the BMAE, which surrounds bursal medulla. A basic helix-loop-helix-type transcription factor, Hairy1, a downstream target of Notch signaling, is expressed in the bursa coordinately with Notch1 and Serrate2 and an immature B cell line, TLT1, which expresses both Notch1 and Serrate2. Furthermore, stable expression of a constitutively active form of chicken Notch1 or Notch2 in a B cell line results in a down-regulation of surface IgM expression, which is accompanied by the reduction of IgH gene transcripts. Transient reporter assay with the human IgH gene intronic enhancer reveals that an active form of Notch1 inhibits the IgH enhancer activity in chicken B cells, suggesting that Notch-mediated signals suppress the IgH gene expression via influencing the IgH intronic enhancer. These findings raise the possibility that the local activation of Notch1 in a subset of B cells by Serrate2 expressed in BMAE may influence the cell fate decision that is involved in B cell differentiation and selection inside the bursa.

Effect of early fetal splenectomy on prenatal B-cell development in sheep

The contribution of early splenic B-cell populations to the colonization of the ileal Peyer's patch was investigated following the surgical removal of the spleen in a series of 56-day-old fetal sheep. The fetuses were killed at 140 days of gestation and the ileal Peyer's patch, the distal jejunal lymph node which drains the Peyer's patch, and a peripheral lymph node, the superficial cervical lymph node, were examined. Enzyme and immunohistochemical evaluation concluded that the distribution of B cells, T cells and stromal cells in the ileal Peyer's patch was similar in splenectomized and normal fetal sheep. Thus, the presence of the fetal spleen was not essential for the colonization of the ileal Peyer's patch and other early sites of B-cell accumulation would appear capable of generating the necessary precursor populations. Investigation of B-cell populations in lymph nodes used a combination of terminal deoxynucleotidyl-transferase-mediated deoxyuridine-triphosphate nick-end-labelling (TUNEL) histochemistry and immunofluorescence to determine the average number of apoptotic B cells in the primary follicles of the outer cortex of splenectomized and normal lambs. A significantly increased number of apoptotic B cells was present in the distal jejunal lymph node but not in the superficial cervical lymph node of splenectomized lambs. This finding suggests that splenectomy affected prenatal B-cell development in fetal sheep and raises questions as to the regulation of B-cell lymphopoiesis in a species using a post-rearrangement organ of diversification.

In vitro characterization of chB6 positive and negative cells from early avian embryos

Density gradient-separated embryonic spleen and bone marrow cells were enriched for chB6(+) cells with positive and negative selection procedures and magnetic cell sorting. The majority of chB6(+) cells, consisting of small, dense, strongly chB6(+) cells, were prone to apoptosis, which was further accentuated after exposure to monoclonal antibodies directed against chB6 alloantigen, but was largely inhibited by PDBU, leading to maintenance and frequently numerical increases of chB6(+) cells after an initial decline. sIgM(+) cells within that population followed a very similar pattern, suggesting a PDBU-induced upregulation of sIgM expression on a proportion of chB6(+) cells. The protective effect of PDBU on anti-chB6-exposed cells was confirmed with bursal lymphocytes and shown to be entirely PDBU concentration dependent. It was calculated that each 14-day embryonic spleen contained a minimum of 250,000 chB6(+) and 3000-4000 sIgM(+) cells, respectively. Endogenous apoptosis appeared to be increased with embryonic age, reaching a peak with bursal cells in the posthatching period. A second population of larger, less dense, and weak chB6(+) cells, often with vacuoles in a more abundant cytoplasm, differed functionally, expanding numerically in unstimulated cultures and being inhibited by PDBU. No sIgM(+) cells developed within this population. It is proposed that this chB6(+) fraction may represent progenitors of a previously suggested chB6(+) subset of macrophages, in contrast to the dense chB6(+), small cells, viewed as B cell progenitors. chB6(-) cells, consisting predominantly of granulocytes, proliferated vigorously in unstimulated cultures, but were consistently inhibited by PDBU. Coculture of age-matched embryonic bursal stroma with positively and negatively enriched chB6(+) cells revealed enhanced protection from apoptosis for chB6(+) cells and a PDBU-induced upregulation of sIgM expressing cells. Bursal stroma also had a pronounced positive effect on the proliferation of chB6(-) cells.

Perinatal deletion of B cells expressing surface Ig molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants in the bursa of Fabricius is not due to intrafollicular competition

During embryonic development, the avian bursa of Fabricius selects B cell precursors that have undergone productive V(D)J recombination for expansion in oligoclonal follicles. During this expansion, Ig diversity is generated by gene conversion. We have used retroviral gene transfer in vivo to introduce surface Ig molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants into B cell precursors. This truncated mu heavy chain supports both B cell expansion within embryo bursal lymphoid follicles and gene conversion. We show that individual follicles can be colonized exclusively by cells expressing the truncated mu chain and lacking endogenous surface IgM, ruling out a requirement for V(D)J-encoded determinants in the establishment of bursal lymphoid follicles. In striking contrast to their normal development in the embryo, bursal cells expressing the truncated mu-chain exhibit reduced rates of cell division and increased levels of apoptosis after hatching. The level of apoptosis in individual follicles reflects the proportion of cells within the follicle that express the truncated mu-chain. In particular, high levels of apoptosis are associated with follicles containing exclusively cells expressing the truncated micro receptor. Thus, apoptotic elimination of such cells is not due to competition within the follicle by cells expressing endogenous surface IgM receptors. This provides the first direct demonstration that the regulation of B cell development in the avian bursa after hatching differs fundamentally from that seen in the embryo. The requirement for intact IgM expression when the bursa is exposed to exogenous Ag implicates a role for Ag in avian B cell development after hatching.

Regulation of chicken haemopoiesis by cytokines

The continuous production, control and functional activation of blood cells involves a complex series of cellular events in which a small population of stem cells generates large numbers of mature cells. The survival, proliferation and development of these cells is strictly dependent on extracellular signals, among these are polypeptide regulators generally known as cytokines. While a large number of mammalian cytokines with proliferative and inhibitory effects have been described in detail, it is surprising that comparatively little is known of the avian system. Given the success of human cytokines as a model, the ability to manipulate the chicken haemopoietic and lymphopoietic systems by precise application of purified cytokines provides a rational approach to defence against disease. As a general caveat, an increased awareness of the existence of regulatory networks and the likelihood that these regulators were designed to function most effectively when acting in combination, will provide an understanding into the regulation of haemopoiesis and hence find application in both clinical and agricultural research.

Avian B cell development: lessons from transgenic models

The bursa of Fabricius is critical for the development of B lymphocytes in avian species. Despite considerable advances in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms by which avian antibody diversity is generated, many stages of B-cell development in the bursa and the means by which they are regulated remain unclear. Here we discuss the use of productive chicken retroviral vectors which allow gene transfer in vitro or in vivo as tools to probe the requirements for bursal B-cell development. Expression of a truncated form of bursal cell surface IgM, lacking variable region encoded determinants, is sufficient to promote the initial colonization and clonal expansion of B-cells within the bursa. Expression of this truncated IgM does not, however, protect developing bursal cells against the apoptosis that occurs within the bursa after hatch. Conversely, over-expression of the proto-oncogene bcl-2, following retroviral gene transfer, protects cells against apoptotic cell death but is not sufficient to allow B lineage progression in the absence of sIgM expression. Finally we discuss the use of regulated promoters within the retroviral gene transfer system to show that while bursal cells are susceptible to transformation by the v-rel oncogene in vitro, this oncogene preferentially targets mature peripheral cells in vivo.

Development of B cells expressing surface immunoglobulin molecules that lack V(D)J-encoded determinants in the avian embryo bursa of fabricius

Immunoglobulin gene rearrangement in avian B cell precursors generates surface Ig receptors of limited diversity. It has been proposed that specificities encoded by these receptors play a critical role in B lineage development by recognizing endogenous ligands within the bursa of Fabricius. To address this issue directly we have introduced a truncated surface IgM, lacking variable region domains, into developing B precursors by retroviral gene transfer in vivo. Cells expressing this truncated receptor lack endogenous surface IgM, and the low level of endogenous Ig rearrangements that have occurred within this population of cells has not been selected for having a productive reading frame. Such cells proliferate rapidly within bursal epithelial buds of normal morphology. In addition, despite reduced levels of endogenous light chain rearrangement, those light chain rearrangements that have occurred have undergone variable region diversification by gene conversion. Therefore, although surface expression of an Ig receptor is required for bursal colonization and the induction of gene conversion, the specificity encoded by the prediversified receptor is irrelevant and, consequently, there is no obligate ligand for V(D)J-encoded determinants of prediversified avian cell surface IgM receptor.

Quantification of T-Cell Progenitors During Ontogeny: Thymus Colonization Depends on Blood Delivery of Progenitors

An in vivo thymus reconstitution assay based on intrathymic injection of hematopoietic progenitors into irradiated chicks was used to determine the number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, paraaortic foci, bone marrow (BM), and spleen during ontogeny. This study allowed us to analyze the regulation of thymus colonization occurring in three waves during embryogenesis. It confirmed that progenitors of the first wave of thymus colonization originate from the paraaortic foci, whereas progenitors of the second and the third waves originate from the BM. The analysis of the number of T-cell progenitors indicates that each wave of thymus colonization is correlated with a peak number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, whereas they are almost absent during the periods defined as refractory for colonization. Moreover, injection of T-cell progenitors into the blood circulation showed that they homed into the thymus without delay during the refractory periods. Thus, thymus colonization kinetics depend mainly on the blood delivery of T-cell progenitors during embryogenesis.

Quantification of T-Cell Progenitors During Ontogeny: Thymus Colonization Depends on Blood Delivery of Progenitors

An in vivo thymus reconstitution assay based on intrathymic injection of hematopoietic progenitors into irradiated chicks was used to determine the number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, paraaortic foci, bone marrow (BM), and spleen during ontogeny. This study allowed us to analyze the regulation of thymus colonization occurring in three waves during embryogenesis. It confirmed that progenitors of the first wave of thymus colonization originate from the paraaortic foci, whereas progenitors of the second and the third waves originate from the BM. The analysis of the number of T-cell progenitors indicates that each wave of thymus colonization is correlated with a peak number of T-cell progenitors in peripheral blood, whereas they are almost absent during the periods defined as refractory for colonization. Moreover, injection of T-cell progenitors into the blood circulation showed that they homed into the thymus without delay during the refractory periods. Thus, thymus colonization kinetics depend mainly on the blood delivery of T-cell progenitors during embryogenesis.

Characterization of prethymic progenitors within the chicken embryo

The thymic primordium in both birds and mammals is first colonized by cells emerging from the intra-embryonic mesenchyme but the nature of these precursors is poorly understood. We demonstrate here an early embryonic day 7 prethymic population with T lymphoid potential. Our work is a phenotypic analysis of, to date, the earliest embryonic prethymic progenitors arising in the avian para-aortic area during ontogeny. The phenotype of these cells, expressing the cell surface molecules alpha2beta1 integrin, c-kit, thrombomucin/MEP21, HEMCAM and chL12, reflects functional properties required for cell adhesion, migration and growth factor responsiveness. Importantly, the presence of these antigens was found to correlate with the recolonization of the recipient thymus following intrathymic cell transfers. These intra-embryonic cells were also found to express the Ikaros transcription factor, the molecular function of which is considered to be prerequisite for embryonic lymphoid development.

Lymphocyte development in fish and amphibians

Recently, molecular markers such as recombination activating genes (RAG), terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT), stem cell leukemia hematopoietic transcription factor (SCL), Ikaros and gata-binding protein (Gata)-family members have been isolated and characterized from key lower vertebrates, adding to our growing knowledge of lymphopoiesis in ectotherms. In all gnathostomes there appear to be two main embryonic locations derived from the early mesoderm, both intra- and extraembryonic, which contribute to primitive and definitive hematopoiesis based upon their differential expression of SCL, Gata-1, Gata-2 and myeloblastosis oncogene (c-myb). In teleosts, a unique intraembryonic location for hematopoietic stem cells termed the intermediate cell mass (ICM) of Oellacher appears to be responsible for primitive or definitive hematopoiesis depending upon the species being investigated. In Xenopus, elegant grafting studies in combination with specific molecular markers has led to a better definition of the roles that ventral blood islands and dorsal lateral plate play in amphibian hematopoiesis, that of primitive and definitive lymphopoiesis. After the early embryonic contribution to hematopoiesis, specialized tissues must assume the role of providing the proper microenvironment for T and B-lymphocyte development from progenitor stem cells. In all gnathostomes, the thymus is the major site for T-cell maturation as evidenced by strong expression of developmental markers such as Ikaros, Rag and TdT plus expression of T-cell specific markers such as T-cell receptor beta and lck. In this respect, several zebrafish mutants have provided new insights on the development of the thymopoietic environment. On the other hand, the sites for B-cell lymphopoiesis are less clear among the lower vertebrates. In elasmobranchs, the spleen, Leydig's organ and the spiral valve may all contribute to B-cell development, although pre-B cells have yet to be fully addressed in fish. In teleosts, the kidney is undeniably the major source of B-cell development based upon functional, cellular and molecular indices. Amphibians appear to use several different sites (spleen, bone marrow and/or kidney) depending upon the species in question.

Probing immunoglobulin gene hypermutation with microsatellites suggests a nonreplicative short patch DNA synthesis process

As the rate of Ig gene hypermutation approximates the level of nucleotide discrimination of DNA polymerases (10(-3) to 10(-4)), a local inhibition of proofreading and mismatch repair during semiconservative replication could generate the mutations introduced by the process. To address this question, we have constructed transgenic mice that carry a hypermutation substrate containing a "polymerase slippage trap": an Ig gene with a mono or dinucleotide tract inserted in its V region. The low amount of slippage events as compared to the number of mutations, the absence of transient misalignment mutations at the border of the repeats, and the dissociation between the amount of frameshifts and mutations when the transgene is put on mismatch repair-deficient genetic backgrounds, suggest that Ig gene hypermutation occurs by an error-prone short patch DNA synthesis taking place outside global DNA replication.

Antigenic phenotype of early intra-embryonic lymphoid progenitors in the chicken

The stem cells for the definitive haematopoiesis are derived from intra-embryonic sources originally described in an avian model and later also in mammals. However, the molecular make-up of the early embryonic haematopoietic progenitors is not yet clearly defined. We have recently characterized the phenotype of prethymic intra-embryonic progenitors capable of thymic colonization. Here we studied the ontogeny of cell-surface antigens HEMCAM, alpha2beta1 integrin, thrombomucin, chL12 and c-kit and their co-expression on prethymic T-cell progenitors. The early intra-embryonic expression of avian B-cell antigen chB6 was also demonstrated on cells derived from the intra-embryonic areas. We suggest that in the chicken, embryonic B-cell progenitors segregate earlier than T-cell progenitors in the differentiation of multipotent haematopoietic stem cells to committed progenitors.

Expression of chL12 surface antigen is associated with cell survival in the avian bursa of Fabricius

During B-cell development in the avian bursa of Fabricius most of the developing B cells die by apoptosis and only a minority survive to emigrate into the periphery. Recently, it has been shown that when developing bursal cells become mature and ready to migrate they start to express chL12 antigen. The expression of this cell-surface molecule was found to be associated with the survival of the bursal cells both after in vitro culture and after in vivo cyclophosphamide (CY) treatment. The frequency of early apoptotic cells in freshly isolated bursal cells was found to be high. The high susceptibility of these cells to apoptosis is in line with the finding of low bcl-2 mRNA expression. We conclude that expression of avian chL12 antigen is associated with the survival of bursal cells.

Avian B cell development

Development of B cells in chickens proceeds via a series of discrete developmental stages that includes the maturation of committed B cell progenitors in the specialized microenvironment of the bursa of Fabricius. The bursa has been shown to be required for the amplification of the B cell pool and selects for cells with productive immunoglobulin rearrangement events. Other events regulating chicken B cell development such as lymphocyte trafficking and apoptosis are just beginning to be elucidated. Within the bursa, the variable regions of immunoglobulin genes of B cell progenitors are diversified by a process of intrachromosomal gene conversion, where blocks of sequence information are transferred from pseudo-V regions to the recombined variable regions of the immunoglobulin genes. Recently gene conversion has been determined to play a role in the diversification of the immune repertoire in other species. In this review we focus on the current understanding and recent advances of B cell development in the chicken.

Applications in in ovo technology

By mid-August 1995, 55% of broiler embryos in North America were vaccinated for Marek's disease using the INOVOJECT system, with 201 INOVOJECT machines placed with 16 of the top 25 poultry producers, providing the industry with the capacity to inject in excess of 400 million eggs per month or about 5 billion eggs per annum. In ovo administration of a bursal disease antibody-infectious bursal disease virus (BDA-IBDV) complexed vaccine to specific-pathogen-free (SPF) embryos was safer and more potent than conventional IBDV vaccine alone because it delayed the appearance of bursal lesions, produced no early mortality, produced higher geometric mean antibody titers against IBDV, and generated protective immunity against challenge. In ovo administration of a BDA-IBDV complexed vaccine to broiler embryos generated antibody titers against IBDV sooner than conventional virus vaccinates, and generated protective immunity against challenge Direct DNA injection of plasmid DNA encoding beta-galactosidase into breast muscle in ovo and posthatch was an effective means to achieve both gene transfer and expression, with potential for the development of gene vaccines using plasmids encoding protective antigens from poultry pathogens. In ovo administration of 800 U chicken myelomonocytic growth factor (cMGF), a chicken hematopoietic cytokine for cells of the monocytic-granulocytic lineages, significantly reduced mortality associated with Escherichia coli exposure within the hatcher when compared to PBS controls (6.1 vs 12.4, P < or = 0.05), but not when compared to a yeast expression control. A procedure was developed enabling injection prior to the onset of incubation without compromising embryo viability. This in ovo injection process has opened up the window of embryo development during incubation for intervention, as illustrated by the 100% male phenotype produced in chicks hatching from eggs injected with aromatase inhibitor prior to incubation. These data illustrate some of the in ovo applications presently in use by the poultry industry, and under development or in research at EMBREX.

Chicken B cells undergo discrete developmental changes in surface carbohydrate structure that appear to play a role in directing lymphocyte migration during embryogenesis

The migration of progenitor cells to specific microenvironments is essential for the development of complex organisms. Avian species possess a unique primary lymphoid organ, the bursa of Fabricius, that plays a central role in the development of B cells. B cell progenitors, however, arise outside the bursa of Fabricius and, during embryonic development, must migrate through the vasculature to the bursa of Fabricius. In this report, we demonstrate that these progenitor B cells express the sialyl Lewis × carbohydrate structure previously shown to be a ligand for the selectin family of vascular adhesion receptors. Soon after migration to the bursa of Fabricius, B cell progenitors are induced to undergo a developmental switch and terminate the expression of sialyl Lewis × in a temporal pattern that correlates with the developmental decline in the ability of these cells to home to the bursa of Fabricius upon transplantation. The induction of the developmental switch in the glycosylation pattern of developing B cells requires the bursal environment. In addition, sialyl Lewis × carbohydrate determinants or structurally similar determinants on the surface of immortalized bursal lymphoid stem cells participate in the adherence of these cells to the vascular regions of the bursal microenvironment. These data demonstrate that the carbohydrate structure sialyl Lewis × is developmentally regulated during chicken B cell development and may facilitate the migration of B cell progenitors to the bursal microenvironment by serving as a ligand for a lectin-like adhesion receptor.

Intraembryonic haemopoietic cells and early T cell development

T cell precursors in the chick embryo have been localized into the intraembryonic mesenchyme (IEM) and into the para-aortic region before the first wave of the thymic colonization on embryonic day (ED) 6,5-8. The cell surface markers of avian prethymic stem cells are not known. It is also not known whether these precursor cells are already committed to the T cell lineage before their thymic colonization. In 7-day-old chick embryos Ov+ cells were found in the para-aortic region. Also the endothelial cells of the embryonic dorsal aorta were positively stained. Ov antigen might represent a very primitive marker for precursor cells having the potentiality to differentiate both to haemopoietic and endothelial cells. Scattered CD45+ cells were observed in the same para-aortic area as in many haemopoietic areas in the loose embryonic mesenchymal tissues. CD8 alpha (MoAb 3-298) expressing haemopoietic cells were detected before thymic colonization on ED6. In flow cytometric analysis of IEM precursors Ov, CD45 and CD8 alpha expressing cells seemed to form distinct subsets suggesting heterogeneity of these haemopoietic cells.

Immunohistochemical evidence that gonads and gonad-associated tissues are sites for enrichment with immunoglobulin-containing cells in adult chickens

Immunohistochemical staining of tissue sections prepared from gonads and gonad-associated tissues obtained from adult chickens was performed in order to assess the possibility that these tissues may be sites of enrichment with IgM-containing cells in various B lineages. Evidence is presented which suggests that IgM-containing B lineage cells are present in 1) the ovarian stroma and subcapsular areas of the ovary and 2) the interstitium and subcapsular areas of the epididymis of the testes. These represent new sites reported for B lineage cells in adult chickens. Some questions relevant to the physiologic, ontogenetic, and phylogenetic implications of these observations relative to vertebrate hematolymphopoietic processes are included.

Expression of human recombination activating genes (RAG-1 and RAG-2) in lymphoma

Two recently discovered genes, the recombination activating genes 1 and 2 (RAG-1 and RAG-2), are necessary to perform variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) recombination. They synergistically activate VDJ recombination to generate immunocompetent lymphocytes. Disruption of either gene results in a maturation arrest at a very early B and T cell progenitor stage. Expression and downregulation of RAG's are closely associated with interleukin 7, sIgM and TCR-CD3 complex, respectively. Assessment of RAG mRNA expression is a valuable marker in identifying the genotypic maturation status of leukemias and lymphomas. Persistent RAG expression in otherwise mature lymphoid proliferations may explain puzzling biological and clinical observations such as multiple rearrangements in lymphomas with a mature phenotype. Lack of RAG expression in Hodgkin's disease with abundant Reed-Sternberg cells is consistent with a mature phenotype of the latter. Availability of a anti-RAG-1 monoclonal antibody in the near future will facilitate RAG analysis of lymphomas.

B cell development in the chicken

A central feature of the vertebrate humoral immune system is that an organism must have a vast repertoire of antibodies to protect it against foreign pathogens. Chickens create a diverse immunological repertoire by intrachromosomal gene conversion of the single variable gene segments of the Ig heavy and light chain genes. This diversification process has been shown to require the bursa of Fabricius. Immature cells commit to the B cell lineage by rearranging their Ig genes prior to migration to the bursa. Recent work has suggested that the ability of a developing B cell to migrate to the bursa may depend on the expression of the carbohydrate structure sialyl Lewis x. Developing B cells in the spleen with the ability to migrate to the bursa have been shown to express sialyl Lewis x. Cells expressing sialyl Lewis x begin appearing in the bursa anlage between embryonic Days 10 and 12. These sialyl Lewis x-positive cells appear to form the nascent bursal follicles and are induced to proliferate. Coincident with the time that B cells initiate the gene conversion process, cells cease expressing sialyl Lewis x and begin expressing the related surface epitope Lewis x. As cells mature further, they undergo another phenotypic change and switch from expressing high levels of Lewis x to become Lewis x-low. At the same time that Lewis x-low cells accumulate in the bursa, cells with this phenotype begin to appear in the spleen. These phenotypic markers may be useful in identifying chicken B cells at different developmental stages.